LAND USE COMMITTEE MINUTES November 19, 2008 Council Chamber
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
A USE COMMIEE Cnl f th Cnt f M MIUES vbr , 2008 Cnl Chbr CONVENE: 9:03 a.m. PRESENT: Councilmember Michael J. Molina, Chair Councilmember Joseph Pontanilla, Vice-Chair (Arrv :0 .. Councilmember Michelle Anderson, Member (Arrv :0 .. Councilmember Gladys C. Baisa, Member Councilmember G Riki Hokama, Member (Arrv 4:0 p.. Councilmember Jo Anne Johnson, Member Councilmember Danny A. Mateo, Member Councilmember Bill Kauakea Medeiros, Member Councilmember Michael P. Victorino, Member STAFF: Tammy M. Frias, Committee Secretary Carla M. Nakata, Legislative Attorney ADMIN.: Jeffrey Hunt, Director, Department of Planning Ann Cua, Planner, Department of Planning James A. Giroux, Deputy Corporation Counsel, Department of the Corporation Counsel OTHERS: Everett Dowling, President, Honua LLC and Keaka LLC Don Fujimoto, Vice President, Honua LLC and Keaka LLC Roy Figueiroa, Project Manager, Honua LLC Gwen Ohashi Hiraga, Munekiyo & Hiraga, Inc. (Applnt lnd nltnt Rowena Dagdag, Planner, Munekiyo & Hiraga, Inc. (Applnt lnd nltnt Bert Toba, R.M. Towill Corporation (Applnt vl nnr Aki Sinoto, Aid Sinoto Consulting LLC (Applnt rhlt Phillip Rowell, Phillip Rowell & Associates (Applnt trff nnr Jacob R. Mau, Ku Puna 0 Makena Chandrika McLaughlin Angie Hoffman Kehaulani Rand Declan McCarthy Corey K. Leong Donald K. Poepoe, Sr. James J. Kahalekai Patrick Ancheta Leo Tai, Wedding Manager, Maui Prince Hotel Patri McLaughlin Heather Ganancial A USE COMMIEE MIUES Cnl f th Cnt f M vbr , 2008 ln Chn, d & vr Mnr, M rn tl vrnd Alln ll hn Crt tn fr brt K. Cbnn Ml rr Obrt Kvn K. ll, M rn tl n Qnn Mhl brtn, Sv Mn n ltr Gl Mnb, M rn tl Gn Wvr n Chpn, M rn tl Ahl Ipl Kl, Mn rt Kn C, Grn vlpnt Crdntr, ln Cpn, In. Mr Mhl dn n Wvr Erl l Ezl "" Kl Ch zn d, rnpl rr, Mn rprt l Cbllr nn n l nnd n Wnr Sn rp hnh Khl Shrnn ln Kl Wll SSz, r. nd Yp Mr d h Clbb, Chr, IWU 42, Unt 2 (M rn tl r rn, Otdr rt rtr, Mn rt Mhl d Gh Cln MCr b rn Erthhld Mr Shhn hn Y. Ar r rr z r l 2 A USE COMMIEE MIUES Cnl f th Cnt f M vbr , 2008 v At ln Mt l rn Wrth r nrtnr nl Knhl Ant Wntnr Ip Khl Kn Kv tn tr, Onr, M Srfr Grl nn Mr nd Mnld r Chn El l K h K Kphlh th Gnzl Chrl Gdn, tl Mnr, M rn tl, Mn rt hn Chll Stv rt rnn , bbt, lbr & ttr Unn l 6 Stt n Gff Mr ll rt, ht Mnr, M rn tl Irn , Extv rtr, M rr ndtn, In. M rn n Mrrt Cr ll K, Crpntr Unn rh, Extv rtr, M Cntrtr Atn Knn Khhnhn, nh ll Atn Whn 0 M Shnnn Gllr lph Ovrtn, Cnltnt, rvn . C., In. Cld h, rtr, ECE Gr Al, ld prnttv, brr Unn l 68 Mr rtltb Knn ltt Altnbr nnfr nn Krt hvr Mtth rr Eldn Kpn Sndr rn -3- A USE COMMIEE MIUES Cnl f th Cnt f M vbr , 2008 nld rn, xn Invttn tr Chr Mntzl Abl . Khhnhn, r., IWU l 42 Mhl OKn lnn Ct Knnth rr n hl Stvn Arnn nd ln Kndl tr h, Kpn 0 M Gr Kh, r. thn h Mhl rd, Chr, IWU Unt 2820 brt Ap Kn Slr Snh l l Crbn Ad trn bn Knx Kl Mnzn, M Cnt Cll A Chn Ernt t h I. p Slv Clr ltn Gbrl rdnt Chrtphr Mdr rd Spnjrd Stphn Wt, IWU nn d l Kll Ahl dr rl Wht Eln Wndr n n Ivn , Crpntr Unn 4 nl Grnth Ed nd, rdnt, M Cltrl nd, In. Kl Gz Mrln Stpplbn hrd Mhl l l Clr Apn ndr SzArl 4 A USE COMMIEE MIUES Cnl f th Cnt f M vbr , 2008 nnh rnrd Addtnl ttnd (0 PRESS: Chr ltn, The Maui News Il , The Maui News Gr Kbt, Honolulu Star Bulletin Akaku--Maui County Community Television, Inc. ITEM NO. 37: CHANGE IN ZONING FOR MAKENA RESORT (C.C. 00242, C.. 0240, nd C.C. 0246 CAI MOIA: . .(gavel). h nd U Ctt tn fr Wdnd, vbr , 2008 n n n. r th rrd hv n ttndn Ctt Mbr Mt, , hnn, Mdr, trn, nd Ctt Chr Mln. If ld pl trn ff th ll phn t.. COUCI MEMES: . .(chuckle). CAI MOIA: . nt t drpt r prdn td, Id pprt t. And tprrl xd r Ctt Mbr Andrn, , nd ntnll h ll b jnn hrtl. r th Ctt Stff hv r ltv Anlt Crl t, Ctt Srtr r. r th Crprtn Cnl Off hv Grx, nd fr th lnnn prtnt hv rtr ff nt nd Snr lnnr Ann C. Gd rnn, Mbr. COUCIMEME ICOIO: Gd rnn, Chr. COUCIMEME MEEIOS: Gd rnn. CAI MOIA: All rht, d. I ld t hr r xbrn nd nth. W hv vr, vr b d hd f . W hv n b t t ndr td, tht nd U It , th Chn n nn fr th Mn rt. fr prd, Mbr, th Chr ld l t f pnn nt. Erlr th r I hd ndrd hvn tn n vbr n th ttr bt dd nt fnl tnt. A f rll t th vbr th Cnl tn, Cnlbr trn prpd t dhr th t fr th nd U Ctt t th fll Cnl. Aftr nrn r hrd fr thr Mbr, t td t b th Cnl Chr t ndr hvn Ctt tn n ptn fr th Mbr t ndr. Yr nd U Chr d tht ffr t ll th Mbr, nd th tn t dhr th ttr b Mr. trn tll n th flr t th t nd ld hv bn prd hvr, th tn thdrn. And t thn rd pn t hv th tn b ll Mbr th n bjtn. And I th, Mbr, b n f r ll d tlt v n th prn tht th tn hr td ll dn. , t nt. It our dn. S Id tht r ll d prvd r nt all -5- A USE COMMIEE MIUES Cnl f th Cnt f M vbr , 2008 th ft bfr n ndd pnn. S n tht Iv t tht ff ht, Mbr, lt prd. Wr n t trt frtI rlz thr lt f ttfr hr td. At th pnt hv 2 ppl nd p. t jt ll f n hv fll ndrtndn f ht bn prntd b th pplnt, r n t trt frt th th pplnt dn fr brf rnt prnttn hh nr f r tn. And ftr tht ll hv th lnnn prtnt f brf nt, nd thn ll nt pbl ttn fr hrn. O? S, Mbr, r n t t brf r t t p th Chbr fr rnt prnttn fr th pplnt. h tn n r, bjt t th ll f th Chr. .(gavel). RECESS: 9:05 a.m. RECONVENE: 9:07 a.m. CAI MOIA: . (gavel). nd U Ctt tn fr Wdnd, vbr th n b n n. W hv fr th fr f Mn & r, Gn r t d prnttn n nd U It . fr d tht, th Chr ld l t rnz th prn f Ctt Mbr ntnll, ll Ctt Mbr Mhll Andrn. rd. Note: Computer generated presentation. MS. OASI IAGA: Gd rnn, Chr Mln nd Mbr f th nd U Ctt. M n Gn r fr Mn & r, nd tn n d l fr fr. I ll b prntn vr brf rnt prnttn t th rnn. O. rt f ll, th r, th ppltn bfr fr Mn rt, nd Mn rt prpn t hn th znn fr vr prl f lnd ttln .68 r n rdr t plnt th KhMn Cnt ln nd th Mn rt Mtr ln. Of th r pprxtl 4 r hv bn dvlpd, th jrt f hh r th t lf r, th Mn rth Cr nd th Mn Sth Cr. Othr dvlpd lnd nld th M rn tl, Mn rn. .Mn nn Clb hh h x rt, Mn Glf Clbh, pbl frt ttn, pbl prn, pn r t Mn ndn nd r Kl Chrh nd t bth d f th pdtrn l frntn th M rn tl. Of th rnn 28.8 r, 2 r r vnt lnd hr xtn znn nt prpd t b hnd, nd r r vnt lnd fr hh th znn prpd t b hnd. A I ntnd, th rt bfr Chn n nn ppltn t plnt th KhMn Cnt ln nd Mn rt Mtr ln. h ppltn bttd t th prtnt f lnnn b n vbr f . h ltn th Mn rt r ntn f vr MK, fr ttl lnd r f .68 r, x . Wth rrd t th lnd dntn, t prrl Urbn hvr, pprxtl r f th -6- A USE COMMIEE MIUES Cnl f th Cnt f M vbr , 2008 xtn Mn rth Glf Cr tll thn th Stt Arltrl trt. h KhMn Cnt ln dnt th r nt vrl dntn: r, r Glf Cr, Snll, Mltl, nCrl, nd tl. Extn znn n th prprt nt f vr znn dtrt: Arltr r Glf Cr nd Opn Sp Opn n A nd A2 Aprtnt , 2, nd dntl n rt M tl nd SW fr th dntn f th Mn S rtnt lnt. f nfrtn nd htr, th M lnnn Cn I ntnd th ppltn fld n vbr f , nd th M lnnn Cn hld pbl rhp n l 0, 2000. ht flld b pbl hrn b th M lnnn Cn hld n l 2, 2000. rn th lnnn Cn hrn, rttn ttn, thr r n lttr n pptn r pprt.