Genetica (2007) 130:99–103 DOI 10.1007/s10709-006-0023-4

BRIEF REPORT

The karyotypes of the thorny catfishes Wertheimeria maculata Steindachner, 1877 and wilderi Kindle, 1895 (Siluriformes: ) and their relevance in doradids chromosomal evolution

Eduardo S. Eler Æ Jorge A. Dergam Æ Paulo C. Veˆnere Æ Lı´lian C. Paiva Æ Gabriela A. Miranda Æ Alessandro A. Oliveira

Received: 13 March 2006 / Accepted: 24 May 2006 / Published online: 8 August 2006 Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2006

Abstract We studied the karyotypes of two doradids, chromosome numbers, chromosomal evolution in do- the rare and endangered Wertheimeria maculata and a radids has involved pericentric inversions and an in- derived Amazonian , . Cytoge- crease of heterochromatic blocks. netic characterization was assessed using conventional staining (Giemsa), C-banding, and NOR banding. Both Keywords Brazilian coastal basins Æ Conservation species had 2n = 58 chromosomes but differed in their genetics Æ Cytotaxonomy Æ South American biodiversity chromosome formulae, 24 m + 14sm + 8st + 12a for W. maculata and 32 m + 16sm + 10st for H. wilderi.In W. maculata heterochromatin was mainly telomeric, Introduction and three chromosomes had a fully heterochromatic arm; in H. wilderi heterochromatin was also predomi- Although the Neotropical fish fauna of freshwater nantly telomeric and evident in many more chromo- fishes is the richest in the planet, studies of the evolu- somes. Hassar wilderi also presented one pair of tion of its ostariophysan (Characiformes + Silurifor- homologues with a fully heterochromatic arm. In both mes) groups have barely started (De Pinna 1998). species, nucleolar organizer regions were restricted to Whereas characiforms are usually diurnal, small-sized one pair of subtelocentric chromosomes. Assuming a and silvery, siluriforms are dark-colored, usually basal position for W. maculata, we hypothesized that nocturnal and have undergone a wide ecological underlying conserved diploid and NOR-bearing adaptation in the Neotropics, ranging from the tiny (0.025–0.06 m) vampire fish, parasitic Vandellia spp. to large species, such as Brachyplatystoma filamentosum (3.6 m) (Lundberg and Littmann 2003). To date, 1649 E. S. Eler species of siluriforms have been described, 1000 only in Gene´tica, Conservac¸a˜o e Biologia Evolutiva – Instituto the last century (Ferraris and Reis 2005 and references Nacional de Pesquisas da Amazoˆ nia, Av. Andre´ Arau´ jo, therein). Among the currently 15 Neotropical catfish 2936, Petro´ polis, 69083-000 Manaus, AM, families, the family Doradidae encompasses 30 extant J. A. Dergam (&) Æ L. C. Paiva Æ G. A. Miranda Æ genera and 72 valid species (Sabaj and Ferraris 2003) A. A. Oliveira diagnosed by several osteological synapomorphies and Departamento de Biologia , Universidade Federal by the presence (albeit modified in Wertheimeria and a de Vic¸osa, Avenida P.H. Rolfs s/n, Campus Universita´rio, few other species) of ossified tubules of the lateral-line 36570-000 Vic¸osa, AM, Brazil e-mail: [email protected] system, arranged on a lateral row. Size variation within doradids is also remarkable, ranging from 3.5 cm P. C. Veˆnere standard length in lira Cope 1871 to 120 cm Departamento de Cieˆncias Biolo´ gicas e da Sau´ de, Instituto fork length and 20 kg in niger (Valenciennes, de Cieˆncias e Letras do Me´dio Araguaia, Universidade Federal de Mato Grosso, Rodovia MT 100, Km 3,5, 78698- 1821)(Sabaj and Ferraris 2003). Doradids occur in most 000 Pontal do Araguaia, MT, Brazil South American basins, though they are absent from

123 100 Genetica (2007) 130:99–103 the Pacific Coast drainages and from coastal drainages Cell division was stimulated in vivo with 2 daily south of the La Plata River (Sabaj and Ferraris 2003). applications of Munolan, a commercially available Geographic distribution of the group is also uneven: antigen lysate (1 pill ground and suspended in 0.5 ml of 70% of the valid species occur in the . water per 100 g body weight). Metaphases were The Orinoco basin harbors ca. 22 species and ranks obtained from cephalic kidney, using a protocol mod- second in species richness. Contrasting with these ified from Egozcue (1971). C-banding and NOR pro- drainages, only two species of doradids have been tocols followed Sumner (1972) and Howell and Black described from Brazilian eastern coastal basins: Wert- (1980). Chromosome measures were obtained digitally heimeria maculata from the Jequitinhonha and Pardo from scanned plates using Image Pro-Plus and mor- rivers and Higuchi, Britski & phology was determined on the basis of arm ratio as Garavello, 1990 from the Paraguac¸u River. Within its proposed by Levan et al. (1964). Chromosomes were restricted range, W. maculata faces strong human classified as metacentrics (m), submetacentrics (sm), habitat disturbances such as siltation, habitat frag- subtelocentrics (st), and acrocentrics (a). NF (chro- mentation, pollution and introduction of exotic species. mosome arm number) was determined considering all Previous systematic studies placed this thorny catfish as chromosome classes as bi-armed, except for acrocen- a member of the family Auchenipteridae, but it was trics, which were counted as being formed by one arm. recognized as a doradid by Miranda-Ribeiro (1911). Based on morphological analysis, Higuchi (1992) placed it as the sister taxon of all other doradids and Results therefore its karyological characters are especially re- levant for the comprehension of the chromosomal The karyotype of W. maculata was 2n = 58 and had 24 evolution of this family. Although chromosome dif- metacentrics, 14 submetacentrics, 8 subtelocentrics, and ferences among related species are well known (White 12 acrocentrics and NF = 104; NORs were telomeric 1978; King 1993), homology assessment on fish chro- and restricted to one pair of homologues (Fig. 2). In H. mosomes is hampered by lack of arm differentiation wilderi, diploid number was also 2n = 58, differing from and therefore, chromosome data are unsuitable for the former species in chromosome morphology, with 32 formulating phylogenetic hypotheses. Instead, we have metacentrics, 16 submetacentrics and 10 subtelocentrics overlapped karyological data on molecular and mor- and NF = 116 (Fig. 2). As in W. maculata, only one phologic hypotheses and explored the information pair of homologues bore NORs in telomeric position, content of karyotypes within a putatively more re- corresponding to a secondary constriction visible in pair stricted monophyletic group. Therefore, the objective 27 in the Giemsa-stained karyotype. Both species pre- of the present paper was to compare some cytogenetic sented also one pair of homologues with a fully het- characters of W. maculata to a phylogenetically derived erochromatic arm (Fig. 3). In W. maculata, species, Hassar wilderi, a member of the Doradinae heterochromatin was mainly telomeric and restricted to (Higuchi 1992). We interpreted these results within the the shorter arms, and heterochromatic blocks were not context of current phylogenetic hypotheses on the evident in 24 chromosomes. One pair of submetacen- evolution of doradids. trics also showed a completely heterochromatic arm, and another pair was characterized by the presence of two interstitial blocks of heterochromatin. Hetero- Material and methods chromatic blocks were apparently more frequent in H. wilderi, which had only six chromosomes without C- Three juvenile specimens of W. maculata were col- bands. The NOR-bearing chromosome pair appeared lected in Berizal (GPS 1538¢ S–41 44¢W), State of associated in the C-banding metaphase. Minas Gerais, in the Pardo River, and four females of H. wilderi were collected in Araguaia River (GPS 1553¢30¢¢ S–5215¢00¢¢ W) (Fig. 1). Voucher W. mac- Discussion ulata and H. wilderi specimens were deposited in the fish collection of the Museu de Zoologia Joa˜o Moojen Karyotypical data on 13 species of doradids indicate de Oliveira, Universidade Federal de Vic¸osa, Vic¸osa, variable diploid numbers, ranging from 2n = 56 (two MG, Brazil, and in the fish collection of the Instituto de species) (Fenocchio et al. 2003; Oliveira and Gosztonyi Cieˆncias e Letras do Me´dio Araguaia, UFMT, Uni- 2000), 2n = 58 (ten species) (Oliveira and Gosztonyi versidade Federal do Mato Grosso, Pontal do Ara- 2000 and present work), and 2n =66 in guaia, MT, Brazil. eigenmanni (Troy and Miyazawa 2000). Assuming

123 Genetica (2007) 130:99–103 101

Fig. 1 Collecting locales in . Left lower inset, H. wilderi collecting locale; right top inset, W. maculata collecting locale

Higuchi’s (1992) hypothesis regarding Wertheimeria,a independent evolution involving gains of heterochro- reduction of diploid number would have occurred matin in at least nine pairs of homologues. Although independently in and (Oliveira our results are the first published C-banding patterns and Gosztonyi 2000), two taxa distantly related in morphological (Higuchi 1992) and molecular (Moyer et al. 2004) data-based hypotheses. Within doradids, number of arms was also informative: W. maculata and H. wilderi’s differences fitted nicely in a putative pericentric inversion process of chromosomal evolu- tion and a consequent change of character state of acrocentrics to the other chromosome classes. How- ever, the family’s diversity is more complex, and even within H. wilderi’s Doradina group, Doras sp. under- went an increase of diploid number apparently asso- ciated to an increase of acrocentrics (Troy and Miyazawa 2000), whereas the remaining Doradina are characterized by less acrocentrics than W. maculata (Veˆnere 1998). One pair of NOR-bearing chromo- somes, a likely generalized character state, has been conserved in W. maculata and in nine other species of Amazonian doradids (reviewed in Veˆnere 1998). C-banding patterns indicated an increase of hetero- Fig. 2 Giemsa-stained karyotypes. 1 Wertheimeria maculata and chromatin in H. wilderi, an apparent result of 2 H. wilderi. Insets: NOR-bearing chromosomes

123 102 Genetica (2007) 130:99–103

number within Pimelodidae, the most derived family within Siluriformes (the ‘‘Pimelodinae’’ of De Pinna 1998). Are those recurrent changes derived from switching on and off involving the same chromosomal regions or do they represent parallel novelties? Al- though major advances regarding fish molecular cyto- genetics and genomics will be necessary for elucidating these chromosomal phenomena in siluriforms, con- vergence and parallelism of diploid numbers suggest the existence in catfishes, of reusable chromosome breakpoints, such as the ones already detected in mammals (e.g. Murphy et al. 2005; Pevzner and Tesler 2003). The resolving power of comparing W. maculata as a sister group of all other doradids underscores the relevance of pericentric inversions as a relevant evo- lutionary mechanism of taxic differentiation within this catfish family. This kind of rearrangements may also be involved in lineage-splitting as well (Noor et al. 2001; Britton-Davidian 2001).

Acknowledgements The authors wish to thank two anonymous reviewers for helpful comments, Silvia G. Pompolo for using her image processing lab, and Claudio Oliveira for allowing access to his Neotropical fish database. Emily Toriani corrected the final English version. This work was partially supported by CNPq, Universidade Federal de Vic¸osa, and Fundac¸a˜o de Amparo a Pesquisa de Mato Grosso/FAPEMAT.

References Fig. 3 C-banding patterns of (a) Wertheimeiria maculata; arrows indicate chromosomes with heterochromatic arms. (b) Hassar wilderi; arrow indicates chromosomes associated through their Britton-Davidian J (2001) How do chromosomal changes fit in? NOR regions. Arrowheads indicate chromosomes with hetero- J Evol Biol 14:872–873 chromatic arms De Pinna MCC (1998) Phylogenetic relationships of Neotropical Siluriformes (Teleostei: Ostariophysi): historical overview and synthesis of hypotheses. In: Malabarba LR, Reis RE, for the family, it seems that chromosomes with whole Vari RP, Lucena ZMS, Lucena CA (eds) Phylogeny and heterochromatic arms are characteristic of doradids. classification of Neotropical fishes. EDIPUCRS, Porto Al- egre, RS, Brazil, pp 279–330 Considering that materials were restricted to juveniles Egozcue J (1971) Te´cnicas em Citogene´tica. Editorial Espaxs, or females, it is likely that part of this variation was due Barcelona, 144 p to the existence of sex chromosome, to be addressed in Fenocchio AS, Pastori MC, Roncati HA, Moreira Filho O, future studies. Bertollo LAC (2003) A cytogenetic survey of the fish fauna from Argentina. Caryologia 56:197–204 The fact that two unrelated doradids recreate the Ferraris Jr CJ, Reis RE (2005) Neotropical catfish diversity: an same diploid number reduction found in many other historical perspective. Neotropical Ichthyol 3:453–454 species in the order remains unresolved. Within the Higuchi H (1992) A phylogeny of South American thorny catf- order Siluriformes, recurrent mutations leading to ishes (Osteichthyes:Siluriformes:Doradidae). D. P. thesis. Harvard University diploid numbers of 54, 56, and 58 comprise the most Howell WM, Black DA (1980) Controlled silver-staining of numerous modal classes across a wide range of families nucleolus organizer regions with a protective colloidal (Oliveira and Gosztonyi 2000) and represent an developer: a 1-step method. Experientia 36:1014–1015 intriguing aspect of the chromosomal evolution of King M (1993) Species evolution: the role of chromosome change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge catfishes. A cytogenetic analysis of three species of Levan A, Fredga K, Sandberg AA (1964) Nomenclature for Diplomystes, a considered to be the sister group centromeric position on chromosomes. Hereditas of all extant siluriforms (Oliveira and Gosztonyi 2000 52:201–220 and references therein) suggested 2n = 56 as the basal Lundberg JG, Littmann MW (2003) Pimelodidae (long-whis- kered catfishes). In: Reis RE, Kullander SO, Ferraris Jr CJ diploid number for the order. Within Siluriformes, (eds) Checklist of the freshwater fishes of South and Central 2n = 56 also characterizes 52 species and it is the modal America. EDIPUCRS, Porto Alegre, Brazil, pp 432–446

123 Genetica (2007) 130:99–103 103

Miranda-Ribeiro A (1911) Fauna Brasiliense. Peixes IV(a). Pevzner P, Tesler G (2003) Human and mouse genomic se- Eleutherobranchios Aspirophoros. Archivos do Museu quences reveal extensive breakpoint reuse in mammalian Nacional do Rio de Janeiro 16:1–504 evolution. Proc Natl Acad Sci 100:7672–7677 Moyer AR, Burr BM, Krajewski C (2004) Phylogenetic rela- Sabaj MH, Ferraris CJ Jr (2003) Family Doradidae (thorny tionships of thorny catfishes (Siluriformes:Doradidae) in- catfishes). In: Reis RE, Kullander SO, Ferraris CJ Jr (eds) ferred from molecular and morphological data. Zool J Linn Checklist of the freshwater fishes of South and Central Soc 140:551–575 America. EDIPUCRS, Porto Alegre, Brazil, pp 45–469 Murphy WJ, Larkin DM, van der Wind AE, Bourque G, Sumner AT (1972) A simple technique for demonstrating cen- Tesler G, Auvil L, Beever JE, Chowdary BP, Galibert F, tromeric heterocromatin. Exp Cell Res 75:304–306 Gatzke L, Hitte C, Meyers SN, Milan D, Ostrander EA, Troy WP, Miyazawa CS (2000) Doras eigenmanni (Siluriformes, Pape G, Parker HG, Raudsepp T, Rogatcheva MB, Doradidae) para o Pantanal – MT, dois cito´ tipos ou duas Schook LB, Skow LC, Welge M, Womack JE, O’Brien SJ, espe´cies? VIII Simpo´ sio de Citogene´tica e Gene´tica de Pevzner PA, Lewin HA (2005) Dynamics of mammalian Peixes, Manaus, Brazil chromosome evolution inferred from multispecies com- Veˆnere PC (1998) Diversificac¸a˜o cariotı´pica em peixes do me´dio parative maps. Science 309:613–617 rio Araguaia, com eˆnfase em Characiformes e Siluriformes Noor MAF, Grams KL, Bertucci LA, Reiland J (2001) Chro- (Teleostei, Ostariophysi). D.Sci. thesis, Universidade Fed- mosomal inversions and the reproductive isolation of eral de Sa˜o Carlos, Brazil species. Proc Natl Acad Sci 98:12084–12088 White MJD (1978) Modes of speciation. W.H Freeman and Oliveira C, Gosztonyi AE (2000) A cytogenetic study of Dip- Company, San Francisco lomystes mesembrinus (Teleostei, Siluriformes, Diplomysti- dae) with a discussion of chromosome evolution in siluriforms. Caryologia 53:31–37

123