Weeks Thesis 20130726
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Molecular insights into fluorine chemistry in living systems by Amy Weeks A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Chemistry in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Michelle C. Y. Chang, Chair Professor Matthew B. Francis Professor J. Christopher Anderson Fall 2013 Molecular insights into fluorine chemistry in living systems © 2013 by Amy Weeks Abstract Molecular insights into fluorine chemistry in living systems by Amy Weeks Doctor of Philosophy in Chemistry University of California, Berkeley Professor Michelle C. Y. Chang, Chair Based on its unique elemental properties, fluorine has emerged as an important design element in synthetic pharmaceuticals, but also a difficult substituent to incorporate into small molecules using synthetic chemistry. Synthetic biology approaches represent an attractive alternative that could allow us to harness the catalytic power and specificity of enzymes for fluorine incorporation into complex small molecules. However, fluorinated natural products are rare and derive from a single pathway for biosynthesis of fluoroacetate, an antimetabolite poison. The fluoroacetate-producing bacterium Streptomyces cattleya has evolved a fluoroacetyl-CoA thioesterase (FlK) that is involved in fluoroacetate resistance. Using FlK as a model system, we have focused on understanding enzymatic fluorine selectivity with the goal of defining principles for the design of fluorine-specific enzymes that can be applied in the development of new methods for preparation of fluorinated molecules. We have demonstrated that FlK exhibits a remarkable 106-fold selectivity for hydrolysis of fluoroacetyl-CoA compared to acetyl-CoA, an abundant central metabolite and cellular competitor. 2 4 This selectivity is based on a decrease in KM (10 ) and an increase in kcat (10 ) for the fluorinated substrate. Through x-ray crystallographic studies, we have identified a unique hydrophobic ‘lid’ in our crystal structure of FlK that shields the active site from water. Mutation of a key lid residue (Phe 36) led to a loss of fluorine-based binding specificity, which was correlated with the appearance of additional ordered water molecules at the active site in the mutant crystal structure. A crystal structure of the FlK product complex revealed that Phe 36 is dynamic, undergoing a conformational change when the active site is occupied with product. By studying the binding of a series of non- hydrolyzable substrate analogs, we have shown that the lid confers the fluorinated substrate with an entropic binding advantage that is lost in lid mutants, which may be related to water release from the ‘polar hydrophobic’ C-F unit. Kinetic studies revealed that Phe 36 controls the substrate off rate, providing the fluorinated substrate with a kinetic as well as a thermodynamic advantage. We have also shown that catalytic specificity in FlK is based on utilization of an unusual reaction pathway initiated by deprotonation at the α-carbon for hydrolysis of fluoroacetyl-CoA but not acetyl-CoA. The enolate that is formed can then breakdown through a putative ketene intermediate to give the same product that would be produced by a canonical hydrolysis mechanism. FlK therefore represents a rare example in which the existence of two reaction pathways in the same active site controls substrate selectivity rather than product outcome. Although catalytic fluorine discrimination occurs mainly in one step of the reaction mechanism, we have demonstrated that fluorine is specifically recognized by the enzyme in both the acylation and deacylation steps of the reaction mechanism. These studies have defined the basis of fluorine selectivity in a naturally occurring enzyme-substrate pair, with implications for drug design and development of fluorine- selective biocatalysts. 1 Table of Contents Table of Contents i List of Figures, Schemes, and Tables iv List of Abbreviations ix Acknowledgments xi Chapter 1: Introduction 1.1 Organohalogen natural products 2 1.2 Fluorine in drug design 4 1.3 Fluorinated secondary metabolites 8 1.4 Organofluorine biosynthesis in Streptomyces cattleya 11 1.5 Mechanisms of fluoroacetate toxicity and resistance 15 1.6 Specific aims and thesis organization 21 1.7 References 22 Chapter 2: Structural and biochemical characterization of FlK 2.1 Introduction 33 2.2 Materials and methods 34 2.3 Results and discussion 37 2.4 Conclusion 56 2.5 Acknowledgments 56 2.6 References 57 Chapter 3: Catalytic control of enzymatic fluorine specificity 3.1 Introduction 62 3.2 Materials and methods 63 3.3 Results and discussion 71 3.4 Conclusion 89 3.5 Acknowledgments 90 i 3.6 References 90 Chapter 4: Molecular recognition and kinetic discrimination of the C-F bond in FlK 4.1 Introduction 96 4.2 Materials and methods 97 4.3 Results and discussion 106 4.4 Conclusion 121 4.5 Acknowledgments 121 4.6 References 121 Chapter 5: Determinants of specificity in the acylation and deacylation steps of FlK-catalyzed thioester hydrolysis 5.1 Introduction 126 5.2 Materials and methods 127 5.3 Results and discussion 133 5.4 Conclusion 146 5.5 Acknowledgments 146 5.6 References 146 Chapter 6: Exploring organofluorine resistance, biosynthesis, and regulation in Streptomyces cattleya 6.1 Introduction 149 6.2 Materials and methods 151 6.3 Results and discussion 153 6.4 Conclusion 159 6.5 References 160 ii Appendices Appendix 1: Published plasmids and oligonucleotides 163 Appendix 2: Unpublished plasmids, strains, and oligonucleotides 168 Appendix 3: 2D NMR spectra and HPLC chromatograms for synthetic acyl- 176 CoAs and analogs Appendix 4: Protein purification gels 190 iii List of Figures, Schemes, and Tables Chapter 1 Figure 1.1 Organohalogen natural products 2 Figure 1.2 Enzymatic halogenation strategies observed in nature 3 Figure 1.3 Fluorine in drug design 5 Figure 1.4 Fluorine-protein interactions 6 Figure 1.5 Erythromycin and flurithomycin 7 Figure 1.6 Mechanism-based inhibition of thymidylate synthase by trifluridine 8 Figure 1.7 Fluorinated secondary metabolites 9 Figure 1.8 5-Fluorouracil derivatives isolated from Phakellia fusca 10 Figure 1.9 Fluorometabolite biosynthesis in Streptomyces cattleya 11 Figure 1.10 Structure and mechanism of the fluorinase 13 Figure 1.11 Organization of the fluorometabolite biosynthesis gene cluster 14 Table 1.1 Proposed functions of genes encoded in the fluorometabolite 15 biosynthesis cluster of S. cattleya Figure 1.12 Lethal synthesis of fluorocitrate 16 Figure 1.13 Fluoroacetate dehalogenase structure and mechanism 17 Figure 1.14 Fluoroacetyl-CoA hydrolysis as a fluoroacetate resistance 18 mechanism Figure 1.15 Hotdog-fold superfamily structure and mechanism 20 Chapter 2 Scheme 2.1 Biogenic organofluorines found in the environment 33 Figure 2.1 FlK confers fluoroacetate resistance in vivo 38 Figure 2.2 Purification of wild-type FlK 39 Figure 2.3 Uncatalyzed rates of fluoroacetyl-CoA and acetyl-CoA hydrolysis 40 Figure 2.4 Rates of FlK-catalyzed hydrolysis of fluoroacetyl-CoA in the 40 presence of varying concentrations of acetyl-CoA Figure 2.5 Comparison of catalyzed and uncatalyzed rates of hydrolysis 41 Figure 2.6 Crystal structure of FlK 42 iv Table 2.1 Data collection and refinement statistics for wild-type FlK 43 structures Figure 2.7 Multiple sequence alignment of FlK and homologs identified 44 by BLAST Figure 2.8 Structural alignments of FlK, 4-hydroxybenzoyl-CoA thioesterase, 45 hTHEM2, and PaaI Table 2.2 Kinetic constants measured for fluoroacetyl-CoA and acetyl-CoA 47 hydrolysis by wild-type and mutant FlKs Figure 2.9 Superdex 75 chromatogram of FlK-E50Q after purification and 48 concentration Figure 2.10 Model of the FlK-fluoroacetyl-CoA complex 49 Figure 2.11 Conformational changes in the fluoroacetate complex of FlK 51 Table 2.3 Data collection and refinement statistics for FlK-F36A structures 52 Figure 2.12 Accessibility of the active site to water in FlK and FlK-F36A 54 Figure 2.13 FlK-F36A product complex 55 Chapter 3 Figure 3.1 Molecular basis of fluoroacetate toxicity 62 Figure 3.2 Alternative mechanisms for discrimination of fluoroacetyl-CoA 72 and acetyl-CoA Figure 3.3 pH dependence of non-enzymatic acyl-CoA hydrolysis 72 Figure 3.4 Steady state and pre-steady state kinetics of FlK-catalyzed 73 acyl-CoA hydrolysis Figure 3.5 Michaelis-Menten curves for substrates used in Taft analysis 74 Figure 3.6 1H/13C HMBC spectrum of fluoroacetyl-CoA under FlK assay 75 conditions Figure 3.7 Characterization of FlK burst-phase kinetics 77 Figure 3.8 Phylogenetic analysis of FlK homologs 80 Figure 3.9 Multiple sequence alignment of FlK and its closest homologs 81 Figure 3.10 Structural comparison of FlK to PhaJ 82 Figure 3.11 Breakdown of the fluoroacetyl-enzyme intermediate is accelerated 83 by Cα-deprotonation Figure 3.12 3,3,3-Trifluoropropionyl-CoA hydrolysis, fluoride release, and FlK 84 inactivation 2 Figure 3.13 Pre-steady-state kinetics of [ H2]-fluoroacetyl-CoA hydrolysis 85 v by FlK Figure 3.14 A change in catalytic mechanism accounts for FlK’s specificity 86 for fluoroacetyl-CoA Figure 3.15 Characterization of FlK-H76A 87 Figure 3.16 Alternative mechanism for enolate breakdown 88 Figure 3.17 Quantification of exchange of α-protons with D2O 88 Chapter 4 Figure 4.1 Sequence alignment of FlK and homologs 107 Figure 4.2 Conformational change observed in FlK upon soaking with 108 substrate or products Figure 4.3 Pre-steady state kinetics of FlK-F36A 108 Scheme 4.1 Synthesis of pantethiene precursors