Summer 2020 Volume 55, Number 9 American Federation NEWS of School Administrators, COUNCIL OF SCHOOL SUPERVISORS AND ADMINISTRATORS AFL-CIO Local 1 ‘The Changes Fair Student Funding Spared Under Current Will Come New York City Budget

BY CRAIG DIFOLCO of advocacy from CSA and our individ- ual members. It also provides ELI with After what many council members the same funding as in recent years and Through Our described as the most difficult budget restores proposed cuts to the Single negotiations they’ve been a part of, the Shepherd program which employees Mayor and City Council reached an approximately 130 guidance counselors agreement just moments before the July throughout the city. 1 deadline. Most notably, the budget agreement Children’ This year’s negotiations were com- includes a plan to transfer responsibil- plicated not only by the tremendous ity of school safety agents and crossing economic impacts of the COVID-19 guards from the NYPD to the DOE. The Principals April Leong and Phoebe pandemic, but also the growing calls to mayor said the transition would take substantially reduce the NYPD budget place over two years, and Speaker Corey Grant-Robinson Discuss Their Work in the wake of protests against police Johnson announced tentative plans to brutality throughout the nation. hold hearings in order to create related During the Pandemic and Protests Thankfully, the budget agreement legislation. reverses the proposed $100 million cut “The first priority of our mem- to Fair Student Funding after months Continued on Page 3

In Memoriam Piercing Intellect, And n Members have helped their school Warm, Caring Soul communities find a way for- BY CHUCK WILBANKS “She knew all the par- ward on race ents and kids. She really while simul- When schools were involved herself in their taneously shuttered in March, Erin lives, and was emotion- confronting Garry, principal of the ally in touch with every- the fear and Urban Assembly Bronx one she worked with, pain over the Academy of Letters, bor- including school safety COVID19 pan- demic . rowed a bike and ped- officers, teachers, cafete- aled around the South ria workers and support BY CHUCK WILBANKS practice of “courageous conversations,” to Bronx delivering tablets staff.” help build understanding and empathy at to her students who Ms. Garry died sud- Phoebe Grant-Robinson her school. needed them. And when Erin Garry denly in her sleep on Well before the country was convulsed “Last year, P.S. 253Q submitted our she learned that some June 4 from complica- by demonstrations prompted by the killing naming request to be formally known as of them didn’t have tions stemming from a of George Floyd, Phoebe Grant-Robinson The Randolph Holder School for Social Internet or other necessities, she used heart arrythmia. She was 36 years old. was quietly fostering racial understand- Justice. He was a police officer from Far her own money to help their families “She raised people up to a stan- ing and emotional support in her Pre-K -5 Rockaway who several years ago was killed get what they needed. dard they didn’t see in themselves,” school. Now, in addition to Covid-related in the line of duty. It was important to have “Principals can tend to be on ped- Mr. Pilc said. “People in our school death and economic hardship in the Far conversations about the police and current estals, but she was very close to the community are absolutely crushed.” Rockaway school community, the school is civil unrest with our students, staff and fam- ground,” said Andy Pilc, a teacher Raised in a family of educators working at confronting questions surround- ilies. If there is a belief that all officers are who, like Ms. Garry, had been a New in a home on White Lake near the ing schools and the NYPD. bad, it’s important that the students under- York City Teaching Fellow, and had Catskills town of Bethel, NY, Ms. She describes how she has used tech- stand that’s not the case at all. We work worked with her at two schools. Continued on Page 9 niques including the Mood Meter, devel- very closely with the 101st precinct. We oped by Mark Brackett at Yale, and the Continued on Page 12 President Of ELI’s Annual Consult CSA Remembering AFSA: Let’s Summer Before You Exceptional Get Serious Sessions Change Titles School Leaders 3 4 5 8 2 CSA NEWS Summer 2020

PRESIDENT’S PAGE A School Year For

Council of School The History Books Supervisors & Administrators American Federation of School Administrators, AFL-CIO, Local 1 Challenges Of Summer And Re-Opening Lie Ahead. By Mark Cannizzaro 40 Rector St., NY, NY 10006 Phone: (212) 823-2020 t has been a year like no other, one see me tearing up. Her colleagues and Fax: (212) 962-6130 www.csa-nyc.org that would have been momentous family described a woman of stunning even without the unthinkable hap- inner beauty, who had transformed President pening. more lives than most people ever touch. Mark Cannizzaro IWhen we returned to our buildings Listening from our kitchen, my wife Executive Vice President in September, we had no contract, Barbara dissolved in tears. Henry Rubio and we were battling over the thorny Because we want to spare lives, First Vice President reassembling our schools feels like Rosemarie Sinclair issue of paid parental leave. Our mem- bers stood solidly together, even if solving a three-dimensional jigsaw Treasurer Christopher Ogno they were beyond that stage in life. puzzle: physical, logistical and emo- Secretary Thousands of you wrote letters and ral- tional. To reopen in September will Steffani Fanizzi lied on the steps of City Hall. Finally, take skilled and creative programming Vice Presidents in February, our patience and solidarity as well as sufficient resources. Sam Akel Jose Garcia paid off: We secured raises, reversion Leadership teams will address the Ramon Gonzalez rights and much more. But the real philosophy of reopening, including the Lois Lee Katiana Louissaint emotional win was paid parental leave. paths to healing and grieving for those Nancy Russo, Retiree Chapter Just as we were celebrating, there we’ve lost, for irreplaceable time on

Executive Director Operations were reports of coronavirus in Asia, task, for missed social life, and for fear Erminia Claudio then Italy. On March 1, we learned that a young of a new surge. To program a school for student success, General Counsel woman returning to Manhattan from Iran was even under normal conditions, takes an extraordinary David Grandwetter infected. Suddenly, a hot spot in New Rochelle. Few of amount of time. The DOE must set the parameters and us expected a bomb of disease to explode overnight. issue adequate budgets so that you and your team can Executive Director Field Services Yet, Governor Cuomo declared a state of emergency on create a schedule that best serves students. Sana Q. Nasser March 7. Your union fought relentlessly to close our Even if kids resist their natural need to socialize, dis- Field Directors Juanita Bass, James Harrigan, schools. On March 19, New York schools went dark. tancing won’t be enough. We will need access to soap, Christine Martin, Frank Patterson, At the outset of the pandemic, you rallied for water and sanitizer on entry to schools, screening for Mercedes Qualls our children, plunging into remote instruction. You signs of the virus in children and staff, and a bunch of Assistant Field Directors worked with your teachers to pull students together complex health protocols. And approaching the whole Beshir Abdellatif, Eleanor Andrew, Mildred Boyce, Laverne Burrowes, on learn-as-you-go platforms. Some kids came up with issue of transportation seems like a bridge too far. Dominic Cipollone, Peter Devlin, Kenneth online pranks; a few thrived; many couldn’t without At the heart of everything, will be overcoming the Llinas, Nancy Esposito, Roberto Flores, live contact. And some kids just didn’t show up. The emotional trauma of this pandemic and the resulting Ellie Greenberg, Ray Gregory, Joseph LaCascia, Monica McDonald, most economically challenged suffered most, many of economic crisis, now compounded by a social justice Dorothy Morris, Beverly Pascal-Miller, them simply lacking access to these platforms. protest movement that has rallied our city and the Wanda Soto, Yvonne Williams world. Some say it feels like we’re living through a • • • version of the 1918 flu pandemic, the Great Depression Grievance Director he health and safety of absentees worried you and the civil rights movement all at the same time. Dale Kelly as much as their need to learn, and you tried Our children will depend on us to help them make Assistant Directors to track them down. Some of you delivered sense of it all. Are we going to be ready to talk to them Carol Atkins, Robert Colon, T Jermaine Garden- laptops to children’s doors. Some helped launch the about this? That question has been eloquently raised Director of Communications grab-and-go meal program. Many of you have found by AFSA president Ernest A. Logan in his brief essay, Craig DiFolco ingenious ways to acknowledge your students’ achieve- “Are We Now Ready to Have a Serious Conversation Director of Political Affairs ments and keep alive commencement and other com- about Race?” Gabe Gallucci ing-of age rituals. Assistant Director, Political Affairs • • • Herman Merritt Then, on May 25, the nation witnessed the murder Assistant Director of George Floyd. Following so soon after the shoot- s school leaders, many of you have led the way John Khani ings of Breonna Taylor and Ahmaud Arbery, protests and have provided a safe forum for conversa- Special Assistant to President erupted around the country and throughout New York tions. We profile three members in this issue Gary Goldstein A who exemplify such efforts at constructive communi- CSA Conference Chair Pierre Lehmuller cation and empathy. Recently, the CSA Black Caucus provided a space for our members that included a CSA Historian Some Say It’s Like We’re Living Manfred Korman discussion with Brooklyn Tech graduate and America’s CSA Retiree Chapter Through The 1918 Pandemic, The Psychologist, Dr. Jeffrey Gardere. Dr. Gardere spoke Gayle Lockett, Chair frankly about the pandemic and race in America. He Mark Brodsky, Director Great Depression And The Civil Rights offered tips for discussions with staff and students and Movement All At The Same Time he stressed self-care. CSA NEWS There will come a time when people with no direct Editor memory of it will be talking about 2020. They won’t Chuck Wilbanks know about it firsthand and they won’t know much Design Consultant City. For the first time since 1943, our mayor imposed about the finest souls among our first responders and Michele Pacheco a curfew requiring that we remain indoors after 8pm. in our schools, who made life possible. Those who walk Production Assistant Christine Altman Our students needed to express themselves and they quietly among us, changing and saving lives, without needed our reassurance. You did your best via social making history. media and online forums. Things will get better for our students, for us and for CSA News (004-532) is published You miss your kids and want to be with them again. our nation. As we head into summer and fall, I thank monthly except July and August for $35 per year per member by CSA, 40 Rector But we fear losing more people. As I sit on the mayor’s you again for your incredible devotion to our children St., NY, NY 10006. Periodical postage Education Sector Advisory Council, I remember losing and pray for your good health. paid at Manhattan, NY, and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send two bigger-than-life union members -- Principal Dez-Ann address changes to CSA News, 40 Romaine and Assistant Principal Omara Flores. When I Mark Cannizzaro is president of the Council of School Rector St., NY, NY 10006. spoke at Ms. Flores’ online service, I hoped no one could Supervisors and Administrators. Summer 2020 CSA NEWS 3 BUDGET Letters Helping To Honor Our Education: NYC Fiscal Plan Mentors, Colleagues Continued from Page 1 unions against any proposed layoffs for city CSA will continue to work closely with bers is to ensure the safety, health and employees. Though the mayor has raised the Department throughout the summer To the Editor: I want to thank well-being of their communities,” said the possibility that 22,000 public sector to determine how and when school build- you for the beautiful obituary CSA President Mark Cannizzaro. “As jobs may be lost, it’s worth noting that the ings can safely reopen. honoring Madeleine Brennan many school leaders remember, NYPD threat of layoffs has been historically uti- It’s also worth noting that the city’s in the May issue of CSA News. I first took responsibility for school safety lized as a negotiation tactic. There is still a financial plans may alter over time had the honor of working with agents because the DOE’s prior attempt at freeze on new hires within the DOE. depending on the economic recovery, her for two years. My transfer to oversight was simply not working for our At press time, many questions still the ability for the city to borrow money, Dyker Heights JHS was during a schools. This gives our union real reason remained on how the city’s expected rev- potential aid from the federal govern- very difficult time in my career for concern. If the transition is to succeed enue shortfall and cuts to the education ment, and further state cuts. This year’s and she, along with her amazing this time around, the DOE will need to department would affect school budgets. state budget gave Governor Cuomo the staff, helped me to recover and Previously, the Chancellor’s team told power to cut funding from localities if the flourish. I would never have con- principals to expect on average a 3 per- state’s revenue is lower than projections, tinued on to become an AP with- The Agreement Includes cent cut in their budgets. and Mayor de Blasio has asked state law- out her guidance and support. Her Though schools normally receive their makers to borrow $5 billion, a number handprint will forever be on my Plans To Transfer School budgets by the end of May, the DOE has he settled on when a prior request of $7 heart. I now have another guard- not yet released specific details on how billion met resistance. As for federal aid, a ian angel! Safety Agents, Crossing cuts will be implemented on a school-by- new stimulus bill called the HEROES Act –Cindy Salamone school basis. Any reductions in school could potentially send more than $900 Retired Assistant Principal Guards To The DOE budgets will no doubt be more problem- billion to cities and states, including $90 RC Suncoast Unit Leader atic than ever before, given that schools billion for public schools. The House has will most likely need additional resources passed the act, but Senate Majority Leader You Can Count On develop a plan that avoids past mistakes to invest in protective measures, from Mitch McConnell has yet to bring the bill without making impossible demands of equipment to additional staffing, that to the Senate floor. CSA’s Welfare Fund school leaders. We look forward to work- may be necessary to maintain proper CSA worked in partnership with AFSA, And Its Administrator ing with the city to make sure their voices social distancing and keep school com- other labor unions, and education orga- are heard on this critical issue.” munities safe as building reopen in the nizations to push elected officials to To the Editor: Recently, I The bill also assumes $1 billion in fall. increase the HEROES Act funding, and received a frightening medical expected savings from labor, and CSA will The DOE began to roll out its tenta- also advocated for the CARES Act which diagnosis. I was in shock and my continue fight alongside other public sector tive reopening plans in early July, and passed in the spring. family was in a state of despair. As I was quickly prepared for che- motherapy, I received the results of an extensive biopsy and I essentially hit the tumor lottery: I ‘Time For A Conversation On Race’ would be able to live many more years, and perhaps be cured even- BY ERNEST LOGAN terrified by this horror and will turn to It will not only be the children, but us, their school leaders, as well as their the entire school community of parents, tually, by taking one pill a day. But I also learned that the drug “We will have to repent in this gen- teachers and counselors, to help make teachers and staff who will lean on us for regimen would cost more than eration not merely for the hateful words sense of what has happened to them and strength and hope. Some among us will $1,600 a month, and that I would and actions of the bad people, but for their families and channel their fear and march and raise our voices with the pro- need to take it for many, many the appalling silence of the good peo- anger into meaningful actions. If they testors to insist on reform, and combat years. ple,” Martin Luther King, Jr. wrote from are children of color, particularly African the haters, or the misguided ones, who I reached out to Doug a Birmingham jail nearly 60 years ago. American children, their hurt and outrage attempt to divide us with violence. But Hathaway. He calmed me and That did not happen. The brutal pub- will be particularly intense for they will each and every one of us will be called settled the situation through a lic killing of George Floyd in Minnesota, have personal experience with racism, no upon to educate our adult communities patient explanation of our bene- not long after the shootings of Breonna matter how young they may be. This, I about the importance of the vote, par- fits. Doug has been nothing but Taylor in Kentucky and Ahmaud Arbery know because I was one of those children. ticipation in the census, and the need to kind, professional and a friend. I in Georgia, ignited righteous protests It is a blessing and a burden that they communicate a sense of our nation’s his- am deeply grateful, and I am lucky against racism across fifty states. The will depend so much on us. As leaders of tory, in all its beauty and ugliness. – indeed, we all are lucky – to anguish sweeping the nation reflects gen- schools, we have been struggling to deal We will have to do much better than have Doug and the benefits that erations of failure of the “good people” with the massive impact of the global the good people who have gone before us CSA has negotiated for us. to reform police practices and to address pandemic on our education system, our and help use this tragedy as an opportu- –Dr. Ilisa D. Sulner both overt and implicit racism in every economy and our own personal lives. In nity to finally make a difference. Retired Principal sector of society, including our schools. the midst of this, we are now called upon We can begin by reading again Dr. 752Q And our schools are among the places to deal with a crisis of racial inequality King’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail. where these events must be most urgently that has not been properly addressed in addressed. this country for centuries. Are we now Ernest Logan is president of the American Seeing Members This is so partly because it is our stu- ready to have a serious conversation Federation of School Administrators and the Through Different Life dents who will be most bewildered and about race? former president of CSA Stages, Tough Times

To the Editor: As the corona- virus has been causing so much CSA-Backed Candidates Win Office suffering in New York and around Guide To the world, I have been doing well, BY CRAIG DIFOLCO Bowman currently leads Eliot Queens Borough President; at mostly because of the actions Engel by a wide margin in the press time he was leading with Reopening and support of CSA. My income The June 23 primary 16th District. Mr. Bowman close to 40 percent of the vote. has not been adversely affected, marked a significant moment is the founding principal of On the state level, things Schools and my mental health has been in NYC politics as our city’s first Cornerstone Academy for mostly went as expected, greatly maintained because of the election against the backdrop of Social Action in the Bronx and though Incumbent Assembly From AFSA diversity of my interests which th pandemic, economic down- gave up his role this year so Members Aravella Simotas, was fostered by my employment. turn, and protests against sys- that he could run. Both CSA Michael DenDekker, Michael As school districts I wanted to be a pediatrician as temic injustice and police bru- and AFSA endorsed him: As a Miller are all trailing at the around the country strug- a teenager. That morphed into a tality. Given that New Yorkers former member of our union, moment. Of the many candi- gled to come up with passion for teaching. I was still could make their voices heard we expect that he will fight for dates CSA endorsed, the major- formulas for reopening, entrusted with the health of chil- not only at polling places but public education, working peo- ity either won or are currently the American Federation dren, but on a different level. For through early and absentee ple, and NYC school leaders. leading. CSA’s rigorous candi- of School Administrators, that, I am grateful. voting, there are still many Most NYC incumbents either date screening events helped of which CSA is a part, put Thank you CSA for your leader- uncounted ballots and it may won or remain in the lead, placed CSA on the right-side of forward a set of suggested ship and support, especially at this be weeks before we know who though Carolyn Maloney is still history in selecting viable can- guidelines for safe prac- time in our lives. officially won each race. in a tight race with Suraj Patel. didates and these victories will tices. Read the report at –Sandra Wilson Haney On the federal level, for- CSA endorsed City Council solidify our voice and seat at www.theschoolleader.org. Retired Assistant Principal mer CSA member Jamaal Member Donovan Richards for the table in the years to come. PS 140, Bronx 4 CSA NEWS Summer 2020

EXECUTIVE NATION LEADERSHIP Moving Leaders Forward Labor INSTITUTE

MINNESOTA Union Solidarity Summer Institute In July 2020 Amalgamated Transit Union (ATU) and members of ATU Local 1005 his year’s Executive Leadership Wed., July 15 9-1:30 • Session 2: ST27 Encouraging Students – the local chapter in Minneapolis Summer Institute is offering a (workshops 10:30 am-1:30 pm) to be Self Directed Learners and St. Paul – issued statements in T wealth of teaching, virtually of • Session 3: Promoting Racial and solidarity with protests against the course. To register, visit: http://eliregistra- • GUEST SPEAKER TESSA ZIMMERMAN Ethnic Equity police killing of George Floyd. The tion.csa-nyc.org/eliregistration. 9-10:15 am: Tessa’s keynote address for union, that represents over 200,000 ELI will equip school leaders with con- Thurs., July 16, 8:30-11:30 public transit workers in the US and Tues., July 14, 8:30-11:30 am crete, stress management tools they can • Session 1: Supervising instruction of Canada, said that just as members • Session 1: ST09 Essential Time use to catalyze mental and emotional students with interrupted formal edu- have the right to refuse danger- Management Skills for School Leaders wellness for all members of their school cation during and after COVID19 ous work during the pandemic, • Session 2: ST31 Supporting communities (including staff, students, • Session 2: Establishing best practices Minneapolis members have the Supervisors and Educators of Learners and families). for Distance (Remote) Learning right to refuse to transport police with Autism Spectrum Disorder • Session 1: ST40 Collaboration and • Session 3: ST41Leadership through to protests and arrested demon- • Session 3: ST39 Leading in a Crisis Advocacy in support of ELLs the use of Soft Skills strators, adding that it is a misuse of public transport. The local chap- ter called for “a new Civil Rights Movement, joined with the labor movement.” (Huffington Post) Dr. Doug V. NEW YORK The Welfare Fund Hathaway Nonprofit Unionizing In a surge of union drives at nonprofits, one of the nation’s Despite Pandemic, Support Continues most respected public defender nonprofits announced its plans to t has been an interesting past few lessen some of the backlog so that it is not impossible once unionize. The Bronx Defenders, months, an end of year experi- we return to the office. We continue to thank you for your that defends low-income people ence we never thought we would patience and understanding as we work through the summer in the Bronx, NY, plans to unionize have (and hopefully will not to support you and your families. with the Association of Legal Aid Irepeat). The normal flow of district • • • Attorneys, under the UAW. There meetings, retiree unit meetings, are anticipated to be about 270 pre-retirement workshops through- here is an important change to the prescription drug members, including attorneys, out the city, end of year scholarship benefit starting July 1, 2020. One of the most beneficial social workers, paralegals and facilities workers. Bronx Defenders dinner have all been replaced by provisions of the Affordable Care Act (“Obamacare”) reportedly see their union drive as Zoom meetings and phone calls. It has been the requirement that medications consid- has certainly been a trying period. Tered as preventive are covered by a participant’s health plan. part of a larger struggle to improve the justice system. (InTheseTimes) In this new environment The Initially contraceptives, flu treatments such as Tamiflu, and Welfare Fund continues to function pre-natal vitamins were on the list of preventive medications. VIRGINIA and provide support for all active In July 2016, low-dose cholesterol lowering drugs, known as in-service and retired participants, statins, were added to the list. Beginning July 1 of this year, Resignations Change both Department of Education one specific dosage of Truvada – 200-300 milligrams – is A USA Today/Ipsos poll warns of and Early Childhood related. We considered a pre-exposure prophylactic, or PreP, medication. a potential wave of teacher resig- To Script continue to issue vouchers, answer Thus, it will be covered by your health plan at no cost rather nations, with 1 in 5 respondents phone calls and emails to address than through The Welfare Fund. If you are retired and not yet saying they are unlikely to return Benefits participant concerns and help in Medicare eligible you will also be able to get the medication to school in the fall. They cited dealing with the insurance plans at no co-pay. Those who are eligible for Medicare will con- the inability to properly do their Begins In and city. tinue to pay the 25 percent copay. In addition, under medical jobs in light of the pandemic as While we have been unable to necessity, Deskovy may be considered for preventive use. A the main reason. Another poll of July Of continue processing claims thus far, generic version of Truvada is expected to be released this fall, parents, with at least one child in we are now building the capacity to which will further reduce costs for everyone. grades K-12, indicated that more This Year process claims remotely. While you than half would pursue home will still encounter a delay in receiv- Dr. Douglas V. Hathaway is CSA Welfare Fund schooling options, with 30% ing reimbursements, we hope to Administrator.You can email him at [email protected]. saying they’d be “very likely” to explore that option. (USA Today)

CALIFORNIA Deny Subsidies CSA Veterans Letter To NY City Council The California Employment Training Panel was called upon CSA’s Veterans’ Committee sent the follow- ask that you stay true to our collective • No excessing, lay-offs or hiring freeze to deny a request for $655,500 in ing letter to the City Council on June 22. mission to provide the 1.1 million chil- • Increase the number of school coun- government subsidies to Space dren of New York City with an excep- selors and social workers in each Exploration Technology Corp To Speaker Johnson, Councilmembers tional educational experience that pre- school (SpaceX). The request came Treyger and Dromm, and to all City pares them for college and career. • Funding for academic support to from Teamsters Joint Council Councilmembers: The Mayor’s proposed cuts to school- catch students up who have fallen 7 President Rome Aloise and As military veterans and educators, based budgets do nothing to bring us closer behind California labor allies. The letter we know first hand what it takes to lead to accomplishing our mission. In fact, they • Professional development for school stated that Elon Musk has been during a crisis. We understand the com- will harm our children. Over the past three based staff on trauma informed best the recipient of billions of public dollars over the past decades plex challenge of prioritizing competing months, the children of New York City practices for his companies and has used needs in order to accomplish a mission have experienced trauma unlike anything We request that you use the full power that money to “tamp down on while also preserving life. Leadership we have seen before. By the time they of the City Council to ensure that our the collective bargaining rights is no easy feat and we would like to return to school buildings in September, schools are adequately funded to support of employees and disregard the thank you for your leadership during the it will be a full six months since they’ve the children of New York City. safety of workers”. The authors COVID19 crisis. seen the inside of a classroom. Whether In service, cited Musk’s track record of In the words of former Secretary of students are learning in-person or remotely Council of School Supervisors and enriching himself and his com- State, General Colin Powell “Fit no ste- this fall, schools must be equipped with Administrators’ Military Veterans panies and said he and SpaceX reotypes. Don’t chase the latest manage- the human and financial resources to pro- Committee: Dr. Noah Angeles, Principal; do not deserve taxpayers’ dol- ment fads. The situation dictates which vide for our children. Henceforth, we are Wayne Benjamin, Assistant Principal; Mark lars. (Teamsters Joint Council 7) approach best accomplishes the team’s requesting that Department of Education’s Brodsky, CSA Veterans Liaison; Charles — Compiled by mission.” budget allow for the following: Hernandez, Assistant Principal (Retired); Christine Altman We believe General Powell’s words • Schools to remain fully staffed pre- Dr. Richard Morell, Principal (Retired); must be appropriately applied today. We COVID19 Rhonda Pekow, Assistant Principal Summer 2020 CSA NEWS 5

Dale Memo From Headquarters Kelly Consult CSA: Transitioning To A New Position May Have Consequences You Haven’t Taken Into Consideration

o, you’re considering changing These examples are among countless per- as the interim acting position. And if the titles. Here’s the most important mutations, and each title change will have last appointed position the employee served piece of information I can offer: its own set of rules. in does not exist under that jurisdiction, Contact your union before mak- then the employee shall revert to their ing the move! There are too many Reversion Rights most recent appointed position prior to Sconsequences that come with a title change Before we begin any discussion about that appointed position within the juris- that may or may not be known to you but reversion rights, I must clarify one common diction. The rule concludes that if the last will potentially impact your probationary misconception. Our collective bargaining appointed title is to a teaching position, or tenure status, your salary, and possibly agreement and state law allow members “the Department will place the employee in your reversion rights. This column is not to revert to their last appointed position. accordance with the UFT contract.” long enough to capture all the nuances that The right to revert is never dependent on If you’re confused, you’re not alone. It’s come with a title change but I want to focus whether one had tenure or was on probation why you need to talk to us before finalizing on some big picture items to underscore the in their previous position. any decision. The language in collective importance of contacting CSA before finaliz- Also, be aware that all CSA members in bargaining or stipulation agreements can be Informed ing any decision. the Department of Education work under murky, and result in different interpretations. one of two jurisdictions: The jurisdiction of Since there is only one correct interpretation Decisions Probationary Status the community superintendent and the juris- to the abovementioned clause, it is imperative Often, when a member changes posi- diction of the chancellor, commonly referred that you allow us to give you a clear interpre- Are Best! tions, that change comes with a new pro- to as the citywide jurisdiction. tation of what may not be apparent to you. Be Sure bationary period. Probationary status is All elementary, K-8, and middle school We want to ensure that no one inadvertently directly related to the license under which APs and principals in community school dis- applies an incorrect understanding, only to To Know a member is working. People often confuse tricts work under the jurisdiction of the com- realize the mistake too late. their position license with their state certi- munity superintendent. These are the only Our most recent collective bargaining All The fication, but they are two different things. titles within this jurisdiction. All other CSA agreement secured a huge win for our mem- Therefore, a tenured employee who elects members, including HS school-based admin- bers who may have crossed jurisdictions to Details to move into another position under a dif- istrators, EAs, supervisors of, D75 and D79 take on a new position. Any appointed super- ferent license will automatically start a new administrators, directors, adult education visor who is denied completion of probation On Any probationary period commensurate with the administrators, etc., work under the jurisdic- or who is discontinued will have the undis- new title. Here are a few examples: tion of the chancellor. puted right to revert to their most recent prior Change • An elementary school principal If you are considering leaving your appointed supervisor or EA position in the sys- becomes a middle school principal. That appointed position to take on an interim act- tem, regardless of jurisdiction. For the purpose Of Title member would begin a new probationary ing position in a different jurisdiction, there of clarity and consistency, CSA has negotiated period, since elementary school and mid- are rules that may adversely impact your abil- that the DOE is obligated to advise any super- That You dle school principals work under different ity to revert to your last appointed position. visor moving from an appointed position to licenses. For example, if someone’s career took an interim-acting position of their reversion Consider • An elementary school AP begins a new them from a teacher to a middle school AP rights in writing prior to taking the position as job as a middle school AP. That member’s to an interim acting high school principal, an interim-acting supervisor. While this new probationary time would carry over to the and this individual was not selected as the provision affords guaranteed reversion rights new position since elementary and middle appointed high school principal after the to appointed administrators, it does not apply school APs work under the same license. If C-30 process, the member would revert to a to administrators moving into interim acting the same elementary school AP took a job teacher line, because a middle school AP is positions in a new jurisdiction. as an AP at a high school, a new probation- in a different jurisdiction than a high school Again, if you have any questions about ary period would begin, since elementary principal. transitioning into a new position, please and high school APs work under different The rules state that an interim acting reach out to us at the Grievance Department licenses. supervisor in a position under any juris- so we can assist you in making an informed • An AP moves into an EA position. In diction who is not selected for the perma- decision. that case, a new probationary period begins nent position can revert to his or her last because they are two separate licenses. appointed position in the same jurisdiction Dale Kelly is Grievance Director at CSA.

Travel Desk Teachers’ Retirement Adventures Still On Hold, For Now System May 2020 BY GARY GOLDSTEIN include air, you need to request assis- them entry in order to fly home. Some Unit Values tance from whomever is responsible cruise lines are attempting to designate I hope you are coping as best you for making your arrangements. You specific vessels for clusters of crew by Diversified Equity can as we search for an end to our cur- should not have to go at it directly nationality so they may route the ves- Fund: 90.415 rent environment. with your air carrier as in some cases sel to their home port. Balanced Fund: 15.925 Since my April article I have the carriers are denying refunds for This procedure and the introduc- received communication from many canceled flights even though you are tion of protocols onboard to assure International Equity of our members searching for infor- entitled to a refund in full with NO health and safety of passengers and Fund: 9.292 mation regarding what’s most current penalty. I am available to guide you if crew for the future means there is great Inflation Protection in the travel industry. necessary. uncertainty about when normal busi- Fund: 8.209 Most major air carriers have drasti- As for the cruise industry, the sus- ness will start again. It is unfortunate cally reduced schedules that have neg- pension of sailings is a much more that onboard crews have no union Sustainable Equity atively impacted upon hotels, cruise complex issue. To date approximately affiliations to move mountains for Fund: 18.926 ships and ground services. Although 100,000 multinational crew members these unfortunate people! U.S Equity Index the situation is fluid, protocols for are stranded aboard vessels world- I invite you to call me at (732) 786- Fund: 10.132 check-in, baggage claim and onboard wide awaiting repatriation. They are 0314, or email me at ggoldstein@csa- services continue to change almost existing onboard under very difficult nyc.org to discuss any travel concerns International Equity daily. conditions with uncertain fates, as you may have. Stay well, as you dream Index Fund: 9.473 If you have travel plans which ports throughout the globe refuse of your favorite travel adventure. www.trsnyc.org 6 CSA NEWS Summer 2020 Ambition Tempered By Kindness, Scholastic Dedication, Joined With Social Commitment VIA ZOOM: Inspiring Group Of Student CSA Scholarship Winners

By Craig DiFolco of self-awareness and an incredible ability for reflection. In navigating Each year, CSA awards scholarships the challenges that come with being to outstanding young citizen students. legally blind, she has consistently Normally, we honor the winners at a ban- demonstrated true perseverance and quet; this year, CSA’s ceremony was led determination. Not only is she a virtually by President Mark Cannizzaro. strong student, but she is also a mem- Here are the winners. Congratulations to ber of the dance team and writes for n ELISE SLAUGHTER of Manhattan Early College School for Advertising, led by them all. the school newspaper. She also works Principal Sarah Kaplan with Council Member Debi Rose and Queens: Emily Liu of Grover hopes to one day become a policy- Cleveland High School in maker in order to give voice to the underrepresented and uplift others. Ridgewood, led by Principal She plans to go to law school, earn a Marc Pascente PhD in policy management and aims Emily is that rare student who to one day work at the UN or start a managed to deftly balance academics non-profit. and extracurriculars as she participated on the Varsity Tennis Team, worked Manhattan: Elise Slaughter as a Library Aid at the Queens Library, of Manhattan Early College and was a Science Olympian, partic- ularly skilled at Geological Mapping. School for Advertising, led by Assistant Principal Suzanne Ledee Principal Sarah Kaplan Garcia describes her as a cheerful, con- Elise is a model student who con- fident young woman and praises not sistently sets lofty goals for herself only her intelligence, but her sense and works hard to achieve them. Her n of responsibility. “Emily is naturally former Assistant Principal Joseph MANAHIL JAFRI of Curtis HS in Staten Island, led by Principal Gregory Jaenicke inquisitive and is an ever present help Young calls her a natural leader and to others,” she writes. Emily’s personal praises her commitment to each essay demonstrates her resilience in and every activity and task that she the face of adversity and showcases engages in. He specifically praised her considerate nature as she often her dedication to her former middle cared for her younger brother when school where she regularly returns her family relocated. Emily remarks to mentor and support the debate that throughout her high school expe- program and serves as a role model rience she has learned the importance for younger students. One of Elise’s of self-discipline, especially when proudest accomplishments is her facing obstacles. She intends to be an active participation in the Civil Air economics major, believing that the Patrol, where students learn to pilot field will help people better under- aircrafts and practice Air Force drills. stand the process of decision-making. She flew her first orientation flight when she was only 11 years old and Staten Island: Manahil Jafri credits the program with teaching her the importance of self-discipline and of Curtis High School, led by n MONIQUE JOHNSON of the Brooklyn Institute for Liberal Arts, led by teamwork. She credits her mother Principal Ann Marie Henry-Stephens Principal Gregory Jaenicke with instilling confidence in her and Manahil’s teachers praise her work showing her the value of empathy. ethic, thoughtfulness and maturity Elise’s love of storytelling was on full and applaud her ability to further display in the advertising campaigns discussions among her fellow stu- she designed throughout high school, dents. Assistant Principal Diana Aversa and she plans to study Business describes Manahil as a motivated, Administration and Marketing in col- inspiring leader and believes she will lege so that she can become a Creative be a tremendous asset to whatever Director and bring more inclusivity to organizations and communities she the field. is a part of throughout her life. She founded an organization to provide Bronx: Waseka Ahmed clothing items to those in need, led the feminist club, and served on the of Pelham Preparatory school council. All the while, her Academy, led by Principal optimism and talent were on full dis- Benvenuto Ferron play. In her essay, Manahil credits her Waseka is a passionate advocate parents for helping her recognize the for the causes she believes in, serv- n WASEKA AHMED of Pelham Preparatory Academy in the Bronx, led by blessings of a good education, and her ing as student government repre- Principal Benvenuto Ferron writing demonstrates a strong sense sentative and as a member of the Summer 2020 CSA NEWS 7

NATION Education

Ambition Tempered By Kindness, Scholastic FLORIDA Blast Off Students in Pine Ridge High School’s Advanced Manufacturing Academy in Deltona have become Dedication, Joined With Social Commitment part of history, making items slated for the International Space Station. Students learned to read Environmental Club, in which she school to her family, who have always as develop the ability to inspire others blueprints from NASA, use a mill- actively protested for greater environ- pushed her forward and wanted the to fulfill their potential. As he reflected ing machine and advanced tools mental protections and conducted best for her. Their constant support on his year abroad in Beijing, China, to manufacture parts for alumi- her school’s Envirothon Contest. has sparked her ambition and focus Blair described how he pushed past his num and stainless steel cargo Throughout high school, Waseka and led to her to become the first discomfort and fear of the unknown, suitcases used to travel to and learned the importance of time man- from her family to attend college, and how the subsequent experience from the station. The program agement and that has contributed after graduating from high school one helped him develop a better sense of is part of HUNCH, High School greatly to her success. She was able year early. When writing about those cultural competency and was one of Students United with NASA to to expertly balance her academics, who have influenced her, Monique the most rewarding of his young life. Create Hardware, in which 277 extracurriculars, and home life, where thanked Principal Henry-Stephens and While elaborating on the importance schools in 44 states participate. she helps care for her autistic brother Assistant Principal Cicily Humes-James of self-advocacy and self-learning, he (The West Volusia Beacon) and often serves as a translator for her for fully understanding who she was writes that “if student leaders are not parents in her efforts to help them as a person, seeing potential within constantly able to push themselves UTAH improve their English. She credits her, and helping her become both to embrace uncertainty and curios- Lunch Deliveries her father with modeling courage, more responsible and more socially ity, they can never achieve any truly Forty-two food service work- determination and resilience for her active. She has found fulfillment in ground-breaking results.” ers in San Juan County, which throughout her young life. She hopes helping others throughout her young When writing about the impor- includes Navajo nation -- with to study environmental science in col- life and hopes to one day do so as a tance of mobilizing others, he noted one of the highest COVID-19 lege and looks forward to that. defense attorney. how social justice activists have influ- rates in the country -- are deliv- enced his thinking and expressed the ering nearly 5,000 breakfasts, Brooklyn: Monique Johnson CSA also awarded our importance for leaders to form bonds lunches and homework to stu- of the Brooklyn Institute for with those they lead to build trust and dents each day. The initiative annual $10,000 scholarship support. He also highlighted lessons to support students during the Liberal Arts, led by Principal for the child of a CSA member he learned through participating in pandemic was complicated by Ann Marie Henry-Stephens to Blair Chase, son of Dwight his school’s peer leadership program, disruptions in the food supply Monique is a president of her Chase, Assistant Principal as he mentored seventh-graders, help- chain but the team worked col- school’s student government, a stu- ing them navigate social dynamics laboratively to find local suppli- dent aide, a member of the National of PS 206 Joseph F Lamb in and contend with stress. Blair is a ers and area businesses with sur- Honor Society, the Student Leadership Brooklyn thoughtful, reflective young man who pluses. In addition to parents, Team, and the Step Team. Assistant In his remarkable essay on leader- already understands the importance administrators, custodial staff Principal Ramon Lopez describes her ship, Blair clearly articulated his belief of taking risks, serving others, and and teachers, many community as energetic, driven ad dependable. that true leaders must consistently treating others with compassion and members have pitched in to help. (Deseret News) Monique credits her success in high step out of their comfort zone as well kindness.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA Teen Suicide Bullying has long been cited as a contributing factor in teen Martin Safran Citizenship Awards suicide, but a recent study shows it’s even more common among Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and and Stewart Weiner Scholarships Transgender (LGBTQ) youth who die by suicide. LGBTQ teens were nearly five times as likely to have By Gail Irizarry Awards and been bullied as non-LGBTQ youth. Stewart Weiner The study outlines the need for Every year, in honor of the late Scholarships. We increased bullying prevention Martin Safran, the Association of are grateful for efforts that explicitly include Assistant Principals (AAP) presents all the scholars sexual orientation and gender 15 public school students with a who show care identity. The study looked at data $100 award in his honor for exem- and commitment from the National Violent Death plary service to their schools and to service and Reporting System for a 15-year communities. leadership in period from 2003-2017. (UPI) At the same time, the AAP awards their communi- the Stewart Weiner Scholarship of ties, and to the WISCONSIN $1,000 to deserving college-bound members who seniors. The award was established nominated them. Planting Pollinators in honor of the late Stewart Weiner, Today they are Sand County Foundation, a former assistant principal of PS 20, leaders in their Chyna Hicks, IS 49-D31 non-profit, is working with agri- in Manhattan. respective elementary, middle and Julia McConnell, PS 1-D31 culture and science programs This year, we encountered the high schools. All recipients will Emily Schroeder, PS 1-D31 in Midwest schools to increase obvious challenge of a global pan- receive their scholarships via mail Saray Hinton, PS 196-D14 habitats of native wildflowers demic. Nevertheless, the AAP exec- in June 2020. Congratulations to all Myrie Grady, PS 196-D14 that are critical to insect pollina- utive board tenaciously reviewed all student winners! Maragaret Castiglia, PS 196-D28 tors. While grants were awarded the applications and held remote Suzanna Vinnitsky, PS 90-D21 before the pandemic and grant- meetings. We thank the executive Martin Safran Award Recipients Avery Ameer Ali, PS/IS 95-D21 ees were given the option of board and its members for their Chloe Celisca, IS 14 –D22 declining the grants, most con- commitment to these venerable Olivia Bennett, IS 278-D22 Stewart Weiner tinued as planned. One teacher scholarships and awards and to the Sienna Flood, IS 278-D22 Scholarship Recipients is growing flowers, planted by students of New York City. Brandon Navarro, IS 347-D32 Rudy Etzel, Cardinal Spellman students, in her living room These young scholars, through Debbie Chen, IS 383-D32 Haley Sim, Bronx HS of Science under special lights with plans to their hard work, dedication, service Nishat Nabilah, IS 383-D32 Metchersa Smith, Kamit Prep. plant the flowers outdoors soon. and leadership, earned Martin Safran Jordan Armstead, IS 383-D32 Institute (Spectrum News) — Compiled by Christine Altman 8 CSA NEWS Summer 2020

mantra was that every child can learn and his wife moved to Walnut Creek where they In Memoriam succeed, given the time and resources,” enjoyed socializing and playing bridge. Mr. said James Harrigan, CSA’s Brooklyn field Schultzman was a member of the Lapidary director and a longtime friend and col- Club for many years, serving as its presi- n DENNIS ABATE, 66, a resident of including the Outstanding Educator prize league of Mr. Landro. “Parents knew that dent for some time. Mr. Schutzman is sur- Montgomery, NY, died Aug. 27, 2019. He from the Jamaica Branch of the NAACP; Frank was totally committed to their chil- vived by his wife, Edith Schutzman; sons retired in 2008. the Jackie Robinson Junior High School dren’s success -- he lived two blocks away David and Howard Schutzman, a daughter, Man of the Year Award from Community n ALLEN S. ARGOFF, 87, a resident of from the school and his sons were stu- Susan Ollar; eight grandchildren and four School District 4, and the Distinguished Sheepshead Bay in Brooklyn, died Sept. 25. dents there.” In 1998, Mr. Landro become great-grandchildren. Mr. Argoff, a life-long resident of Brooklyn, Citizens Service Award from the New York a Supervisory Support Program mentor at n JOHN STIPANELA, 86, died on March 9 graduated from Brooklyn Technical High State Black and Puerto Rican Legislative CSA, sharing his knowledge and wisdom while under hospice care at his Manhattan School. He earned both his bachelor’s and Caucus. He is survived by his wife of with up and coming school supervisors. home. Mr. Stipanela graduated from master’s degrees from City College of New 60 years, Renee Bluford, his daughters He was also a stalwart unionist, serving as Cardinal Hayes High School and from the York, according to his son, Charles Argoff. Pamela, Paula, and Penny, six grandchil- CSA’s chair of District 20 for many years. University of Washington in Seattle, where Mr. Argoff began his career with New York dren and one great grandson. He also was president of NYCESPA from he also received his teacher training. City’s Department of Education as a teach- n PETER CARRIER, 76, died Aug. 11, 2019. 2001-2002. Frank also served for many Later he earned a master’s degree at NYU er at JHS 210 (John Marshall) in Brooklyn, A resident of Hastings on Hudson, NY, he years on the board of directors of the Dave and took additional coursework at City where he’d earlier been a student, said retired in 2002. Winfield Foundation, working with the College. He taught English in New York his daughter, Fran Bar-Eli. He moved on n THELMA JONES of Teaneck, NJ, 87, died Hall of Fame baseball player on philan- City junior high schools for several years, to the former Lafayette High School in the Nov. 11, 2019. She retired from NYC’s DOE thropic programs. Mr. Harrigan noted that and spent a year in Baumholder, Germany, Bathgate section of Brooklyn, before serv- in 1996. in later years he became an excellent golf- teaching English at a high school for the ing in the Bureau of Audiovisual Instruction n FRANK LANDRO, 72, died May 16. Born er, usually playing with a close group of children of Army members. In 1963 Mr. at DOE headquarters, then as supervisor and raised in Brooklyn, Mr. Landro was friends, all retired principals. Mr. Landro is Stipanela began a long career at Food and of Audiovisual Instruction and Library a talented athlete who excelled in base- survived by his wife, Ginay Marks Landro, a Maritime Trades High School, first as an Instruction for District 22 in Brooklyn. Mr. ball, playing in high school and at Long former DOE director of guidance, his sons English teacher, then as an AP (Admin) in Argoff was also an AV supervisor for District Island University where he attended col- Brett and Blake, and three grandchildren. charge of guidance. He continued in this 1 in lower Manhattan for a time, said his lege. He began teaching in District 15 n BERNARD NEIDERMAN, 94, died June position when Food and Maritime merged daughter. He taught evening high school in Brooklyn in the late 1960s, a time of 1 in Safety Harbor, FL. Mr. Neiderman was with Haaren High School to become Park and summer school at Lincoln High School an explosion of illicit drug use, especial- born in the Bronx in 1925 and lived in West High School. He then served as assis- in District 21 before being appointed assis- ly among young people. To combat this Brooklyn for many years before moving to tant director in the Office of High School tant principal at JHS 14 (Shell Bank) in epidemic, the Board of Education created Marlboro, NJ in 1987. Mr. Neiderman was a Admissions, followed by an administrative Sheepshead Bay, a position from which drug abuse prevention and education pro- high school social studies teacher, assistant position in the Office of the Alternative he retired around 1991. Mr. Argoff was a grams in each school district, and named principal and principal at PS 148 and PS 19 High School Superintendent. After his veteran of the US Army. Most of his career Mr. Landro the substance abuse preven- Annex in Brooklyn. After retiring in 1987, retirement, he worked as a substance was spent at Fort Jackson in Columbia, S.C., tion and education director for District 15, he mentored student teachers at Rutgers abuse counselor for many years at the but he closed out on Governor’s Island in a position he held for 10 years. Mr. Landro University and Georgian Court University International Center for the Disabled. Mr. NYC in 1954. He married the former Renee frequently testified at public hearings at in New Jersey. He enjoyed working with Stipanela is survived by his husband, Venetek in 1955. According to his son, Mr. the city, state and federal levels, culmi- these future teachers and improving their Charles Troob, with whom he had been Argoff enjoyed golf, playing bridge and nating in 1978 with his appearance before skills. In retirement, he remained interested together for nearly 40 years. “Our week- the theater. He was also involved in his the House Select Committee on Narcotics in history, current events and investing in end house in Greenport, Long Island, was temple. “He loved his family,” said his son. Abuse and Control. In 1982, He became the stock market. Mr. Neiderman was pre- a source of great joy to him,” said Mr. In addition to his wife, Renee Argoff, his principal of PS 185 in District 20. The city deceased by his wife, Helene Neiderman, Troob. “Many in New York, Greenport and son, Charles, and daughter, Fran Bar-Eli, had not yet fully recovered from the finan- in 2012, and a grandson, Paul. Surviving elsewhere will remember him for his infec- Mr. Argoff is survived by five grandchildren, cial crisis, and despite austerity policies, are his daughters, Natalie Wolle and Anne tious laugh and his enormous heart.” Chaim Bar-Eli, Brett Bar-Eli, David Argoff, Mr. Landro helped make the school into a Rapisarda, four grandchildren and eight Melanie Argoff, and Emily Argoff, as well as n ARTHUR TRAIGER, 92, died May 15, beacon of excellence, bringing in private great-grandchildren. two great-grandchildren, Yardena Bar-Eli 2020. Born in the Bronx, he graduated from and competitive grant money to fund spe- and Ezra Bar-Eli. n NORMAN NUSSBAUM, 84, of Bayside, DeWitt Clinton High School when he was cialized student programs. He also lobbied NY, died April 10. Born in Sunnyside, NY, 16. He attended City College for two years n MILDRED M.ASHEPA, 95, a resident of to make the school a gifted and talented he graduated from Stuyvesant High School until, near the end of World War II, he enlist- Boca Raton, FL, died May 15, 2019. She site. One of his projects was to secure and went on to get his B.S. from City College ed in the Army. After the war, he finished retired in 1979. funding for a botanical garden on the roof of New York, a master’s degree from his undergraduate education at Brooklyn n ERWIN BERMAN, 92, died Dec. 8, 2019. of the school, which served not only as a Brooklyn College, and a professional diplo- College and in 1949 began teaching English A resident of Brooklyn, NY, he retired from science center for botany but as a venue ma in administration and supervision from at Far Rockaway High School. In 1963, he NYC’s DOE in 1983. for school and community events. In the St. John’s University. Mr. Nussbaum spent became assistant principal of English at n EFREM BLANK, 83, died June 21, 2019. early 1990’s, when the BOE started to his entire 42-year career at PS 113, which New Utrecht High School in Brooklyn and in A resident of Great Neck, NY, he retired in embrace greater shared decision making closed and reopened as PS 384 in District 1966, assistant principal of English at Martin 1991. at the school level, many principals were 32. He initially taught sixth grade before Van Buren High School in Queens, where he reluctant to become involved, not sure n taking on several roles in the school as an spent the rest of his public school career. DAVID F. BLUFORD, 87, died on May 26. if it would lead to their authority being He lived in Queens. Born in Winston Salem, administrator. For many years, he was the He also worked for the Board of Examiners diminished. Mr. Landro piloted what was assistant principal. He retired in that role in at 110 Livingston Street. Throughout his NC, he attended public schools there and then called school-based management, received a BS from Fayetteville State 1999. Mr. Nussbaum also managed sum- 33-year teaching and supervisory career, he now known as school leadership teams. mer programs in District 30 and weekend was an advocate for students’ and teachers’ University, in Fayetteville, NC, an MA from The experiences at PS 185 and other pilot Hunter College in New York, and pursued programs at Samuel J. Tilden High School in rights. While teaching at Far Rockaway in schools provided the DOE with crucial District 18. “Mr. Nussbaum was the admin- the 1950s, he strongly supported teacher advanced studies in educational adminis- input about what was effective. “Frank’s tration from Columbia University and St. istrator in the building that all teachers unionization efforts, and in the late 1960s John’s University. He also was relied upon to address whatever need or and early 1970s at Martin Van Buren he a Hazen Fellow in political phi- problem that confronted them,” said his supported students’ rights to protest the losophy, at St. John’s College in longtime friend, teacher Joe Valinotti. “His Vietnam War. Upon his retirement in 1982, Santa Fe, NM. He served in the ability to solve problems at any level was Mr. Traiger and his wife Dorothy were invit- Army during the Korean War. legendary. He was a respected friend to ed to teach English as a second language in Mr. Bluford began his 50-year us all.” He is survived by his wife, Carole a Japanese private school, before accept- education career as a teacher at Nussbaum, a retired NYC principal, his son, ing positions to teach English at Nihon IS 55 in Ocean Hill Brownsville, Steven Nussbaum, his daughters, Michelle University in Mishima, Japan for eight more District 23, in the early 1960s. Katz and Lauren Rothberg and his grand- years. In addition to teaching, the cou- At the age of 30, he became the daughter, Sydney Katz. ple spent their years in Japan studying principal of JHS 13 in District 4 n IRVING SCHUTZMAN, 97, died Oct. 28, Japanese and practicing pottery and the in Manhattan. Later, he was an 2019. At the time of his death, he had been art of the tea ceremony. Even after leaving assistant to the superintendent residing in Walnut Creek, CA. Mr. Schutzman Japan, Mr. Traiger maintained strong ties of District 4, served as chairman was born and raised in Brooklyn, NY. He was with his Japanese colleagues and friends. of Community School Board a decorated sergeant who served during In 1992, the couple moved to Sandy, Utah 29, was a director of Upward World War II in the Philippines, New Guinea where they became ski instructors at the Bound at Queens College, an and Japan. Mr. Schutzman earned a BA Brighton Ski School. Mr. Traiger retired adjunct professor of education- from Long Island University and a MA from as a ski instructor in 2013, at age 85. The al administration at Brooklyn Adelphi University. Mr. Schutzman taught next year, they moved to Ridgefield, CT, in College and an adjunct pro- elementary school at PS 11 in the Clinton a house across the road from their daugh- fessor of English communica- Hill neighborhood of Brooklyn, and later, ter’s family. Mr. Traiger is survived by his tion at St. John’s University. taught science at the former Sheepshead wife of 70 years, Dorothy Cohen Traiger, “His mission was to educate Bay High School. He was later appointed a retired English teacher; their daughter, and lead the next generation an assistant principal at Stephen A. Halsey Ilene Traiger; their sons, Saul and Laurence; of educators and communi- Junior High School in Rego Park, Queens, nine grandchildren, and six great grand- ty leaders,” said his daugh- before being named principal of PS 62 children. “ Arthur was a devoted and loving ter, Paula Rainer. He received n A life in public service – David Bluford was a teacher, (Chester Park School) in Queens (District husband and father, a skier, boatsman, many awards during his career, principal, assistant superintendent and professor. 27). He retired in 1983. Mr. Schutzman and Continued on next page Summer 2020 CSA NEWS 9 ‘A Fiercely Dedicated School Leader’

Continued from Page 1 new teachers and building teacher Garry was valedictorian of her high craft,” he said. “And she was so school class, and was known for tack- passionate about serving students ling any challenges she took on, from who were underrepresented – she cross country running, to water skiing, knew how to bring out the best in to playing first violin in the orchestra. them, through the activities and “She chose things that were diffi- tasks and how she worked with the cult and found ways to excel,” said her teachers.” brother, John Garry. “That was exem- As news of her death became plified in her educational career: It took public, outpourings of grief prolif- her less than 10 years to go from being erated. a teacher to becoming a principal. Both “The soul of BAL has left us this of our parents were teachers, and it was Wednesday,” her school’s staff important to her that she was continu- members said in an Instagram post ing that family legacy. She was very soon after her death. “The bright proud of the work she did, and our smile that used to greet everyone parents were incredibly proud of her, in the morning outside. The per- from a young age.” son who used to put everyone Ms. Garry attended Cornell ahead of herself, and still keep an University where she began her stud- entire school running. The mind ies in engineering. She realized that that was brilliant and loving. The wasn’t her path, her brother said, and one who used to love and care in her sophomore year she became an for every single student no matter English major. After she graduated, she what. spent a year working as a paralegal, and “Today students and staff came then set her sights on teaching. She together to remember all the many was accepted as a New York Teaching n Erin Garry celebrating with a graduating senior at Bronx Academy of Letters. ways that you made our lives bet- Fellow, and after completing that pro- ter, and for that we will never for- gram in 2004 became an English teacher the tenth grader who was alone and misunderstood. get you. Every single tear and smile at the new School for Global Leaders in the Lower East She would walk down a hall with a mishmash of kids shared today was a tribute to you. We are endlessly Side of Manhattan where she began teaching a sixth- trailing behind her. There was a group of sixth-grade grateful for all you did for the South Bronx and its grade class and moved up with the students. “The boys who had lunch in her office every day. They were people; your legacy will always be there. Rest in Peace, parents asked for that,” her brother said. “She helped kids who found a home in her office. She was a home Ms. Garry.” develop the curriculum, and she had strong ties to the for so many kids. It’s a terrible loss.” In a year already darkened by the deaths and severe kids and the parents as well.” Ms. Pecharo, who described Ms. Garry as a woman illnesses of CSA members and people throughout our In 2014, she went to Bronx Academy of Letters, a of both superior intellect and warm compassion, school communities due to Covid, Ms. Garry’s passing 6-12 school, as an AP, and when Principal Brandon also noted how supportive she was of teachers and was another sad event for the union and public schools. Cardet Hernandez left, she was appointed princi- staff. “My mom died last year, and I had to be gone “Erin Garry, at a young age, was already a successful pal. She quickly developed a reputation as a deeply for a week,” she said. “It wasn’t a problem for her. principal – a shining star,” said CSA President Mark involved and caring school leader who was fiercely She knew the kids wouldn’t be their best selves if we Cannizzaro. “She was someone who cared for her stu- dedicated to her students. weren’t at our best.” dents and staff in ways that would help them realize On any day, her office was awash in backpacks and Derek Premo, who went through the Teaching their potential, a true hallmark of a great school leader.” jackets. “I will always remember how she took certain Fellows program with her and is now finishing In addition to her brother John, Ms. Garry is kids under her wing, and they would always stick to his first year as principal of Lower Manhattan Arts survived by her parents, Kenneth Garry and Diane her,” said Dana Pecharo, an English teacher at Bronx Academy, said Ms. Garry believed deeply in the S. Garry, her sister Meghan Garry, and her partner Letters. “From the sixth grader who misbehaved to Teaching Fellows program. “She loved working with Andrew Hartz.

Continued from previous page at Brooklyn College and started fresh. Mr. made sure we were engaged, inspired, chal- n PHILIP ALAN ZEMMEL, 85, died March Tsufura taught math at PS 11 in Chelsea, lenged and smiling. Thank you for keeping 18. He lived in Sarasota. Mr. Zemmel grew potter, lover of music and art, and a then at PS 3 in Greenwich Village. He was our creative fires alive.” Mr. Tsufura is sur- up in The Bronx and graduated from world traveler,” his wife said. “He lived a named principal of PS 41 in Greenwich vived by two daughters, Lisa Tsufura and DeWitt Clinton High School, before earn- life that inspired all who knew him, and he Village — a post he held for eight years Eve Tsufura, and a grandson. ing a bachelor’s degree from City College never stopped teaching.” before being appointed a deputy superin- of New York in Manhattan and a mas- n TADASHI TSUFURA, 89, died March 29, tendent of District 3. Mr. Tsufura retired in n HENRY WHITNEY, 80, of St. Albans, ter’s degree from Fordham University in a victim of coronavirus. His wife, Mabel 1988. Mr. Tsufura told The Daily News in Queens, died April 5. Mr. Whitney was born The Bronx. His daughter, Susan Zemmel, (Murakami) Tsufura, a former home eco- 1966 that internment “was an ego-destroy- in Brooklyn and grew up in Williamsburg. said her father completed coursework nomics teacher, died of the disease five ing experience, and it is this that has made He graduated from the Fashion Institute of toward a doctorate degree but did not days earlier. Mr. Tsufura, one of the DOE’s me determined to help others to use their Design, before earning a basketball schol- complete his dissertation. He served in the first Japanese-American principals, was suffering as youths for constructive goals.” arship to Iowa State University, where Army National Guard. Mr. Zemmel spent born in Los Angeles to parents who had His determination made an impression on he graduated with a bachelor’s degree the bulk of his career at PS 76 in Long immigrated from Japan. He and his family many students and their parents. An online in physical education. He later earned Island City, Queens, rising from teacher moved to Parlier, near Fresno, when he was memorial page maintained by Thomas M. a master’s degree. Mr. Whitney met his to principal, a post from which he retired six years old. After the Japanese attack on Quinn & Sons Funeral Home in Woodside, wife, Gloria, while at Iowa State and they in the late 1990s. “He loved his job, he Pearl Harbor in 1941, Mr. Tsufura and his Queens, contains moving tributes to Mr. returned to Brooklyn. They moved to St. loved his students, he loved his teachers,” family were among the 120,000 Japanese- Tsufura. “You were an awesome teach- Albans, Queens four years later, where said his daughter. “He was a very happy Americans forced by the US government er and so many of your students loved Mr. Whitney and his family resided for 54 man.” The Zemmel family lived in New into internment camps. After two years and appreciated you. I (and most of your years. He began his career as a physical City, NY, while Mr. Zemmel pursued his living in a camp in Arizona, Mr. Tsufura students) never realized your background education teacher at IS 33 (Mark Hopkins) career. He and his wife eventually moved and his parents moved to Seabrook, NJ., and when I read what you and your family in Bedford-Stuyvesant in 1964, went on to Manhattan, before relocating perma- according to an obituary in the New York had gone through during WWII, my heart to be named an assistant principal at the nently to Sarasota some 20 years ago. Times. Following his two older brothers, cried. You came through a shining star!” school, and later became principal at IS After retiring, his daughter said her father Mr. Tsufura served in the US Army, and wrote Sharon Pacheco, who credited Mr. 49 (W.J. Gaynor) in Brooklyn, a post from enjoyed his grandchildren, golf, reading served on the front lines of the Korean War Tsufura with helping her understand alge- which he retired in 2001. His daughter, and solving crossword puzzles. “He had a from 1951 to 1953. After his discharge, bra. Samantha Kaplan, principal of Yorkville Chrystal Whitney-Murray, said her father, beautiful life,” she said. In addition to his Mr. Tsufura earned a bachelor’s degree in Community School, said that Mr. Tsufura’s at 6’ 7” tall, “was a gentle giant. His staff daughter, Mr. Zemmel is survived by his chemical engineering from Fenn College, example led her to embark on her own loved him. Some called him a second wife of 65 years, Sandra Zemmel; another now Cleveland State University, in Ohio. career as an educator. “You have helped father.” After he retired, Mr. Whitney daughter, Caroline Ratner; and grandchil- Mr. Tsufura disliked his work as a chemical to mold me into the principal I am today,” enjoyed golf and traveling. His wife, a dren Chelsea, Jon David, Olivia and Chloe. engineer, and joining one of his brothers in she wrote. “I remember how you walked retired nurse, predeceased him in 2013. In New York City in the 1960s, he discovered the halls of PS 41, when I was one of your addition to his daughter, he is survived by Send obituary notices to CSA News there was a shortage of teachers in the pub- students, making sure we were all OK. You two sons, Bret and Bryant, a sister, Cynthia Editor Chuck Wilbanks at chuck@csa-nyc. lic schools, so he took education courses made sure to say hello every morning. You Whitfield, and eight grandchildren. org. 10 CSA NEWS Summer 2020 RETIREE Chapter CHAIR’S MESSAGE Gayle Lockett Now, More Than End-Of-Year Update ven though our union headquarters are closed, Ever, We Must Be our members still receive their Welfare Fund benefits and have their questions Eanswered. Meanwhile, Retiree Chapter officers and our director Politically Active reach out to our members and answer questions. Unit Leaders and BY DONALD SINGER Wisconsin’s primary elections their executive boards are keeping and the enormous obstacles vot- members informed by email updates rom the terrible death ers faced amid the coronavirus and phone calls. Some units are hav- of George Floyd in pandemic to see how important ing executive board Zoom meetings. Minneapolis, to the this is. Unfortunately, we will not violence in New York We must support candidates be able to produce another outstanding fall brochure of and around the world, who vote pro-union. classes, trips, clubs, and lectures since venues are closed. The Fto the ongoing tragedy of the We must support candidates Educational/Cultural Committee has provided virtual classes -- Covid pandemic, I cannot think who support public education watch for updates for more information. The committee mem- of a time that has been more and the United States Postal bers and Lucie Elio, the Educational/Cultural Coordinator, are challenging to organized labor Service, as opposed to privatizing working on the fall virtual classes which will come out later and unions in the United States such essential services. this summer. You should have received an update on the avail- than now. And there has never Please check the Alliance for able virtual programs. If you didn’t, go to CSA RC Upcoming been a time when it was more Retired Americans’ Annual Events on CSA’s website, csa-nyc.org. Donald Singer important that we stand up Voting Record, January- Political Affairs Director Gabe Gallucci held a May PAC December 2019, to see how your representatives meeting at which we received updates on the city, state and fed- politically for those who will stand with us. eral levels regarding hearings and budgets. Please remember to To me, democracy and unionism are closely voted on issues such as retirement security, send in your census form and encourage others to do the same. connected, and we must be prepared to elect declining availability of guaranteed pensions In May, Juanita Johnson and I attended the Welfare Fund RC candidates on the local, state and national levels and threats to Social Security and Medicare. Trustee meeting. Our Welfare Fund is doing very well. who share our agenda, regardless of political “Elections have consequences,” noted ARA The Retiree Chapter Officers held its May RC Executive party. We must be prepared to vote with the leadership. “Retirees vote in the greatest num- Board meeting via Zoom. Our guest speakers were CSA President largest number of voters in the history of unions. bers, and the American people elected a new Mark Cannizzaro and AFSA President, Ernest Logan. President As I’m writing this note, I’m listening to the majority to the U.S. House of Representatives in Cannizzaro thanked the retirees/unit leaders and their execu- majority leader of the U.S. Senate telling the 2018. With that change came some progress on tive boards for reaching out to retirees who needed help, were states to apply for bankruptcy. Does Senator pro-retiree legislation.” living alone or just bringing greetings. He shared with the RC McConnell represent our values and beliefs? But much more needs to be done to ensure Executive Board that, at the CSA Executive Board meeting in Why is he concerned about the “cost” of our our hard-fought gains are protected. May, he requested in-service members to notify Mark Brodsky hard-fought pensions? As was noted at CSA’s recent PAC meeting, of any retirees who need help i.e. in obtaining prescriptions or Compare his remarks with N.Y. State’s our city, state and federal representatives are groceries. The in-service members were very receptive. This is Comptroller DiNapoli, who wrote to retirees, assessing government priorities and competing another great example of union solidarity. Your pensions are safe and will continue to interests. CSA, in partnership with the Central • • • pay your benefits as scheduled each and every Labor Council, the AFL-CIO and other affiliates month as promised.” are working diligently to ensure that education or the first time, all 17 Unit Leaders, including Norm There are many reports about voting by mail remains a top priority and an essential compo- Sherman, Florida’s Outreach Liaison, were invited to attend appearing in many states. We believe that any nent to the advancement of our society. the Zoom meeting. Some of the highlights: F mechanism which enhances and enlarges voting • IRMAA reimbursement forms can still be submitted and • • • the application form can be downloaded from the CSA Welfare is something we should be fighting for. Affiliates Fund website. In case the Office of Labor Relations is still closed, of the AFL-CIO are working with ARA in New s a delegate of the NYC chapter of the send your papers and signed cover sheet to the Welfare Fund, York and Florida, and across the country to get New York State ARA, and a board member Attn: Dr. Douglas Hathaway. the vote out, and to improve mail-in ballot pro- Aof the Florida ARA, I have been reaching • Under the Cares Act, RMD’s were suspended for 2020 cedures. out to all our retired members to remind them but will resume in 2021. Remember, you can always take your We should applaud Governor Cuomo’s efforts that the first Florida primaries are scheduled for money out when you want but you will pay taxes on it. to make it easier to obtain a mail-in ballot for Aug. 18 and that one must register to vote. To • According to NY State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, and June’s New York primaries, by signing an exec- do so, go to Florida.Gov. City Comptroller Scott Stringer, our pensions are in good shape. utive order that will allow voters to receive a Support your union! And support and vote for • The RC Executive Board donated assistance in rebuilding prepaid application. candidates who support us. Your future and your Puerto Rico. The Board also donated again to CSA’s Scholarship Let’s support candidates who support more family’s future are at stake. Fund. Scholarships were presented at CSA’s June meeting. mailed ballots and early voting in addition to We look forward to seeing you in the Fall. Be well and safe. voting on election day. We only need to look at Donald Singer was president of CSA. In Unity, Gayle Lockett 2020 Census: Participation Critical As you know, participation in the Census is izenship status, your job, or your Social Security critical so that members of every community are or ITIN number. Your responses are private, pro- counted to ensure funding for schools, housing, tected by federal law, and will never be shared with roads, bridges, hospitals, senior centers, congres- anyone, including law enforcement or your land- sional representation and more. The census is 10 lord. We encourage you to share this information questions, takes 10 minutes, and will help shape widely and on social media. your city’s and state’s future for the next 10 years. Go online to my2020census.gov to fill out It does not ask about your immigration or cit- the 2020 census or call (844) 330-2020. Summer 2020 CSA NEWS 11 Running Strong RC Regional Units SUNCOAST MANHATTAN We have persevered through the Due to the COVID 19 crisis, all Despite COVID19 quarantine and gong forward, we need in-person events have been can- to continue to be vigilant. This has been celed. We did reschedule our annual BY MARK BRODSKY our values. We have members in 41 a time to reflect on our blessings and luncheon at the National Arts Club states, Washington D.C. and Puerto be grateful. Please continue your social for Friday, June 4, 2021 at noon. The Retiree Chapter has been up Rico, so our voice is heard far and distancing: Take nothing for granted. Hopefully things will have improved and running, full speed since the wide. I have had the opportunity through by then. In the meantime, we will moment this horrific pandemic Our ever-supportive RC officers and Zoom to connect with many people for send you more email blasts to keep occurred. Working with CSA’s offi- executive board have been meeting meetings, social gatherings and espe- you informed. If you have changed cers, directors and staff, we have often, discussing ways we can con- cially teaching live streamed Zoomba your email, please inform us by email- remained a full service department. tinue to provide support to you. Our Gold classes. Our classes are offered ing us at [email protected]. As We are guiding our in-service mem- 17 Units, their leaders and executive through the CSARC Virtual Programs always, you can reach me at (917) 692- bers who are in the process of retiring, boards have been emailing and call- via Zoom. Mark Brodsky’s Retiree 2942 or [email protected] working with those families who have ing members to let them know we are Update from June 2, 2020 has all the — Stanley Wilson lost loved ones and ensuring our mem- here for them, to provide support and details. If you would like more infor- bers who are due retroactive monies for those members who are alone, mation, just send me an email at cin- and final entitlements get them in as and to help them avoid social isola- [email protected] or cindyzum- SOUTHEAST FLORIDA timely a fashion as possible. tion. [email protected]. I will be inviting This has been a very trying and We have been coordinating and We are in the midst of starting our our Suncoast retirees to join me in a challenging time for all of us. Our Zoom meeting sometime in September. hastening resolves with TRS as we 18th Unit in Central Florida. newsletter, which usually is mailed I will send you an email with all the are able to cut through red tape and On a sad note, we wont be offer- out in early May has been delayed details. In the meantime, please stay often move mountains. We have ing a free Blue Natter’s Calendar this because of the pandemic situation. safe and healthy. I hope to meet you all developed wonderful relationships year. They are based on the school Many of our snowbird members again on Thursday, Jan. 14, 2021. Your calendar, which has not yet been remained in Florida and we had to with the hard working members of hugs will be waiting for you! determined. Irving Natters’ son, who determine who was still here. That TRS and enjoy open and constant — Cindy Salamone communications with the DOE. publishes the calendar, has not made being said, we have contracted dates Unfortunately we have had to cur- it available. for the Civic Center for next season’s schedule but we don’t yet know if tail all our wonderful trips, lectures DOE members who retired on SOUTHWEST things will be open and if it will be and events that were planned for or after July 1, 2015, should have safe to congregate in large groups. As the members and we have informed received the fourth retro payment We were disappointed to cancel our time goes by, we will let you know. If everyone that full reimbursements based on our contract agreed upon March meeting due to Covid-19, but we have reached out to our members you have a change of address, phone will be made once we can get back in December 2014. This payment via email. We hope our members and number or email, please let me know. into our offices. At the same time, was due in Feb., 2020. If you should families stay well, safe and cool for My email is: [email protected] and we have started virtual classes such have received this payment and did summer. We look forward to meeting phone number (561) 964-8865. Stay not, and have not yet contacted CSA, in 2021! safe and healthy. please email me at [email protected]. —Stef Thier and Dom Nigro — Lois Turetzky Unfortunately, Blue There is one last payment due in Feb., 2021. Natter’s Calendars The RC staff, while working remotely, has access to all our data- Will Not Be Available bases and are ready to assist as we For This Year have always been. Watch for our Perfect Timing! Carnegie Hall emails that provide you with up to date and important information. And Offers Free Music Live Streams as cooking demonstrations, book to answer many of your questions discussions, financial lectures, tech- regarding our pensions – the trustees Music has the undeniable power to gettable episodes that feature some of nology, creative writing, jewelry, of TRS have assured us they are fully comfort, uplift, connect and inspire. In the world’s finest artists as they share Mah Jong, bridge and Zumba classes focused on overseeing the funds response to this unprecedented time, behind the scenes stories, past perfor- as well as negotiated a discount for with diligence and prudence so we Carnegie Hall invites you to join them mances and live musical moments. Free OneDayUniversity. can continue to enjoy the benefits for an entirely new online series: Live live streams and archived episodes can with Carnegie Hall. It features unfor- be viewed at: www.carnegiehall.org. We have been knee-deep in poli- we earned with our blood, sweat and tics – supporting those who support tears.

Protection FYI How To Avoid Social Security Imposters

BY DEBBIE FIGUEROA If you receive a suspicious call from numbers over the phone. ongoing business you have with someone alleging to be from Social • Require a specific means of debt them. Scammers go to great lengths to trick Security, please: repayment, like a prepaid debit • Mail you a letter if there is a problem. you out of your personal information. • Hang up right away. card, a retail gift card, or cash. • Mail you a letter if you need to We want to help you protect your • Never give your personal informa- • Demand that you pay a Social submit payments that will have information by helping you recognize tion, money, or retail gift cards. Security debt without the ability to detailed information about options a Social Security imposter. • Report the scam at oig.ssa.gov to appeal the amount you owe. to make payments and the ability There’s a widespread telephone scam Social Security’s law enforcement • Promise a Social Security benefit to appeal the decision. involving callers claiming they’re from team, office of Inspector General. approval, or increase, in exchange • Use emails, text messages, and Social Security. The caller ID may even for information or money. social media to provide general show a government number. These Social Security will not: • Request personal or financial infor- information (not personal or finan- callers may tell you there’s a problem • Threaten you. mation through email, text mes- cial information) on its programs with your Social Security number. They • Tell you that your Social Security sages, or social media. and services if you have signed up may also threaten to arrest you unless Number has been suspended. to receive these messages. you pay a fine or fee using gift cards, • Call you to demand an immediate Social Security will: pre-paid debit cards, a wire transfer, or payment. • Sometimes call you to confirm you Debbie Figueroa is a Social Security cash. That call is not from us. • Ask you for credit or debit card filed for a claim or to discuss other Public Affairs Specialist in New York. Social Justice:ConversationAndCourage sation starter as we work our way toward sation starteras weworkourwaytoward and theMood Meter hasbeenaconver- ular “let’stalkitout”meetings for ourstaff, black, and LatinX. I have been having reg- professionals whoareSouthAsian, white, a diversestaff,whichcurrently includes their planofaction. other platformstoshowtheirresearchand for theseprojects.StudentsusedFlipgridand dards andskillstotargetintherequirements technology andmath,determinedstan- lyzed ourstudents’skillsacrosswriting,ELA, to students andteachers as well.Weana- food security–issuesthatwereimportant included votingrights,policebrutality,and explored asocialjusticeissue.Topics name: Ourfifthgradersdeterminedand nected totheheartofourpendingschool learning experiences.Oneprojectiscon- understand theirvariedexperiences. and openness, which has given us a lens to sense ofcommunity. Therehasbeentrust virtually, theybroughttheirlongstanding a yearnow.Whenwebegandoingthat dents inrestorativescirclesformorethan board. Wehavebeenengagingourstu- really happytoseethattheyweresoon they’re makingthemathome.Wewere them tousetheMoodMeterandnow worry abouttheirchildren.Ihaveurged talk about continued abuse of power and of themaresadaboutpolicebrutality.They if necessary. deeper, andeventoalignoutsidesupports with support. Teachersareabletodiveabit peers aswellteachersareableto“leanin” When studentsnametheirfeeling, and staffthewordstonametheirfeelings. find outwhytheykeepkillingus.’ I wanttobeadetective,because Ineedto check-in, afifth-gradestudentsaid,‘Ithink meets andonGoogleClassroom. Inarecent daily check-inswithstudentsduringvirtual parents andguardians.Teachersconduct ports dialoguebetweenstudents,staff,and impact onournation.TheMoodMetersup- about thedeathofGeorgeFloydandits ment series to facilitate student discussions restorative circlesandourparent engage- vehicles. mom passedawayandthereweresixescort had aparaderecentlyforstudentwhose Continued from Page 3 “I’ve been very conscious about having “I’ve beenveryconsciousabout having “We beganworkingonproject-based “I speak with parentseachweek.Many “We haveleveragedtheMoodMeter, “The Mood Meter gives our students “The Mood Meter gives our students SUMMER 2020

Printed onFSCcertifiedpaper 40 RectorSt.,NY,NY10006 Local 1AFSA,AFL-CIO New YorkStateFederationofSchoolAdministrators Council ofSchoolSupervisors&Administrators,NYC involved toplanofactiontheyallaccept. choice, it’s a necessity, leading everyone race andequitysocialjusticeisnota dren. Courageousconversationsabout want toseewillcomethroughourchil- their staffsas facilitators. Thechangeswe principals canbettersupportandequip tions isitcreatesapathwayforward,so The beautifulthingabouttheconversa- work butmaynotknowwheretobegin. about howtofacilitatethedialogue. be alotofcriticalthinkingandquestioning can’t push their ownagendas.Therehasto ognize the power oftheirvoice.Soteachers dialogue betweenkidsandhelpthemrec- trained. Theyneedtoopenthespacefor sations betweenstudents,theyneedtobe But ifteachersarefacilitatingtheseconver- truths. Somepeoplehavebeenoffended. and mortar.Peoplehavebeenspeakingtheir they didwhenweweremeetinginbrick conversations togosomuchfurtherthan closure. uncomfortable, andsometimesthereisno Still, theseconversationsaregoingtobe norms aboutrespectingpeople’sviews. have a discussion protocol and revisit our constructing aconciseplanofaction.We April Leong the ways of the NYPD. Her students, in turn, the ways of the NYPD. Her students, in turn, York Citycops educatingherstudentsin program inherschoolthatfeatures New School inConeyIsland,hasconducted a principal ofLiberationDiploma High n AprilLeong,center,withpoliceandstudentsinthisyear’sJuniorCitizen’sPoliceAcademy. A lot of school leaders want to do the A lotofschoolleaderswanttodothe “The virtual arena has allowed for the For the last several years, April Leong, For thelastseveralyears,April Leong, able to help families pay their phone bills able tohelpfamilies paytheirphonebills drove it over to their family. We’ve been I took toilet paper from my home and embarrassed that she hadno toilet paper, work hoursduetothepandemic, wasso nobody getscomplacent. off somewithfamiliesaswell. I makesure equipped with extra face masks and drop been knockingondoors--wetrytostay support staffwhoworkforourCBO.We’ve guidance counselor,aparaprofessionaland supplies. WehavetwoAPs,12teachers,a ping for them, getting them gift cards or food banksorhavingtheCBOgoshop- them –whetherit’sconnectingwith with my CBO, JCCA, just to get food to the familiesafloat.We’vebeenworking they need, and find the resources to keep keep kids engaged, find out everything tuous months. CSA Newsherworkduringthelasttumul- urgency totheprogram.Shediscusseswith around the country created an even greater in Minneapolisandtheresultingprotests 16-21, the police killing of George Floyd school ofnearly200studentsagingfrom hostility topolice.Forherandtransfer often markedbypoverty,violence,and the NYPDandherstudents,whoselivesare Island, as a way of offering a bridge between chokehold killing of Eric Garner in Staten Citizens PoliceAcademy,inthewakeof ple ofcolorinaroughparttown. tions withpolicecanbelikeforyoungpeo- give NYPDcadetsatasteofwhatinterac- “One mother,whohadlost many “It has been an absolute struggle –to She startedtheprogram,Junior port. on thecallstoofferthemadditionalsup- parents andIinviteamentalhealthliaison also holdperiodicZOOMmeetingswith not everything theyreadorhearis true. I tion, howtofactcheckthings.Itellthem discuss withthemhowtosortfactfromfic- tively. Ilook atitas an open forum, and about howtoexpressthemselvesconstruc- thoughtful andItrytogivethemadvice – someofthemcanhavetroublebeing it comesoutofmyownpocket. ask themwhat they needandsometimes -- sometimesIpayabillforthemmyself. peaceful manner.” students canengage withthepoliceina we should be creating platforms where the violence that has goneon. Instead, the schoolsandfunding police with the conversationbetween security in about thepolice. ficult itiseventalkingtotheirownfamilies going to the police academy, and how dif- They talkedabouttheirexcitementof more programslikethisaroundthestate. see. Theytoldhimthatthey’dliketosee become part of the change they want to know hisstory. He encouragedthem to a policeofficerhimself.Thestudentsdidn’t victim ofpolicebrutalitybeforehebecame He told everyone how he too had been a Brooklyn BoroughPresidentEricAdams. meeting withtheschoolcommunityand ticipating. Iwishitwerethewholeschool. worse. Rightnow,thereare14studentspar- gram, theirmentalstatewouldbemuch have toldmethatifitwasn’tforthispro- should bepayingattentionto.Mystudents the chancellorbecauseit’ssomethinghe young peopleandthepolice.I’vecontacted city should have this dialogue between believe they’reright:Otherschoolsinthe more we have these kinds of exchanges. I we wouldhavefeweroftheseincidentsthe than 100recruits.Thestudentsreallybelieve talking about12-14kidstomore cate. Thesedialoguesareincredible.We’re with therecruitsabouthowtocommuni- are the teachers and they have a dialogue In those sessions, it’s our students who and speaktorecruitsatthepoliceacademy. During ourregularyear,studentsgoin are conductedtotheroutinesofbeatcops. police protocol,fromhowinvestigations “I do phone call check-ins with students “I dophonecallcheck-inswithstudents “I don’tthinkit’shelpfulto lump “The otherdaywehadatownhall “Our program with the NYPD teaches

and AdditionalMailingOffice Brooklyn, NY11201 US POSTAGEPAIDAT Periodicals