Towards a Macrosociology of Dialogic Globalization
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Critical Rationalism And Macrosociology of Globalisation By Masoud Mohammadi Alamuti Submitted to the Graduate School Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences in a partial fulfillment of the requirements for The degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Politics The School of Geography, Politics and Sociology Department of Politics Newcastle University June 2011 Critical Rationalism And Macrosociology of Globalisation i Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................. vi Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................ vii Part I: A Critical Rationalist Approach to Globalisation Chapter 1 Principal Argument and Thesis Structure 1.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Principal Argument ......................................................................................................... 7 1.3 Thesis Structure ............................................................................................................... 23 Chapter 2 Critical Rationalism and Research Methodology 2.1 The Nature of a (Historical) Macrosociology of Globalisation .................................... 30 2.2 Critical Rationalism and the Logic of the Social Sciences ........................................... 32 2.1.1 Historical Background of Popper’s Conjectural Theory of Knowledge ............................. 34 2.2.2 The Two Contexts of the Logic of Scientific Discovery ................................................ 37 2.2.3 From ‘Empirical Falsificationism’ to ‘Inter-Subjective Criticism’ ............................... 39 2.2.4 The Situational Analysis and the Hermeneutic Logic of the Social Sciences ................ 40 2.3 A Critical Rationalist Approach to Critical Social Theory ......................................... 49 2.3.1 Adorno’s Critique of Popper’s Logic of the Social Sciences ........................................ 50 2.3.2 Critical Rationalism and the Logic of Critical Social Sciences ..................................... 53 2.4 The Logic of Macrosociology of Globalisation: A Critical Rationalist Approach .... 57 Part II: Introducing the Idea of Open Global Society Chapter 3 Three Normative Critiques of Contemporary Globalisation 3.1 David Held’s Normative Critique of Globalisation ...................................................... 63 3.1.1 The Ideal Type of Global Social Democracy ................................................................. 63 3.1.2 Globalisation as a Shift in the Scale of Human Organisation ......................................... 66 3.1.3 Globalisation’s Democratic Deficit ............................................................................... 69 ii 3.1.4 The Problematic Nature of Held’s Normative Critique ................................................. 70 3.2 Richard Falk’s Normative Critique of Globalisation ................................................... 71 3.2.1 The Ideal Type of Humane Global Governance ............................................................ 72 3.2.2 Globalisation-From-Above: Liberal Ideology and Capitalist Interests .......................... 73 3.2.3 The Absence of a People-Driven Globalisation.............................................................. 74 3.2.4 Falk’s Normative Critique: A Weak Link between ‘Culture’ and ‘Politics’ .................. 77 3.3 Jürgen Habermas’ Normative Critique of Globalisation ............................................. 77 3.3.1 The Ideal Type of Dialogic World Society ..................................................................... 78 3.3.2 Globalisation as the Emergence of a Post-National Constellation.................................. 79 3.3.3 Globalisation’s Societal Deficits: Culture, Politics and Economy.................................. 83 3.3.4 Communicative Rationality and Dialogue of Civilisations ............................................ 86 Chapter 4 The Ideal Type of an Open Global Society 4.1 Critical Rationalism and Popper’s Philosophy of the Open Society ........................... 90 4.1.1 Critical Rationalism and the Conception of Human Nature ........................................... 90 4.1.2 Critical Rationalism and the Meaning of Open Society ................................................. 93 4.1.3 Critical Rationalism and Social Philosophy of the Open Society ................................... 98 4.2. Critical Rationalism and the Ideal Type of an Open Global Society ......................... 99 4.2.1 Developing Popper’s Normative Conception of the Person ........................................... 100 4.2.2 Epistemology and Social Philosophy of an Open Global Society .................................. 104 4.2.3 An Institutional Outlook for an Open Global Society .................................................... 115 4.3 Towards the Normative Vision of a Dialogic Globalisation ......................................... 119 Part III: Developing a Critical Macrosociology of Globalisation Chapter 5 Towards an Analytical Framework for a Macrosociology of Globalisation 5.1 Introducing a Critical Rationalist Model of Human Action ........................................ 123 5.1.1 Three Competing Models of Human Action .................................................................. 123 5.1.2 Critical Rationalism and the Origins of Action-Goals .................................................... 137 5.2 Critical Rationality and Social Learning for Building an Open Society ..................... 144 5.2.1 A Critical Rationalist Model of Social Learning ............................................................ 144 5.2.2 Civil Society and Social Learning for Creating an Open Society ................................... 155 5.3 Macrosociology of Globalisation: A Critical Rationalist Analytical Model .............. 158 iii Chapter 6 A New Macrosociology of Contemporary Globalisation 6.1 Two Competing Approaches to Globalisation .............................................................. 161 6.1.1 Globalisation as the Expansion of Global Interconnectivity .......................................... 161 6.1.2 Globalisation as the Emergence of Institutions of Planetary Scope ............................... 163 6.2 Global Social Learning: An Epistemic-Institutional Approach to Globalisation ...... 164 6.3 The Emergence of Global Liberalism: A Global Epistemic Shift................................ 165 6.3.1 Towards a Cultural History of the Western Liberal-Democracy .................................... 166 6.3.2 The Emergence of the Western Liberal-Democracies’ Bloc .......................................... 178 6.4 The Cultural Logic of Global Liberalism and Political Collapse of the Cold War .... 180 6.4.1 The Emergence of a Bipolar Political Order................................................................... 180 6.4.2 The Cultural Logic of a Bipolar Cold War and Its Political Outcomes .......................... 182 6.4.3 Inter-Bloc Social Learning and Institutional Reforms .................................................... 185 6.4.4 The Collapse of the Cold War and the Emergence of Global Governance ..................... 188 6.5 The End of the Cold War and the Emergence of a Transnational Economy ............. 192 6.5.1 The Liberal Logic of Economic Competition ................................................................. 192 6.5.2 The Cultural Politics of the Emergence of a Transnational Economy ............................ 194 6.5.3 Economic Dynamics of the Transnational Economy ...................................................... 195 Chapter 7 Unsocial Sociability of Liberal Globalisation 7.1 A Critical Review of Liberal Social Philosophy ............................................................ 201 7.1.1 From Locke’s Theological Liberalism to Hume-Smith’s Secular Liberalism ................ 201 7.1.2 Friedrich Hayek, Human Ignorance, and a Liberal Society ............................................ 204 7.1.3 John Rawls, Political Liberalism, and a Well-Ordered Society ...................................... 207 7.1.4 A Kantian-Inspired Critique of Liberal Democracy ....................................................... 212 7.2 The Cultural Shortfalls of Liberal Globalisation .......................................................... 217 7.3 The Political Insufficiencies of Liberal Globalisation ............................................... 218 7.4 The Economic Deficits of Liberal Globalisation ........................................................... 221 7.5 A Macrosociological Critique of Liberal Globalisation ................................................ 226 Chapter 8 Towards a Dialogic Globalisation: The Formation of an Open Global Society 8.1 The Cultural Logics of Civilisational Formation .......................................................... 231 8.1.1 Civilisations as ‘Highest Cultural Grouping of People’ ................................................. 231 8.1.2 ‘Rationale Systems’ and the ‘Logics of Cultural Grouping’ of People .......................... 238 iv 8.2 ‘Rationality’ and ‘Social Organisation’ in Three World Civilisations........................ 241 8.2.1 Islamic Civilisation: The Wisdom of God and Islamic Social Order ............................. 247 8.2.2 Western Civilisation: Liberal Wisdom and Liberal Democracy ....................................