HISTORIC POPULATIONS of NORTHWESTERN ONTARIO KAC Dawson Lakehead University Published In
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
157 HISTORIC POPULATIONS OF NORTHWESTERN ONTARIO K.A.C. Dawson Lakehead University Published in: Papers of the 7th Algonquian Conference (1975) 158 This paper was prompted by the continuing emphasis placed by some eth nologists on the rather vague historical references to Assiniboine peoples in northwestern Ontario as evidence of their occupation of portions of the area. The prime purpose of the paper is to examine the historical record. It is recognized that the early archaeological literature dealing with Minn esota and Manitoba (Wilford 1941, 1945, 1955; MacNeish 1954, 1958) strongly influenced the approach in equating the Terminal Woodland period Blackduck tradition as an exclusive product of the Assiniboine. This was prior to the record of the presence of the tradition in Ontario from the Severn River in the north, south to the border region of west of Lake Superior and east to roughly the Ottawa river region (Conway 1975; Dawson 1974, 1975a, 1975d; Hurley and Kenyon 1972; Kenyon 1961; Pollock and Noble 1975; Ridley 1954,19- 66; Wright 1965, 1966, 1968c, 1972, n.d.). The extensive spacial and temp oral depth of the tradition and its presence into historic times in this area historically dominated by Algonkian speaking peoples negates Assiniboine affinities in Ontario. Further it is implicit in the record that the Algon kian speakers are not recent arrivals to northwestern Ontario. Information pertaining to the early historic period is reviewed in this paper and the results of the extensive archaeological records are introduced concluding that northwestern Ontario has been occupied from time out of mind by Algonkian speaking peoples. In attempting to identify the indigenous populations resident in north western Ontario at the time of European contact, much of the earliest infor- Published in: Papers of the 7th Algonquian Conference (1975) 159 mation respecting the area is based on early French maps of the interior. Cognizance must be taken of the fact that, representation of details of the interior of the country on early maps is in the words of Warkentin and Ruggles following their detailed study of thousands of maps, both ''spurious and in cipient" (1970) hence a measure of conjecture is always involved in their interpretation. Map makers were usually unfamiliar with the country being mapped, hence they were working with second-hand information, which was pro vided by individuals who were involved in an internecine struggle for new territory, furs and souls. Consistent with this diversity of interest, in formation was jealously guarded hence wide cartographic differences exist even within one decade. In some cases, northwestern Ontario is represented by a bewildering confusion of lakes and rivers. The situation has often lead to misinterpretation of the location of Lake Nipigon, Winnipeg and the border lakes (Warkentin and Ruggles 1970; White 1914; Wilson 1910; Winchell 1911). These locations are salient to the consideration of which peoples were resident in the southern portion of northwestern Ontario at the time of contact. It has been recently contended by Charles A. Bishop and others that, the Assiniboine at the time of contact occupied portions of northwestern Ontario and that they were resident in the area west from the Kaministikwia River at Thunder Bay, (Bishop 1974; Bishop and Ray 1974; Bishop and Smith 1975). The "Handbook of American Indians" earlier made a similar inference (Hodge 1912:45). An initial important reference cited is to a single early mention of the Assiniboine beyond Lake Nipigon, reportedly recorded prior to the his toric records of major population shifts, circa 1637, (Bishop and Smith 1975:57). There are no maps or records of Euro-Canadians visiting the area at this early date, thus at best the reference would have to be based on second-hand information. It occurs in the Jesuit Relations of 1656-58. Published in: Papers of the 7th Algonquian Conference (1975) 160 Here it is stated that the people living thirty-five leagues or there abouts from Lake Alimibea (N'ipigon) are called the Nation of the Assinipoualak,(Assiniboine) or "Warriors of the rock", (Thwaites 1896- 1901, 44:249) Apart from the nebulous nature of the reference, to conclude from a single report that a particular people resided in an area is spur ious . On this basis a claim could be made for the early presence of Iro quois west of Lake Superior for they are so shown on a Dutch map of 16~5 (Winchell 1911:26). The claim is even more tenuous when such turbid all usions to Assiniboine, as the reference of Gabriel Marset's report from the mouth of the Nelson River in 1695 of Assiniboine and Cree towards Lake Superior, is used to support the position, (Bishop and Smith 19"5:5"). Even a cursory examination of the early records of peoples in northern Ont ario reveals a confusing array of names few of whom can be positively identified and virtually none of whom are consistently located in a specific local, (cf. Wright 1965). An examination of French records shows that Etienne Brule visited Lake Superior as early as 1622 but it was only following the return of the French Colonies in 1632 that they actually sought out the Indians in their own territory on the rivers draining the north slope. This was by way of the Great Lakes system, (Ontario 18"8:135). The earliest known map to show a portion of the area is Champlain's map of 1652 "Carte de la Nouvelle France". (op. cit.) It shows the country westward to the limits of discovery. This includes territory north of the eastern end of Lake Superior (Grand Lac) to approximately the Michipicoten River. On Nicolas Sanson's similar map of 1650 'X'Amerique Septentrionale", a number of the peoples of the area are shown. The Irini Nadous are shown to the northwest of the river and the Kiristinous are shown to the north, (Warkentin and Ruggles 1970:51). Medard Chouart des Groseilleirs and Pierre Esprit Radisson penetrated Published in: Papers of the 7th Algonquian Conference (1975) 161 the interior during their explorations in 1658-59, (Nute 1943) but it was not until Father Franciscus Creuxius (Du Creux) map of 1660 "Tabula Novae Franciae" that the interior between Lake Superior and James Bay is portrayed. Lake Nipigon (Lacus Alimibegoueci) is shown with the Nipigon River (Klistonum Fl.) draining south to Lake Superior. North of the lake are shown the Kilistones Alimibegoueci (Cree of Lake Nipigon). From an unnamed lake to the west a river, the Assinipoualacus Fl. is portrayed draining east into Lake Nipigon. This appears to be the first use on a map of the synonym for Assiniboine which gradually becomes synomymous with the major lakes of Manitoba (Warkentin and Ruggles 1970:12). Father Allouez in the Jesuit Relations of 1666-67 reported that to the north and north-west of Lake Superior were several Indian Nations, one of which laying far beyond the Cree were called the Assinipoulac, (Thwaites 1896-1901, Vol. 51:57). He also describes a river (Nelson?) entering Hud son Bay used by the Assinipoualacs. Father Marquette in 1669 reported that he heard of a river (Nelson?) which flows into the western Ocean from the lands of the Assinipouars, who live to the west of Lake Superior on a lake (Winnipeg?) where they gather wild oats, (rice) and fish are plenty, (Thwaites 1896-1901, Vol. 54:193). The reference has to be to the lake complex at Winnipeg not Lake Nipigon, for it is north of Lake Superior not west and there is no great river flowing north out of the lake as it lies south of the height of land. Father Dablon in the Jesuit Relations of 1670-71 states that the peoples called Assinipoulac were reported to live in one large village or thirty small villages in one group about two weeks journey west and north-west of Lake Superior, (Thwaites 1896-1901, Vol. 55:97-98). On the Jesuit Re lations map of 1671 the western end of Lake Superior and the border lakes and rivers are depicted for the first time. Very significantly, there is Published in: Papers of the 7th Algonquian Conference (1975) 162 an inscription on the north shore of Lake Superior opposite Isle Royale which states "R. par ou l'on va aux Assinipoualac a 120 licucs vers le nor ouest", (Thwaites 1896-1901; Vol. 55: facing 95). A similar note is affixed to Marquette's map of 1673 (Ontario 1878:136b). The reference appears to be from a location at the mouth of the Kaministikwia River, the route to the west used by Jacques de Noyon in 1688. Another map dated 1680 (Carte d'une grande partie du Canada, depuis Quebec jusq'au fond du Lac Superior...) has a similar note on the shore which reads "Par cette riviere on va aux Assin- epoulacs a 150 lieues vers le Nord-Ouest ou il y a beaucoup de castors", (Ontario 1878:136b). The same note appears on Abbe Bernou's map of 1682, (Warkentin and Ruggles 1970:42). Franquelin's map of 1681 and Hennepin's map of 1683 place the Assiniboine around Lake Winnipeg. (Winchell 1911; Thwaites 1903). It is clear from these references that the Assiniboine resided about 300 to 375 miles (1 lieue = 2 1/2 miles) to the northwest from a point on the north shore of Lake Superior about the Kaministikwia River. This places them at or beyond Lake of the Woods at the time of contact. Further, on the map of 1680 and on the Jesuit map of 1670-71, there is a note at the St. Louis River in Minnesota which reads "Par cette riviere on va au pays des Nadouessiens a 60 lieues au couchant..." Another early map ("Carte dc l'Amerique Septentrionale contenant le pays du Canada ou la Nouvelle France la Louisiane.