(No. 13)Craccum-1976-050-013.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
autonomy by the sub-committee’s report concern the findings on World Vision’s political stance. The fact that policies and decisions of World Vision International are ulti mately made in America has obvious| political implications for some - especially Asian - countries. For example, unlike many other aid organisations who were able to give aid to both North and South Viet Nam, World Vision was not per mitted to operate in the North. The | authorities there were perhaps unable to distinguish between American aid and American bombs. A trouble spot to which World Vision is sending aid is Beirut. In a magazine put out by World Vision, j Renner describes the situation of the refugees there and says that they j plan “ to channel funds for refugee relief through the Armenian Insti tute, a neutral Christian organisa tion.” It seems difficult to recon cile the term ‘neutral Christian’ with the knowledge that the Christians and the Moslems are the two opposing factions. McKinley stated that World Vision had to work through any organisation they could, and that if they believed that the body was not ‘neutral’ then they] would not do so. Aid,Overheadsn - w - s • • Political neutrality within an aid organisation seems to be an ideal which never quite makes it to reality j It is a vague objective, depending & much upon one’s own definition of Imperialism terms. World Vision does claim to World Vision International, babies in Australia. (Until then, McKinley says that World Vision in be apolitical - a state which can founded in 1951, is one o f the World Vision International believed fact kept far greater surveillance never be absolute. They operate largest aid organisations in the world it preferable to rear a child in its over their work than did other such within countries defined by political today. Centered in California, with own culture.) This change of pol organisations. He also points out boundaries ‘guided’ by political support offices in Canada, South icy was only made known to the that there was a tremendous scope philosophies. Their work is often Africa, Australia and New Zealand, support offices through the organi for corruption: once a body with people suffering from the its operations now extend to over sation’s quarterly magazine. registers itself as a charitable organi effects of political action. To claim thirty countries in Asia, Africa, and But Geoff Renner, Executive sation, it is virtually left free to neutrality in such a field as overseas Latin America. It has been a sub Director of the Auckland Office, operate as it will. The monthly aid is rather like trying to separate ject of controversy and debate in maintains that “ New Zealand is auditing o f World Vision’s financial politics from sport. New Zealand from the time it was directly involved in international accounts, he says, meant that they first established here early in decision-making through my member were more than fulfilling their legal Evangelism 1972. Russell Marshall, then MP ship of the Administration Commit requirements. An area in which the World for Wanganui, criticised its opera tee of World Vision International The tightly organised procedures Vision aid organisation makes no tions in Indochina after a visit there which makes the major internation also mean that a lot more people such claims of neutrality is its in February 1975. A report, al decisions.” McKinley, Executive have to be employed, entailing evangelistic ministry. The investiga entitled Aid oi Obstruction: World Associate, commented: “ We are increased overhead costs. These, it tion made by the sub-committee Vision in the Third World was sub autonomous in the sense that we is maintained, are kept as minimal doubted the validity of this. Was sequently made by representatives don’t have to give a dollar to any as efficiency will allow - about 20% World Vision justified, they asked, of the National Youth Council, the project we didn’t want to - it just so of the total income, which is the in spending money raised from the Student Christian Movement, and happens that so far we have wanted same as Corso’s. Renner points out public on evangelism, a definite the Youth Advisory Council o f the to.” Autonomy, apparently, is a that “ World Vision is investing over component of their aid programmes? | Labour Party. This sub-committee concept that can vary in interpreta $20 million in projects overseas and Is Christian evangelism an effective investigated World Vision policy, tion. this cannot be handled by guesswork method of aiding the development practice and philosophy and cast a and hope. We firmly believe it is of Third World countries, and is somewhat doubtful light on the aid Distributing the Loaves better to pay the 5% -1 0 % more this facet of World Vision operations organisation. CRACCUM discussed for supervision and internal manage fully explained to the public? with Trevor McKinley, the Execu As far as the distribution and ment control at every point than McKinley’s answer is that World tive Associate o f World Vision in use of the funds raised in New risk the 30% - 50% loss that can Vision is first and foremost an aid New Zealand, the questions and Zealand by World Vision is con easily occur in mismanagement, organisation, primarily concerned doubts raised by the investigation. cerned, again a lack of ‘democratic corruption or incompetence through with ‘helping those in need.’ “ We procedure’ is evident. A Project lack o f supervision, internal auditing have a point of view which does One area examined by the sub Supervisor and his staff are respons and training.” happen to be Christian,” he said, committee was the actual structure ible to a Field Director - all of McKinley was also anxious to “ But this does not alter the fact of the organisation. World Vision whom work in the particular coun stress that if any corruption was that thousands of people who would in New Zealand was originally con try receiving aid. The Field Direct discovered in the handling of pro otherwise be suffering have bene trolled by the Australasian Office, or, in turn, is responsible only to ject funds, this was clamped down fited from our work.” based in Melbourne, but became the Head Office, rather than to the on immediately. He gave as an A large portion of the money autonomous in 1974. The report support office which originally pro example a case in Viet Nam where raised by World Vision is spent on suggested that there was, in fact, a vided the funds. the office there was found to be childcare - 56% of the money sent lack of direct responsibility, that At the same time, however, a dealing dishonestly. Not only were overseas. In order to define more decisions made by World Vision close check is kept by the Auckland the staff sacked, but the entire pro exactly the general term childcare International were not subject to office on the work and finances. gramme was called off, resulting in it is useful to look at a breakdown scrutiny and that there were no Constant contact is maintained with the suffering of innocent people. of funds allotted to this field. channels through which support the field offices, which keep the Money went toward such projects offices could influence this decision home office informed on the pro as replacement of 220 dropped making. They gave as an example gress of each project. A financial The American Connection the policy change involved in the report is also sent back to New Zea The doubts raised about the 1972 decision to adopt Vietnamese land each month for auditing. value of World Vision’s concept of Continued on page 2 14 June 1976/Craccum/page 1 Continued from page 1 whether it is just to transpose these haps the fundamental policies and concepts on which World Vision’s philosophies provide a more reliable aid programmes are based on to the base for criticism. One has to look sponsorship cases; home visitation more socialist and communal life critically at World Vision’s views to check each family’s living stan styles of the Third World. If true and concepts of ‘aid and develop dards; home visitation for evange aid and development is to be ment’ to see if thev are justifiable, listic meetings; a choir’s appear effected, values and concepts of the and to see if World Vision’s work ance on T V ; medical treatment for one culture cannot be imposed on is truly contributing to the long 700 children. the other. World Vision, because term improvement of social condi Individual sponsorship raises the of its financial position in these tions in the poorer countries. largest amount of money used in poorer countries, has a great deal of But perhaps a more creative Isn’t it fi ‘childcare’ programmes. The reason authority there, and the ultimate answer to these problems lies not A n d ii for such an emphasis is given by benefit of their work in the Third so much in separate institutions, | later” de Renner in the World Vision maga World must be questioned. independent of the bulk of the out b y tl zine: “ We have a special commit population. Greater understanding ' unfunny ment to children because they are Questioning the basis and closer contact between the This r helpless. Our main commitment is aiders and the aided could lead to a It is difficult to assess the effect I disturbai to help them break out of the web iveness of aid organisations, and one more active participation of the pub of circumstances that trap the poor.” lie and their representatives.