THE ISSUE 11
THE UNIVERSITY OF WINNIPEG STUDENT WEEKLY 2005/11/17 VOLUME 60 » INSIDE 02 News 06 Comments 08 Diversions 10 Features 12 Arts & Culture » 16 Listings 20 Sports uniter.ca ON THE WEB » [email protected] E-MAIL VOL. 60 ISSUE 11 ISSUE 60 VOL.
BIG OIL, BIG MONEY, BIG CONCERNS NOVEMBER 17, 2005 17, NOVEMBER 02 DEBATE RAGES OVER OIL DRILLING IN THE ALASKAN ARCTIC NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE
WARD CHURCHILL UNCENSORED 10 THE CHURCHILL CONTROVERSY EXPOSED AND EXPLORED
MUSICAL COLLAGE 15 WINNIPEG’S TROUVÈRES RELEASES FIRST RECORD TO A PACKED HOUSE
2005 BOMBER REPORT CARD 21 BOMBERS RECEIVE A ‘D’ IN DEFENCE THE UNIVERSITY OF WINNIPEG STUDENT WEEKLY WEEKLY STUDENT WINNIPEG OF UNIVERSITY THE ♼ November 17, 2005 The Uniter
02 VOL.60 ISS.10 CONTACT: [email protected] NOVEMBER 17 2005
NEWS EDITOR: VIVIAN BELIK SENIOR EDITOR: LEIGHTON KLASSEN NEWS EDITOR: DEREK LESCHASIN UNITER STAFF UNITER NEWS E-MAIL: [email protected] E-MAIL: [email protected] E-MAIL: [email protected] Managing Editor » Jo Snyder 01 [email protected]
Business Coordinator & Offi ce Manager 02 » James D. Patterson [email protected] NEWS EDITOR » Vivian Belik Fate of Arctic Wildlife Refuge Still Uncertain 03 [email protected]
NEWS PRODUCTION EDITOR » 04 Derek Leschasin [email protected] Whitney Light Now that a recent US Geological Woods. “The reduction of such impacts Study has estimated there to be 10.4 has made great strides since the fi rst SENIOR EDITOR » Leighton Klassen Beat Reporter 05 [email protected] billion barrels of oil in the area, the developments occurred on Alaska’s North ebate continues over opening part of US government and Big Oil are seeing Slope, but challenges still remain.” He 06 BEAT REPORTER » Whitney Light dollar signs. Supporters argue that notes that regardless of what decision is [email protected] the Alaskan Arctic National Wildlife resource development at home will reduce reached by Congress, the Service remains BEAT REPORTER » Alan MacKenzie Refuge (ANWR) to oil-drilling, as US America’s reliance on foreign markets. entrusted to protect resources in the 07 [email protected] D Congress drew nearer in recent weeks towards The opposition, however, sees more Refuge. of the Arctic’s fragile ecosystem going The Gwich’in Steering Company FEATURES EDITOR » Lori Ebbitt making provisions for development in its budget down the tube. fears that development will mean turning 08 [email protected] plan. As of Nov. 10, however, the House Rules “This is not about need - it is about the area into a maze of roads and ARTS & CULTURE EDITOR » Mike Lewis Committee decided to strip language regarding greed masked as a solution,” says Luci pipelines, drilling pads, pumping stations, 09 [email protected] Beach, Executive Director of the Gwich’in and production wells as has happened ANWR from the House Budget Reconciliation bill, to land around established oil recovery SPORTS EDITOR » Mike Pyl 10 [email protected] a move that appears to acknowledge the concerns projects. Oil spills and gas pollution, too, are considered a constant threat to the Daniel Blaikie of anti-oil protestors and Americans’ hesitation to “This is not about 11 COMMENTS EDITOR » environment. [email protected] industrialize the last 5 percent of Alaska’s North need - it is about Woods adds, “Despite efforts to HUMOUR EDITOR » Matt Cohen Slope. manage the disposal of solid wastes using 12 [email protected] greed masked as state-of-the-art dumpsters and employee ANWR is protected for the moment, training, industry has not been able to PHOTO EDITOR » Wade Andrew but the chance remains that the fi nal a solution” – Luci avoid the attraction of scavengers and 13 [email protected] version of the budget bill could have the Beach predators to the oil fi eld.” This means LISTINGS COORDINATOR » provisions reinstated. The Senate, for its industry is disrupting the natural patterns 14 Nick Weigeldt [email protected] part, appears strongly in favour of Arctic of species, fostering a wider distribution of oil drilling, having passed a bill on Nov. 3 some to the detriment of others. COPY & STYLE EDITOR » 15 Melody Rogan [email protected] to begin oil leases within two years. Steering Company. Along with suggestions that new oil- The ANWR issue is being addressed Beach represents the Gwich’in people, drilling technology will have only a small DISTRIBUTION MANAGER » 16 through the budget process because it a tribe who live in the ANWR region and impact on the area, supporters argue Scott McArthur has the potential to increase government know it as The Sacred Place Where Life that development will create jobs. A U.S. PRODUCTION MANAGER & revenue. Opponents of oil drilling are Begins. They lead a subsistence lifestyle, Department of the Interior fact sheet states 17 GRAPHICS EDITOR » David C. Tan critical of this approach because it avoids relying on the Porcupine Caribou herd for that “a large number of jobs will directly [email protected] dealing directly with the issue by lumping 60 to 70 percent of their food. Beach and and indirectly result from exploration, ADVERTISING MANAGER oil-drilling provisions together with a many environmental awareness groups development, and production in the 1002 18 » Ted Turner [email protected] number of other pressing concerns. are concerned that the health of the area.” 786-9779 The area proposed for development Caribou herd, which visits the 1002 area Beach remains sceptical that this is referred to as the 1002 area of ANWR, annually to birth and nurse its young, aspect will be of any benefi t to Gwich’in a 1.5 million acre coastal plain that lies would be threatened by oil development. people. “Twenty percent of the jobs THIS WEEKS CONTRIBUTORS between the Beaufort Sea and Brooks Other species native to the area could also were promised when the (Trans-Alaska)
Kenton Smith, Jaya Beange, Jon Symons, David Range at the most eastern edge of Alaska. be at risk. Pipeline was built and this has been yet Christiansen, Ben MacPhee-Sigurdson, Daniel Although the Alaska National Interest Bruce Woods, a representative of another false promise,” she says. Only Falloon, Jayme VandenBerg, Joel CoteSelig, Lands Conservation Act designated the US Fish and Wildlife Service, admits a small percentage of Native people are Ksenia Prints, Jonathan Davis, Thomas Asselin, Brad Pennington, Rhys Kelso, Patrick Faucher, Matt ANWR as ‘wilderness’ in 1980, the 1002 that there are some valid concerns. “The actually employed in the industry. Urban, Ben Snakepit, Shane Gibson, William area was not. Instead, it was set aside for Service will work to minimize impacts Nonetheless, Beach emphasizes O’Donnell, Jon Schledewitz further study, its fate to be determined by through regulation and monitoring of that the Gwich’in are not opposed to Congress. whatever activities are authorized,” says all oil, and acknowledge that by taking
The Uniter is the offi cial student newspaper of the University proper precautions some of Winnipeg and is published by the University of Winnipeg development may be Students’ Association. The Uniter is editorially autonomous and the opinions expressed within do not necessarily refl ect a good thing. Beach is those of the UWSA. The Uniter is a member of the Canadian University Press and Campus Plus Media Services. optimistic that the ‘right’ decision can still be made. SUBMISSION OF ARTICLES, LETTERS, PHOTOS AND GRAPHICS ARE WELCOME Articles should be submitted “To Americans this is an in text or Microsoft Word format to uniter@uwinnipeg. ca. Deadline for submissions is noon Friday (contact opportunity to do right the section’s editor for more information). Deadline for by an indigenous people, advertisements is noon Friday, six days prior to publication. The Uniter reserves the right to refuse to print submitted which has not been material. The Uniter will not print submissions that are homophobic, misogynistic, racist or libelous. We also something that has been reserve the right to edit for length or style. done in the continental United States,” she says. In CONTACT US » light of the House decision General Inquiries: 204.786.9790 to drop ANWR language Advertising: 204.786.9779 Editors: 204.786.9497 she warns, “We still have Fax: 204.783.7080 to be vigilant and educate Email: [email protected] people about the human LOCATION » rights of the Gwich’in Room ORM14 and the Gwich’in Nation’s University of Winnipeg 515 Portage Avenue stake in the issue.” Winnipeg, Manitoba R3B 2E9 It remains unclear as to where the majority of Americans stand on the COVER IMAGE issue. Supporters cite polls showing a majority in Illustration by: Salvador Dali favour of oil drilling, while The Aliyah suite is being exhibited on opponents refer to polls the mezzanine level of the Winnipeg that indicate otherwise. Art Gallery until March 19, 2006. The Uniter November 17, 2005
NEWS EDITOR: VIVIAN BELIK SENIOR EDITOR: LEIGHTON KLASSEN NEWS EDITOR: DEREK LESCHASIN E-MAIL: [email protected] E-MAIL: [email protected] E-MAIL: [email protected] NEWS 03 NEW ABORIGINAL LEARNING CENTRE OPEN FOR STUDENTS AND COMMUNITY “POST-GAZA REALITIES” Through the Eyes of Jeff Halper
Ksenia Prints
ven at a time of diplomatic achievements and relative calm between Israel and EPalestine, complete tranquility has yet to be attained. This loaded confl ict still excites and stirs many all over the world, and among them is activist Jeff Halper. In a series of lectures titled “Post-Gaza Realities: Is There a Way Out of The Confl ict?”, he analyzes the confl ict, addresses burning questions regarding the present situation in Israel, and makes Photo by: Wade Andrew assumptions about the future.
As he stood in front of an almost packed Alan MacKenzie through a partnership between the University room at the University of Winnipeg last week, Beat Reporter of Winnipeg and the Southeast Resource “The learning commons will provide a Jeff Halper, the coordinator of the Israeli Development Council, the Winnipeg direct response to the growing digital divide that separates so many people Committee Against House Demolitions, spoke Partnership Agreement, the Aboriginal in this society” – Lloyd Axworthy quite avidly about a subject many choose to new University of Winnipeg building, Council of Winnipeg, the Assembly of First avoid. Nations, Manitoba Métis Federation, and The ICAHD is an action group that which will serve as a learning centre several other Aboriginal Peoples’ groups and attempts to oppose and cr it ique Israel’s policy of Afor aboriginal students and youth organizations. donated $100,000 and RBC Financial demolishing Palestinian homes, and to promote living in the neighboring area, offi cially opened “Wii Chiiwaakanak is a term I grew up Group, which gave $300,000. These funds peace while working closely with Palestinian with,” said Young, who named the centre. are in addition to a Winnipeg Partnership organizations. As the Al-Aqsa Intifada erupted its doors last week. The opening ceremony was “Both my father and my mother referred to Agreement grant of $295,000 announced in 2000, they’ve expanded their activities to attended by members of the three levels of one another as Wii Chiiwaakanak when they in April. also opposing the construction of roads and government, investors, University of Winnipeg spoke to other people. When I was asked The RBC Community Learning expansion of Jewish settlements in the Gaza to come up with a name for the centre, I Commons will be open to the public Monday and West Bank territories, land expropriation offi cials and students. thought about my parents and I wondered to Friday until 10 p.m. The centre will and the construction of the Security Fence, about collaboration.” allow students and neighborhood residents which is meant to separate Palestinian and The University of Winnipeg’s Wii “The aboriginal community will not to access the internet, read news, or do Israeli territories, thus defending against illegal Chiiwaakanak Learning Centre, located be merely observers in this partnership,” research and homework. passage and various attacks. across from the Duckworth Centre on she said, “but partners who will engage Lloyd Axworthy, University of Winnipeg When asked about the group’s methods Ellice Avenue, opened on Wednesday, fully, addressing the needs of all aboriginal president, said the learning commons will of action, Halper responded that they “get in Nov. 9. people.” help create possibilities for area residents. front of bulldozers when they come to demolish Mary Young, the university’s Young began her work with the “The learning commons will provide a Palestinian homes… and when houses are Director of Aboriginal Student Services, University of Winnipeg in 1984. At the time direct response to the growing digital divide demolished, we rebuild houses.” However, says Wii Chiiwaakanak is an Ojibway there were 46 aboriginal students enrolled, that separates so many people in this society,” he insists that the rebuilding is not done on term meaning “partners.” The centre, but today, she said, about 10 per cent of the he said. “It will enable them to get access to a humanitarian basis, but out of political she said, will connect aboriginal people student population is aboriginal. the most modern information systems for motives. living in the Spence Street area with the Corporate funding for the centre came education and community purposes.” The main point of Halper’s lecture was university and its 800 aboriginal students from the North West Company, which He also announced the U of W has not, to the surprise of many, pitching his recently developed a new strategy for ideas about promoting peace under current aboriginal education which will be presented conditions – Israel’s completion of the at the First Ministers meeting this month. unilateral disengagement from the Gaza Strip and victimized world. In fact, he strives hard just stages in the Israeli Apartheid regime, “We need to have good teachers,” he on Sept. 12, and the transfer of control to to press his view of Israel’s true face, which is attempts to isolate the Palestinians so that said “We need to have good professors the Palestinian Authority, led by Mahmoud that of a powerful country that dominates and they can be monitored and controlled with in our universities and we need to attract Abbas. persecutes a weak nation. more ease. The one-sided withdrawal from more aboriginal people into the teaching Halper’s main argument was the Israel’s main problem, according to Gaza is a “brilliant PR move on the part and academic professions. We need to have comparison of the Israeli government to the Halper, is its idea of exclusivity. “Israel tries of Sharon,” and not what is mistakenly innovative programs so we learn from the infamous Apartheid regime in South Africa, to represent itself as a western democracy,” viewed by many as the fi rst step on the past and provide some new pathways to the a dark time of racial segregation against non- he says, but states it will never become one. It road to cooperation and peace. It is a clever future. That is the point of this strategy.” whites, which later on resulted in territorial lacks multiculturalism, as “even the very name tactic meant to quiet the situation, and A l s o s p e a k i n g a t t h e o f fi cial opening were separation, severe repression and brutal of the place, the land of Israel, is exclusive.” enable Sharon to “consolidate his hold on Premier Gary Doer, city councillor Harvey killings. Halper views Israel as a society According to Halper, “From the Israeli the West Bank.” Smith, former mayor and president/CEO founded on racism and a part of the Old World point of view, there is no confl ict, because there Halper concluded his lecture with a of the University of Winnipeg Foundation Order (represented by Bush and Sharon), is no other side. A bunch of Arabs don’t add up series of slides showing the Security Fence. Susan Thompson, MP for Winnipeg South which is focused on power, domination and to a nation… This is our country, and we are As the images were projected on Anita Neville, Kirk Dudstchak, regional exploitation. reclaiming it.” He describes in vivid colours screen, the eyes of many in the crowd were president of RBC, and Edward Kennedy, Halper draws an analogy with the Lord of Israel’s conquering of Arabic territories after drawn to the soldiers standing in front president and CEO of the North West the Rings trilogy, describing Israel as Mordor, its UN-authorized formation, explaining how of weeping Palestinian mothers who are Company. a focal battleground where the Old World it left the Palestinian nation with 22 percent of apparently forced to confi nement in a land “This is not just for students taking of oppression will confront a world based the country. they fi ght over so readily. Halper can think credit courses,” Doer said, “but for the on “human rights and inclusive international The disengagement from the West Bank of no feasible solution to a bloody struggle community, for youth after hours who need law.” Halper casts aside Israeli arguments of and Gaza and the allocation of these territories that ties two already inseparable nations computers. This centre will help make the being under constant fear of terrorism that for a Palestinian state is not a fair enough together. Maybe Palestinian mothers or world available to all our citizens in an equal originates in what he refers to as a righteous solution to Halper. He believes that these are 18-year-old soldiers can. way.” November 17, 2005 The Uniter
NEWS EDITOR: VIVIAN BELIK SENIOR EDITOR: LEIGHTON KLASSEN NEWS EDITOR: DEREK LESCHASIN 04 NEWS E-MAIL: [email protected] E-MAIL: [email protected] E-MAIL: [email protected] STUDENT LOAN BANKRUPTCY REFORMS PROPOSED
By Eric Szeto returns on their loans, said Gauthier. can get away with and it’ll still look good for The Ubyssey (University of British Columbia) “You need to have some period of time the public,” she said. after the study to really assess whether the Caen Suni, public relations and AVIS borrower will get a job, get in the work force communications at the Canadian Alliance D ANCOUVER (CUP) -- The federal and start capitalising on his or her education of Students Association said that instead of government is proposing legislation and be in a fi nancial position to pay the loan,” focusing on the profi t margin, the government The ONATHANUniter “Streeter” that would reduce the time a graduate he said. should address the fundamental issues, which J V with government student loans would have to University of British Columbia Alma may mitigate future loan defaults. Mater Society VP External Jess Klug said the “Instead of deciding when and how wait before declaring bankruptcy. proposal will ease the burden on those who are people can declare bankruptcy with those faced with undue fi nancial hardship, however, loans, maybe we should be talking about why Bill C-55, which is still several months that nebulous two-year window is problematic they’re in that situation to begin with,” he away from being passed into law, would because it leaves the borrower with little or no said. among other amendments, permit borrowers options. “[The government] stands to make quite who have shown fi nancial hardship the “At this point of time when you end a bit of money due to interest rates while Streeter: December or February? What’s the ability to discharge their loans after seven interest relief you only have about fi ve years students are repaying them,” said Suni. best time for Canada to have an election? years instead of the current ten. to make use of any of those services from the Still, others feel that the bill neglects the Gilles Gauthier, director of Corporate Canada Student Loans program,” she said. whole process of discharging a loan. KATE-LYN D. - Arts Major and Insolvency Law Policy at Industry “Once that fi ve years is up what do you According to John Leblanc of the Canada said that the federal government do between those two years? You end up in Canadian Financial Awareness Group, the “I love elections, the poverty and destitution and that’s one of those Canadian government may be reducing the more the merrier. was concerned that “[the current legislation] Merry Christmas. I was too harsh because the various relief things that needs to be lowered to fi ve years,” wait time, but this is nothing compared to think we need it [be- measures that exist under the Canada Klug said. the callousness the government has displayed cause] I don’t like the student loan program can take about seven Klug suggested the proposed changes when people apply for bankruptcy. Liberal party; I’d rath- years to be completed.” may be the government’s way of making “Will [the government] make the er see anyone else Canada Student Loan borrowers are amends for its bad past policies. discharge process any easier? Absolutely not,” in power rather than offered a plethora of options that include “I think [the government] realised when he said. them. I mean, I’m not interest relief, debt reduction, or loan they put in the prohibitions in the late 1990s “Will they tighten up the discharge a huge Conservative fan either, but the Lib- bridging, all of which can last up to fi ve that it was a bad idea to begin with...Now I process even more so if the limitation period erals have been in power too long.” years upon graduation. If the bankruptcy think the government is trying to do something is reduced? Yes, absolutely,” commented GILLIAN DOW - Business Major reform is passed, the two-year wait between about that.” Leblanc. the fi fth and seventh year would be an “Obviously there’s going to be cost for “You’re dealing with a system that isn’t “Christmas. Get it adequate amount of time to judge whether them to do that and maybe thaat seven years going to be forgiving for too many people,” done and out of the the borrower will have the means to make is that arbitrary number that they think they he said. way. Stop dragging through this issue over and over again. Get it done.”
CHRISTINE LACHO - Biology Major
“People might not be wanting to concen- trate on the election if it was during Christ- mas. February would be a better time to do it now that I think about it. I don’t neces- sarily agree with his reasons [Jack Layton] but a February elec- tion would be a better idea.”
STEPHEN WINNEMULLER - General Studies
“It would make more sense to have it in Feb- ruary as opposed to Christmas time. Voter turnout is already low enough as it is. People aren’t going to come out to vote because they have more things to do than worry about.”
ROB VENDRAMEL- LI - Bio-Chemistry Major
“An election in Feb- ruary would allow WE’RE HIRING A NEW the voters more time to prepare. Rather than the hustle and bustle of Christmas, Febru- ary might allow for more informed voting. GRAPHIC DESIGNER I always vote.” EMAIL RESUMES TO [email protected] AND DESIGNER@ UNITER.CA OR COME DOWN TO THE UNITER OFFICE ORM14 BULMAN CENTRE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF WINNIPEG. The Uniter November 17, 2005 NEWS 05
World News Report
COMPILED BY DEREK LESCHASIN
Pakistan – Over a month after a devastating earthquake hit central Asia, the United Nations has received only about one quarter of the $550 million worth of aid it had requested, the Taipei Times reports. Offi cial fi gures state that 73 thousand people in Pakistan alone were killed by the UNIVERSITY CONDEMNS earthquake, and nearly 3 million were left homeless. With a harsh winter looming, UNICEF is expecting a new wave of deaths as people succumb to the elements. Due to a lack of commitment from world governments, food, proper shelters, and ANTI-SEMITIC FLYERS medicine are in short supply, and where these things are available there are severe Hate pamphlets warning against ‘Jewish transport problems. Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, after initially hesitating, has postponed conspiracy’ planted on Toronto campuses the purchase of 50 F-16 fi ghter planes from the United States, valued at $40 million each. The money will instead be By Sarah Barmak used for disaster relief, despite pressure The Varsity (University of Toronto) Holocaust Education Week, which ends Wednesday, their source was someone connected to the from the military. and the annual meeting of the United Jewish university. Communities (UJC) General Assembly, which “If that is the case, we will take swift ORONTO (CUP) -- University of convenes in Toronto from Sunday to Nov. 16 and at and appropriate action,” said Farrar. Shames Liberia - Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf is which Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has been emphasized that community members had poised to become Africa’s fi rst female Toronto’s Jewish community invited to speak. been pleased with U of T’s quick response democratically-elected president, but her Tis reeling after Toronto police News of Sharon’s visit had already sparked a to the situation. opposition in Liberia is crying foul over confi scated hundreds of anti-Semitic postering campaign against him around campus, Campus police said Friday that all the election results, Reuters reports. which is close to the UJC, but there was no evidence remaining copies of the pamphlets had been On Nov. 12, with 99 percent of ballots fl yers found on Ryerson, York, and all the two campaigns were related. destroyed or turned over to Toronto police. counted, Johnson-Sirleaf had the lead three University of Toronto campuses Although the materials were only found on with 59.6 percent of votes over her rival, last week. university grounds, it is not yet clear whether George Weah. International observers, including the African Union, have given the results their support. The pamphlets, bearing However, Weah has declared that the the title “Jewish Supremacism elections were unfair, alleging doctored Unmasked,” were found inserted voting papers and ballot-box stuffi ng. He into library books and sitting on is arguing that there be a re-vote – a library shelves on Monday. The demand that will require an investigation brochure contained anti-Semitic by the National Elections Commission and anti-Israel attacks, and shocked and a decision by the Supreme Court to both students and members of the be fulfi lled. wider community. Last Friday, Weah supporters staged “In the 11 years that I have a demonstration outside the U.S. embassy been working on campus in in Monrovia. The protestors threw stones Toronto, I have never seen anything and were dispersed by police. A peaceful this disturbing,” said Zac Kaye, demonstration of over 500 occurred the executive director of Hillel of following day outside UN headquarters. Greater Toronto. “I fi nd that it creates a very hostile environment for students, Russia – A vast frozen peat bog in not just Jewish students on campus, Western Siberia has begun to melt and that one group would target another has the potential to release billions of tons like this,” said Hagai Kuperman, of methane, a greenhouse gas far more president of Hillel at U of T. potent than carbon dioxide, New Scientist Some of the more bizarre reports. claims of the pamphlet were that Two scientists who visited the area of both the U.S. civil rights movement nearly a million square kilometres earlier of the 1960s and the attacks of this year say that the peat bog, a type of September 11 had been part of a permafrost, has begun to thaw, forming worldwide Jewish conspiracy. large lakes and completely changing the U of T’s deputy provost and landscape. The permafrost had been vice-provost (students), professor frozen since the end of the last Ice Age, David Farrar condemned “hatred about 11 thousand years ago. Peat bogs in all its guises” in response to the generate methane gas, which was trapped crimes. Jewish groups with campus in the permafrost. Some estimates suggest connections are taking steps to do that the bog in Western Siberia contains so, minimizing the damage caused one quarter of all methane stored in the by the materials. earth worldwide. “We’re working to support Scientists have recently become those who have been affected by concerned that as global temperatures these pamphlets, and to ensure that rise due to climate change, melting they’re taken off campus,” said Tilly permafrost such as this will boost climate R. Shames, director of Israel Affairs change further, through the release of vast at Hillel. amounts of methane. The bog in Siberia is The anti-Semitic campaign a prime example, as average temperatures comes close to both the 25th annual have risen there by about three degrees in the last 40 years. November 17, 2005 The Uniter COMMENTS EDITOR: DANIEL BLAIKIE E-MAIL: [email protected] PHONE: 786-9497 06 AX F : 783-7080
X
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X CommentsX
The Good, The Bad, and The Productive
Daniel Blaikie Comments Editor on policy, the script writers to stretch the analogy a little further, are to blame as well. Asleep at the Wheel They think scandal and corruption (sex and Over the past year or so the comments violence?) sells, and they’re out to give the public what they want. By Daniel Falloon section of The Uniter has run an “In the House” feature, bringing you questions The other key ingredient to any good I feel more intelligent and able to think and dialogue direct from the House of production, however, is the audience. A show Sweet sixteen. The age at which reasonably because of it. One of the Commons. Given the impending election doesn’t run week after week, month after many power-starved adolescents get their fi rst major nuggets I have taken out of – it looks like January or sooner – and the month, unless there is an audience that buys fi rst major taste of freedom. While the considering politics is that it is far more fact that Canadian governments seem to it. It’s here that I think Canadians themselves driver’s license represents freedom, it important to concern ourselves with why require a long time to prepare Speeches have to fess up to a larger share of responsibility also represents the responsibility to be people are dying and suffering than to from the Throne, it may be April or later for the poor state of public discourse in this a safe, courteous and watchful driver. concern ourselves with the personal lives of before the House sits again. Meaning we country. It represents the power to kill, and puts others. I came to think this way during the could be down to our last few “In the On the one hand, Canadians want real, one in harm’s way more often. Yet, after same-sex marriage debate. This has been House” features for this year. In light of no nonsense politics to take place. They want I received mine, all I could think about one of the most dominant stories over the this, I wanted to make a few comments politicians to ‘get down to business’ and take was the fact that, while I was entrusted past year or two, and I don’t understand about question period and how it fi gures ‘the issues’ seriously. In the case of the NDP, with the keys to a potential death trap, the fact that so much time and energy into Canada’s political scene. however, when they negotiate – as in the it would still be 20 long months before I is being spent on opposing it. People I’ve always found it interesting to spring – to win changes in the budget that would acquire one major key of trust; a are dying unjustly in our communities note what the actual questions are, as they believe will benefi t ordinary Canadians, ballot in a municipal, provincial or federal because of stigma, racism, sexism and opposed to the three-second ‘clip’ rendition they are blamed for selling out to a corrupt election. It made no sense to me that I was homophobia. To me, and many others I provided by the media. It’s also interesting government. When, after long negotiations, able to drive but have no say in the laws am sure, someone getting murdered is an to note what the members are asking about they come out and say that the government that govern our roads and highways. This issue that deserves more public attention after the hoopla of the lead questions is is not willing to move enough on the issues frustration is one of the reasons I support than someone’s getting married. Yet it over (usually Gomery or some such thing). they feel are important, they’re portrayed as lowering the voting age to sixteen. seems this notion is thrown out the window That is where the real differences between having changed their tune. As if trying to when that person is a homosexual. parties are made manifest. Even more negotiate, running up against intransigence One concern I’ve heard voiced interesting are the answers, or more usually in government, and then looking for other about this initiative is that the newly A fi nal objection to this initiative I’ve the red-herrings, provided by government ways to address their issues was somehow enfranchised will be infl uenced by any heard argued is that voter turnout will members in response. opportunism. number of people and organizations— be even lower than it already is. Perhaps Often, especially on the lead issues When Belinda Stronach changed parties parents, friends, teachers, even the parties it will be. Perhaps it will rise. Perhaps of the day, members of the opposition because she no longer felt that a Harper themselves! The only refutation I can give nothing will happen. It will not be known use their “questions” to make statements government would be good for the country, to this worry is the rhetorical question, “Is until it is enacted. It wouldn’t hurt the condemning the government (as if asking she was chastised rather than applauded for a voter not infl uenced this way when they cause to try to snag young people early. “Why are you so horrible?” was a question making a tough political choice (granted, she are 18, when they are 20, when they are Many corporations seem to understand anyone could provide an explanation for). climbed the Liberal ranks faster than a proper 30?” and so on. We are the sum of our this, and spend large amounts of time and Too often, it is obvious that the member decorum might allow). experiences. How we were raised helps money making their pitches. An infl ux has drafted his or her supplemental This minority parliament has furnished defi ne our ideology, whether we follow of new voters could clear the logjam question before ever hearing the minister’s other examples, but I won’t go on. The fact is what we were taught, reject it, or combine that had been Canadian federal politics reply. If this demonstration of intellectual that for the fi rst time in a long time, it really the two. during the minority government. In the impotence can be dignifi ed by calling it matters who is in offi ce (and by this I don’t same vein, interest in politics will likely an art, Manitoba Conservative MP Brian mean parties, but individuals). One vote can Besides, the 15 through 17-year-old rise among young people, creating more Pallister is a veritable Van Gogh. make or break the government. This has seen age bracket is when, I believe, the potential politicians out of the youth of today. This And so the old adage about Question some members step up to the plate. Some have for the purest form of thinking exists. means different ideologies will become Period being more theatre than constructive crossed the fl oor, others have chosen to sit Current adolescents have been asking prominent, and the public will not have dialogue isn’t too far off the mark. Except as independents. Some Liberal backbenchers questions since they were able to speak, to choose from the lesser of three evils (or the script is written by political junkies even dissented from the government line. but it is only now that they are able to four in Quebec). rather than playwrights, and most of our All the while, obnoxious political think critically about the answer in any parliamentary thespians have the talent commentators have preached superfi cial notable capacity. Seeing as they are only I would like to end with a few words to and improvisational skills of a Keenanu analysis while bemoaning the lack of learning to think about the ideas of others, any parents whose children would benefi t Reeves, which, even on a good day, is tough predictability in the Commons. Many the possibility of a totally independent by this legislation. Politically, you may see to swallow. Canadians have labeled those willing to make thought is most likely. They gradually eye to eye with your teenager, and you may It’s easy to blame the superfi ciality of tough political decisions about the issues as begin to accept more and more of what not. If you clash with them about politics, Question Period on the politicians. They sellouts or opportunists. they are told, and start to claim the ideas debate the issues, try to understand where are after all the ones who execute the Canadians want Ottawa to put on some of others as their own. There is only a brief they are coming from, and try to make whole production. While a fair share of the political theatre with integrity, but whenever window of pure thought available, and them see where you are coming from. In responsibility does lie here, this is perhaps some people in Ottawa try to do that no one what better outlet for it than to express it the heat of battle, however, be thankful too quick. Another obvious culprit in this is willing to give it a chance. While the debate politically. that your adolescent is coming to a stage of terrible movie is the media, the people between good and bad in Terminator might be critical thinking, not falling asleep behind who shoot the production. Of course, the universally accessible, it doesn’t produce good Awakening this critical thinking is a the wheel and checking a random box on political wonks in the backroom who advise policy or create a space for politics to unfold major step in our development. Personally, election day. with integrity. The Uniter November 17, 2005 07 In the House WESTERN MEDIA SHUNS TRANQUIL FTAA EVENTS, HIGHLIGHTS VIOLENT MINORITY By Erin Kaipenen Nov. 4, 2005, Gomery continues to dominate Question Period’s lead questions. Here are The Brock Press (Brock University) nearly fi lling the stadium, to dance, chant, some of the other questions being asked in the House -- ones that aren’t necessarily and listen to various performers including making the news. For complete hansard go to www.parl.gc.ca and click on the “Latest Cuban Silvio Rodriguez and to listen to a list Debates” link. MAR DEL PLATA/ROSARIO, of speakers which included Hebe Bonafi ni of ARGENTINA (CUP) -- Newspapers the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, soccer- and television media in both Canada and god Diego Maradona, and the President of Conservative BQ NDP Argentina hugely exaggerated the gravity of a Venezuela, Hugo Chavez. minor disturbance in Mar del Plata this past After Chavez’s speech, most people left Mr. Merv Tweed (Bran- Mr. Bernard Bigras Hon. Bill Blaikie (Elm- Friday, the day of the offi cial opening of the the stadium and went home. I went alone to don—Souris, CPC): Mr. (Rosemont—La Petite- wood—Transcona, NDP): Mr. Speaker, the Deputy Prime fourth Summit of the Americas. the summit and didn’t know the schedule of Speaker, the Minister of Patrie, BQ): Mr. Speaker, Minister’s capacity for self-con- events, and because of what I “knew” of the Justice says that those the Quebec National As- gratulation seems to know no who commit serious sembly yesterday passed a end. The Liberals continue to To begin with, news sources in Canada Quebec summit (in quotations marks because sexual assault could get motion requiring a bilateral be ethically challenged with devoted little or no attention to the People’s now I don’t know if I should believe the house arrest under ex- agreement to be signed respect to their own behav- Summit which began last Wednesday and media stories about the 2001 summit either), I iour, but I would hope against ceptional circumstances. with the federal govern- hope that they are not ethically fi nished with a street march and gathering in assumed that after the rally in the stadium the For Canadians, house ar- ment to respond to Que- challenged when it comes to a soccer stadium on Friday. march would continue back downtown, to the rest for sexual assault un- bec’s concerns. Unable to something like torture. Perhaps this is because aside from the fences and to the other Summit. der any circumstances is agree with his counterpart, dialogue between the people of the Americas But this was never on the agenda for the just unacceptable. minister Mulcair has decid- Given the recent revelations about secret CIA prisons on top (there were large groups of people from organizers of the People’s Summit, so at 5 p.m. ed to go over his head and of what we already know about Cuba, Venezuela, Brazil, and Uruguay, and when the offi cial summit opened, the streets of Can the minister explain negotiate directly with the Guantanamo Bay, could the how he defi nes excep- Minister of Transport. Minister of National Defence or smaller groups from the other nations of Mar del Plata were nearly as quiet as they had tional circumstances, or the Deputy Prime Minister tell the Americas), and aside from a reunion of been during the days leading up to the arrival is that just code for more Why is the federal govern- us whether the government is Indigenous peoples from across the Americas, of the heads of state. This tranquility was not reconsidering its policy of un- soft on crime, Liberal jus- ment refusing to sign an critically handing over those and aside from the attendance of about 10,000 reported in the media. tice? agreement that responds captured by Canadian Forces people at the People’s Summit, there was However, as soon as a small group of to all the concerns ex- to the American forces? nothing of signifi cance to report. “punkateros” (a cross between punks and the Hon. Irwin Cotler (Min- pressed by Quebec, which sometimes violent bands of protesters, the ister of Justice and At- has the best record with re- Hon. Keith Martin (Par- liamentary Secretary to The lack of media coverage at the Piqueteros, and a term borrowed from Rosario torney General of Can- gard to greenhouse gases the Minister of National People’s Summit however, had nothing to do daily, La Capital), started clashing with police, ada, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, in Canada? Defence, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, all federal, provincial and when our Canadian Forces with the lack of journalists or photographers the media had something to work with. territorial ministers of jus- Hon. Jean Lapierre (Min- apprehend members from in attendance, to the contrary, they were This moment and the Argentine television tice agreed at their last Afghanistan, those people are everywhere. coverage afterwards (as well as Canadian print ister of Transport, Lib.): questioned, some are released, meeting in January that Mr. Speaker, fi rst off , the some are handed over to U.S. No, the lack of media coverage of the coverage and coverage on the MSN/CTV/ conditional sentencing Minister of the Environ- troops and some are handed People’s Summit stems from the fact that Sympatico Web site) confi rmed to me that this is a valid instrument, but ment has the full confi - over to Afghanistan authori- before 4 p.m. Friday afternoon, the city of Mar is what the media (and many of its consumers) it should not be used for ties. For all of them, we no- dence of the government. del Plata was asleep. wanted and expected of the Summit of the purposes for which it was He alone is negotiating tify the Red Cross about their whereabouts and the condi- Residents and tourists alike fl ed amidst Americas. not originally intended, for all the provinces. He is tions upon which they were fears of violence and disturbances. Some news sources in Argentina directly for example, serious and currently working to put released. All are treated under violent off ences such as an extraordinary plan in the Geneva Convention. We Nearly all of the local businesses had associated the disturbance on Avenida Colón child sexual off ences. place in connection with feel utterly confi dent that our closed and many had boarded up their shops with the “anti-summit” but those who broke the Kyoto protocol. And Canadian Forces members are with plywood. Mar del Plata, usually a bustling windows, burned the Banco Galícia and stole treating those people in full With regard to child sex- we have every confi dence accordance with humanitarian seaside destination felt like the scene from alfajores (Argentine sweets) from the local ual off ences, not only is in the negotiations he will law. Vanilla Sky when Tom Cruise’s character Havana café franchise, were not the same there not a possibility of a undertake, not publicly fi nds himself driving through the abandoned people who attended the People’s Summit. conditional sentence for but privately, with his col- streets of New York City at rush hour. News sources in Canada and Argentina youth but there are man- leagues. That was Mar del Plata last week, even varied in their estimates of the number involved datory minimums which would exclude even its on Friday, the day of the arrival of the 34 in the clash with police but they ranged from application in exception- heads of state (excluding Fidel Castro), and the 300 to as many as 1,000. al circumstances. day of the march against the president of the While I was not right there, (I maintained U.S., George Bush and the Free Trade Area of a distance of two or three blocks), in my the Americas. opinion, there were fewer than 100, and more The only street which was awake was likely the number of rioters was between 20 Avenida Independencia, where some 10,000- and 30. 30,000 (depending on the source) marched Only on Sunday, two days later, did the from downtown to the Estadio Mundialista. Argentine press (Rosario Daily La Capital) That’s right, we, the people in opposition revise this generous estimate to be “a group of a Letter to the editor to the FTAA and to Bush marched away from little more than 50.” In Saturday’s newspapers the three rings of police fences and the some and Friday’s television coverage, those who 60 blocks that made up the restricted zone. clashed with police were “anti-globalization” I recently read the article pertaining to a problem with him as a person it would have Although, and rightfully so, there was no protesters or “anti-Bush” protesters. Sunday, the cancellation of Ward Churchill’s talk and done well to put him on stage and have him shortage of anti-Bush sentiment, the march after some refl ection, they were reduced to I was rather displeased by the lack of concrete answer to them instead of avoiding the issue was peaceful. “punketeros” without any particular political info given in the article. I have a couple of altogether. Maybe then we would actually The massive reunion in the stadium ideology. comments. Firstly, it doesn’t seem apparent in know what the issue is about and what both illustrated this fact — the people gathered, the article that anyone involved in the issue sides have to say about it. Ward Churchill is actually knew what Churchill had said about a man of controversy and that makes him an the Kelly family. I searched the internet for easy target like so many outspoken activists, this information but could only fi nd generally but that doesn’t mean I wouldn’t haveliked to that he was accused by the family of misstating hear his speculations about the state of global facts about his former wife’s death and the politics simply because we’ve somehow gotten traditions of her band. I’m not saying that ourselves wrapped up in his family feud. To me he should have been invited if it would have it seems like a personal attack on the man and been inappropriate, but the article portrayed I think the issue should have been investigated it as if no one involved had any clue as to further before cancelling any opportunity what his disagreeable comments were and we might have had to hear him speak and just tried to stay out of trouble. Secondly, I even potentially question him about these really doubt that Ward was coming to the inappropriate statements. university to preach slander against his dead wife, and personally I think that if people have Ø Daniel Gladu
November 17, 2005 The Uniter
HUMOUR EDITOR: MATT COHEN E-MAIL: [email protected] PHONE: 786-9497 08 Diversions FAX: 783-7080 Straight Faced Avian Infl uenza Hits North America: Big Bird First Victim
By Matt Cohen
March 20 1969 – November 16 2005
The world mourns the passing of one of North America’s most with grace and dignity. It’s just Willy Loman in Death of a Salesman. week. When asked to comment, the episode. Audiences should expect a beloved characters. Peacefully, and unfortunate that he was so young.” Count stated, “I can’t believe he was realistic approach to the problem. surrounded by friends, Big Bird Big Bird had spent some time in so young. 36… 36 years old. Ha ha “We could sugarcoat it [the issue], passed away last night at the age Big Bird has had an impressive Asia as a spokesanimal for P. Diddy’s ha. If only he hadn’t died, he might but what would people learn of 36. career. Appearing in over 37 new clothing line, Sean John. It have made it to 37… 37 years old. from that?” said Elmo at a press “This is the fi rst reported case fi lms, including; The Muppets Take is rumored that he contracted the Ha ha ha. Or 38… 38 years old. Ha conference. “Kids have to learn of avian infl uenza we’ve seen on Manhattan, Follow That Bird, and Elmo disease during his travels. ha ha. It’s a tragedy.” about death. It’s part of the life this side of the hemisphere,” said In Grouchland. Currently, he has been cycle.” The episode will be brought Dr. Sanders, the attending physician working in several off-Broadway Long-time friends are planning Sesame Street is planning to to you by the numbers 3, 7, and the for Big Bird’s fi nal hours. “He died productions, most notably playing a memorial service for early next deal with the issue on an upcoming letter L, for loss.
BY: BEN SNAKEPIT WWW.YOUNGAMERICANCOMICS.COM
TALES FROM THE MURITES
” Contrary to popular belief, Dr. Muire invented the fl ux capacitor”
The Uniter November 17, 2005 Diversions 09
Recipes on a budget: MACARONI SALAD 3-4 stalks celery 2-3 green onions 1 1/2 - 2 lbs. macaroni About 2 cups mayo About 1/2 cup sweet relish 1 green peppe Mustard (to tate) Seasoning to taste
Rub eggplant with olive oil and also oil a cookie sheet. Mix bread crumbs with the herbs and coat the eggplant with mix- ture. Lay on the cookie sheet and bake at 400 degrees F until brown. Turn at least once.
Great Moments In Canadian History
By Joel CoteSelig These behaviours led to many people claiming personal bankruptcy and being wrongfully dismissed from As nations across the globe work. Prime Minister Clark’s Pac- prepare for the next pandemic, a Man fever grew to delusions that he more politically deadly disease slew was being chased by ghosts named what was to be the most modern Inky, Blinky, Pinky and Clyde (who government in Canada’s history. later received gender-reassignment Pac-Man fever sickened surgery and became “Sue”). The the nation back in 1979. This PM’s symptoms were so severe that debilitating disease affected people he was unable to sit down with of all ages and professions; including the Finance Minister to table an our youngest Prime Minister, acceptable budget, leading to the the Right Honourable Joe Clark. defeat of his minority government Although Pac-Man fever caused no in a vote of non-confi dence. Even 26 fatalities, many people were affected years later, the Rt. Hon. Joe Clark by its symptoms, which included is rumoured to be still receiving obsessively putting quarters into treatment for Pac-Man fever with a slots and running around cubicle strict diet of cherries, oranges, and mazes searching for power pellets. bananas.
Cross Campus by Shane Gibson ALMOST A THOUGHT William O’Donnell Across Down
1. Give it a shot 35. Turns down 49. “Trading 34. ___ reef 4. “___ a boy!” 38. Race track Spaces” Ch. 35. Travel by boat If I were Spiderman, I’d save 7. Pitcher’s pride circuit 50. Student’s 36. Friend 10. Garden tool briefl turtles crossing highways. 41. Miss. worry, y 37. Ivy league 11. Museum fi ll neighbour Down school It’s just the right thing to do. 12. ___ 42. Circle part 1. Better ___ Ezra 39. Quickly, Speedwagon 44. “He ___ slob!” (band) briefl y 13. Cloth made of 45. Sick 2. “___ Cop” 40. A&W burger Camel hair 46. Taxi 3. Young cow e.g. choice When is a good time to re- 14. New prefi x 47. Brief sleep 4. 43. down’s 43. 4. down’s Ch. 15. Hearing aid? 48. Oven cleaning Hanomansing shingle the roof? When your 16. Neither’s agent 5. Pay for pet bear is in heat partner 6. Squirrel away 17. Pinball area 7. Region 19. WKRP’s 8. Do a book chore newsman 9. Extra Nessman 18. Asteroid scar I decided to be rid of that 22. Contemplate 20. Goes in annoying wasp nest near my 24. Simile words 21. Reggae’s kin house. “isn’t that a country 28. Christmas 22. Cdn. stock club”? my friend asked. gift giver exchange Whatever, they’re all inside 29. Prefi x of graph 23. Once owned or type and that’s what’s important” 25. Young plant 30. Rim 26. As well I said as I pushed down 31. Necessities 27. Rejections the plunger hooked to the 32. Vinyl disc 29. ___ -cone dynamite. 33. Pass, as a law November 17, 2005 The Uniter 010 Features
SOME PEOPLE PUSH BACK: WARD CHURCHILL IS ONE OF THEM If You Can Turn Down the Chatter of the Maelstrom, Churchill’s Ideas Matter.
By James Patterson
“If you don’t want to be in the mental disorder of whiteness to constant fear of the terrorists you assert their entitlement, which they need to eliminate the motive of the have anointed themselves to defi ne terrorists and the simplest way to do who they are and who everybody that is to stop killing their babies and else is as well. The meaning of this they won’t be fl ying planes into your juxtaposition between those things buildings.” and consequently the values of those various decisions means that if you It seems almost natural to shy buy into that you are buying into away from the confrontation that white supremacism and I reject it.” Ward Churchill brings to every dialogue. Possessing a ‘command Since this time Churchill has presence’ greater than most police been cleared of any wrongdoing by offi cers, a quick wit, and a vernacular the University regarding his claims in the upper percentile of the against his indigenous heritage. academic world, his opponents have Despite this, claims of him not being much to fear from his arguments. aboriginal continue to litter the Internet. “How would you do that? Maybe you would try obeying things Another nine allegations were like international law which makes submitted to a formal academic it illegal to starve other people’s misconduct investigation of which children for personal gain, which seven have been adopted for review. makes it illegal to hit civilian targets One of the claims rejected was anywhere. But if your going to from the Manitoba based family rationalize the hitting of civilian of Churchill’s deceased wife, Leah targets in order to consolidate your Ward Churchill, political activist and contoversial author, was scheduled to speak at the University Kelly. This strife between Churchill grip on the economies of others ….if of Winnipeg on Nov. 4. and Kelly’s family was also part your the public that endorses the of the rational that resulted in doing of it in your name then you Churchill’s invitation to speak really have in complaint when it of things they actually are,” quips can only be stopped with meaningful ancestry, his academic credentials, being rescinded by the University is done to you….In the end, I am Churchill, author of more than dissent. and several counts of plagiarism and of Winnipeg Students Association. putting out an appropriate method twenty novels, numerous academic academic misconduct have put the Among the allegations are that that would break the dynamic of papers, and a few spoken word CDs. “Many people reacted to that initial argument on the backburner. Churchill misrepresented the Kelly terrorism He’s considered by many to be an without even knowing who Eichmann family in a book about her which put expert on genocide, dissent, and was. He was a Nazi, but a not a Nazi Questions revolving around them in a bad light. The University You cannot exempt yourself Aboriginal Studies. He also happens of the particular strata that literally his claims of aboriginal heritage of Colorado dropped the allegations, from the consequences of your to be one of the most outspoken, killed Jews. Eichmann was not even arose from an investigation by the as the book was biographical and actions, you have to face what it is controversial speakers today, often accused by the Israelis, as far as I Denver Post in mid-February 2005. personal, not academic. your doing and if you don’t want that resulting in ruffl ing more than a few can recall, of having killed a single Census documents did not record type of response, stop doing it…. If feathers on either side of the political Jew, not directly, not personally.” any aboriginal people living in the Of the remaining claims you want to stop it you have to stop spectrum. Despite this, Eichmann was deemed Illinois neighborhood when Churchill the most significant revolve the ones who are doing it; the ones complicit for his major, but technical, was growing up there. The media, around plagiarism and misuse of who are doing it on your tax dollar, “What got their attention was role in the Holocaust and found particularly Bill O’Reilly and the facts regarding his assertion that in your name.” my ‘extremist contention’ that if guilty of crimes against humanity Rocky Mountain News (a Colorado systematic and deliberate genocide you make a practice of maximizing and genocide. These were crimes for daily) ran with it. From this story, the of Native Americans occurred. For For those of you unfamiliar profi ts for the purposes of sales of which he was hanged in 1962. case was made that Churchill, who at his part, Churchill believes that these with Churchill, the Professor of stocks and bonds in order to pay this point resigned as departmental claims have to do with trying to Ethnic Studies at the University heavier dividends to investors, as a “Technocrats of Empire, a chair but remained a professor under discredit his fi ndings. The media of Colorado became the object of consequence you make your living on station I assigned to a good number of protection of tenure, could be fi red jumped onboard these concerns and intense media scrutiny this past year, the commissions of such sales, then those killed on 9-11, those who were if he lied about his ancestry if he exacerbated the situation to stifl e particularly from Bill O’Reilly of Fox the provocation of that profi tability referred to in knee-jerk fashion as claimed his background with the his comments regarding Eichmann. News. Since January, Churchill has of those sales is to your knowledge being innocent Americans were not University of Colorado as part of He also asserts that none of the become somewhat of a fascination the systematic emmiseration of third innocent. This was not a statement in affi rmative action policies. claims brought against him are for O’Reilly and other media world children. reference to the janitorial staff as the found in Some People Push Back. pundits. The issue at hand was a media tried to make it seem. My god, “I refuse to answer those paper written in September 2001 You are part of what Hanna they would make it seem like there allegations anymore. The way I “There are two specific called ‘Some People Push Back: On the Arendt described as the “Banality of was nothing and no one in those put in the fi rst major public speech things that are on the table with Nature of roosting chickens.’ Evil”, those who don’t kill directly, but towers but janitors and food service on February 8th is that punk white regard to my so-called academic ‘desk murders’, consciously benefi ting workers. You almost get the idea journalists of the Denver press misconduct or regarding fabricating This essay confronted a from the horror that the actual killers that it would be a gigantic homeless crops don’t defi ne who I am. My historical events. One of them has nation with perspectives few could perpetrate. That is what set them shelter.” community does and my community to do with stating the there is strong articulate, and even fewer would off. In fact, as a profession, your was standing right with me when I circumstantial evidence that John dare utter: that the September 11th technical expertise of that endeavour said it, in support. I did not invent Smith started an epidemic disease in terror attacks were a response to makes you a technician of carnage THE MEDIA FIRESTORM an identity, as they like to say. They a Plymouth colony, or what becomes aggressive American policy in the equivalent to what is represented by AND THE ACADEMIC even have Indians who suck up to a Plymouth colony in 1619. The Middle East, and that the victims of Adolf Eichmann, [the organizer of white people who like to say that. evidence exists but is circumstantial the attacks were far from innocent. the Final Solution].” FREEDOM ACCUSATIONS: As far back as they can trace it I’ve evidence, I didn’t say it happened I The fi rst statement may not seem Plagiarism, and Ancestral Heritage been identifi ed in the same way. My said there is circumstantial evidence a far stretch given our privileged Uncompromising in his position, grandmother defi ned who I am, even that it happened; it is self nullifying observational vantage point north of even going to the point of lumping The Eichmann comment was through the right wing source that if you think about it. I am not even the 49th parallel, but as we approach his students in as metaphysical what initially drew the focus of the has been confi rmed. saying what I am accused of saying. year fi ve of the political roller-coaster ‘Eichmanns’, Churchill’s position major media, but the dialogue of the ride that is the ‘war on terror’ the draws on the idea that people have media, and the soap opera that it has … That is the traditional way The second one was in 1837 second half of his point still remains become self removed from the impact now become, lies far from the debate where past identity is ascertained, and has to do with the U.S. army a bitter pill to swallow. their actions have on others. As a Churchill tried to stimulate. Instead, it comes from the family, it comes having done the same with the consequence, he views that complicity the focus has turned on Churchill for the community; it comes more Mandan at Fort Clark in the upper “The right wing propaganda is akin to consent. It is a product of himself. Questions about Churchill broadly than the area where I grew Missouri river. I never developed it did not pick up on this until early socialization, but something that can have arisen by the right and left. up. It is for damn sure it’s not the in any depth, it is self evident that it 2005 which shows you how abreast be unlearned, but something that Accusations regarding his aboriginal prerogative for those affl icted with happened by what my people have The Uniter November 17, 2005
FEATURES EDITOR: LORI EBBITT E-MAIL: [email protected] PHONE: 786-9497 FAX: 783-7080 Features 011 “If you don’t want to be in constant fear of the terrorists you need to eliminate the motive of the terrorists and the simplest way to do that is to stop killing their babies and they won’t be fl ying planes into your buildings.” -WC told me. I put a couple citations their private interests onto America’s journalism that’s propaganda.” and Steel, Diamond says almost all I was too young to have any politics. behind it for people to look at and campuses. For his comments the same things I do, in terms of This has been my entire experience draw their own conclusions, the Churchill has endured countless “It is amusing, as they infecting Indians with smallpox, with the bulk of the left. It has been citations don’t say what I said, which death threats. The fi restorm that are conceding that whom I have with no sources cited, no footnotes. circling that rock, jerking itself off, is not unusual but in this case this is started in late January 2005 quickly plagiarized is now myself, which by playing the game that tweedle-tee is considered fraud. I never considered claimed University of Colorado dictionary defi nition is impossible. He wasn’t required to going to be better than tweedle-dum. an in depth treatment of it, but I am President Elizabeth Hoffman, who substantiate it to be a credible scholar, They say we are morally obligated to now. And guess what? Not only what resigned after she said the debate I have been accused of various because he arrived to the right advocate for the lesser of two evils. I said was true but if was far worse was harming academic freedom and things and have had my life strung conclusion. If you say the same thing But guess what, by supporting the than what I said. They should have turning into a ‘new McCarthyism’. out for the world to see in accordance and arrive at the wrong conclusion lesser of evils, what you get is evil. left it alone. It turns out there was an The department head at Hamilton with their interpretations of it. That then all of a sudden your stuff is This is the game we play, and it turns actual war department policy, not a College who invited Churchill is stock in trade; it is the way it subjected to microscopic scrutiny. out that we perpetuate the system in couple of lonely offi cers at an outpost has also resigned citing “political goes. But the things I’m accused It is about time people caught onto the process of doing that. that could be an anomaly. pressure”. of, the people, the experts they use this because it has been a recurrent to analyze the think in terms of theme of right wing elimination of The point is not to make cosmetic The implications of that are Many of the accusations and the comportment they are guilt of to a dissident voices in the academy, and change, we need fundamental change, much more profound. The whole scrutiny that Churchill has endured far greater degree than me. That is if sometimes elsewhere, for about the and we [in the left] used to know that. analysis is that genocide was eerily mimic those of The Agents of last twenty-fi ve years. It is not a painless process to make genuinely perpetrated and this is how Repression, a book that he co-authored that change and that is the nature of it was done as well as the way it was with Jim Vander Wall originally They went after Mike Davis privilege. We live pretty well and are done. That is the whole point of this published in 1988. In it the authors O’Reilly, Clear because of what he wrote about comfortable so we pretend to make exercise, the academic misconduct document the counter intelligence Channel, Silverman, regarding the patterns public progressive politics [so we are still and research fraud allegations, my programs (COINTELPRO) of the expenditure and the actual conditions safe]. body of work on genocide gained FBI that were used to discredit, Peter Boyle, and in Los Angeles and where you should some resonance and that this was fractionalize and eventually dissolve and shouldn’t go regarding in The Transformational politics, not some monumental historical dissidents like the Black Panther that crew are Ecology of Fear. It served to undercut or any labels we want to put on accident that benefi cial result for all Party and the American Indian not mainstream the real estate market so they alleged our particular stance, that adds up those concerned. Movement. This time the right wing that he invented all manner of things. to anything meaningful cannot be media seem to be the purveyors of [journalists] they Turns out everything he said was painless and risk free. If it is painless If your going to critique my the program. true. The people who were making and risk free, even if requires work, if scholarship, you will be found wanting. are essentially neo- the allegations had absolutely no it is sanctioned, it is ineffectual and Franking when I get done with this “It is exactly the same thing Nazis. competence to be assessing the it is diluting yourself. From this, it is long march of a charade, regarding but with a much greater degree validity or invalidity of the points he quite possible you are lying to yourself my scholarship I will be vindicated. of technological capacity to do it was making. These people are not and others around you. The accusations of appropriating and a much reduced ability for the academics but they are stationing other works are laughable. In the opposition to respond, which is -WC themselves to pass judgment on the It is about time this process terms of the historiography of the partly the fault of the opposition for quality of the academic work on a stopped. I’m getting weary of going legal interpretation I hold my own on letting it go. You have an alternative it is a sin for me to have messed up a completely ideological position. into areas that are disadvantaged, in those too. But there are other people press that is in the 1970s, it’s pathetic. footnote or as they see it distorted the material terms and formal education, out there I am going after when I am Alternative media is on a grander citation or engaged in plagiarism. In the meantime in good and having them understand, and done, who play fast and loose from scale but not very great in terms Americana, in popular Americana, knowing what should be done, while the right wing perspective. of the establishment. You need the Where is the condemnation historians like Stephen Andrews can I going to the highly enlightened press because you cannot get the from the corporate media for those be found to plagiarize and adlib, politicized on University campuses These people [who hold these same analyses you get out of a book who support their position, say like because it is what the status quo and in progressive organizations and accusations as true] should stop on other forms of media. Allen Dershowitz? There is an entire wants to hear.” having everybody confused as to what bickering over nonsense and pay book out just juxtaposing text that might be done. attention to the fact that people Part of what the alternative he lifted [into his book ‘The Case for Despite what could easily be who are galvanizing an alternative media needs to do is develop the press Israel’] from Joan Peters to the way seen as dire circumstances Churchill We need to frame things consciousness are being systematically because books and book production it appears in his own defence of still fi nds hope on the ability for differently, that what needs to be neutralized while you go tisk-tisk over are much more cost effective in terms Israel. Page after page of direct lift meaningful social change. Many done now. I’m gonna quote Rush a footnote. You are just empowering of opposition. So-called oppositionists and there is no response, no reaction of his opponents believe his is the Limbaugh…. anybody who talks as the right to do what they are doing, need to read if they know what they to attempt to discredit Dershowitz, proponent of violence as a means of much as he does, eventually you will which is rationalizing that dissidents are talking about, if they are to be so again this is not reporting, this achieving this change, which often fi nd something that you agree with. have to be more perfect scholars to capable of responding appropriately is propaganda. It is shaping things. makes him the subject of ire in both To paraphrase: ‘A liberal is the most be considered credible. We all play to situations. So no, the left has You always take a Kernel of truth the left and right. The problem that despicable thing you can possible be. by the same rules or there are no not learned what if needed to from that is plausible as an objection and Churchill sees is not that violence All you have to is say you care, you rules at all.” the COINTELPRO era. Some of it work with that. is necessary but that there is no don’t have to do anything.’ That is has… but not enough to organize an platform to work form to achieve this the alternative to the mad dogs in Most recently, two members effective opposition” I have twenty-two books in change. The result to achieve the the right. of the investigative committee were print right and they honed in on platform is often violence. removed after the Rocky Mountain THE ABILITY FOR a grand total of six footnotes, and Change will happen, it can Times found that these members had ACADEMIC OPPOSITION they want to chew on those footnotes “There is still hope in the left follow the trajectory that is happening previously found merit in Churchill’s to make a case for academic but I am using the left in the very right now, with people rationalizing, scholarship. Churchill draws to this IN TODAY’S SOCIETY misconduct. Meanwhile you have broad way, the responsible left, not predicating and justifying inaction on as an example of how the state and a half dozen right wing luminaries those who would run John Kerry, but their own part to the point where when media are trying to elicit desired For Churchill there is no love lost who are documented as engaging the conscious oppositionist. they are locked in the cell for twenty results. for the media has helped bring these the same thing, but on a much three hours a day, and let out only for accusations to light. “O’Reilly, Clear greater scale, as I am accused of and The broader left always a shower, they will still think they are Aside from the charges, others, Channel, Silverman, Peter Boyle, don’t have the avalanche of criticism. gets channelled into being anti-‘a free. The other alternative, and there including Colorado Governor Billy and that crew are not mainstream The corporate media protects its personality’ which means advocacy are a number of possibilities, is maybe Owens and the Colorado Senate, have [journalists], they are essentially neo- own interest in terms of shaping of another personality. Then the to create enough of a critical mass thrown about ideas that Churchill is Nazis. Rocky Mountain News and consciousness to support itself. Part agenda becomes to get one guy out to alter that trajectory to a different treasonous. This quickly evolved into the papers that have been focusing of that is discrediting analysis of those and replace him with somebody else outcome. But if you leave it to people a debate about the legitimacy of using on it down here in the Denver area who may undermine its credibility so we that we can be in opposition to whose main stock in trade is fi guring tax dollars to subsidize scholarship and the States are not reparable and support from the public. somebody we just replaced him with. out how to leave everything intact and public education if the results journalists. They’re essentially the while pretending to do the opposite, included dissenting ideas. Numerous same thing as the yellow journalists [If] you juxtapose [A Little I’m getting to be old and this is your going to end up where others discussions erupted regarding the ran by Hearst from the times of the matter of Genocide] with Jared getting old. This has been the nature want to take you.” ability of private donor’s to illicit Spanish American War, that’s not Diamond who wrote Guns Germs of so-called opposition politics since November 17, 2005 The Uniter FEATURES EDITOR: LORI EBBITT E-MAIL: [email protected] PHONE: 786-9497 012 Features FAX: 783-7080
TIMELINE Photo by: Jon Schledewitz OF A CONTROVERSY
TH Colorado newspaper “The Rocky Moun- SEPTEMBER 11 2001, tain News” publishes articles question- ing Churchill’s claim of being aboriginal. Professor Churchill writes and releases Thomas Brown, an assistant professor at “Some Peoples push back: On the Jus- Lamar University questions the accuracy tice of Roosting Chickens”. In it, he of Churchill’s writing. makes scathing criticisms of the U.S. foreign policy claiming that attacks were retaliatory, logical, and entirely March 2005 predictable. His rational is that the historical warmongering of the United Colorado Governor Billy Owens calls for States and the continued aggression in Churchill’s job, calling him “treasonous”. the Middle East through warfare and Churchill, protected by tenure, refuses TEDIOUS MINUTIAE continued sanctions against Iraq are the to resign. There are suggestions that cause of 9-11. school funding may be cut. OR: INEFFECTIVELY DETAILING He also takes aim at ineff ectual facets of Churchill is academically cleared of any opposition against the original Iraq war wrongdoing regarding his comments. claiming “those involved by-and-large In the New York Times, the University ONE’S CULTURAL CONSUMPTION contented themselves with signing peti- of Colorado president refers to the tions and conducting candle-lit prayer maelstrom as “new McCarthyism”. The U vigils”. of C president resigns shortly afterwards FOR THE UNCARING as more donors threaten to remove Viewing this as complacency by the funding. American people, Churchill asserts that INSTALLMENT #9 the victims in the World Trade Center Legal Council at Nova Scotia’s Dart- were civilians, but most were far from mouth University makes claim that By Ben MacPhee-Sigurdson innocent. He refers to those working Churchill plagiarized one of their in the World Trade Centre as “little professor’s works. Churchill is accused Eichmans”, a reference to high-ranking of verbally threatening the professor. Neglected: National Novel Writing Month Gestapo Leader Adolf Eichmann who Accusations of academic misconduct unrepentantly organized the genocide and questions regarding his ethnicity Completed: Warren Kinsella, Fury’s Hour: A (sort of) Punk Manifesto (Random House, 2005) of millions of Jews and others during increase the pressure to fi re Churchill. the Second World War. Drunk: tap water Churchill maintains that the perceived Churchill points to Eichmann’s defence threats were regarding possible legal Not Missing: former neighbours during his trail in the early 60s where action against accusations of plagia- Eichman asserted that he was nothing rism and not violent threats. He denies and/or a sound (or both). sold. I wish I could have seen the more than a clog in a much greater ma- plagiarism ever occurred. irst off , National Novel chine, that everybody in Germany was Kinsella tells of how he and a look on my face when I walked out killing Jews, and that he, like everybody Writing Month is not few friends travelled to Vancouver the front door and saw the ‘for sale’ else in Germany, was just following APRIL 2005 going so swimmingly. I’ve by bus, using up all their money sign planted in their front yard. I orders. In the end everybody was F to get to the show and with no actually went back inside, started guilty. From this, Churchill draws similar Media begin to openly criticize only produced about 2,000 words acquaintances in the city to speak laughing, yelled “hell yeah” or connections to most workers in the Churchill’s qualifi cations. Questions since last week, when I should be World Trade Center who unknowingly erupt regarding how he can have tenure of. After the show Kinsella manages something similar (there may have continued and profi ted for suff ering and or be given the position of departmen- producing that many words every to be ushered backstage and—to his been a fi st pump or two), and carried bloodshed carried out in their country’s tal chair with the quality of his educa- sheer joy—speak with Joe Strummer. on with my day. name. tion (he has a masters degree). day. Yes, I’ve been busy, but there An impromptu interview ensues They have these two dogs, have also been times when I could Accusations of plagiarism continue. before Kinsella ends up splitting as which shall (like the neighbours) Sept 2001- Dec 2004 Churchill is accused of copying a paint- have been upping the word count Strummer returns his attention to remain nameless. Every time I went ing from an artist and selling it for $100. Several editions of the paper are and have chosen to take the road a “cucumber-sized spliff,” but not between the houses to walk to work before getting the late voice of The or get in the car, the hellhounds published, including the latest, a book Churchill’s lawyer goes on The O’Reilly less productive. entitled On the Justice of Roosting Chick- Factor, denies all accusations of pla- Clash to sign his notebook. would throw themselves against the ens: Consequences of American Conquest giarism, and addresses concerns over I haven’t totally given up All in all, Fury’s Hour is more fence, eyeing me up and snarling. and Carnage. Churchill’s ethnicity. as of yet but I know that the than a worthwhile read for those They seriously wanted nothing 50,000 word count is slipping interested in punk. I would have more than to sink their tiny fangs January 2005 May- Oct 2005 away with each passing moment. liked some more insight into punk into a major artery of mine. Creepy. All I can do is try to keep myself movements in Canada—coverage Now they, like the neighbours, A group of students at Hamilton College Media accuse Churchill of inciting from looking for any distraction of Canadian punks is pretty much are someone else’s problem. And in New York State protest an upcoming violence, saying he is encouraging sol- speaking engagement with Professor ders to “frag”(or murder) their superior available and just spew out as relegated to D.O.A. and Kinsella’s while I’ll miss the matching faux- Churchill. The major media pick it up. A offi cers rather than contentiously object much quasi-literary tripe as own band, The Hot Nasties. More mullets and dye jobs of this family (as fi restorm ensures regarding Churchill’s to military service. possible. And on that note. . . attention to the role of women and well as the incessant loogies horked essay. Fox Network television show “The ***** minorities (or lack thereof) would up by the Dad), the tranquillity that O’Reilly Factor”, hosted by a fl amboyant In Late August the University of right-wing commentator, gives out the Colorado drops its investigation into I managed to fi nish the have been welcome too, but hey— has descended upon the street is email address of Hamilton College’s Churchill’s ethnicity. Churchill states to Kinsella book a few days ago, this is Kinsella’s manifesto, and not a overwhelming. They were, by far, President, and the school’s phone the Associated Press that “You’ve got and enjoyed the second half as by-the-book telling of punk’s history. the loudest people (and dogs) on the number on-air. essentially, a gaggle of white guys out much as the fi rst. We are privy He thanks Jean C. in the credits… block, and it goes without saying that there trying to discredit me, and the Churchill’s talk is cancelled due to worst they can do is call me a white guy.” to a transcription of an interview as in “Chrétien,” his former boss! I’d really rather have anyone living threats of violence. between Kinsella and the late Joey Kinsella’s picks for best punk albums next door than them. Another investigative body is struck by Ramone, for whom the author and singles are also included, as So to them I say goodbye and Public pressure results in the resigna- the University of Colorado to address clearly has unlimited affection. well as a comprehensive list of good riddance, and to all of you I tion of Churchill from the departmental seven allegations of academic miscon- Chair of the University of Colorado’s duct and fabrication. But the best part of the whole books/publications about punk. say: until next week. As it will be Ethnic Studies program. He remains a book, in my opinion, is Kinsella’s Recommended. my tenth installment of the minutiae tenured professor. detailing of his experience seeing ***** and the fi rst as a thirty-year-old, Nov 2005 The Clash and D.O.A. at the As I write this, I am suffering perhaps I’ll refl ect on exactly what February 2005 Two members of the investigative PNE in Vancouver in 1979. This from what one might call a the hell it is I’m trying to do with committee regarding Churchill’s alleged chapter most successfully fuses “hangover,” and have no fi ltered/ this column… The debate over the content in misconduct resign when bloggers re- the personal with the historical; bottled water in the house. Is it just Bark worse than bite, honest: Churchill’s book begins to take a back- veal that both had previously stated the seat to a debate over the limitations of importance and relevancy of Churchill’s where other chapters focused me or does this city’s tap water taste [email protected] free speech and state sponsored dissent work. on the documentation and like utter crap? conducted by academics. chronology of various facets and ***** Churchill continues to speak at colleges movements of punk, “There is a The house next door sits empty in the United States. Future” examines the potential and quiet. Our neighbours recently for punk’s survival, as an ethos moved, and their house has not yet The Uniter November 17, 2005
ARTS EDITOR: MIKE LEWIS E-MAIL: [email protected] PHONE: 786-9497 FAX: 783-7080 Arts & Culture013
AliyahBy Kenton Smith Museum in Fredericton as recently as 2004, their last exhibition at the WAG was in 1993. n the minds of most people, the name Salvador A noteworthy part of that event was a showing of the prints at the University of Winnipeg’s Dali likely conjures up images of melting clocks own Gallery 1C03. Iand anthropomorphism. But it is a far more Delacratez also says that it was simply topical subject at the centre of the Aliyah suite, an her opinion that the quality and vitality of the prints demand that they be seen. exhibition of lithographs by Dali currently showing There is a dynamic energy at work in at the Winnipeg Art Gallery. the Aliyah suite. Dali’s use of colour in prints such as The Battle of the Jerusalem Hills feature bold contrasts that command the eye, and his Commissioned in 1966 by Shorewood conspicuous use of red as a motif for bloodshed Publishers of New York, the twenty-fi ve photo- in Victory: A Song for Thanksgiving, juxtaposed offset print lithographs on display were created with the ambiguous facial expressions seen and fi rst shown to commemorate the twentieth in the foreground (do they refl ect sorrow or anniversary, in 1968, of the founding of the simply relief?), evokes a profound sadness. It state of Israel. is the boldness of fi gural gesture and pose that The subject and thematic content of these leap out in other works such as the biblically prints may surprise those who are unfamiliar titled “Let them have dominion over the fi sh of the with the work of Dali’s later years, when he sea…” (Genesis 1:26) and “We shall go up at once had long since been excommunicated by the and possess it” (Numbers 13:30), which Dali Surrealist movement, and consciously turned clearly rendered after muscular examples of towards religious, historical, and classical classical statuary, the latter after mournful sources for new inspiration. The current Hellenistic battle monuments. exhibit thus presents visitors an opportunity to One can even fi nd traces of Dali’s discover a lesser-known side of one of the last well-known Surrealist technique: the century’s most famous and distinctive artistic disproportionate scale of man and irrigation personalities. pipe in The Land at the Start of the Jewish Settlement, It also showcases noteworthy works of art and what appears to be two voluptuous female that many may be unaware are in fact a part of bodies morphed into one in “Return O virgin of the WAG’s permanent collection. One of two Israel…” (Jeremiah 31:21). Perhaps Dali’s most 250 sets that were produced by two European disturbing use of his ability to trick the eye printing houses and all individually signed by can be seen in his startling visualization of Dali himself, the prints presently hanging in Psalms 23:4, in which a mass of human fi gures “The Land of Milk and Honey” the WAG have in fact been part of the gallery’s is overshadowed by what at fi rst seems merely possession since 1974. Dali’s original proofs for to be an abstract mass, but which reveals itself the commission are also WAG acquisitions. to be, upon closer inspection, a hideously Viewing the prints in the sombrely lit deformed skull – a spectre of death. mezzanine, I’m struck by what one could fairly Even as I marvel at the artist’s aesthetic call their marked propagandistic character. and technical virtuosity, another question The word aliyah refers, in the contemporary arises in my mind: What were Dali’s own context, to the (ongoing) waves of immigration motives in accepting the commission? What to Israel, which many Jews see as a return to were his feelings towards this politically the Promised Land. The images of the Aliyah charged subject matter? suite visualize this theme. The Land of Milk Presenting this query to Delacratez, I am and Honey, with its bright palette and fertility provided with another unexpected link to the motifs, is a joyful expression of hope and U of W: access to a paper, “Courage to Make optimism for the Jewish state, and The Land the Ascents: An Analysis of Salvador Dali’s at the Start of the Jewish Settlement and The Lava Aliyah Suite,” written by a U of W student at Come to Life suggest community, civilization, the time of the 1993 exhibition. Now in the and culture blossoming from the rich but arid collection of the Clara Lander Library at the tones of the brown desert. WAG, the paper, written by Nancy Mullick, Other compositions express triumph attempts in part to answer my question. using the prominence of the Israeli fl ag: in According to Mullick, who draws from the signature image of the series upon its Lee Caterall’s 1992 book The Great Dali Art initial release, Aliyah, we see the fl ag draped Fraud and Other Deceptions, the commission across the proudly, powerfully upheld body was, for Dali, part of a personal game of of a classically idealized youth, who seems to pitting Jewish publishers against one another personify the spirit of the Jewish state at its in competition for his services. This was the inception. And The Pioneers of Israel, with its observation of A. Reynolds Morse, former featured upraised arms and rifl es, emphasizes close friend of the artist and owner of the both the work and armed struggle involved in world’s largest private Dali art collection, who the founding of the nation. noted in his personal diary that both Dali and Given the present contentious political his wife Gala were unabashedly anti-Semitic: climate where issues of land and statehood in their demands that publishers always pay the Middle East are concerned, such images everything completely in advance were based may have the potential to spark controversy. upon bad past experiences with Jewish art Speaking with Helen Delacretaz, the WAG’s dealers. Curator of Decorative and Fine Arts, I ask: Mullick argues that these sentiments surely a major part of the impetus to mount show up in the prints themselves: the woman’s the show must have been the relevancy of the face in A Voice is heard in Ramah, for instance, subject matter within the context of current may be interpreted as expressing sorrow at the world affairs? turmoil surrounding Israel’s founding -- but Not at all, she replies, adding that even also possibly as indifference or amusement. with the signifi cantly large number of visitors Of course, one could counter by pointing “The Lava Come to Life” that have visited the exhibition, there has been to the distinctly unambiguous character of little politically-tinged feedback, and certainly other pieces such as The Price – Bereave, with its David Ben-Gurion and a representation of modern history, and religion. The Aliyah suite nothing in a markedly negative vein. stark expression of grief that almost seems to the illegal immigrant ship Eliahu Golomb are raises intriguing questions for both art lovers Delacretaz further explains that there border on madness. exemplary of what was Dali’s new interest in and followers of world headlines – as well had been increased requests that more of the Delacratez’s own take is that for Dali, the the treatment of recent historical events. as presenting, for the intended faithful, a gallery’s permanent collection be hauled out of commission was strictly a matter of business, If art’s true place is in the public sphere, visualization of a long journey having fi nally storage. She also points out that it has been a and simultaneously suited the thematic content where any potential infl uence it possesses arrived at its destination. signifi cant length of time since these works by of the artist’s late style. Indeed, the face in can be the most widely felt then it is indeed The Aliyah suite is being exhibited on the Dali have been made available to the viewing The Price – Bereave is again reminiscent of serendipitous that a rummaging through the mezzanine level of the Winnipeg Art Gallery public in Winnipeg; although the lithographs Hellenistic sculpture, the faces of which express WAG’s closets should produce an exhibition until March 19, 2006. toured and showed at the Beaverbrook extreme ranges of emotion. And a portrait of that so captivatingly mixes aesthetics, politics, November 17, 2005 The Uniter 014 Arts & Culture Cul de Sac A Da Da Kamera Production MTC Warehouse
By Mike Lewis room floor. No one knows how he died, at the end of the street changed from but they’re quick to share their opinions “dead-end” to “cul de sac,” to a broken on what he did whilst still alive. down, miserable man seeking love single chair sits centre-stage bathed As the minutes tick by, beginning from any place he can get it. We see at 2:01 a.m., the precise moment that how Leonard, by simply being himself, in soft blue light as the sound of rain Leonard uttered his last sound, each transformed each neighbour he came Abuilds steadily throughout the theatre. neighbour recalls what they were doing into contact with, and how he changed The lights fade, and CRASH!, the audience is startled as they heard the “long kind of low kind their lives, by saving a notebook here, of strange kind of moan kind of sound.” or passing along a “Hello Dr.” there. out of its pre-show, anticipatory banter. Leonard, As each neighbour wraps up his or The most notable transformation the central fi gure of tonight’s show,Cul De her reminiscence, Leonard appears to comes when we meet Leonard’s killer, a Sac, takes the stage and sits cross-legged in the make a rebuttle or offer explanation to strung-out prostitute who comes home the audience. with Leonard only to beat him to death chair. Without preamble, Leonard launches into The transition from each character in his living room. Leonard’s killer a monologue about why we’re all here. Not a happens so fast that, at times, it is watches in disbelief as the minutes metaphysical question, but simply an explanation difficult to catch all the dialogue. That tick by from 2:01 a.m. onward, trying being the only downside, MacIvor anything to keep the reality of the as to why a “cultured group such as [ourselves]” portrays each one as though they situation from taking hold. It is here might be in a theatre on a Thursday night. were people he’s known his entire life. that the play is transformed from a Indeed, each neighbour, from Madison quaint jaunt down memory lane, to a the “like, whatever” teenage girl thunderously raw climax. Leonard’s movements are tense living next-door, to Dr. Pickerson the It is at that moment that the and edgy, as though the man has a lot retired veterinarian (secretly guilty of audience is transformed as well. to get off his chest. Leonard is a lonely killing Leonard’s cat), to Victoria the Leonard’s effeminate mannerisms, gay man, who resides in a pleasant flamboyantly cultured art lover, to the having made the audience laugh with neighbourhood, on a dead-end road blue-collar couple of Eddy and his wife each flamboyant gesture, suddenly in an anonymous city. Leonard is also who bicker and argue like any other seemed less funny. With every word, dead. couple, could come out of the life of Leonard just seemed more and more As the play unfolds, Leonard any person. With a little imagination, it tragic as the play wound down. As the narrates the events that lead up to his was very easy to picture each character lights fade, we see only the tiny flame death, threading seamlessly between in costume, stepping right out of the of a lighter, held aloft in Leonard’s the stories and confessions given by his anonymous neighbourhood to let you in hand. As the theatre darkens, the diverse neighbours. Each character, on the local gossip. flame is snuffed out, and the room is ably played by Daniel MacIvor, talks Ultimately, Cul de Sac is a story of transformed from complete and utter at length about their relationship with transformation. We see how Leonard silence to uproarious applause. Leonard and the last sound they heard is transformed from a content, gay Cul de Sac is playing at the MTC him utter as he lay dying on his living suburbanite, who simply wants the sign Warehouse from Nov. 10 to Nov. 26.
By Jaya Beange
n artist by the name of Nancy Edell Mary Janes and Paper Dolls spent a good period of time teaching Canadian artist blurs the lines between Athrough the Winnipeg Art Gallery studio Arts and Crafts at the WAG programs (so the exhibition now at the WAG is of particular interest). She spent the last of her years in the Maritimes and passed away last year after battling cancer. The current exhibit is the work she completed while living on the east coast.
Her oeuvre is colourful, complex, curious and composite. Indeed! She worked as a cartoonist and is, clearly, a skilled artist. The earlier work presented in this exhibition is in one medium: rug-hooking. I suppose it was rather disrespectful of me to have been thinking, “Wouldn’t that be lovely as a welcome mat?” This certainly makes her work original -- the questioning of the divide between art and craft. Edell used layering techniques. Earlier, this was just using paper – inserting paper dolls (sometimes the stereotypical image of herself in Mary Janes, striped socks and glasses) into random scenes. She referenced historical “Nancy Edell at the WAG” imagery: the reclining nude and Egyptian goddesses. But of course – as a contemporary mixing many different media: rug-hooking, (mutated female bodies connected at the artist we would expect nothing less from her painting, drawing and engraving so that we waste covered in a striped stocking – again a – she used these images to make a political are presented with elaborate tapestries. The reference to her and her stereotypical attire). WRITE TO US AT EDITOR@UNITER. statement. sections of frames were carved as though they This later work is reminiscent of Frida CA OR COME DOWN TO THE UNITER Further into this selection of works were to be used to make prints. Edell wanted Kahlo’s work – dealing with painful feminine OFFICE ORM14 BULMAN CENTRE AT THE she became interested in depicting non- to test the boundaries presented by the frame issues and illnesses. Edell’s work is also, UNIVERSITY OF WINNIPEG. GENERAL religious nuns or rather nuns devoted to our so we see it slowly disappearing in her works similarly, surreal. These composite works can CONTRIBUTOR MEETINGS WILL BE HELD modern religions. Art nuns and structure and eventually there are only small sections be contemplated for hours and even then one THE FIRST MONDAY OF EVERY MONTH nuns represent, for her, our new devotional found at corners of her work. may never notice each of the many, many STARTING SEPTEMBER 12 FROM 12:30- disciplines. The structural nuns are supposed In the later years, while she was dealing dimensions present in her work. Here we fi nd 1:30PM IN THE UNITER OFFICE. EVERYONE to be carrying the weight of the world on their with cancer, there is evidence of her struggle in a sheep, some Egyptian script and a temple IS WELCOME. IF YOUʼRE AN ASPIRING shoulders, a symbol into which one could read her work. She depicts many insects and other and there a scarab (the detail in these insects WRITER, WRITE FOR THE UNITER. feminist interpretations. organisms – much growth (as perhaps, the is impressive). One really must go back and In the eighties, her work became more antithesis of decay). Some of these organisms spend more time staring at them. complex, and she began to experiment with are shown attacking representations of herself The Uniter November 17, 2005 Arts & Culture 015 NOT FIRING BLINDLY: TROUVÈRES RELEASE AN IMPRESSIVE EP By David Christiansen
t may have killed the cat, but Trouvères’ curiosity won’t land them Iin the same predicament. The band, drawing on several genres, has put out its fi rst recording,A Shot in the Dark.
The three-piece outfit is fronted by Jason Bernstein, former journeyman singer/songwriter. Bernstein is flanked by bassist Ariel Posen, with whom he writes the arrangements, and drummer Darrin Cohen, who jokingly describes himself as the “glue holding the band together.” The fledgling band’s life is summarized as: formed in late 2004, added Cohen last summer and recorded this five-song EP, which was launched Nov. 6, 2005. “We try to keep it really eclectic. I think we would have gotten bored if we had done all the songs like this,” says an honest Posen, hinting at one of their songs playing in the background. A self-described “musical schizophrenic,” Bernstein says being in the band has let him take his knack for bending genres to an extreme. “Any genre that has a universal Photo by: MarkLipson quality to it appeals to me,” says Bernstein, speaking to his breadth of influences. Bernstein’s songs “The Trouveres live at Mondragon” are tinted by blues, pop-jazz, indie rock, and the heartbreak lyrics typical of emo. Among local chances are there’ll be at least two Problem,” which features a musicians, Bernstein admires people in the crowd that’ll like our chorus that could easily have guitarist Tim Butler, a finalist in sound, but the rest will be like, been plucked from an old the Jimi Hendrix Electric Guitar ‘You guys are too slow, get out Weezer tune. Festival in Seattle. of here!’” Regardless, the open- A Shot in the Dark, a self- “I like having my own minded listener will appreciate funded venture, was recorded experiences, and to write having their music. at Groove Jungle studios in had those, as opposed to writing Hoping to use A Shot in the Winnipeg. The EP puts the about them,” explains Bernstein. Dark to gauge their audience’s band on solid footing to He wrote most of his songs while response, the band likely won’t be eventually release an album. busking in places like Toronto, dissappointed. Their EP is gritty, The internet has been British Colombia, and even Israel full of great melodies, and has a kind to Trouvères. Through and South Africa. This allowed rough-around-the-edges feel that its website, “All these people him immediate feedback, and adds to its appeal. we’ve never met get to hear our time to experiment with the songs. A crowd packed the songs, and a couple of them Bringing them home to Posen and Mondragon Bookstore & Coffee came to the [release] show,” Cohen, he says the songs took on a House for the Nov. 6 release show. says Bernstein. new dimension, with the other two It opened with Joanna Colledge, The band has harnessed musicians adding their collective a skilled singer who shared a the power of 40, yes 40, online four cents. Coldplay rendition, as well as music stores to spread its music “It’s almost like we’re covering some original songs. Trouvères’ set across the land. Included our own songs sometimes. We was true to form, with Bernstein among these are the ubiquitous really like to mess with them,” leading the charge, supported by iTunes, as well as MusicMatch. notes Bernstein. The band says it witty banter from Posen; however, For those wanting a more owes its tendency for tweaking to an extra member would help boost tangible stranglehold on the All the King’s Men, a local jam the trio’s presence on stage. Their EP, it is available through most band renowned for their openly- material was well-adapted to a Winnipeg music stores for interpreted covers. coffee house, although a more around $10. A Jewish upbringing has rowdy venue would likely require With a spring 2006 tour, undeniably influenced the group. a few quicker tunes. possibly including stops at In particular, Posen’s parents are On the EP, the opener, Toronto’s North by Northeast both musicians and were part of “Again,” is a slower-pace song, and (NXNE) Festival and the a Klezmer band, a type of Jewish a good introduction to Trouvères. northern U.S., Trouvères hopes music. The unexpected samba (you read to get the word out to as many “I don’t think I could have it here) in “Out of My Mind,” the people as possible. Bernstein stayed in the house if I didn’t play second track, signals the band’s indicated a full album might something,” quips Posen. willingness to deviate from rock. emerge next fall. Cohen figures their music “The Neighbouring Cats,” a dark, Catch Trouvères at might find a home with “the sulking song, manages to build Winnipeg’s most endearing harder rock people and the poppy tension, and cymbal flourishes venue, the Royal Albert people” alike. abound; used to open their Arms, on Sunday, Nov. “It’s important to share show, this song’s mature sound 27. (www.myspace.com/ the stage with different types of adds much credibility to the EP. trouverestheband) bands,” says the drummer. “If Bernstein also crafted a goodie we’re playing before a punk band, with the anthem-like “Common November 17, 2005 The Uniter Page 18 LISTINGS COORDINATOR: NICK WEIGELDT E-MAIL: [email protected] @uniter.ca PHONE: 786-9497 016 Listings FAX: 783-7080
Want to submit your listing to Uniter Listings? Email your listings to listings@uniter. ca. Deadline for submissions is Wednesday, eight days before the issue you’d like your listing to fi rst appear in. The Uniter publishes on Thursdays, 25 times a year. dpohsbuvmbujpot DPOHSBUVMBUJPOT! UP!VOJWFSTJUZ!PG!XJOOJQFH!TUVEFOUT
s !NDREA 2OSE "!"%D 9EAR s 4ARA -ONKMAN "3C 9EAR s $ENISE 7OODFORD "!"%D 9EAR
RECIPIENTS OF THE (ELEN "ETTY /SBORNE -EMORIAL &OUNDATION