Completed actions by the end of December 2016
Status Production of RE: 17,4% Reduction and energy consumption: 8,6% Reduction of CO2: 8,85%
Ton CO2/year 700000 600000 500000 400000 300000 200000 100000
0 Year 2007 2020
Evaluation of the Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors Completed actions at the end of December 2016 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
Table of Contents
Foreword 3
1. Summary 5 Background of the EU Covenant of Mayors EU's Energy and Climate Measures 6 Frederikshavn Municipality’s accession to the Covenant and municipal obligations 6
2. Vision and objectives 7
3. Procedures for evaluation and revision of the Action Plan10 8
4. Completed actions 9
5. Priorities and actions 11 5.1 Frederikshavn Municipality as company 11 5.1.1 Municipality plans, local plans and urban development strategies 11 5.1.2 Integration of renewable energy 11 - Long-term actions (2020) 12 - Coastal wind turbines 12 5.2 Landbo Nord 13 5.3 Efforts energy savings in Frederikshavn Municipality 14 5.3.1 Energy Advisors, private homes in cities and in rural areas 14 5.4 Municipal buildings 16 5.5 Utilities 17 5.5.1 Frederikshavn Utility 17 5.5.2 MN-Natural gas 17 5.5.3 Skagen District Heating Company 19 5.5.4 Strandby District Heating 20 5.5.5 Hørby, Thorshøj & Østervrå dirstrict heat plants 20 5.5.6 Sæby District Heating 21 5.6 Public housing Association 22 5.6.1 Frederikshavn Housing 22 5.6.2 Vesterport Housing 24
6. Conclusions 26
COVENANT OF MAYORS Completed actions pr. 30 Decmber 2016 28
2 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
Foreword
Frederikshavn Municipality aims to graphically limited trial area, called ”Energy City Frederikshavn” has been be one of the first fossil free munici- ”Energy City Frederikshavn” shall be tasked to generate activities that are palities in Denmark. The overall goal provided with 100% renewable en- consistent with the municipality’s is to create a climate wise statement ergy, where renewable energy should vision on climate and the environ- and image, which we can use as a re- cover all consumption of electricity, ment as a growth track that can also vitalization that opens new horizons heat and transport. promote local business development for everyone - citizens, residents and Frederikshavn will be among the first strategy, settlement policy and edu- businesses. cities in the modern world to switch cation policy. from fossil to renewable energy sup- Frederikshavn Municipality has de- ply. In addition, Frederikshavn must Frederikshavn will continue to be cided to actively contribute to Den- become a ”demonstratorium” where known and to market itself as a green mark’s emissions of greenhouse Denmark’s leading energy technology municipality. In short, Frederikshavn gases can be reduced significantly will be developed, tested and dem- is trying to create ”new sustainable and that Denmark can become in- onstrated in full 1:1 scale. livelihoods” for its citizens and busi- dependent of fossil fuels by 2050. nesses. Frederikshavn Municipality has a long Frederikshavn Municipality’s Action tradition to prioritize energy and en- Plan 2012 is based on the Energy Sincerely, vironment particularly high. As the city’s Energy scenarios for the tran- first municipality in Denmark in 2007 sition to renewable energy, supple- Frederikshavn signed an agreement mented by municipal solid effort in Lars M. Møller with the Danish Society for Nature energy savings both in the context of Mayor of Frederikshavn Conservation about 3% reduction in climate municipality agreement and the municipality’s own CO2 per year, the ongoing energy-saving activities and the first municipality in North in the municipality as defined geo- Jutland joined Frederikshavn EU cov- graphical area. enant of Mayors in April 2011.
In November 2006, a number of leading Danish energy experts gath- ered at the Energy Camp 06, where they designated Frederikshavn as the most obvious Danish city that had the potential to become Denmark’s renewable energy city. The experts emphasized the city’s qualities as special favourable for this particular project.
Frederikshavn City Council adopted energy experts’ recommendation and decided in spring 2007, that a geo-
3 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
Completed actions by November 2013 are highighted with orange color in the tables.
Completed actions by November 2015 are highlighted with green color in the tabless.
Completed actions per December 2016 arehighlighted with blue color in the tables.
Authored by: Bahram Dehghan Energy City Municipality of Frederikshavn
Layout: Hanne Lund Ejendomscenteret, Grafik Municipality of Frederikshavn
Published by Municipality of Frederikshavn 2012. First eidtion: Secund edition: November 2015. Third Edition: Oktober 2017
4 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
1. Summery
This evaluation report presents Frederikshavn Municipality’s EU’s key figures for CO2 inventory is used. There has also been completed actions by the end of December 2016. made new categorization of the survey so that it is consistent with the EU Commission’s requirements for baseline emission in- This Action Plan has been prepared by Energy City Frederikshavn. ventory. Frederikshavn Municipality’s baseline year for this plan is therefore 2007. The original “Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors” shows that Frederikshavn Municipality, by impletion of the specified ac- Energy City Frederikshavn has carried out the evaluation of the tions, will be able to reduce local CO2-emissions for electricity action plan by the end of December 2016. The evaluation shows and heat production and transport by 354,537 tons, equivalent to that Frederikshavn Municipality in 2016 has reduced its CO2 emis- a CO2-reduction of 53%, compared to the baseline year of 2007. sion by an additional 6.72 tonnes. The share of renewable energy Implementation of the action plans on transportation can also in 2016 has also increased by 404.43 MWh. In 2016, there were reduce local CO2-emissions by 1,242 tons / year, equivalent to a also reported energy savings in Frederikshavn Municipality, cor- CO2-reduction of 1% compared to 2007. responding to 12,618.36 MWh. (Se fig. 2)
The original "Action Plan for the EU Convant of Mayors" also con- Fig. 2 The table below indicates the development of the munici- tains energy savings potentials at 360,487 MWh, corresponding to pality's efforts to reduce CO emissions, renewable energy 23% of the municipality´s total energy consumption in the ref- 2 integration and energy savings in recent years. erence year 2007 . The action plan's energy-saving potential is evaluated and updated every other year.
Furthermore, the implementation of the action plans for the in- 2007 2013 2015 2016 tegration of renewable energy in municipal‘s energy production will increase the proportion of renewable energy production in MWh/year the municipality from 16% in 2007 to 70% in 2020. The munici- 1500000 pality’s total CO2-reduction is thus amounted to 354,537 tons in 2020. This corresponds to a total CO savings in Frederikshavn of 2 1000000 53% compared to 2007. (Se fig. 1)
The calculation of the municipality’s total CO2- emissions have 500000 been carried out by using Frederikshavn Municipality’s existing CO2-emissions energy and CO mapping, which was prepared in cooperation be- Sustainable energy 2 0 tween Frederikshavn Municipality and Cowi in 2007, where the Energy savings Energy consumtion
Fig. 1 The table below indicates Frederikshavn Municipality’s CO2 accounts for years 2007 and 2020.
MWh/year
1500000
1000000
500000 Tonnes Tonnes
CO2-emissions Sustainable energy 0 Energy savings Energy consumtion 2007 2020
5 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
BACKGROUND OF EU COVENANT OF MAYORS
In 2007 the EU started up an initiative of the Covenant, as a tool for European cities who wanted to take the lead on climate change. On accession to the Covenant binds the cities to make a specific effort to reduce CO2-emissions in an amount that is above the EU target of 20% CO2 reduction by 2020. Cities must submit an action plan for reductions within a year of their accession and regularly submit detailed rapports of realized actions. In addition, cities must assist to com- municate the idea of Covenant of Mayors through among other things, an annual Conference of Mayors and contribute to the sharing of experiences and exchange of know-how with the other signatories to the Covenant of Mayors.
EU´S ENERGY AND CLIMATE MEASURES
The European Union has set energy and climate measures. The EU's energy and climate measures for 2020, 2030 and 2050 is listed below.
Objectives for 2020: • Reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by at least 20% compared to 1990 level • 20% energy from renewable sources • 20% improvement in energy efficiency
Objectives for 2030: • Reduction of greenhouse gas emissions by 40% • At least 27% of energy from renewable sources • 27-30% improvement in energy efficiency • 15% interconnection of the grid (ie, 15% of the electricity generated in the EU can be transported to other EU countries)
Objectives for 2050: • 80-95% less greenhouse gas emissions in the EU compared with 1990.
FREDERIKSHAVN MUNICIPALITY’S ACCESSION OF THE COVENANT AND OBLIGATIONS
By Mayor Lars Møller Mejlvang’s signature on 19 May 2011 joined Frederikshavn Municipality joined the Covenant of May- ors. Upon accession has Frederikshavn Municipality committed itself to the following:
• To achieve higher goals than those set by the EU climate targets for 2020 to reduce CO2- emissions in accordance with the agreement guidelines for reducing CO2-emissions by at least 20%. • To submit an action plan for promoting sustainable energy for evaluation, monitoring and control within one year after the above entry date. • To organize Energy Days in cooperation with the European Commission and other interested parties, to enable people to directly benefit from the opportunities and benefits that more intelligent use of energy offers. And to regularly inform the local media on the progress of the Action Plan. • To participate in and contribute to the annual EU Conference of Mayors.
6 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
2. Vision and objectives
With the adoption of the project En- Frederikshavn Municipality’s total ergy City Frederikshavn in 2007 the energy consumption for electricity, municipality decided to convert a heat and transportation amounted to geographically defined areas’ con- 1,561.3 GWH. The share of renewable sumption of electricity and heat to energy in Frederikshavn Municipality 100% renewable energy in 2015. In in 2008 was 89.67 GWH, equivalent addition, Frederikshavn Municipality to 16% of all energy consumption. has a vision is to become a 100 % fos- The current renewable energy comes sil free municipality in 2030. To fulfill mainly from wind turbines installed its vision, Frederikshavn Municipality on land and at sea. has set the following goals: By signing the Covenant of Mayors • The municipality’s fossil energy Frederikshavn as defined geographi- production should adjust to re- cal area has committed itself to re- newable energy as much as pos- ducing municipality’s total CO2-emis- sible. sions by minimum 20% compared to the baseline year of 2007 in accord- • Energy conservation efforts must ance with EU Commission guidelines have a high priority particularly for CO2 inventory. both in municipality as an or- ganization and municipality as a Frederikshavn Municipality has set geographical area. itself the goal to implement energy saving savings efforts in buildings and • Sustainable use of energy resourc- the residential sector. This includes es and climate considerations the preparation of actual action plans must be an integral part of daily for energy conservation efforts in the day for all employees and citizens municipality as a company, in private in the municipality. homes and in public housing asso- ciations, representing minimum 20% • Frederikshavn is determined to be of the energy consumption of these a role model for transport sector’s buildings, compared with consump- transition to renewable energy in- tion in 2007. cluding commissioning of sustain- able vehicles in to employees and citizens’ daily lives to benefit the environment and public health.
7 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
3. Procedures for evaluation and revision of the Action Plan
This report is applicable for 2007 to the end of December 2016.
Within the aforesaid period this action plan is evaluated at the end of December every other year. The evalua- tion process includes preparation of a supplement to this present Action Plan, which describes necessary changes, justifications of the changes and what corrective actions is to be taken in order to ensure that Frederikshavn as minimum in able to achieve the EU Commission’s objectives on climate area.
8 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
4. Completed actions
Completed actions 2007-2013 Completed actions 2013-2015 The following table presents Frederikshavn Municipality's The following table presents Frederikshavn Municipality's actions for energy savings, integration of renewable en- actions for energy savings, integration of renewable en- ergy energy supply and reduction of CO2-emissions at the ergy energy supply and reduction of CO2-emissions at the end of November 2013. end of November 2015.
Year Energy Energy Sustainable CO2-emissions Year Energy Energy Sustainable CO2-emissions consumption savings energy consumtion savings energy 2007 1561289 0 0 669224 2007 1561289 0 0 669224 2013 1508297,05 52991,95 196450,67 637410,93 2013 1508297,05 52991,5 196450,67 637410,93 2015 1439701,94 121587,06 388360,18 616708,88 Figure 3 indicates that, during the first evaluation period by the end of November 2013, Frederikshavn Municipality Figure 4 indicates that, during the second evaluation has reduced its energy consumption by 52,991.95 MWh, period by the end of November 2015, Frederikshavn Mu- equivalent to 3.4% of the total energy consumption of the nicipality has reduced its energy consumption by 121,587.0 municipality in the reference year 2007. MWh, equivalent to 7.78% of the total energy consumption of the municipality in the reference year 2007. It is also apparent from figure three that during this pe- riod the municipality has integrated renewable energy at It is also apparent from figure 4 that during this period the 196,450.7 MWh, corresponding to 12.6% of the municipal- municipality has integrated renewable energy at 270,831.15 ity's total energy consumption in the reference year 2007. MWh, corresponding to 17.3% of the municipality's total In addition, figure 3 indicates that, until the end of No- energy consumption in the reference year 2007. vember 2013, the municipality has reduced its CO2- emis- In addition, Figure 4 indicates that, by the end of Novem- sions by 31,813 tonnes, corresponding to 4.75% of the mu- ber 2015, the municipality has reduced its CO2- emissions nicipality’s total CO2-emissions in the reference year 2007. by 52,515.12 tonnes, corresponding to 7.84% of the mu- nicipality’s total CO2-emissions in the reference year 2007. Fig. 3 Fig 4
2007 2013 2007 2013 2015
MWh/year MWh/year
1500000 1500000
1000000 1000000
500000 500000
CO2-emissions Sustainable energy 0 Energy savings CO2-emissions Energy consumtion 0 Sustainable energy Energy savings Energy consumtion
9 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
Completed actions November 2015 - December 2016 Figure 5 indicates that, during the third evaluation by the The following table presents Frederikshavn Municipality's end of December 2016 Frederikshavn Municipality has re- actions for energy savings, integration of renewable en- duced its energy consumption by 134,205.42 MWh, equiva- ergy energy supply and reduction of CO2-emissions at the lent to 8.6% of the total energy consumption of the mu- end of December 2016. nicipality in the reference year 2007.
Year Energy Energy Sustainable CO2-emissions It is also apparent from figure 5 that during the same pe- consumtion savings energy riod of time the municipality has integrated renewable 2007 1561289,00 0 0 669224 energy by 271,235.58 MWh, corresponding to 17.4% of the 2013 1508297,05 52991,5 313979,7 637410,93 municipality's total energy consumption in the reference 2015 1439701,94 121587,06 270831,15 616708,88 year 2007. 2016 1427083,58 134205,42 271235,58 609981,95 In addition, figure 5 indicates that since 2007 the mu- nicipality has reduced its CO2- emissions by 59.242 tonnes, corresponding to 8.85% of the municipality’s total CO2- emissions in the reference year 2007.
Fig. 5
2007 2013 2015 2016
MWh/year
1500000
1000000
500000
CO2-emissions 0 Sustainable energy Energy savings Energy consumtion
10 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
5. Priorities and actions
5.1 Goal: ed in such plans. The same applies FREDERIKSHAVN MUNICIPALITY The ultimate goal is to create a model to new constructions, expansion or AS COMPANY of a low carbon society in the mu- maintenance of municipal buildings nicipality as geographical boundary, and renovation projects, procurement 5.1.1 to minimize the municipality’s CO2- and more, where CO2-reduction, en- Municipality plans, local plans and emission, to take its share of respon- ergy efficiency and integration of re- urban development strategies sibility for implementation of the newable energy should be a natural state’s energy strategy ”Energy Plan part of the municipality’s activities. Vision: 2050”, and as a minimum to obtain Frederikshavn Municipality aims to the EU’s climate targets for 2020. 5.1.2 implement renewable energy in all integration of renewable energy municipal climate and energy plan- Action plans: ning, including urban planning, mu- The City Council has announced that The strategy for integration of renew- nicipal plans, local plans in cities and when preparing local plans, traffic able energy concentrates on the fol- rural areas. plans and other municipal planning, lowing areas: as well as preparation of amend- ments to existing plans, energy effi- • Wind turbines on land and at sea ciency, CO2-reduction and integration • Biogas of renewable energy must be includ- • Solar energy • Industrial waste heat • Waste
The following table lists wind Turbines installed by the end of December 2016 Total effect in Number of wind Effect pr. wind Total height: Production: Construction Projects the project: mills pcs. mill MW m MWh/year Year MW Fr. havn Sea & land - - - - 89.671,18 2008 Højstrup 4 3,0 12,0 125 23.700 2013 Kragelund IIa 2 3,075 6,5 107 9.450 2015 Kragelund IIb 2 3,075 6,5 107 9.450 2015 Total 8 - - - 132.271 - Source: Applications and calculations received by candidates
11 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
Small wind turbines The municipal wind turbine planning informs that in the period 2011-2015 has installed 12 pieces of 10 KW, 1 piece 11 KW and 5 pieces 25 KW small household wind turbines in Frederikshavn Municipality.
RE-production/ Investment Nr. Action plan Period POI1) [%] Energy saving [DKK] Installing 18 units small houshold wind 281.5 MWH/year 1 turbines with a total installed capacity of CO2-saving: 83.5 t/ 2011-2015 Owners pay 100 256 KW. year 134,53 Mwh/year Installing 6 units small houshold wind CO2-saving: 40,76 t/ 2 2016 100 turbines. year
By the end of 2011 two unites of 2.0 MW wind turbines with a total height of 107 meters was installed in a site south of Sæby town by a property called Kragelund. There were planned 3 wind turbines, of which an estimated annual production of around 13,600 MWH.
LONG-TERM ACTIONS (UP TO 2020): There may be new wind turbine applications initiated in this period.
COASTAL WIND TURBINES Planning for wind turbines with a total height greater than 150 meters or planning for offshore wind turbines is carried out by the State. In such cases Frederikshavn Municipality is consulting party.
At the present time Frederikshavn Municipality has the knowledge that the state is working on planning and locat- ing of wind turbines at sea concerning the following projects:
- Dong Energy has decided to install 6 pieces of 3-7 MW coastal Wind mills outside the port of Frederikshavn with a total installed power of 12 MW and an estimated annual production of 39,000 MWH. Dong Energy has stated that each wind turbine can be expected to have more installed capacity than those in the planning enlightened values.
According to the plan the implementation period is set for 2012-2016.
- Establishment of a 200 MW wind turbine costal site be- tween Sæby town and Frederikshavn, (process initiated).
- Construction of 7 pieces 3.6 MW wind turbines for extend- edtion of Frederikshavn port (process initiated).
12 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
The table below sets Frederikshavn Municipality's (as organisation) completed actions on transport Construction Investment POI1) Nr. Action plan CO2- saving [ton/year] period [DKK] [%] 2 Replacement of 5 conventional munici- 8 2011-2013 600,000 80 pal vehicles with 5 electric vehicles. 3 Diversion of public transport by city RE= 2,902 MWh/year buses and inter-municipal buses, corre- Savings: 2,902 MWh/year 2012-2015 3,000,000 80 sponding to an annual bus at 444.111 km CO2-saving: 826 from diesel- to biogas operation. 4 Conversion of 2 inter-city buses, cor- RE= 895 MWh/year responding to an annual busdrive at Savings: 895 MWh/year 2015-2016 1,200,000 175.000 km to biogas operation CO2-saving: 240 5 Conversion of 5 waste collection trycks RE= 258.6 MWh/year consumption of diesel, equivalent to Savings: 258.6 MWh/year 2012-2016 867,000 80 200.000 km drive per years to biogas. CO2-saving: 335 6 Replacement of 5 conventional munici RE= 11,3 MWh/year pal vehicles with 3 biogas-driven vehi- Savings: 11.3 MWh/year 2016-2017 650,000 70 cles per year CO2-saving: 8 Total 1967,7 1): POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage.
5.2 LandboNord LandboNord provides energy advisory to its members in the agricultural industry. The statement of LandboNord’s energy advisory activities (completed actions) are listed in the following table:
Construction Investment 1) Nr. Action plan CO2- saving [ton/year] POI [%] period [DKK] 1 Energy consultancy in agricul- Energy saving: 1,793 tral industry RE-production: 1.493 2011-2015 Consumers pay 100 CO2-saving: 477.6 2 Energy consultancy in agricul- Energisaving: 1.457 tral industry CO2-saving: 250,75 2016 860,827 100
13 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
5.3 The goal is to reduce private dwell- Action plans: EFFORTS FOR ENERGY SAVINGS IN ings’ consume of heat by 700 MWH Frederikshavn Municipality, in co- FREDERIKSHAVN MUNICIPALITY per year, thus reducing the private operation with Frederikshavn Utility, housings share of CO2-emissions. decided to establish an independ- 5.3.1 Along with the integration of renew- ent and unpaid advisory function Energy advisors, private homes in able energy in the private housing for energy consultancy of homeown- cities and in rural areas sector the municipality aims to fulfill ers in Frederikshavn Municipality. In its vision of becoming 100% fossil free addition the partners are working to Vision: municipality in 2030 and simultane- make definite plans for cluster energy Frederikshavn Municipality has a vi- ously meets the EU Covenant of May- renovations in rural areas, clubs and sion of reducing private energy con- ors climate targets for 2020. associations. sumption from private hose holds and wishes to motivate homeowners Until 10th of September 2012, 280 PV- to include renewable energy in sup- power plants with a total of 1,437 MW plying their homes in cities and in has been installed in Frederikshavn rural areas. Municipality, including solar PV-. Goal: plans installed in municipal build- ings.
14 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
The table below sets Frederikshavn Municipality's completed actions on private property consultancy RE-production/ Investment Nr. Action plan Project period POI 1) [%] Energy saving [DKK] Consultancy regarding heating CO2 savings: 1 2012-2020 390,000 100 in private housing sector 85.4 ton/year Consultancy regarding electric- CO2 savings: 2 2012-2020 210,000 80 ity in private housing sector 0,36 ton/year 1): POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage.
The table below indicates Completed energy savings for private homeowners RE-production/ Investment Nr. Action plan Project period POI 1) [%] Energy saving [DKK] Electricity - 1,2 MWh 1 Energy consultancy Heat: 700 MWh 2013 600,000 100 CO2-saving: 85,76 ton Electricity- 204,11 MWh 2 Energy consultancy Heat: 1.222 MWh 2014-2015 1,114,965 100 CO2 savings: 306,63 ton Electricity - 1.194,43 MWh 3 Energy consultancy Heat: 3.146,45 MWh 2016 2,568,799 100 CO2-saving: 741,45 ton 1): POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage.
15 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
5.4 MUNICIPAL BUILDINGS Goal: Action Plans: The goal is to reduce municipal build- The following action plan is drawn up Vision: ings CO2- emissions by 20% by 2020, by Frederikshavn Municipality’s Prop- Frederikshavn has a vision to contin- to integrate renewable energy in mu- erty Centre: ue reducing municipal energy con- nicipal buildings energy supply cor- sumption of buildings and integrate responding to 20% of the consump- Institutional and school areas are still as much renewable energy in regard tion and to achieve energy savings in focus areas, also in the future. One with construction of new buildings, these buildings corresponding to 20% reason for this is that the quality ’s renovation and building mainte- compared to the energy consumption funding from the state has focused on nance. in 2007. these areas. At the same time merge schools, for example, there has been a merger of Ankermedets School and Hedebo School, and the same hap- pened to Fladstrand School and Abildgård School.
Completed energy savings in 2014 and 2015 Appendix 1 in this action plan Indicate detailed inventory material for reporting years 2013, 2014 and part of 2015. The sum- marized energy savings in Annex 1 shows that energy conservation and energy data are specified on the different municipal building categories such as schools, care centers, etc. The classification of municipal buildings helps us to make clear the are- as that have been the focus, regarding energy savings.
Energy savings in 2013-2014 Savings Energy (MWh) CO2-saving (Ton) Electricity 1,281 378 Heat 612 548 Transport -92,58 -243
Annex 1 indicates Frederikshavn Municipality’s (municipality as an organization) energy saving measures for 2014.
Energy savings in 2014-2015 Savings Energy (MWH) CO2-saving (Ton) Electricity 5 1,249 Heat 893 267 Transport -200 -507
Annex 1 indicates Frederikshavn Municipality’s (municipality as an organization) energy saving measures for 2014.
Energy savings in 2016 Savings Energy (MWH) CO2-saving (Ton) Electricity 412 123,6 Heat 1.617 310,25
16 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
5.5 UTILITIES Action plans: Since Frederikshavn Utility LMT owns, operates and maintains all street and Vision: 5.5.1 Frederikshavn Utility LMT path lighting in Frederikshavn Mu- Utilities located in Frederikshavn Mu- Frederikshavn Utility LMT, owned by nicipality, the company works con- nicipality are working intensively on the municipality of Frederikshavn, tinuously to reduce operating costs, reducing CO2- emissions and reduce has worked out definite plans for re- including energy consumption to the energy loss at all stages from produc- ducing CO2- emissions among others lighting. tion of energy distribution loss to the by reducing distribution losses from efficient use of individual consumers. district heating pipelines. The action 5.5.2 HMN-Natural gas In addition, the utilities seek to re- plan suggests that the overall heat HMN-Natural gas is the national gas direct their energy production to re- loss must be reduced by 1% per year company, which is responsible for the newable energy. until the year 2018. Reduction of line transmission of natural gas to con- losses has been running since 2008. sumers in Denmark. HMN-Gas deliv- Goal: Quantification of effort year 2011 ers annually 95,076,600 m3 natural Utilities’ goal is to reduce these com- shows that district heating pipe reno- gas to consumers in Frederikshavn panies’ CO2- emissions, ensure stable vation has resulted in energy savings Municipality, equal to 1,042 GWH. supply, deliver lower cost energy to of 1,209 MWH. Similarly, the improve- all in Frederikshavn Municipality and ment of the control of the heat trans- MN-Natural gas provides energy ad- gradually redirect to renewable en- mission and distribution has resulted visory to all heat consumers in the ergy. Parts of the district heat supply in a heat savings of 513 MWH. municipality, where the largest part companies have begun integration of of its advisory activities deals with solar energy in their collective energy conversion from oil boilers to natural supply. gas boilers as well as customer advice on efficient energy use.
The table below sets HMN-Natural gas' completed actions RE-production/ Energy Investment Nr. Action plan Project period POI1) [%] saving [DKK] Replacement of 190 oil-fired Savings: 1.388 MWh/year 1 2011-2015 Consumers pay 100 boilers to natural gas boilers CO2-saving: 466,7 T/year Switching boilers from heating Savings: 85 MWh 2 2016 Consumers pay 100 oil to natural gas CO2-saving: 22,64
17 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
The table below indicates Frederikshavn Supply A/S’s completed actions RE-production/ Project Investment POI 1) Nr. Action plan Energysavings periode [DKK] [%] 1 Replacing the light bulbs in street lights Electricity savings 412 MWH 2013-2014 6.279.000 100 to LED + regulation of on-off function. CO2-savings: 223 ton/year 2 Renovation of district heating grid in Heat savings 2,200 MWH/ Part of the Frederikshavn, which results in 1% per- year 2012-2018 general mainte- 100 centage points in the reduction of heat CO2-savings: 708 ton/year nance loss corresponding to 42.9 GWH heat. 3 Optimization of the operation of the Part of the Heat savings 3.6 MWH/year district heating network in form of opti- 2012-2013 energy optimi- 100 CO2-savings: 0,44 ton/year mal control and regulation. zation 4 Improving the cooling conditions of end Heat savings 1,570 MWH/year 2012-2013 1.000.000 100 consumers CO2-savings: 506 ton/year 5 Consultancy of private properties, own Electricity: 154 MWh 2013-2014 470.000 100 advisor Heat: 285 MWh CO2-savings: 102.8 ton/year 6 Part of the Renovation of district heat transmission District Heat: 2030 MWh 2013-2014 general mainte- 100 grid CO2-savings: 247,66 ton/year nance 7 El-savings: 678 MWH Public lighting converted to LED 2013-2014 147.770.000 100 CO2-savings: 205 ton/year Savings: 62 ton Heat Oil Coverting from heat Oil to district heat- District heat consumption: 8 2013-2014 470.000 100 ing 620 MWH CO2-savings: 89,5 t 9 Electricity: 315 MWH District Heating: 453 MWH Energy consultancy carried out by external Natural gas: 52 MWH 2013-2014 100 advisors (B) Heat oil: 101 MWH Biomas: 251MWh CO2-savings: 191.48 ton/year 10 Establishment of 17.6 KW solar PV at Aal- Produktion af RE 8,0 MWh 2014-2015 224.000 100 bæk waste water treatment plant CO2-savings: 5,44 ton/year 11 Establishment of heat surplus recov- District heat 20,000 MWH/year ery from MAN B&W into district heating ER: 20,000 MWh/year 2014-2015 Not informed 100 system CO2-savings: 2,440 ton/year 12 Optimization of the district heating grid Heat savings: 270,87 MWh 2016 2.53017 100 CO2-savings: 33,17 ton 13 Energy saving: Electricity: Replacing the light bulbs in public 14,04 MWh 2016 1.271.800 100 lighting to LED CO2-saving: 4252,6 ton
1): POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage.
18 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
5.5.3 Skagen District Heating In 2007, the Skagen District Heating preparation of a strategic action plan in- cluding its vision to reduce the plant’s total natural gas consumption by 50% Skagen District heating is a CHP-plant by the year 2017, compared to the gas consumption in 2006. that produces district heating to 2,450 consumers. Production of district Skagen District Heating has since 2008 had the following initiatives in its heating is mainly based on the natu- strategic plan: ral gas via 3 gas engines, each deliv- ering 14.1 MW of electricity and 17 MW • Establishment of an electric boiler for making better use of wind power of heat. District heating plant buys • Construction of 3 units absorption heat pumps, driven by the exhaust gas- annually 30,000 MWH of heat from es from gas engines Skagen Waste Incineration Plant. • Increase in heat production, based on waste from 21,000 MWH per year to In addition, heat is also produced 30,000 MWH per year through 4 natural gas peak load boil- • Increase in heat production, based on industrial surplus heat from 5,000 ers with an annual gas consumption MWH per year to 15,000 MWH per year of 46 MW and heating oil consump- tion of 20 MW and one 11 MW electric boiler unit.
The table below sets Skagen District Heating's completed actions RE-production/ Project Investment POI 1) Nr. Action plan Energy saving periode [DKK] [%] Fisherman Utilization of surplus heat from Fisherman 5.000 MWH/year The fishing 1 Fishing industry to Skagen District Heating, CO2-savings: 2008-2010 100 industry has stage 1 1,021 ton/year invested Utilization of surplus heat from Fisherman 10.000 MWH/year Fisherman 2 Fishing industry to Skagen District Heating, CO2-savings: 2010-2012 Fishing industry 100 stage 2 1,021 ton/year invests Electricity savings 50 Replacing the pumps in transmission and MWH 4 2008-2011 100 distribution grid. CO2-savings: 10.2 ton/year Natural gas savings Establishment of 3 absorption heat pumps 10,000 MWH 5 2012-2013 100 and exhaust gas condensing (economiser). CO2-savings: 2,041 ton/year 1): POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage.
19 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
5.5.4 Strandby District heating
Strandby Heating Plant is a natu- ral gas-powered CHP district heating plant. District heat is produced mainly in a gas engine, a gas-powered peak load boiler and an electric boiler. District heating plant’s total energy consumption in 2011 was 2.8 million m3 of natural gas. The electric boiler was set in to operation in sep. 2012 and is expected an annual consump- tion of 2,000 MWH of electricity per year. The electric boiler is installed in order to exploit cheap surplus power from wind turbine production. In 2011 Strandby District Heating sold 17,725.6 MWH of heat and 7665.3 MWH of elec- tricity. Strandby District Heating has 857 connected heat consumers.
The table below sets Strandby District heating’s completed actions RE-production/ Project Investment POI 1) Nr. Action plan Energy saving period [DKK] [%] 1 Establishment of 8,019 m2 6.0 MW 3,759 MWH/year solar plant. Natural gas savings 348,060 m3 2008-2011 14.500.000 100 (1 m3 = 10,8 kWH) CO2-savings: 782,7 tonnes/year 1): POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage.
5.5.5 Hørby, Thorshøj and Østervrå dirstrict heat plants
Hørby district heating plant uses Østervrå has a natural gas powered heating produced from straw can be straw to produce district heat to the CHP plant. These three district heat- transmitted to Thorshøj and Østervrå town of Hørby. Hørby Distric Heat ing plants has decided to intercon- in order to conserve consumption had a surplus of heat. Thorshøj has a nect their respective transmission of natural gas in these two heating natural gas-driven heating plant and grid together, so that the district plants
RE-production/ Project Investment POI 1) Nr. Action plan Energy saving periode [DKK] [%] 1 Interoperation of Hørby, Thorshøj 24456 ton/year 2014-2015 16.500.000 100 and Østervrå by interconnecting the CO2-savings: 5000 ton/year DH-grid
20 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
5.5.6 Sæby District Heating
Vision: Sæby District heating wants to reduce its CO2-emissions and implement en- ergy optimization at all stages from energy production to distribution losses from district heating pipelines as well as making efforts for efficient use of district heating for the individ- ual customer. In addition, the utili- ties seek to redirect their energy pro- duction to renewable energy.
Goal: Sæby District Heating’s goal is to re- duce the plant’s CO2-emissions, en- sure stable supply, provide cheap heating to its consumers and gradu- ally transfer to renewable energy. The company’s goal is also to integrate solar into the collective district heat- ing system.
The table below sets Sæby District Heating’s completed actions Project Investment POI1) Nr. Action plan RE-production/ Energy saving period [DKK] [%] 1 Establishment of 11,870 m2, 8.2 MW solar for Natural gas savings: 1,35 mio. m3/year district heating, stage 1 (1 m3= 10,8 kWH) 14.580 MWH. RE- 2010-2012 16.500.000 100 produktion: 6.350 MWH heat/ year CO2-savings: 2,979 ton/year 2 Establishment of a 12 MW electric boiler, dri- Consumption of electricity 2,180 MWH/ ven by wind turbines surplus power. year 2008-2009 5.000.000 100 CO2-savings: 2,979 ton/year 3 Reduction of distribution grid losses equiva- Heat savings: 1,750 MWH/year in 5 ye- lent to 2% of heat production in the next 3-5 ars, total 8,750 MWH. 2011-2017 Ej oplyst 100 years. The total theoretical savings potential CO2-savings: 1,073 ton/year is amounted to 16% of heat production. 4 District heating supply of Sæby camping site, CO2-savings: (0,265-0,137)kg CO2 /KWH x Hedebo eliminates consumption of 24.000 240.000KWH x 10-3= 30,7 ton CO2 2012-2017 40.000 100 liters heating oil per. year, equivalent to 240 CO2: savings: 37,6 ton/year MWH to favor of the district heating.
1): POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage.
21 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
5.6 PUBLIC HOUSING ASSOCIATIONS Frederikshavn Housing Association will: • Reduce energy consumption and CO2- emissions in the housing associa- Frederikshavn has a number of hous- tion ing associations. This section de- • Create a significant decrease in energy consumption from fossil fuels and scribes two of the largest housing as- CO2-emissions sociations’ action plans for reducing • Be a pioneer housing association for its industry energy consumption by making en- • Make attempts and proposals to improvement ergy renovations, construction of low • Keeping abreast of knowledge, development and new initiatives energy buildings and integration of • Participate in the debate and disseminate results renewable energy in public housing. • As a minimum follow rules and legislation to reduce energy consump-
tion and CO2- emissions 5.6.1 • Seek to detect discrepancies by rules and legislation, that have practical Frederikshavn Housing Association or economic impact of this policy, and affect politicians and authorities to remove these Frederikshavn Housings association’s • Support Frederikshavn Municipality in the desire to be a leader in energy executive committee has adopted savings and help the municipality to meet its climate targets following energy policy: • Communicate this policy to residents, employees and other stakeholders and seek to influence them, so energy policy is a natural part of the life Vision: in their daily work, and stakeholders, with whom housing association For Frederikshavn Housing Association is collaborating by delivering supplies, advice with more. energy savings and reduction of CO - 2 • Measure and evaluate performance and degree of target achievement emissions is a social commitment and • Communicate housing association results in the reduction of energy a competitive factor for rental hous- consumption and CO2 emissions ing association.
22 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
Goal: Action plans: The goal of Frederikshavn Housing Energy Cooperative Groups Association is to become 100% self- Housing association will reduce its en- The groups must measure and re- sufficient by renewable energy by ergy consumption and CO2-emissions cord results, which are published on with the objective of making the hous- 2050. housing association’s website. ing association in 2050 completely CO2- neutral by: For 2020, it applies that the total heat 1. To insert the requirement for al- The groups must have appropriate consumption in housing association, terations and renovations in training and the opportunity to ob- used in 2,600 dwellings should be dwellings in accordance with the tain information needed and be en- reduced by 75% compared with heat requirements for the buildings in ergy ambassadors in Frederikshavn 2020 (20 KWH per m2 per year, ex- consumption in 2010. Electricity con- Housing Association. clusive hot water production). sumption in the same dwellings must 2. Effective insulation of buildings correspondingly be reduced by 75% in and replacement of building com- 2030. ponents to the parts that insulates Change in habits and routines better and / or consume less en- This will be achieved by ensuring that ergy The policy on energy and CO2-reduc- all employees are aware of housing 3. Switch to renewable energy sourc- tion in housing association refers to associations policy on energy and es any kind of energy consumption from 4. Recovery of heat by effective ven- CO2-emissions and are familiar with fossil to renewable energy sources. tilation systems the ways of reducing consumption. 5. Applying best possible control sys- Housing association will ask employ- Housing association has divided con- tems, applications, and automa- ees about proposals for improvements sumption areas into 5 categories: tion and will award the best proposals. 6. Regularly replacement of cars, machinery, appliances with more 1. All buildings energy efficient models and types 2. Vehicles and machines 7. Keeping the focus on energy con- 3. Appliances and other electricity sumption and CO2- emission by consumers. purchasing 4. The residents’ own energy 8. Information and motivation of employees, establishing coopera- consumption tion groups on energy savings 5. Energy consumption and CO2- 9. Conversion of operating and ad- emissions from suppliers and pro- ministrative facilities to energy ducers of goods, services and ad- efficient devices with limited CO2- vice to the housing association. emmission 10. Implementation of Residential En- ergy schools throughout the hous- Housing association’s energy policy ing association in order to advise also includes advice and guidance on residents on energy savings and energy consultancy and CO2-emis- motivate reduction of consump- sions as well as dissemination of ob- tion and CO2-emissions tained results. 11. Making demands on suppliers and service companies, for whom the housing association is a customer This communication must, among other things, be carried out by hous- ing association’s website and by participation in and organization of courses, lectures, exhibitions, visits and public debate in general.
23 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
The table below sets Frederikshavn Housing association’s completed actions Investment POI 1) Nr. Action plan RE-production/ Energy saving Project period [DKK] [%] 1 Replacing the light bulbs in all Electricity savings: 250 MWH/ administration buildings, gara- year 2013-2015 1,440,000 100 ges and warehouses. CO2-savings: 75,75 ton/year 2 Energy renovation of 30 dwel- Electricity savings: 10 MWh lings in Section 2, Højbo Heat savings: 310 MWh (district 2014-2015 20,000,000 100 heat) CO2-savings: 41 ton/year 3 Establishment of 500 m2 solar Heat savings: 400 MWh (di- 2011-2013 A part of the 100 at Sæby Strand. strict heat) project CO2-savings: 48.8 ton/year 4 Establishment of 370 KWp PV- 347 MWH/year 2013-2015 5,205,000 systems in different sections CO2-savings: 105.14 ton/year 5 Grøntorvet, heat pump til dryer Electricity saving: 17,082 MWh 2016 10.600 100 CO2-saving: 5,17 ton 6 Midtpunkt, heat pump til dryer Electricity saving: 17,082 MWh 2016 10,600 100 CO2-saving: 5,17 ton 7 Råholt, heat pump til dryer Electricity saving: 21,102 MWh 2016 13,094 100 CO2-saving: 6,39 ton 8 Munkeparken, Switching Electricity saving: 10,453MWh 2016 245,778 100 lighting ot LED CO2-saving: 3,16 ton 9 Sæbyparken, Energy refurbish- Heat saving: 303.507MWh 2016 47,346,187 100 ment CO2-saving: 37,16 ton 1): POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage.
5.6.2 the cities of Frederikshavn, Ravnshøj, association’s CO2- emissions through Vesterport Housing Association Strandby, Elling and Ålbæk. targeted energy saving efforts and production of renewable energy. Vesterport Housing Association was Vision: established in 1946, when the first 120 Vesterport Housing Association con- Goal: dwellings were built in Frederikshavn siders the implementation of energy The goal for Vesterport Housing As- city. Today, the housing association savings and reduction of CO2- emis- sociation is to reduce CO2-emission manages 2,400 residential build- sions as a social obligation and as much as possible and to include ings, spread over 12 departments in therefore wishes to reduce housing application of renewable energy in its dwellings.
24 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
The table below sets Vesterport Housing Association’s completed actions Project Investment POI 1) Nr. Action plan RE-production/ Energy saving period [DKK] [%] 1 Installation of 14.6 kW solar PV for 15 Electricity production: 12 MWh/year newly constructed flex housing by Kokt- Co2-savings: 3,6 ton/year 2012-2013 245.000 100 vedstien. 2 Installation of 29.2 kW solar PV as an Electricity production: 24 MWh/year extension of the section 1 indicated by CO2-savings: 7,3 ton/year 2012-2014 491.000 100 Koktvedstien. 3 Establishment of 4 units of DVE heat Consumption of electricity: 41,844 pumps for heat supply of 15 dwellings MWh/year at 70 m2, built in accordance with 2020 Heat producion: 81,2 MWh/year 2013-2014 470.000 100 requirements and 280 m2 of common ser- CO2-savings: 4,8 ton/year vice building at Koktvedvej. 4 Establishment of 24 heat pumps for heat Consumption of electricity: 144 supply of a total of 113 new dwellings by MWh/year, Heat savings: 353 MWh/ A part of the 2013-2014 100 Gl. Skagensvej. year project CO2-savings: 1,713 ton/year 5 Establishment of a 117 kW PV system in Electricity production: connection with the construction of 113 127 MWH/year A part of the 2013-2015 100 new dwellings by Gl. Skagensvej. Heat savings: 209 MWh/year project CO2-Savings: 38,5 ton/year 6 Construction of 15 new Class 1 dwelling Electricity production: 24 MWH/ units by Ravnshøj, supplied with 29.2 kW year 2012-2013 500.000 100 solar PV. CO2-savings: 7,3 ton/year 7 Establishment of 29 kW solar PV system in Electricity production: 29 MWh/ Fælledbo. year 2012-2013 369.000 100 CO2-savings: 7,3 ton/year 8 Establisment of 72 kW solar PV system in Electricity production: Lindegårdsvej. 60 MWh/year 2012-2013 1.150.000 100 CO2-savings: 18,8 ton/year 9 Engparken, energy renovation of 165 Electricity saving: 24,22 MWh, apartments, replacement to three glazed CO2-saving: 7,33 ton 2013-2016 140.00.000 100 windows, new exterior envelope and new Heat savings: 988,19 MWH/year roof. CO2-savings: 222,013 MWh/year 10 Engparken, total renovation of a 350 m2 Heat savings: 22,18 MWH/year 2012-2013 3.000.000 100 facility building (The Multi House). CO2-savings: 2,7 ton/year 11 Section 4, Provst Dreslersvej, energy reno- Heat savings: 1.385 MWh/year vation of 294 apartments, replacement all CO2-savings: 168 ton/year 2013-2016 210.000.000 100 of the windows, new exterior envelope In proces and new roof. 12 Section 1, Gammel Vesterport, energy ren- Heat savings: 1.600 MWh ovation of 538 apartments, replacement CO2-saving: 195 ton/year 2013-2015 444.000.000 100 of part of the windows to three glazed windows, new exterior and new roof.
*CO2 saving by installing 1 MWH solar photovolitc corresponds to 303 kg/MWh pr/year. 1) POI is an abbreviation of Probability Of Implementation and expressed as a percentage. 25 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
6. Conclusions
It has not yet been possible to calculate Frederikshavn Municipal- ity's total energy consumption in 1990, as the municipal reform in 2007 caused, that three former municipalities (Skagen-, Sæby- and Frederikshavn municipalities), joined in one municipality, which today forms the municipality of Frederikshavn. The reference year in this evaluation report and the conclusions are therefore based on energy data in the reference year 2007.
Reduction of energy consumption: By the end of December 2016, Frederikshavn had reduced the mu- nicipality's energy consumption by 134,205 MWh, equivalent to 8.6% of the municipality's total energy consumption in 2007.
Compared to the EU's 20% energy efficiency target, it is concluded that the municipality must intensify its efforts to reduce munici- pality’s energy consumption to meet EU targets for energy ef- ficiency by 2020.
Reduction of CO2 emissions: By the end of December 2016, Frederikshavn Municipality had re- duced its CO2 emissions by 59,242 tonnes, equivalent to 8.85% of the total CO2 emissions in the municipality in 2007.
Compared with the EU's target on 20% reduction of greenhouse gases by 2020, it is concluded that Frederikshavn Municipality must intensify its efforts to achieve 20% reduction of green- house gases to meet EU targets by 2020.
Integration of renewable energy By the end of December 2016, Frederikshavn had integrated renew- able energy from the municipality of 271,235.58 MWh, equivalent to 17.4% of the municipality's total energy consumption in 2007.
Compared with the EU’s 2020 target on renewable energy sup- ply, it is concluded that Frederikshavn Municipality can meet the EU's target on 20% integration of renewable energy supply into municipality’s energy systems by the end of 2020.
26 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016
Frederikshavn Municipality’s Evaluated Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors is valid for 2012 – 2016 and must be reviewed every other year.
Prepared by Energy City Frederikshavn, November 2017.
Approved by
Birgit S. Hansen Mayor
Approved unanimously by the members of Frederikshavn Municipality’s Finance Committee by a committee meeting on Wednesday 22th. November 2017.
27 Action Plan for EU Covenant of Mayors • evaluation 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 Period 8,59% 17,4% 8,85% 5,170 5,170 7, 330 3,160 2,700 0,075 6,390 37,160 33,170 22,640 212,013 40,760 123,165 250,750 169,540 618,288 433,850 335,000 168,000 ton/year 52515,120 4252,600 59242,051 2- CO 1427083,58 271235,58 609981,95 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 11,30 134,53 258,60 270831,15 271235,58 RE MWh/year 134205,42 271235,58 59242,05 0,25 21,10 0,00 11,30 17,08 17,08 24,22 10,45 14,04 85,00 713,38 303,51 270,87 988,19 258,60 3627,70 1456,99 1385,00 1384,60 2029,00 121587,06 134205,42 Savings MWh/year Savings 1561289 MWh/year 1561289 669224 tons 669224 0 1561289 0 669224
2016, Vesterport, Engparken, energirenovering, heat energirenovering, Engparken, Vesterport, 2016, Transfer from 2010-2015 from Transfer Action 2016, Vesterport, Engparken, energirenovering, electricity energirenovering, Engparken, Vesterport, 2016, heat Mølleparken, Vesterport, 2016, 2016, Vesterport, provst Drelsersvej 294 units, heat units, 294 Drelsersvej provst Vesterport, 2016, electricity energirenovering, Mølleparken, Vesterport, 2016, Gas Natural Oli to Heat from switching HMN-Naturgas, 2016, DH-grid optimizing Utility, Fr.havn 2016, advisory extern homes, of refurbishment Energy Utility, 2016, lighting public LED in Utility, Fr.havn 2016, advisory Own homes. private advisory energy Utility, Fr.havn 2016, advisory energy Landbo-Nord, 2016, trucks 5 biogas Waste, Fr.havn 2016, 2016, Municipal Buildings, energy retrofit energy Buildings, Municipal 2016, turbines wind 6 pcs. Household 2016, vehicles 3 biogas Municipality, Fr.havn 2016, Grøntorvet dryer, pumps, heat Association, Housing Fr.havn Fr.havn Housing Association, heat pumps, dryer, Midtpunkt dryer, pumps, heat Association, Housing Fr.havn Fr.havn Housing Association, heat pumps, dryer, Råholt dryer, pumps, heat Association, Housing Fr.havn LED to lighting of conversion Association, Housing Fr.havn Fr.havn Housing Association, energy retrofit, 110 units Saebyparken Saebyparken units 110 retrofit, energy Association, Housing Fr.havn Total: -emmision -emmision 2 2 1 Nr. 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 14 12 13 15 16 17 18 19 20 (reference year) (reference 2007 Status, consumption Energy CO Renewable energy Renewable 2016 30 December Status: Energy Savings: Energy Renewable energy Renewable CO COVENANT OF MAYORS OF COVENANT 2016 Decmber 30 pr. actions Completed
28 Grafik 12-709.hl • Revideret december 16 december Revideret • 12-709.hl Grafik
FREDERIKSHAVN MUNICIPALITY
Frederikshavn Kommune Rådhus Allé 100 9900 Frederikshavn
Tel.: 98 45 50 00 [email protected] www.frederikshavn.dk