DOCSLIB.ORG

Wk 09 Mon, Mar 1 Advaita Vedānta

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Wk 09 Mon, Mar 1 Advaita Vedānta Wk 09 Mon, Mar 1 Today Advaita Vedānta – Khilnani, Sunil. 2016. "Adi Shankara: A God without Qualities." In Incarnations – Hamilton IP: VSI section on Śaṅkara, pp. 125-31 in Ch. 8, "The Word and the Book." – Deutsch, Eliot S. 1965. "Karma as a ‘Convenient Fiction’ in the Advaita Vedānta." Philosophy East and West 15 (1): 3-12. – Matilal, Bimal K. 1992. "A Note on Śaṃkara's Theodicy." Journal of Indian Philosophy 20 (4): 363-76. – Sthaneshwar Timalsina’s Ch. 8 “Self, Causation, and Agency in the Advaita of Sankara” in FWASIP 1 Looking Ahead Wed: Viśiṣṭādvaita Martin Ganeri’s “Free Will, Agency, and Selfhood in Ramanuja,” Ch. 10 in FWASIP Mumme article? Next Mon: Dvaita David Buchta’s “Dependent Agency and Hierarchical Determinism in the Theology of Madhva,” Ch. 11 in FWASIP Final Paper Grading Rubric The paper is worth 100 points. The paper + presentation constitute 35% of your course grade. Points are awarded for the paper as follows: 10 - Formatting, length, proofreading (no egregious spelling mistakes!) 10 - Consistently formatted Bibliography 10 - Citing your sources 20 - Structure & clarity of writing 50 - Content & coverage 2 Final Paper & Presentation 10-12 pgs + Bibliography 35% of Course Grade Due Mon Finals Week 2pm – Mar 15 – 10 min Presentation 2:30-4:20 pm. Goal: Synthesis, your own position on karma vs. free will Important concepts studied: – Karma, dharma, reincarnation, self, theodicy – Free Will & Agency – Determinism, fatalism, compatibilism, libertarianism – Bhagavad Gītā, Brahma-sūtras & Agency – Consciousness? Luck? Systems Considered: 7. Grammarian 1. Sāṅkhya 8. Advaita Ved nta 2. Nyāya ā 3. Abhidharma Buddhism 9. Viśiṣṭādvaita 10. Madhva Ved nta 4. Mādhyamika Buddhism ā 5. Jainism 11. Kashmir Śaivism 12. Gau ya Vai avism 6. Mīmāṃsā ḍī ṣṇ Final Paper, cont’d Some questions to address: – Is karma necessary? Why (not)? – What are implications of (not) accepting karma as seen in the different systems? – What in your opinion is the best solution to the problem karma is trying to answer? – Is there free will? Why (not)? – How do the different systems answer this question? . Are they successful? . Why, or why not? – How has this class affected your thinking on free-will? – What is/are the most significant take-away(s) for you? 3 WOTD • avidyā, ignorance / nescience, “the cosmic misconception” Mat. 363 Dhandeep Questions Who has karma? Ātman / Brahman? Locus of ignorance? Karma : beginning of creation :: chicken : egg 4 Vedānta Literally “end of the Vedas” Versions: Advaita … Viśiṣṭādvaita … Dvaita Three source texts, “canons” 1. Upaniṣads, śruti - revelation 2. Bhagavad Gītā, smr̥ti - recollection . bet. 200 BCE and 200 CE. 3. Brahmasūtras, systematization . bet. 200 BCE and 200 CE. Commentaries on these three written by “founders” 4. Not included by all: Purāṇas Śaṅkara’s Advaita-vedānta Textbook dates for Śaṅkara: 788-820 CE Recent scholarship: late 7th-early 8th c. Teacher’s teacher: Gauḍapāda, 7th c.? Hagiography - “life stories of saints” . Only child of a Kerala Brahmin family . encounter w. crocodile, age 8 . debates w. Mandana Miśra & wife Sarasvati 5 Conquest of the four quarters Monastic organizations setup in the corners of India: 5 1. Śṛṅgerī (Karnataka) 2. Kāñcī (Tamil Nadu) . controversial 3 3. Dvārakā (Gujarat) 4 4. Purī (Orissa) 5. Badrināth (NW Himalaya mtns) 1 2 All are still functioning & significant Śaṅkara & Buddhism Śaṅkara is credited with Hindu revival, precipitating decline of Buddhism in India . Introduced Buddhist principles of organization into Hinduism . Rejected sacrificial practices & extreme asceticism . Moved away from rituals: BU 4.3.22: “[in liberation] gods are not gods, the Vedas are not the Vedas” . Familiarity w. Buddhist thought . Accused of being a “crypto- Buddhist” 6 What is advaita, non-duality? Ātman, Self = Brahman, ultimate reality, ground of being . Eternal, uncreated, indivisible, unchanging, infinite, pure, free, liberated . sat existence, cit consciousness, ānanda happiness . Analogies: wave/ocean, gold/ornament, diamond Māyā, “illusion” = avidyā, ignorance . Degrees of reality: conceptual & absolute . Indescribable, neither real nor unreal, beginning-less . Mysterious power of Brahman as Īśvara . Brahman ≠ māyā . Movie analogy What is Non-duality? Due to ignorance, diversity is superimposed on Brahman – Rope/snake analogy . Hamilton IP:VSI 127 – 10th man Individual self, jīva = reality + illusion –Real → jīva is Brahman – Illusory → jīva is limited and finite –Story: Śaṅkara’s encounter w. tiger 7 More on “reality” Three levels: 1. Illusory, prātibhāsika 2. Empirical/conventional/phenomenal, vyāvahārika 3. Ultimate, pāramārthika Empirical Reality is anirvacanīya, “indescribable” – Logically undefinable, neither absolutely real nor empirically false (cf. Tetra-lemma) – Rope/snake, mother-of-pearl/silver Liberation, mokṣa Mokṣa = removal of ignorance . By knowledge alone . Action (karma), devotion (bhakti) assist . No becoming, no transformation . Liberation now, while alive . Philosophy just a means for Śaṅkara . Relation w. Brahman 2 kinds . saguṇa Brahman = Īśvara . nirguṇa Brahman 8 From Wk01: Advaita Vedānta Non-duality – God, self, creation are identical Brahman = ātman / ātmā Three levels of reality – Absolute – Empirical –Dream Leading proponent: Śaṅkara, 8th cent. CE –Sureśvara, immediate disciple –=? Maṇḍana Miśra, contemporary From Wk01: Advaita Vedānta Triple Canon / Foundation, prasthāna-trayī 1. Upaniṣads 2. Brahmasūtras 3. Bhagavad Gītā Types of karma, [ritual] acts A. Prescribed, vidhi 1. regular rites, nitya-karman 2. special occasion rites, naimittika-karman 3. rites to attain specific desires, kāmya-karman 4. rites for atonement, prāyaścitta-karman B. Forbidden, niṣedha 9 From Wk01: Advaita Vedānta 3 types of stores of karma 1. prārabdha-karma, active in present life 2. sañcita-karma, inactive, accumulated over past lives 3. āgāmī-karma, to be effective in the future 3 paths after death 1. uttarāyaṇa, devāyana, Northern path 2. dakṣināyana, pitrāyaṇa, Southern path 3. saṃyamana, world of Yama, lord of death From Wk01: Liberation in Advaita Vedānta Achieved through knowledge of identity –Brahman = ātmā Neutralizes sañcita-karma, āgāmī-karma – Subsequent new karma doesn’t accumulate – Non-attachment Only prārabdha-karma remains and must be worked out – Already launched arrow 10 Other Advaitins Bhartṛprapañca, 550 CE Gauḍapāda, early 7th c.? Maṇḍana Miśra, 660-720 CE Śaṅkara’s students –Sureśvara, 8th c. author of Naiṣkarmya-siddhi –Padmapāda, 8th c., Pañcapādikā . Prakāśātman, 11th c., Vivaraṇa Vācaspati Miśra, 842 CE, Bhāmati on BSBh Sarvajñātman, 1050 CE, Saṃkṣepa-śārīraka Prakāśānanda, 1550-1650 CE, Siddhānta-muktāvalī Means Of Knowledge, pramāṇa Revisited by Deutsch 1. Pratyakṣa, perception: nirvikalpa & savikalpa 2. Upamāna, comparison 3. Anupalabdhi, non-perception / non-cognition – karma is not an sense-object like a table, a tree, a pot 4. Anumāna, inference –“the nature of inferential reasoning in Indian philosophy precludes the possibility of universal proposition or law be the conclusion of an inference (6-7)” 5. Arthāpatti, postulation – Not unique explanation of effects 6. Śabda, verbal testimony – Only for truths which transcend reason, senses and derived from spiritual experience. Karma is not content of spiritual experience (9) 11 Deutsch’s Conclusion Karma is undemonstratable – Not an object of a valid means of knowledge. Convenient Fiction – PRO: Motivation to escape bondage – PRO: Persuasion to live a moral life – PRO: Preserves morale: no effort goes to waste – CON: Induces apathy The Western Problem (Wk06 W) If God exists, then God is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect. If God is omnipotent, then God has power to eliminate all evil. If God is omniscient, then God knows when evil exists. If God is morally perfect, then God has the desire to eliminate all evil. BUT evil exists. If evil exists and God exists, then either God doesn’t have the power to eliminate all evil , OR God doesn’t know when evil exists, OR God doesn’t have the desire to eliminate all evil. Therefore, God doesn’t exist. 12 Matilal on Śaṅkara’s Theodicy “the Creator is not independent. He does not have free choice (365).” “In the very beginning of creation, no karma existed, so whence the diversity (366)?” “[karma] is the given in Indian religion...It produces a morality that is important. Not to believe in it would be a taboo. And there cannot be a culture without taboos (375).” Timalsina on Advaita “the self is devoid of action, and action and wisdom are as contradictory as light and darkness (189).” “… agents are bound due to ignorance ... Due to self- imposed bondage, the phenomenal self undergoes karmic flux (190).” “since the self is nothing but Brahman in reality, the self is autonomous in giving rise to the world of common- sense experience (193).” “From the Advaita standpoint, the discourse on the autonomy of an agent is a quest to alter one's own dreams, and the Advaitins are interested not in changing the dream, but in waking up (197).” 13 Īśvara, the Lord & Jīva, the individual Sureśvara – Īśvara =Collective ego (204) = Brahman conditioned by avidyā – Jīva = Brahman conditioned by buddhi Vidyāraṇya, Sarvajñātman – Īśvara = reflection of consciousness in māyā – Jīva = reflection of consciousness in avidyā Questions Revisited Who has karma? Ātman / Brahman? Locus of ignorance? Karma : beginning of creation :: chicken : egg 14.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • East Meets West
    East Meets West The stories of the remarkable men and women from the East and the West who built a bridge across a cultural divide and introduced Meditation and Eastern Philosophy to the West John Adago SHEPHEARD-WALWYN (PUBLISHERS) LTD © John Adago 2014 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form without the written permission of the publisher, Shepheard-Walwyn (Publishers) Ltd www.shepheard-walwyn.co.uk First published in 2014 by Shepheard-Walwyn (Publishers) Ltd 107 Parkway House, Sheen Lane, London SW14 8LS www.shepheard-walwyn.co.uk British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record of this book is available from the British Library ISBN: 978-0-85683-286-4 Typeset by Alacrity, Chesterfield, Sandford, Somerset Printed and bound in the United Kingdom by imprintdigital.com Contents Photographs viii Acknowledgements ix Introduction 1 1 Seekers of Truth 3 2 Gurdjieff in Russia 7 3 P.D. Ouspensky: The Work Comes to London 15 4 Willem A. Nyland: Firefly 27 5 Forty Days 31 6 Andrew MacLaren: Standing for Justice 36 7 Leon MacLaren: A School is Born 43 8 Adi Shankara 47 9 Shri Gurudeva – Swami Brahmananda Saraswati 51 10 Vedanta and Western Philosophy 57 11 Maharishi Mahesh Yogi: Flower Power – The Spirit of the Sixties 62 12 Swami Muktananda: Growing Roses in Concrete 70 13 Shantananda Saraswati 77 14 Dr Francis Roles: Return to the Source 81 15 Satsanga: Good Company 88 16 Joy Dillingham and Nicolai Rabeneck: Guarding the Light 95 17 Last Days 106 18 The Bridge 111 The Author 116 Appendix 1 – Words of the Wise 129 Appendix 2 – The Enneagram 140 Appendix 3 – Philosophy and Christianity 143 Notes 157 Bibliography 161 ~vii~ Photographs G.I.
    [Show full text]
  • Shankaraachaarya: Life and Works
    Shankaraachaarya: Life and Works Introduction1 thereafter, the couple was blessed with a wonderful son Let us offer our praNaams to Adi Shankara, one and they named him Shankara. According to historians, of the greatest philosophers, mystics, and poets to grace Shankara was born in the year Nandana (26th year of bhaaratavarshha and this planet. the sixty year cycle or sa.nvatsara) in the lunar month of Vaishaakha (corresponding to May/June) under the According to various historians, Adi Shankaracharya Zodiac sign of the Archer on Monday in the year 805 was born at a time when Buddhism held sway in India, AD.3 and the philosophy of Buddhism had come to be inter- preted as a denial of God. Hinduism was divided into Once Aryamba was shocked to find a large co- various sects and the ritualistic practice had taken a pre- bra coiled around the neck of Shankara. While she was dominance over actual philosophical practice. watching, it turned to a garland. It is said that Shankara could read, write, and speak Sanskrit at the age of one. Shankara, in his indisputable style, set out on a Once some children were arguing about the number of difficult mission and changed the outlook of the country seeds inside a melon. Young Shankara said that the and its people by revamping the vast hindu literature number of seeds inside that melon would correspond to into simple, easy to understand language. the number of gods who created the universe. When The life of Shankara the children cut open the melon, they found only one seed !! Once, Shankara was collecting alms from vari- Among numerous biographies of Shankara, the ous families in the village.
    [Show full text]
  • Advaita Vedanta – System of Philosophy Centred on Non Duality – Drawn from the Upanishads
    ADVAITA PHILOSOPHY ADVAITA PHILOSOPHY 1. Where does it come from & how do we know about it? 2. What does it say? 3. What are its implications for everyday living? ABSTRACTED SUMMARY OF THE TALK CONTENT 0 February 2018 Indus Valley Ganges Valley 1. WHERE DOES IT COME FROM? 1 Vedas are the Source UPANISHADS - Eesha VEDAS - Kena - Katha - Rig-Veda - Taittireeya - Sama-Veda - Aitareya - Yajur-Veda - Mundaka - Atharva- - Mandukya Veda - Prashna - Brhadaranyaka - Chandogya ‘Vedanta’ 2 Terminology • Vedas - the works that contain the knowledge • Upanishads – chapters at the end (anta) of the Veda • Advaita Vedanta – system of Philosophy centred on non duality – drawn from the Upanishads • There are other closely linked Vedanta systems as well e.g. Yoga System of Patanjali 3 Historical Perspective 4 Organisation - Adi Shankara • Adi Shankara – 788 – 820 • Rediscovered the essence of Vedic Knowledge • Wrote commentaries & original works • Toured India • Reorganised swamis under 4 mathas – ‘seats’ – each led by a Shankaracharya 5 Locations of the 4 Mathas in the Shankaracharya Tradition Northern: Jyotirmath, Uttarakhand Western: Shankaracharya Dwarka, of the North seat Gurjarat moved here in Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh – Matha establish by Guru Deva Southern: Shringeri, Karnataka Eastern: Puri, Odisha 6 Some of the Prominent Indian Sages Who Came to the West 7 How This Knowledge Came to The West West East Indian Sages Popular Thinkers/ Leaders Writers/ Poets Scientists Cultural Academia Explorers 8 Dates for The Famous Scientists Who Were Influenced 9 One Example 10 One Western Philosopher – Schopenhauer was Particularly Moved He said: In the whole world there is no study so beneficial and so elevating as that of the Upanishads.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ever Growing Banyan Tree
    Chapter 2 Spirituality in India: The Ever Growing Banyan Tree Comparing Western and Indian knowledge, Rolland (1960, p. 91) described Western knowledge as the “science of facts” and spirituality as “the science of the soul, a peculiarly Indian science.” A major difference between philosophy and spirituality, or for that matter religion and spirituality, is that spirituality, as prac- ticed in India, has an action bias over and above cognitive (thinking or thoughts) or value (considering something important) concerns. Spirituality has been valued in the Indian culture from time immemorial, and it is no surprise that many innova- tions in the field of spirituality originated in India. Since people strive to excel in areas that are compatible with their cultural values, India has seen the emergence of many geniuses in the field of spirituality even in the modern times. I combine two qualitative methods, historical analysis and case analysis, to document how spirituality is valued in India, and much like a banyan tree, how it continues to grow even today. An examination of the life of the list of spiritual gurus presented in the chapter shows that they were all practitioners, and they practiced what they preached. Also, the case analysis shows that Ramakrishna was a practitioner, and both the Maharishi and Rajneesh recommended daily practice of meditation. A historical evolution of spirituality in India is traced by generating a list of spiritual gurus over the last 2,500 years by using published sources both in the West (Kroeber, 1944) and in India. Following this historical analysis, three case studies are presented to illustrate that spirituality is valued even today in India, and this culture continues to produce eminent spiritual gurus.
    [Show full text]
  • Shankara's Advaita Vedanta
    Shankara’s Advaita Vedanta David Paul Boaz The Purusha, the inner Self, dwells always at the Heart. That One is the Bright, the luminous immortal Self. Katha Upanishad Shankara’s teaching on the Upanishads, Vedanta (Brahma) Sutra and Bhagavad Gita is the very nondual essence of Vedanta, and a sublime contribution to the world’s spiritual literature, and to our nondual Great Wisdom Tradition teaching. Shankara (788-820) was the supreme adept-realizer of the Hindu Upanishadic tradition. In his thirty two years this great master and scholar re-established the authority of the Vedas against the prevailing Buddhist ideology of the time. For Shankara’s Advaita Vedanta the supreme truth of the three Hindu canons (the Upanishads, Vedanta Sutra and Bhagvad Gita) is the nondual nature of Brahman, Absolute Spirit that is Reality Itself. For the Advaita Vedanta of Shankara, Brahman is the nondual primordial awareness that is Absolute or Ultimate Consciousness Being Itself, “One, without a second,” without limit, empty of all predicates, attributes and qualities, beyond concept and belief, or any subject-object dualism whatsoever. As we have seen, Shankara refers to this prior unity as Nirguna Brahman, the Absolute. Satchitananda however, is usually understood as Saguna Brahman, Brahman with relative qualities, the Great Love that is being (sat), consciousness (chit) and bliss (ananda). Ishvara (usually as the Trimurti) the primordial creator-God or creative principle of Brahman is also Saguna Brahman, the spacetime limited creator God, the cause of the conditional state of ananda/bliss and the object of the spiritual devotion of the devotee. Nirguna Brahman is pure nondual Being Itself; Saguna Brahman is pure Being in the various states and stages of becoming in spacetime reality.
    [Show full text]
  • Trailanga - Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    ַטִאַילְנג ְסָוואִמי ترايﻻنغا سوامي تريلينگا http://fa.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D9%81%D9%87%D8%B1%D8%B3%D8%AA_%D8%AD%D8%B2%D 8%A8%E2%80%8C%D9%87%D8%A7_%D8%AF%D8%B1_%D9%87%D9%86%D8%AF%D9%88%D 8%B3%D8%AA%D8%A7%D9%86 سوامی Trailanga - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trailanga Trailanga From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Trailanga Swami (also Tailang Swami , Telang Swami ) [nb 1] [2] [2][3] Swami Ganapati Saraswati (Telugu: cంగ ాI ) (reportedly 1607 – 1887 ) was a Hindu yogi famed for his spiritual powers who lived in Born Shivarama Varanasi, India.[2] He is regarded as a legendary figure in 1607 Bengal, with many stories told about his yogic powers and Vizianagaram longevity. According to some accounts, Trailanga Swami Died December 26, 1887 (aged 280) [2][4] lived to be 280 years old, residing at Varanasi between Varanasi 1737-1887. [3] He is regarded by devotees as an incarnation of Shiva. Ramakrishna referred to him as the "The walking Titles/honours known as "The walking Shiva of Varanasi" Shiva of Varanasi". [5] Guru Bhagirathananda Saraswati Philosophy Dashanami Contents 1 Life 2 Death 3 Legends and stories 4 Teachings 5 Notes 6 References 7 References 8 Further reading 9 External links Life A member of the Dashanami order, he became known as Trailanga Swami after he settled in Varanasi. His biographers and his disciples differ on his birth date and the period of his longevity. According to one disciple biographer, he was born in 1529, while according to another biographer it was 1607.
    [Show full text]
  • Adi Shankara
    Adi Shankara A brief history Raj Vedam, May 12, 2013 5/16/2013 Raj Vedam 1 Adi Shankara - Ancestry • Born in Kalady in Kerala, a village on the banks of the Purna river. • Grandfather: Vidhyadhiraja • Father: Shivaguru • Mother: Aryamba or Vishista Devi • Gothram: Atri • Krishna Yajurvedi • Nambudari Brahmana 5/16/2013 Raj Vedam 2 Kalady – Location on the map 5/16/2013 Raj Vedam 3 Kalady – closer look 5/16/2013 Raj Vedam 4 Brief Outline of Travels • At age of 8, left Kerala toward North, met guru Govinda Bhagavatpada on the banks of Narmada. • After studies went to Kashi then to Badrinath. • Met Kumarila in Prayag. Proceeded to Mahismati on Narmada in MP to meet Madana Mishra. • Went with disciples to Maharashtra,Gokarna, and Kollur near Shimoga. • Then began Dig-Vijaya (tour of conquest). Traveled all over India. Went to Kashmir, Nepal, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Vidarbha, Karnataka, Saurashtra Girnar, Somnath, Prabhasa, Dwarka. Went up to Kamboja (north of Kashmir?). • Final days, went to Kedarnath-Badrinath 5/16/2013 Raj Vedam 5 5/16/2013 Raj Vedam 6 Some Works of Adi Shankara • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adi_Shankara_ bibliography • Bhashyas (commentaries) on the Upanishads, Bhagavatgita, Mahabharata. • Prakarana Grantha (Thesis) (Vivekachudamani, Upadesa sahasri, Tattva Bodha, etc.) • Stotras on Shiva, Vishnu, Devi, Ganesha and Subrahmanya (e.g., Bhaja Govindam, Bhavani Astakam, Dakshinamurthy stotram, etc.) 5/16/2013 Raj Vedam 7 Dating Adi Shankara • Sringeri records: 788CE-820CE • Kanchi Peetam, Govardhana Matha, Dwaraka Pitha: 509-477BCE • Another tradition (astrologer BV Raman) 44BCE-12BCE • 805CE–897CE (Venkiteswara) (92 years) • Controversies exist till today on first two dates.
    [Show full text]
  • Faces of Nondualism
    Faces of Nondualism By Swami Jnaneshvara This paper is created to help the participants of the Center for Nondualism and Abhyasa Ashram better understand the wide range of principles and practices related to Nondualism (The paper will be revised from time to time to make it ever more clear). Although there is ultimately only one Nondual reality, people approach the direct realization of this through a variety of faces. Following are brief descriptions of many, if not most of these approaches. By exploring the breadth of approaches, we can better understand our own chosen path to direct experience of the Nondual Reality, Truth, Source, or other such ways of denoting this. Individual seekers will find much greater depth within his or her own tradition. Unfortunately, from lack of understanding some people incorrectly believe nondualism to be “against” dualism, whereas dualism is actually an essential aspect of the journey towards realization in direct experience of the Nondual Reality, Truth, or Beingness. Gently, lovingly one treads the path of life in the world towards the knowing of that Nonduality which is both beyond and yet inclusive of the world. There is no separateness, no division. It is only due to ignorance (avidya) that there appears to be separateness and division where there is actually seamless Nondual Reality. Nondualism is a minority worldview in our times. In the U.S. especially, the dominant worldview is that of dualistic Christian monotheism. It is in large part for this reason that people of the Nondualism perspective can benefit from coming together in a spirit of friendship to explore the principles and practices of the various paths leading to nondual experience.
    [Show full text]
  • Sri Krishna Kathamrita
    Sri Krishna Kathamrita Tav k QaaMa*Ta& TaáJaqvNaMa( tava kathāmṛtaṁ tapta-jīvanam Bindu Fortnightly email mini-magazine from Gopal Jiu Publications Issue No. 313 Śrī Utthānā Ekādaśī 13 November 2013 Circulation 6,710 • THE BHAGAVATAM PREDATES VOPADEV His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada • "NO INTEREST" Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Saraswati Thakur Prabhupada • NOT BY VOPADEV From a commentary on Srila Baladev Vidyabhushan’s Siddhānta-darpaṇa Highlights • Definitions of Bhakti Various Authors • Shyam has come to Nadia Sri Harivallabha Das THE BHAGAVATAM PREDATES VOPADEV His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada Some Māyāvādī scholars argue that Śrīmad Bhāgavatam was not compiled by Sri Vyasadev. And some of them suggest that this book is a modern creation written by someone named Vopadev. In order to refute such meaningless arguments, Sri Sridhar Svami points out that there is reference to the Bhāgavatam in many of the oldest Purāṇas. This first śloka of the Bhāgavatam begins with the Gāyatrī mantra. There is reference to this in the Matsya Purāṇa, which is the oldest Purāṇa. In that Purāṇa it is said about the Bhāgavatam that in it there are many narrations of spiritual instructions, that it begins with the Gāyatrī mantra, and that it contains the history of Vritrasura. Anyone who makes His Divine Grace a gift of this great work on a full moon day attains to A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada the highest perfection of life by returning to Godhead. There is reference to the Bhāgavatam in other Purāṇas of the Bhāgavatam. Within the past five hundred also, where it is clearly stated that this work was years, many erudite scholars and ācāryas like Jiva finished in twelve cantos, which include eighteen Goswami, Sanatan Goswami, Viswanath Chakravarti, thousand ślokas.
    [Show full text]
  • Hitler Rebirth
    Hitler Rebirth From page 2 onwards Copying, forwarding and transmission in full or any part of this web is not authorised but excerpts allowed only for media reviews and comments (Page 13 to 70) Prabha escaped bribing MR (77-138 pages) 2 Hitler Rebirth Story Next US President Hillary Rodham Clinton (15 A4 pages) Clinton Comments: Bill Clinton's December 19, 2014 email letter to Keerthi was headed; "My family to Yours" and he did so after reading Hitler reincarnation story which said that Germany's Chancellor Angela Merkel was the daughter of then German Chancellor Adolf Hitler who is alive and kicking, being reborn in Sri Lanka. Mrs. Hillary Rodham Clinton, who knew and met Chancellor Angela Merkel possibly several times as US 3 Secretary of State, repeated in her January 1, 2014 letter to Keerthi: " Again, thank you from our family to yours." Keerthi remained unmarried throughout, having no family but was Adolf Hitler in previous birth whose undeniable biological daughter is Angela Merkel. World-shaking story of Hitler rebirth President Bill Clinton's December 19 email letter to Keerthi was headed; "My family to Yours" and he did so after reading Hitler reincarnation story which said that German Chancellor Angela Merkel was the daughter of then German Chancellor Adolf Hitler who is alive and kicking, being reborn in Sri Lanka. Mrs. Hillary Rodham Clinton, next likely US president , who knew and met Chancellor Angela Merkel possibly several times as US Secretary of State, repeated in her January 1, 2014 letter to Keerthi : " Again, thank you from our family to yours." Keerthi remained unmarried throughout, having no family but was Adolf Hitler in previous birth whose biological daughter is Angela Merkel.
    [Show full text]
  • Teaching of Shankara
    ADHYATMA GRANTHAVALI THE UNIQUE TEACHING OF SHANKARA (A Discussion on His Adhyaasa Bhaasbya) Original Writer in Kannada Sri Swamy Satchidanandendra Saraswathi Translator : Sri D. B. Gangolli Serial No. 186 Publishers: ADHYATMA PRAKASHA KARYALAVA Holenarsipur 1983 2 Book. on Genuine Y.da~t. i~ Engli.h Published by : Adhyatma Prakasha Karyalaya. Holenarasipur • 573211, Karnataka State (India) 1. How to Recognise the method of Vedanta. The first sustained attempt to reduce all the seemingly different methods of U panishadl to the only comprensive method of Adhyaropa. Apavada (Superimposition and rescission). 2. Vedanta or the Science of Reality. By K. A. Krishna Swamy Iyer with a fore­ ward by Dr. Radha Krishnan dealing with the immediate realisation of Brahman by a reflection on the witness of the three states. All systems of thought, Eastern and Western are examined to prove the truths of Vedanta. Later Edition. revised by H. H. Swamiji. 3. Suddha-Sankara-Prakriya Bhaskara (Parts. I, II & IIi) Light on the Vedantic method accordiDi toSankara. ADHYATMA GRANTHAVALI The Unique Teaching of Shankar. (A Discussion on His Adhyaasa Bhaasbya) Original Writer in Kannada Sri Swamy Satchidanandendra Saraswathi Translator: Sri D. B. Gangolli Serial No. 186 Publishers: ADHVATMA PRAKASHA KARVALAVA Holenarsipur 1983 First Edition 1983 (Reprint from "Adhyatma Prakasha" ) All Rights Reserved by Publishers Printed at : PARTHASARATHI PRINTING WORKS. ca. B .....ne, Cot to n pet, 8angalON· leo 053 INTRODUCTION His Holiness Shri Satchidanandendra Saraswati Swamiji had written more than 15 books on Vedanta in English besides editing the book, "Vedanta or The Science of Reality", by the late K. A. Krishnaswamy· Iyer- He has also written masterly introduction in English to his own two magnificent Sanskrit works, viz.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction to the Non-Dualism Approach in Hinduism and Its Connection to Other Religions and Philosophies
    Introduction to the Non-dualism Approach in Hinduism and its Connection to Other Religions and Philosophies Sriram Ganapathi Subramanian [email protected] Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada Benyamin Ghojogh [email protected] Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada Abstract In this paper, we introduce the Hinduism reli- gion and philosophy. We start with introduc- 1. Introduction ing the holy books in Hinduism including Vedas Hinduism is a holy religion which is mostly based on logic and Upanishads. Then, we explain the simplis- and philosophy. Therefore, it is also called Hindu philos- tic Hinduism, Brahman, gods and their incarna- ophy. The religious leaders of Hinduism were all philoso- tions, stories of apocalypse, karma, reincarna- phers. A well-known example is Adi Shankara (Menon, tion, heavens and hells, vegetarianism, and sanc- 2004) who was a great philosopher. Hinduism has changed tity of cows. Then, we switch to the profound many lives and affected many people such as Steve Jobs Hinduism which is the main core of Hinduism (Lakin, 2015) before he founded the Apple company. and is monotheistic. In profound Hinduism, we Hinduism has two versions for two levels of truth which focus on the non-dualism or Advaita Vedanta ap- will be explained in this paper. The two versions are sim- proach in Hinduism. We discuss consciousness, plistic Hinduism and profound Hinduism. The simplistic causality, Brahman, psychology based on Hin- Hinduism is like a shell around the profound Hinduism duism, supportive scientific facts for Hinduism, which is the core.
    [Show full text]