Re s e a r c h Ar t i c l e s

A possible case of mimicry involving a heteropteran and an anuran tadpole

MARCO AURÉLIO P. HORTA1, ALAN LANE DE MELO2 and JAIME BERTOLUCI3,4

1 Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública, Rua Leopoldo Bulhões, 1480, Manguinhos, 21041-210, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil. 2 Laboratório de Taxonomia e Biologia de Invertebrados, Departamento de Parasitologia, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil.

3 Departamento de Ciências Biológicas, Escola Superior de Agricultura “Luiz de Queiroz”, Universidade de São Paulo, Av. Pádua Dias, 11, 13418-900, Piracicaba, SP, Brazil.

4 Corresponding author: [email protected]

ABSTRACT - We report on the occurrence of similar aposematic colour pattern between two phylogeneticaly unrelated aquatic organisms, an insect and a tadpole. The limnocorid Heteroptera Limnocoris porphyrus and tadpoles of the hylid frog Scinax machadoi are found in sympatry and syntopy in several streams in the Serra do Cipó, a pristine area located in the Espinhaço Range, Minas Gerais state, southeastern Brazil. The similarity between these two organisms makes it difficult to distinguish them at first sight. We suggest that they are possibly part of a process of Müllerian mimicry, but we recognize an evaluation of palatability and population size estimates are needed to ascertain our suggestions.

posematism, the use of bright colour Many organisms present bright or conspicuous Apatterns by noxious to deter predators, patterns of colour and observations under is a well-documented phenomenon in nature (Mallet experimental conditions simulating naive avian & Joron, 1999; Joron, 2003; Wüster et al., 2004). predators have shown how these species are In the evolutionary process of mimicry a species involved in so-called mimicry rings (Mallet & evolves coloration similar to another species. In Joron, 1999; Joron, 2003). Elucidating conditions Batesian mimicry a palatable prey species mimics favouring co-evolution in mimicry is one of the the appearance of a noxious species reducing its oldest problems in Evolutionary Biology (Gilbert, risk of being attacked. In Müllerian mimicry, 1983). This work presents a case of two sympatric two aposematic organisms conform to the same aquatic species, an insect and a frog tadpole. The aposematic signal to their mutual benefit (Joron, bright colour pattern of the insect and the tadpole is 2003). found in their early stages of its development. Predators learn to avoid brightly patterned The Serra do Espinhaço is a mountain range or otherwise conspicuous noxious prey items located in the states of Minas Gerais and Bahia, more rapidly than cryptic prey items (Guilford, Brazil, and observations have been made at two 1986; Rowe & Guilford, 2000), and consequently localities at 95 km in a straight line from each other. aposematism and/or Batesian mimicry have In Serra do Cipó (19º12’-19º20’ S, 43º30’-43º40’ usually been inferred in cases where the presumed W), a high altitudinal area covered by savanna mimic matches a brightly patterned model. Most vegetation, xeric habitats and an abundance of of aposematism theory is based on two-species sclerophylous plants. Above 900 m ASL campo interactions, with one noxious prey (the signaller) rupestre vegetation dominates with fragments and one predator (the receiver) (Wüster et al., of high altitude grassland vegetation (Ribeiro et 2004). al., 1990). Serra do Caraça (20º05’S, 43º28’W)

4 Number 114 - Herpetological Bulletin [2010] Aposematism in an insect and tadpole has altitudes between 900 and 2000 m ASL. It is Heteroptera, this group are the best adapted to characterised by Atlantic Rainforest and Savanna life in running water although many species live at low parts and campo rupestre vegetation at beneath or among submerged rocks or attached higher altitudes. to leaves and branches on the stream bottom. From surveys made between October Limnocoris is a widespread genus (Southeastern 1999 and October 2001, young instars of Brazil to Argentina) and the main representative of Limnocoris porphyrus Nieser & Lopez Ruf, 2001 subfamily Limnocorinae (Nieser & Melo, 1997). (Heteroptera, ) and tadpoles of Limnocoris porphyrus was only recently described Scinax machadoi (Bokermann & Sazima, from individuals collected in Serra do Cipó (Nieser 1973) (Anura, Hylidae) (Fig. 1) were & Lopez Ruf, 2001). Like the other members of the found sharing the same stream habitats. subfamily, L. porphyrus inhabits first and second order streams. These seem to be diurnal and are constantly moving on the rocks. The bright colour pattern is only present at the larval forms before the insect becomes adult. The young insects have a flattened-round body and non-developed wings covering the thorax. The body is yellowish with a single black stripe on the dorsal region over the pronotus. Adult body lengths averaged 7.8 (males) and 8.0 mm (females) (Nieser & Lopez Ruf, 2001). After its final moult,L. porphyrus loses its pattern and a brownish colour is observed for all adult forms that become cryptically colored. A behavioural change is also observed after last Figure 1. Larval stages of Scinax machadoi (Anura, Hylidae) and Limnocoris porphyrus (Heteroptera, moult. The adults were no longer found foraging Naucoridae) from Serra do Cipó, Southeastern Brazil. over the rocks. Bokermann & Sazima (1973) described Hyla In Serra do Cipó individuals of both species were machadoi, later considered as Scinax machadoi collected in streams of clear water with a depth of (Duellman & Wiens, 1992), and pointed out the about 40 cm and width varying between 1 and 3 peculiar coloration of tadpoles (see Figure 7 in m. In Córrego Indaiá, a stream located about 1400 Bokerman & Sazima, 1973). However, these authors m, the tadpoles and nymphs were found foraging considered the tadpole colour as cryptic in relation next to each other on rocks in the stream. Due to to its freshwater environment. The tadpoles were their initial resemblance it was almost impossible also considered as nocturnal animals but presenting for an observer to distinguish between them. Both some activity during the day (Bokermann & Sazima, were attached to the rocks and easily seen in the 1973). Like the naucorids, S. machadoi tadpoles flowing water. In sampled aquatic habitats few present an oval body in dorsal view. The body organisms were seen as easily as the ones from has a yellowish coloration with two black stripes this study though several other anuran and insect crossing it. The tail presents some conspicuous dark species also inhabit these streams (Nieser & Melo, dots visible mostly when laterally viewed. Most of 1997; Eterovick & Fernandes, 2001). The tadpoles the time they remain attached to stones or beneath of other anuran species that inhabit the freshwater aquatic vegetation. The tadpoles observed herein habitats are cryptically colored, except those of were observed close to the Limnocoris porphyrus Bufo rubescens, which are black and often observed bugs, becoming almost impossible to distinguish in schools of hundreds of individuals. them for an observer. The bright colour pattern of The Naucoridae, or creeping water bugs, are the tadpoles appeared to vary with age. Younger predatory insects common in tropical aquatic tadpoles had a more contrasting pattern in relation systems (Sites & Nichols, 1990). Among to the older ones. As individuals grow, the black

Herpetological Bulletin [2010] - Number 114 5 Aposematism in an insect and tadpole stripes became larger and the contrast between mimicry to be truly accepted it would be necessary black and yellow decreased. that the model organism would be more abundant Bokermann & Sazima (1973) observed S. than its mimic (Joron, 2003). Observations herein machadoi tadpoles throughout the year in freshwater indicate that L. porphyrus and S. machadoi habitats of Serra do Cipó. Information on population are equally abundant in the sampled streams. dynamics and distribution, life cycle, and larval Additional collections are needed to quantify their development may elucidate aspects involving a relative abundance throughout a defined period possible coevolution of aposematism. Natural of time. In cases of Batesian mimicry, simulated selection acting on larval forms might guarantee the models have shown that for mimicry to evolve it future of the adult forms, that are likely to undergo is necessary that the mimic approaches the model other selective pressures. Nevertheless, changes in faster than the model moves away and so long colour pattern may not mean lacking in protection. as the appearance of the two players is different Although bright colours and patterns may enhance (Holmgren & Enquist, 1999). predator learning, experiments using captive birds Müllerian mimics are sympatric aposematic have demonstrated that cryptic, noxious prey also species that share the same or similar warning gains protection against attack, albeit more slowly patterns. If a predator learns to avoid a warning than conspicuous prey (Sille´n-Tullberg, 1985). pattern of a species by a fixed number of encounters, Mallet & Joron (1999) argued that any pattern then Müllerian mimics benefit as fewer individuals could potentially generate predator avoidance, of each species would be killed educating naive provided it is recognisable and memorable, even predators (Skelhorn & Rowe, 2005). If observations if no conspicuous coloration is involved. Endler described in this paper would be a case of Müllerian & Mappes (2004) argued that conspicuous colours mimicry then it is expected that L. porphyrus and and patterns may have selective disadvantages. S. machadoi are noxious with similar abundance Such cases include those where an aposematic acting together to advertise noxious qualities to species has a specialist predator that can overcome a generalist predator. Skelhorn & Rowe (2005) its noxious features or the aposematic species is show that the presence of two defence chemicals itself a predator. Wüster et al. (2004) argued that in a Müllerian mimicry system enhances predator although it is in the signaller’s interest to advertise learning and memory. However, the authors point its noxious qualities to a generalist predator, it will out that this is only true if the species involved also be in its interest to avoid detection by specialist possess different defence chemicals. predators and by its own prey. Therefore if mimicry is occurring between Despite the phylogenetic distance between L. porphyrus and S. machadoi its proof is still L. porphyrus and S. machadoi, biotic and abiotic unanswered. We suggest that further investigations factors may create selective constraints that induce must define the system of mimicry and the involved these organisms to develop their bright colour species. If a mimicry system is acting behind the pattern. Duping predators can be the main reason aposematic pattern then observations and laboratory for a species to resemble another one. Nevertheless experiments should investigate the predators the resemblance between both species is not the involved (generalists and specifics) and the lack of only aspect involved in this study but also the bright colour pattern in adult L. porphyrus. Tests of aposematic coloration. Mimicry has an adaptive palatability and data on relative abundance would value when a predator learns which species is greatly further this interesting paradigm. unpalatable in association with its colour. Voucher specimens of insects were deposited That Batesian mimicry could be acting in in the collections of the Departamento de these organisms is possible if one of the species is Parasitologia, Universidade Federal de Minas palatable and resembles a protected noxious model, Gerais (DPIC, registered in ARNETT et al., 1993); followed by an accumulation and selection of vouchers specimens of tadpoles were deposited in characteristics that would progressively refine the the Herpetological Collection of the Departamento mimicry (Nijhout, 2003). However, for Batesian de Zoologia (UFMG).

6 Number 114 - Herpetological Bulletin [2010] Aposematism in an insect and tadpole

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 726. New York: Academic Press. The authors would like to thank the UFMG´s Mallet, J. & Joron, M. (1999). The evolution of Graduate Program in Ecology, Conservation and diversity in warning colour and mimicry: Management of Wildlife, Francisco A. Barbosa, polymorphisms, shifting balance, and speciation. Paula C. Eterovick, Paulo H.C. Corgosinho, and Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 30, 201-233. José Cassimiro for collection support, and CAPES Nieser, N. & Lopez Ruf, M. (2001). A review of and CNPq for financial support. JB is a CNPq Limnocoris Stal (Heteroptera: Naucoridae) in researcher. Southern South America East of the Andes. Tij. Entomol. 144, 261-328. REFERENCES Nieser, N. & Melo, A.L. (1997). Os Heterópteros Arnett-Jr., R.H., Samuelson, G.A. & Nishida, Aquáticos de Minas Gerais. Guia Introdutório G.M. (1993). The Insect and Spider Collections com Chaves de Identificação para as Espécies de of the World, 2nd Edition. Gainesville: Sandhill e Gerromorpha. Belo Horizonte, Crane Press, Inc. Editora UFMG. Bokermann, W.C.A. & Sazima, I. (1973). Anfíbios Nijhout, H.F. (2003). Polymorphic mimicry in da Serra do Cipó, Minas Gerais, Brasil. 1: duas Papilio dardanus: mosaic dominance, big espécies novas de Hyla (Anura, Hylidae). Rev. effects, and origins. Evol. Dev. 5, 579-592. Brasil. Biol. 33, 457-472. Ribeiro, S.P., Carneiro, M.A.A. & Fernandes, G. Duellman, W.E. & Wiens, J.J. (1992). The status of W. (1998). Free-feeding insect herbivores along the hylid frog genus Ololygon and the recognition environmental gradients in Serra do Cipó: basis of Scinax Wagler, 1830. Occ. Pap. Mus. Nat. for a management plan. J. Insect Cons. 2, 107- Hist. Univ. Kansas 191, 1-23. 118. Endler, J.A. & Mappes, J. (2004). Predator mixes Rowe, C. & Guilford, T. (2000). Aposematism: to and the conspicuousness of aposematic signals. be red or dead. Trends Ecol. Evol. 15, 261-262. Am. Nat. 163, 532-547. Sille´n-Tullberg, B. (1985). Higher survival of an Eterovick, P.C. & Fernandes, G.W. (2001). Tadpole aposematic than of a cryptic form of a distasteful distribution within montane meadow streams at bug. Oecologia 67, 411-415. the Serra do Cipó, southeastern Brazil: ecological Sites, R.W. & Nichols, B.J. (1990). Life history or phylogenetic constraints? J. Trop. Ecol. 17, and descriptions of immature stages of 683-693. Ambrysus lunatus lunatus (: Gilbert, L.E. (1983). Coevolution and Mimicry. Naucoridae). Ann. Entomol. Soc. Amer. 83, 800- In: Coevolution. D.J. Futuyma & M. Slatkin 808. (Eds.). Pp. 263-281. Sunderland: Sinauer Skelhorn, J. & Rowe, C. (2005). Tasting the Associates. difference: do multiple defence chemicals Guilford, T. (1986). How do ‘warning colours’ interact in Müllerian mimicry? Proc. R. Soc. B. work? Conspicuousness may reduce recognition 272, 339-345. errors in experienced predators. Anim. Behav. Wüster, W., Allum, C.S.E., Bjargardottir, I.B., 34, 286-288. Bailey, K.L, Dawson, K.J., Guenioui, J., Lewis, Holmgren, N.M.A. & Enquist, M. (1999). J., Mcgurk, J., Moore, A.G., Niskaneny, M., & Dynamics of mimicry evolution. Biol. J. Linn. Pollard, C.P. (2004). Do aposematism and Soc. 66, 145-158. Batesian mimicry require bright colours? A test Joron, M. (2003). Mimicry. In: Encyclopedia of using European viper markings. Proc. R. Soc. Insects. R.T. Carde & V.H. Resh (Eds.). Pp. 714- Lond. B 271, 2495-2499.

Herpetological Bulletin [2010] - Number 114 7