Final Evaluation of the IUC Partner Programme with the Saint Louis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Flemish University Council – University Development Cooperation (VLIR‐UOS) Programme for Institutional University Cooperation (IUC) Final evaluation of the IUC partner programme with the Saint Louis University and the Benguet State University, Philippines Phase I and II (1999‐2008) FINAL REPORT – April 2010 Ad Boeren Dr Roberto Borromeo university cooperation for development sharing minds, changing lives Table of contents TABLE OF CONTENTS........................................................................................................................1 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..................................................................................................................3 FOREWORD BY THE TEAM LEADER...................................................................................................5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.....................................................................................................................6 1. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 10 1.1. BACKGROUND INFORMATION ON THE EVALUATION EXERCISE............................................................ 10 1.1.1. The IUC programme............................................................................................................. 10 1.1.2. The Terms of Reference eof th evaluation............................................................................ 12 1.1.3. The evaluation methodology ............................................................................................... 13 1.1.4. The evaluation activities undertaken................................................................................... 14 1.1.5. Structure of the evaluation report ....................................................................................... 14 1.2. CONTEXTUAL INFORMATION....................................................................................................... 14 1.2.1. The Philippines .....................................................................................................................14 1.2.2. The Cordillera Administrative Region................................................................................... 15 1.2.3. The Philippine Educational System ...................................................................................... 16 1.2.4. The Universities in the VLIR‐PIUC Programme..................................................................... 17 1.3. THE VLIR‐IUC PROGRAMME WITH SLU/BSU............................................................................... 20 2. EVALUATION FINDINGS: THE PROJECTS ...................................................................................... 24 2.1. PROJECT 1. STRENGTHENING THE SLU‐BSU NETWORK AND IUC PROGRAMME MANAGEMENT............ 24 2.2. PROJECT 2. INSTITUTIONAL MANAGEMENT AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT ‐SLU.....................................27 2.3. PROJECT 2. INSTITUTIONAL MANAGEMENT AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT ‐ BSU .................................. 30 2.4. PROJECT 3. ICT DEVELOPMENT ‐ SLU ......................................................................................... 33 2.5. PROJECT 3. ICT DEVELOPMENT ‐ BSU..........................................................................................37 2.6. PROJECT 4. LIBRARY DEVELOPMENT ‐ SLU ................................................................................... 40 2.7. PROJECT 4. LIBRARY DEVELOPMENT ‐ BSU................................................................................... 44 2.8. PROJECT 5. BUSINESS RESEARCH AND EXTENSION DEVELOPMENT ‐ SLU ............................................47 2.9. PROJECT 5. SOCIO‐ECONOMICS RESEARCH AND EXTENSION DEVELOPMENT ‐ BSU ............................. 51 2.10. PROJECT 6. HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT ‐ SLU............................................................................. 56 2.11. PROJECT 6. SEMI‐TEMPERATE VEGETABLE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ‐ BSU................................ 60 2.12. COMBINED PERFORMANCE ........................................................................................................ 64 3. EVALUATION FINDINGS: THE PROGRAMME................................................................................ 67 3.1. ADDED VALUE OF THE VLIR‐PIUC PROGRAMME............................................................................ 67 3.1.1. Regional and National Development Goals ......................................................................... 67 3.1.2. SLU and BSU Strategic Plans within the Context of National and Regional Development Goals.................................................................................................................................... 68 3.1.3. SLU and BSU Contributions to Regional and National Development Goals......................... 70 3.2. THE PIUC – SLU/BSU MANAGEMENT SET‐UP .............................................................................. 70 3.3. PLANNING AND PROGRAMMEMING............................................................................................. 71 3.4. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT ......................................................................................................... 73 3.5. MANAGEMENT CAPACITY IMPROVEMENTS.................................................................................... 75 3.6. INTER‐UNIVERSITY COOPERATION .................................................................................................76 3.7. LESSONS LEARNED FROM IMPLEMENTATION.................................................................................. 77 3.8. THE COOPERATION MODEL......................................................................................................... 78 Final evaluation of the IUC partner programme with SLU and BSU, Philippines 1/102 3.9. CONTINUED COLLABORATION ..................................................................................................... 79 3.10. VLIR‐IUC IN COMPARISON TO OTHER DONOR FUNDED COOPERATION PROGRAMMES .......................... 79 3.11. SUMMARIZING ........................................................................................................................ 80 4. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.................................................................................. 82 4.1. CONCLUSIONS ......................................................................................................................... 82 4.2. RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................................................ 82 ANNEX 1. PROGRAMME OF THE VISIT AND PERSONS ATTENDING ................................................. 84 ANNEX 2. CONTEXTUAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE PHILIPPINES, THE CORDILLERAS ADMINISTRATIVE REGION, AND THE EDUCATION SYSTEM IN THE PHILIPPINES.............. 88 ANNEX 3. SCHOLARSHIPS AND TRAINING PROVIDED UNDER PIUC................................................. 94 ANNEX 4. REFERENCES ................................................................................................................ 100 Final evaluation of the IUC partner programme with SLU and BSU, Philippines 2/102 List of abbreviations AP Activity Programme AVRDC Asian Vegetable Research and Development Centre BOR Board of Regents BREAD Business Research, Extension And Development BSU Benguet State University CAR Cordillera Administrative Region CARRDP The Cordillera Regional Development Plan CEA College of Engineering and Architecture (SLU) CHE Chemical Engineering CHED Commission on Higher Education CICM Congregation of the Immaculate Heart of Mary CICS College of Information and Computing Sciences CNS College of Natural Sciences (SLU) COD Centre of Development COE Centre of Excellence DipHEM Diploma for Higher Education Management ECE Electronics and Communications Engineering EE Electrical Engineering EISSIF Institute of Small‐Scale Industries Foundation ESPOL Escuela Superior Politecnica del Litoral ERL/EURFL Environmental Research Lab/ Engineering Urban Planning Research Lab or EUPRL not EURFL EU European Union GDP Gross Domestic Product GIS Geographic Information System GNP Gross National Product GRDP Gross Regional Domestic Product HORTI Horticulture Research and Training Institute HRD Human Resource Development HRDO Human Resource and Development Office ICOS Institutional Coordinators for University Development Cooperation ICT Information and Communications Technology ICTP International Centre for Theoretical Physics ICTRL Information and Communications Technology Research Laboratory IE Industrial Engineering IEC Information and Education Campaign IFLIS Institute for Foreign Languages and International Studies IHFSA Institute of Highland Farming Systems ando Agr forestry ILS Integrated Library System IMFG International Monsanto Fund Grant IPs Indigenous Peoples IQUAAO Institutional Quality Assurance and Accreditation Office IRO International Relations Office ISRD Institute of Social Research and Development Final evaluation of the IUC partner programme with SLU and BSU, Philippines 3/102 IUC Programme for Institutional University Cooperation JSCM Joint Steering Committee Meeting KRA Key Result Area KULeuven Katholieke Universiteit Leuven LAN Local Area Network LET Licensure Examination for Teachers ME Mechanical Engineering MEP Masters in Engineering Programme MOA Memorandum of Agreement MOPG Manual of Operating Procedures and Guidelines MOU Memorandum of Understanding MSc Master of Science