Attachment A ‐ Forest Service , NEPA, and Salvage Summary

Fiscal Year 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2007‐2016 Number of Fires 1 63 64 53 33 66 79 56 56 127 110 707 Total fire acres on NFS 2 1,751,118 1,326,893 549,108 211,327 1,489,029 2,411,413 1,141,353 741,465 1,587,843 1,038,686 12,248,235 High severity acres on NFS 3 842,658 368,595 268,944 76,192 619,020 809,720 513,957 265,045 489,668 397,654 4,651,453 Number of NEPA decisions identified 4 129 Acres of salvage planned in NEPA 5 218 17,255 2,134 14,010 22,761 28,937 13,809 13,264 112,388 Number of NEPA decisions litigated 6 125110332422 Litigation cases won by USFS 7 013110131112 Litigation cases lost by USFS 8 1120001011 7 Litigation cases pending 9 0000001002 3 Acres of salvage reported accomplished 10 328 2,665 8,125 3,464 8,774 6,916 11,672 19,792 16,926 21,234 99,896

1 Fires burning more than 1,000 acres on NFS land 10 Salvage harvest activity records identified as awarded in Forest Service Activity 2 Total acres inside fire perimeter on NFS land Tracking System (FACTS) by GIS analysis of fire perimeters. 3 Classified as greater than 75% mortality using Rapid Assessment of Vegetation Condition after Wildfire (RAVG)

4 Identified by fire salvage keyword search in PALS (Planning Appeals and Disclaimer: Only the litigation data is believed to be 100% complete and Litigation System) or reported with sale activity records in Forest Service systems accurate. Some discrepancies exist between fire data in different systems of FACTS or TIM. Some from PALS not included in report if inadequate detail record. Some salvage sale data in TIM and FACTS are difficult to identify as available. These decisions include authorizing fire salvage timber sales and timber such depending on level of detail recorded and presence or accuracy of sales to remove hazard trees along roads and facilities after a fire. This includes accompanying GIS data. NEPA data may also be difficult to identify as fire NEPA decisions made from fiscal years 2007‐2016. salvage and older projects may not be recorded in PALS. 5 Approximate acres available for only 49 decisions identified. Some of these decisions are based on a NEPA categorical exclusion for salvage that is limited to 250 acres. Many salvage activities are authorized using a NEPA categorical exclusion that does not require documentation of the decision. These decisions and associated acres are not accounted for here.

6 All fire salvage sale project lawsuits filed in fiscal years 2007 through 2016.

7 Litigation cases where the court ruled favorably for the Agency. Projects litigated in Court often result in substantial delays for project implementation and may affect the ability of the Agency to sell salvage sales 8 Includes cases lost by court decision, decisions withdrawn by the agency, or where parties agreed to settlement. 9 Litigation cases where the court has yet to rule. Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2007 1 Ahorn 51344 31994 2007 2 Alabaugh 1671 1408 2007 3 Birdie 5414 387 2007 1 Bitterroot WFU Complex 24783 6555 2007 1 Black Cat 3204 1575 2007 4 Black Pine 2 35759 29030 2007 1 Boundary Junction 4431 1285 2007 1 Bridge 39153 14496 2007 1 Brush Creek 28112 10810 2007 8 Bugaboo 55225 36186 2007 1 Calbick 1057 254 2007 4 Cascade Complex 232517 94867 2007 4 Cathedral 4386 3324 2007 1 Chimney Complex 1737 446 2007 1 Chippy Creek 46702 29718 2007 2 Citadel 1866 696 2007 1 Conger Creek 24819 14145 2007 1 Corporal 15545 3948 2007 4 Deep Creek 1177 238 2007 6 Domke Lake 10548 2205 2007 4 East Zone Complex 232285 101099 2007 6 Egley Complex 97161 42886 2007 1 Fool Creek 61170 41359 2007 4 French Creek WFU 3784 1024 2007 4 Grays Creek 12225 5686 2007 6 GW 5904 2296 2007 9 Ham Lake 29317 17166 2007 4 Hardscrabble 2155 1393 2007 4 Hawken 2213 1296 2007 4 Horse Creek 9685 4513 2007 1 Jocko Lakes 12225 5471 2007 4 Jungle 5581 2592 2007 4 Lightning 7001 1594 2007 2 Little Goose 1842 1262 2007 4 Lucky 1585 204 2007 1 Madison Arm 3557 3129 2007 1 Meriwether 25930 14063 2007 4 Middle 2529 864 2007 1 Middle Fork 1195 877 2007 6 Monument Complex 20560 3242 2007 1 Moose Creek WFU Complex 40006 10768 2007 4 Murphy Complex 81644 58934 2007 4 Neola North 19617 12711 2007 3 Ojo Peak 6331 2613 2007 6 Otter Creek 3042 1428 2007 1 Pattengail Creek 15850 6225 2007 1 Poe Cabin 44308 23549 2007 4 Profile 4867 1310 2007 3 Promontory 4534 488 2007 1 Railley Mountain 17320 7304 2007 1 Rat Creek 24287 13654 2007 1 Rattlesnake 99797 42263 2007 1 Rombo Mountain 29487 11800 2007 4 Salt Creek 10215 7533 2007 4 Salt Lick 2485 1607 2007 1 Sawmill Complex 67675 27725

2 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2007 4 Shower Bath 53858 24989 2007 1 Skyland 35231 21247 2007 3 Slide 6396 3941 2007 4 Trapper Ridge 19574 6490 2007 4 Van Horn 1571 359 2007 1 WH Complex 28204 20019 2007 3 Wilkins 7465 118 2008 3 Alamo 4564 2264 2008 5 American River Complex 18447 4745 2008 5 Antelope 2119 808 2008 8 Ball Goal 2048 4 2008 5 Basin Complex 140959 74054 2008 5 Bear Wallow Complex 71185 7069 2008 3 Big Spring 4404 2384 2008 8 Blackhorse 1344 289 2008 6 Bridge Creek 3719 1910 2008 5 BTU Lightning Complex 25083 5330 2008 3 Buck 2120 187 2008 5 Canyon Complex 34676 4738 2008 1 Cascade 11001 6490 2008 5 Chalk 14948 6136 2008 5 Clover 14799 9295 2008 6 Cold Springs 4911 2227 2008 4 Corn Creek 2254 1571 2008 5 Corral 4503 1843 2008 5 Cub Complex 17962 3068 2008 3 Distillery 7503 989 2008 3 Eagle 12861 286 2008 4 East Slide Rock Ridge 56011 30918 2008 4 Elkhorn 2 5549 3785 2008 3 Frye Mesa 2794 2115 2008 6 Gnarl Ridge 3237 751 2008 5 Gulch 2902 1625 2008 8 Gum Bay 2894 923 2008 2 Gunbarrel 70467 27508 2008 5 Hell's Half Complex 14267 458 2008 3 Hot Air 10963 1428 2008 5 Indians 50463 31897 2008 5 Iron / Alps Complex 102655 7982 2008 3 Jack Wood WFU 8408 1287 2008 3 Lane 2 9588 6418 2008 5 Lime Complex 64486 4526 2008 8 Little Cuba 3143 390 2008 6 Lonesome Complex 20614 5592 2008 5 Mad Complex 2662 183 2008 5 Mill 4833 960 2008 5 Motion Complex 5394 1300 2008 4 New Fork 14094 4372 2008 5 North Mountain 2176 452 2008 5 Panther 97231 13164 2008 5 Peterson Complex 2813 438 2008 5 Piute 33222 18711 2008 1 Porcupine 1901 981 2008 6 Rattle 21821 5084 2008 1 Rattlesnake 2309 576 2008 5 Rich 6171 1923

3 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2008 3 Rocky 21597 8699 2008 5 Siskiyou / Blue 2 Complex 104551 10053 2008 5 Soda Complex 5870 321 2008 4 South Barker WFU 38520 10423 2008 5 Stein 1160 17 2008 5 Telegraph 4231 2792 2008 3 Trigo 10367 6799 2008 3 Twenty Two WFU 1257 153 2008 5 Venture 1166 726 2008 5 Whiskey 5048 2815 2008 4 Willow WFU 4415 1157 2008 6 Wizard 2372 123 2008 3 X Fire 2065 1465 2008 5 Yolla Bolly Complex 97397 11477 2008 5 Yuba River Complex 2399 141 2009 3 4th of July Independence 5284 104 2009 3 Anderson 1505 99 2009 3 Ash Creek 5701 1188 2009 5 Backbone 6728 2316 2009 4 Big Pole 12044 9483 2009 6 Boze 13441 1313 2009 3 Brady 4160 47 2009 4 Bridge 3112 385 2009 3 Canelo 2970 1788 2009 8 Carolina Bay 3423 516 2009 3 Chevlon Complex 12010 3043 2009 3 Cross 7685 44 2009 3 Diamond 23392 225 2009 2 Dominguez 2942 1406 2009 3 Guthrie 4971 1372 2009 5 Hat Creek Complex 9280 5362 2009 3 Hog 9827 1377 2009 4 Horse Valley 2264 802 2009 5 Knight 5068 169 2009 5 La Brea 85967 75275 2009 4 Lake Fork 2045 1221 2009 1 Lawrence Mtn. 2835 148 2009 5 Lion Complex 4932 122 2009 3 Meason 7939 169 2009 3 Melendrez Pass 5084 0 2009 5 Mill Creek 4 1972 136 2009 4 Mill Flat 12682 7708 2009 3 Miller 3163 89 2009 3 Montana 2744 615 2009 3 Moore 4135 4 2009 3 Moraga 4939 67 2009 2 Narraguinnep 7081 4354 2009 6 North Fork Complex 16367 2229 2009 3 Pioneer 1799 251 2009 3 Pipeline 1654 4 2009 3 Point 1538 68 2009 3 Rae 2217 108 2009 5 Red Rock 1398 109 2009 3 Reno 5464 359 2009 3 Rim 2799 1080 2009 3 Ruby Complex 1609 15

4 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2009 4 Sawmill Canyon 4404 3620 2009 5 Sheep 6388 5223 2009 4 Solomon Basin 1483 753 2009 5 Station 160918 127970 2009 3 Taylor 3542 794 2009 5 Tennant 2520 1718 2009 3 Tucker 2936 22 2009 6 Tumblebug Complex 14814 945 2009 3 Wagon Draw 1254 40 2009 3 Wild Horse Complex 13996 1847 2009 6 Williams Creek 8268 471 2009 3 Willow 12415 371 2010 3 Aspen 2349 94 2010 4 Banner 2361 954 2010 2 Beaver 2296 798 2010 3 Brushy 5923 98 2010 5 Bull 16415 12390 2010 5 Canyon 6335 2834 2010 3 Circle Bar 4185 23 2010 4 Coffee Pot 2250 849 2010 8 Crippled Chinook 5338 1783 2010 1 Davis 1468 906 2010 3 Eagle Rock 3247 1606 2010 3 Grave 1672 13 2010 3 Hobble 2735 243 2010 3 Horseshoe 3847 958 2010 4 Hurd 1377 195 2010 4 Little Beaver Complex 8514 1833 2010 2 Meadow Creek 1578 522 2010 9 Meridian Boundary 5200 3450 2010 8 Mother's Day 3739 545 2010 6 Oak Flat 7740 873 2010 3 Paradise 6471 1754 2010 3 Ranger Complex 5894 17 2010 3 Rio 1369 373 2010 4 River Breaks 2743 203 2010 3 Schultz 15636 7858 2010 5 Sheep 5782 306 2010 3 South Fork 17101 2621 2010 6 Swakane 10156 5704 2010 4 Twitchell Canyon 44650 24358 2010 6 View Lake Complex 5510 1973 2010 3 Wash Complex 1126 1 2010 3 Weir 2001 3 2010 8 Wrangler 4319 54 2011 3 Arlene 10184 8876 2011 3 Armstrong 2736 168 2011 3 Beale 5096 53 2011 3 Beaverhead 3065 600 2011 6 Big Hump 1222 131 2011 1 Big Salmon Lake 4521 2359 2011 4 Black Canyon 2444 999 2011 3 Bluff 3558 48 2011 3 Bolt 1786 1 2011 3 Bull 9620 5253 2011 6 Cactus Mountain 8541 5224

5 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2011 4 Castro 4845 1307 2011 2 Coal Canyon 4801 1859 2011 5 1899 1318 2011 2 Crystal 1053 762 2011 6 Dollar Lake 6484 1834 2011 2 Duckett 3316 1889 2011 3 Duke 7484 1773 2011 3 Duquesne 1702 1124 2011 1 East Fork 12273 3109 2011 1 Forty One Complex 11621 5433 2011 3 Frio 4244 611 2011 3 Greaterville 2024 1396 2011 1 Hammer Creek 5950 2006 2011 2 Hole In The Wall 6333 5460 2011 3 Horseshoe 2 199253 96266 2011 8 Impassable Bay 7797 5531 2011 4 Indian 2084 475 2011 3 Jack Complex 4936 2 2011 3 Las Conchas 75687 33314 2011 3 Last Chance 26840 21317 2011 5 Lion 17858 4665 2011 1 Liz Butte 1117 17 2011 3 Lookout Complex 17976 2203 2011 3 Lower 1829 18 2011 3 Mayhill 18455 12310 2011 3 Miller 88397 15392 2011 3 Monument 16006 10501 2011 6 Mother Lode 2345 1214 2011 5 Motor 4952 2699 2011 3 Murphy Complex 66053 31786 2011 4 Nowlin 3844 1281 2011 8 Ocean Bay 3973 544 2011 1 Otter 6430 462 2011 3 Pacheco 9473 4953 2011 9 Pagami Creek 82241 64182 2011 3 Parallel 4435 810 2011 3 Pena 3852 1252 2011 3 Queen 3898 3440 2011 4 Red Rock Complex 12227 5681 2011 8 Rifle 2027 666 2011 3 Rocky 5009 6 2011 5 Ruth 1206 214 2011 4 Saddle Complex 34903 20281 2011 4 Salt 21750 9172 2011 3 Sand Rock Complex 4647 15 2011 6 Shadow Lake 10388 2974 2011 4 Ship Island 2422 825 2011 3 Skinner 2105 18 2011 1 Stewart 2844 1216 2011 1 Storm Complex 4304 807 2011 3 Tanner 5692 2281 2011 4 Velvet 3488 542 2011 3 Wallow 568765 197995 2011 3 White 9614 8088 2011 3 Woodbridge 1105 12 2012 8 Alleghany Tunnels 7702 1659

6 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2012 1 Ash Creek 95394 29814 2012 5 Bagley 33022 3630 2012 8 Barbours Creek 7192 2539 2012 6 Barry Point 59603 30044 2012 5 Bear 977 538 2012 4 Bear Cub 6614 3394 2012 4 Box Creek 2087 1188 2012 4 Butte Creek 1621 194 2012 6 Cache Creek 54179 35718 2012 3 Canyon 8780 3806 2012 6 Cascade Creek 20167 122 2012 5 Chips 66222 16865 2012 1 Chrandal Creek 2478 2270 2012 1 Condon Mountain 4112 666 2012 3 Cottonwood 1563 3 2012 8 County Line 28633 19428 2012 1 Dugan 6569 3616 2012 1 Dutch 9892 5734 2012 1 Elbow Pass Complex 28769 10346 2012 1 Elizabeth 1946 742 2012 5 Flat 1649 828 2012 4 Fontenelle 47906 25760 2012 5 Fort Complex 25522 7325 2012 3 Fox 6855 1122 2012 5 George 1698 887 2012 2 Gilead 6182 1094 2012 3 Gladiator 14946 10452 2012 3 Grapevine 17130 1188 2012 4 Halstead 209585 82765 2012 2 Hewlett 6226 1352 2012 2 High Park 42362 21421 2012 3 Horse Canyon 4890 1039 2012 3 Little Bear 35405 9447 2012 4 Little Pine 2227 1373 2012 2 Little Sand 24143 4226 2012 4 Lost Lake 2050 1165 2012 1 McGuire Complex 48599 11020 2012 4 Merino 10248 4322 2012 5 Mill 26354 18939 2012 1 Millie 10673 7033 2012 4 Minidoka Complex 61583 16649 2012 3 Mistake Peak 5304 1270 2012 4 Mustang Complex 404002 122183 2012 2 Myrtle 7474 5210 2012 4 North Buffalo 44247 13212 2012 5 North Pass 31123 5645 2012 4 North Schell 8210 3832 2012 6 Okanogan Complex 11570 2512 2012 1 Pine Creek 4801 3032 2012 3 Poco 11906 2307 2012 8 Point 2 1145 212 2012 6 Pole Creek 26597 8876 2012 1 Pony 3301 2567 2012 1 Prisoner Lake 5523 3960 2012 5 Ramsey 1127 172 2012 5 Reading 11066 4596

7 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2012 8 Rich Hole 14675 2796 2012 2 Russels Camp 4121 2053 2012 5 Salt Creek 862 592 2012 1 Sawtooth 4795 1892 2012 3 School Canyon 6268 528 2012 4 Seeley 38163 12213 2012 1 Sheep 33372 5609 2012 4 Shingle 7655 4893 2012 8 Shipwreck 3198 379 2012 2 Squirrel Creek 9468 5443 2012 5 Stafford 4125 991 2012 3 Sunflower 17801 7146 2012 6 Table Mountain 31949 9726 2012 1 Taylor Creek 54214 28904 2012 4 Trinity Ridge 145308 52552 2012 2 Waldo Canyon 15662 8509 2012 6 Wenatchee Complex 44731 8743 2012 4 Wesley 15828 3691 2012 2 White Draw 6092 1851 2012 3 Whitewater‐Baldy 315266 66508 2012 5 Williams 4110 3004 2012 6 Yakima Complex 2599 388 2013 5 American 22425 6335 2013 5 Aspen 22700 5019 2013 1 Bailey 2090 223 2013 4 Beaver Creek 91490 42141 2013 2 Burroughs 1773 1172 2013 4 Carpenter 1 26702 19835 2013 5 Carstens 1026 368 2013 4 Chestnut 3863 3481 2013 6 Conrad Lake 1088 236 2013 5 Corral Complex 13095 5021 2013 1 Damnation 8278 3724 2013 3 Doce 7739 5094 2013 2 East Peak 2429 616 2013 4 Elk Complex 99939 59107 2013 1 Eureka 6448 1058 2013 5 Fish 2103 887 2013 5 Forks Complex 22138 2040 2013 1 Gold Pan Complex 46402 19167 2013 6 Government Flats Complex 2360 957 2013 6 Green Ridge 1646 80 2013 2 Hardluck 24597 10896 2013 5 Hathaway 2950 1667 2013 8 Hopkins Prairie 1960 1572 2013 3 Jaroso 11506 5890 2013 4 Kelley 17443 7007 2013 6 Labrador 2033 462 2013 4 Little Queens 28109 10531 2013 4 Lodgepole 23204 12502 2013 6 Manastash Ridge 2359 936 2013 1 Miner Paradise Complex 12698 6803 2013 1 Moose Meadows 3500 1984 2013 5 Mountain 14376 11425 2013 5 Panther 2887 893 2013 4 Papoose 9502 3834

8 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2013 4 Patch Springs 19909 8977 2013 4 Pony Complex 52197 38155 2013 5 Powerhouse 19172 17613 2013 1 Red Shale 13583 8644 2013 4 Ridge 4976 2239 2013 5 Rim 154634 66993 2013 5 Salmon River Complex 14756 3671 2013 3 Silver 137641 31068 2013 4 Silver 2229 832 2013 5 Silver 3224 1910 2013 3 Skinner 1492 50 2013 9 Smoke Hole 1425 125 2013 3 Soldier Basin 10224 5683 2013 4 Spring Peak 8511 6684 2013 8 Table Rock 2532 56 2013 3 Thompson Ridge 41 0 2013 4 Thunder City 13465 4700 2013 3 Tres Lagunas 8086 2324 2013 6 Vinegar 1318 121 2013 2 West Fork Complex 107901 59841 2013 1 West Mullan 3334 609 2013 6 Whiskey Complex 17845 699 2014 6 790 3023 471 2014 6 36 Pit 3837 422 2014 6 5 Mile 3921 2802 2014 5 Bald 30783 18078 2014 6 Bald Sisters 3075 431 2014 3 Bar M 6211 19 2014 4 Bear Trap 10615 4372 2014 3 Belknap 2179 37 2014 6 Bridge 99 Complex 5658 1569 2014 6 Carlton Complex 98493 46091 2014 6 China Cap 1387 229 2014 6 Chiwaukum Complex 37749 16478 2014 5 Coffee Complex 6296 3733 2014 5 Day 1351 902 2014 6 Deception Complex 6472 404 2014 3 Diego 3343 1575 2014 5 Eiler 14837 9792 2014 5 El Portal 3558 2074 2014 6 Freezeout Ridge 3629 1152 2014 5 French 13128 5403 2014 8 Gravelstand 1148 113 2014 3 Hammer 8873 219 2014 4 Hampton 11766 7060 2014 5 Happy Camp Complex 130289 29433 2014 6 Hurricane Creek 2134 522 2014 1 Johnson Bar 12878 892 2014 5 King 63689 32094 2014 5 KNF Beaver 13627 5476 2014 4 Levan 3544 2633 2014 6 Little Bridge Creek 5565 1276 2014 5 Little Deer 4339 2434 2014 5 Log 1679 133 2014 3 McRae 5586 213 2014 1 Myers 2679 1413

9 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2014 5 Nicolls 1781 1267 2014 3 Oak 13041 3016 2014 6 Ochoco Complex 2778 276 2014 6 Onion Mountain 4131 1272 2014 3 Pino 3047 392 2014 1 Rain 4303 1431 2014 3 San Juan 6691 1846 2014 3 Signal 5756 1410 2014 3 Sitgreaves 11153 198 2014 3 Slide 21432 3161 2014 5 Soda 1543 33 2014 6 Somers 34721 19812 2014 6 South Fork Complex 26920 6884 2014 6 Sunflower 6785 1034 2014 2 Swede 1573 823 2014 3 Sycamore 3871 71 2014 1 Thompson River Complex 1644 311 2014 6 Two Bulls 4845 3987 2014 6 Upper Falls 8425 4168 2014 6 Waterman Complex 7794 1725 2014 4 Whiskey Complex 9046 3316 2014 5 Whites 32844 8667 2015 3 Alder 2286 8 2015 1 Army Mule 6531 2139 2015 1 Bailey 2121 580 2015 8 Bald Knob 942 61 2015 1 Baldy 5211 1274 2015 5 Barker 2512 911 2015 1 Barren 4224 1679 2015 5 Bear 11826 1407 2015 1 Bear Creek 61764 31569 2015 6 Bear Ridge 1858 12 2015 1 Berray Mountain 4492 511 2015 6 Black Canyon 33431 10816 2015 5 Blue 2468 891 2015 8 Blue Room 1787 0 2015 1 Boulder 5132 2430 2015 1 Breezy 1087 304 2015 5 Buck 1338 8 2015 6 Buckskin 5640 1260 2015 3 Burnt Complex 3911 2 2015 6 Butte Creek 68897 11647 2015 5 Cabin 6938 1593 2015 1 Cabin Gulch 1428 1032 2015 3 Camillo 23889 99 2015 4 Campbells 8434 1611 2015 6 Canyon Creek Complex 90572 37158 2015 9 Carty 2045 133 2015 5 Castle 14757 2955 2015 1 Chicadee 5584 450 2015 6 Collier Butte 12640 2196 2015 3 Commissary 2563 12 2015 5 Coon 5439 604 2015 6 Corner Creek 0297 PR 25523 6876 2015 6 Cornet‐Windy Ridge 29868 16846 2015 6 Cougar Creek 5617 3375

10 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2015 1 Crown 33491 14043 2015 4 Dillinger 7341 4027 2015 6 Dry Gulch 2504 1692 2015 6 Eagle 12924 861 2015 3 Echo 1951 5 2015 6 Eldorado 4146 2169 2015 4 Elevenmile 10472 6225 2015 1 Family Peak Complex 42158 22023 2015 6 First Creek 5167 2204 2015 1 Fourbit Creek 1566 49 2015 3 Fox 1103 0 2015 5 Frog 4867 2558 2015 3 General 2693 2 2015 5 Gobbler 7414 934 2015 6 Graves Mountain 8499 1512 2015 1 Green 1073 102 2015 3 Guadalupe 5247 1645 2015 1 Heather 2301 338 2015 3 Hog 7653 2953 2015 3 Horse Tank 3596 165 2015 1 Jay Pt 4156 853 2015 5 Johnson 22698 2798 2015 1 Klatawa 4972 596 2015 5 Lake 24095 13267 2015 5 Lassics 17589 2311 2015 1 Lena Lake 1253 337 2015 6 Limbelt 11435 3220 2015 1 Little Green 1428 435 2015 3 Locust 3272 15 2015 1 Lower Flat 7731 484 2015 1 Marble Creek 843 162 2015 1 Marston 7126 1934 2015 3 Mason‐Jar Cx 4360 13 2015 1 Meeker 3015 537 2015 1 Moonshine 2274 253 2015 3 Moore 4243 96 2015 1 Moose Ridge 11421 6476 2015 1 Napoleon 1 9023 433 2015 6 National Creek Complex 6395 748 2015 6 Newby Lake Long Draw 3231 1752 2015 5 Nickowitz 8002 102 2015 1 Noble 5607 2100 2015 1 North Grizzly 5100 631 2015 6 North Star 44215 10509 2015 1 Parker Ridge 3711 1442 2015 5 Pattison 12576 1249 2015 5 Peak 18903 2269 2015 1 Pete Forks 8034 2836 2015 6 Phillips Creek 1911 90 2015 5 Pickett 9362 1678 2015 5 Pine 1721 46 2015 3 Pinon 2910 30 2015 5 Rail 8222 2299 2015 3 Rebel 2324 4 2015 3 Red Canyon 15559 44 2015 6 Renner 11499 2207

11 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2015 5 River Complex 77318 9216 2015 3 Rock 2494 46 2015 1 Roll Creek 9282 2346 2015 5 Rough 135474 52680 2015 5 Round 2620 1655 2015 1 Sawtooth 3155 215 2015 1 Scotchman Peak 2430 776 2015 1 Sheep 2190 688 2015 1 Sheep Mountain 4224 1594 2015 5 Shiell 14765 2197 2015 1 Slide 11327 2462 2015 1 Snow Creek 2753 220 2015 1 Snowy Summit 6865 1064 2015 4 Solitude 2105 790 2015 1 South Bobtail 9813 1124 2015 1 Sponge‐Air Strip 6823 3727 2015 3 Springs 7403 50 2015 6 Stickpin 48961 27588 2015 6 Stouts Creek 14339 2484 2015 1 Sucker Creek 3104 1388 2015 4 Tepee Springs 72456 20972 2015 1 & 6 Tower 17109 3626 2015 1 Trail Creek 21795 13360 2015 6 Tunk Block 8541 2045 2015 3 Turkey 1306 1 2015 6 Twisp River 4937 1358 2015 4 Walker 5312 799 2015 5 Walker 3331 2736 2015 1 Wash 37906 9848 2015 4 Washington 16701 8899 2015 4 Waterfall 4075 1254 2015 1 West Fork Fish Creek 13434 6425 2015 1 Whitetail 1896 156 2015 5 Willow 5420 2045 2015 1 Wolf 2 1204 105 2015 6 Wolverine 63284 33393 2015 1 Woodrat 2554 124 2016 1 Cedar 4959 1289 2016 1 Copper King 19415 8037 2016 1 Moose 9144 2408 2016 1 Observation 1407 387 2016 1 Roaring Lion 6936 3948 2016 2 Beaver Creek 22344 10881 2016 2 Cold 1355 44 2016 2 Crow Peak 2375 477 2016 2 Fulton 3236 85 2016 2 Hayden Pass 15273 10799 2016 2 Hunter Peak 3572 2025 2016 2 Junkins 10571 5221 2016 2 Kelso 1288 71 2016 2 Lava Mountain 12235 8401 2016 2 Long Draw 2135 0 2016 2 Lost Solar 4771 773 2016 2 Snake 2559 1297 2016 3 Bert 5591 3398 2016 3 Black Peak 4524 1947

12 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2016 3 Coco 2997 80 2016 3 Cooney 3659 0 2016 3 Cowboy 2126 4 2016 3 Dog Head 6591 4625 2016 3 Eden 1177 30 2016 3 Elk 1930 7 2016 3 Fill 3243 93 2016 3 Fuller 6999 3588 2016 3 Jack 37272 450 2016 3 Juniper 31667 11590 2016 3 La Sierra 4843 1863 2016 3 Maple 1393 0 2016 3 Mckenna 10895 12 2016 3 Mormon 7892 55 2016 3 Mule Ridge 8212 4477 2016 3 North 40853 5155 2016 3 Pinchot 3864 0 2016 3 Pivot Rock 6014 47 2016 3 Sam Jim 2440 10 2016 3 School 7316 1237 2016 3 Scott 2256 1308 2016 3 Spur 2754 39 2016 3 Timber 2833 30 2016 3 Turkey 6462 308 2016 3 Wildcat 1501 1177 2016 4 Box Canyon 4470 793 2016 4 Briggs 7949 1421 2016 4 Buck 1260 548 2016 4 Cliff Creek 36100 11423 2016 4 Fly Canyon 2349 1070 2016 4 Jocks Canyon 1589 935 2016 4 Lower Ebbs 5468 4439 2016 4 Peterson Hollow 1265 384 2016 4 Pioneer 188917 88700 2016 4 Porcupine 2488 157 2016 4 Roaring 6012 2641 2016 4 Rough 4155 1151 2016 4 Saddle 2348 673 2016 4 Sawmill 1567 1101 2016 4 Strawberry 1417 1182 2016 4 West Government Creek 3230 2445 2016 5 Bluecut 29328 21980 2016 5 Cedar 28165 16554 2016 5 Clark 2827 1167 2016 5 Erskine 21865 14594 2016 5 Gap 23033 3345 2016 5 Jacobson 1673 332 2016 5 Meadow 4234 445 2016 5 Owens River 4649 3672 2016 5 Pilot 6870 4942 2016 5 Pine 2375 460 2016 5 Pony 2871 603 2016 5 Rey 19660 17359 2016 5 Sacata 2096 1103 2016 5 Sand 34581 27062 2016 5 Soberanes 90526 43250

13 Attachment B ‐ List of Total and High Severity Fire Acres 2007‐2016 Total Fire Acres High Severity Year Region Fire Name NFS Fire Acres NFS 2016 5 Soup 2 2512 649 2016 5 Trailhead 3597 498 2016 6 0624 Rs East Maury 1439 224 2016 6 Buck Creek 4040 735 2016 6 Rail 43803 19551 2016 8 Addison 617 2 2016 8 Big Point 3962 0 2016 8 Boteler 8455 69 2016 8 Camp Branch 2882 123 2016 8 Caney Head 905 1 2016 8 Cellar Mountain 641 3 2016 8 Clear Creek 1779 9 2016 8 Half Way 778 4 2016 8 Halls Top 2013 19 2016 8 Knob 978 0 2016 8 Lake Chinnabee 2207 0 2016 8 Maple Springs 7764 28 2016 8 Millis Swamp 1347 991 2016 8 Mount Pleasant 8935 22 2016 8 Neddy Mountain Road 608 27 2016 8 Old Roughy 589 0 2016 8 Pipeline 3285 0 2016 8 Power Horn 520 2 2016 8 Railroad Grade 2016 1495 7 2016 8 Raven Rock 1041 3 2016 8 Rock Mountain 23994 53 2016 8 Rock Pond 1289 8 2016 8 Silver Mine 5858 260 2016 8 Tater Creek 623 0 2016 8 Taylor 941 62 2016 8 Tellico 9659 244 2016 8 Timber Ridge 644 1 2016 8 Welcome Home 1 1022 16 2016 8 Wood Lake 1347 2 2016 9 Foss Lake 901 437

Totals 12,248,235 4,651,453

14 Attachment C ‐ Number of Severely Burned Acres Proposed for Salvage Harvest ESTIMATED NEPA SALVAGE DECISION TYPE OF NEPA ANALYSIS ACRES IN PROJECT_NAME SIGNED DATE CONDUCTED DECISION Restoration Project 9‐Jul‐10 Environmental Assessment 1,398 Ashland Roadside Hazard Tree Abatement &19‐Apr‐13 Categorical Exclusion 176 Ashland Roadside Hazard Tree Abatement &26‐Nov‐13 Categorical Exclusion 94 Aspen Recovery and Reforestation Project 1‐Jun‐14 Environmental Assessment 2,806 Bagley Hazard Tree Abatement Project 29‐Aug‐13 Environmental Assessment 776 Bailey Butte Salvage 19‐May‐15 Environmental Assessment 900 Bald Fire Salvage and Restoration Projec 8‐Jul‐15 Environmental Assessment 8,447 Barry Point Salvage Project 31‐Jul‐13 Environmental Assessment 2,669 Barry Point South Salvage Project 25‐Jun‐13 Environmental Assessment 1,668 Big Hope Fire Salvage and Restoration Pr 24‐Jun‐14 Environmental Assessment 8,965 Brimstone Salvage 24‐Nov‐14 Categorical Exclusion 248 Bull Salvage 19‐Nov‐14 Categorical Exclusion 249 Cascade Creek Salvage 8‐Aug‐13 Categorical Exclusion 56 Chip‐munk Recovery and Restoration Proje 30‐Jul‐13 Environmental Assessment 5,463 Chips Fire Roadside Hazard Tree Removal 7‐Dec‐12 Categorical Exclusion 250 Chitty Fire TImber Salvage 2‐Sep‐10 Categorical Exclusion 200 Cornet Windy Ridge Fire ‐ Burnt River Wa 19‐Feb‐16 Categorical Exclusion 250 Restoration 29‐Jul‐15 Categorical Exclusion 124 Eagle Salvage 25‐Jul‐16 Categorical Exclusion 250 Five Mile Fire Salvage 29‐May‐15 Categorical Exclusion 20 Fontenelle Salvage 26‐Sep‐13 Environmental Assessment 1,125 French Fire Recovery and Reforestation Project 26‐Aug‐15 Environmental Assessment 3,387 Grizzly Fire Salvage and Restoration Project 30‐Jun‐16 Environmental Assessment 3,025 GW Fire Timber Salvage Project 27‐Jun‐08 Categorical Exclusion 218 Huntit Fire Salvage and Reforestation Pr 18‐Apr‐16 Categorical Exclusion 250 Kelley Salvage 21‐Jan‐14 Categorical Exclusion 30 Mill Fire Salvage and Hazard Tree Removal Project 23‐Apr‐13 Environmental Assessment 562 Moonlight‐Wheeler Fires Recovery and Restoration Project 20‐Jul‐09 Environmental Impact Statement 14,755 North Whitetail Post Fire Project 28‐Jun‐16 Categorical Exclusion 250 Onion Salvage 9‐Jul‐15 Categorical Exclusion 120 Panther II Fire Salvage Project 23‐Aug‐10 Environmental Assessment 536 Poker Chip Project 10‐Jul‐13 Environmental Assessment 2,139 Pole Salvage 30‐Sep‐13 Environmental Assessment 962 Rat Creek Fire Salvage 22‐Jul‐09 Environmental Assessment 2,500 Reading Project 10‐Jul‐13 Environmental Assessment 4,203 HT (Hazard Trees) 5‐May‐14 Environmental Assessment 1,329 Rim Fire Recovery 28‐Aug‐14 Environmental Impact Statement 15,383 Roadside Hazard Tree Removal Project 18‐Jun‐13 Environmental Assessment 1,440 Salmon Salvage 24‐Jul‐14 Environmental Assessment 330 Second Stick 28‐Jul‐16 Categorical Exclusion 250 Snowy Pete Roadside Hazard 17‐Aug‐16 Environmental Assessment 1,600 Stafford Fire Salvage and Restoration Pr 23‐Aug‐13 Environmental Impact Statement 780 Sunflower Fire Roadside Salvage 10‐Nov‐14 Categorical Exclusion 314 Tower Fire Salvage and Reforestation Project 23‐Jun‐16 Environmental Assessment 1,819 Trinity Ridge Fire Roadside Salvage 3‐May‐13 Categorical Exclusion 250 Wallow Alpine Salvage CE 4‐Feb‐13 Categorical Exclusion 242 Wallow West Fuel Reduction and Forest Re 7‐Jun‐12 Environmental Assessment 14,010 Westside Fire Recovery Project 29‐Feb‐16 Environmental Impact Statement 5,570

Total 112,388 Attachment D ‐ Time from NEPA Decision to Sale Award FS NAT FIRE NEPA SIGNED ADVERTISED AWARD OR AWARD SALE ACRES NEPA DEC REGION FOREST YEAR DATE DATE ACCOMP DATE FY NBR SALE NAME AWARDED TYPE NEPA DOC NAME FIRE NAME FIRE ACRES 1 2 2007 5/19/2008 9/15/2008 2008 8301 RAT CREEK ROADSIDE SALV HAZ REDUC RESALE 283 DM (PALS)RAT CREEK ROADSIDE HAZARD REDUCTION Rat Creek 24,781 1 10 2007 10/16/2008 12/20/2007 2008 4 BRUSH ROADSIDE SALVAGE 1788 ROD (PALS)SHEPPARD CREEK POST‐FIRE PROJECT Brush Creek 29,641 MADISON ARM COMMERCIAL FIREWOOD AND 1 11 2007 6/4/2009 7/21/2010 2010 29716 POST & POLE PROJECT 1 RESALE 146.5 DN (PALS)MADISON ARM COMMERCIAL FIREWOOD DECISION NOTICE Madison Arm 3,794 1 11 2007 6/4/2009 6/23/2010 2010 29715 POST & POLE PROJECT 1A RESALE 327 DN (PALS)MADISON ARM COMMERCIAL FIREWOOD DECISION NOTICE Madison Arm 3,794 1 11 2007 6/4/2009 5/25/2010 2010 29714 POST & POLE PROJECT 3 39.8 DN (PALS)MADISON ARM COMMERCIAL FIREWOOD DECISION NOTICE Madison Arm 3,794 1 11 2007 6/4/2009 5/24/2010 2010 29713 POST & POLE PROJECT 4 96 DN (PALS)MADISON ARM COMMERCIAL FIREWOOD DECISION NOTICE Madison Arm 3,794 1 11 2007 6/4/2009 5/24/2010 2010 29712 POST & POLE PROJECT 4A 88 DN (PALS)MADISON ARM COMMERCIAL FIREWOOD DECISION NOTICE Madison Arm 3,794 1 11 2007 3/14/2008 7/16/2008 2008 28210 PROJECT 54 DM (PALS)WICKED CREEK ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE REDUCTION DECISION WH Complex 28,260 1 15 2007 10/5/2007 2008 9 Fool Creek 61,163 1 15 2007 6/9/2008 8/18/2008 2008 8102 TETON HAZARD REDUCTION SALVAGE SALE 106 DM (PALS)TETON HAZARD REDUCTION Fool Creek 61,163 1 16 2007 12/19/2008 1/8/2009 2009 9001 JOCKO SALVAGE 330 DN (PALS)JOCKO LAKES FIRE SALVAGE Jocko Lakes 38,581 4 2 2007 6/20/2008 8/20/2008 2008 189 DN (PALS)MIDDLE FORK SALVAGE DECISION NOTICE Lucky 1,583 4 2 2007 6/20/2008 8/20/2008 2008 8602 LUCKY SALVAGE RE‐OFFER 40 DN (PALS)MIDDLE FORK SALVAGE DECISION NOTICE Lucky 1,583 4 12 2007 4/18/2008 Not Awarded 8102 GRAY'S CREEK FIRE SALVAGE 60 DN (PALS)GRAYS CREEK FIRE SALVAGE PROJECT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESS Grays Creek 24,683 4 12 2007 12/3/2012 5/8/2013 2013 13601 KRASSEL ADMINISTRATIVE HAZARD TREE 5 DM (PALS)KRASSEL ADMINISTRATIVE HAZARD TREE East Zone Complex 235,072 4 13 2007 9/30/2014 2014 423 Shower Bath 53,874 4 13 2007 9/30/2014 2014 505 Van Horn 1,575 4 13 2007 10/1/2012 2013 110 SOUTH ZONE CHARGE PERSONAL USE FIREWOOD 928 Shower Bath 53,874 6 4 2007 9/8/2008 10/28/2008 2009 1642 DN (PALS)EGLEY FIRE RESTORATION PROJECT DECISION NOTICE AND FON Egley Complex 138,654 6 4 2007 10/1/2008 2009 4265 Egley Complex 138,654 6 4 2007 6/8/2011 2011 11006 41 RD SALVAGE 1311 Egley Complex 138,654 6 14 2007 7/14/2008 10/26/2009 2010 100 DM (PALS)OTTER FIRE SALVAGE SALE CE Otter Creek 3,041 6 14 2007 7/14/2008 10/26/2009 2010 50803 OTTER SALVAGE 167 DM (PALS)OTTER FIRE SALVAGE SALE CE Otter Creek 3,041 6 14 2007 7/12/2010 11/9/2010 2011 20001 WILDCAT II 25 DN (PALS)WILDCAT II FUELS REDUCTION AND VEGETATION MANAGEMENMonument Complex 54,108 9 9 2007 11/23/2007 4/1/2008 2008 20331 ROUND LOON 12 DM (PALS)HAM LAKE SALVAGE DECISION MEMO Ham Lake 73,721 4 7 2008 4/30/2009 2/12/2010 3/12/2010 2010 20401 CORN CREEK SALVAGE 189 DN (PALS)CORN CREEK FIRE SALVAGE AND REFORESTATION PROJECT Corn Creek 2,336 5 5 2008 10/2/2009 9/14/2010 2010 40902 PROJECT 94 DN (PALS)CARIBOU FIRE REFORESTATION PROJECT Bear Wallow Complex 71,432 5 6 2008 9/7/2010 2010 831 BTU Lightning Complex 58,342 5 6 2008 2/17/2009 8/28/2009 9/21/2009 2009 30122 SALVAGE REOFFER 3 645.7 DN (PALS)CORRAL FIRE SALVAGE AND FUELS REDUCTION PROJECT Corral 12,057 5 6 2008 6/10/2009 7/21/2009 2009 40038 SLATE FUELWOOD 241 Cub Complex 20,869 5 11 2008 3/17/2009 6/29/2009 2009 38.2 DM (PALS)DOME SALVAGE TREE PROJECT SSTS Canyon Complex 39,799 5 11 2008 9/29/2009 10/20/2009 2010 598.6 DN (PALS) RECOVERY AND ROADSIDE SAFETY PROJECT Canyon Complex 39,799 5 11 2008 7/1/2010 9/22/2010 2010 123.3 DN (PALS)RICH FIRE RECOVERY PROJECT Rich 6,931 5 11 2008 6/26/2012 10/30/2013 11/13/2013 2014 11305 RIDGE BLOWDOWN SSTS 12.2 DN (PALS)DN AND FONSI FOR BIG HILL EA Canyon Complex 39,799 5 14 2008 5/26/2015 2015 1.5 Lime Complex 91,311 5 14 2008 7/18/2016 2016 10.4 Lime Complex 91,311 5 14 2008 10/15/2008 10/29/2008 2009 52806 MINERS FIRE SALVAGE 265.2 Iron Alps Complex 108,098 5 17 2008 1/9/2009 7/15/2009 2009 219.2 DM (PALS)FALL FIRE SALVAGE PROJECT Yuba River Complex 4,307 5 17 2008 4/30/2009 10/2/2009 10/13/2009 2010 29406 BLACK FORK FIRE SALVAGE RE‐OFFER 616.2 DN (PALS)BLACK FORK FIRE SALVAGE AND HAZARD TREE REMOVAL PROJEAmerican River Complex 21,298 5 17 2008 1/9/2009 7/15/2009 2009 1 NA 41.2 DM (PALS)FALL FIRE SALVAGE PROJECT Yuba River Complex 4,307 3 1 2009 7/1/2005 7/29/2008 2008 163 DN (PALS)NAGEL FOREST HEALTH PROJECT Chevlon Complex 12,170 3 11 2009 7/1/2005 11/15/2010 2011 20801 WATER SPRINGS A 321 DN (PALS)NAGEL FOREST HEALTH PROJECT Chevlon Complex 12,170 5 5 2009 1/7/2011 2011 71005 MT.HEBRON FIRE SALVAGE MULTIPRODUCT 767 DN MT. HEBRON #1 Tennant 3,184 5 6 2009 6/23/2015 7/14/2015 7/22/2015 2015 30176 HAZARD TREE SSTS 11.8 DM (PALS)HIGHWAY 44 WINDTHROW AND HAZARD TREE REMOVAL PROJ Hat Creek Complex 11,385 5 6 2009 9/9/2003 11/20/2015 2016 20200 SOUTH EBLIS WT SSTS RESALE 31.2 DN QSOUTH STATION PROJECT Hat Creek Complex 11,385 6 15 2009 10/1/2009 2010 5.6 Williams Creek 9,487 16 Attachment D ‐ Time from NEPA Decision to Sale Award FS NAT FIRE NEPA SIGNED ADVERTISED AWARD OR AWARD SALE ACRES NEPA DEC REGION FOREST YEAR DATE DATE ACCOMP DATE FY NBR SALE NAME AWARDED TYPE NEPA DOC NAME FIRE NAME FIRE ACRES 6 15 2009 6/29/2010 8/11/2010 2010 10603 WILLIAMS CREEK SALVAGE 42 DM (PALS)WILLIAMS CREEK FIRE SALVAGE TIMBER SALE Williams Creek 9,487 6 18 2009 7/19/2011 4/26/2012 2012 10116 TUMBLEBUG SALVAGE 443 DN (PALS)TUMBLEBUG FIRE ROADSIDE TREATMENT PROJECT Tumblebug Complex 14,814 4 13 2010 8/8/2011 10/26/2011 2012 136 DN (PALS)DECISION NOTICE FONSI FOR LO‐ELLY FUELS REDUCTION PROJE Banner 2,364 3 1 2011 2/7/2007 12/31/2014 2015 200 DM (PALS)BEAVERHEAD FIRE SALVAGE Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 2/4/2013 10/1/2014 2015 23 DM (PALS)WALLOW ALPINE SALVAGE AND FUEL REDUCTION PROJECT Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 3/20/2013 10/1/2014 2015 90 DM (PALS)WALLOW ASPEN PROJECT Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 8/10/2006 12/1/2011 2012 1313 DN (PALS)DN & FONSI EAGAR SOUTH WILDLAND URBAN INTERFACE FUEL Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 11/22/2004 7/2/2016 2016 20 DN (PALS)GREER WILDLAND URBAN INTERFACE FUELS REDUCTION Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 11/25/2014 2015 172 Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 6/14/2006 1/11/2012 2012 10101 01‐10‐NUTRIOSO 2 4395 DN (PALS)NUTRIOSO WILDLAND URBAN INTERFACE FUEL REDUCTION Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 6/7/2012 5/10/2013 2013 61203 06‐13 BURRO SALVAGE 1093 DN (PALS)WALLOW WEST FUEL REDUCTION AND FOREST RECOVERY PROJWallow 630,447 3 1 2011 8/1/2013 2013 61304 116A RD SALVAGE 48 NR CE without DM Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 1/15/2015 2015 11206 191 SOUTH ADMINISTRATIVE FREE USE 218 NR CE without DM Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 6/27/2013 2013 11307 8842 SALVAGE 78 NR CE without DM Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 10/29/2013 11/21/2013 2014 61401 BIG LAKE TOWER HAZARD SALVAGE 28 NR CE without DM Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 9/2/2009 9/19/2014 5/15/2015 2015 14105 CHITTY BLOWDOWN SALVAGE 314 DM (PALS)CHITTY FIRE SALVAGE Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 11/1/2012 2013 11301 FISH BENCH SALVAGE 263 NR CE without DM Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 8/31/2012 10/1/2012 2012 11212 HULSEY BENCH 146 NR CE without DM Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 8/11/2011 2011 3001 HWY 261 HAZARD TREES 990 Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 6/14/2006 9/19/2014 10/22/2014 2015 14106 NUTRI1B BLOWDOWN SALVAGE 142 DN (PALS)NUTRIOSO WILDLAND URBAN INTERFACE FUEL REDUCTION Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 4/10/2014 2014 61404 SAFFELL PAT KNOLL HAZARDS SALVAGE 38 NR CE without DM Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 2/4/2013 4/16/2013 5/16/2013 2013 11304 WALLOW ALPINE 1 SALVAGE 168 DM (PALS)WALLOW ALPINE SALVAGE AND FUEL REDUCTION PROJECT Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 8/11/2011 2011 200 WALLOW BURN AREA COMMERCIAL PRODUCTS 5360 Wallow 630,447 3 1 2011 6/7/2012 8/11/2014 2014 14605 WALLOW WEST UNIT 26 90 DN (PALS)WALLOW WEST FUEL REDUCTION AND FOREST RECOVERY PROJWallow 630,447 3 1 2011 6/7/2012 8/15/2015 2015 14606 WALLOW WEST UNIT 27 SALVAGE 492 DN (PALS)WALLOW WEST FUEL REDUCTION AND FOREST RECOVERY PROJWallow 630,447 3 1 2011 7/29/2014 2014 14603 WEST FORK TRAILHEAD HAZARDS 28 NR CE without DM Wallow 630,447 3 10 2011 3/5/2013 2013 30001 289 HAZARD TREE 78 Las Conchas 145,813 1 8 2012 4/19/2013 10/26/2014 4/17/2015 2015 15401 ASHLAND ROADSIDE SALVAGE HTR RESALE 76 DM (PALS)ASHLAND ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE ABATEMENT & REMOVAsh Creek MT 261,550 1 8 2012 7/20/2016 8/3/2016 2016 16842 NORTH WHITETAIL SALVAGE 247 Ash Creek MT 261,550 1 8 2012 Not Awarded 6301 ZIG ZAG SALVAGE 52 NR CE without DM Dugan 10,644 1 11 2012 11/26/2013 10/5/2014 11/7/2014 2015 14401 REMOVAL 182 DM (PALS)ASHLAND ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE ABATEMENT & REMOVAsh Creek MT 261,550 1 11 2012 4/17/2013 9/12/2013 9/24/2013 2013 13604 MILLIE ROADSIDE SALVAGE HTR RESALE 164 DM (PALS)DECISION MEMO ‐ MILLIE ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE REMOVAL Millie 10,709 1 11 2012 3/14/2008 3/31/2008 2008 28211 REDUCTION PROJECT 21 DM (PALS)WICKED CREEK ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE REDUCTION DECISION Pine Creek 8,277 1 17 2012 6/18/2013 10/30/2013 11/8/2013 2014 41316 BLACK SHEEP SALVAGE 372 DN (PALS)NEZ PERCE ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE PROJECT Sheep 48,446 1 17 2012 6/18/2013 10/23/2013 11/21/2013 2014 41317 QUAGMIRE SALVAGE 400 DN (PALS)NEZ PERCE ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE PROJECT McGuire Complex 48,631 3 6 2012 7/11/2013 7/21/2014 2014 93 DM (PALS)WHITEWATER‐BALDY HAZARD TREE REMOVAL Whitewater Baldy 316,681 3 6 2012 9/1/2007 2007 316 Whitewater Baldy 316,681 4 2 2012 5/3/2013 11/1/2015 2016 106 DM (PALS)TRINITY RIDGE FIRE ROADSIDE SALVAGE PROJECT DECISION ME Trinity Ridge 147,289 4 2 2012 10/1/2015 2016 4 Trinity Ridge 147,289 4 2 2012 5/6/2015 2015 42106 RED WARRIOR PIT REOFFER 2 Trinity Ridge 147,289 4 2 2012 5/3/2013 6/11/2013 6/20/2013 2013 42103 TRINITY 129 SALVAGE 52 DM (PALS)TRINITY RIDGE FIRE ROADSIDE SALVAGE PROJECT DECISION ME Trinity Ridge 147,289 4 2 2012 5/3/2013 8/1/2013 2013 42104 TRINITY 172 SALVAGE 14 DM (PALS)TRINITY RIDGE FIRE ROADSIDE SALVAGE PROJECT DECISION ME Trinity Ridge 147,289 4 2 2012 5/3/2013 7/31/2013 2013 42102 TRINITY 255 SALVAGE 46 DM (PALS)TRINITY RIDGE FIRE ROADSIDE SALVAGE PROJECT DECISION ME Trinity Ridge 147,289 4 3 2012 9/26/2013 9/16/2014 2014 70 DN (PALS)FONTENELLE FIRE SALVAGE PROJECT DN/FONSI Fontenelle 64,305 4 3 2012 9/13/2013 2013 1 Fontenelle 64,305 4 3 2012 9/26/2013 6/7/2014 8/25/2014 2014 30214 FONTENELLE SALVAGE 1 DN (PALS)FONTENELLE FIRE SALVAGE PROJECT DN/FONSI Fontenelle 64,305 4 3 2012 11/7/2006 2007 6208 SACAJAWEA 11 Fontenelle 64,305 17 Attachment D ‐ Time from NEPA Decision to Sale Award FS NAT FIRE NEPA SIGNED ADVERTISED AWARD OR AWARD SALE ACRES NEPA DEC REGION FOREST YEAR DATE DATE ACCOMP DATE FY NBR SALE NAME AWARDED TYPE NEPA DOC NAME FIRE NAME FIRE ACRES 4 7 2012 9/26/2013 9/19/2014 2014 1086 DN (PALS)SHINGLE FIRE SALVAGE AND RESTORATION Shingle 8,095 4 10 2012 5/17/2013 8/25/2015 9/30/2015 2015 11 MINE 1 158 DN (PALS)SHALOM HAZARD FUELS PROJECT Seeley 47,768 4 13 2012 7/22/2008 10/26/2011 2012 120 DN (PALS)CAPE HORN ROAD FUELS REDUCTION Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 6/10/2009 2009 437 Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 8/8/2011 6/26/2014 7/30/2014 2014 14601 008 ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE SALE 163.5 DN (PALS)DECISION NOTICE FONSI FOR LO‐ELLY FUELS REDUCTION PROJE Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 6/26/2014 8/27/2014 2014 14602 172 ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE REMOVAL 93 NR CE without DM Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 6/26/2014 7/28/2014 2014 14603 203‐199 ROADSIDE HAZARD TIMBER SALE 54 NR CE without DM Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 8/8/2011 6/6/2013 9/19/2013 2013 13602 BOY SCOUT HILL TIMBER SALE 62 DN (PALS)DECISION NOTICE FONSI FOR LO‐ELLY FUELS REDUCTION PROJE Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 8/8/2011 9/23/2016 2016 16602 CAPE HORN LAKES SALVAGE 15 DN (PALS)DECISION NOTICE FONSI FOR LO‐ELLY FUELS REDUCTION PROJE Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 9/25/2012 10/23/2012 2013 12605 DRY CREEK ROADSIDE HTR 205 NR CE without DM Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 8/8/2011 8/15/2013 11/25/2013 2014 13601 LO‐ELLY TIMBER SALE 108 DN (PALS)DECISION NOTICE FONSI FOR LO‐ELLY FUELS REDUCTION PROJE Halstead 210,015 4 13 2012 7/11/2013 8/12/2013 2013 13605 VALLEY CREEK DECKS 8 Halstead 210,015 5 6 2012 7/10/2013 5/27/2014 2014 253 DN (PALS)POKER CHIP PROJECT Chips 76,349 5 6 2012 9/19/2014 2014 833 Chips 76,349 5 6 2012 7/10/2013 8/6/2013 8/15/2013 2013 20183 LOST FIRE SALVAGE 821.1 DN (PALS)READING PROJECT Reading 28,073 5 6 2012 7/10/2013 7/16/2013 7/26/2013 2013 20182 NORTH RAIL FIRE SALVAGE 1649.8 DN (PALS)READING PROJECT Reading 28,073 5 6 2012 7/10/2013 10/9/2014 2015 20195 PEACOCK STEWARDSHIP 686 DN (PALS)POKER CHIP PROJECT Chips 76,349 5 6 2012 7/10/2013 7/16/2013 8/5/2013 2013 20197 POKER CHIPS FIRE SALVAGE HELICOPTER 943 DN (PALS)POKER CHIP PROJECT Chips 76,349 5 6 2012 7/10/2013 7/16/2013 7/26/2013 2013 20181 PROSPECT FIRE SALVAGE 724.3 DN (PALS)READING PROJECT Reading 28,073 5 11 2012 7/30/2013 8/21/2013 8/29/2013 2013 21312 DUTCH FIRE SALVAGE 1544.4 DN (PALS)DN AND FONSI CHIP‐MUNK RECOVERY AND RESTORATION PROJChips 76,349 5 11 2012 12/7/2012 1/30/2013 3/8/2013 2013 21306 FORK ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE SSTS 89.1 DM (PALS)CHIPS FIRE ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE REMOVAL PROJECT Chips 76,349 5 11 2012 7/30/2013 8/14/2013 8/23/2013 2013 21314 MOSQUITO FIRE SALVAGE SBA 761.8 DN (PALS)DN AND FONSI CHIP‐MUNK RECOVERY AND RESTORATION PROJChips 76,349 5 11 2012 12/7/2012 3/13/2013 4/15/2013 2013 21305 OHIO ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE FIRE SALVAGE 131.8 DM (PALS)CHIPS FIRE ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE REMOVAL PROJECT Chips 76,349 5 11 2012 7/1/2013 12/11/2013 6/16/2014 2014 21311 POWERLINE II FIRE SALVAGE 70.1 DM (PALS)CHIPS FIRE PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC RIGHT OF WAY SALVAGEChips 76,349 5 11 2012 7/1/2013 7/24/2013 2013 21307 POWERLINE SETTLEMENT FIRE SALVAGE 153.1 DM (PALS)CHIPS FIRE PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC RIGHT OF WAY SALVAGEChips 76,349 5 11 2012 7/30/2013 9/11/2013 9/20/2013 2013 21313 SKINNER FIRE SALVAGE REOFFER 1591 DN (PALS)DN AND FONSI CHIP‐MUNK RECOVERY AND RESTORATION PROJChips 76,349 5 11 2012 8/25/2015 10/14/2015 10/23/2015 2016 21505 SOUTH ALMA SALVAGE 22.6 DM (PALS)SOUTH ALMA SALVAGE DECISION MEMO Chips 76,349 5 14 2012 5/12/2015 2015 2.5 Stafford 4,423 5 14 2012 8/26/2013 10/30/2014 2015 52151 STAFFORD LOCAL SALVAGE 0.5 DN (PALS)STAFFORD FIRE SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT DECISIONStafford 4,423 5 14 2012 8/26/2013 9/24/2014 10/7/2014 2015 52145 STAFFORD MIXED SALVAGE 12.6 DN (PALS)STAFFORD FIRE SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT DECISIONStafford 4,423 6 1 2012 11/19/2013 11/22/2013 3/4/2014 2014 13892 PCN SALVAGE 628 DN (PALS)POLE CREEK FIRE TIMBER SALVAGE PROJECT Pole Creek 26,603 6 1 2012 11/19/2013 11/22/2013 12/6/2013 2014 13891 POLE CREEK SALVAGE 492 DN (PALS)POLE CREEK FIRE TIMBER SALVAGE PROJECT Pole Creek 26,603 6 2 2012 7/31/2013 11/4/2014 11/14/2014 2015 14022 BP ROADSIDE STEW REOFFER 5656.5 DN (PALS) SALVAGE PROJECT AND FOREST PLAN AMEN Barry Point 92,761 6 3 2012 8/8/2013 11/18/2013 12/19/2013 2014 13044 CC FIRE SALVAGE 1 DM (PALS)CASCADE CREEK SALVAGE DECISION MEMO Cascade Creek 20,168 4 2 2013 9/4/2015 2015 15101 FALL CREEK HAZARD TREE SALVAGE 36 ELK COMPLEX 131,029 4 13 2013 9/30/2012 2012 360 LODGEPOLE 23,223 4 14 2013 1/21/2014 4/7/2014 5/1/2014 2014 14551 KELLEY SALVAGE 30 DM (PALS)KELLEY SALVAGE KELLEY 17,445 5 5 2013 7/24/2014 8/7/2014 8/28/2014 2014 41401 SALMON SALVAGE FIRE HELI 974 DN (PALS)SALMON SALVAGE DECISION NOTICE AND FINDING OF NO SIGNSALMON RIVER COMPLEX 14,779 5 15 2013 6/27/2014 7/7/2014 7/22/2014 2014 14058 ASPEN FIRE SALVAGE SBA 75.9 DN (PALS)ALTERNATIVE 2 OF THE ASPEN RECOVERY AND REFORESTATIONASPEN 22,730 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 6/30/2016 2016 92.4 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 6/5/2009 3/31/2016 2016 6 DN (PALS)SOLDIER CREEK HEALTHY FOREST RESTORATION RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/29/2016 2016 52.3 NR CE without DM RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 8/28/2014 1/26/2015 2015 675.8 ROD (PALS)RIM FIRE RECOVERY RECORD OF DECISION RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 5/1/2014 6/3/2014 2014 54359 BLACKWOOD HT FS 1899.6 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 5/1/2014 5/27/2014 2014 54362 CROCKER HT FS 1064.1 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 5/29/2014 2014 54360 DITCH IT SETTLEMENT 187.6 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 8/28/2014 6/10/2015 6/22/2015 2015 54377 DOUBLE NORTH FS 315.3 ROD (PALS)RIM FIRE RECOVERY RECORD OF DECISION RIM 257,620 18 Attachment D ‐ Time from NEPA Decision to Sale Award FS NAT FIRE NEPA SIGNED ADVERTISED AWARD OR AWARD SALE ACRES NEPA DEC REGION FOREST YEAR DATE DATE ACCOMP DATE FY NBR SALE NAME AWARDED TYPE NEPA DOC NAME FIRE NAME FIRE ACRES 5 16 2013 8/28/2014 11/25/2015 2016 54397 DOUBLE SOUTH HT FS 114.1 ROD (PALS)RIM FIRE RECOVERY RECORD OF DECISION RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 8/28/2014 11/17/2014 12/11/2014 2015 54373 FEMMONS FIRE SALVAGE 3148.2 ROD (PALS)RIM FIRE RECOVERY RECORD OF DECISION RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 8/18/2014 2014 54370 GATEWAY HT FS 91.6 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 6/8/2016 2016 54401 GOLDEN GATE HT SALVAGE (MP) 561.9 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 5/1/2014 6/3/2014 2014 54361 MATCHSTICK HT FS 802 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 5/5/2014 2014 54358 PG&E HT FS SETTLEMENT 384.4 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 8/28/2014 10/23/2014 11/4/2014 2015 54372 REED FIRE SALVAGE 1583.1 ROD (PALS)RIM FIRE RECOVERY RECORD OF DECISION RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 8/28/2014 12/2/2014 8/12/2015 2015 54374 RIDGE FIRE SALVAGE 153.8 ROD (PALS)RIM FIRE RECOVERY RECORD OF DECISION RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 8/28/2014 9/29/2015 2015 54376 RIDGE FIRE SALVAGE STEWARDSHIP 600.3 ROD (PALS)RIM FIRE RECOVERY RECORD OF DECISION RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 5/1/2014 5/12/2014 2014 54363 SAWMILL HT FS 1222.6 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 16 2013 4/25/2014 6/4/2014 6/30/2014 2014 54364 TWIN LAKES HT FS 562 DN (PALS)RIM FIRE HAZARD TREES RIM 257,620 5 17 2013 6/24/2014 7/30/2014 8/11/2014 2014 14404 BARN FIRE SALVAGE 887.3 DN (PALS)BIG HOPE FIRE SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT AMERICAN 27,443 5 17 2013 6/24/2014 7/23/2014 8/1/2014 2014 14407 DEADWOOD FIRE SALVAGE REOFFER 1006.6 DN (PALS)BIG HOPE FIRE SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT AMERICAN 27,443 5 17 2013 6/24/2014 9/4/2014 9/15/2014 2014 14405 DUSTY FIRE SALVAGE SSTS REOFFER 900.8 DN (PALS)BIG HOPE FIRE SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT AMERICAN 27,443 5 17 2013 3/12/2014 3/27/2014 4/11/2014 2014 14403 FORD HAZARD TREE TIMBER SALE 246.7 DM (PALS)FORD ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE REMOVAL PROJECT AMERICAN 27,443 5 17 2013 6/24/2014 7/3/2014 7/17/2014 2014 14402 MACEDON FIRE SALVAGE 2080.9 DN (PALS)BIG HOPE FIRE SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT AMERICAN 27,443 3 1 2014 9/19/2014 10/21/2014 2015 14607 SAN JUAN ROAD HAZARD SALVAGE 291 NR CE without DM SAN JUAN 6,997 5 3 2014 4/16/2015 5/11/2015 5/22/2015 2015 15301 GOODBYE GIRL SSTS RE‐OFFER 189 DM (PALS)GEORGETOWN RECREATION FACILITY FIRE RECOVERY PROJECT KING 96,552 5 5 2014 2/29/2016 1/9/2016 2016 560 ROD (PALS)WESTSIDE FIRE RECOVERY PROJECT RECORD OF DECISION WHITES 33,795 5 5 2014 7/10/2013 4/1/2014 2014 51201 EAGLE SPRINGS RD HZD SALV SBA 1534 DM (PALS)EAGLE SPRINGS ROADSIDE HAZARD HAPPY CAMP COMPLEX 133,177 5 5 2014 2/29/2016 4/28/2016 5/10/2016 2016 51502 MIDDLE CREEK FIRE SALVAGE RE‐OFFER II 804 ROD (PALS)WESTSIDE FIRE RECOVERY PROJECT RECORD OF DECISION HAPPY CAMP COMPLEX 133,177 5 5 2014 2/29/2016 3/11/2016 4/14/2016 2016 11502 WALKER CREEK FIRE SALVAGE HELI 6 ROD (PALS)WESTSIDE FIRE RECOVERY PROJECT RECORD OF DECISION HAPPY CAMP COMPLEX 133,177 5 5 2014 2/29/2016 4/28/2016 5/10/2016 2016 41502 WHITES FIRE SALVAGE RE‐OFFER II 1156 ROD (PALS)WESTSIDE FIRE RECOVERY PROJECT RECORD OF DECISION WHITES 33,795 5 6 2014 7/8/2015 7/21/2016 2016 313 DN (PALS)BALD SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT BALD 39,832 5 6 2014 6/19/2015 7/11/2016 2016 280.4 DN (PALS)EILER FIRE SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT EILER 33,176 5 6 2014 7/8/2015 10/13/2015 10/27/2015 2016 20193 BALD FIRE SALVAGE REOFFER II 2738.4 DN (PALS)BALD SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT BALD 39,832 5 6 2014 4/8/2015 1/29/2015 2015 20190 CAL‐TRANS HWY89 4 DM (PALS)HAT CREEK BLOWDOWN AND HAZARD TREE PROJECT EILER 33,176 5 6 2014 7/29/2015 6/14/2016 11/24/2015 2016 20199 DAY FIRE SSTS RESALE 78 DM (PALS)DAY FIRE SALVAGE DAY 13,178 5 6 2014 10/8/2014 3/24/2015 4/9/2015 2015 20192 HAT CREEK WORK CENTER FIRE SALVAGE 45 DM (PALS)HAT CREEK WORK CENTER FIRE HAZARD REDUCTION PROJECT EILER 33,176 5 6 2014 4/8/2015 5/26/2015 6/8/2015 2015 20195 HC SALVAGE AND HAZARD TREE REOFFER 241 DM (PALS)HAT CREEK BLOWDOWN AND HAZARD TREE PROJECT EILER 33,176 5 6 2014 7/8/2015 10/13/2015 10/28/2015 2016 20194 JELLICO FIRE SALVAGE REOFFER II 3308 DN (PALS)BALD SALVAGE AND RESTORATION PROJECT BALD 39,832 5 15 2014 7/17/2006 7/31/2015 2015 50 DN (PALS)HAZARD TREE REMOVAL ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS FRENCH 13,828 5 15 2014 7/31/2015 2015 14 FRENCH 13,828 6 1 2014 11/19/2014 5/22/2015 6/4/2015 2015 15000 BULL SALVAGE REOFFER II 249 DM (PALS)DECISION MEMO TWO BULLS TIMBER SALVAGE PROJECT TWO BULLS FIRE 6,906 6 4 2014 7/11/2007 2007 1 SOUTH FORK COMPLEX 66,164 6 7 2014 5/19/2015 5/22/2015 6/2/2015 2015 15009 BAILEY SALVAGE 626 DN (PALS)BAILEY PROJECT WATERMAN COMPLEX 12,995 6 10 2014 7/9/2015 8/26/2015 9/16/2015 2016 15201 ONION SALVAGE 121 DM (PALS)ONION SALVAGE ONION MOUNTAIN 4,129 6 14 2014 9/10/2014 7/20/2015 2015 6 PAD (PALS)SUNFLOWER HAZARD TREE REMOVAL SUNFLOWER 7,165 6 14 2014 9/10/2014 12/2/2014 12/16/2014 2015 20020 SUNFLOWER FIRE ROADSIDE SALVAGE 7 PAD (PALS)SUNFLOWER HAZARD TREE REMOVAL SUNFLOWER 7,165 6 16 2014 5/29/2015 5/25/2016 6/22/2016 2016 15402 FIVE MILE SALVAGE AND THINNING 11 DM (PALS)FIVE MILE FIRE SALVAGE 5 MILE 4,576 6 17 2014 11/24/2014 12/16/2014 12/31/2014 2015 14405 BRIMSTONE SALVAGE 248 DM (PALS)BRIMSTONE SALVAGE CARLTON COMPLEX 287,140 6 18 2014 10/7/2015 5/5/2016 Not Awarded 10162 DECEPTION 8 DM (PALS)DECEPTION DANGER TREE PROJECT DECEPTION COMPLEX 6,476 1 4 2015 6/23/2016 8/30/2016 9/9/2016 2016 16808 BURNT GOOSE II SALVAGE 15 DN (PALS)TOWER FIRE SALVAGE AND REFORESTATION PROJECT TOWER 24,253 1 4 2015 6/23/2016 6/27/2016 7/8/2016 2016 16803 COOKED GROUSE SALVAGE 41 DN (PALS)TOWER FIRE SALVAGE AND REFORESTATION PROJECT TOWER 24,253 1 4 2015 6/23/2016 8/10/2016 8/24/2016 2016 16806 RED SOLO SALVAGE 4 DN (PALS)TOWER FIRE SALVAGE AND REFORESTATION PROJECT TOWER 24,253 1 10 2015 9/27/2015 10/9/2015 2016 16402 BEAR CR HAZARD TREE SALVAGE 27 NR CE without DM BEAR CREEK 61,790 1 17 2015 8/19/2016 10/2/2016 2017 122 DM (PALS)SNOWY SUMMIT/LOST HAT FIRE RECOVERY PROJECT SNOWY SUMMIT 6,865 19 Attachment D ‐ Time from NEPA Decision to Sale Award FS NAT FIRE NEPA SIGNED ADVERTISED AWARD OR AWARD SALE ACRES NEPA DEC REGION FOREST YEAR DATE DATE ACCOMP DATE FY NBR SALE NAME AWARDED TYPE NEPA DOC NAME FIRE NAME FIRE ACRES 1 17 2015 8/18/2016 10/2/2016 2017 0.5 DN (PALS)NEZ PERCE‐CLEARWATER NF'S ROADSIDE, RECREATION SITE AN PETE FORKS 8,033 1 17 2015 8/18/2016 10/2/2016 2017 16562 101 ROADSIDE HAZARD 50.7 DN (PALS)NEZ PERCE‐CLEARWATER NF'S ROADSIDE, RECREATION SITE AN WOODRAT 6,662 1 17 2015 8/24/2016 9/8/2016 2016 16502 BALDY ROADSIDE SALVAGE 25 BALDY 5,216 1 17 2015 8/18/2016 9/9/2016 9/22/2016 2017 16561 SNOWY PETE ROADSIDE HAZARD 74.5 DN (PALS)NEZ PERCE‐CLEARWATER NF'S ROADSIDE, RECREATION SITE AN FOURBIT CREEK 1,567 4 13 2015 8/10/2012 2012 3 ELEVENMILE 10,483 5 14 2015 5/12/2015 2015 1.9 RAIL 8,656 5 14 2015 5/26/2015 2015 1.5 SHIELL 15,366 5 14 2015 7/18/2016 2016 19.3 RAIL 8,656 5 14 2015 7/18/2016 2016 29.1 SHIELL 15,366 5 14 2015 4/18/2016 6/29/2016 8/16/2016 2017 52603 CORRAL BOTTOM RD DECKS SALV REOFFER 9.6 DM (PALS)ROADSIDE DECK SALVAGE CASTLE 15,500 6 4 2015 12/17/2015 2016 669.1 CANYON CREEK COMPLEX 110,387 6 4 2015 7/15/2013 8/6/2015 2016 14006 D‐15‐4003 4.9 ROD (PALS)GALENA RECORD OF DECISION CANYON CREEK COMPLEX 110,387 6 4 2015 4/19/2016 2016 16005 D‐16‐4007 3945 CANYON CREEK COMPLEX 110,387 6 4 2015 Not Awarded 13002 PARISH CABIN FIRE SALVAGE SBA 235 CANYON CREEK COMPLEX 110,387 6 4 2015 7/1/2005 4/27/2016 5/16/2016 2016 16006 PL DECK 68.3 DN (PALS)OTEC FOREST‐WIDE ELECTRICAL TRANSM CANYON CREEK COMPLEX 110,387 6 14 2015 2/5/2016 2/16/2016 2016 60022 HOODOO SALVAGE 1219.3 BUTTE CREEK 80,866 6 14 2015 7/1/2016 7/25/2016 2016 60023 HUNTIT SALVAGE SBA 820 BUTTE CREEK 80,866 6 16 2015 11/20/2015 12/21/2015 1/7/2016 2016 16313 CORNET HAZARD SALVAGE 1414 DM (PALS)CORNET WINDY RIDGE FIRE ROADSIDE DANGER TREE ABATEMECORNET‐WINDY RIDGE 102,601 6 16 2015 7/25/2016 8/22/2016 9/2/2016 2016 16317 EAGLE SALVAGE 619 DM (PALS)EAGLE COMPLEX FIRE SALVAGE EAGLE 13,424 6 16 2015 9/2/2016 9/21/2016 2016 16316 ELDORADO HAZARD 35 ELDORADO 20,776 6 16 2015 2/19/2016 4/18/2016 4/28/2016 2016 16315 WINDY SALVAGE 500 DM (PALS)CORNET WINDY RIDGE FIRE ‐ BURNT RIVER WATERSHED CORNET‐WINDY RIDGE 102,601 6 21 2015 7/28/2016 1/30/2017 2017 12172 JUNGLE SALVAGE 116 DM (PALS)SECOND CREEK POST FIRE RESTORATION STICKPIN 54,196 6 21 2015 11/4/2015 5/11/2016 5/20/2016 2016 12161 RENNER SALVAGE 119 DM (PALS)ROADSIDE HAZARD TREE PROJECT CE RENNER 13,816 6 21 2015 8/4/2016 8/15/2016 2017 4163 SECOND STICK SALVAGE 349 STICKPIN 54,196 6 21 2015 5/26/2016 5/26/2016 6/9/2016 2016 4161 SWAN STAR SALVAGE 358 DM (PALS)SWAN LAKE SALVAGE NORTH STAR 218,592 6 21 2015 11/20/2015 12/8/2015 12/16/2015 2016 3316 TOWER SALVAGE 1 DM (PALS)COLVILLE NATIONAL FOREST NEWPORT SULLIVAN LAKE RD ROATOWER 24,253 2 14 2/9/2017 3/7/2017 2017 27514 Lava Fire Bunchers 86 5 5 3/4/2016 3/29/2016 2016 11504 Salvage Heli 642 5 9 6/27/2013 7/22/2013 2013 13002 South Barry Fire Salvage 50

20 Attachment E ‐ Legal Proceedings Against Proposed Salvage Operations

NEPA DECISION TYPE OF NEPA ANALYSIS CATEGORICAL DAYS IN REGION PROJECT_NAME CASE NAME D.CT./ CIR. DOCKET D.CT/CIR. DATE FILED CASE OUTCOME SIGNED CONDUCTED EXCLUSION LITIGATION DATE Loss/Withdrew 1 Johnson Bar Fire Salvage 28‐Jun‐17 Environmental Impact Statement N Idaho Rivers United v. Probert 16‐102; 16‐35443 D. Idaho 11‐Mar‐16 280 Decision

Native Ecocystem Council v. Krueger D. Mont.; 1 Millie Roadside Hazard Tree Removal 17‐Apr‐13 Categorical Exclusion Y 13‐167; 14‐35518 9th Cir. 13‐Aug‐13 1003 Win Native Ecosystem Council v. Weldon 1 North Whitetail Post Fire Project 28‐Jun‐16 Categorical Exclusion Y 16‐106 D. Mont. 15‐Aug‐16 175 Win D. Mont.; AWR v. Cottrell 1 Rat Creek Fire Salvage 22‐Jul‐09 Environmental Assessment N 09‐107; 09‐35756 9th Cir. 24‐Jul‐09 937 Loss Alliance for the Wild Rockies v. Farnsworth, Tower/Grizzly Fire Salvage and et al. 1 Reforestation Project 23‐Jun‐16 Environmental Assessment N 16‐433 D. Idaho 27‐Sep‐16 Ongoing CBD v. USFS 3 Warm Fire Recovery Project 2‐Mar‐09 Environmental Impact Statement N 09‐8116; 9‐17521 D.Ariz./9th 6‐Jul‐09 603 Win E.D. Earth Island Institute v. Marceron 5 Angora Fire Restoration Project 9‐Jul‐10 Environmental Assessment N 11‐402; 11‐16718 Cal./9th 11‐Feb‐11 643 Win

Aspen Recovery and Reforestation Earth Island Institute v. Gould 5 Project 1‐Jun‐14 Environmental Assessment N 14‐1140 E. D. Cal. 8‐Jul‐14 231 Win Conservation Congress v. USFS/USFWS 5 Bagley Hazard Tree Abatement Project 29‐Aug‐13 Environmental Assessment N 13‐1922 E.D. Cal. 16‐Sep‐13 Ongoing Center for Biological Diversity et al. v. Hays 15‐1627 E.D. Cal. 5 Bald Fire Salvage and Restoration Project 8‐Jul‐15 Environmental Assessment N 30‐Jul‐15 145 Win N.D. Cal.; Earth Island Institute v. Quinn et al. 5 Big Hope Fire Salvage and Restoration Pr 24‐Jun‐14 Environmental Assessment N 14‐3101; 14‐1723 E.D. Cal. 8‐Jul‐14 237 Win

Los Padres ForestWatch v. USFS C.D. Cal.; 5 Day Fire Restoration 29‐Jul‐15 Categorical Exclusion Y 08‐845; 08‐56696 9th Cir. 15‐Feb‐08 236 Loss

French Fire Recovery and Reforestation Center for Biological Diversity v. Gould 5 Project 26‐Aug‐15 Environmental Assessment N 15‐1329 E.D. Cal. 31‐Aug‐15 295 Loss

Mill Fire Salvage and Hazard Tree Conservation Congress v. USFS 5 Removal Project 23‐Apr‐13 Environmental Assessment N 13‐832 E.D. Cal. 29‐Apr‐13 386 Loss

Moonlight‐Wheeler Fires Recovery and Earth Island Institute v. Carlton 5 Restoration Project 20‐Jul‐09 Environmental Impact Statement N 09‐2020 E.D. Cal. 21‐Jul‐09 1183 Win

Klamath‐Siskiyou Wild.Ctr v. Grantham Loss/Withdrew 5 Panther I Fire Salvage Project 10‐Aug‐09 Environmental Assessment N 09‐2249 E.D. Cal. 13‐Aug‐09 14 Decision Klamath‐Siskiyou Wildlands Center et al. v. E.D. 5 Panther II Fire Salvage Project 23‐Aug‐10 Environmental Assessment N Grantham 10‐2350; 10‐17347 Cal./9th 31‐Aug‐10 262 Win E. D. Cal.; Center for Biological Diversity v. Skalski 5 Rim Fire Recovery 28‐Aug‐14 Environmental Impact Statement N 14‐1382; 14‐16848 9th Cir. 4‐Sep‐14 421 Win

Klamath‐Siskiyou Wild.Ctr v. Heywood 5 Trough Fire Recovery Project 10‐Aug‐09 Categorical Exclusion Y 09‐2252 E.D. Cal. 14‐Aug‐09 103 Win N.D. Cal.; Karuk Tribe et al. v. Stelle (NMFS) et al. 5 Westside Fire Recovery Project 29‐Feb‐16 Environmental Impact Statement N 16‐1079; 16‐15818 9th Cir. 15‐Mar‐16 Ongoing

Cascadia Wildlands Project v. Anthony 6 Black Crater Fire Timber Salvage Project 8‐Feb‐07 Categorical Exclusion Y 07‐6147 D. Or. 22‐Jun‐07 104 Loss/Settlement Cascadia Wildlands Project et.al. v. Anthony 6GW Fire Timber Salvage Project 27‐Jun‐08 Categorical Exclusion Y 08‐6198 D. Or. 30‐Jun‐08 220 Win