'Terminal Year' Granted to Those Denied Tenure Can Be Awkward, If Not Risky - Faculty - the Chronicle of Higher Education
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA ACADEMIC SENATE ●MERCED DIVISION Committee on Faculty Welfare, Diversity & Academic Freedom (FWDAF) Tuesday, September 17, 2013 2:00 pm – 3:30 pm, KL 324 Documents found at UCMCROPS/FWDAF1314/Resources AGENDA I. Consent Calendar Action requested: Approval of the agenda II. Guest – De Acker, Campus Ombuds Introduction and overview of services provided to faculty III. Chair’s Report – Rudy Ortiz A. Welcome FWDAF members B. Issues for the AY 13-14 year i. Systemwide representatives. University Committee on Faculty Welfare (Linda Cameron), University Committee on Academic Freedom (Sean Malloy), and University Committee on Affirmative Action and Diversity (Rudy Ortiz) ii. Faculty recruitment process in the Schools iii. Faculty retention issues iv. Faculty mentoring program v. “Terminal Year” granted to faculty denied tenure Page 4 vi. APM 210. Meet with CAP chair to discuss assessment of faculty contributions to diversity, and develop and implement diversity worksheet. vii. Additional member of FWDAF. Committee Bylaws state the committee needs at least five members which is the current number of members; however, the committee can decide if it wants another member to attend systemwide meetings if necessary. viii. Meeting schedule. Suggested schedule is September, December, January, and April (last meeting with the Chancellor and Provost). 1 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA ACADEMIC SENATE ●MERCED DIVISION IV. Physics Proposal for the Establishment of a Graduate Program Page 11 Background. At the end of AY 12-13, the Physics graduate group submitted a proposal to establish a graduate program leading to the M.S. and Ph.D. degrees. All Senate standing committees are asked to review and comment. The proposal is available at UCMCROPS/FWDAF13/Resources/Review Items - Campus Action requested: Review proposal. If FWDAF chooses to opine, the committee analyst will draft a memo with comments to Senate Chair López-Calvo and transmit to [email protected]. Comments are due on Friday, September 20. V. Course Buyout Policy Page 188 Background. A draft policy was developed by the Provost and School Deans in 2012. The Provost and Deans are seeking approval of the policy for five years after which a re- evaluation of the policy will occur. Policy is available at UCMCROPS/FWDAF1314/Resources/Review Items - Campus Action requested: Discuss draft policy. If FWDAF chooses to opine, committee analyst will draft a memo with the compilation of comments and transmit to Senate Chair López-Calvo at [email protected]. Deadline for comments is Monday, September 23. VI. SACAP Charge Page 192 Background. Senate-Administration Council on Assessment and Planning (SACAP) was established in 2009 as a joint effort between the Academic Senate and the Administration. Provost Peterson has requested a revision to the council’s charge. The charge is available at UCMCROPS/FWDAF1314/Resources/Review Items - Campus Action requested: Review revised charge. If FWDAF chooses to opine, the committee analyst will draft a memo with comments to Senate Chair López- Calvo and transmit to [email protected]. Comments are due on Monday, September 30. VII. Informational Items – Rudy Ortiz A. UC CARE - Tier 1 health care providers for campuses without medical centers. Documents available at UCMCROPS/FWDAF1314/Resources/Correspondence/UCFW/UC Care. Please do not distribute. B. UC Online Education - copyright concerns for faculty. C. UC Retirement Program – increasing employer contributions. 2 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA ACADEMIC SENATE ●MERCED DIVISION VIII. Other Business 3 'Terminal Year' Granted to Those Denied Tenure Can Be Awkward, if Not Risky - Faculty - The Chronicle of Higher Education Log In | Events | Store August 22, 2013 Subscribe Today Home News Global Opinion & Ideas Facts & Figures Blogs Jobs Advice Forums Go Faculty Comments (68) August 19, 2013 'Terminal Year' Granted to Those Denied Tenure Can Be Awkward, if Not Risky By Robin Wilson Debra M. Moriarity recalls making a promise to Amy Bishop when her colleague pointed a 9-millimeter pistol at her head. "I have helped you before," Ms. Moriarity told her. Most Popular Christine Prichard for The Chronicle "I can help you again." Most Viewed Most Commented Debra Moriarity, now the chair of the biology department at the U. of Alabama at Huntsville, 1. Obama Vows Action on College Costs, but Will It Work? But the offer may have sounded was at the faculty meeting where Amy Bishop, 2. Oregon's 'Pay It Forward' Plan on Student Loans Could who had been denied tenure, shot six people. hollow to Ms. Bishop, an assistant Enlarge Image Become 'Pay It Yourself' professor of biology at the 3. Scholars in Bondage University of Alabama at Huntsville. After all, her colleagues, including Ms. Moriarity, a full professor of 4. 'Terminal Year' Granted to Those Denied Tenure Can Be Awkward, if Not Risky biochemistry, had already voted against Ms. Bishop's tenure bid. Despite that 5. The Comforts of the Apocalypse negative decision, Ms. Bishop continued working in the department and attending faculty meetings for months. At one of those meetings, in February 2010, she http://chronicle.com/article/Terminal-Year-Granted-to/141145/?key=TWIgIlNpZSJLbXwyaz1BZTkHPHxsNRp7MSNFaXklbl9WEQ==[8/22/2013 1:55:18 PM] 'Terminal Year' Granted to Those Denied Tenure Can Be Awkward, if Not Risky - Faculty - The Chronicle of Higher Education Campus Viewpoint opened fire, killing three professors and wounding three others. Her gun jammed Information provided by participating institution when she pointed it at Ms. Moriarity, ending the killing spree. There is no better place to be right now than Texas Tech Like most academics who are denied tenure, Ms. Bishop was granted a final year University. Not since the university was founded in to stay on at the university. The official reason for the "terminal year," as it's 1923 has there been such opportunity or known in the profession, is that tenure decisions are often made in the spring, momentum. Graduate and undergraduate enrollments are at record... when faculty job openings for the following academic year have already been filled. To give people on their way out enough time to search for another post, View Campus Viewpoint almost all colleges pay tenure-track professors to continue teaching and performing research for another year. The longstanding policy, a concept unique to academe, is endorsed by the American Association of University Professors and spelled out in the association's 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure. But the terminal year, while rarely as treacherous as it proved to be in the Huntsville case, is often a painful and uncomfortable time, both for those who are on their way out and those who remain. Few universities offer guidelines to help lame-duck professors deal with the rejection, navigate their final year in a department that no longer wants them, and chart a future. A wrongful-death lawsuit filed against former Huntsville administrators by relatives of two of the three tenured professors Ms. Bishop killed calls into question the wisdom of the terminal year. It alleges that Huntsville's top administrators knew Ms. Bishop was volatile during that time and protected themselves from confrontations with her but failed to take steps to safeguard her colleagues from danger. Ms. Bishop was sentenced last year to life in prison for the murders. Lawyers for the university's former provost, Vistasp M. Karbhari, who is now president of the University of Texas at Arlington, have asked a judge to dismiss the lawsuit, saying there is no evidence that top administrators knew Ms. Bishop http://chronicle.com/article/Terminal-Year-Granted-to/141145/?key=TWIgIlNpZSJLbXwyaz1BZTkHPHxsNRp7MSNFaXklbl9WEQ==[8/22/2013 1:55:18 PM] 'Terminal Year' Granted to Those Denied Tenure Can Be Awkward, if Not Risky - Faculty - The Chronicle of Higher Education was dangerous before the killings. But Douglas Fierberg, a lawyer for the relatives of the slain professors—Adriel D. Johnson and Maria Ragland Davis—updated the lawsuit with a filing last month that provides phone records as well as recordings of calls that he says support the suit's allegations. In the new filing, Mr. Fierberg and other lawyers for the relatives accuse university administrators of not only ignoring the safety of others on the campus but also trying to cover up the steps they took to shield themselves by calling campus police. "Bishop's later rampage was not only foreseeable," says the lawsuit, "it was foreseen by those who protected themselves and no one else." Little Guidance Ms. Bishop's case is clearly unique. Not only was the outcome extreme, but she had a violent background. The same year she committed the Huntsville murders she was indicted for the 1986 shooting death of her brother, which had previously been considered accidental. Her lawyer has said she has long suffered from mental illness. "While it is true that you can get an Amy Bishop, most people spend their terminal year doing the best they can to complete their responsibilities and look for another job," says B. Robert Kreiser, who retired this month as a senior program officer at the AAUP. "And it doesn't cause harm to the institution." But that doesn't mean that universities couldn't do a better job of helping professors deal with tenure denial. Robert Meier, director of the employee- assistance program at Ohio State University and president of the International Association of Employee Assistance Professionals in Education, says his office offers group sessions to help young professors make their way through the strain of trying to earn tenure. But Ohio State, like most other universities, provides no formal program for those who ultimately fail. When professors who've been denied tenure do come to his office for help, says http://chronicle.com/article/Terminal-Year-Granted-to/141145/?key=TWIgIlNpZSJLbXwyaz1BZTkHPHxsNRp7MSNFaXklbl9WEQ==[8/22/2013 1:55:18 PM] 'Terminal Year' Granted to Those Denied Tenure Can Be Awkward, if Not Risky - Faculty - The Chronicle of Higher Education Mr.