Resettlement Monitoring Report PRC: Lanzhou
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Resettlement Monitoring Report Project Number: 35354-013 December 2018 PRC: Lanzhou - Chongqing Railway Development Project Prepared by CIECC Overseas Consulting Co., Ltd. This Resettlement Monitoring Report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB’s Board of Director, Management or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area. ADB LOAN 2471-PRC The 11th Report for External Monitoring Resettlement ADB LOAN 2471-PRC For New Construction of Lanzhou-Chongqing Railway Project External Monitoring Report for Land Requisition and Demolition as well as Resettlement of Inhabitant (Vol.11) CIECC Overseas Consulting Co., Ltd Dec. 2018 Beijing ADB LOAN 2471-PRC The 11th Report for External Monitoring Resettlement 目 录 1. PREFACE ........................................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1. MONITORING METHODS AND CONTENTS ....................................................................................................................... 1 1.2. RETROSPECT AND PROBLEMS FEEDBACK ON PREVIOUS MONITORING ACTIVITIES ......................................................... 1 1.3. HIGHLIGHT ON THIS MONITORING WORK ...................................................................................................................... 2 1.4. PERSON CHIEFLY IN CHARGE OF THE MONITORING AND TEAM MEMBERS IN THE MONITORING TEAM ............................ 2 2. PROGRESS OF LAND REQUISITION, DEMOLISHING AND RESETTLEMENT OF INHABITANTS ................................................. 3 2.1. GENERAL PROCESS AND THE LATEST PROGRESS OF LAND REQUISITION, DEMOLISHING AND RESETTLEMENT OF INHABITANTS ............................................................................................................................................................................ 3 2.2. USE OF THE SCHEDULE TO DESCRIBE THE BEGINNING AND COMPLETION TIME OF MAIN ACTIVITIES FOR LAND REQUISITION AND DEMOLISHING AS WELL AS RESETTLEMENT OF INHABITANTS ........................................................................ 3 2.3. APPRAISAL OF COORDINATION SITUATION FOR PROGRESS OF RESETTLEMENT OF INHABITANTS AND PROGRESS OF ENGINEERING CONSTRUCTION .................................................................................................................................................. 5 3. CHANGES OF PROJECT INFLUENCE AND ITS CAUSE ANALYSIS ............................................................................................ 6 3.1. A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ACTUAL PROJECT INFLUENCE AND RESETTLEMENT PLAN, INCLUDING EACH SUBPROJECT OR PROJECTS IN PHASES ............................................................................................................ 6 3.2. ANALYSIS AND EXPLANATIONS FOR THE CAUSES FOR THE ABOVE CHANGES ................................................................. 9 4. EXECUTION OF RESETTLEMENT POLICY .......................................................................................................................... 10 4.1. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF RESETTLEMENT POLICIES AND ALL TYPES OF COMPENSATION STANDARDS DURING THE ACTUAL EXECUTION OF PROJECT ............................................................................................................................................ 10 4.2. A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE ACTUALLY EXECUTED POLICIES AND THAT OF PLAN FOR RESETTLEMENT OF INHABITANTS ............................................................................................................................................ 22 4.3. ANALYSIS AND EXPLANATIONS FOR THE CAUSES FOR THE ABOVE DIFFERENCE .......................................................... 22 4.4. APPRAISAL OF ADAPTABILITY OF RESETTLEMENT POLICIES ........................................................................................ 22 5. RESTORATION FOR INCOMES AND PRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 22 5.1. PROVISION OF IMPLEMENTATION CONDITION FOR ALL TYPES OF THE DETAILED MEASURES FOR THE AFFECTED PERSONS ’S INCOMES AND RESTORATION FOR PRODUCTION .................................................................................................... 22 5.2. IMPLEMENTATION CONDITIONS FOR ALL TYPES OF DETAILED MEASURES FOR PRODUCTION AND COMMERCE IN THE ENTERPRISES AND STORES AS WELL AS RESTORATION OF EMPLOYEE’S POSTS ......................................................................... 24 5.3. PROVISION OF IMPLEMENTATION CONDITIONS FOR ALL TYPES OF DETAILED MEASURES FOR LIVELIHOOD RESTORATION FOR SOCIAL VULNERABLE GROUP ........................................................................................................................................... 24 5.4. USE OF SAMPLING TRACE FOR INVESTIGATION ON THE DETAILS INDEXES ON ALL TYPES OF CHANGES OF ANNUAL THE AFFECTED PERSONS’ INCOMES AND EXPENDITURE AND USE OF THESE DETAILED INDEXES AND BASE DATA TO MAKE A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS ......................................................................................................................................................... 25 5.5 APPRAISAL OF THE AFFECTED PERSONS ’S INCOME RESTORATION DEGREE ........................................................................ 33 6. RELOCATION AND RECONSTRUCTION OF THE BUILDINGS ................................................................................................ 34 6.1. RELOCATION AND RECONSTRUCTION MODES AS WELL AS MEASURES FOR THE HOUSING, ENTERPRISES, SCHOOLS AS WELL AS OTHER BUILDINGS..................................................................................................................................................... 34 6.2. SELECTION AND CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS OF RELOCATION SITES, INCLUDING BASIC INFRASTRUCTURE FOR ALL TYPES OF RELOCATION SITES AND CONSTRUCTION OF PUBLIC FACILITIES ............................................................................... 36 6.3. THE MEASURES AND IMPLEMENTATION CONDITIONS FOR ASPECTS OF HOUSE-BUILDING AND RESETTLEMENT THE SOCIAL VULNERABLE GROUP AS WELL AS PROVISION OF THEIR APPLICABLE CASE ANALYSIS .................................................. 38 6.4 INVESTIGATED THE INFLUENCED PEOPLE’S OPINIONS AND COMMENTS ON THE HOUSE BUILDING BY QUESTIONNAIRE OR INTERVIEW .............................................................................................................................................................................. 40 7. RESTORATION OF INFRASTRUCTURE AND PUBLIC FACILITIES .............................................................................................. 45 7.1 INFRASTRUCTURES INFLUENCED BY PROJECT AND THE RESTORATION STATUS OF PUBLIC FACILITIES ................................ 45 7.2.REMAINED ISSUES AND MEASURES TO BE TAKEN BY THE OWNER ...................................................................................... 47 8.IMPLEMENTATION OF IMMIGRATION BUDGET AND CAPITAL SOURCE ..................................................................................... 48 8.1 PAYMENT OF IMMIGRATION FEES AND ACTUAL FUNDS FLOW ............................................................................................. 48 8.2 PAYMENT SCHEDULE OF IMMIGRANT FUNDS...................................................................................................................... 48 8.3. SOURCE AND PAYMENT STATUS OF IMMIGRATION FUNDS ............................................................................................ 48 8.4. COMPARISON ANALYSIS OF ACTUALLY OCCURRED IMMIGRATION FEE AND BUDGET OF IMMIGRATION PLAN AND ANALYSIS OF VARIATION REASONS .......................................................................................................................................................... 49 9. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE ..................................................................................................... 50 9.1. PUBLIC RECORDS OF PROJECT INFORMATION .................................................................................................................... 50 9.2 PUBLIC RECORDS OF POLICIES AND PLAN FOR LAND EXPROPRIATION AND HOUSE REMOVAL AND IMMIGRANT RESETTLEMENT ....................................................................................................................................................................... 56 9.3.PARTICIPATION MECHANISM AND PARTICIPATION RECORDS OF THE INFLUENCED PEOPLE IN THE PROCESS OF IMMIGRANT ADB LOAN 2471-PRC The 11th Report for External Monitoring Resettlement IMPLEMENTATION AND MONITORING ASSESSMENT .................................................................................................................. 56 9.4 ASSESSMENT OF PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AND INFORMATION PUBLICITY ............................................................................. 56 10.IMMIGRANT IMPLEMENTATION AND MANAGEMENT ORGANIZATIONS ................................................................................. 59 10.1 WORKS OF THE MAIN ORGANIZATIONS OF IMMIGRANT IMPLEMENTATION AND MANAGEMENT AND ARRANGEMENT OF MAIN RESPONSIBILITIES