Consumer Co-Operatives in Postwar Britain

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Consumer Co-Operatives in Postwar Britain chapter 21 Affluence and Decline: Consumer Co-operatives in Postwar Britain Corrado Secchi The history of the British consumer co-operative movement has been thor- oughly analyzed, by both co-operators and historians. In this chapter I am go- ing to analyze the post-1945 period, and within that time frame I will focus on international links with other European co-operative movements. In the first section I will illustrate the situation before 1945, concentrating on the main themes to be expanded upon in postwar history. The consumers’ co-operative retail movement was certainly the most important because of its size and im- portance within British society and history, but I will also take into account other co-operatives in housing, industry and agriculture. I will also consider separately the Co-operative Insurance Society and the Co-operative Bank, be- cause, even if they were officially cws ventures, their history remained quite separate from the rest of the retail consumer movement. The British movement takes the year 1844 as its official beginning as that year marks the creation of the Rochdale Society of Equitable Pioneers. How- ever, the first co-operatives were created in the second half of the eighteenth century.1 From 1820, two men in particular shaped the form of co-operative societies: the socialist thinker Robert Owen with his communitarian project,2 and the activist William King who founded the Brighton Co-operative Society and helped to gather support for this new form of business.3 The Rochdale Pio- neers, however, were instrumental in setting strict parameters for co-operative societies, in particular through the set of principles in their annual almanac that are still today the basis for the ica’s statement on co-operative identity.4 Rochdale influenced the movement’s development in three ways: first, from * This chapter draws on work for the author’s recent PhD thesis: see Secchi, The Co-operative Movement in Italy and Britain. 1 Bonner, British Co-operation, pp. 1–40. 2 Owen, A New View of Society. 3 Mercer, Co-operation’s Prophet. 4 Website of the Rochdale Pioneers Museum; available at http://www.rochdalepioneersmuse- um.coop/about-us/the-rochdale-principles; last accessed 19 August 2016. See also Chapter 3. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���7 | doi �0.��63/978900433655�_0�5 <UN> 528 Secchi then on the British movement was dominated by consumer co-operatives; second, although socialist in its conception the movement claimed political neutrality; third, the dividend returned to members was to become a distinc- tive feature of the British movement, as well as an integral part of its ideology.5 With its strong working-class links, the movement grew steadily during the course of the nineteenth century. Like many consumer co-operative move- ments in Europe, it consisted of co-operatives in small towns, spreading from the industrial northwest to other areas in England and Scotland.6 Major cities turned out to be harder to conquer, but in 1868 there was already a foothold in London with the Royal Arsenal Co-operative Society, which became one of the most active societies thanks to its strong links to the labor movement and later the Labour Party.7 National organizations – the Co-operative Union (cu) and the Co-operative Wholesale Society (cws) – were founded as advisory bodies to help societ- ies with problems and to help jumpstart their business and community ac- tivities. The Co-operative Union (founded in 1870) was originally meant as an all- encompassing organization for all kinds of co-operatives. By the late nineteenth-century it affiliated mostly consumer co-operatives and gradually lost its original function to become the center for consumer societies only. The cws on the other hand, founded in 1863, was built as a business organization for the consumer movement. It was meant to advise societies on how to make their purchases and to provide them with products that the movement would manufacture in the cws factories. It was not created as an organization meant to control all purchases within the movement, although this ambition was probably in the minds of its creators. The cws supported many affiliated activities: the biggest were the tea plan- tations in Ceylon (now Sri Lanka) that allowed cws to control as much as 20 percent of the tea market in the 1950s.8 It also built factories to produce its own goods for consumer co-operatives. There were also other co-operative ventures, among them were the Co-operative Insurance Society and the Co- operative Bank, which grew steadily during the twentieth century and in 2016 provided insurance and banking for millions of consumers under the banner of the Co-operative Banking Group. The Co-operative Productive Federation was another branch of the Co-operative Union, and, being so small, worked 5 Bonner, British Co-operation, pp. 41–116; Gurney, Co-operative Culture, pp. 105–31; Bailey, The British Co-operative Movement, pp. 35–82. 6 Purvis, “The Development of Co-operative Retailing”. 7 Rhodes, An Arsenal for Labour. 8 Anderson, “Cost of a Cup of Tea”. See also Wilson et al., Building Co-operation and Chapter 22. <UN>.
Recommended publications
  • Parliamentary Debates (Hansard)
    Thursday Volume 513 15 July 2010 No. 33 HOUSE OF COMMONS OFFICIAL REPORT PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) Thursday 15 July 2010 £5·00 © Parliamentary Copyright House of Commons 2010 This publication may be reproduced under the terms of the Parliamentary Click-Use Licence, available online through the Office of Public Sector Information website at www.opsi.gov.uk/click-use/ Enquiries to the Office of Public Sector Information, Kew, Richmond, Surrey TW9 4DU; e-mail: [email protected] 1069 15 JULY 2010 1070 what can be done to speed up transactions. I know that House of Commons my right hon. Friend the Minister for Housing is looking at ways to speed up the introduction of e-conveyancing. Thursday 15 July 2010 Dr Alan Whitehead (Southampton, Test) (Lab): Why has the Secretary of State decided, alongside the abolition The House met at half-past Ten o’clock of HIPs, that energy performance certificates should no longer be required at the point when a house is initially viewed for purchase? Does he intend to downgrade the PRAYERS importance of those as well? [MR SPEAKER in the Chair] Mr Pickles: Gracious, no—indeed, under our green deal, energy certificates will perform a much more important role. They will be about bringing the price of energy down and ensuring that somebody with a house Oral Answers to Questions that has a good energy certificate does well, because we want to get houses on to the market. We will insist that the energy certificate be commissioned and in place before the sale takes place. It is about speeding things COMMUNITIES AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT up—the hon.
    [Show full text]
  • Activity 6 [COOPERATIVES in the SCHOOLS]
    Day 1 – Activity 6 [COOPERATIVES IN THE SCHOOLS] Activity 6 - Cooperative Facts Time: 20 minutes Objective: Students will learn some basic history and facts about cooperatives. Step 1: Instruct students to take out their handouts called “Cooperative Fact Sheets.” Give them 3-5 minutes to read them silently to themselves. Step 2: Tell students that they will play, “Find the Fact”. Have each material handler come up and get a white board for each cooperative. If the teacher does not have white boards, then have the reporter take out a notebook and a marker. Tell students that each group will get 30 seconds to find the answer to a fact question and write it on their whiteboard or notebook. At the end of the 30 seconds, each team will hold up their answers and accumulate points for each correct fact found. Team will use their “Cooperative Fact Sheet” to help them with this game. Step 3: Give an example so that students understand the game. “Who is the founding father that organized the first successful US cooperative in 1752?” After 30 seconds, call time and have students hold up their answers. For the teams who wrote, “Benjamin Franklin” say, these teams would have gotten one point. Write the team names on the board to keep track of points. Step 4: When teams understand the rules, begin the game. Below are sample questions/answers: 1. What year was the first cooperative in Wisconsin formed? A: 1841 2. What is the word that means, “The money left over after you pay all your expenses?” A: profit 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Dr. William King and the Co-Operator, 1828-1830
    Dr. William King AN!) THK ,Cp-operator i828^i83o I Edited by T. W. MERCER, nn-: CO-OPERATIVE UNWN Liv Hfornia MO!,VOAKE HOCSI', HANOV«R STRLl.T onal ity Dr. WILLIAM KING AND THE CO-OPERATOR 1828-1830 Dk. William King. From a Photoiiraph by his friend, Mons. L. Leuliette, i Frontispiece, Dr. WILLIAM KING AND THE CO-OPERATOR 1828-1830 With Introduction and Xotes by T. W. MERCER MANCHESTER: The Co-operative Union Limitku, Holvoake House. Hanover Street. 1922. "Co-operation is a voluntar}' act, and all the power in the world cannot make it compulsory ; nor is it desir- able that it should depend upon any power but its own." —The Co-operator, 1829. 1 C7S PREFATORY NOTE. Fifty-Fourth Annual \Y/HEN it was agreed that the Co-operative Congress should be held at Brighton of in June, 1922, the General Publications Committee the Co-operative Union decided that the time was " Co-operator," a small opportune to . reprint The co-operative periodical, first published in Brighton by Dr. William King nearly a century ago. In consequence of that decision, the present volume has been prepared. It includes a faithful reprint of " Co-operator a the twenty-eight numbers of The " ; sketch of Dr. King's Ufe and teaching, containing notes information not previously published ; and a few contributed by the present writer. Several letters written by Dr. King to other early co-operators are also here reprinted. In "The Co-operator" both spelling and punctuation have been left as they are in the original edition, but a few obvious printer's errors have been corrected.
    [Show full text]
  • Mapping: Key Figures National Report: United Kingdom Ica-Eu Partnership
    MAPPING: KEY FIGURES NATIONAL REPORT: UNITED KINGDOM ICA-EU PARTNERSHIP TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION AND CONTEXT ........................................................................... 2 i. Historical background ........................................................................................... 2 ii. Public national statistics ....................................................................................... 4 iii. Research methodology......................................................................................... 5 II. KEY FIGURES ......................................................................................................... 6 iv. ICA member data ................................................................................................. 7 v. General overview .................................................................................................. 7 vi. Sector overview .................................................................................................... 8 III. GRAPHS................................................................................................................. 11 vii. Number of cooperatives by type of cooperative: ............................................... 11 viii. Number of memberships by type of cooperative: .............................................. 12 ix. Number of employees by type of cooperative: .................................................. 13 x. Turnover by type of cooperative in EUR: ..........................................................
    [Show full text]
  • A Dialectical Approach to the Future of Work Narrative
    Work and totality: A dialectical approach to the future of work narrative by Duane Fontaine M.A., Simon Fraser University, 2005 Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Under Individualized Interdisciplinary Studies with Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies and Department of Humanities Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences © Duane Fontaine 2021 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY Spring 2021 Copyright in this work rests with the author. Please ensure that any reproduction or re-use is done in accordance with the relevant national copyright legislation. Declaration of Committee Name: Duane Fontaine Degree: Doctor of Philosophy Thesis title: Work and totality: A dialectical approach to the future of work narrative Chair: Gary McCarron Committee: Associate Professor, Communication Samir Gandesha Supervisor Associate Professor, Humanities Stephen Duguid Committee Member Professor Emeritus, Humanities Geoffrey Poitras Committee Member Professor, Beedie School of Business Marjorie Griffin Cohen Examiner Professor Emeritus, Political Science and Gender, Sexuality and Women’s Studies Douglas Moggach External Examiner Emeritus Professor, Political Studies University of Ottawa ii Abstract Our current confluence of global crises points to the very real possibility of systems collapse. These crises will continue to accelerate under capitalism due to its inherent structural contradictions. Capitalism’s profit motive creates its insatiable need for perpetual growth, a growth only achieved through the exploitation of man and nature. Radical systems change is therefore required and only a collective agent can affect this change. While the working class has so far failed to live up to its potential as that collective agent, the human drive to work—to contribute to society and to express itself creatively—will continue to play a primary role in bringing about the required change.
    [Show full text]
  • Principles and Practices in the 21St Century
    A1457 Cooperatives: Principles and practices in the 21st century Kimberly A. Zeuli and Robert Cropp ABOUT THE COVER IMAGE: The “twin pines” is a familiar symbol for cooperatives in the United States.The Cooperative League of the USA, which eventually became the National Cooperative Business Association (NCBA), adopted it as their logo in 1922.The pine tree is an ancient symbol of endurance and immor- tality.The two pines represent mutual cooperation—people helping people. C OOPERATIVES: q Publication notes ii C ont Chapter 1 1 An introduction to cooperatives Chapter 2 5 ents Historical development of cooperatives throughout the world Chapter 3 15 Cooperative history, trends, and laws in the United States Chapter 4 27 Cooperative classification Chapter 5 39 Alternative business models in the United States Chapter 6 49 Cooperative roles, responsibilities, and communication Chapter 7 59 Cooperative financial management Chapter 8 69 Procedures for organizing a cooperative Chapter 9 77 A summary of cooperative benefits and limitations Notes 81 Glossary 85 Cooperative resources 89 PRINCIPLES & PRACTICES IN THE 21ST CENTURY i Kimberly Zeuli and Robert Cropp, Assistant Publication notes Professor and Professor Emeritus in the This publication is the fourth and most extensive Department of Agricultural and Applied revision of the Marvin A. Schaars’ text, Cooperatives, Economics, University of Wisconsin—Madison, Principles and Practices, University of Wisconsin are responsible for all of the editing and most Extension—Madison, Publication A1457, July 1980. of the revised text. The following individuals What has come to be known simply as “the also contributed to various chapters: Schaars book,” was originally written in 1936 by David Erickson, Director of Member Relations, Chris L.
    [Show full text]
  • Cooperative Banks: International Evidence Part of Nef's Stakeholder
    Cooperative banks: International evidence Part of nef’s Stakeholder Banks series nef is an independent think-and-do tank that inspires and demonstrates real economic well-being. We aim to improve quality of life by promoting innovative solutions that challenge mainstream thinking on economic, environmental and social issues. We work in partnership and put people and the planet first. nef (the new economics foundation) is a registered charity founded in 1986 by the leaders of The Other Economic Summit (TOES), which forced issues such as international debt onto the agenda of the G8 summit meetings. It has taken a lead in helping establish new coalitions and organisations such as the Jubilee 2000 debt campaign; the Ethical Trading Initiative; the UK Social Investment Forum; and new ways to measure social and economic well-being. Contents Executive Summary 2 1. What are Cooperative Banks? 4 2. The case for Cooperative Banks 7 2.1 The impact of cooperative ownership 7 2.2 A greater focus on high-street banking and branch services 8 2.3 Inclusive banking for SMEs and individuals 9 2.4 Long-term thinking and stable profits 11 2.5 Stability in a crisis: consistent lending and prudent management 12 3. What criticisms are typically made of the sector? 15 3.1 Cooperatives cannot quickly raise large amounts of capital 15 3.2 They are not as democratic as they claim to be 15 3.3 They act like commercial banks, but less successfully 16 3.4 They struggle to remove ineffective or opportunistic managers 17 3.5 Cooperatives are inefficient 17 4.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliography
    Bibliography Aal, A (2008) ‘The Egyptian cooperative movement: between state and market’, in Develtere, Pollet and Wanyama (eds) (2008) Cooperating Out of Poverty: The Renaissance of the African Co-operative Movement, Geneva: International Labour Organisation All-Party Parliamentary Group for Building Societies and Financial Mutuals (2006) Windfalls or Shortfalls: The True Cost of Demutualisation, London: Mutuo Apthorpe, R and Gasper, D (1982) ‘Policy evaluation and meta-evaluation: The case of rural co-operatives’, World Development, 10(8): 651–668 Armitage, S and Kirk, P (1994) ‘The performance of proprietary compared with mutual life offices’, Service Industries Journal, 14(2): 238–261 Attwood, D and Bhaviskar, B (1988) Who Shares? Co-operatives and Rural Development, Oxford: Oxford University Press Aubrun, R (1915) Mutual Aid Societies in France, Exposition Universelle de San Francisco Axelrod, R (1984) The Evolution of Co-operation, New York: Basic Books Banturaki, J (2000) Cooperatives and Poverty Alleviation, Dar es Salaam: Tema Publishers Baron, M-L (2007) ‘Defining the frontiers of the firm through property rights allocation: The case of the French retailer co-operative Leclerc’, Review of Social Economy, LXV, 3: 293–317 Beito, D (1990) ‘Mutual aid for social welfare: The case of American fraternal societies’, in Critical Review, 4(4): 709–736 Beveridge, W (1948) Voluntary Action: A Report on the Methods of Social Advance, London: George Allen and Unwin Bibby, A and Shaw, L (eds) (2005) Making a Difference: Co-operative Solutions
    [Show full text]
  • Le Paradigme Coopératif : Une Matrice Philosophique Dévoilant L'homo Cooperatus Pour Une Oikonomia Renouvelée
    Le paradigme coopératif : une matrice philosophique dévoilant l’Homo cooperatus pour une oikonomia renouvelée Thèse André Martin Doctorat en philosophie de l’Université Laval offert en extension à l’Université de Sherbrooke Philosophiae Doctor (Ph.D.) Faculté des lettres et sciences humaines Université de Sherbrooke Sherbrooke, Canada Faculté de philosophie Université Laval Québec, Canada © André Martin, 2016 RÉSUMÉ La présente thèse porte sur des postulats philosophiques qui fondent l’activité coopérative. La coopérative est une association de personnes réunies sur une base volontaire afin de satisfaire des aspirations et des besoins d’ordre économique, social et culturel par le biais d’une entreprise collective où le pouvoir est exercé démocratiquement. Une représentation particulière de l’être l’humain, un cadre normatif spécifique et des finalités existentielles singulières se dégagent de cette définition. Ainsi, de la coopérative émerge une autre vision du monde. Par conséquent, elle contraste avec le paradigme dominant actuel de type économiste, qui base toute sa praxis sur la logique interne de l’homo œconomicus et des valeurs qui transcendent cette posture héritée du libéralisme classique et confirmée par le nouveau libéralisme du 20e siècle. Hautement influencé par cette représentation du monde, l’Occident est toujours aux prises avec les conséquences sociales, économiques, politiques, culturelles que provoque un système dont la chrématistique institutionnalisée tente de subordonner le politique et le du social à l’économique, conduisant ainsi au réductionnisme anthropologique et éthique. Devant l’impasse qu’il suscite, bon nombre d’auteurs en questionnent actuellement la pertinence et la justesse. Cela conduit aussi à l’évaluation d’un changement de paradigme pour notre temps et à l’analyse d’alternatives.
    [Show full text]
  • CRD 101: Principles and Practice of Co-Operation Is a First Semester Year One, Two Credit Diploma Core Course of Any Student of Entrepreneurship
    COURSE GUIDE CRD 101 PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OF CO-OPERATION Course Team: Dr Emejulu Gerald A. Department of Cooperative Economics and Management, Nnamdi Azikiwe University Awka, Anambra state Taiwo Olabisi Abdulahi Department of Cooperative Economics and Management, Nnamdi Azikiwe University Awka, Anambra State Dr. Tessy Anigbogu (Course Editor) – Department of Cooperative Economics and Management, Nnamdi Azikiwe University Awka, Anambra State Lawal, Kamaldeen A. A. Ph.D – (HoD) Faculty of Management Science, Department of Entrepreneurship – NOUN Dr. Ishola, Timothy O. (Dean) Faculty of Management Science – NOUN NATIONAL OPEN UNIVERSITY OF NIGERIA CRD 101 PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OF COOPERATION National Open University of Nigeria Headquarters University Village Plot 91 Cadastral Zone Nnamdi Azikiwe Expressway Jabi, Abuja. Lagos Office 14/16 Ahmadu Bello Way Victoria Island, Lagos e-mail: [email protected] URL: www.noun.edu.ng Published by: National Open University of Nigeria ISBN: Printed: 2017 All Rights Reserved ii CRD 101 MODULES CONTENTS PAGE Introduction……………………………………….…. iv Course Aims……………………………………….… iv Course Objectives………………………………….... iv What you will Learn in this Course………………..... iv Working through this Course…………………….….. iv Course Materials………………………………….…. v Study Units……………………………………….….. v Textbooks and References……………………….….. v Assessment………………………………………..….. vi Tutor-Marked Assignment………………………..….. vi Final Examination and Grading…………………..….. vii Course Overview/Presentation…………………….… vii How to Get the Most from this Course…………….… viii Facilitators, Tutors and Tutorials………………….…. ix Summary……………………………………………… x iii CRD 101 PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICE OF COOPERATION INTRODUCTION CRD 101: Principles and practice of co-operation is a first semester year one, two credit diploma core course of any student of entrepreneurship. The course introduces you to some basic concepts that will help you to understand the course.
    [Show full text]
  • International Cooperative Alliance
    International Cooperative Alliance Alan Brouder I. Introduction Th e International Cooperative Alliance (ICA) is an independent non-gov- ernmental organization (NGO) whose aim is to unite, represent, and serve cooperatives around the world. Th e ICA defi nes a cooperative as “an autono- mous association of persons united voluntarily to meet their common eco- nomic, social, and cultural needs and aspirations through a jointly-owned and democratically-controlled enterprise” (ICA 1995). Its 227 member orga- nizations represent more than 800 million people in 91 countries, making it the world’s largest NGO by membership. ICA member cooperatives are conservatively estimated to employ some 100 million people worldwide, 20 percent more than all multinational companies combined. Cooperatives are a signifi cant presence in the global economy; each of the 300 largest coop- eratives has an annual turnover of at least USD 100 million (ICA 2006). In 1994, the UN estimated on the basis of ICA membership alone that coop- eratives contribute directly to improving the living standards of 3.1 billion people (A/49/213). Th e ICA is headquartered in Geneva, and has offi ces in Argentina, Belgium, Burkina Faso, Costa Rica, India, Kenya, and Singapore. It has the legal status of an association organized as a corporate body and is regulated by the Swiss Civil Code. II. Origins and Development Th e cooperative movement emerged in Britain in the fi rst half of the nine- teenth century in response to the social and economic upheaval of the indus- trial revolution. Dramatic changes in the nature and scale of production were accompanied by the decline of mercantilism, the consolidation of the market economy, and legislative reform conferring absolute property rights on landowners.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliography Selected Works Related to the History of Co-Operatives Compiled by Brett Fairbarin
    Bibliography Selected Works Related to the History of Co-operatives compiled by Brett Fairbarin PART I Works marked with an asterisk (*) are especially useful. General, International, and Miscellaneous Works - Journals * Review of International Co-operation (good, short pieces on co-operatives in various countries – historical, contemporary, opinion) * Annals of Public and Co-operative Economy * Journal of Agricultural Co-operation (U.S.) * American Cooperation (yearbook) * Agricultural History (has occasional useful articles) * Coopératives et Développement (Quebec; has some English-language articles) (1999 renamed Économie et Solidarités) Abbott, John Cave. Agricultural Marketing Enterprises for the Developing World: With Case Studies of Indigenous Private, Transnational, Cooperative, and Parastatal Enterprise. Cambridge, 1987. *Attwood, D.W., and Baviskar, B.S. (eds.) Who Shares? Co-operatives and Rural Development. Delhi, 1988. (Good anthology with contributions on Asia, Africa, and Latin America.) Baker, Jacob. Cooperative Enterprise. New York, 1937. (dated but good on European co-operatives in this period) Bekkum, Onno-Frank van, and Gert van Dijk (eds.). Agricultural Co-operatives in the European Union: Trends and Issues on the Eve of the 21st Century. Assen, Netherlands, 1997. Benecke, Dieter W. Cooperation and Development. Role of Cooperative Societies in Developing Countries. Mainz, 1972. (Source is now dated but could be used to illustrate the attitude of the time.) *Birchall, Johnston. The International Co-operative Movement. Manchester, 1997. *Brazda, J. , and R. Schediwy (eds.). Consumer Co-operatives in a Changing World. Geneva, 1989. *Cobia, David W. (ed.). Cooperatives in Agriculture. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1989. (Has chapters on nonagricultural co-ops, international statistics.) *Craig, John G. The Nature of Co-operation.
    [Show full text]