DOCSLIB.ORG

Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Of Reframing MAiD in the Media: Rationalizing and Normalizing a New Mode of Dying in Canada by Jasmine Macaulay A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Anthropology Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario © 2019 Jasmine Macaulay i Abstract Through the examination of media discourse during three key periods from the 1990s to 2018, this thesis will demonstrate how Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD) has historically, and is presently, being constructed in the Canadian mass media. This thesis will demonstrate how this reporting is impacting the nation's social consciousness, effectively normalizing and rationalizing the fledgling practice as a legitimate new mode of dying in Canada. Acknowledgements Many thanks my supervisor Jen Pylypa for her support, advice and willingness to take me on as a masters student despite being on leave, and her careful reading of a very long draft thesis. Thanks to Frances Slaney for guiding me through the first year and proposal phase of my masters, and for contributing to my understanding of the anthropology of death and dying. To Danny Rosenblatt, for his invaluable questions which fuelled the inevitable direction of this thesis. To Bernhard Leistle, for his membership on my committee and his valuable feedback. To Sally Sax and Sylvie Lafortune, library specialists at MacOdrum for assistance with sourcing sample data for this thesis and locating official parliamentary rulings. To Dr. Viren Naik, for his knowledge and support. To Dr. Stefanie Green, CAMAP, Bridge C-14 (Jan Ditch) and The Ottawa Hospital MAiD program (Mike Kekewich) for their early and continued support of this project. To Carleton University and the Department of Anthropology and SSHRC for funding opportunities which have made possible this research. ii Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction ......................................................................................................... 1 Definitions ........................................................................................................................................... 2 Background to Assisted Death in Canada ................................................................................. 4 Theoretical Frameworks ............................................................................................................... 7 Euthanasia Talk ............................................................................................................................................... 7 Discourse and Language .............................................................................................................................. 9 Self-Care and Final Gift ............................................................................................................................... 11 Normative Rationalization ........................................................................................................................ 12 Storytelling and Intersubjectivity .......................................................................................................... 14 Framing and the Canadian Media .......................................................................................................... 16 Methods ............................................................................................................................................. 20 Outline of Chapters ........................................................................................................................ 27 Chapter 2: Literature Review ........................................................................................... 29 Canadian Individualism, Rights and Medicare ..................................................................... 29 Official Government Discourse ............................................................................................................... 33 ‘Grievous and Irremediable Medical Condition’ .............................................................................. 36 SliPPery Slope and Conscientious Objection .................................................................................... 37 The Sociability of Death and Dying ........................................................................................... 38 Good and Bad Death .................................................................................................................................... 38 Social and Biological Death ...................................................................................................................... 40 ScriPts, Construction and Medicalized Death ................................................................................... 42 Palliative Care in Canada ............................................................................................................. 45 Suicide ................................................................................................................................................ 49 Survivor’s Stigma and Mourning ............................................................................................................ 51 Assisted Death in the Media and Academia ........................................................................... 52 Chapter 3: Assisted Death in the Canadian Press: the 1990s ................................ 60 Frame vs. Discourse ..................................................................................................................................... 62 Stigmatizing Language ............................................................................................................................... 64 1993 and 1994 - Footing and (Mis)Frame .............................................................................. 65 Religion - What Was Sayable? .................................................................................................................. 72 Official Government - What Was Sayable? ......................................................................................... 75 Messengers, Storytelling and Subjectivity ......................................................................................... 78 Sue Rodriguez ............................................................................................................................................................. 79 ErWin Krickhahn ....................................................................................................................................................... 81 Role of Media .................................................................................................................................................. 85 Self-Care and Final Gift ............................................................................................................................... 88 Chapter 4: Reframing Assisted Death in the Early 21st Century ........................... 91 2004 and 2005 – Frame Alignment & Transformation ...................................................... 91 2000s Language, Ambiguity and Confusion ...................................................................................... 94 Normative Rationalization, Frame AmPlification and Extension ............................................ 99 2016–2018 – Continued Frame Alignment and Normalization ................................... 103 Assisted Death Talk in Canada ............................................................................................................. 107 Language as a Barometer to Social Consciousness .................................................................................. 108 Carter vs. Canada ........................................................................................................................................ 111 Assisted Death Talk – Discourse as Procedural Rules ............................................................... 114 Personal Narratives .................................................................................................................................. 116 iii Assisted Death Talk - Social and Ontological ................................................................................. 118 Self-Care and Final Gift ............................................................................................................................ 126 Self Care ...................................................................................................................................................................... 127 Final Gift ..................................................................................................................................................................... 130 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................. 137 Bibliography ......................................................................................................................... 142 List of Tables Table 1: Euthanasia Definitions .............................................................................................................................................. 4 Table 2: Article Selection by Key Date .............................................................................................................................. 22 Table 3: The Framing of MAiD in Academia
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Jeffrey Brooks 16 JULY 2010 [email protected]
    CSMD – 170M C.G. – Question de mourir dans la dignité 16 JULY 2010 A brief in support of Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide presented to the Québec Select Committee on Dying with Dignity By Jeffrey H Brooks Montréal, QC H3E 1Z2 Under the Quebec Charter of Human Rights & Freedoms: Clause 2: Every human being whose life is in peril has a right to assistance. Clause 4: Every person has a right to the safeguard of his dignity, honour and reputation. Clause 5: Every person has a right to respect for his private life. Object: This brief proposes that every Quebecker should have the right to decide to end their life pre-maturely with appropriate professional assistance. The current option of allowing only passive assistance by withholding treatment is not acceptable and can be barbaric. With confidence, we respectfully request our honourable members of the National Assembly and their counsel enact legislation which would legalize procedures to provide for assisted suicide and euthanasia following appropriate specific protocols, safeguards against misuse, etc. Rationale: I believe personal life experience qualifies me to examine my own views and to present this brief in a clear and lucid manner. It is not theory; it is how I feel and the conclusions I arrive at after careful consideration. I view myself as an ethical person and take pride in doing the right thing. I actively participated in the care of my parents in their final years and days. This was done with sensitivity and much love. They were totally dependent but they were never a burden. My children were not very involved at that time.
    [Show full text]
  • Programme (Pdf)
    Canadian Political Science Association Association canadienne de science politique 81th Annual Conference May 27, 28, 29 2009 81e Congrès annuel 27, 28, 29 mai PROGRAMME Congress of the Humanities and Social Sciences Congrès des sciences humaines TABLE OF CONTENTS/TABLE DES MATIÈRES Buildings/Édifices 1 Acknowledgements/Remerciements 2 General Information/Renseignements généraux 3 2009 Programme Committee/Comité du programme 2009 4 CPSA Board of Directors/Conseil d’administration de l’ACSP 5 Special Event/Événement spécial 6 Other Special Events/Autres événements spéciaux 6-7 CPSA Business and Committee Meetings/Réunions d’affaires et comités de l’ACSP 8 Prizes/Prix 9-11 Section Index/Index des sections 12-16 Notices to Participants/Note à l’intention des congressistes 17-19 Workshops/Ateliers 19-26 Sessions/Séances 30-98 CPSA Trust Fund/Fonds de prévoyance de l’ACSP 101 Participants 102-115 A Personal Timetable/Un horaire personnel 117 AGM Agenda and annual reports/Ordre du jour pour la AGA et les rapports annuels 118-151 Campus Map/Carte du campus 152 BUILDINGS / ÉDIFICES The CPSA sessions will be held in the following buildings (see sessions for room numbers): Les séances de l’ACSP auront lieu dans les édifices suivants (voir les séances pour les numéros des locaux) : Édifice Loeb Building Édifice Mackenzie Building Édifice Tory Building Édifice Southam Building 1 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Joseph Wong, University of Toronto The CPSA wishes to acknowledge the following organisations for their assistance with this year’s conference: • the Social
    [Show full text]
  • The Limits to Influence: the Club of Rome and Canada
    THE LIMITS TO INFLUENCE: THE CLUB OF ROME AND CANADA, 1968 TO 1988 by JASON LEMOINE CHURCHILL A thesis presented to the University of Waterloo in fulfilment of the thesis requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History Waterloo, Ontario, Canada, 2006 © Jason Lemoine Churchill, 2006 Declaration AUTHOR'S DECLARATION FOR ELECTRONIC SUBMISSION OF A THESIS I hereby declare that I am the sole author of this thesis. This is a true copy of the thesis, including any required final revisions, as accepted by my examiners. I understand that my thesis may be made electronically available to the public. ii Abstract This dissertation is about influence which is defined as the ability to move ideas forward within, and in some cases across, organizations. More specifically it is about an extraordinary organization called the Club of Rome (COR), who became advocates of the idea of greater use of systems analysis in the development of policy. The systems approach to policy required rational, holistic and long-range thinking. It was an approach that attracted the attention of Canadian Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau. Commonality of interests and concerns united the disparate members of the COR and allowed that organization to develop an influential presence within Canada during Trudeau’s time in office from 1968 to 1984. The story of the COR in Canada is extended beyond the end of the Trudeau era to explain how the key elements that had allowed the organization and its Canadian Association (CACOR) to develop an influential presence quickly dissipated in the post- 1984 era. The key reasons for decline were time and circumstance as the COR/CACOR membership aged, contacts were lost, and there was a political paradigm shift that was antithetical to COR/CACOR ideas.
    [Show full text]
  • Nature-Based Solutions: Policy Options for Climate and Biodiversity
    NATURE-BASED SOLUTIONS: POLICY OPTIONS FOR CLIMATE AND BIODIVERSITY FEBRUARY 2020 About Smart Prosperity Institute Smart Prosperity Institute (formerly Sustainable Prosperity) is a national research network and policy think tank based at the University of Ottawa. We deliver world-class research and work with public and private partners – all to advance practical policies and market solutions for a stronger, cleaner economy. institute.smartprosperity.ca Written by Katherine Monahan, Ben Filewod, John McNally and Shabnam Khalaj February 2020 CONTENTS Key Messages 1 Infographic: Policymaker’s Guide to Integrating Biodiversity into Climate Policy 2 Introduction: The Biggest Bang for the Buck 3 Outline 5 Section 1: Policy Options for Nature-Based Climate Solutions: Integrating Biodiversity 7 Chapter 1 – Public Funding 7 1.1 Establishing Guiding Principles for Project and Policy Selection 9 1.2 Reverse Auctions – A Market-Based Solution to Minimize Costs 12 1.2.1 Challenges and Design Options for Reverse Auctions 13 Chapter 2 – Achieving Multiple Objectives through Carbon Offsets 15 2.1 Integrating Biodiversity into Carbon Offset Protocols 15 Option A - Regulatory Compliance 15 Option B - Top Up Funding for Biodiversity Benefits (Hybrid: Public-Private Approach) 17 2.2 Biodiversity, Conservation and Carbon Offset Credit Stacking 17 Barriers to Credit Stacking in Canada 18 Chapter 3 – Carbon Pricing & Regulations 19 Section 1 Key Points 21 Infographic: The Multiple Benefits of Canada’s Nature 22 Section 2: Evidence-Based Criteria for Project Selection 23 1. Comparing Projects 25 2. Collapsing Dimensions: How Can we Compare Co-Benefits in a Common Unit? 25 The Options for Monetary Valuation 25 • Direct Valuation 25 • Indirect Valuation 25 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Final
    In Pursuit of a Good Death: Responding to Changing Sensibilities in the Context of the Right to Die Debate A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Juridical Studies at the University of Sydney VICTORIA HILEY The Faculty of Law University of Sydney January 2008 ABSTRACT This thesis challenges a number of claims that are made in the context of the euthanasia debate: that there is only one version of the good death; that rights discourse is the most appropriate vehicle by which to secure legal recognition of a right to die; that the Netherlands is either a model for reform or the epitome of a slippery slope in its regulation of euthanasia; and that a key argument in the euthanasia debate, the sanctity of life doctrine, is a fixed, immutable concept. In this thesis I use process sociology, developed by Norbert Elias, in order to capture changing sensibilities toward death and dying in the common law jurisdictions (Australia, England, the United States of America, Canada and New Zealand) and in the Netherlands. At the same time I analyse changing attitudes among key groups whose work impacts upon the euthanasia debate namely, parliamentarians, law reform bodies, the judiciary and medical associations. My aim in adopting this approach is threefold. First of all, to examine evolving attitudes to death and dying in order to determine whether the institutions of law and medicine are responding in an adequate manner to changing sensibilities in the common law countries and in the Netherlands. Secondly, to highlight shifting balances of power within the euthanasia debate.
    [Show full text]
  • Campaign 2019
    www.policymagazine.ca September—October 2019 Canadian Politics and Public Policy Campaign 2019 $6.95 Volume 7 – Issue 5 On On June 6, 1919, CN was created by an act of the Parliament of Canada. This year, we celebrate 100 years on the move. It took the best employees, retirees, customers, partners Track and neighbouring communities to make us a world leader in transportation. For our first 100 years and the next 100, we say thank you. for 100 cn.ca Years CNC_191045_CN100_Policy_Magazine.indd 1 19-06-14 10:45 dossier : CNC-191045 client : CN date/modif. rédaction relecture D.A. épreuve à description : EN ad Juin 100% titre : CN & Aboriginal Communities 1 sc/client infographe production couleur(s) publication : On Track for 100 Years 14/06/19 format : 8,5" x 11" infographe : CM 4c 358, rue Beaubien Ouest, bureau 500 Montréal (Québec) H2V 4S6 t 514 285-1414 PDF/X-1a:2003 Love moving Canada in the right direction Together, we’re leading Canadians towards a more sustainable future We’re always We’re committed We help grow We’re connecting connected to the environment the economy communities With free Wi-Fi, phone charging Where next is up to all of us. Maximizing taxpayer We are connecting more than outlets and roomy seats, Making smart choices today value is good for 400 communities across the you’re in for a comfy ride will contribute to a greener your bottom line country by bringing some (and a productive one, too). tomorrow. (and Canada’s too). 4,8 million Canadians closer to the people and places they love.
    [Show full text]
  • Debates of the House of Commons
    43rd PARLIAMENT, 1st SESSION House of Commons Debates Official Report (Hansard) VOLUME 149 NUMBER 014 Tuesday, February 4, 2020 Speaker: The Honourable Anthony Rota CONTENTS (Table of Contents appears at back of this issue.) 865 HOUSE OF COMMONS Tuesday, February 4, 2020 The House met at 10 a.m. culty putting food on the table. Canada remains among the few in‐ dustrialized countries without a universal school food program. A national school food program would not only give every stu‐ Prayer dent in Canada access to nutritious food, it would make healthy eat‐ ing a daily lesson for our kids. ROUTINE PROCEEDINGS I am pleased to see in budget 2019 that the government an‐ nounced its intention to establish a national school food program in ● (1005) Canada. This legislation represents an important first step toward [English] making that goal a reality. PARLIAMENTARY BUDGET OFFICER I call on all parliamentarians to work together to support this im‐ The Speaker: Pursuant to section 79.2(2) of the Parliament of portant health and social justice initiative. Canada Act, it is my duty to present to the House a report from the Parliamentary Budget Officer, entitled “Reviewing the Fiscal and (Motions deemed adopted, bill read the first time and printed) Distributional Analysis of the Federal Carbon Pricing System”. * * * * * * CRIMINAL CODE JUDGES ACT Hon. David Lametti (Minister of Justice and Attorney Gen‐ Mr. Don Davies (Vancouver Kingsway, NDP) moved for leave eral of Canada, Lib.) moved for leave to introduce Bill C-5, An to introduce Bill C-202, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (as‐ Act to amend the Judges Act and the Criminal Code.
    [Show full text]
  • The State of Knowledge on Medical Assistance in Dying for Mature Minors
    THE STATE OF KNOWLEDGE ON MEDICAL AssIstANCE IN DYING FOR MATURE MINORS The Expert Panel Working Group on MAID for Mature Minors ASSESSING EVIDENCE. INFORMING DECISIONS. THE STATE OF KNOWLEDGE ON MEDICAL ASSISTANCE IN DYING FOR MATURE MINORS The Expert Panel Working Group on MAID for Mature Minors ii The State of Knowledge on Medical Assistance in Dying for Mature Minors THE COUNCIL OF CANADIAN ACADEMIES 180 Elgin Street, Suite 1401, Ottawa, ON, Canada K2P 2K3 Notice: The project that is the subject of this report was undertaken with the approval of the Board of Directors of the Council of Canadian Academies (CCA). Board members are drawn from the Royal Society of Canada (RSC), the Canadian Academy of Engineering (CAE), and the Canadian Academy of Health Sciences (CAHS), as well as from the general public. The members of the expert panel responsible for the report were selected by the CCA for their special competencies and with regard for appropriate balance. This report was prepared for the Government of Canada in response to a request from the Minister of Health and the Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada. Any opinions, findings, or conclusions expressed in this publication are those of the authors, the Expert Panel Working Group on MAID for Mature Minors, and do not necessarily represent the views of their organizations of affiliation or employment, or of the sponsoring organizations, Health Canada and the Department of Justice Canada. Library and Archives Canada ISBN: 978-1-926522-47-0 (electronic book) 978-1-926522-46-3 (paperback) This report should be cited as: Council of Canadian Academies, 2018.
    [Show full text]
  • Submission to Inquiry Into Voluntary Assisted Dying
    Submission to Inquiry into Voluntary Assisted Dying Joint Committee | South Australia | August 2019 This is page is left blank intentionally to allow for double-sided printing 2 “Palliative care services are not offering what a percentage of their patients desperately need. Palliative care has become a mantra chanted by … politicians and religious organisations opposing euthanasia.” − Clive Deverall, founder of Palliative Care WA “While pain and other symptoms can be helped, complete relief of suffering is not always possible, even with optimal palliative care.” – Palliative Care Australia “It is not the role of any health care team to suggest its ministrations can give meaning, purpose and dignity to a dying person’s remaining life if that person feels that these are irretrievably lost … palliative care is a model of care, not a moral crusade.” − Professor Michael Ashby, Director, Palliative Care, Tasmanian Health Service 3 This is page is left blank intentionally to allow for double-sided printing 4 What’s in this Submission INTRODUCTION Page 7 PART A What The Evidence Shows Page 9 The need for Voluntary Assisted Dying laws in Australia PART B Assisted Dying In South Australia Today Page 15 An incoherent, largely unregulated, and inequitable legal situation PART C Beyond Pain Page 31 Why more resources for palliative care alone will not address the need for Voluntary Assisted Dying PART D Responding To Key Arguments Against VAD Page 59 PART E Fear. Uncertainty. Doubt. Page 81 Tactics used to create an alarmist picture of assisted dying PART F Propaganda Case Studies Part 1. Fatal Flaws Page 105 Part 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Catholics in Trudeau's Canada
    APRIL 30, 2018 THE JESUIT REVIEW OF FAITH AND CULTURE Catholics in Trudeau’s Canada By Dean Dettlo p18 Refl ections on ‘Gaudete et Exsultate’ p42 A Life (With Disability) in Full p26 Bruce Springsteen’s ‘Crookedly Blessed’ Imagination p44 1 | AMERICAMAGAZINE.ORG APRIL 30, 2018 AMERICA | PB Purchase your commemorative issue today Featuring beautiful full-color photos and content from America’s contributors, with an introduction by America editor-at-large Fr. James Martin, S.J., and a concluding essay by award-winning Catholic journal- ist and author David Gibson, this one-of-a- kind issue includes in-depth explorations of Pope Francis’ background, impact and hopes for the future. 100 pages with over 50 photos $14.95 With over 50 1-800-627-9533 or contact us at https://americamag.org/francis5 Asking the right question I am writing this from Saint Louis opinions with which we disagree? best hope. As long as you believe that University, where I am taking part How many of us complain about the the problem is someone else, then in a lecture series celebrating the content in our social media feeds there is nothing you can do about it, 200th anniversary of this great insti- while somehow forgetting that we and you will continue to feel helpless tution. My topic is Pope Francis, U.S. actually chose to follow every one and at the mercy of forces beyond politics and polarization, a subject of those people? How many of us, your control. But if we are all able I am often called upon to discuss.
    [Show full text]
  • In Canada Market Research Done? Medical Problems
    ISSN #1481-7314 Vol. 8, No. 3 Jul. - Sep. 2006 A QUARTERLY NEWSLETTER BY AND FOR THE MEMBERS OF: Choice in Dying - Ottawa Dying With Dignity Canada Right to Die Society of Canada Sharma is free on $50,000 bail and is no husband John visited her every day; NEWS longer working as a doctor in the area. hospital staff members noticed that they were very devoted to each other. Unfortunately, John also was having in Canada Market Research Done? medical problems. He had suffered a series An August 5 Vancouver Sun story of small strokes, and since then had been Vernon Is Not Lugano or Zurich reported the theft of some drugs from a having memory difficulties. veterinarian’s car. The thief discarded At some point Lorna and John were told As was mentioned in the first 2006 much of the loot but kept 11 vials contain- that Lorna would not be able to live at home issue of Free To Go, nursing homes in ing “a number of different drugs used for any more. When she was well enough to the Swiss cities of Lugano and Zurich have euthanizing or operating on animals”. leave the hospital, she was to be transferred been allowing residents to receive suicide These drugs likely included pento- to a nursing home. assistance (from the group called Exit) for barbital and thiopental. For aid in dying, Both partners probably accepted this, at several years now. pentobarbital (a veterinary euthanatic) is first; John spoke with the manager of his But things are not at that stage in the drug most frequently used when the apartment building about having to move, Vernon BC.
    [Show full text]
  • Perceptions of Carbon Pricing in Canada a Survey of 2250 Canadians
    PERCEPTIONS OF CARBON PRICING IN CANADA A SURVEY OF 2250 CANADIANS FEB 2018 METHODOLOGY Survey was conducted online with Canadians aged 18 and over. A random sample of panelists were invited to Online survey complete the survey from a set of partner panels based on the Lucid exchange platform. 2,250 Canadians Sample Size Margin of error for a comparable probability-based random sample of the same size is +/- 2.1%, 19 times out of 20. Field dates February 9th to 15th, 2018 Data was weighted according to census data to ensure Statistical Weighting that the sample matched Canada's population according to age, gender, educational attainment, and region. KEY FINDINGS LARGE MAJORITY WANT A TRANSITION TO A LOW CARBON ECONOMY, BUT WITH CARE TO MANAGE IMPACTS . • This goal is broadly embraced, including in Alberta. • The caution about the pace of ambition is clear, and not only in Alberta. Most people believe we should continue to develop oil and gas resources while transitioning. • Most Canadians believe climate change is happening, is caused by human behaviour. While 75% say action on climate change should be a high priority, it trails a range of other economic and social issues in terms of perceived urgency. • 60% want governments to take more action to combat climate change. Only 16% want less action, but this number has doubled in three years. • Most Canadians prefer regulations and subsidies to carbon pricing, but also prefer carbon pricing to doing nothing at all. FAMILIARITY WITH CARBON PRICING REMAINS LIMITED YET SUPPORT HAS GROWN SINCE 2015. • Less than half feel familiar with carbon pricing.
    [Show full text]