Ethnonational Identity and Detached Lives in a Serbian Province: a Study of Parallelism Among Vojvodina's Hungarian Community
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Portland State University PDXScholar Dissertations and Theses Dissertations and Theses 12-18-2019 Ethnonational Identity and Detached Lives in a Serbian Province: a Study of Parallelism Among Vojvodina's Hungarian Community Uros Prokic Portland State University Follow this and additional works at: https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/open_access_etds Part of the Eastern European Studies Commons, and the Public Policy Commons Let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Prokic, Uros, "Ethnonational Identity and Detached Lives in a Serbian Province: a Study of Parallelism Among Vojvodina's Hungarian Community" (2019). Dissertations and Theses. Paper 5413. https://doi.org/10.15760/etd.7286 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations and Theses by an authorized administrator of PDXScholar. Please contact us if we can make this document more accessible: [email protected]. Ethnonational Identity and Detached Lives in a Serbian Province: A Study of Parallelism Among Vojvodina’s Hungarian Community by Uros Prokic A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Public Affairs and Policy Dissertation Committee: David Kinsella, Chair Bruce Gilley Aleksandar Jokic Vandy Kanyako Portland State University 2020 © 2019 Uros Prokic Abstract Current theories of interethnic relations generally posit assimilation, integration and marginalization as possible outcomes between minority and dominant groups in Eastern Europe (Berry, 1974; Dimitras & Papanikolatos, 2002). However, there may be cases that are not adequately described by any of these existing interethnic relations paradigms. This dissertation explores one alternative, dubbed parallelism, which can be described as institutionally-driven self-isolation and detachment leading to communities living side by side on parallel trajectories and not interacting. Using the Hungarian ethnonational minority community in Serbia’s autonomous northern province of Vojvodina as a case study, I examine the institutional factors that have led to parallelism. Primary data from 23 interviews and a variety of secondary sources reveal that two institutional factors are responsible for the current dynamic: repeated policy oscillations on the issue of Vojvodina’s territorial and cultural autonomy and activism from the minority’s kin-state, Hungary. Contentions over Vojvodina’s autonomy act as the push factor, leading Hungarians in Vojvodina to self-isolate and cling to ingroup cultural markers, such as language. Hungary’s activism towards it’s kin-minority across borders, especially the 2001 “Status Law” and the Prosperitati economic assistance program, act as a pull factor, enticing Hungarians in Vojvodina to look to the Republic of Hungary for political, economic, social, and ethnic belonging. These mutually-reinforcing push and pull factors have ultimately resulted in a Vojvodinian Hungarians’ disassociation and detachment from the dominant group on a number of levels. In this case, parallelism may just present an optimal solution to maintain the status quo by managing minority nationalism without necessitating border revision and eroding state sovereignty. In this i particular case, parallelism has led to largely non-violent relations between Serbs and Hungarians in an otherwise tumultuous region. As there are currently very few in-depth studies of parallelism, elaborating on the factors that lead to such an outcome provides a useful case study that may be referenced when examining whether parallelism may exist in other contexts. ii Acknowledgments I am grateful to the members of the Hungarian community in Vojvodina who were so generous to take time out of their schedules to share their stories and perspectives with me for this research. It was an honor being invited into their homes and gaining a glimpse into their lives and experiences. Their hospitality and keenness to partake in this study was uplifting. I only hope that I have done justice to their perspectives and experiences by capturing and retelling them as adequately as possible in this study. I am indebted to my dissertation committee who have been wonderful mentors throughout this process. I am especially thankful to my dissertation chair, Dr. David Kinsella, for taking me under his stewardship throughout this entire process. His guidance, perseverance, and academic rigor have been invaluable in this experience; he always encouraged me to do better, to ponder the deeper questions and issues, and he inevitably provided me with a roadmap to my work. I am further thankful to Dr. Bruce Gilley for his enthusiasm, astute insight, and alternative approaches to thinking through issues; to Dr. Aleksandar Jokic for always forcing me to consider alternative perspectives and taking care to provide logically-coherent arguments; and to Dr. Vandy Kanyako for impressing on me the need to value the human experience in academic research. I am further thankful to my wife, Laura, for her loving support and motivation throughout this process. Our continuous discussions about my research, along with countless hours of copy-editing (several times over), have been invaluable in articulating the main ideas in this dissertation. I am blessed to be your husband, Laura Prokic. I could also not have accomplished this without the support of by fellows in the PAP program, especially Rebecca Jensen Craven who has been a wonderful colleague iii and counselor on this invaluable personal and academic journey. I would also like to thank kuma Mia Grijakovic for her translations, Dan Lyons for his copy-editing, Ethan Snyder for his encouragement, and my dear friend Chris Green for being such a trustworthy confidant throughout this process. Finally, none of this would have been possible without the immeasurable love and unconditional support of my parents, Miroslav and Gordana. My mother’s unwavering belief in me, even when I doubted myself, is humbling. As I wrote this dissertation I found myself reflecting on the intellectually stimulating discussions my mother and I used to have on our regular evening strolls. I am who I am because of my parents’ generous sacrifices. I am forever grateful for all that they have done, and continue to do for me. They are both my role models, and my only hope is that I have made them proud with this. My success is their success. iv Table of Contents Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………….i Acknowledgments………………………………………………………………………..iii List of Figures………..…………………………………………………………………....x Introduction – Parallel Lives in the Age of Retrenched Ethnonational Identities………...1 Prelude – A Glimpse of Life in the Village……………………………………………..1 Vojvodina – A Beacon for Stability Amid Interethnic Separateness…………………...4 Considering Acculturation Models…………………………………………………….10 The Argument.…………………………………………………………………………12 Roadmap to Conclusions………………………………………………………………18 Chapter I – Case Study Approach of Hungarian Community in Vojvodina…………….22 Methodology for Examining Hungarian Parallelism…………………………………..25 Chapter II – Issues of Identity in Vojvodina……………………………………………..30 Hungarian Ethnicity as Collective Identity Basis……………………………………...30 Hungarian Community in Vojvodina as Categorized “Narodnost”……………………32 Perspectives on Nationhood……………………………………………………………34 Modernist Perspective on Nations…………………………………………………34 Ethno-Symbolic Perspective on Nations…………………………………………..37 Hungarian Community in Vojvodina as an Ethnonationality……………………...39 Issue of National Identity………………………………………………………………40 Overarching Supranational Identity………………………………………………..45 Question of Vojvodinian Identity………………………………………………….46 v Ethnocultural, Multicultural and Liberal Pluralist Interpretation of Vojvodinian Identity……………………………………………………………………………..46 Chapter III – Parallelism…………………………………………………………………55 Questions Concerning Multiculturalism and Interculturalism in Vojvodina…………..57 Interethnic Dynamic of Parallelism……………………………………………………60 Parallelism for the Hungarian Community in Vojvodina……………………………...62 Parallelism Through Language…………………………………………………….75 Parallelism Through Education…………………………………………………….78 Parallelism Through Political Affiliation…………………………………………..82 Parallelism in Daily Life…………………………………………………………...83 Parallelism as a Result of Institutional Realities……………………………………….84 Parallelism as Institutional Outcome Versus Berry’s Self-Segregation Outcome…84 Factors Facilitating Hungarian Parallelism in Vojvodina………………………….87 Chapter IV – Historical Contentions Surrounding Vojvodinian Territorial and Cultural Autonomy………………………………………………………………………………..91 Amplitudes of Autonomy in Vojvodina……………………………………………….94 Preluding “Golden Age” of Vojvodinian Autonomy…………………………………..97 Vojvodina Before 1945………………………………………………………………...98 Voivodeship of Serbia and Banat of Temeschwar…………………………………98 Vojvodina and the First World War………………………………………………..99 Vojvodina in the Interwar Kingdom of Yugoslavia……………………………….99 Vojvodina and the Communist Party of Yugoslavia……………………………..107 Vojvodina and the Second World War…………………………………………...108 vi Vojvodina During the Communist Era……………………………………………….109 Vojvodina and the National Question in the FNRJ and Subsequent SFRJ……….109 Problem of Hungarian National Partiality in the FNRJ and SFRJ………………..116 Vojvodina in the FNRJ of the 1950s……………………………………………...118 Vojvodina – Administrative Region Versus Political Category………………….119 Debates Concerning Vojvodina’s Duties in 1967………………………………...121 Vojvodina and