LETTERS Your nonprofit community news source since 1958 continued from page 6 home be built without a thorough that new middle-income families are Vote yes on amendment and and complete review, including water just not able to make it work. The Town Plan articles supply, wastewater, traffic safety etc., etc. Some of you know this very well, Many of you know that I have focused Dear Charlotte friends and neighbors, while others possibly do not know since my historic community service time you may be newer residents. on land conservation, and with great Charlotte News I am calling with a sense of urgency success, largely because Charlotte is Thursday, February 11, 2021 | Volume LXIII Number 16 to ask that you please become well In this new round of plan and blessed with abundant and fabulous informed about the town plan and regulation updates for the East Village, nature to nurture. And largely because regulation articles coming up for vote the proposed village-related articles our town has a generous desire to give this year at town meeting. I am reaching are simply proposing potential to allow money to protect our natural assets. out to friends and neighbors right now for a modest amount of new homes This richness is only a problem if we to say: VOTE YES in support of the to be built on one-acre lots (vs less do not provide for an economically and proposed articles on Town Meeting affordable five-acre lots) in the village socio-diverse community. For the sake Day. commercial district only. Our regs of community health and justice, we all To my recent surprise and great already provide for far smaller lot must make this happen with purpose. It disappointment, I am hearing faulty size potential for elderly and affordable will not happen by itself. This is a very messaging sweeping about, almost homes in the entire larger village important fact to know. district. We do not provide for smaller reminding me of Washington, D.C. This So please read the Town Plan and the is so, so discouraging. one acre lots for middle income homes. So, to be very conservative, we are only regs online. They are our two bibles Please be sure you know what we proposing these one-acre lots in the and we must all treat them as such, and are proposing, and please do not, smaller east village commercial district be in this together. The PC depends carte blanche, believe what a few are only. That’s it. upon well informed residents. We love saying…that the PC is proposing more our time as community volunteers, but development in the village without My biggest interest as a PC member we can’t do this without you. today is to make sure my town has having done our homework…this could Charlotte is at a crossroad, and I sure not be further from the truth. decent affordable places for middle income folks to reside in Charlotte do hope our little town can be united in The truth is that Charlotte has very and go to CCS. As a middle incomer our vision. detailed and robust regs today (over myself, I know well that home prices Marty Illick 100 pages), and would never let any have escalated so much since the 1980s, Planning Commission

Winter wonderland

View from Charlotte Park. presorted Photo by Frances Foster U.S. POSTAGE PAID ZIP CODE 05482 MAILED FROM PERMIT NO. 9

Frost among the trees along Greenbush Road.

Photo by Lee Krohn standard Tom Cosinuke and Annie Kelton are the proud owners of a newly appointed champion apple tree. Photo by Vince Crockenberg READ MORE ON PAGE 8 The CharlotteNewsVT.org Vol. 63, no.16 February 11, 2021 Charlotte News Your nonprofit community news source since 1958

Proposed changes to Town Plan The dream is real & Land Use Regs: A primer from the Planning Commission Peter Joslin . Article 7 would change the LURs to CHAIR, CHARLOTTE PLANNING COMMISSION adjust the allowed density for the East Charlotte Village Commercial district from 5 acres per unit to 1 acre for residential At Town Meeting, Charlotte residents are development, and permit wastewater being asked to vote on a set of proposed and water lines to connect outside the updates to the Town Plan and Land Use commercial district to support projects Regulations. These proposals were developed inside the district. It also reinforces that by your Planning Commission, with input all projects must maintain and respect the from residents, the Selectboard, and reviewed historic character of the area. by our town attorney, over the past 2 ½ years. . Article 8 would update the LURs to It’s important to understand the relationship enable the growth of accessory on-farm between the Town Plan, LURs, and the businesses, as required by the Vermont process by which development does (or Legislature in 2018. This version includes does not) occur in town. The Town Plan is less restrictive rules that provide Charlotte a policy document that sets forth the goals farmers opportunity to develop new farm- and objectives for Charlotte’s future, in many related accessory businesses, while still Charlotte artist Cap’n Dan titled this work “2 Dream”—it’s both a request and a state of mind. The artwork is photography of handmade paper collage. dimensions, including land development, enforcing town standards. energy use, town facilities, and conserving Art and photo by Cap’n Dan. natural resources and the open landscapes, . Article 9 proposes several minor LUR which are core values for residents. The updates and corrections to address glitches, LURs are the main rule book that reflect the grammatical errors and obsolete sections. goals, policies and planning maps within our For example, it eliminates farm cafés as East Charlotte Village LUR Town Plan. a use (to be replaced by accessory farm businesses), clarifies types of allowed amendments: An analysis of the issues Charlotte’s Town Plan was last updated in outdoor storage, and adds and updates 2018 and approved by residents’ vote in 2019. many key definitions, such as “Right of Chea Waters Evans will not be completed until there’s an actual The plan and LURs are living documents that Way” and “Impervious Surface.” EDITOR possibility of development in an area, there’s need to be regularly updated to stay current no way to tell in advance how increased with changes in state law, community values, Some residents have raised questions and It’s the biggest topic of the year—you’ve read housing density will affect traffic, the and changes in the environment, such as an concerns about the proposed Town Plan map about it in the paper for months, you’ve been environment, taxes and wastewater issues in aging population, reduced school enrollment, and LUR changes for the East Charlotte to the Planning Commission Meetings, seen the surrounding area. Village Commercial District (Articles 6 and the need for more diverse housing options, the Front Porch Forum posts, and read varying 7). During its review and hearing process, the Why do people support Articles 6 and 7? a changing climate, etc. If we don’t update opinions in letters to the editor. Without Town Planning Commission produced a theoretical the LURs, they risk becoming irrelevant, Meeting for discussion and questions this People who support Articles 6 and 7 buildout analysis of these proposed changes, thus becoming more difficult to apply to year, it’s up to you to figure out on your own acknowledge that, in order for a community posted to the project page on the town development projects reviewed by the town what you think. And you’re still not sure what to thrive, there must be some form of website. It said that up to 45 units could and the state. the real story is with Articles 6 and 7 and how development; passing these amendments potentially be built within current rules, On the warrant for your upcoming Town they will affect you. doesn’t necessarily mean there will be quick, while up to 65 units could be built with these haphazard, damaging development in the Meeting vote are four separate articles Following are some of the most common changes. However, it’s very important to area, it just means that the opportunity now proposing changes to our Town Plan and questions we’ve received at The Charlotte recognize that all development in town is also exists to create thoughtful and meaningful Land Use Regulations: News regarding the East Charlotte Village constrained by septic and water capacity, and growth. The Town Plan and a 2010 survey of Land Use Regulation amendments that are . Article 6 proposes a Town Plan map other variables, including zoning standards East Charlotte residents indicate that there is on the ballot on March 2. In trying to present change for the East Charlotte Village and housing market demand. a desire for improvement and growth in the both sides of the issue, I’ve summarized Commercial District (ECVCD) that area, and these articles open the door to make As with all proposed development, any and condensed comments and opinions extends its boundaries by ± 24 acres from projects in the East Village are subject to that happen. existing (± 20 acres now), to ± 44 acres. from letters to the editor, past articles and a robust and comprehensive review by the public comment during multiple Planning Why don’t people support Articles 6 and 7? The new boundary affects 16 parcels vs. Planning Commission and Zoning Board, 10 parcels now. This is a separate article Commission and Selectboard meetings. People who don’t support Articles 6 and 7 are because it would change the zoning district The article by Peter Joslin (see page 1) from concerned about the repercussions of passing map in the Town Plan. see LURS page 2 the Planning Commission gives a history these articles without consideration of the and explanation of the particulars of each impact of expanding sewage capacity under article; here are the confusing parts, hopefully the roads to nearby neighborhoods. They are explained. also concerned that the priorities and people Meet the Candidates Night: Save the date in the area have changed since the survey Why do some think the ECVCD LURs will was initially done 11 years ago, and that once There are two contested Selectboard races this year, and the candidates are cause positive development? the door is opened to development, it will coming out (metaphorically) to discuss town issues and meet the voters. The Allowing the commercial district to expand be too difficult to manage—like putting the Charlotte Grange and The Charlotte News are teaming up yet again to facilitate in East Charlotte will open opportunities proverbial toothpaste back into the tube. Some the discussion and offer voters an opportunity to ask questions and get to know for property owners in that zone to develop also think that there needs to be more time, the candidates and their opinions on the issues that affect our town today. communities of affordable and senior housing. more discussion, more planning and more Meet the Candidates night is on Tuesday, Feb. 16, at 7 p.m. Because of the More dwelling units in the village area means study before a permanent change to the LURs coronavirus pandemic, the meeting will take place on Zoom. The link to join the acting on the mandate set forth in the Town is approved. Plan to offer a range of more affordable meeting is https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88627161701?pwd=cS9FMnprcGZZ- How could this be considered spot zoning? V0dSVElRMG9wUFRtZz09 housing options in Charlotte for seniors and families of varied incomes. Spot zoning is creating a law or laws specific Meeting ID: 886 2716 1701 Passcode: 148029 to one area to suit the development needs of Why do some think the ECVCD LURs will one particular project or property. Because To keep the discussion running smoothly, Charlotters can submit questions in cause problematic development? Articles 6 and 7 apply only to the East Village advance to Editor Chea Evans at [email protected] or ask them via It’s unclear how many housing units will Commercial District and not other commercial chat during the meeting. ultimately be constructed in the expanded commercial district. Because impact studies see AMENDMENTS page 19 The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 3 Town LURS It’s also key to place these proposed changes for even modest development to proceed. continued from page 1 in the context of Vermont land use policy, as Hence, the Article 6 and 7 proposals. If who are bound by the LURs. If anyone has embedded in state law (24 VSA 4302) and adopted, they would allow mixed use and any doubt about how these rules are applied in our Town Plan. Vermont and Charlotte planned residential projects in the East Village by our citizen boards, just look around you: encourage development in established Commercial District with diverse housing Charlotte remains a beautiful community village centers, while discouraging sprawl options for people to live, work and recreate. that has retained its rural character, with development across open landscapes. This That’s the goal. was reinforced by the results of a 2010 study a combination of working farms, forests, The Planning Commission will be posting individual houses on large lots, and open (see: http://bit.do/2010-ECV-study-rpt), which asked residents what they value about the East more information in the next couple of weeks, The Charlotte News landscapes, with stringent protection of our Mission Statement Village, and what changes they want to see including a follow-up article, a video panel natural resources. discussion, questions & answers with more The mission of The Charlotte News is to inform our going forward. Many respondents prioritized readers about current events, issues and topics, and No one is suggesting we abandon our high modest village growth in housing, and some details, and posts to the Front Porch Forum. to serve as a forum for the free exchange of views of standards. At their core, these changes are kind of café or community gathering place, We urge everyone to learn more about these town residents and community volunteer organizations proposals before you cast your votes. For on matters related to Charlotte and the lives of its about fine-tuning the rulebook (LURs) to while maintaining the historic character of the residents. allow limited, very targeted growth in an village area. more information, see the project page on the town website (at: http://bit.do/LURs- Editorial independence existing village center. Whatever projects The Board of Directors retains full authority over all are proposed will be held to the same high But the current minimum of five acres per amends-docs), or contact Larry Lewack, Town housing unit that’s now required in the village Planner, at 425-3533 ext. 206, or via email at: editorial and advertising content in The Charlotte standards as are applied elsewhere in town News. While we are funded by advertising revenue and would be rejected if they don’t meet those center directly contradicts these goals in [email protected]. and donor contributions, our news judgments are standards. the town plan. This makes it very difficult made in accordance with our mission and independent of all sources of financial support, including support given through our affiliated 501(c)3 organization, The Friends of The Charlotte News. Selectboard candidates weigh in on commercial Letters, Commentaries and Obituaries Consistent with our mission The Charlotte News publishes letters to the editor, commentaries and district expansion obituaries from our readers. All letters, commentaries and obituaries are subject to review and approval by Ethan Putnam move. Dunbar said he does not support the need to move toward increased density, the the news editor of the paper and to the following rules COMMUNITY NEWS SERVICE amendment to the Town Plan that increases the selective changes didn’t sit right with him. and standards: • Letters to the editor, commentaries and obituaries size of the East Charlotte commercial district “The purpose of [the zoning changes] is to should be emailed to news@thecharlottenews. After two recent public comment sessions on or the proposed zoning changes. preserve open spaces and not have every house org as attachments in .doc format. All letters, the proposed increase of the East Charlotte commentaries and obituaries must contain the “If the town’s direction is to concentrate in your rural area have five acres. I agree Village commercial district’s borders and writer’s full name, town of residence and, for housing in town centers, which is the direction with that methodology. But not in applying it editing purposes only, phone number. allowable density, some Charlotte Selectboard that a lot of Vermont towns are taking, then it selectively.” • Letters may not exceed 300 words, obituaries 500 candidates gave their views on the topic. words and commentaries 750 words. should apply to the entire town, including the When asked the same question, Lewis Mudge, • The opinions expressed in commentaries and Mike Dunbar, a candidate for both the two- West Charlotte Village, in addition to the East director of Central Africa for Human Rights letters to the editor belong solely to the author year term and auditor, and the owner of the and are not to be understood as endorsed by Charlotte village,” Dunbar said. Watch and candidate for the two-year term, either the Board of Directors or the editorial staff Charlotte Crossings building, opposes the Dunbar said while he believes town centers said the current Town Plan called for density of the paper. already. • All published letters and commentaries will include the writer’s name and town of residence. “If the question is there should be no density in • Before publishing any obituary, we will need proper verification of death. the village, then really what we need to do, this • All submissions are subject to editing for clarity, shouldn’t be sorted out at the zoning board and factual accuracy, tone, length and consistency Selectboard level, frankly, this should be: ‘We with our house publishing style. Jewelry, • Whenever editing is necessary we will make need to reevaluate our town plan’,” Mudge every effort to publish each submission in its said. entirety and to preserve the original intent and wording. We will confer with writers before He went on to say that he believed in publishing any submitted material that in our gifts, increasing density and foresaw increased judgment requires significant editing before it can be published. development in East Charlotte’s future, so to • The news editor makes the final determination him the question was, ‘How would that density whether a letter to the editor, a commentary or an clothing, need to evolve and how does it take shape?’ obituary will be published as submitted, returned for rewriting or rejected. “There are folks in the East Charlotte village Publisher: Claudia Marshall who are not happy with this,” Mudge said. ([email protected]) cards, Editorial Staff He himself had no stake in the matter, Mudge Managing Editor: Anna Cyr said, and he has not yet decided how he will ([email protected]) vote. Editor: Chea Waters Evans candy ([email protected]) While Mudge said he sees this as a balance Contributing Editor: Edd Merritt Copy editor: Beth Merritt between development and protecting access to Proofreaders: Edd Merritt, HAPPY HOLIDAYSand more. countryside and open land, he also made clear Mike & Janet Yantachka his support for more affordable housing. Business Staff Ad manager: Christy Hagios “My wife and I put every cent we own into ([email protected]) buying a place in Charlotte,” Mudge said. Bookkeeper: Susan Jones Beat Black Friday For every $50 ([email protected]) Beat Black $10 “It’s an expensive place to buy. And you you spend, you’ll get to spend know, I’d love the opportunity to have folks Board Members Free Gift Wrapping! President: Claudia Marshall in December! move in with kids or move into an area like ([email protected]) Friday & warm the village and not have to wait the 10 years Treasurer: Ted leBlanc ([email protected]) 4th annual Winter Wear Drive professionally that I had to in order to accrue Board members: Vince Crockenberg, Bob up a neighbor Drop off good condition winter clothing the capital.” Bloch, Gay Regan, Tom Tiller, John Quinney, Jack Fairweather, Christina Asquith, Ben Miller, Bailey and receive a $5 gift card! These items Justin Bora, owner of Bora’s Welding & Grattelo, John Hammer (emeritus) with our Winter Repair, who is running for the three-year term, Technical advisor: Melissa Mendelsohn, Orchard will be passed into the hands of needy said he had not had time to take a look at the Road Computers families at no cost to them. issue and therefore could not offer an opinion Website: thecharlottenews.org Wear Drive Subscription Information by press time. The Charlotte News is delivered at no cost to all Frank Tenney, a Charlotte native running for Charlotte residences. Subscriptions are available for Programs active thru first-class delivery at $60 per calendar year. JewelryJewelry & Gifts & Gifts his third term on the Selectboard and who is Want a subscription? Please send a check payable to November 16th currently on the Zoning Board of Adjustment, The Charlotte News, P.O. Box 251, didn’t respond to multiple requests for Charlotte, VT 05445. Postmaster/Send address changes to: shelburne bay plaza comment. The Charlotte News P.O. Box 251, Charlotte, VT 05445 2989 shelburne rd • 985.9909 Community News Service works in a Telephone: 425-4949 alittlesomethingvt.com M partnership with The Charlotte News Circulation: 2,000 I and other local media outlets to provide Copyright © 2021 The Charlotte News, Inc. Member of the New England Newspaper next to the Shelburne Meat Market opportunities to University of Vermont and Press Association, LION Publishers and the students. Vermont Press Association.

8H-alittlesomething110619.indd 1 11/5/19VT 1:04 PM

shshelburneshelshbuelelburnbuebrnrnebayeb bayayplayazapl plazaplazaaza 29298929892989 sh89shelburneshelshbuelelburnbuerd•9rnrnerd•9 rderd•9 •85 985.990985.985909.9.9909909 alalittlesomethingvt.comitaltlalitestlitesomtlesometomhietetnghihingvtng.cvtvtom.c.comom ALAAL itALLittletliteStliteStlom eSSomethingometomhietetnghihing(Gng(G if(Gifts)(Gts)ifts)ifts) FP-0000405969 FP-0000405969 FP-0000405969 4 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News Report from the Legislature Budgets and broadband, tax increase decreases The Vermont House has broadband deployment to every Vermonter as change dramatically. worked productively in to every part of the quickly as possible, we the last two weeks. We state. Building on the are encouraging CUDs Also on the education front, the sustainability approved the annual Communication Union and telecom providers of the pension funds for teachers and state Budget Adjustment bill District model that was to work with each other employees has become a top priority with (H.138), a mid-year authorized in 2015 and to avoid duplication of the release of a recommendation from State technical adjustment to enhanced last year, effort. The rate at which Treasurer Beth Pearce that would increase contributions and decrease benefits. The source Rep. Mike keep the state’s Fiscal availability to planning high-speed broadband Yantachka Year 2021 budget in grants and low-cost loans can be built depends of the underfunded pension fund problem balance. H.138 passed will be provided to CUDs not only on funding was a decision by the Legislature in the 1990s with strong support and included investments to build fiber networks but on the availability to underfund the system based on overly to support the Legislature’s continuing throughout Vermont. of skilled line workers optimistic assumptions about investment response to the Coronavirus pandemic. Much CUDs are organized and of the required returns. The unfunded liability is $1.5 billion of the adjustment was a result of reallocating by towns that want to materials, both of which at present and is expected to grow by another unused Coronavirus Relief Funds, which build fiber to the areas are in short supply. Our $600 million if remediation steps are not were supposed to expire at the end of last year where for-profit internet service providers bill will also include funding for workforce taken. The Legislature is studying the report but were extended by the $900 billion relief find it unprofitable to reach. Most for-profit training in partnership with Vermont Technical and seeking alternatives by working with all bill passed by Congress last December. CRF companies build their infrastructure along the College. Even with this support, broadband to parties to assure Vermonters that they will have money was redirected to assistance for the main arteries with a higher residential density. the “last mile” will take years to accomplish. their retirement benefit while also curtailing hard-hit hospitality industry, for emergency Fiberoptic lines cost about $33,000 per mile to We will continue to work on the details of the the unfunded liability. Pension contracts are food, hotel housing for the homeless, and build. The more subscribers within that mile, bill over the next few weeks. an obligation that should not be set aside. rental assistance,for support of Vermont State the lower the cost per subscriber. Teachers and state employees should not be Colleges, and for completion of broadband There’s good news on the 9.5 cent education penalized for the fiduciary mistakes made expansion projects. Local telecommunications carriers like property tax rate increase that created a stir by government. We must solve this dilemma WCVT or Consolidated Communications also in December. Improved non-property tax fairly. Speaking of broadband, the pandemic has provide internet service. The U.S. Department revenues in the Education Fund and input from highlighted the necessity of high-speed internet of Agriculture recently accepted bids from school districts have resulted in a reduction to I welcome your emails (myantachka.dfa@ for education, work, and communications. traditional carriers to extend broadband in rural roughly a one cent increase. This may change gmail.com) or phone calls (802-233-5238). The Energy & Technology Committee has areas under the Rural Digital Opportunities as more information about actual budgets This article and others can be found at my been working on a major bill to accelerate Fund. With the objective of getting service becomes available, but it is not expected to website (MikeYantachka.com). Around Town Congratulations: Sympathies: Lynne Bond—his partner and collaborator conversations throughout life. He began his in parenting and adventure. Delighted as his legal practice at Vermont Legal Aid, acting on to Annika Gruber and Lila Taylor whose are extended to family and friends of Rita family grew, David dearly loved Tucker’s what he preached and believed. The majority poems were selected to appear in the Kieslick Johnson of South Burlington who wife, Kristen, Brooks’ wife, Diana, and their of his law practice was shared with Stephen Burlington Free Press’ Young Writers Project passed away Jan. 27 at the age of 94. She two children, Katie and Misha. His niece Blodgett, an important partner, mentor and on Jan. 29. Calling her poem “Mind Watcher,” and her husband, Donald Johnson, began Molly was like a daughter to him; his brother friend. Paul Volk subsequently joined their Annika wrote about how movies project what the Overhead Door Company of Burlington, Lanny was his very best friend; his sister firm as well. David was “thinking about a person’s mind sees through that person’s which grew over her tenure to include offices Linda was a dear life-long connection; Omar retiring” next December 2021 (at age 76!). imagination. In a current setting these days in in three other towns in New Hampshire and Granados came to be seen as an “honorary theaters, due to coronavirus infestation, the Vermont. Following her retirement as the son.” David got such joy from his family and Of David’s many community and volunteer author sits alone as her thoughts parade their company’s president in 1999, its management friends, and from their families and friends. activities, he was an enthusiastic member way across the screen. Soon the theater fills as was picked up by members of her family The circle was ever expanding and David ever of the Charlotte Land Trust. He loved the people from the author’s future “trickle in.” As who continue to run it. She is survived by her welcoming. thoughtful and collaborative spirit and action the author left, everyone left with her and the daughter, Lynn, and Lynn’s husband, Tony of the group and was convinced that it made next person came in to begin his viewing. And Cairns, of Charlotte and Bonita Springs, Fla. David’s life is difficult to summarize because a huge contribution to our community. so it went. Her family included seven grandchildren and it extended in so many directions. A day Perhaps most important to him was his on the ski slopes, camping in the woods, shared leadership of Volunteer Vermont. In In an “Ode to Strangers,” Lila talks about four great grandchildren. canoeing, and roaming the world with friends response to the racist arsons of many southern moments she has shared with strangers, most are extended to family and friends of Norman and family, especially with his sons, brought Black churches during the mid-1990s, David often happening in spots and at times when Leduc, now of Rockledge, Fla., previously him pure delight. As David strolled through helped to organize youth and adult service they are unexpected—a “warm smile from of South Burlington, who passed away Jan. Burlington, his companions would often call trips from Charlotte and surrounding towns an elderly woman walking down the street,” 27 at the age of 82. He married his wife, him “the Mayor” because everyone seemed to to Summerton, South Carolina, for 15 years, someone opening a door for her, a kid looking Jeanne Laberge, in Charlotte, and they know him, folks from all walks of life. David to rebuild community centers and places of up at her with an earnest glance as he hands lived for a number of years on their farm on explained that what he loved best about his worship. He was also instrumental in founding her the hat she dropped. She says that while Cheesefactory Road in South Burlington. His occupation as a lawyer was his opportunity to the nonprofit Volunteer Vermont, LLC to raise they are all strangers, they are “all aware of brother-in-law Louis Laberge of Charlotte “learn everyone’s stories.” Nothing satisfied money for building supplies and trip expenses. each other’s presence yet completely inside died before Norm did. The family asks that, him more than the ability to help family, their own worlds.” She ends her poem by in lieu of flowers, donations be made to friends, and clients find ways for life to flow In light of the current pandemic, no formal saying to all the strangers she sees, “Although ReflectionsLSC.org. more justly and smoothly. gathering or celebration of David’s life is we’ve never met, I think I miss you most of currently planned. We encourage donations to all.” David Watts (1945-2021) Born in Middletown, Conn., April 23, 1945, the Southern Poverty Law Center, the ACLU, In the wee hours of Saturday morning, Jan. to Courtney McDermott and Margaret to Fay Bennett and Rowland Watts, David and to any local food shelf. Please know that 16, 2021 David died in his sleep on the couch Eagan who had their poems selected to appear spent his childhood years in Usonia, New David’s family deeply appreciates whatever with the latest New in the Feb. 5 Young Writers Workshop of the York, and graduated from Pleasantville friendship and care you brought to his life. Yorker magazine Burlington Free Press. Margaret’s “Letters” High. Usonia was an unusual, experimental, at his side. It was asks the reader to answer whether we are all collaborative community that his parents a total shock to all just “inky swirls scrawled across the page”— helped to shape. The commitment of Usonian who knew him. The letters—just “As and Ts crossed before the community members to social justice and David was the end?” Our lives depend on vowels. equity profoundly affected David’s goals and Charlotte image of fitness actions throughout his life—his pursuit of Courtney’s poem is titled “Something Simple.” and vitality, but a legal career as well as volunteer activities In it she says that “while life seems to form his heart appeared that focused on social justice, economic and News out of many simple things, we seldom think to fail him after David Watts housing equity, developmental disabilities TO ADVERTISE CONTACT: of them at the time they occur.” The author 75 active years. If rights, and family law; and his extraordinary [email protected] goes on to say she is always thinking of last you knew David at all, you knew him entirely generosity and skills in collaboration, SEND YOUR CHARLOTTE NEWS TO: year, yesterday—“something I never bothered because he was just as he appeared—generous, especially supporting those with more limited [email protected] to appreciate at the time, or something you kind, enthusiastic, principled, optimistic and resources. (reader) didn’t.” She closes by asking simple loving—no pretensions and a real mensch. PUBLICATION DATES questions that she will “never bother to think A graduate of Haverford College (1967) about again.” The best day of his life—David stated often and Antioch School of Law (1975), David February 25, 2021 and emphatically—was the day he became established strong friendships that remained Copy Deadline: Friday, Feb. 19 a father. He adored his three sons, Tucker, central to his adventures and soul-searching Ads Deadline: Friday, Feb. 19 Ethan and Brooks Bond-Watts, and his wife, The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 5 Lettters to the Editor Support for Lewis Mudge’s activities have included joining the Town candidacy Conservation Committee, and communications published in The Charlotte News regarding To the editor: human rights and voicing his opinion I am writing to offer my support for Lewis regarding the future of East Charlotte. He is Mudge’s candidacy for the two-year a member of the Charlotte Congregational Selectboard seat. I have found Lewis to be Church, participating as a Sunday School intelligent and committed to Charlotte not just teacher. as a place where he has chosen to reside, but Professionally, Lewis is the Central Africa where he and his family want to grow roots Director at Human Rights Watch. With his and give back to their local community. recent job promotion, he works remotely from I strongly believe that in order to better home in Charlotte with occasional trips to the world in which we live we all need to Africa. Previous to his current assignment, contribute in some meaningful way. That Lewis completed an assignment with the can mean volunteering at your local food Peace Corp in Lesotho, Africa, and Habitat bank, coaching youth sports or acting as a for Humanity in North Carolina, plus several teen mentor, or it can mean serving on your consulting and research activities with human local planning commission or as an elected rights issues. He also has extensive financial official. Lewis shares these values both in his and management experience. professional career as Central Africa Director Lewis is investing in Charlotte for the long for Human Rights Watch and in his candidacy term. Please support his candidacy. for the Charlotte Selectboard. I believe he has a unique set of experiences and skills that he Thank you, can bring to our town government, and I think Lane Morrison he will do so in a respectful and diplomatic manner. Frank Tenney for Selectboard Lewis has a balanced and thoughtful My name is Frank Tenney, currently vice chair perspective on our community. He is sensitive of the Selectboard. I am on the ballot for the to what makes Charlotte special that it inspired Selectboard three-year term. him and his family to move here in the first First and foremost, I would like to thank all place, but he also recognizes that change is Town employees and volunteers for their inevitable and neither good nor bad on its amazing dedication and commitment to public own. Instead that change should be guided service during this time of global and local thoughtfully and transparently to achieve the uncertainty. best possible outcomes for our town’s future. In Lewis I believe we will have a Selectboard The Board has been very busy lately meeting member who is open to discussion, welcoming 4, 5 and even 6 times a month. I have attended of ideas and respectful of our community almost all meetings, and I am up to date on the values. I am confident that he will work hard current and future issues facing the Town. for our collective best interests. A partial list of the items discussed or com- Lastly, I am encouraged that we have a pleted recently include: number of local residents who have thrown 1) The Library addition their hats in the ring for the two available 2) The electric charger station at Town Hall Selectboard seats. I think we owe them a 3) The completion of the State Park Road debt of gratitude as well as to those currently section of the Town Link Trail serving and those who have served in the 4) The rollout of the application process past. The recently passed former Secretary and fee schedule for the West Charlotte of State George Schultz’s favorite quote was, Village Municipal Wastewater Ordinance “Democracy is not a spectator sport.” That 5) A new committee to explore and develop has never been more apparent than now. We the idea of a Charlotte Community Center need committed people willing to serve for the 6) The preemptive removal of Ash trees in greater public good. But it is also a reminder the Town Right-of-Way that our democracy is dependent upon all of 7) A committee to investigate a sand shed to us to continue to do our best to contribute in reduce wasted materials and time any number of ways, the most basic of which 8) An update to the master plan for the Char- is to exercise our democratic right to vote. So, lotte Beach, and while the purpose of my letter is to support 9) The proposed amendments to the Land Lewis’ candidacy, more importantly I would Use Regulations and Town Plan Map by encourage each of you to get informed and the Planning Commission. simply get out and vote. You can request a mail-in ballot from the Town Clerk or you can The Town Plan and Land Use Regulations vote in person starting Wednesday, Feb. 10. updates are important issues for all residents. Thank you for your consideration of Lewis The Planning Commission has spent two years Mudge’s candidacy. of open meetings to bring a recommendation to the Selectboard. Your neighbor, Evan Langfeldt These changes will appear on the ballot. Article 6 – Town Plan Update – This expands Vote for Lewis Mudge for the land included in the East Village Commer- Selectboard cial District. To the editor: Article 7 – Land Use Regulation Update – This reduces the 5 acres residential lot size to Lewis brings new energy and will be an asset 1 acre in the East Village Commercial District as a member of the Selectboard. He is eager and allows septic to be transferred from this to learn, is a good listener, and wants the best district to the Rural District. for the residents of Charlotte. His educational background with advanced degrees in law and Article 8 – Accessory-On-Farm Business – government will complement this work. This creates a new separate set of regulations governing these types of businesses. He has a young family that includes his wife and three children, with two in CCS now Article 9 – This corrects grammatical mistakes and their third child will start kindergarten and updates definitions throughout the Land in a couple years. Lewis is a resident living Use Regulations. on Greenbush Road. His recent community see LETTERS page 5 6 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News Lettters to the Editor to a UVM study published in December, 70 LETTERS percent of respondents in Vermont walked continued from page 4 outside more because of the pandemic, citing This is one trick pony mental health and general well-being as chief All of these Articles can be voted on indi- benefits. Nationwide, trail usage was up by as vidually. I have heard many comments for much as 80 percent over 2019, according to and against these recommendations. I voted the Rails-to-Trails Conservancy. to place the updates on the ballot since to do otherwise could deny residents the chance to The growth in trail usage was notable make these decisions for themselves. enough for Governor Scott to mention it in his recent annual budget address: “Through I look forward to continue working with the the pandemic, we have seen increased use current Selectboard: Matt, Louise, Jim, and of our trails, paths and parks as folks looked whoever wins the two-year term. Even though for healthy ways to get out of the house. many people have asked, I will not be littering Let’s make them even more attractive and the roadsides with signs, posters or mailboxes accessible.” He added that outdoor recreation with flyers. projects “improve communities, grow Please help me continue working for Charlot- economic activity in the areas that need it ters another three years. most, and strengthen our Vermont brand.” It is important that Scott mentioned accessibility. Respectfully, Vermont offers ample challenging terrain for Frank W. Tenney serious hikers, cyclists and skiers, but only municipal trails are wide, smooth and level Tenney for Selectboard enough for all kinds of trail users, including children, parents with strollers, and the elderly. To the editor: The Trails Committee, which works at the How it’s done is a mystery, but this little horse on Greenbush Road is perfectly balanced on When Frank Tenney ran for a seat on the direction of the Selectboard, has been a the fence...even with snow all around. Photo by Janice Heilmann Selectboard in 2019, I wrote the endorsement responsible steward of taxpayers’ hard-earned below: money. Many have enjoyed the new section of properties like coffee shops or a pub. “I have worked with Frank as a member the Town Link Trail that was completed along Beware of zoning changes of the zoning board for three years and I State Park Road this fall, keeping your tax These recommendations have been To the editor: have followed his first term as a Charlotte money in the community by using a Charlotte incorporated in the Town Plan, and a key step Selectman. He has an encyclopedic knowledge construction company to do the work. Previous in moving ahead with the plan is amending the I’m writing to ask Charlotte voters to take a of the town and its regulations. This is sections of the trail were completed on time LURs. look at Articles 6 and 7 on the Charlotte Town priceless when developing and implementing and on budget. Trails themselves are among Meeting ballot which could have significant We don’t believe the proposed LUR policies that shape the town. the least expensive forms of community and swift implications for the character of our infrastructure. Charlotte has benefited from amendments do justice to the range of town. This is a case where the effect is greater He works well with everyone in Town Hall, is volunteers spending countless hours planning recommendations in the master plan. than the sum of its parts. a stickler for detail, and is a good listener. He trails, preparing the ground for construction, The proposed changes simply relax the is thoughtful, honest, and has no agenda other Existing zoning regulations are nearly the putting up signs and kiosks, making GPS LURs to allow greater density of residential than the responsible preservation and evolution same in East and West Charlotte and allow for maps, and maintaining trails once they are development in East Charlotte. That opens up of our community. When you bundle all this appropriate growth and development including built. the possibility of development at odds with the into a Charlotte native, Frank makes a valuable Affordable and Senior housing. However, intentions of the master plan. contribution that we cannot afford to lose.” There is a final reason for supporting Article 4. the new proposed changes only impact East New federal and state grant money that will be Furthermore, in taking a piecemeal approach Charlotte and would significantly increase Since then, the Selectboard has made him the available later this year and in 2022 requires to Charlotte’s development, the Town is the amount of development that could be board’s vice chair, and his commitment to local communities to contribute to the costs of engaging in “spot zoning.” That is, making possible. This includes doubling the land area Charlotte has been plain to see. trail projects. A favorable vote on Article 4 will a change for a single permittable situation of the East Charlotte commercial district, allowing for sewage pumping to other parts Ironically, the era of Zoom town committee position Charlotte to apply for those grants. that would not be appropriate for continued of town, and decreasing the minimum lot size meetings has made it easier for everyone to be growth and development of the community. Thank you to the citizens of Charlotte for from 5 acres to 1 acre. engaged. You don’t have to leave home. supporting this incredible town asset over the Spot zoning is generally frowned upon in community development scenarios. At first glance going from five down Frank has taken advantage of this by listening years. We will continue to work hard for you to to one acre per lot doesn’t seem in on the Trails, Recreation, Planning, Park & connect and increase our trails in town. Please Without the broader context, it’s difficult to unreasonable. However, keep in mind that Wildlife Refuge, and Senior Center meetings. vote YES on Article 4! picture what East Charlotte will look like in density bonuses already allow 20 Senior And he is on the Conservation, Energy, the future. The Charlotte Trails Committee housing units, or 10 Affordable housing units, Community Center, and Salt Shed committees. What will East Charlotte look like after the mixed into ¼ acre lots. This multiplying His commitment to Charlotte deserves our Vote NO on LUR Articles 6 & 7 proposed development? Will we have more effect would allow the growth potential of the continued support. To the editor: wealthy seasonal residents? More young commercial East Charlotte Village to increase working families with school-age children? from 15 units, today, to upward of 60 units in Thanks, We serve as volunteer members of Charlotte’s More senior citizens? All of the above? the future. Why should East Charlotte Village Stuart Bennett Zoning Board of Adjustment. We interpret What do we consider affordable housing be rezoned to allow five times the density of the intent of the Land Use Regulations to help for these populations? What do we consider West Charlotte Village? Trails Committee says yes on Article 4 residents obtain permits for building projects. “attractive?” Those attending the past few public Charlotte To the editor: However, we write today as Charlotte citizens By not fully addressing the requirements for Selectboard Meetings have learned that This year’s Town Meeting will not be like any who care about the future of our town. residential development as agreed by Charlotte the properties targeted for potential dense residents in the Town Plan, the proposed development have insufficient sewage capacity previous, but the all-volunteer Charlotte Trails We don’t support the proposed amendments to amendments to the LURs risk opening the due to poor soils. As a result, sewage would Committee is again asking you to vote in favor Charlotte’s Land Use Regulations in Articles door to development that was not intended be pumped across borders and potentially of Article 4 to fund continued construction 6 and 7 that will be on the ballot on Town or imagined by Charlotte residents in the into existing nearby neighborhoods. This on the Town Link Trail that eventually will Meeting Day 2021. connect Mt. Philo, the West Village and the planning process. is completely crazy but would be formally The proposed LUR amendments are part of a allowed under the new regulations. Town Beach. Vermont mandates that towns In order to make our votes on the LURs broader, thoughtful development initiative that vote each year for funding of multi-year considered and thoughtful, we want a clearer We have seen no village plan that would was launched over 10 years ago. Discussions projects like the Town Link Trail. picture of how Charlotte will develop and who propose infrastructure improvements and and surveys engaged residents in the plans for will be our new neighbors and the things we address the very real problem of pedestrian/ There are many reasons why trails are a development of East Charlotte. The result was will see when driving or walking through the traffic safety. Should these elements be an worthwhile investment in our community— a master plan for developing the East Charlotte improved quality of life, attracting taxpaying future East Charlotte commercial district. afterthought and dropped into the taxpayer’s Village Commercial District with specific lap? families to our town, and a safe way to recommendations, released in 2010. Until we see that clearer picture, we will vote exercise off of busy roads. But even better “No” on the proposed amendments. We ask Let’s promote reasonable growth in East Residential development that is “affordable, proof is in the pudding: because of COVID-19, you to consider doing the same. Charlotte and keep zoning density consistent we counted 220 pedestrians and 110 cyclists attractive and walkable” is one of the with West Charlotte. using the Town Link Trail during a 10-day recommendations. Lane Morrison and Matt Zucker Please vote NO on Articles 6 & 7. period in June. Even on a chilly, gray weekday Other recommendations include maintaining Editor’s note: Matt Zucker is married to afternoon in November, there were over 20 community character, preserving historical Claudia Marshall, who is the publisher of The Rick Leonard pedestrians and a half-dozen bikers on a single properties, enhancing recreational facilities, Charlotte News and the president of its board. section of the trail. These numbers are echoed and encouraging development of commercial across Vermont and the country. According see LETTERS page 6 The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 7 Lettters to the Editor LETTERS possibility of a town sewage plant, senior As I read about the new zoning proposals published a letter by Alex Bunten containing housing, and the goal of maintaining as much for East Charlotte, I see some of the same personal attacks on several East Charlotters continued from page 5 as possible of the rural character that so issues that were addressed over 40 years ago. by name and members of our Planning enhances Charlotte. East Charlotte has remained a rural stop at Commission and Selectboard by reference. Not everyone voted for a four corners and maintained its character. In addition, you allowed Alex to make up The commission began the work of creating the Town Plan Changing zoning acreage and density will “facts” about the proposed East Charlotte the first town plan for Charlotte and possibly impact traffic, road maintenance, safety, Zoning Changes up for vote on Town To the editor: the state. Without a plan, the town zoning school enrollment, town budgets and taxes Meeting Day and my plans for my property. was set at one-acre residential zoning. To put First off, I want to offer an apology to and forever, the character of the land. Is that change and growth temporarily on the shelf, The plan Alex declared that I have for the Chris Snyder for calling the Kwiniaska Charlotte’s future? the town initiated “Interim Zoning.” This land behind his house is to put 10 to 12 development a “debacle.” Poor choice of put Charlotte zoning at a 10-acre minimum Nancy Flinn houses on one acre lots. That is not my plan words. for any growth until the town plan could be and the zoning changes only affect four or To the lay person driving by, it’s a bit of a developed and voters would approve the plan. Proposed changes to East Charlotte five acres of my property. Therefore, my net shame that open space is now gone. Do we During this time, surveys were generated that Village density gain under the new zoning map is want the E. Charlotte Village to look more helped direct the “then future” projected for three or four units, total. I would like to put like Shelburne? That’s not why my family the town. To the editor: the Sheehan house on one acre, but my corner lives here. Would it be nice to fix up what we is currently zoned for five-acre lots and the The main goal, at that time, was to keep We are within days of voting on changes that have? Sure. eastern two corners are zoned for one acre our farms and rural beauty and develop will forever alter the gentle landscape and lots. I would like to work with the Grange to a plan without taxing residents, schools, quiet character of our sweet little village. Some Second is a quick reminder about the Town provide them with more parking and perhaps roads and vistas. At this time, the federal of us have been watching this slow and painful Plan and how we got into this predicament water and septic capacity if possible. And, I government was helping fund sewer systems process of the Planning Commission, and about the future of E. Charlotte. As I want to do the senior housing allowed under and wastewater plants, and the Charlotte recently the two Selectboard hearings, which understand it, the Planning Commission’s job current regulations but made practical by the Selectboard was reviewing possibilities. were unimpressive to this observer. is to help facilitate the Town Plan and bring new regulations. Watch for more details in the Working together, what resulted was the any changes to residents for a vote. Only one Selectboard person had the courage next Charlotte News. decision to pass on the sewer proposal. to do the right thing! It’s important to remember that not everyone I believe that Alex’s letter failed to meet the The issue of planning for senior housing voted for the Town Plan and not everyone has As president of the Sheehan Green community published standards for a Letter to the Editor was also considered. At that time, there to agree with how it’s executed. The proposed for 20-plus years, it is possible that I could in The Charlotte News and I think that the were no commercial bus routes running expansion of the E. Charlotte commercial speak for some 30+ voters. The Selectboard Board of Directors should review his letter that would accommodate seniors living district and changes to residential density in heard directly from some of them, others and their policies regarding letters at a future south of Shelburne and Burlington. And the area (Articles 6 and 7) are good examples wish to not be so vocal. I have been asked to Board meeting. of this. public transportation was important. It was represent a high percentage of them and will determined that, if senior housing were attempt to do so with this letter. Most Charlotters know that Alex served We are a small town that likes to take it to be developed down the road, it should honorably as the editor of The Charlotte slow. Call me crazy but five acres to one for occur adjacent to Route 7, which would Mr. Schneider’s letter in The Charlotte News News for several years. One would like to residential–along with sewage movement accommodate bus transportation. The other of January 28 alerts us as to what is ahead for think that the journalistic standards he upheld outside the village district and an expansion determination was to maintain Route 7 as a our little village of East Charlotte if we vote as editor would have led him to state his to the commercial district–sounds fast. And funnel without new access and egress. The “yes” on Articles 6 and 7. We are on the cusp opinions as opinions and dispense with all of the potential impact is still unclear at this late light at 7 and Ferry Road came a number of of becoming another Columbia, Md. the name calling. stage in the process. years later. Let’s talk about what the Planning What some Charlotters may not know is that We have plenty of opportunities available We considered various zones for residential Commission and the Selectboard are asking us Alex owns the old Baptist Church in East under the current land use regulations in the and rural designations and the feasibility to approve! Charlotte which sits on about half an acre. E. Charlotte Village District. Just because of development rights to provide equity for A. Change in density from 5 acres to 1, Three of the folks he attacked by name are they don’t suit the developer du jour, doesn’t farmers. There were many hearings, and I his adjoining landowners. Alex’s letter was mean we should change them. fielded some angry phone calls (often while B. Increase of the commercial district acreage not a personal expression of his opinion Vote NO on Articles 6 and 7. trying to put supper on the table), staying by 20+ acres, or 122% increase! about a civic matter, but a below-the-belt accountable to Charlotte’s farm families who attack on his neighbors unworthy of inclusion C. Increase in new residential housing could Alex Bunten could justifiably state, “My farm is my money in a newspaper founded by the Charlotte be up to 75, (the numbers are without specifics in the bank.” Congregational Church. Insights into Charlotte zoning from the P.C.) Sadly, most of Charlotte’s farms have I’d like to correct Alex’s attack on retiring history D. The ability to pump sewage/septic under disappeared in the past 40-plus years. Saving Selectboard member Carrie Spear. She does the road or across the street. (We know where To the editor: them should have been a function of the town not have a conflict of interest in the proposed it is coming from but we don’t know where it plan. East Charlotte Zoning change as her store is I wanted to share some of the history of is going!) “No answers available but we have already in the village commercial district so Charlotte Town Planning. The first Charlotte Town Plan was considered our suspicions.” the additions to that district have no impact an improvement over the old one-acre zoning. During the late 1970s and early 1980s, I E. Different set of LURs (land use regulations) on her property. Opposing the zoning change For me, it was less than its potential. Five- served on the Charlotte Town Planning for similar commercial districts in the same to enlarge the village commercial district acre zoning was approved at Town Meeting Commission (three years as a member and town! (Why would we do that?) would have been a conflict of interest in and maintained until improvements made by seven chairing the commission). This was a potentially eliminating competition from subsequent town plans. time of growth in the town. It included the F. No request by the PC or Selectboard for businesses that might be built in the expanded any impact studies before voting! (That seems commercial area. to me like buying a home and then inviting the house inspector in to see what’s wrong with The Town of Charlotte does have a conflict- Professional Office Suite Available my decision!) of-interest policy which allows for the In the heart of the revitalizing Charlotte West Village creation of a municipal panel to review G. Absolutely no discussion of the • Newly renovated at move-in office at conflict of interest charges. I have encouraged infrastructure needed or the cost to the the Selectboard to activate this panel and I the corner of Greenbush Road and taxpayers. Ferry Road. hope you will too. The community has a right Here is the last question: Where will the to know the truth when a conflict of interest • Large, sunny and visible 500 sewage treatment facility be built? charge is levied against a public official and square foot office suite with onsite the official has the right to have their good management. In summary, it appears to me and others name cleared if they have done nothing • Shared conference room. that these proposals will benefit a few to wrong. • Kitchen and other common facilities. the detriment of many! Please vote “no” on Articles 6 and 7. I appreciate The Charlotte News coverage of • Annual lease with renewal options the proposed Zoning changes and hope you at $900 per month with heat and Richard Stowe will continue to provide factual articles and electricity included. President of Sheehan Green appropriately written opinions in the editions Homeowners Assoc. Located just south of Route 7 this location offers easy walking to the Post Office, Town leading up to Town Meeting Day. Hall, Library, Senior Center, Fire Station, food amenities and is part of the growing activity Civility and truthfulness above all Sincerely, in the Charlotte West Village. Ideally located to capitalize on increased activity and Clark Hinsdale visibility for your practice. else…please! Call Andrew at 802 318-6228 or Michael at 802 777-8757 To the editor: or email any questions to [email protected] In the last issue of The Charlotte News, you see LETTERS page 20 8 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News Opinion Taking issue with $110 per life Mike Donoghue And yet, Seward’s fate started with the State others familiar with family court proceedings. CONTRIBUTOR Police. Chet and Connie The Vermont Department for Children and Families would be expected to monitor a They issued a news release the day of the Something is way out of whack. “Hawkins died in the juvenile long distance for the court. crash, withholding Seward’s identity. Two days Isabel Jennifer Seward, a teenage driver, was later, the VSP eventually disclosed it. (And head-on crash, after We concur with the attorney general that you fined $220 for her part in a double-fatal vehicle much later, the Vermont Department of Motor Seward, who was 16 must come down on the side of transparency crash that killed an elderly Ferrisburgh couple Vehicles provided Seward’s name, hometown when it comes to releasing names of teenagers last fall in Charlotte. and complete crash details in the public at the time, crossed involved in fatal crashes. Also, they need to be Were it not for a freelance journalist, we never accident report filed by State Police.) public for serious crimes or providing names the double yellow-line, of children that have been abducted or lost. would have known where to place our outrage. Chittenden County State’s Attorney Sarah Period. Chet and Connie Hawkins died in the head-on George was upset with Vermont State Police striking them. crash, after Seward, who was 16 at the time, for releasing Seward’s name as the driver ” If they are given a license, and the crossed the double yellow-line, striking them. in the fatal crash. George did not want the responsibility to drive, minors deserve the name public if there was any chance Seward rights and responsibilities that come from their Seward received a civil traffic ticket for an might undergo confidential proceedings Safety Commissioner Michael Schirling actions—especially if those actions lead to offense listed as “driving on roadways laned in Vermont Family Court for her driving. directed a gag order on all State Police, death. for traffic.” She pleaded no contest to the civil George could file criminal charges in adult preventing them from providing any news Earlier this week, an 18-year-old man fired traffic ticket and was assessed $220 by the court as well, if warranted. Vermont State releases with names of juveniles, including off a round at the University Mall in South Vermont Judicial Bureau. Her mother paid the Police countered that they had relied on the if they are killed or injured. As written, the Burlington. His alleged actions caused injury. fine. department’s transparency policy and several order also appears to restrict public release More than likely, he will face a consequence legal opinions, the Vermont Constitution, the about child abductions, AMBER Alerts, Sure, you can be angry a fine was issued in far more severe than a fine, and his name has Vermont Public Records Law and the rules of missing skiers, overdue hunters and other light of the death of two individuals. Or you been plastered all over the news for two days the Vermont Judiciary—all of them siding with cases involving children. Schirling’s gag order can be angry about the fact many efforts were remains in effect today. now. made to conceal Seward’s identity from the transparency for public records. What we hope is four-fold: public eye. Here’s the wrinkle: Since last July, state However, the Vermont Judiciary maintains We hope that the Seward case will be held attorneys, including George, were directed Seward’s name and information are public. The fine was only made public after reporter up as a transparency issue, especially for to send cases involving juveniles initially And Vermont Attorney General T.J. Michael Donoghue made a public records cases involving minors and serious crimes to family court, except for the most serious Donovan has stated that he sides with public request, which Vermont State Police ignored (especially with death resulting). We hope crimes. Once the case is at family court, the transparency in the Seward case. for more than a month. Vermont’s records law Schirling’s gag order will be called out and state’s attorney is free to move it to adult requires a prompt response—but also allows State Police noted Seward might face legal lifted for being short-sighted. We hope when criminal court, but needs to indicate the reason up to 10 days for delays in special cases. action in Vermont Family Court as a juvenile, minors commit serious crimes, they are held for the move is “in the interest of justice.” which would be confidential. Vermont responsible. And we hope—beyond all else— When State Police finally filed a response, it Adult proceedings are public. Family Court has few options in juvenile had redacted several parts of the civil ticket, that no one’s life is reduced to $110. The day after Seward’s name was released by cases. Vermont closed its juvenile jail last including Seward’s name and hometown, This op-ed originally ran in the Rutland Vermont State Police, Department of Public year. A judge could impose counseling or Atlanta, Georgia. community service, according to lawyers and Herald/Times Argus. The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 9 Town All hail Old Craggy: The South Charlotte Farm New champion crowned and Viewshed Project Vince Crockenberg CHARLOTTE TREE TRIBE The Charlotte Tree Tribe is pleased to announce a new champion tree, one not previously on the Hamilton Roster: an apple tree owned by Tom Cosinuke and Annie Kelton on Sanctuary Lane. Affectionately known by its owners as Old Craggy, the tree measures 101 inches in diameter—though at 3 feet rather than at 4 ½ feet (hence the asterisk). Deputy Tree Warden Sue Smith and I agreed that Old Craggy deserved a waiver of the standard requirements by virtue of living to what appears to be a grand old age.

If you have a candidate for champion status, including one for a species not yet on the roster, contact me (vince. [email protected]) or Sue (ssmith@ gmavt.net) to schedule a visit to confirm the tree’s identity and circumference.

A constantly updated Hamilton Roster, which includes information on where the current champion trees reside, can be also found on the Charlotte News website and on the town website. Featured on the cover: Tom Cosinuke and Photo courtsey headoverfieldsvt.com Annie Kelton are the proud owners of a newly appointed champion apple tree. Photo by Vince Crockenberg Kate Lampton The South Charlotte Farm and Viewshed CHARLOTTE LAND TRUST Project is a striking example of the multiple benefits of land conservation. Don’t forget From the summit of Mt Philo, the most John and Carol Snow have owned visited state park in Vermont, and from Mt your little property on the east side of Route 7 near Philo Road the view of the Snow property the border with North Ferrisburgh since is a prominent part of the patchwork sweethearts 1994. A few years ago, they subdivided of fields, streams and woodland that their house, outbuildings and some of compose this iconic Champlain Valley on Valentine’s Day! the acreage from the open farmland that scene. Conservation will protect the spread from near Route 7 up toward Mt. scenic vistas of the property and its place Philo Road. Their hope was to create a lot in the larger viewshed. Almost the entire Jamie Two-CoatS’ that could be sold to a farmer and to see acreage to be conserved is ranked in the the land remain in agricultural use. “We highest categories of agricultural soils. learned,” John said, “that land does not Conservation will also protect a small JAMIEToY ShoP keep itself open. It needs to be worked.” wooded section of the property traversed Meanwhile, Bryan Seward and Katie by a tributary of Kimball Brook with TWO-COATS54 Falls Road Rose Leonard had been searching for land protection guidelines in the conservation Shelburne, VT to become Katie Rose’s own farm, after easement specific to water quality and TOY SHOP several years of managing and working on wildlife habitat. farms for others. Located In The Of Shelburne Conservation is about preserving In the l of Shelburne land, but it is also an economic driver. “We’ve been searching for the perfect 54 Falls Road | Hours: 10am - 5pm Mon-Sat, 11am-4pm Sun | 802-985-3221 place to start a farm since my first Conservation will make this land HOURS: 10AM–5PM MON-SAT, 11AM–4PM SUN | 802-985-3221 growing season 7 years ago,” Leonard affordable enough for a young couple to said. After meeting and discussing the purchase it as their first farm, becoming possibilities, John and Carol realized an important addition to the agricultural Correction and Send us they had found their farmer, and Katie economy of Charlotte. Katie Rose will Rose and Bryan knew they had found grow a diversified organic mix of produce your photos! their farm. “As we reflected on our hopes and flowers. An existing farm structure on ommission for this land we realized that our vision Route 7 is being converted to a farmstand. In the Jan. 28 issue, the article “Assistant of keeping it open and worked required Katie Rose said, “For us, conserving this position in the works, other Selectboard some new partners who could share that land is about ensuring it remains an active business,” we incorrectly explained the vision. We found them in Bryan and Katie part of Charlotte’s incredible working plowing situation on Plouffe Lane and the Rose,” Carol said. landscape and is forever protected parking on its nearby trails. The trails are from over development. It’s also about The Charlotte Land Trust and the Vermont owned by the town; the road is not a town accessibility for generations of farmers to Land Trust are working in partnership to highway. Gregg Beldock currently plows come.” Plouffe Lane, in a fashion which creates a conserve the Snows’ 71 acres of excellent farmland that is also a major portion More information about Katie Rose’s berm that blocks entry to the parking area new farm can be found at www. at the Town’s parcel. The Selectboard of the Mt Philo viewshed. Other than headoverfieldsvt.com. If you would hired Karol Halack to plow the Town’s a house for Bryan and Katie Rose that like to help conserve this special land, driveway and parking area. will be built on adjacent unconserved land, the farmland will be preserved for donations for the project can be made to In thanking our much-appreciated Charlotte events, people or places. continued agricultural use. Major funding the Charlotte Land Trust, P.O. Box 43, volunteers in our Dec. 17, 2020 issue, We want to publish your photos. commitments have been received from the Charlotte, VT 05445. To donate online we inadvertently left out Junior Tuiqere, Email them to: Vermont Housing and Conservation Board please visit: charlottelandtrust.org. who cheerfully and efficiently delivers [email protected] and the Town of Charlotte Conservation newspapers to various newsstands in the Fund. CLT is committed to raising area. Thanks, Junior! The $25,000 toward funding for the project in Charlotte News time for a closing in March. 10 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News Into The Woods Giving forestry “The Agriculture Treatment” Ethan Tapper permanent (as is the case of many non- CONTRIBUTOR renewable resources). The cheapness and availability of non- When forest management is done well it local resources allows us to pretend that makes our forests healthier, more complex we can consume without costs to our and more resilient; provides incredible ecosystems, but it doesn’t erase those habitat for wildlife; and produces local, impacts—it just displaces them to peoples renewable resources. Responsible forest and ecosystems somewhere else, perhaps management supports many things we at environmental and social costs that we value, from healthy local economies and wouldn’t find acceptable if they were in ecology to the culture and the character our communities. of our communities. As someone who believes in forest management, a In forestry, as in agriculture, if we can big part of my job involves diffusing move past denying that our actions have misunderstandings about it, asking environmental impacts, we can start people to reexamine deeply rooted being proactive. Using local resources, misconceptions about forestry and especially local renewable resources, logging. I do this because I genuinely means owning those impacts, keeping believe that forest management can be them right where we can see them. Some part of how we build a better world. of these impacts—benefits to our local economies, our neighbors, the culture Recently, I’ve been marveling at the and the character of our communities, amazing culture we’ve built around local our working landscape—are easy to own. agriculture in Vermont and wondering Others, like the initial messiness of a why the same pride doesn’t always apply freshly managed forest or the buzz of a to local forestry. Forest management and chainsaw from your neighbor’s woodlot, agriculture have may be a little more a lot in common: challenging. they are both types of land use, in Bringing which we manage Forest management our resource our environment consumption home for a renewable “and agriculture have means that we resource. In the take the radical case of agriculture, a lot in common: step to confront it provides us with the impacts that delicious food. In they are both types our lives have on the case of forestry, of land use, in which our world with our it provides us with eyes wide open. beautiful wood. we manage our It allows us to But, while we love actively develop a and celebrate the environment for a relationship with farms that dot our our resources, landscape and the renewable resource. rather than farmers and the consuming without ” an understanding food that show up at summer farmer’s of the toll we markets, forestry are taking on receives a much less ecosystems and universally warm treatment. peoples across the world. Like agriculture, forestry can be done The way that we use land and alter in different ways and at different scales. ecosystems will always be a compromise. Comparing historic and industrial After all, virtually every farm in Vermont forestry practices to forest management (and every one of our houses and in Chittenden County is like comparing businesses) is on a site that was a forest industrial agriculture in the Midwest or a wetland just a few hundred years ago. with Vermont’s local organic farms. We accept these environmental impacts Like farming, forest management can be because they allow us to live happy, extractive and commodity focused, or it healthy lives in a beautiful place, to eat can be regenerative, producing amazing delicious food, and to be warm all winter. renewable resources while leaving a In comparison, forest management healthier ecosystem in its wake. is a small compromise—harvesting An important part of understanding our a renewable resource while keeping role with respect to forests and other ecosystems intact, encouraging great ecosystems means recognizing that the wildlife habitat and the “ecosystem question is not if we want to have an services” that make our world work, impact. Rather, it is: what do we want keeping our communities beautiful and that impact to be? Humans always have functional. Treating local forestry like and always will consume resources— local agriculture is something that may the things we eat, we wear, we use to require some of us to re-examine how we fuel our lives. Everything is made of think about it—but it’s worth the effort. something and comes from somewhere— Ethan Tapper is the Chittenden County and there is no way to extract, process Forester. He can be reached at ethan. and transport resources without having [email protected] or (802) 585-9099. an impact on ecosystems. Depending on the resource, those impacts could be minor or ephemeral (as in the case of most renewable resources) or major and The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 11 Hi, Neighbor! Stephanie Sumner: Bringing her A-game to Charlotte Central School Stephanie Sumner and collaborative learning. It’s like a giant math coordinator in 2013 when she first just finished what think tank.” began working at Charlotte Central School. she described as the “I’m drawn to the K-4 age group,” she best professional The initial meetings were all at Lake said. “I love to see how our students grow, development experience Morey, but when COVID-19 hit, in-person change, learn new things, and recognize she’s ever had. workshops were shut down and the March and feel pride at what they’ve learned. Sumner has been session was held remotely and had to be Elementary age kids really love school and Phyl Newbeck the lead principal scaled back because participants were they are happy to be here and easy to work CONTRIBUTOR at Charlotte Central dealing with transforming their schools to with.” School since 2017. remote learning. “We continued to set up Former Champlain Valley Union principal opportunities to check in with each other Sumner and her husband have two teenage Val Gardner, who together with Peter remotely during the school year,” Sumner children with whom they love to kayak in Burrows co-directs the Snelling Center for said. Participants were given the option the summer and skate in the winter. Sumner Government’s Vermont School Leadership of attending the July session in person describes herself as a “recovering runner” Project, was one of her mentors in her and Sumner chose to do so, together with who is getting back into the sport after early years at CCS and her advisor for her roughly half of the cohort. The October foot injuries. She worked with Girls on the Certificate in Advance Graduate Studies at and November sessions brought almost all Run for several years before she got hurt. St. Michael’s College. Gardner periodically of the participants on-site. “In November She is a voracious reader and admits that invites those she has worked with to we had a closure session,” Sumner said during the pandemic she has become a bit take part in the Leadership Project, and “where we reflected and shared growth obsessed with puzzles. Sumner was happy to get an invitation and stories and wrapped up the work we had accomplished.” Sumner is pleased with how things have Stephanie Sumner Photo contributed participate last year. been going at CCS. “We’ve got a lot of What Sumner really liked about the things we’ve done well and will continue to “It was amazing,” Sumner said. “I’ve which they hope to continue.” been lucky to participate in really great program was the way it allowed her to do,” she said “and the pandemic has given professional development during my focus on leadership skills. “When I think us the chance to step back, reflect, and Sumner said she continues to be gratified career, but hands down this was the best about the entire experience, it really was a prioritize.” Before the onset of COVID, by the support she has received from the I’ve ever had and the best growth process.” process of continually zooming in and out,” the CCS team emphasized play-based community. she said. “I got to look in at myself and also learning and social connections and that Sumner praised Gardner and Burrows for “Being able to come into a school and be their leadership, knowledge and work as at the systems we have in place and then will continue to be prioritized. “We got how I go into the systems, and then come more creative with how we used our with the students has helped sustain me facilitators. “It’s a cohort model,” she said and my teachers during the pandemic,” she “so you are with a group of educators who back out to reflect on what I’ve done.” campus and outdoor education,” Sumner said “and that’s something we’d like to said. “We feel very lucky that we are back are your colleagues for 18 months. It’s Sumner started her teaching career in 1996 in the building as much as possible because great to be able to brainstorm and problem put more energy into post-pandemic.” with 4th grade students and then taught The team has also designed a vision for being with the kids is a fun and exciting solve and learn among people with the either 5th grade or a combined 5th/6th place to be.” same goals. There was a lot of consulting enhanced STEAM (Science, Technology, grade, with the exception of one year as a Engineering, Arts, Mathematics) education

The Charlotte FREELANCE WRITERS News Your nonprofit community & REPORTERS WANTED news source since 1958

The Charlotte News is looking for paid freelance writers and reporters. No specific reporting experience is necessary, and good writers from all backgrounds are welcome. You may cover local news, politics, events, local education, and human interest stories, particularly relating to environmental issues, farming, and the evolution of Charlotte. And we’re open to more ideas, too. Send us a pitch.

The ideal candidate writes well, meets deadlines, and cares about the community of Charlotte. Contact Editor Chea Evans at [email protected]. 12 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News Out Takes I wish I could get guns off my plate I’ve been demoralized duck blinds on a point in the lake’s middle. too many times Twice a day the local ducks would migrate But now I realize, ah, from one end to the other—mallards, teal, ah, no more redheads, canvasbacks, pintails and an I’m gonna get me a occasional ruddy duck. gun I’m gonna get me a gun We would have to arrive in the blinds early Edd Merritt And all those people in the morning to kill from the first flock. CONTRIBUTOR who put me down Then we would sit in cold, wet blinds for You better get ready to most of the day until the flocks migrated run back to the other end of the lake. Thank ‘Cause I’m gonna get me a gun goodness Saturday was our primary hunting Cat Stevens – I’m Gonna Get Me a Gun day and we could listen to the University of Minnesota football broadcast while we Guns again are an issue—this time at awaited the ducks. the University Mall in South Burlington. Although, according to news reports, no I never got into hunting ducks or clay one was hit directly by a bullet, the fact pigeons even though my grandfather that guns were the first line of retaliation gave me a shotgun for my high school between feuding groups or individuals graduation. It hung in our home gun closet once again raises the question of what our for years. culture believes about the value of human To me there is a difference between life. shotguns carried by my family and handguns and multiple-round rifles carried The U.S. differs from Great Britain in by the protesters at the capital last month. regard to even police carrying and using I feel strongly that these latter weapons weapons. Of the four constituent British ought to be banned because they were countries, only Northern Ireland officers all developed primarily to hunt people, not carry firearms. In the others, some specially birds. trained fire-arms officers carry them, but most do not. This practice goes back to I have held to that opinion. Lately, the 19th century and the formation of the however, I questioned it after reading two Metropolitan Police Service and the fear opinion pieces in which the authors support by the majority of the public that armed protecting themselves through their own officers were detrimental to its safety. Ten gun carrying. years ago there were fewer than 7,000 Charles Blow in the Times last December “Authorized Firearms Officers” and only wrote about being Black and armed, saying five incidents where conventional arms that the “surge in Black gun-buying is a were used. response to America’s failing to create a Apparently, however, the continued society where all citizens feel safe.” His practice by police is an annual topic of home town in Louisiana was predominantly debate. Black and “gun ownership was the norm . . . including in the Black community.” Not so here, though. I’m drawn back to Before the Civil War, gun ownership by the incident in Las Vegas in 2017 when a Blacks had been prohibited, and many of shooter staying in a hotel suite managed to them saw this as an attempt to block them get 47 weapons, loaded with high-capacity from defending themselves. Although magazines, up to his suite and into two of Blow believes that fewer guns in his Black his Nevada homes without being noticed community would make it safer, he does and without having his guns confiscated. note that due to the “unrelenting series Several of these weapons carried high- of unarmed Black people being killed on powered ammunition capable of piercing video . . . gun sales to Black Americans police armor. were up 58 percent through September.” I opened the New York Times Sunday He wishes that America could have created magazine December 20 last year and the a society that felt safe “without the need main article, which addressed the debate for personal firearms. . . However, it chose over vote numbers in the presidential not to.” “Many Black people feel the election as counted in Pennsylvania, carried need to defend themselves from their own along with it pictures of Trump supporters country.” Roger Cohen, another Times carrying loaded pistols and AR-15-style correspondent, said freedom had become rifles plus 160 rounds of ammunition. the muzzle of a Glock. These weapons and amount of ammunition Let us hope that, despite the recent incident were meant for hunting people, not game. in the mall, weapons should not be a Coming from a hunting and gun-club solution to disagreement. family I was drawn into sporting arms at an Life on earth should not depend on our early age. ability to threaten the death of others. My grandfather owned property that Despite what John Lennon said, happiness fronted on an hourglass shaped lake with is not a warm gun. Lets us create your next advertisment! TheCharlotte News Contact [email protected] to advertise The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 13 Health COVID vaccine in Vermont Elizabeth Hunt, M.D., FAAP, the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 (people 16 with CCS students Audrey Neilson, Kenna years and older are eligible) and Moderna Hutchins and Holly Lian, with the guidance of vaccines (age 18 years and older) to be science teacher Andrew Lounsbury distributed in the U.S., and the campaign began in our state on Dec. 15, 2020. At the time of publication there will have New developments emerge almost daily. At been nearly 500,000 deaths in the United the time of publication it is likely Johnson States from COVID-19 and over 100 and Johnson will have applied for an EUA million cases worldwide. There is good for their single shot Janssen vaccine, which news on the horizon; many vaccines are has been trialed in over 40,000 people here or in development. The vaccines (with no anaphylaxis side effects) and referenced in this article or in development showed 85% efficacy in preventing severe have largely illustrated the ability to disease. The newer vaccines are almost prevent significant symptomatic infection, all 100% effective against severe disease hospitalization and death. and remain in development: AstroZeneca/ COVID vaccines will help our Oxford, Novavax, J & J, Gamaleya communities develop herd immunity, National Research. where most people are protected against Effectiveness of vaccine against emerging infection from the virus, and therefore variants and re-infection is an active area lower the degree of overall spread. of study at present. In his press briefing Scientists still cannot say for certain how on Feb. 2, Governor Scott alluded to long immunity lasts or whether a vaccine is ways to boost the import of vaccine to better at preventing infection than having Vermont and stated that we should see had COVID-19 infection itself. more in coming weeks. There are currently Image by hakan german from Pixabay We do know that mass vaccination will vaccine appointments available through slow spread and death from this virus. On the Vermont Department of Health for Kinney’s on either the Kinney website or come and destroy the harmful antibody. Dec. 11, 2020, the U.S. Food and Drug Vermonters age 75 and older. The next the state website. The COVID-19 vaccine Administration issued the first emergency age band will be in Vermonters age 70 and should be given 14 days apart from any Once they are made, the antibodies stay in use authorization (EUA) for a vaccine for over, and then 65 years and up will follow. other vaccine. your immune system to help fight off future the prevention of coronavirus disease 2019 You need to have had your birthday and be antibodies. Vaccines contain a weakened (COVID-19) caused by the coronavirus we the actual age to sign up. To get your vaccine, sign up on this or inactive part of the antigen that triggers website: https://www.healthvermont. the immune system to make antibodies are all focused on (SARS-CoV-2) in adult Kinney Drugs pharmacies are the only humans. gov/covid-19/vaccine/getting-covid-19- against the weakened antigen, so that they Vermont official vaccine delivery partner, vaccine. There is a video on this website are not harmed by the antigen, but the The emergency use authorization allowed and you can sign up for a vaccine at on exactly how to register. Or go to https:// immune system can train itself for future kinneydrugs.com/pharmacy/covid-19/ encounters with a more harmful version of vaccination-scheduling/vt/, or call 855-722- this antigen. 7878. COVID mRNA vaccines are a new vaccine Here is some helpful background that scientists have made to combat information on immunizations from COVID. The mRNA vaccines work by Charlotte Central School students to round giving our cells a piece of something called out this conversation regarding COVID-19 a spike protein. A spike protein is the vaccine: reason our bodies get infected by viruses. Spike proteins have little spikes (hence Your immune system plays a huge part in the name) that act like keys to get into our how your body protects you from diseases bodies. Once they’re in our bodies they and viruses. One part of your immune can multiply, infecting our bodies. When system is something called an antibody, or the mRNA vaccine puts the instructions immunoglobulins, that is produced by the in your immune cells, the cells then know immune system when the body recognizes how to make a piece of a protein that can a pathogen (a disease-causing organism). fight off the virus. Once the cells know how These act as the defense system for your to make the proteins, they break down the body and have specific pathogens that they instructions and get rid of them. After our protect you from. They latch themselves bodies make the proteins, our bodies can onto specific antigens (foreign substances fight off the virus when we get infected, that the body recognizes as something keeping us safe. harmful) and then call for another part of the immune system called lymphocytes to 14 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News

ink master Bill Fraser-Harris has been waiting for this moment for weeks; the Charlotte Public Ice R Rink is finally frozen. He said it TThe rink’s up is “so good to finally have ice and a decent, skateable surface…It was really well used over the weekend. Flooding continues, thanks to Ed and Craig for their multiple and running shifts in pretty cold weather, and to Dave S. for tractor work...with more snow coming for him to clear.”

Photos by Bill Fraser-Harris The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 15 Education College app assessments are changing, but writing isn’t going away Margo Bartsch has added an additional 250-word essay about the effects of Covid-19 on a student’s As the COVID-19 pandemic hits the one- life and learning environment. Although year mark, many changes to the college the essay is optional, this is an important admissions process have become the opportunity to reflect on this past year, how new normal. During this recent 2020–21 a student has shifted family responsibilities application season, all colleges have and engaged in the community. Colleges want become test-optional, and many are already to understand character traits and values that announcing that they will continue being can be extended to the college community. test-optional for the upcoming 2021–22 Writing within a short structure still requires application year. In addition, the College an outline, main idea and various paragraphs Board, which administers the SAT, subject to trace challenge and growth. tests (SAT-2s) and AP exams announced last Also, most colleges have added essays to month that they will be eliminating the essay their specific application forms (supplemental section of the SAT after the June 2021 test essays). For example, this year, the University date and that the hour-long subject tests have of Vermont included a choice of five essay been permanently discontinued. The ACT prompts to consider: “What Ben & Jerry’s ice has not announced scrapping their essay. cream flavor best describes you?” and “How With all the ongoing changes on the horizon, do you create meaningful connections with families should be aware that the purpose those who have differing opinions than you?” of testing has not gone away; rather, tests Although the UVM essays are optional, this Photo by Tirachard Kumtanom from Pexels have been replaced with other measurement is a test as to how a student writes within 500 assessments. test subject competency in one hour within scoring process. words and shares some insight about their a multiple-choice format. Similar to the AP The SAT and ACT essays have been scored interests with the Admissions Committee. exams, the core subjects include history, The saying “There is more than one way to skin a cat” rings true with the college components of both exams. The written Some colleges have required additional math, science and foreign languages. The essay measures the ability of a student to New York Times reported on Jan. 19 that application process. Both testing assessments essays to get to know more about the and college essays highlight the need to write within a set time (SAT in 50 minutes student’s academic interests. Dartmouth this test was dropped to “… place a greater and the ACT in 40 minutes), organize their importance on Advanced Placement tests.” write structured and engaging analysis and included a choice of six prompts with reflections that share a student’s academic ideas in a structure and with a theme, and most referencing authors and thought- highlight their critical analysis. The essay The AP exams were revised in May of 2020 knowledge and personal interests. Although leaders within a shorter, 300-word count. to an online format. When most high schools various application requirements may evolve, sections are optional, but they are scored to Colleges review these writing samples with show a student’s performance with reading were closed during the pandemic, the College the core root of knowledge and expression similar criteria as the SAT and ACT essay. Board created the new AP test with one essay are best represented with compelling and comprehension, writing deduction and Memorable writing includes a compelling outline structure. The essays allow colleges prompt or multiple math or science equations. insightful writing. Great essays reveal how a theme, logical structure and personalized tone With the new written format, students must student’s past will influence their future. to compare candidates within a standardized, to get to know the student and assess how timed setting and uniform essay prompt. show their work, organize the structure of they will fit into the campus community. their response, and submit their analysis Margo Bartsch founded College Essay To continue the ability to measure a within the hour. Having solid writing skills Coach, a full-service college admission As for the subject tests, most parents did not business, and has been an adjunct professor student’s writing effectiveness, the Common have this test option when they were applying to outline top points and draw a persuasive Application (required by nearly all colleges) conclusion are all essential elements of the in business at Champlain College and at to college. The purpose of SAT-2s was to Middlebury College. New CCS FUND helps families in urgent need Jen Novak The fund can also be used to provide short- decisions. These include family-centered current circumstances of living through PRESIDENT, CCS PTO term relief from financial stress for families decision-making, a clear and urgent need, a pandemic, which has caused greater of CCS students like monthly bills, utilities and equity in the system, with families economic challenges for many, we feel The Charlotte Central School PTO, in and transportation costs. The goal is to able to access funds up to three times an this is a timely initiative. The need may be collaboration with the CCS administration, provide immediate support for families with academic year. Families can access this fund greater than ever. is pleased to announce the development an urgent need that other support services by contacting school counselor Betsy Lloyd would not be able to meet in a timely or CCS co-principals Stephanie Sumner The PTO will raise money for this fund of the CCS Family Urgent Need through fundraising efforts and community Donations. The purpose of this fund is to manner. Families in need will work with a or Jen Roth. Anyone requesting support school counselor to empower and support through this fund will be kept strictly donations. Anyone wishing to support assist families in the school community with this initiative can donate by sending support for purchasing children’s clothing, them to access sustainable community confidential and will be known only to the resources in addition to accessing this fund. members of the CCS FUND committee. cash or check to CCS PTO at P.O. Box food, school supplies, and funding for 244, Charlotte, with a notation of CCS items necessary for school participation and The CCS FUND committee, made up of We hope this will significantly benefit FUND. Donations can also easily be made school-sponsored, co-curricular activities. PTO members and school administrators, families in our community who have an by PayPal at Charlotte Central School PTO. will follow important guidelines for making immediate and urgent need. Given the

CAMP ABNAKI • Day and overnight camp options • Learn skills, build confidence, make friends — technology-free! • High staff-to-camper ratio, safety protocols in place • Archery, sailing, camp fires, more! campabnaki.org

The Y’s Community Partner 16 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News Sports Nordic and Alpine ski racers hit trails and slopes Rotary high CVU’s ski racers saw school speech only members of their own team on trails as contest they raced through the woods and down the registration open slalom courses. This wariness of clustering Staff report Edd Merritt several teams together CONTRIBUTOR was designed to limit Charlotte Shelburne Hinesburg Rotary the possibilities of will hold its annual high school speech interpersonal contact and, hence, the contest via Zoom on March 10 at 7:30 a.m. chance for corona infection. This year’s topic is “How can you and your local Rotary Clubs work together to January 27 saw Nordic racers carry improve your community and open new out a 4K Classic run at Sleepy Hollow. opportunities for you and other students?” Charlotte’s Finn Mittelstadt led the Redhawk women, finishing in second Students will deliver a five-minute speech place, less than a minute behind the relating this topic to teamwork and winner from Burlington High School. community values. The winner will receive Maddie Haydock and Ava Rohrbaugh a cash prize of $100 and the opportunity to finished among the top 32 skiers. compete at the Rotary District 7850 contest. Winners of the District level receive an Charlotte’s Matthew Servin finished sixth additional $150. among men, with his teammate George DeBosse slightly ahead of him in fifth. To register, or for more information, contact Skyler Heininger and Sam Holmes were Carrie Fenn at [email protected] or High school Nordic teams race in clusters to limit contact with students from other areas. 802-999-1024. Registrations are due by other Charlotters near the top of the Photo by Al Frey board, and Sam Haydock completed the March 3, 2021. For more information on the course in 34th place. speech contest go to rotaryclubofcsh.org. such as Nordic and Alpine skiing have The Essex Carnival allowed the Alpine been going with racers competing racers to test their slalom skills at by themselves and only others from Smuggler’s Notch the following week. their team. No general spectators were Both men’s and women’s Redhawk present. teams ranked first, ahead of second-place St. Johnsbury Academy and four other Moving to low-contact indoor sports, schools. teams will be allowed to conduct virtual meets, according to Julie Moore, chair Among the women CVU’s Olivia of the state’s task force on restarting Zubarick, Dicey Manning and Ella scholastic sports. Lisle took first, second and third places through their combined times. Kate Kogut placed ninth and Charlotte Megan Nick flips on a world- Couperthwait tenth. class stage Providing Repair, Refinishing, On the men’s side, six of the top ten CVU grad from Shelburne, Megan Nick individuals were Redhawks. Ethan Lisle recently won her first World Cup event as Megan Nick Restoration and Transport placed first, Ari Diamond third, Sean a freestyle aerialist, in Yaroslavl, Russia. Photo courtsey usskiandsnowboard.org Gilliam fifth, Will Bartley sixth, Peter Gilliam eighth, Cody Van Dine ninth and Megan graduated from CVU in 2014. Kyle Marvin tenth. While a student there, her primary sport As an aerialist she demonstrates her George & Pam Darling had been gymnastics. However, she and ability to carry out tricks while in the P.O. Box 32 Governor sets Feb. 12 as a group of gymnasts decided to attend a air, coming down the slope. It requires potential start date for winter freestyle ski aerials tryout camp in Lake body control that can only be developed Ferry Road, Charlotte, VT sports Placid, which led Megan to a national through lengthy practice. development program in Utah. Since then During a media briefing on Friday, it has been down European slopes for her. Governor Scott said that high school Her first U.S. stop is this week in Deer [email protected] and youth sports competition could Valley, Utah. start the end of this week. Snow sports The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 17 Town CVSD universal PreK Bird invasion incoming enrollment is open Staff report • The state tuition rate paid to community-based private PreK Champlain Valley School District offers providers on behalf of CVSD children publicly funded Prekindergarten for attending prekindergarten during the children between the ages of three and 2021–22 school year is $3,536. five who reside in Charlotte, Hinesburg, How do I apply? Shelburne, St. George and Williston. They are now enrolling for the 2021–22 school • If your child is going to attend a year. qualified prekindergarten program outside of the school (in the What is publicly funded community), you will have to enroll prekindergarten education? both with the community program/ Publicly funded prekindergarten is provider for your child’s place in defined as: the program and with your school district to ensure PreK funding for • Ten hours per week (for 35 weeks) your child is sent to the program. The of developmentally appropriate early full registration packet is available on learning experiences that is based on CVSD’s website at: https://sites.google. Vermont’s Early Learning Standards. com/cvsdvt.org/cvsd-early-education/ universal-preschool • Children who reside in Charlotte, Photos and caption by Hank Kaestner Hinesburg, Shelburne, St. George and • If you would like information about Williston and will be *3, 4 or 5 years PreK programs offered in a CVSD You may have seen some different birds old and not attending kindergarten school contact your local school about at your feeder recently. This year is an on or before September 1, 2021 are the lottery. invasion year for common redpolls. eligible for universal PreK funding There are five northern Canada birds from CVSD. Funding is limited to 35 If you have questions about the CVSD that, due to a shortage in food sources weeks during the academic school year registration process, contact Wendy Clark further north, will from time to time irrupt (September 2021–June 2022). at [email protected] or 985-1903. If southward and enter the United States in you have questions about publicly funded large numbers. In past winters we have *Children must be at least 3 years old Prekindergarten, contact Shelley Henson seen invasions of snowy owls (there are on or before Sept. 1, 2021 to qualify for at [email protected] or 985-1936. some in Vermont this year but not a major prekindergarten funding. invasion), bohemian waxwings, pine What should CVSD families know grosbeaks and evening grosbeaks. This about universal/publicly funded PreK? phenomenon happens every five to10 years, usually during a different year for • Whereas goldfinches, and almost all other Publicly funded PreK services can each of the species. be found in schools and qualified species of birds, are found only on one community-based programs (homes The invader this winter is the common continent or the other, redpolls are breed and centers). This link will bring you to redpoll. Large flocks were first seen just across the globe in the arctic regions of a data base of qualified PreK providers before Christmas along East Thompson’s North America, Europe and Asia. In 1852 in Vermont: https://education.vermont. Point Road, and now the redpolls are they were introduced to New Zealand and gov/documents/2020-2021-public-and- beginning to discover bird feeders (of now are a common bird there. private-prekindergarten-providers-list- course, they are not used to that food With COVID-19 keeping so many of us at and-prequalification-status. source in their native range in the tundra of home, bird feeders have become a constant Canada). This photo is of a male common source of pleasure, as we can watch from redpoll sharing the feeder with a winter- our windows as our feathered friends come plumaged American goldfinch. Redpolls for a meal. are very closely related to goldfinches. Academic achievements abound Staff report Julie Sulva has been named to the dean’s list at the University of New Hampshire in Congratulations to these high-achieving, Durham, N.H. hard-working students who had great Cooper T. Whalen, a senior at Champlain success despite the challenges of a Valley Union High School, has been named pandemic: one of more than 4,500 candidates in the Elizabeth Breen was named to fall 2020 2021 U.S. Presidential Scholars Program. dean’s list at the College of the Holy Cross The candidates were selected from nearly in Worcester, Mass. 3.6 million students expected to graduate from U.S. high schools in the year 2021. James Fox was named to the fall 2020 Inclusion in the U.S. Presidential Scholars dean’s list at Champlain College in Program is one of the highest honors Burlington. bestowed upon graduating high school Lily Menk was named to the fall 2020 seniors. Scholars are selected on the basis of dean’s list at the S.I. Newhouse School superior academic and artistic achievements, of Public Communications at Syracuse leadership qualities, strong character and University in Syracuse, N.Y. involvement in community and school activities. Lets us create your next advertisment! TheCharlotte News Contact [email protected] to advertise 18 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News Town Library news Although the ground Men’s Book Group: Cod: A Biography of but books and other materials available for is still frozen, many of the Fish That Changed the World by Mark porch pickup. us turn our thoughts Kurlansky Porch pickup hours: to spring planting and Wednesday, Feb. 17, 7:30 p.m. garden planning in Monday, Wednesday and Friday: The Cod. Wars have been fought over February. If you’re 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. it, revolutions have been triggered by looking for seeds, Tuesday and Thursday: it, national diets have been based on it, Margaret Woodruff seed catalogs or 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. economies and livelihoods have depended DIRECTOR garden know-how, Saturday: 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on it. To the millions it has sustained, it has the Charlotte Seed been a treasure more precious that gold. This Library can help! We make available small book spans 1,000 years and four continents. Please call or email to let us know what we packets (of 6-8 seeds) of selected heirloom From the Vikings to Clarence Birdseye, can set out for you! Not sure what to read? vegetable, herb and pollinator-friendly or Mark Kurlansky introduces the explorers, We’re happy to help select books for readers edible flower seeds each spring, and offer merchants, writers, chefs and fisherman, of all ages! a variety of educational programs and whose lives have been interwoven with this activities throughout the year. Our website prolific fish. He chronicles the cod wars of includes reliable references on topics such Library Contact Information the 16th and 20th centuries. He blends in as eco-friendly permaculture and garden Margaret Woodruff, Director recipes and lore from the Middle Ages to the design, composting and vermiculture, how to Cheryl Sloan, Youth Services Librarian present. In a story that brings world history save seeds, managing for pests and disease, Susanna Kahn, Tech Librarian and human passions into captivating focus, and more. Follow our blog to stay informed Phone: 802-425-3864 he shows how the most profitable fish in about current and upcoming programs. Coding Club Email: [email protected] Wednesdays, 3 p.m. history is today faced with extinction. Copies If you need to buy seeds for this year, we Get coding with Susanna and coding mentor available at the library via porch pickup. urge you to do so as soon as possible. The Charlie! All levels are welcome to learn Rokeby Museum Book Discussion: demand is higher than ever and supplies can Scratch or hone their Scratch skills. Ready Discovering Black Vermont: African Nominate your neighbor! run out quickly. We’ve placed free catalogs to take your coding know-how to the next American Farmers in Hinesburgh, from some of our favorite organic/heirloom Know someone level? We will have a breakout room with 1790–1890 by Elise Guyette seed sources in the Library’s foyer (open interesting in Charlotte? Charlie to work on different platforms. 4th Tuesday, Feb. 23, 6:30 p.m. during book pick-up hours). Help yourself. grade and up. We want to interview them If nothing else, they will inspire you with the Register here: https://rokeby.org/visit/ and share their story. possibilities! Book Chat programsevents/ Fridays, 10 a.m. Email Heirloom variety seeds offered this year Copy available at the library via porch Join Margaret for a virtual stroll through the [email protected] by the Seed Library are listed in our 2021 library collections. Focusing on a different pickup. Seed Catalog, along with tips on saving topic or theme each week, she’ll share new The seeds from them. The 2021 Catalog is titles and some old favorites. There will Library Book Discussion: The Custom of Charlotte News available right here, and paper copies are be plenty of time to share your ideas and the Country by Edith Wharton in the Library foyer. Request seeds from suggestions, too! Thursday, Feb. 25, 7:30 p.m. the Catalog by emailing us at Seed@ charlottepubliclibrary.org and we will Mystery Book Group: One of Us is Lying Considered by many to be her masterpiece, arrange contact-less pick-up in the Library Monday, Feb. 15, 10 a.m. Edith Wharton’s epic work is a scathing yet foyer. https://charlotteseedlibrary.files. The Breakfast Club meets Pretty Little personal examination of the exploits and wordpress.com/2021/02/2021-csl-catalog. Liars, One of Us Is Lying is the story of follies of the modern upper class. As she pdf what happens when five strangers walk unfolds the story of Undine Spragg, from into detention and only four walk out alive. New York to Europe, Wharton affords us Upcoming Programs at the Everyone is a suspect, and everyone has a detailed glimpse of what might be called Charlotte Library something to hide. Pay close attention and the interior décor of this America and its Please contact the library at info@ you might solve this. nouveau riche fringes. Through a heroine who is as vain, spoiled and selfish as she charlottepubliclibrary.org for the Zoom Only, Simon never makes it out of that registration links to our programs. is irresistibly fascinating, and through classroom. Before the end of detention, a most intricate and satisfying plot that Valentine Activities: Simon’s dead. And according to follows Undine’s marriages and affairs, she investigators, his death wasn’t an accident. conveys a vision of social behavior that is Bring home one of these “Take & Make” On Monday, he died. But on Tuesday, he’d kits, available in the library vestibule. both supremely informed and supremely planned to post juicy reveals about all four disenchanted. Copies available at the library Adults: indulge your craftiness with origami of his high-profile classmates, which makes via porch pickup. and cookie projects as well as tea and all four of them suspects in his murder. Or sweets. are they the perfect patsies for a killer who’s For the latest information about programs, still on the loose? Everyone has secrets, books and activity kits, sign up for our Kids: make up a heart-shaped seed bomb to right? What really matters is how far you monthly newsletter: Charlotte Library give to your favorite gardener for Valentine’s would go to protect them. Copies available Newsletter. Day. Reward yourself a cup of hot chocolate at the library via porch pickup. using the library’s cocoa recipe set. The library building is closed to the public The Charlotte News • February 11, 2021 • 19 Town Charlotte Senior Center news side, there is Chair Yoga and Gentle Yoga, followed by T’ai Chi Ch’uan for Beginners, EssentricsTM, Pilates and Pilates Plus. And, for a totally different approach to well-being that is not overtly physical, there is Mindfulness Meditation Practice with Jill Abilock on Wednesday Carolyn Kulik afternoons. SENIOR CENTER DIRECTOR Because everything is on Zoom, all Love keeps the cold out better than a courses require registration. The instructor cloak.” sends the invitation/link for each class. ~ Henry Wadsworth Longfellow For course descriptions and days/times, visit: CharlotteSeniorCenterVT.org. For “The true mystery of the world is the registration and payment information, visible, not the invisible.” please also see the end of this article. ~ Oscar Wilde Ending soon “A lot of people like snow. I find it to be an 2/24: Coping with COVID unnecessary freezing of water.” with Karen Chatfield culture and land. Included will be pictures ~ Carl Reiner Wednesday mornings, 11–12 noon. of our trek along the Annapurna Circuit For more expanded descriptions, as ______Last meeting: 2/24. as well as pictures of people and places well as additional courses and talks, Registration required by prior Monday. in Kathmandu and Bhaktapur. A virtual please visit CharlotteSeniorCenterVT. Join your peers to explore coping strategies visit to Nepal could be the antidote to any org. The mission of the Senior Center Love Carl Reiner’s work. Have my own and share methods you have used to deal winter blues. ~ Sandi was an ESL teacher is to serve those 50 and up; some thoughts about snow. For me, when it’s with life during the pandemic. This group in American International Schools in course enrollments are limited, and if a white outside—with families of icicles and is designed to provide connections and Greece, Israel, Bangladesh, Hungary and course is not full, younger participants blankets of roof snow suspended in mid- support as we navigate “the new normal” Brazil where her husband, Rick, served are welcome to enroll. Feel free to slide—it feels like something is right with together. Please note that this group is not as each school’s director. After 21 years leave a message anytime at 425-6345; the world. intended to be a substitute for therapy or abroad, they returned to Vermont in 2009. voicemail is checked frequently. ______professional mental health treatment. Winter season is winding down at CSC— No fee. 2/24: Here’s Looking at You... Louise which is not to say that there is not a Nevelson! with Linda Finkelstein 2/24: Snowshoe Expeditions How to Register for a Course lot happening—just that other than the The art and amazing life of Louise with Susan Hyde All courses are online—and all require Wednesday talks at 1 p.m., there are no Nevelson will be featured in this engaging Wednesday morning at 11. registration in order to receive the invitation/ new courses that start in February. hour. Learn how a little girl who fled the Last outing on 2/24. Ukraine with her family to Rockland, link. The insert for the Spring Schedule For more information, please email Susan Maine, became the most celebrated and To register, send your name, mailing covering March through May will be in directly at: [email protected]. influential American female sculptor of address and phone number to: CSCZoom@ the 2/25 issue here, and it will be posted No fee. the 20th century—best known for her gmavt.net. Be sure to note the title of the on the website. Registration for new ______monumental, monochromatic, wooden course in the subject line of the email. courses and activities will begin 3/1 online wall assemblages and outdoor sculptures. You will receive confirmation that you are at [email protected]. Please follow registered. Please send a separate email and Talks on Wednesdays at 1 p.m. This experience will be a feast for your directions at the end of this column. registration information for each course. These free, interactive events are online via eyes and spirit at the end of the winter. ~ Linda Finkelstein is a mixed media artist Zoom. • Payment – If there is a fee, kindly pay by Ongoing exercise courses Please note that they do not require and former art teacher, with degrees in art ‘Ongoing’ means continuing throughout history and art education. check (made out to CSC) and send to: P.O. registration. The Zoom invitation/link to Box 207, Charlotte, VT 05445. Be sure to the year, with no end point. Join any week, the talks are posted on the website the day ______and continue as long as you wish; pay at note the title of the course in the memo line. before: CharlotteSeniorCenterVT.org. The • For ongoing exercise courses, please pay the end of the month for the classes you link also appears in Front Porch Forum for attended. Art exhibits at the end of each month for the classes that week. The Senior Center’s monthly art exhibits attended. Unless otherwise stated, tally your You are probably aware that not all are suspended until further notice. attendance and figure $5/class. 2/17: Nepal: Through the Eyes of An If fees present a hardship, don’t hesitate exercise is equal, but did you realize that American with Sandi Detwiler we have courses that cover the complete Keep being careful. Don’t let up. The end to request an adjustment by sending an Nepal, home to Mt. Everest, is a is in sight. email to [email protected]. We want range? There are those that have high geographically diverse and a multiethnic intensity, challenging workouts to the more ______everyone to be able to keep themselves country situated between India to the healthy and engaged, especially during this mellow sort of stretching—and everything south and China to the north. This talk in between. Starting on the lower intensity “There comes a time when the world gets challenging time. will present the beauty of its people, quiet and the only thing left is your own heart. So, you’d better learn the sound of Questions? Need help with Zooming? it. Otherwise, you’ll never understand what Please email: [email protected], or it’s saying.” leave a message at (802) 425-6345. ~ Sarah Dessen, Just Listen ______Charlotte Senior Center 802-425-6345 CharlotteSeniorCenterVT.org 20 • February 11, 2021 • The Charlotte News

AMENDMENTS Last week, the Selectboard voted 4-1 to put continued from page 1 these articles forward to voters on the ballot. Classifieds They did not vote in favor of or against the districts in town, some are concerned that articles or amendments themselves. Two approving these changes for only part of Selectboard members, Carrie Spear and Reach your friends and neighbors for only $12 per issue. (Payment must be sent before town, and for only a handful of property Frank Tenney, own property that is currently issue date.) Please limit your ad to 35 words or fewer and send it to The Charlotte News owners, is the very definition of spot zoning. included in the ECVCD. Spear owns a store Classifieds, P.O. Box 251, Charlotte, VT 05445 or email [email protected]. How could it not be considered spot in the East Village; Tenney’s brother owns zoning? a store in the East Village. Neither recused THE CHARLOTTE NEWS: FOR THE beautiful new look. Our painters can themselves from the vote, giving the reason PEOPLE, BY THE PEOPLE do a lot in a day. LafayettePaintingInc. The history of the intersection where the that they don’t believe they stand to gain In addition to our professional staff of com or call 863-5397 to hear about our changes will take place, which is known anything from sending the issue to the three, as many as 170 people provide winter discount. as Baptist Corners, is varied and extends voters, and that they don’t think they would back for generations. Zoning has changed stories, photos and commentaries to benefit financially or personally should The Charlotte News each year. MT. PHILO INN - A unique hotel with in this area multiple times, and some say the amendments pass; these decisions are that excluding just this one particular corner Join us! Send your story ideas, panoramic views of Lake Champlain generally left to the individuals potentially commentaries and great photos of and private road to Mt. Philo. from the commercial district goes against the conflicted. Some believe that it’s inevitable Charlotte to [email protected] 1800 sq. ft., 3-bedroom suites with 2 history of the area, and that including it would that property or store owners in the village set the situation back to where it once was commercial district, or their families, Let your voice be heard. bathrooms and a complete kitchen. previously. would eventually benefit financially from By the day, week and month.Privacy, What exactly did the Selectboard vote increased density. Others think they should Need a fresh start to 2021? Let space, tranquility. Bigger on the on last week and was there a conflict of have recused themselves to avoid even the Lafayette Painting give your home a inside. MtPhiloInn.com, 425-3335. interest for any members? appearance of impropriety. Charlotte Fire and Rescue Log January 2021

Monday, Jan. 4 Saturday, Jan. 9 Thursday, Jan. 14 Friday, Jan. 22 21:10:00 Intercept 16:34:00 Canceled (Transferred to 22:07:00 Standby—Public Safety, 15:43:45 Patient Treated, 16:13:10 Patient Treated, Mutual Aid) Fire, or EMS Operational Support Transported by this EMS Unit Friday, Jan. 1 Transported by this EMS Unit 15:39:00 Patient Treated, Provided Saturday, Jan. 23 2:25:00 Patient Treated, Transported by this EMS Unit 15:39:00 Patient Evaluated, No Tuesday, Jan. 5 12:42:00 Patient Treated, Transported by this EMS Unit 13:51:00 Patient Treated, Treatment/Transport Required 17:06:00 Patient Treated, Transported by this EMS Unit Transported by this EMS Unit Transported by this EMS Unit Friday, Jan. 15 Saturday, Jan. 2 7:43:00 Standby—Public Safety, 11:10:00 Standby—Public Safety, 19:51:00 Intercept 13:34:00 Patient Treated, 10:02:00 Intercept Fire, or EMS Operational Support Transported by this EMS Unit Fire, or EMS Operational Support 1:17:00 Patient Dead at Scene—No 16:24:00 Patient Treated, Provided Provided Transported by this EMS Unit 7:24:00 Patient Treated, Transported Resuscitation Attempted (Without 7:00:00 Patient Evaluated, No 8:54:14 Patient Dead at Scene— by this EMS Unit Monday, Jan. 11 Transport) Treatment/Transport Required No Resuscitation Attempted (Without 01:29:00 Standby—No Services or 18:23:00 Patient Treated, Saturday, Jan. 16 Transport) Support Provided Transported by this EMS Unit 8:08:00 Canceled on Scene (No Wednesday, Jan. 27 8:48:00 Patient Treated, Wednesday, Jan. 6 8:08:00 Patient Treated, Patient Contact) 12:17:08 Patient Treated, Transported by this EMS Unit 16:00:00 Patient Treated, Transported by this EMS Unit Transported by this EMS Unit Sunday, Jan. 3 Transported by this EMS Unit Tuesday, Jan. 12 Sunday, Jan. 17 Saturday, Jan. 30 21:38:00 Patient Treated, 22:38:00 Standby—No Services or 14:34:00 Canceled (Prior to Arrival 11:38:00 Patient Treated, 11:01:00 Patient Treated, Transported by this EMS Unit Support Provided At Scene) Transported by this EMS Unit Transported by this EMS Unit 18:14:00 Canceled on Scene (No Thursday, Jan. 7 10:31:00 Patient Treated, Transferred Monday, Jan. 18 Care to Another EMS Unit Sunday, Jan. 31 Patient Contact) 12:35:00 Canceled (Prior to Arrival 11:06:33 Patient Treated, 8:24:00 Canceled on Scene (No 14:44:00 Canceled (Prior to Arrival At Scene) Wednesday, Jan. 13 Transported by this EMS Unit Patient Contact) At Scene) 9:33:00 Standby—Public Safety, Patient Evaluated, No Treatment/ Fire, or EMS Operational Support Transport Required Provided

Business Directory To advertise your business contact [email protected]

www.DeePT.com 23 San Remo Drive SOUTH BURLINGTON | 865.0010 166 Athletic Drive SHELBURNE | 985.4445 52 Farmall Drive feel good again!■ HINESBURG | 482.3333

I I

• I

■-

- LETTERS Your nonprofit community news source since 1958 continued from page 6 home be built without a thorough that new middle-income families are Vote yes on amendment and and complete review, including water just not able to make it work. The Town Plan articles supply, wastewater, traffic safety etc., etc. Some of you know this very well, Many of you know that I have focused Dear Charlotte friends and neighbors, while others possibly do not know since my historic community service time you may be newer residents. on land conservation, and with great Charlotte News I am calling with a sense of urgency success, largely because Charlotte is Thursday, February 11, 2021 | Volume LXIII Number 16 to ask that you please become well In this new round of plan and blessed with abundant and fabulous informed about the town plan and regulation updates for the East Village, nature to nurture. And largely because regulation articles coming up for vote the proposed village-related articles our town has a generous desire to give this year at town meeting. I am reaching are simply proposing potential to allow money to protect our natural assets. out to friends and neighbors right now for a modest amount of new homes This richness is only a problem if we to say: VOTE YES in support of the to be built on one-acre lots (vs less do not provide for an economically and proposed articles on Town Meeting affordable five-acre lots) in the village socio-diverse community. For the sake Day. commercial district only. Our regs of community health and justice, we all To my recent surprise and great already provide for far smaller lot must make this happen with purpose. It disappointment, I am hearing faulty size potential for elderly and affordable will not happen by itself. This is a very messaging sweeping about, almost homes in the entire larger village important fact to know. district. We do not provide for smaller reminding me of Washington, D.C. This So please read the Town Plan and the is so, so discouraging. one acre lots for middle income homes. So, to be very conservative, we are only regs online. They are our two bibles Please be sure you know what we proposing these one-acre lots in the and we must all treat them as such, and are proposing, and please do not, smaller east village commercial district be in this together. The PC depends carte blanche, believe what a few are only. That’s it. upon well informed residents. We love saying…that the PC is proposing more our time as community volunteers, but development in the village without My biggest interest as a PC member we can’t do this without you. today is to make sure my town has having done our homework…this could Charlotte is at a crossroad, and I sure not be further from the truth. decent affordable places for middle income folks to reside in Charlotte do hope our little town can be united in The truth is that Charlotte has very and go to CCS. As a middle incomer our vision. detailed and robust regs today (over myself, I know well that home prices Marty Illick 100 pages), and would never let any have escalated so much since the 1980s, Planning Commission

Winter wonderland

View from Charlotte Park. presorted Photo by Frances Foster U.S. POSTAGE PAID ZIP CODE 05482 MAILED FROM PERMIT NO. 9

Frost among the trees along Greenbush Road.

Photo by Lee Krohn standard Tom Cosinuke and Annie Kelton are the proud owners of a newly appointed champion apple tree. Photo by Vince Crockenberg READ MORE ON PAGE 8