Index to Single Letters of Ivo of Chartres

Home , Burchard of Worms, Fulbert of Chartres, Ivo of Chartres

Cambridge University Press 978-0-521-76682-1 - Canon Law and the Letters of Ivo of Chartres Christof Rolker Index More information

INDEX TO SINGLE LETTERS OF IVO OF CHARTRES

The numbers are those of Juret’s second edition as reprinted by Migne. ‘Add. III’ refers to the third addition found in Migne’s edition. For all letters marked by an askerisk (*), and also for letters not listed in this index, see Appendix.

ep. 1 (= Urban II, JL 5438): 135n41, 140n74 ep. 49 241n177 ep. 8* 15n64, 158n155 ep. 50 200–1, 232n118, 240n174 canon law in 131, 132, 157 ep. 52* 207n220 earliest datable use of Tripartita A 73–4, ep. 54 238n161 135 ep. 55* 152–3 editions and manuscripts of 131n25 ep. 56 236n145, 240n171 ep. 12 15n64, 197n156, 197n158 ep. 57* 168n20, 179n62, 236n146 ep. 13 222n103, 231n109, 232n114, 234n133 ep. 58* 201n181 ep. 14 231n104 ep. 59* 19n82, 199n168, 201n182, 201n183, ep. 15 231n109, 232n118, 234n134 239n166 ep. 16* 138n58, 140–1, 221, 301–2 ep. 60* 2, 133n30, 138n58, 151n125, 202–3, date of 235 276 canon law in 131, 140, 141 canon law in 99n68, 131, 147, 153, 160n165, edition and manuscripts of 131n25 168n18, 272 on concubinage 168, 217n33, 218 editions and manuscripts of 130n20, on ‘mercy and justice’ 170n30 131n25 ep. 17 9n35–6, 9n40, 15n67, 136n44 known widely in Ivo’s lifetime ep. 18 136n44, 218n40, 236n146 2, 129n11, 276 ep. 19 16n73, 207n220 on investiture 189–90, 201–3 ep. 20 16n71 see also Daimbert of Sens; Hugo of Lyon ep. 22 15n66, 231n109, 240n174 ep. 61* 198n162, 239n166, 241n177 ep. 23 231n109, 232n118, 236n146 ep. 62* 19n84, 159n164, 239n166 ep.24 231n109, 232n118 ep. 63* 157n150, 186n99, 272n117 ep. 27* 141–4 ep. 64 19n84 canon law in 131, 136, 141–4, 158 ep. 65* 16n75, 147, 204n200 editions and manuscripts of 131n25, 141n82 ep. 66 232n118 ep. 28 16n74, 232n118, 236n145, 237n155 ep. 67* 168n20, 201n185, 228n94 ep. 35* 136–7, 232n119, 240n174 ep. 68* 232n118 canon law in 144 ep. 69* 129n11, 187n103, 207n221 ep. 36* 206n211 ep. 71* 130n16, 138n58, 160n165 canon law in 131, 136, 144, 146n107, 205n202 ep. 72* 152 editions and manuscripts of 131n25, ep. 73* 138n58, 150n121, 186n100, 188n107, 207n217 189n110, 193n128, 272n117 ep. 41* 144, 186n100, 186n102, 188n105, ep. 74* 133, 227n88 205n202, 207n222 ep. 77* 197n77, 198n159 ep. 43 238n161 ep. 78 188n107, 207n220 ep. 46 238n158–9, 239n162 ep. 80* 152, 186n102 date of, threat of French schism 238n158 ep. 83* 147, 199n167 ep. 47* 232n118, 236n146, 240n171 ep. 87 199n166, 242n188

373

Index to single letters of Ivo of Chartres

ep. 88 189n109 on marriage and concubinage 216–17, 219, ep. 91 241n177 219n45 ep. 95* 194, 198n162, 286n194 on ‘mercy and justice’ 217n36, 219n45 ep. 96 192n125 ep. 189* 129n15, 197n152 ep. 98 9n40 canon law and historical material quoted in ep. 99* 138n58, 151n125, 315n35 131, 154–7, 197n155 canon law in 131, 146, 146n108, 149, 151, edition and manuscripts of 131n25, 156n145 160n165 ep. 190 100n71 Roman law in 215n21 ep. 191* 157n150 editions and manuscripts of 131n25 ep. 192* 137n55, 138n58, 157n150 ep. 102 9n40 ep. 193 205n207, 241n184 ep. 104 9n40, 236n146 ep. 195 192n126 ep. 105* 131, 146n105, 316n38 ep. 204* 154, 154n132 canon law in 131, 137n54, 149–50, ep. 205* 147, 192n120, 192n124, 227n89, 160n165 227n90 editions and manuscripts of 131n25, ep. 211 220n49, 222n56, 235n140 150n120 ep. 212* 154, 154n132, 226n83 ep. 108* 186n100, 187n104, 205n202 ep. 213* 187n103, 207n221 ep. 109 199n170 ep. 214 168n20, 170n30 ep. 116 241n177 ep. 216 206n213 ep. 119* 158n158 ep. 220* 158n158 ep. 121 240n176 ep. 221* 217n31, 224–6 ep. 122* 151n125, 227n93 ep. 222* 131, 227n86 ep. 123* 138n58, 216n28, 216n30 canon law in 131, 228n94 ep. 125* 138n58, 151, 151n124, 151n125, editions and manuscripts of 131n25, 217n36 160n165, 227n86, 227n92 on ‘mercy and justice’ 170n30, 217n36, ep. 133* 137n55, 168n20 228n94–5 ep. 134* 138n58, 147, 211n1, 215n21 ep. 225* 227n91 ep. 135 179n62 ep. 228* 192n120, 192n124 ep. 140 168n20, 198n164 ep. 229* 157n150, 227n89, 227n91 ep. 141 234n134, 236n145 ep. 230* 220n46, 222n230, 230n107 ep. 144* 231n109, 236n145, 242n185 ep. 231* 170n30, 184n83 ep. 146 242n189 ep. 232* 221n56, 227n89 ep. 148* 127n3, 138n58, 145n102, 151, 151n124, ep. 234* 147, 170n30, 188n107 219n42, 320n46 ep. 235 188n107 ep. 151 205n204 ep. 236* 20n87, 190n113, 194n139, 203n194 ep. 155* 138n58, 146n105 ep. 237 20n87, 203n196, 204n197 canon law in 131, 147, 151, 151n124, 160n165 ep. 238 230n104 editions and manuscripts of 131n25 ep. 241* 158n158 on marriage 216–17 ep. 242* 147, 160n165, 185n92, 224–6 ep. 156* 137n55, 157n150, 191n119 ep. 243* 147, 215n21 ep. 158 220n49, 242n191 ep. 246* 146, 151, 151n124, 216n28 ep. 166 172n36, 213n11, 215n20, 230n108 ep. 247* 227n88 ep. 167* 145n102, 147, 214n12, 214n14, ep. 249* 157n150, 227n89 215n20 ep. 251* 184n83 ep. 170 217n35, 218n39 ep. 252* 147, 192n124, 227n90 ep. 171* 159n164, 170n29, 192n123 ep. 255* 147–8, 184n88, 186n102 ep. 176* 147 canon law and theological content 131 ep. 183* 147, 215n20 date of 147–8 ep. 184* 157n150, 197n152 editions and manuscripts of 131n25, 148n113 ep. 186* 137n55, 157n150, 164n5, 186n101 on Extreme Unction 184–5 ep. 187 242n193 relation to Triparita B 147, 161 ep. 188* 131, 138n58 ep. 258 168n20, 172n36 canon law in 131, 147, 160n165 ep. 259* 172n36, 197n155 edition and manuscripts of 131n25 ep. 261 261n49

374

Index to single letters of Ivo of Chartres

ep. 262 26n103, 180n66 on the Eucharist 182–4 ep. 266 206n213 source of Ivo’s Decretum 108, 119, 139–40, ep. 274 172n36 254–5, 271–2 ep. 280* 147, 172n36, 227n88 see also epp. 231 and 251 ep. 287* 9, 91, 139–40, 151n125, ep. Add. III* 147–8, 184n88 271–2 manuscripts and editions of canon law and theological content 131, 135, 147n11, 184n88 139–40, 182–4, 271–2 see also ep. 255, which is almost identical to editions and manuscripts of 131n25 Add. III

375

MANUSCRIPT INDEX

For manuscripts referred to by sigla in the text or the footnotes, these sigla are repeated here. In the case of the Ivonian collections, these are the sigla used by Martin Brett in his editions.

Admont, Stiftsbibliothek 162 (Tripartita, ms D) Cambridge, University Library Ff.iv.41 101n79 (Panormia) 117n172 Alençon, BM 135 (Tripartita, ms A) 101n80, Celle, Oberlandesgericht C.8 83n199 113n146, 137n54, 142 Châlons-en-Champagne, BM 47 120n194 Angers, BM 368 (Burchard’s Decretum) 68n107 Châlons-en-Champagne, BM 75 30n118 Antwerp, Museum Plantin-Moretus M.82 Chartres, BM 26 55n22, 92n23 (‘TC’ group) 119n187, 120n193, 158n155, Chartres, BM 50 92n24 158n156, 263n70 Chartres, BM 65 92n26 Chartres, BM 124 58n45, 92n25 Bamberg, Staatsbibliothek Can. 6 (Burchard’s Chartres, BM 161 (Burchard’s Decretum) Decretum) 110n132, 112n144 69n108, 110n127 Bergamo, Biblioteca Civica 224, 83n196 Chartres, BM 193, 57n39, 92n26, 116n165, Berkeley, University of California, Law Library, 118n172, 120n188 Robbins 102 (Tripartita, ms K) 101n79 Chartres, BM 234 (no copy of Burchard’s Berlin, SBPK Hamilton 345 (Tripartita, ms H) Decretum) 110n127 30n122, 101n80, 137n54, 142 Chartres, BM 376 55n22, 92n23 Berlin, SBPK lat. fol. 197 (Tripartita, ms S) Chartres, BM ‘534’ 110n127 30n120, 37n161, 101n79, 102n85, Copenhagen, Thott in 4° 555 (Tripartita, ms T) 267n87 101n80, 137n54 Berlin, SBPK Phil. 1694 (Ivo’s letters, ms Bb) 131n25, 150n120 Durham, CL B.IV.17 (Burchard’s Decretum) Berlin, SBPK Phil. 1778 75n150, 131n25 110n132, 111n136, 112n143 Berlin, SBPK Savigny 3 73n133, 74n135 Bern, Burgerbibliothek 314 75, 76n156 Florence, Biblioteca Medicea Laurenziana Bologna, Biblioteca Universitaria 2239 Calci 11 (Burchard’s Decretum) 62n70 (Burchard’s Decretum) 62n70, 111n137 Florence, BNC Conv. sopp. D.2.1476 30n116 Bordeaux, BM 11 78n167, 78n170 Florence, BNC Conv. sopp. F.4.255 (Burchard’s Budapest, Bib. Széchényiana 5 57n41 Decretum) 62n70, 111n139 Freiburg, Universitätsbibliothek cod.7 Cambridge, Corpus Christi 19 (Ivo’s Decretum, (Burchard’s Decretum) 63n72 ms C) 28n113, 130n16, 139n66, 259–64 Cambridge, Corpus Christi 299 (Ivo’s letters, Ghent, UB 23, 72n127 ms Cc) 131n25 Gniezno, Bib. Kapitulna ms 25 (Tripartita, ms Cambridge, Corpus Christi 442 70, 70n117, 71, N) 101n79 129n14 s’Gravenhage, Koninklijke Bibliotheek 72.J.10k Cambridge, Gonville and Caius 455 (393) 83n199 (Tripartita, ms S) 101n80 Cambridge, Jesus College Q G 5 (Ivo’s letters, Heiligenkreuz, Stiftsbibliothek 188 (Ivo’s letters, ms Cd) 131n25, 141n81, 268 ms Hb) 128n9

376

Manuscript index

Heiligenkreuz, Stiftsbibliothek 236 214n18 Orléans, BM 229 (Burchard’s Decretum) 69n108 Hereford, Cathedral Library O.2.VII 75 Oxford, Bodleian, Bodley 407 (Ivo’s sermons with his Prologus) 266n84, 267n86 Krakow, Arch. Kapituly Katedralnej 84 Oxford, Bodleian, Bodley 561 30n119, 101, (Tripartita, ms K) 101n79 267n85 Oxford, Bodleian, D’Orville 46 Leiden, BPL 184.1 (abbreviation of Ivo’s (Tripartita, ms O) 101n80 Decretum) 263 Oxford, Bodleian, Laud misc. 226 (Ivo’s letters, Leipzig, UB 955.9 (abbreviation of Ivo’s ms Od) 131n25 Decretum) 144n101, 263–4, 264n71 Liège, UB 230 (Ivo’s Prologus) 267n90, 275n132 Palermo, Archivio della Cattedrale 14 Lincoln, Cathedral Library 193 (abbreviation of (‘TC’ group) 58, 118n175, 121n194, 158n155 Ivo’s Decretum) 263, 277n143 Paris, Arsenal 678 (Burchard’s Decretum) 62n70, Linz, Studienbibliothek 295 (Ivo’s letters, ms 62n68, 68n107, 112n142 Lf) 128 Paris, Arsenal 713 (Arsenal collections) 94, 107, London, BL Add. 8873 (Collectio Britannica) 92, 117, 122n200, 124, 288 94–100, 153, 155–7, 156n144 Paris, Arsenal 721 80n178, 144n99, 277n143 date of 157 Paris, Bibliothèque Mazarine 2010 (Ivo’s letters, London, BL Add. 18333 (Ivo’s letters, ms Lj) ms Pa) 131n25, 131n26, 150n120 131n25, 141n81 Paris, BN lat. 2481 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pb) 129n13, London, BL Cotton Cleopatra C.VIII 104n94, 131n25, 148n113, 150n120 195n143 Paris, BN lat. 2483 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pc) 131n25, London, BL Harley 3021 (abbreviation of Ivo’s 150n120 Decretum) 129n14, 144n101, 263–4, 264n71 Paris, BN lat. 2484 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pd) 131n25, London, BL Royal 6.B.vi (Ivo’s letters, 150n120 ms Ln) 128, 131n25, 141n81 Paris, BN lat. 2485 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pe) 129n13, London, BL Royal 11.D.vii (Ivo’s Decretum 131n25, 150n120 ms R) 259–64 Paris, BN lat. 2486 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pf) 129n13, 131n25, 150n120 Milan, Ambrosiana D.59 supr. 85n211 Paris, BN lat. 2487 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pg) 129n13, Milan, Ambrosiana E.144 supr. (Burchard’s 131n25 Decretum) 62n67 Paris, BN lat. 2488 (Ivo’s letters, ms Ph) 131n25, Milan, Trivulziana 601 (Burchard’s Decretum) 150n120 111n138 Paris, BN lat. 2489 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pj) 131n25, Modena, Biblioteca del Duomo O.II.15 150n120 (Burchard’s Decretum) 62n70 Paris, BN lat. 2490 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pk) 131n25, Montpellier, BIU section de méd. H.137 57n40, 150n120 58n43, 76 Paris, BN lat. 2887 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pl) 131n25, Montpellier, BM 7 (Burchard’s Decretum) 150n120 68n106, 112n142 Paris, BN lat. 2887A (Ivo’s letters, ms Pm) Montpellier, BM 231 (Ivo’s letters, ms Mb) 129n13, 131n25, 150n120, 207n217 131n25 Paris, BN lat. 2889 (Ivo’s letters, ms Po) 131n25 Montpellier, BM 542 (Ivo’s letters, ms Md) Paris, BN lat. 2890 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pp) 131n25, 131n25 150n120 Munich, BSB clm 12603 (Tripartita, ms M) Paris, BN lat. 2891 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pq) 131n25, 101n79 150n120 Munich, BSB clm 22291 (Ivo’s letters, ms Mj) Paris, BN lat. 2892 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pr) 129n14, 128, 131n25, 150n120 131n25, 150n120, 207n217 Munich, BSB clm 7608 (Panormia) 266n84 Paris, BN lat. 2892A (Ivo’s letters, ms Ps) 131n25, 150n120 Namur, Bibliothèque de la Ville 91(Ivo’s letters, Paris, BN lat. 2893 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pt) ms Na) 129n14 131n25, 150n120 Paris, BN lat. 2894 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pu) 131n25, Olomouc, Statni Archiv CO 205 150n120 (Tripartita, ms L) 101n79 Paris, BN lat. 3348 (Panormia) 280n166

377

Manuscript index

Paris, BN lat. 3858 (Tripartita, ms Z) 101n80, Paris, BN lat. 16713 (Ivo’s letters, ms Qg) 137n54, 142 131n25, 148n113, 150n120 Paris, BN lat. 3858A (Tripartita, ms B) 101n79, Paris, BN lat. 18219 (Ivo’s letters, ms Qh) 316n38 131n25 Paris, BN lat. 3858B (Tripartita, ms C) 101n79 Paris, BN lat. 18586 (Ivo’s letters, ms Qk) Paris, BN lat. 3860 (Burchard’s Decretum) 131n25 68n107, 69n108, 110n132, 112n142 Paris, BN nouv. acq. lat. 3041 (Ivo’s letters, Paris, BN lat. 3862 (Burchard’s Decretum) 62n68, ms Ql) 131n25 68n106 Paris, Ste Geneviève 166 80n178 Paris, BN lat. 3865 (Panormia) 117n172, 267n86 Parma, Palatina 3777 (Burchard’s Decretum) Paris, BN lat. 3867 (Panormia) 280n166 112n142 Paris, BN lat. 3869 (Panormia) 267n86, 280n166 Paris, BN lat. 3874 (Ivo’s Decretum, ms B) Reims, BM 134 (abbreviation of Burchard’s 113n48, 252n12, 259–62 Decretum) 70n113 Paris, BN lat. 3876 158n157 Reims, BM 673 (Burchard’s Decretum) 69n108, Paris, BN lat. 4221 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pw) 131n25, 69n109, 112n142, 112n143 150n120 Reims, BM 674 (Burchard’s Decretum) 69n108, Paris, BN lat. 4282 (Tripartita, ms Q) 101n80, 112n142, 112n143 137n54, 142 Reims, BM 675 75n150, 77n161 Paris, BN lat. 4283 (Burchard fragment) 80n178 Rome, Lincei 41.E.1 (abbreviation of Ivo’s Paris, BN lat. 4376 83n199 Decretum) 144n101, 263–4 Paris, BN lat. 5505 (Ivo’s letters, ms Py) 131n25 Rouen, BM 704 (abbreviation of Burchard’s Paris, BN lat. 5517 85n211, 120n191 Decretum) 80n178 Paris, BN lat. 9630 (Burchard’s Decretum) 62n68, 68n106 Salzburg, St. Peter a.VIII.15 (Panormia) 267n86 Paris, BN lat. 10341 (Ivo’s letters, ms Pz) Siguenza, Bib. cap. 61 (Ivo’s Decretum, ms S) 131n25, 148n113, 207n217 259–60, 316n38 Paris, BN lat. 12317 40n177, 256n37 St Gallen, Stiftbibliothek ms 620 (Ivo’s Prologus) Paris, BN lat. 12318 256n37 266n84 Paris, BN lat. 12449 (Burchard’s Decretum) St Omer, BM 194 (Burchard’s Decretum) 112n142 69n108, 110n132, 111n136, 112n142, Paris, BN lat. 12711 (Continuatio Aimonis) 112n143 155n140, 156n144, 156n146 St Petersburg, Ermitage lat. 25 (Panormia) Paris, BN lat. 13368 (‘TC’) 73, 116, 158n155, 267n86 158n157 Stuttgart, WLB, Cod. hist. fol. 419 158n155 see also General index canonical collections TC Stuttgart, WLB, Cod. iur. quarto 146 (Panormia) Paris, BN lat. 13413 (‘TC’ group) 158n155, 266n84 158n156 Paris, BN lat. 13656 (Tripartita, ms J) 101n80, Tarragona, Biblioteca Provincial 26 85n211 105n103, 137n54 Trier, Stadtbibliothek 910 (Panormia) 117n172 Paris, BN lat. 14135 (Panormia) 32n132 Troyes, BM 1386 (Burchard fragment) Paris, BN lat. 14145 30n116, 73n132, 267n85, 80n178 277n147 Turin, BNU D.IV.33 74n135 Paris, BN lat. 14146 (Ivo’s letters, ms Qb) 129n113 Paris, BN lat. 14193 (‘TC’ group) 129n13, Vatican City, BAV, Barberini lat. 535 65n92 158n155, 158n156 Vatican City, BAV lat. 1351 281n174 Paris, BN lat. 14315 (Ivo’s Decretum, ms P) Vatican City, BAV lat. 1355 (Burchard’s 130n16, 259–64, 260n53 Decretum) 112n141 Paris, BN lat. 14809 (abbreviation of Ivo’s Vatican City, BAV lat. 1357 (Ivo’s Decretum ms Decretum) 263n70 V) 130n16, 174n45, 259–64, 260n53 Paris, BN lat. 14994 (Panormia) 32n132, 36n152 Vatican City, BAV lat. 3809 (Burchard’s Paris, BN lat. 15165 (Ivo’s letters, ms Qd) Decretum) 111n136 131n25, 132n26, 141n81, 148n113, 150n120 Vatican City, BAV Ottobon. lat. 93 55, 58 Paris, BN lat. 16250 (Ivo’s letters, ms Qe) Vatican City, BAV Pal. lat. 585/586 (Burchard’s 131n25, 148n81, 150n120, 203n194 Decretum) 110, 110n133, 112n143

378

Manuscript index

Vatican City, BAV Pal. lat. 587 (Ivo’s Decretum, Vienna, ÖNB 806 (Ivo’s letters, ms Wc) 131n25 ms D) 117n172, 259–64 Vienna, ÖNB 2192 (Panormia) 273n120 Vatican City, BAV Reg. lat. 79 (Ivo’s letters, Vienna, ÖNB 2196 (abbreviation of Ivo’s ms Vl) 131n25, 150n120 Decretum) 144n101, 263, 264n71 Vatican City, BAV Reg. lat. 147 (Ivo’s letters, Vienna, ÖNB 2229 (Ivo’s letters, ms Wd) ms Vm) 131n25, 141n81, 150n120 131n25 Vatican City, BAV Reg. lat. 973 (Tripartita, ms R) 101n79 Wolfenbüttel, HAB, Gud. lat. 212 72n127, Vatican City, BAV Reg. lat. 979 (Burchard’s 72n129 Decretum) 69n108, 111n136, 112n142–3 Wolfenbüttel, HAB, Helmst. 180 Vatican City, S. Petri G.19 (Panormia) 267n86 (Tripartita, ms W) 101n79 Vendôme, BM 160 (Panormia) 267n86, 274n124 Vienna, ÖNB 533 (Ivo’s letters, ms Wa ) 131n25, Zurich, Zentralbibliothek Car. C 42 (Tripartita, 150n120 ms X) 101n79, 102n85

379

GENERAL INDEX

Entries in bold refer to passages where the subject is discussed more thoroughly.

Abbo of Fleury 50 Baluze, Étienne 35–7 Abelard 292, 294–5, 296 Beauvais his Sic et non 43, 167, 280, 295 disputed episcopal election at 241–2 other works 280, 281n176 see also Galo of Paris; Guy of Beauvais; Adela of Blois 10–11, 15, 16, 239n165, 241 St Quentin see also Blois-Chartres, counts of Bec Abbey Agustín, Antonio 32–7 having three copies of Ivo’s letter collection Alexander II, pope, in canon law 76, 105–6, 128 113–14, 153 Ivo said to have studied at 90–1 see also Decretals see also Lanfranc of Bec Alger of Liège, knowledge of Ivonian Benedicti Regula 91, 114, 169–70, 206n211 collections 43, 274–6, 277–8 Benedictus Levita see capitularies/capitulary Ambrose, St, 143, 148, 157, 271–2 canons Anjou, counts of 13 Berengar of Tours 24, 79, 140, 182–4, 300 see also Fulk of Anjou Bernard of Clairvaux 73n132, 277n146, 282 Ansegisus see capitularies/capitulary canons his letter collection 127 Anselm of Canterbury 152n127, 247n199 Bernold of Constance, and his canonical works his letter collection 4 45, 52, 64, 95, 171n35 Anselm of Laon 215 Bertha of Holland 231, 234–5, 243–5 Sententiae Anselmi 229n100 Bertrada of Montfort 15–16, 222n56, 231, Anselm of Lucca and his Collectio canonum 64, 234n133 65, 67, 87, 158n154, 281 Ivo on 232n118 and penance 66n98 recognised as queen 243 reception of 65–6, 87, 295 see also Philip I, marriage affair of Atto of San Marco and his Breviarum 64, 67, 87 Blois-Chartres, counts of 10–11, 13, 22, 207, Augustine, St 233, 240 as quoted by Berengar and Lanfranc 139, see also Adela of Blois 182–4 Bohemund of Antioch 16, 242 in Alger of Liège’s De sacramentis 277–8 Boniface, St, in canon law 93, 143, 196 in Ivo’s Decretum 119, 120, 139, 171, 174, Bonizo of Sutri and his Liber de vita christiana 180–1, 251, 255, 269n103, 271 51, 64, 67, 177–8, 180, 208, 225n76 in Ivo’s letters 139, 144, 147, 154, 192, 315n35 Bonneval, abbey of (diocese of Chartres) 12 in Ivo’s Prologus 96, 121–3, 165, 269n103, Boulogne, counts of 6 315n35 see also Geoffrey I of Chartres; Geoffrey of in Ivo’s sermons 180–1, 191 Boulogne in Panormia 251, 255, 271, 315n35 Brant, Sebastian 31–4 in TC and related canonical collections 120, Burchard of Worms, Decretum 50–1, 60–71, 216 154, 158n157 book 19 (penitential book) 65, 78, 79, 88, 258 in Tripartita 154, 315n35 book 20 (theology) 77, 79, 252 on marriage 185, 228 in Ivo’s Decretum 109–12, 258

380

General index

in Ivo’s letter collection 140–1, 152, 252 Collectio Tarraconensis see Liber Tarraconensis in the Panormia 124, 251–2 Collectio Vetus Gallica 51 marriage legislation in 79, 216, 223n67, 224, Collection de Sainte-Geneviève 43 229 Collection de Thérouanne see Collection in nine reception among the ‘Gregorians’ 45, 63–8 books (9L/9V) see also Manuscript index Collection in 342 chapters 76 Collection in four books (4L) 75, 82–4, 124, 148, canonical collections 253, 284 Appendix Seguntina 59, 158n156 Collection in nine books (9L/9V) 59n51, 71, Arsenal 713 collections 72–3, 148n114 first107 , 145, 160n165, 196n149, 197n150, Collection in seven books (7L) 74, 84n207 257, 259, 284–5 Collection in seventeen books (17L) 73, 75–8, 84, second 122n200, 124, 148, 253, 254, 284–5, 177, 277n143 288 Collection in seventy-four titles (74T) 45, 51, 64, see also Manuscript index for Paris Arsenal 81–2, 295, 297 713 Fournier on 45, 81–2 Collectio Ambrosiana II 76, 84, 281 in France often combined with Burchard Collectio Anselmo dedicata 178, 216n25, 223n69, of Worms 83 229n98 monastic, not Gregorian 82 Collectio Atrebatensis 70, 71–2 Collection in thirteen books (13L) 30n119, 74, Collectio Britannica 92–100, 114, 197n150, 254 267n85, 281 date of extant manuscript 157 Collection in two books 70, 74 lost earlier versions 94–5, 105, 156–7 Collection of Celle 83 not quoted in Panormia 124 Diversorum patrum sententiae see Collection in quoted in Ivo’s letters 152–4, 155–7 seventy-four titles version used for Tripartita A 105–6 False Decretals see Pseudo-Isidore see also Manuscript index for London, BL Lex romana canonice compta 178, 223, 223n69 Add. 8873 Liber Tarraconensis 70, 73, 74, 78, 84–5 Collectio Brugensis 115, 195n143 and TC 59, 118n175, 121n194, 158n155, relation to Tripartita A 103–4 158n156 Collectio Burdegalensis 73, 78–81, 84 Quadripartitus, the Carolingian canonical Collectio Caesaraugustana I 43, 285 collection 102, 115, 124, 161 Collectio Caesaraugustana II 59n51, 158n157, TC 59–60, 86, 116–17 281 and Ivo’s Decretum 115–21 Collectio Catalaunensis I 43–4, 121n194, and Ivo’s letter collection 157–8 148n114, 267n87, 277n143, 281 and Tripartita A 102, 104–5 Collectio Catalaunensis II 30, 43–4, 281 manuscripts of or related to 158n155 Collectio Dacheriana 51–2, 76 not source of Panormia 124 Collectio decem partium (10P) 29–30, 43, see also Abbo of Fleury; Alger of Liège; 148n114, 266, 277, 277n143 Anselm of Lucca; Atto of San and the Panormia 32, 280 Marco; Bernold of Constance; Collectio Dionysio(-Hadriana) 52, 223n67 Bonizo of Sutri; Burchard of Collectio duodecim partium (12P) 66n99 Worms; Deusdedit; Fulbert of Collectio Gaddiana 83 Chartres; Geoffrey of Vendôme; Collectio Hibernensis 51–2, 71, 88, 92 Gratian; Gregory of San Grisogno; and penance 88n218 Haimo of Bazoches; Hugh of as known to Fulbert 58 Châlons; Ivo of Chartres; John Collectio Hispana (and derivative collections) of Warneton; Lanfranc of Bec; 52, 223n67 Pseudo-Isidore; Regino of Prüm Collectio Quesnelliana 52, 223n67 canons regular see St Quentin; Chartres, Collectio Sinemuriensis 59–60, 69–71, 86, 115, cathedral chapter; St Jean en Vallée 276n136 capitularies/capitulary canons 92, 224n70 as a source of Ivo’s letters? 136 Abbreviatio Ansegisi et Benedicti Levitae 54, as source of Tripartita A 104–5 57–8, 76 not source of Panormia 124 Ansegisus 53, 57–8, 114

381

General index

capitularies/capitulary canons (cont.) JK †4 (Anaclet I) 199n173 Benedictus Levita 53, 114, 159, 224 JK †10 (Clement I) 195n139 on marriage 216, 222n59, 223n67, 224n71 JK †20 (Evarist I) 216n24, 216n27 in Ivo’s Decretum 159–60, 178 JK †86 (Calixt I) 277n143 in Ivo’s letters 159–60 JK †131 (Stephen I) 137 Celestine II, pope 281 JK †196 (Julius I) 275n136 Chartres JK 286 (Innocent I) 222n62 bishops of see Fulbert of Chartres; Geoffrey I JK 311 (Innocent I) 184n88 of Chartres; Ivo of Chartres; Geoffrey JK 334 (Zosimus I) 197n153, 198n159 of Lèves; Goslin of Lèves JK 411 (Leo I) 202n189 cathedral chapter 22–3 JK 544 (Leo I) 136, 142, 216n24, 223, diocese of 10–14 225 libraries/manuscripts at 53–4, 91–2, 110, 116, JK 622 (Gelasius I) 135 203n194; see also Manuscript index, JK †866 (Hormisdas I) 60n59 Chartres JK †899 (Silverius I) 142–3 religious houses at see Marmoutier; St Père; JK 992 (Leo I) 152 St Jean en Vallée JE †1366 (Gregory I) 92n26, 104n94 Clement I, see Decretals JE 1451 (Gregory I) 136, 143 Cluny 13, 188, 264 JE 1525 (Gregory I) 104n94 Constance, daughter of Philip I, her marriage JE 1747 (Gregory I) 136, 143 dissolved by Ivo 16, 242 JL †1948 (Alexander II) 76n154 Continuatio Aimonis 154–7 JE †1951 (Gregory I) 80n, 84n203 see also Manuscript index, Paris, BN lat. 12711 JE †1996 (Boniface IV) , 80n176, 84n203 councils, synods and conciliar legislation JE 2174 (Gregory II) 229n100, 230n105 Autun (1094) 236, 239n162 JE †2579 (Gregory I/Gregory IV) 60, Beaugency (1104) 242n186 132n28, 135, 195 Berry (1031) 229n99 JE 2720 (Nicholas I) 60n58 Bordeaux (1079 and 1080) 78 JE †2765 (Nicholas I) 194n139, 195, 202n188, Chalcedon (451) 56n31, 140, 141n80 204 Châlon-sur-Saone (813) 140, 222n59, 224n70 JE 2796 (Nicholas I) 198n162 Clermont (1096) 18, 41, 200, 273 JE 2812 (Nicholas I, Responsa) 214n13, and King Philip’s marriage affair235 , 237–8 226n82 Étampes (1092) 232n119 JE 3012 (John VIII) 56n31 Melfi (1089) 94 JE 3180 (John VIII) 95–9 Nîmes (1096) 41, 138, 239, 273 JL 3442 (Stephen V) 195n142, 198n162 Paris (1092) 231 JL 4589 (Alexander II) 105n103 Paris (1104) 242, 244–5 JL 5167 (Gregory VII) 157n151 Piacenza (1095) 74, 237 JL 5360 (Gregory VII) 158n154, 158n155 Poitiers (1078) 73–5, 78, 79, 84 JL 5383 (Urban II) 95–9, 122n201, 153, 170n31, Poitiers (1100) 241, 277 254n23 Reims (1049) 60 JL 5404 (Urban II) 254n23 Reims (1074) 221 JL 5423 (Urban II) 254n23 Reims (1094) 15n68, 232n119, 236, 239n162 JL 5438 (Urban II) 135n41, 140n74 Rome (autumn 1078) 79 JL 5469 (Urban II) 232n116, 234n129, Rome (spring 1080) 85 235n139, 235n149, 244n197 Rome, Lateran I (1123) 73n132, 277n146 JL 5523 (Urban II) 238n162 Rome, Lateran II (1139) 33 JL 5536 (Urban II) 252n14 Seligenstadt (1023) 61n63, 112 JL 5600 (Urban II) 200n176, 200n177 Tours (1060) 229n99 JL 5730 (Urban II) 105n103, 106n111, 333n84 Crusade, First 227, 240, 299 JL 5741 (Urban II) 102n84 Cyprian, in Ivo’s letters 153, 158, 306n9, 331n74 JL 5742 (Urban II) 102n84 JL 5788 (Urban II) 200n176, 203n192 Daimbert of Sens 189, 201–3, 238n158, 239n165 JL 5979 (Paschal II) 242n185 disputed consecration as archbishop 19–21 JL †6613 (Epistola Widonis) 120, 143 Decretals Deusdedit and his Collectio canonum 51, 64, 67, JK †3 (Anaclet I) 194n132, 194n134, 195n139 93, 99, 157n149 382

General index

Digest see Roman law see also Anselm of Lucca; Atto of San Marco; Duby, George 218n38, 219n42, 232n115, Bonizo of Sutri; Collection in seventy-four 235n138, 243n196 titles; Deusdedit; Gregory VII; Gregory of San Grisogono; Hugh of Lyon; Peter Ernulf of Rochester 89–91, 276n139 Damiani Eucharist controversy see Berengar; Lanfranc of Gregory I, pope 92, 93, 169, 195 Bec; Index to Ivo’s letters, ep. 287 in Ivo’s letters 136, 143, 305n5, 331n73 in Tripartita A 100, 103, 104–5, 132n28, 135, Fournier, Paul 136 influence on modern scholarship63 –4, 81–2, in 74T and 4L 82, 84 87, 248, 293–6 in Sinemuriensis 60, 136 on 74T 81–2 see also Decretals on Ivo and the Ivonian collections Gregory II, pope see Decretals on Ivo’s canonical works 41–8, 138, 149, Gregory VII, pope 2, 44, 63–4, 157, 202 293–6 his Dictatus papae 85, 157, 196n146 on Ivo’s letters 130–1, 149 in canon law 196, 297 on Ivo’s Prologus (‘Turning point’ debate) see also Decretals 95–6 Gregory of San Grisogono and his Polycarpus on ‘reform collections’ and ‘reform papacy’ 64, 295 44–7, 63–4, 81–2, 293–4 on penance 66n98 Fronteau, Jean 33–4, 39n171, 109n123 Guy of Beauvais 7, 9 Fulbert of Chartres 11, 222n59 his letter collection 54–9, 88, 92, 114 Haimo of Bazoches and his Summa 30, 44, legal sources known to 55–7, 58 266n85, 281 Poenitentiale Fulberti 88, 114 Hildebert of Lavardin 33, 43, 286–7 Fulk of Anjou 222n56, 231, 234, 234n133, his letter collection 88, 264, 273, 286–7 235–6 Hincmar of Reims 53, 70 in canon law 60, 70, 98n68, 214n13 Galo, a pupil of Ivo 9, 232n117, 265 Hugh of Châlons 27–8, 31, 33–7, 265, 286 bishop-elect of Beauvais, dispute over Hugh of Lyon 2–3, 64n86, 78, 85 election 242 and King Philip’s marriage affair234n132 , bishop of Paris 16, 265, 288 235, 236, 239 Gelasius I, pope conflicts with Ivo 17–21, 189, 199–204, in Tripartita A 113 203n193 see also Decretals Hugh of Puiset see Puiset family Geoffrey of Boulogne, bishop of Paris6 , 14, Hugh of St Victor 43, 183n78, 225n80, 274, 282 238 Geoffrey I of Chartres 6, 14–15, 135, 207 Investiture Contest 20–1, 24 Geoffrey of Lèves, bishop of Chartres6 dominating historiography on Ivo 292–6 Geoffrey of Vendôme3 , 12, 185, 188, 190, 207, Ivo’s view on investiture 17–21, 189–90 232n121, 273 Isidore of Seville 52, 154, 175, 182, 184, 197 his letters 129n11, 147 False Decretals, see Pseudo-Isidore Gilbert of Paris, a pupil of Ivo 288 Ivo of Chartres Goslin of Lèves, bishop of Chartres 6 and monks 169, 186, 187–9, 205–8 Gratian 28, 40, 292–6 chronicles known to 154–7 abbreviation of transmitted with Ivo’s Decretum 107–26, 158, 160, 171 Prologus 30 book 16 (lay legislation) 176–8, 253 as an early reader of the Panormia 280 compared to Burchard 109–12, 165–7, 171, contrast to Ivo and his Decretum 171, 209, 213 193–9, 300–1 his method prepared by Ivo? 292, 294–5, 296 contrast to Gratian 171, 209, 213 on marriage 213, 214n17, 222n59, 226, 229 contrast to Panormia 124–5, 248–56, 253 see also scholasticism discrepancies in 165–71, 170, 182–4, Gregorians and canon law 63–8, 196, 301 209–10, 249 difference from Ivo171 , 180, 198, 208 doublets in, and their elimination historiography on 44–7, 63–4, 81–2, 293–6 145n102, 175n50, 195, 259–64 limited influence of ‘Gregorians’295 –6, 297 Eucharist in 119, 182–4 383

General index

Ivo of Chartres, Decretum (cont.) ‘Jesus collection’ 268 manuscripts of manuscripts of 127–9, 128n10, 131n25, English v. French tradition? 260n53 131–2 extant 259–60 medieval interest in 127–9 lost 256n36–7 see also Index to Ivo’s letters used by Molinaeus 256n37 on canons regular 187, 205–8 see also Manuscript index on dispensation and its limits 168–71, misattributions in 140–1, 195, 214n13, 170n30, 220, 236 226n82 see also Ivo on ‘mercy and justice’ opening sections of single books 175, 180, on Eucharist, see Index to Ivo’s letters, epp. 193, 205, 254–6 231, 251 and esp. 287 Prologus written for it? 163–4 on Extreme Unction 184–5 relation to his letter collection 137–45, 158 on Holy Orders 175, 184, 185, 186, 254–5 role of Tripartita A 112, 115 on investiture see Investiture Contest ‘sandwich books’ 173–6 on marriage 140, 146, 178, 185, 213–30, 228 textual manipulation? 230n106 adultery 192, 218, 219, 221, 222, 226–7, 244 versions of 144–5, 256–65 age of reason 215n21 abbreviations 144, 252n12, 263–4, between Christians and Jews 222 306n11 between free and unfree 222–6 early reworking outside Chartres concubinage 218–19, 244, 249–50 259–64 consent and consummation 213–15 first stages of 139–40, 144–5, 256–65, dissolution and divorce 16, 220, 221, 259–60 227–30, 229 ecclesiology of 181–2, 193–9 ecclesiastical blessing 192, 215–17, 216n30 editions of his works see Brant; Vosmedian; enforcement of rules? 220–1, 226–7, 246–7 Fronteau; Merlet; Migne; Leclercq; impediments 220–2, 244 Molinaeus; Juret; Sackur; for Martin affinity 221 Brett’s editions see Bibliography blood relationship 220 historiography on 25–31, 291–8 spiritual kinship 222 dominated by ‘scholasticism’ and ‘mercy and justice’ and dispensation 218, ‘Investiture Contest’ 292–6 220, 228 see also Duby; Fournier sacrament 185, 192 letter collection 1–6, 21–2, 30, 88, 163–4 verba de futuro / de presenti 214–15 canon law in 127–62, 131, 160 see also Philip I; Index to Ivo’s letters how to determine formal sources on ‘mercy and justice’ 67, 165–71, 170n30, 131–2 190–1, 228, 302 Ivo’s favourite quotations 146 see also Ivo on dispensation misattributions in 140–1, 272 on ordo iudicarius 172n36 role of Burchard of Worms 140–1, 152, on penance 179, 186, 191–2 160n165 on peregrina iudicia 144 role of Collectio Britannica 152–4, 155–7 on sacraments 178, 180–2 role of Ivo’s own Decretum 137–45, 160 Panormia role of Panormia 148 and Burchard’s Decretum 124, 251 role of Pseudo-Isidore 100, 103–4, 115, authorship and date 265, 283–4 135, 152 contrast to Ivo’s Decretum 151, 248–56, 253 role of TC 157–8 contrast to Tripartita B 151, 253 role of Tripartita A 135–7 link to Ivo’s Prologus? 266–70 role of Tripartita B 145–8, 161, 311n22, manuscripts of 280 311n23 misattributions in 133n30, 149n119, earliest form of the letter collection 151n124, 151n125, 254, 271–2, 315n35 268n91 on penance 252–3 editions of 130, 131–2, 134 opening sections of single books 254–6 see also Juret; Leclercq; Merlet; Migne; Prologus written for it? 266–70 Sackur; for editions of single role in Ivo’s letters 148, 161–2, 254 letters see Index to Ivo’s letters sources of 123–6, 253–6

384

General index

Prologus 121–3, 165–71, 242n189, 302 Leclercq, Jean, his edition of Ivo’s letters 131, making of 134, 164n5 date (1105 as terminus ante quem) 267–8 Leges Henrici Primi, quoting from the Panormia inspired by Urban II? 95–7 278–9 sources of 121–3 Leo I, pope 143, 169, 223 written for Ivo’s Decretum or for the in Tripartita A 113 Panormia? 163–4, 266–70 see also Decretals manuscripts and reception of 30, 266, Leo IV, pope 133n30 267–8 see also Decretals attached to many canon law collections Leo IX, pope 44, 113 29–31, 266 see also Decretals circulating with Ivo’s letters 268 letter collections (apart from Ivo’s) 4, 88, 127 versions 267, 267n86, 267n87, 268n91 see also Bernard of Clairvaux; Fulbert of on ‘mercy and justice’ 165–7, 209, 302 Chartres; Hildebert of Lavardin; Peter sermons 169n23, 180–1, 182, 190–1 Damiani; Peter of Blois manuscript of 129n13 Liber Pancrisis 129n12, 214 Sermo II see Ivo on Holy Orders Louis VI, king of France 19, 204n198, 222n63, Tripartita A 59, 70, 72, 100–7, 112 233, 242 date(s) of 105, 135–7 coronation of 22, 100, 154–7, 299 early stages of 103–4, 105, 148 marriage dissolved by Ivo 16, 242 first version manuscripts101 , 137n54, 143, 148 Lyon, archbishops of, see Hugh of Lyon; not quoted in Panormia 124 Josceran of Sens role in Ivo’s letters 135–7, 154, 160–1 Sententiae sections in 102–3, 115, 137, Marbod of Rennes 273 154, 161 Marmoutier 13–14, 187, 188–9, 206, 207 Tripartita B 101, 120, 143, 145–8 marriage, doctrine of, see Augustine; Ivo containing most of Ivo’s favourite of Chartres; Gratian; Roman law; quotations 147 see also Decretals for JK †20; JK 544; manuscripts of 101, 143 JE 2174; JE 2812 preserving original form of Decretum Merlet, Lucien, his edition of Ivo’s letters 203n194 canons? 120, 117n172, 143 Migne, Jean-Paul, his edition of Ivo’s works 39, role in Ivo’s letter collection 145–8, 161 147–8, 217n36, 328n63, 328n64 used but checked against manuscripts 131 Jerome, St 205, 228, 310n17, 327n56 Molinaeus, Johannes (Jean van der Meulene) in Ivo’s letters 144, 187n104, 188n105, 205, on the Ivonian collections 32–4 205n202 his edition of Ivo’s Decretum (‘M’) 117n171, John VIII, pope, in canon law 107, 121n198, 196 118n179, 121n194, 159n161, 175n50, 259–64 see also Decretals manuscripts used 256n36–7 John of Warneton, bishop of Thérouanne 71, monks and their use of canon law 72, 89 Collection in seventy-four titles as a monastic Josceran of Sens 203–4 collection 81–2 Juret, François, his edition of Ivo’s letters monastic forgeries 83–4 130n16, 131, 134, 203n194, 217n36 see also Decretals JE †1366; †1951; †1996; †2579 Lambert of Arras 89, 237n150, 241–2 role in King Philip’s marriage affair 232n117, Nicholas I, pope 53, 60, 133n30, 153 241, 245 in Ivonian collections 101, 107, 272 Lanfranc of Bec 7, 90–1 see also Decretals Collectio Lanfranci 90 Norman Anonymous, knowledge of Ivonian De corpore 42, 139–40, 182–4, 271–2 collections 3, 264, 276–7 Laon, school of 7, 212, 282 see also Anselm of Laon; Liber Pancrisis; Paris Sententiae magistri A., William of bishops of see Galo; Geoffrey of Boulogne; Champeaux Gilbert;William of Montfort Le Puiset, see Puiset family see also St Martin des Champs and St Victor

385

General index

Paschal II, pope 189, 192, 198 in Ivo’s Decretum 108, 114, 178, 196, and King Philip 241–2 230n105 see also Decretals in Ivo’s letters 130, 154, 215n21, 225, 329n67, penance, see Burchard of Worms, Decretum; 330n70 Fulbert of Chartres; Gregory of San in Tripartita 102, 146 Grisogono; Anselm of Lucca; Collectio Sententiae Pauli 116, 178 Hibernensis; Ivo of Chartres, Decretum; Roscelin 89–91 Panormia Peter Damiani 52, 63, 184 Sackur, Ernst, his edition of Ivo’s letters his letter collection 131, 157n152 130n20 Peter of Blois, his letter collection 4 scholasticism, concept of 292–6, 301n23 Peter the Venerable, his letter collection 4 Sens, archbishops of, see Daimbert of Sens; Philip I, king of France 18–21, 201 Richer of Sens marriage affair of222n56 , 226, 230–46 Sententiae magistri A. 43, 176n52, 274–6, as a clash of ‘two models of marriage’? 243 280 danger of French schism 238n158 Sententiae Pauli see Roman law Ivo as ‘rigorist’? 218, 236, 245–6 Sic et non see Abelard Ivo in 1104 not the main player 241, 245 Sigebert of Gembloux 63, 129n11, 232n115 role of French bishops 232, 233, 236–8, on Ivo of Chartres 1–2, 3–5, 26 238n158, 245 St Jean en Vallée (Chartres) 11, 23, 207 role of Hugh of Lyon 235, 236, 239 St Martin des Champs (Paris) 7, 8 role of Lambert of Arras 232n117, 237n150, St Père (Chartres) 11, 14, 116, 207, 232 241, 245 St Quentin (Beauvais) 7–9, 15, 89–91, 139–40, role of Paschal II 241–2 241n184 role of Urban II 234, 235, 236–8, 239 St Trinité (diocese of Vendôme) 12 see also Bertrada of Montfort St Victor (Paris) 285, 288 supporting Ivo of Chartres 10, 15, 16–17 Stephen of Garlande 199n166, 242 Pseudo-Isidore 53–4, 65, 90, 199 as known to Fulbert of Chartres 55, 58 Urban II, pope in Ivonian collections and Ivo’s letters 100, and Daimbert of Sens 201–3 103–4, 115, 135, 152 and Hugh of Lyon 3, 201–3 on episcopal rights 86, 199, 202 and Ivo of Chartres 14–15, 18–20, 95–6, 135, see also Decretals 296 Puiset family 11, 12, 22, 237, 240 and King Philip’s marriage affair 234, 235, imprisoning Ivo 16, 232 236–8, 239 and Richer of Sens 200 Quadripartitus, twelfth-century English law Fournier on 44, 95–6, 296 book 279 in canon law in Collectio Britannica 95–6, 97, 153, 196, Regino of Prüm 50, 175n50 253–4 Richer of Sens 3, 18–21, 197, 238n158 in Ivo’s Decretum 107, 113–14, 153, 196, refusing to consecrate Ivo 14–15 253–4 Rochester in Panormia 253–4 Ivo’s Decretum at 265 in Tripartita A 102, 103, 105–6, 153 Ivo’s letters at 128 see also Decretals see also Ernulf of Rochester Roman law Victor III, pope 3 and medieval doctrine of marriage 213–14, Vincent of Beauvais 27–9, 31, 34, 286 215n21, 223–6, 229, 230n105 Vosmedian, Melchior 32–4 as known to Fulbert of Chartres 55–7, 92 Digest Wasserschleben, Friedrich Wilhelm Hermann in Collectio Britannica 93, 95–6 37–40, 46–7 in Ivo’s Decretum 108, 178 William of Champeaux 16, 214 in Ivo’s letters 146, 157n149, 214, 215n21 William of Fécamp 152, 232n117 in Collectio Britannica 93, 95–6, 196, 197n150 William of Montfort 238, 288

386