Reviewed: Ward/Superward: 4/7 Ief Deputy

To the Honorable Council December 11, 2018 City of Norfolk, Virginia

From: George M. Homewood, FAICP, CFM, Planning Director ,._/VS.

Subject: Aldi, c., for a Conditional Use Permit for the Sale of Alcoholic Beverages, Off- Pr ises at 1050 N. Milit ry Highway. Reviewed: Ward/Superward: 4/7

ief Deputy City Manager Approved: Item Number: C-1 , City Manager

I. Staff Recommendation: Approval.

II. Planning Commission Recommendation: By a vote of 6 to 0, the Planning Commission recommends Approval.

Request: Conditional Use Permit to allow for the sale of alcoholic beverages for off-premises consumption.

III. Applicant: Aldi, Inc.

IV. Description: • The site is located along N. Military Highway, just north of the intersection with E. Virginia Beach Boulevard and adjacent to the JANAF shopping center. • The building on the site was most recently occupied by Uptown Buffet. • Granting this request will allow Aldi, a proposed grocery store, to offer alcoholic beverages for off-premises consumption. • The Zoning Ordinance allows Grocery Stores that are larger than 15,000 sq. ft. to sell alcoholic beverages for off-premises consumption in packages containing a minimum of six bottles or cans by-right. • A Conditional Use Permit must be obtained if a Grocery Store proposes to offer packages with less than six bottles or cans. o Aldi proposes to sell beer in four-packs, six-packs, twelve-packs, and 24- packs.

810 UNION STREET, SUITE 1 1 0 1 • NORFOLK VIRGINIA 23510 . 757-664-4242 www.norfokgov Proposed Hours of Operation and for the 8:00 a.m. until 9:00 p.m., Sale of Alcoholic Beverages for Seven days a week Off-Premises Consumption • No less than 4-packs of beer • Specialty-sized single servings of beer Off-Premises Alcohol Types (12 oz. — 32 oz.) • No less than 375 ml. wine

Staff contact: Chris Whitney at (757) 823-1253, [email protected]

Attachments: • Proponents and Opponents • Staff Report to CPC dated November 15, 2018 with attachments • Ordinance THE CITYITYOF

NORFO L ., CITY PLANNING City Planning Commission Public Hearing: November 15 2018 cxecutive Secretary: Leonard M. Newcomb, Ill, CFM Staff Planner: Chris Whitney, CZA, CFM CtLi,

Staff Report Item No. 9 Address 1050 N. Military Highway Applicant Aldi, Inc.

Request Conditional Use Permit Sale of Alcoholic Beverages, Off-Premises

Property Owner The American Heart Association, Inc. Site/Building Area 3.9 acres/21,659 sq. ft. (proposed) Future Land Use Map Commercial C-R (Regional Commercial), JANAF-LASO Site Characteristics Zoning (JANAF Shopping Center Localized Alternative Sign Overlay) Neighborhood N/A Character District Suburban North C-R: Verizon retail store East C-R: JANAF Shopping Center Surrounding Area South C-R: Logan's Roadhouse restaurant C-C: Lowe's Home Improvement store, West Chipotle, Sprint retail store, Aspen Dental

‘ ...- ., .

r ...... - „ :. r '4C' r" . ,: ;.::14 ,- • ..,.. .,..• • /A4',4' , • - ., .,• f•4 ,,.-" _, ••.. '. ..•!......

• • . r. 6- •• --'s, ''

At. .. tot . •,. .., 1%.- is -At .. %.7•1 ...... e ...._ _.. .,...4.406

, , — _ - ---- —.-,S f'" -1160,_. - i , , 18 Pictometry A. Summary of Request • The site is located along N. Military Highway, just north of the intersection with E. Virginia Beach Boulevard and adjacent to the JANAF shopping center. • The building on the site was most recently occupied by Uptown Buffet. • Granting this request will allow Aldi, a proposed grocery store, to offer alcoholic beverages for off-premises consumption. o The request includes the ability to offer beer in packages containing a minimum of four bottles or cans.

B. Plan Consistency The proposed use is consistent with plallorfolk2030, which designates this site as Commercial.

C. Zoning Analysis i. General • The site is zoned C-R, which permits this use with a Conditional Use Permit. • The Zoning Ordinance allows Grocery Stores that are larger than 15,000 sq. ft. to sell alcoholic beverages for off-premises consumption in packages containing a minimum of six bottles or cans by-right. • A Conditional Use Permit must be obtained if an establishment proposes to offer packages with less than six bottles or cans. o Aldi proposes to sell beer in four-packs, six-packs, twelve-packs, and 24-packs.

Proposed

Hours of Operation and for the 8:00 a.m. until 9:00 p.m., Sale of Alcoholic Beverages for Seven days a week Off-Premises Consumption • No less than 4-packs of beer • Specialty-sized single servings of beer Off-Premises Alcohol Types (12 oz. — 32 oz.) • No less than 375 ml. wine

• History

City Council Approval Applicant Changes Special Exception — Eating and 2002 Old Town Super Buffet Drinking Establishment Conditional Use Permit — Sale of Pending Aldi, Inc. Alcoholic Beverages, Off- Premises (new Grocery Store) ii. Parking The City's Site Plan Review process will ensure that the location and amount of parking meets Zoning Ordinance requirements.

iii. Flood Zone The property is located in the X (Low to Moderate) Flood Zone, which is a low-to- moderate-risk flood zone.

D. Transportation Impacts • Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) figures estimate that the proposed new grocery store will generate 1,829 vehicle trips per day. • N. Military Highway and E. Virginia Beach Boulevard adjacent to the site are identified as severely congested corridors in the current update to regional Hampton Roads Congestion Management analysis. • The site is near transit service with Hampton Roads Transit bus routes 15, 20 and 23 operating along N. Military Highway and E. Virginia Beach Boulevard near the site. • N. Military Highway and E. Virginia Beach Boulevard adjacent to the site are not identified priority corridors in the City of Norfolk Bicycle and Pedestrian Strategic Plan.

E. Historic Resources Impacts The site is not located in any local, state, or federal historic district.

F. Public Schools Impacts According to the Existing ABC Establishments and Norfolk Public Schools Proximity Map (see attached), the proposed property is not within 1,000 feet of a Norfolk Public School.

G. Environmental Impacts The new Grocery Store will undergo the Site Plan Review process, which will ensure compliance with all standards set forth in the Zoning Ordinance, including landscaping, perimeter buffering, and stormwater management.

H. AICUZ Impacts N/A

I. Surrounding Area/Site Impacts The site is surrounded by a mix of commercial uses.

J. Payment of Taxes The owner of the property is current on all taxes.

K. Civic League • The application was sent to the Lake Taylor Civic League on October 2. • An email of support was received from the Lake Taylor Civic League on September 20. L. Communication Outreach/Notification • Legal notice was posted on the property on October 9. • Letters were mailed to all property owners within 300 feet of the property on November 1. • Legal notification was placed in The Virginian-Pilot on November 1 and November 8.

M. Recommendation Staff recommends that the Conditional Use Permit request be approved subject to the conditions shown below:

(a) The hours of operation for the sale of alcoholic beverages for off-premises consumption shall be limited to 8:00 a.m. until 9:00 p.m., seven days a week.

(b) This conditional use permit shall terminate in the event of a change in ownership of the establishment and may be revoked in the event of a change in the operation of the establishment as described in the Description of Operations set forth in "Exhibit A," attached hereto, provided that no termination in the event of a change in ownership of the establishment shall be effective until 120 days after the change or until a new conditional use permit is granted showing the new owner, whichever is earlier.

(c) No alcoholic beverages other than those defined as "beer," "wine," "wine cooler," or "low alcohol beverage cooler," as defined by state law, shall be sold.

(d) No alcoholic beverage having more than 21% alcohol by volume shall be sold.

(e) No beer shall be sold in any package containing fewer than four (4) bottles or cans, with the exception of those bottled beers which are exclusively produced in bottles greater than 12 ounces but less than 32 ounces in size. No wine shall be sold in containers less than 375 ml each.

(f) The facility shall maintain a current, active business license at all times while in operation.

(g) The business authorized by this conditional use permit shall be conducted in accordance with the Description of Operations set forth in "Exhibit A," attached hereto. The representations made in "Exhibit A" shall be binding upon all owners, operators and managers who operate and/or manage the premises covered by this conditional use permit. Should any owner, operator or manager desire to operate the business in a manner different than as represented in "Exhibit A," a new conditional use permit must be obtained prior to any such change. Where any limitation or representation contained in "Exhibit A" is inconsistent with any condition of this ordinance, the conditions of this ordinance shall govern.

(h) The violation of any requirement, limitation, or restriction imposed by the Virginia ABC Commission shall be deemed a violation of this conditional use permit. This conditional use permit may be revoked for any violation of a general or specific condition, including a condition incorporated by reference and including a condition arising from requirements, limitations, or restrictions imposed by the ABC Commission or by Virginia law.

(i) A copy of this conditional use permit ordinance and "Exhibit A" shall be available on site at all times for inspection, and a notice indicating that this conditional use permit ordinance and all amendments are kept on the premises and are available for review by any member of the general public shall be posted in a visible location. The notice shall also contain information on where and how to report violations of conditions and shall include the address of the zoning administrator.

(j) During all hours of operation, the establishment operator shall be responsible for maintaining those portions of public rights-of-way improved by sidewalk and portions of any parking lot adjacent to the premises regulated by the conditional use permit so as to keep such areas free of litter, refuse, and both solid and liquid waste.

(k) At all times, all temporary window signage must comply with the applicable regulations of section 5.7 of the Norfolk Zoning Ordinance.

Attachments: Conditional Use Permit Review Standards Overview map Location map Zoning map 1000' radii map of similar ABC establishments and Norfolk Public Schools Application Notification list of all property owners within 300 feet of the site Notice to the Lake Taylor Civic League Email of support from the Lake Taylor Civic League Proponents and Opponents

Proponents Mark Boyd — Applicant 1700 Willow Lawn Drive, Suite 200 Richmond, VA 23230

Justin Spruill — Applicant 4600 Singing Bird Drive Moseley, VA 23120

Opponents None 11/13/2018 1sb

Form and Correctness App Contents Approved: Co3

By Office of the City Attorney NORFOLK, VIRGINIA

ORDINANCE No.

AN ORDINANCE GRANTING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT AUTHORIZING THE SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES FOR OFF- PREMISES CONSUMPTION AT AN ESTABLISHMENT NAMED "ALDI" ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1050 NORTH MILITARY HIGHWAY.

- - -

BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Norfolk:

Section 1:- That a conditional use permit is hereby granted to Aldi, Inc. authorizing the accessory use of the sale of alcoholic beverages, off-premises, at an establishment named "Aldi."

Section 2:- That the full extent of the property or properties where the permit or permits described above are hereby made effective, upon the date set forth below, is described as follows:

Property fronts 250 feet, more or less, along the eastern line of North Military Highway beginning 705 feet more or less, from the northern line of East Virginia Beach Boulevard and extending northwardly; premises numbered 1050 North Military Highway.

Section 3: - That the conditional use permit or permits granted herein shall be subject to all of the general conditions set forth in section 2.4.8.D of the Norfolk Zoning Ordinance and all of the following additional conditions, requirements, and limitations:

(a) The operation of the principal use of Grocery store must be conducted in accordance with the applicable performance standards that are set forth in section 4.2 of the Norfolk Zoning Ordinance in effect at the time of the adoption of this ordinance.

(b) The hours of operation for the sale of alcoholic beverages for off-premises consumption shall be limited to 8:00 a.m. until 9:00 p.m., seven days a week. (c) This conditional use permit shall terminate in the event of a change in ownership of the establishment and may be revoked in the event of a change in the operation of the establishment as described in the Description of Operations set forth in "Exhibit A," attached hereto, provided that no termination in the event of a change in ownership of the establishment shall be effective until 120 days after the change or until a new conditional use permit is granted showing the new owner, whichever is earlier.

(d) No alcoholic beverages other than those defined as "beer," "wine," "wine cooler," or "low alcohol beverage cooler," as defined by state law, shall be sold.

(e) No alcoholic beverage having more than 21% alcohol by volume shall be sold.

(f) All beer sold for off-premises consumption shall be in a package containing a minimum of four (4) bottles or cans, with the exception of those bottled beers which are exclusively produced in bottles greater than 12 ounces but less than 32 ounces in size. All wine shall be sold in containers with a minimum of 375 ml each.

(g) The facility shall maintain a current, active business license at all times while in operation.

(h) The business authorized by this conditional use permit shall be conducted in accordance with the Description of Operations set forth in "Exhibit A," attached hereto. The representations made in "Exhibit A" shall be binding upon all owners, operators and managers who operate and/or manage the premises covered by this conditional use permit. Should any owner, operator or manager desire to operate the business in a manner different than as represented in "Exhibit A," a new conditional use permit must be obtained prior to any such change. Where any limitation or representation contained in "Exhibit A" is inconsistent with any condition of this ordinance, the conditions of this ordinance shall govern.

2 (i) The violation of any requirement, limitation, or restriction imposed by the Virginia ABC Commission shall be deemed a violation of this conditional use permit. This conditional use permit may be revoked for any violation of a general or specific condition, including a condition incorporated by reference and including a condition arising from requirements, limitations, or restrictions imposed by the ABC Commission or by Virginia law.

(j) A copy of this conditional use permit ordinance and "Exhibit A" shall be available on site at all times for inspection, and a notice indicating that this conditional use permit ordinance and all amendments are kept on the premises and are available for review by any member of the general public shall be posted in a visible location. The notice shall also contain information on where and how to report violations of conditions and shall include the address of the zoning administrator.

(k) During all hours of operation, the establishment operator shall be responsible for maintaining those portions of public rights-of-way improved by sidewalk and portions of any parking lot adjacent to the premises regulated by the conditional use permit so as to keep such areas free of litter, refuse, and both solid and liquid waste.

(1) At all times, all temporary window signage must comply with the applicable regulations of section 5.7 of the Norfolk Zoning Ordinance.

Section 4:- That the City Council hereby determines that the conditional use permit or permits granted herein comply with each of the standards set forth in section 2.4.8.0 of the Norfolk Zoning Ordinance.

Section 5:- That this ordinance shall be in effect from the date of its adoption.

ATTACHMENT: Exhibit A (2 pages)

3 EXHIBIT "A" Description of Operations Sale of Alcoholic Beverages, Off-Premises

Date of Application: 10/01/18

Name of business: Aldi Inc.

Address of business: 1050 North Military Highway Norfolk, VA 23502

Name(s) of business owner(s)*: Aldi Inc., Justin Spruill

Name(s) of property owner(s)*: American Heart Association, Inc.

Name of business managers/operators Justin Spruill, Director of Real Estate - Atk

Daytime telephone number: ( 804 ) 362-0828

*If business or property owner is partnership, all partners must be listed. *If business or property owner is an LLC or Corporation, all principals must be listed.

1. Proposed Hours of Operation:

Facility Alcoholic Beverage Sales Weekday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM Weekday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM

Friday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM Friday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM

Saturday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM Saturday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM

Sunday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM Sunday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM

2. Type of alcoholic beverage applied for: X Beer X Wine C Mixed Beverage

3. Alcoholic beverages to be sold: X Room temperature NI Refrigerated

DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING 810 Union Street, Room 508 Norfolk, Virginia 23510 Telephone (757) 664-4752 Fax (757) 441-1569 (Revised July, 2018) Exhibit A — Page 2 Sale of Alcoholic Beverages, Off-Premises

4. As a general rule, the City does not approve selling beer in a single-sized serving container or selling wine in a bottle that is less than 375 milliliters. If you are seeking approval to sell servings that do not meet these criteria, please explain your justification as well as indicate what sizes you would sell:

Beer will be sold in 4-packs, 6-packs, 12-packs, and 24-packs.

Wine will be sold in single bottles (750 mL).

— • Signature of applicant/owner

DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING 810 Union Street, Room 508 Norfolk, Virginia 23510 Telephone (757) 664-4752 Fax (757) 441-1569 (Revised July, 2018) 2.4.8.C. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT REVIEW STANDARDS

A Conditional Use Permit may be approved if the applicant demonstrates that the proposed conditional use:

1) Is consistent with the purposes, goals and policies of the comprehensive plan and other applicable city-adopted plans;

2) Complies with all applicable zoning district-specific standards in Article 3. Zoning Districts;

3) Complies with all applicable use-specific standards in Article 4. Performance Standards;

4) Complies with all applicable development and design standards in Article 5. Development Standards;

5) Complies with all relevant subdivision and infrastructure standards in Chapter 42.5 of City Code;

6) Is appropriate for its location and is compatible with the general character of surrounding lands and the types, scale, and intensity of uses allowed in the zoning district where proposed;

7) Adequately screens, buffers, or otherwise minimizes adverse visual impacts on adjacent lands;

8) Avoids significant adverse odor, noise, glare, and vibration impacts on surrounding lands regarding refuse collection, service delivery, parking and loading, signs, lighting, night-time activity, and other site elements;

9) Avoids significant deterioration of water and air resources, scenic resources, and other natural resources;

10) Maintains safe and convenient ingress and egress and traffic flow onto and through the site by vehicles and pedestrians, and safe road conditions around the site;

11) Is served adequately by essential public facilities and services such as streets, public utilities, drainage structures, police and fire protection, refuse disposal, parks, libraries, and schools;

12) Maintains adequate parking, loading and other necessary facilities to serve the proposed use;

13) Will not substantially diminish or impair the value of the land within the neighborhood in which it is located.

14) Will not cause a negative cumulative effect, when its effect is considered in conjunction with the cumulative effect of various Conditional Use Permits of all types on the immediate neighborhood and the effect of the proposed type of Conditional Use Permit on the city as a whole;

15) Complies with all other relevant city, state and federal laws and standards; and

16) Is required by the public necessity, convenience, general welfare, or good zoning practice. Overview Map

Jinaf Library

w 1 >- cG LANE MERIDIAN .73 z CC

:77 '73

E VIRGINIA BEACH BOULEVARD Z

2 C IJJ 0 0_ cc 1- MCCABE LANE} z RING RO/ 0 105 210 420 IMINCEMIFeet _

Existing ABC Establishments & Norfolk Public Schools Proximity Map

BJS WHOLESALE CLUB 180

)APPLEBEES NEIGHBO Norfolk Public School On-Premises closing time before 12AM • On-Premises closing time 12-1:45AM • On-Premises closing time 2AM After Hours Club E VIRGINIA H BOULEVARD Off-Premises

0 80 160 320 CIIMMIFeet I I 1 Application Conditional Use Permit Sale of Alcoholic Beverages, Off-Premises (Please Print)

Date 10/01/18

DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY

Address: 1050 North Military Highway

Existing Use of Property: Commercial - Resturant

Proposed Use: Commercial - Grocery Store

Current Building Square Footage: 10,075 Proposed Building Square Footage: 19,209 (21,659 with expansion) Trade Name of Business (if applicable): Aldi Inc.

APPLICANT*

1. Name of applicant: (Last) Spruill (First) Justin (MI)

Mailing address of applicant (Street/P.O. Box): 6801 Aldi Way

(City): Petersburg (State): VA (Zip Code): 23803

Daytime telephone number of applicant: (804) 362-0828

E-mail address: [email protected]

AUTHORIZED AGENT* (if applicable)

2. Name of applicant: (Last) (First) (MI)

Mailing address of applicant (Street/P.O. Box):

(City): (State): (Zip Code):

Daytime telephone number of applicant: ( ) Fax ( )

E-mail address:

DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING 810 Union Street, Room 508 Norfolk, Virginia 23510 Telephone (757) 664-4752 Fax (757) 441-1569 (Revised July, 2018) Application Conditional Use Permit - Sale of Alcoholic Beverages, Off-Premises Page 2

PROPERTY OWNER* VQN1-/R kF , 3. Name of property owner: (Last) (First) (MI)

Mailing address of property owner (Street/P.O. box): V tricot ik I o— BeAtt,L-... 61 VOL

(City): VIvrtki us. e>ear..AA- (State): Vtrzt,...t (Zip Code): z3,-f- z-

Daytime telephone number of owner: (1.l) (02-7 -ctoee

E-mail address: af'Y'CLA--iiii v•-9/ 0.-*Lr. ak.s

*(If applicant/agent/property owner is a LLC or a Corp./Inc., include name of official representative and/or all partners)

CIVIC LEAGUE INFORMATION

Civic League contact: Steve Mirman, Lake Taylor Civic League President

Date meeting attended/held: Thursday 09/20/18

Ward/Super Ward information: Ward 4/Super Ward 7

CERTIFICATION I hereby submit this complete application and certify the information contained herein is true and accurate to the best of my knowledge:

Print name: /0•41,04:41.../ FR-An.P4.4..> e'd Sign: 1/2- Yfi g (Property Owner) (Date)

Print name: / I Sign: (Applicant) (Date)

(If Applicable)

Print name: Sign: (Authorized Agent Signature) (Date)

DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING 810 Union Street, Room 508 Norfolk, Virginia 23510 Telephone (757) 664-4752 Fax (757) 441-1569 (Revised July. 2018)

EXHIBIT "A" Description of Operations Sale of Alcoholic Beverages, Off-Premises

Date of Application: 10/01/18

Name of business: Aldi Inc.

Address of business: 1050 North Military Highway Norfolk, VA 23502

Name(s) of business owner(s)*: Aldi Inc., Justin Spruill

Name(s) of property owner(s)*: American Heart Association, Inc.

Name of business managers/operators Justin Spruill, Director of Real Estate —

Daytime telephone number: ( 804 )362-0828

*If business or property owner is partnership, all partners must be listed. *If business or property owner is an LLC or Corporation, all principals must be listed.

1. Proposed Hours of Operation:

Facility Alcoholic Beverage Sales Weekday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM Weekday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM

Friday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM Friday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM

Saturday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM Saturday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM

Sunday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM Sunday From: 8 AM To: 9 PM

2. Type of alcoholic beverage applied for: X Beer X Wine Mixed Beverage

3. Alcoholic beverages to be sold:z X Room temperature '1 Refrigerated

Beer will be sold in 4-packs, 6-packs, 12-packs, and 24-packs.

Wine will be sold in single bottles (750 mL).

Signature of applicant/owner

DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING 810 Union Street, Room 508 Norfolk, Virginia 23510 Telephone (757) 664-4752 Fax (757) 441-1569 (Revised July, 2018) F

0 PROPOSED LEASE UNE

PROPOSED ALDI Building Sq. Ft.: 19,209 (21,659 WITH EXPANSION)

I I, all1:1 I I I FUTURE BUILDING EXPANSION AREA

NOTE: LANDSCAPING IS SHOWN FOR CONCEPTUAL PURPOSES ONLY AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE PER THE CITY OF NORFOLK PLANTING REQUIREMENTS.

GRAPHIC SCALE IN FEET 0 30 60 120 MILITARY HIGHWAY (VARIABLE WIDTH PUBLIC RAN) M.B. 56, PG. 62) SHEET NUIA.

CS1 0 1 33311000( AREA ...RV OCCUPANCY USE RO031 MIRE SM.ROOTAGE Issued: Dote, LASICANVILF (RN 30313 u0130ULE 12541 Concept tso.3 09/10/10 31043 ROOM 107 3.39,3110031 131 PRELIMINARY - NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION SuelsNas IMeCANREI 12.

DuSINSS OGRIGE Revisions: Dote: I 1133,1 ROOM 419

SURIDIAL tOCCVRANOES) NOW LATERIORINTEN103 NAILS /11E0CLUP013 SPACE 13131

TOTAL SQUARE ROOTAGE (11•01313010 6000111 46317

00 NOSSCALE SlAs0 csome rme.a.m...... esesseeess.

carton era c..1.11‘..010 arcle..6 rig suit—

ms consultants, inc_ Onglneers, architects, planners I{ 00011COPH1 920 Main Campus Drive 330..113,0 Suite 430 Raleigh, North Caroline 27606-5213 prone 919.771 5565 Fax 919.779 2308

DRAWN ST: ..0,..0000Ce mug/ wRIF SP.

0.1 VC ISA 1/7 WAR Seal

CIS4IEANE.113 NOT 010.1.90301.00 MOM. Ci

wat 016 3E3,3340.6 !OR GENERAL EiGu.G LLNEWL bklizia)li Inc. RERESINCE TO EGLRFERENL Gray Nu 664maxoeld INEORNATION IS Achim. 500234 G.330µ3L GEE Mesa. NOGG USED FOR CON3730CRON OCIEDOING PuRPOSES 1031? 100 Yr aid ALDI Inc. Store #: TBD NG 10 ENCE 31110 3 INS MO. 000 NO1 COWAN WERT, Norfolk (JANAF) MC.,MORE. N. Military Hwy 003.301 A 3,3 Rog, 6 EREENG33003 Norfolk, VA 23502 INERE n 30 ON ... .11310.1.21,4 FLOOR IREOURMO2 S GONDOLA 40C, 110. 01tE CORNER.. slAa1033.1013 0,0•40.,0 Fp. 800100S) Of 00 V. reef Project Name & Location: G.G MOW.* W. Operations Plan

REAR G3CR OPERLEGOK DAIN Drawing Name: V/ 01310.1rPE Prototype Rh. Project No. 134333001ANF Of NSE (PRODUCE 300004 07/27/18

07 W.S.IdE0 3: $01.0•10. 00.101•190.13 Type: 40454-11 8 , SALB 0.003 041..0003

0 LHRD-V70 ER 100011101,611131120Ci 1ZR

8/2 COOL1111011.3 DOMS 9/

COW* 013.10. 00010 13 Operations Plan P0E010 00.11111.01. 00003 16 cowmen. 9C11.140 • 1 ,0 A-131

TED: eou.sisse.OSSI T frOrMIC.1.00016 10 0 UW 3.000 saw CAN APACE Scale: As Noted Drawing No. PLO BHA PROJECT 0 JANAF CONDITIONAL USE 113180031 10/1/18De) PREPARED FOR PERMIT Kimley*Horn SAME AS SHO " MALEY X A-ISC.A08. _1E Of9(0480 BY 980 1811.08 U181 08. 108 .8. VA .230 ALDI EXISTING 14140. 04 873-38112 1.8.81 EY MOM C. Om BY 980

NORFOLK VA CONDITIONS .80.0 BY 14881 RETASIONS DA BY ALDI INC.- Notification sent to all Property Owners within 300ft

Property Owners Property Address Mailing Address

1081 Military Highway Holdings, LIc 735 Glouchester St Boca Raton FL 33487-3209 American Heart Assoc Inc The 2529 Virginia Beach Blvd Ste 200 Virginia Beach VA 23452-7650 Arora Properties, LIc 3434 Litchfield Rd Virginia Beach VA 23452-6216 Baylor Enterprises LIc 248 W Bute St Ste 200 Norfolk VA 23510-1441 Boom, Inc 5623 Fairfield Rd Columbia SC 29203-3304 Curtis Investments-Norfolk, LIc 5641 Smu Blvd Ste 100 Dallas TX 75206-5026 Economic Development Authority Of The City Of Norfolk 500 E Main St Ste 1500 Norfolk VA 23510-2205 Franchise Realty Interstate Corp Po Box 66207 Amf Ohare Chicago IL 60666-0207 Gmaccms 2004-C2 Military Circle Mall, LIc 475 5th Ave New York NY 10017-6220 Izaak, Ltd 1121 S Military Hwy Chesapeake VA 23320-2353 Lowes Home Centers Inc 4800 N Federal Hwy Ste 201b Boca Raton FL 33431-3408 Movement Mortgage, LIc - Lessee 8024 Calvin Hall Rd Indian Land SC 29707-8737 Nawab Properties LIc 3434 Litchfield Rd Virginia Beach VA 23452-0000 Sentara Health Plans, Inc - Lessee 835 Glenrock Rd Ste 170 Norfolk VA 23502-3767 Shah, Geeta S Declaration Of Trust 1460 S Ocean Blvd Apt 701 Pompano Beach FL 33062-2706 Spencer Family LIc 100 Charles Park Rd West Roxbury MA 02132-0000 Taa Nflk Car Care Ctr Property, LIc 5366 Virginia Beach Blvd Virginia Beach VA 23462-1828 Wh Capital, LIc 3290 Northside Pkwy Nw Ste 385 Atlanta GA 30327-2273 Whitney, Chris

From: Williams, Sherri Sent: Tuesday, October 02, 2018 1:49 PM To: Riddick, Paul; Graves, Angelia; Howard, Oneiceia; '[email protected]' Cc: Whitney, Chris Subject: New Planning Commission Application -1050 N Military Hwy Attachments: Application.pdf

Mr./Mrs.

Attached please find the following application tentatively scheduled to be heard at the November 15, 2018 Planning Commission public hearing:

ALDI INC., for a Conditional Use Permit for the sale of alcoholic beverage, off-premises at 1050 N. Military Highway.

The purpose of this request is to add off-premises sales of alcoholic beverages to a proposed grocery store.

Staff contact: Chris Whitney at (757) 823-1253, chris.whitneygnorfolk.gov

Thank You

Sherri Williams Planning Technician TH N RFO Planning Department 810 Union Street Suite 508 Norfolk, VA 23510 (757) 664-6771

Connect with us: www.norfolk.gov 0000

1 Dougherty, Sean

From: [email protected] Sent: Thursday, September 20, 2018 9:48 PM To: Dougherty, Sean Cc: [email protected] Subject: RE: Aldi

RE: Aldi

To Whom it May Concern:

Please be advised that the Lake Taylor Civic League met on September 20, 2018, there were 41 members in attendance.

Representatives from Aldi spoke about the proposed location at the Janaf Shopping Yard and numerous questions were answered. Following the presentation, the Civic League voted on whether to support the proposed grocery store and the conditional use permit to sell alcohol at this location. The vote was unanimous in favor of the project.

We are proud to support Aldi in its effort to bring their brand to the Janaf area. Please feel free to contact me if you have any further questions.

Sincerely,

Steven A. Mirman President, Lake Taylor Civic League

Steven A. Mirman, Attorney Mirman Law Firm, P.L.L.C. MAILING ADDRESS: P.O. BOX 12069, NORFOLK, VIRGINIA 23541 5900 E. VIRGINIA BEACH BLVD, SUITE 202 NORFOLK, VA. 23502 Phone (757) 961-2888 / Fax (757) 566-7878 [email protected] www.mirmanlawfirm.com

STATEMENT OF CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail message (including all attachments transmitted with it, if any) is intended solely for the use of the addressee and may contain legally privileged and confidential information. If you are not the person to whom this e-mail is addressed, or an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the person to whom it is addressed, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, copying, or other use of this message or its attachments is strictly prohibited. If you have received this e- mail in error, please notify the sender immediately by e-mail reply, then please delete this e-mail, together with any attachments to it, from your computer.