The Remuneration of Canadian Writers for Literary Works: a Benchmarking Study

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Remuneration of Canadian Writers for Literary Works: a Benchmarking Study The Remuneration of Canadian Writers for Literary Works: A Benchmarking Study PREPARED FOR SUBMITTED BY The Writers’ Union of Canada (TWUC) Marilyn Burgess and Maria De Rosa Communications MDR Union des écrivaines et des écrivains www.communicationsmdr.com québécois (UNEQ) September 27, 2017 The Remuneration of Canadian Writers for Literary Works Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................................................................... 1 INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................................................................... 3 1. CONTEXT .............................................................................................................................................................................. 3 2. GOALS OF THE STUDY ........................................................................................................................................................ 3 3. APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY ..................................................................................................................................... 3 3.1 Scope of Study .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 3.2 Review of Literature ....................................................................................................................................................... 4 3.3 Key Informant Interviews ............................................................................................................................................. 4 3.4 Development of Remuneration Rates and Terms .............................................................................................. 4 4. STRUCTURE OF THIS REPORT .......................................................................................................................................... 5 I. REMUNERATION OF WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN SELECTED INTERNATIONAL JURISDICTIONS ....................................................................................................................................................... 6 1. REMUNERATION OF WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN THE UNITED KINGDOM ................................................... 6 1.1 Print ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 6 1.2 Digital .................................................................................................................................................................................... 7 2.3 Live Appearances and Events ..................................................................................................................................... 8 2. REMUNERATION OF WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN IRELAND ............................................................................ 9 2.1 Print and Digital ............................................................................................................................................................... 9 2.2 Live Appearances and Events .................................................................................................................................. 10 3. REMUNERATION OF WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN FRANCE ............................................................................ 10 3.1 Print ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 11 3.2 Digital ................................................................................................................................................................................. 12 3.3 Live Appearances and Events .................................................................................................................................. 12 4. REMUNERATION OF WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN AUSTRALIA ...................................................................... 13 4.1 Print ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 13 4.2 Digital ................................................................................................................................................................................. 15 4.3 Live Appearances and Events .................................................................................................................................. 15 5. THE REMUNERATION OF WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN THE UNITED STATES ............................................. 16 5.1 Print ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 17 5.2 Digital ................................................................................................................................................................................. 18 5.3 Live Appearances and Events .................................................................................................................................. 19 6. SUMMARY ANALYSIS AND OBSERVATIONS ................................................................................................................... 19 6.1 Trends Show a Decline in Remuneration for Writers in Selected Jurisdictions ............................... 19 6.2 Advocating for Minimum Standards in the Remuneration of Writers ................................................. 21 6.3 Summary of Remuneration Rates for Print in Selected Jurisdictions ................................................... 22 6.4 Summary of Remuneration Rates for Digital Content in Selected Jurisdictions .............................. 23 6.5 Summary of Remuneration Rates for Live Appearances and Events in Selected Jurisdictions . 23 II. REMUNERATION OF WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN CANADA .............................................. 25 1. THE REMUNERATION OF WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN CANADA ................................................................... 25 1.1 Print ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 25 1.2 Digital ................................................................................................................................................................................. 27 1.3 Live Appearances and Events .................................................................................................................................. 28 2. CURRENT REMUNERATION OF WRITERS IN RELATED SECTORS.............................................................................. 30 2.1 Current Remuneration Rates for Literary Translation and Editing in Canada ............................... 30 1 The Remuneration of Canadian Writers for Literary Works 2.2 Remuneration Rates for Writers Working in Radio and Screen-Based Cultural Industries in Canada ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 31 3. SUMMARY ANALYSIS AND OBSERVATIONS ................................................................................................................... 33 3.1 Royalty Rates for Authors of Printed Books in Canada are Comparable to Rates in Selected International Jurisdictions ............................................................................................................................................... 33 3.2 Rates for Magazine Writing Varies Widely by Jurisdictions ..................................................................... 34 3.3. Canadian eBook Royalty Rates are Comparable to Rates in Selected Jurisdictions ..................... 35 3.4 Rates for Live Appearances are Higher in Other Jurisdictions ................................................................. 36 3.5 Canadian Remuneration Rates for Literary Works Are Lower Than Rates in Related Sectors in Canada ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 37 III. PROPOSED MINIMUM REMUNERATION RATES FOR WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN CANADA .................................................................................................................................................................. 38 1. PROPOSED MINIMUM REMUNERATION RATES AND TERMS FOR WRITERS OF LITERARY WORKS IN PRINT .. 38 2. PROPOSED MINIMUM REMUNERATION RATES AND TERMS FOR WRITERS OF DIGITAL LITERARY WORKS.... 39 3. PROPOSED MINIMUM REMUNERATION RATES AND TERMS FOR WRITERS FOR LIVE APPEARANCES .............. 40 GLOSSARY .............................................................................................................................................................. 41 LIST OF ACRONYMS USED IN THIS REPORT .............................................................................................. 44 BIBLIOGRAPHY ...................................................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • PAPERS DELIVERED at SHARP CONFERENCES to DATE (Alphabetically by Author; Includes Meeting Year)
    PAPERS DELIVERED AT SHARP CONFERENCES TO DATE (alphabetically by author; includes meeting year) Abel, Jonathan. Cutting, molding, covering: media-sensitive suppression in Japan. 2009 Abel, Trudi Johanna. The end of a genre: postal regulations and the dime novel's demise. 1994 ___________________. When the devil came to Washington: Congress, cheap literature, and the struggle to control reading. 1995 Abreu, Márcia Azevedo. Connected by fiction: the presence of the European novel In Brazil. 2013 Absillis, Kevin. Angele Manteau and the Indonesian connection: a remarkable story of Flemish book trade (1958-1962). 2006 ___________. The biggest scam in Flemish literature? On the question of linguistic gatekeeping In literary publishing. 2009 ___________. Pascale Casanova's The World Republic of Letters and the analysis of centre-periphery relations In literary book publishing. 2008 ___________. The printing press and utopia: why imaginary geographies really matter to book history. 2013 Acheson, Katherine O. The Renaissance author in his text. 1994 Acerra, Eleonora. See Louichon, Brigitte (2015) Acres, William. Objet de vertu: Euler's image and the circulation of genius in print, 1740-60. 2011 ____________. A "religious" model for history: John Strype's Reformation, 1660-1735. 2014 ____________, and David Bellhouse. Illustrating Innovation: mathematical books and their frontispieces, 1650-1750. 2009 Aebel, Ian J. Illustrating America: John Ogilby and the geographies of empire in Restoration England. 2013 Agten, Els. Vernacular Bible translation in the Netherlands in the seventeenth century: the debates between Roman Catholic faction and the Jansenists. 2014 Ahokas, Minna. Book history meets history of concepts: approaches to the books of the Enlightenment in eighteenth-century Finland.
    [Show full text]
  • Anempiricaltestofrobertdarnton
    Do Books Cause Revolutions? An Empirical Test of Robert Darnton’s The Forbidden Best-Sellers of Pre-Revolutionary France* Yu Sasaki† This version: March 22, 2020 Preliminary; comments welcome Abstract This article is the first empirical test of Robert Darnton (1995)’s thesis that illegal books clandes- tinely circulated contributed to the French Revolution. The provocative argument has spawned a vibrant industry in historical research but quantitative studies have not been offered. I do so by constructing a new data set that digitizes all 720 illegal works in Darnton’s published corpus. Using the number of émigrés and deaths sentences as my proxies for the Revolution, I show that the diffusion of illegal books has a positive and significant impact on nobles and clergy- men who fled from France but not those who received death sentences. My findings are robust to a host of covariates that could determine diffusion and the two revolutionary outcomes. My analysis implies that an information revolution in which technological progress allows for a fast and inexpensive transmission of information could facilitate a political revolution. *I thank Takayuki Kubouchi for his able research assistance. Financial support from the Joint Usage and Research Center Programs, Institute of Economic Research, Hitotsubashi University (IERPK1917) is gratefully acknowledged. All errors are mine. †Assistant Professor, Waseda Institute for Advanced Study, Waseda University. E-mail: [email protected]. See yusasaki.squarespace.com for the most updated version. Introduction In the spring of 2011, a wave of mass mobilization and regime change in the Middle East and North Africa has made scholars reconsider the causes of political revolution.
    [Show full text]
  • ADBU Study of European Indicators
    Study of European indicators The situation of French university libraries compared with other European countries ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Prepared for ADBU by Eric Anjeaux - | STUDY OF EUROPEAN INDICATORS NEXT BACK TO 2 CHAPTER CONTENTS THE SITUATION OF FRENCH UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES COMPARED WITH OTHER EUROPEAN COUNTRIES Contents 1. Context and objectives of the study . 4 1.1. Context 4 1.2. Objectives 4 2. The initial scope of the study . 4 3. The final scope of the study . 4 3.1. The 13 countries 4 3.2. Notes on the collected data 5 4. Common data . 6 4.1. Constructing the corpus of common data 6 4.2. Common data 6 5. Common indicators . 8 5.1. Constructing the corpus of common indicators 8 5.2. Common indicators 8 5.2.1. Library target population 8 5.2.2. Resources and services: Library adequacy / availability 8 5.2.3. Resources and services: Library use 8 5.2.4. Resources and services: Library efficiency 8 5.2.5. Capacity for evolution and development 9 6. Study limitations . 9 6.1. Countries 9 6.2. Types of university libraries 9 6.3. Data coverage 10 6.4. Data consistency and comparability 10 6.5. Data quality 11 7. Benchmarking . 11 7.1. Students as libraries' target audience 12 7.1.1. A European population increasing slightly, as in France (D0. Population) 12 7.1.2. A growing student population, particularly in France (I0. Number of students (enrolled in the study institutions) / Country population (%)) 13 7.1.3. Changing numbers of academic complicates comparisons 14 7.2.
    [Show full text]
  • WELLESLEY-In-AIX SPRING 2017
    WELLESLEY-in-AIX GUIDE AIX-PARIS (G.A.P.) Photo by Hannah Stiles, Fall 2016 Photo by Nikki Hwa, 2016-17 SPRING 2017 Table of contents Bienvenue à WIA p.2 I. Pre-departure information & arrival in Paris p.3 1. Passport, visas and other documents p.3 2. Insurance p.3 3. Travel arrangements p.4 4. What to pack: some tips p.5 5. Paris pre-session p.6 6. Safety & security p.8 7. Group activities & museum visits p.9 8. Practical information – Paris p.10 II. Practical information - France 1. Calendar & holidays p.13 2. Telling time & making appointments p.13 3. Health matters p.13 4. Personal safety & well-being p.15 5. Drugs, alcohol & French laws p.16 6. Electrical outlets & miscellaneous p.16 7. French newspapers & magazines p.17 8. Tipping p.17 9. Work & internships p.17 10. Recommended reading p.19 11. FAQ p.19 III. Le savoir-vivre en France p.23 IV. Academics – General information p.26 2016-17 calendar p.26 Higher Education & cultural differences p.26 Vocabulary of higher education in France p.28 Aix-Marseille Université (AMU) p.29 French grading system & grade conversion scale p.33 Other academic information p.34 WIA courses p.34 Ensuring your academic success in Aix : advice p.35 Transfer credit and role of the dossier de cours p.36 Extracurricular activities & student life in Aix p.38 WIA &Sciences-Po Aix p.39 Libraries p.40 V. Aix-en-Provence p.41 1. Wellesley-in-Aix Center p.42 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Italian Books and French Medical Libraries in the Renaissance
    Shanti Graheli (St Andrews), Italian Books and French Medical Libraries in the Renaissance This chapter is an analysis of French medical libraries in the Renaissance, and of the role played by Italian books within this social and cultural environment.1 There are a number of reasons for picking these two samples – the French physicians, and the Italian books – and interweaving them into a single discussion. The connections between Italy and France in the early modern period were particularly intense, due to political and cultural reasons. In particular, the unfolding of the Italian Wars (1494-1559) saw a series of campaigns led with the objective of conquering parts of the Italian peninsula that the French monarchs perceived as part of their own heritage, such as Naples and Milan. The result of these contacts was not merely political; the French returned home accompanied by Italian artists and intellectuals, as well as carrying numerous objects such as paintings, sculptures, and books.2 Italo-French exchanges are then added to the quite independent development of the medical discipline at the time. In the sixteenth century, medicine was reconsidering its authorities, its methodological approach and its place in society. Italian humanists played an important role within this development, inasmuch as they contributed new editions of the medical classics, first of all Galen. Concurrently, Italian universities were also highly regarded because of a number of innovative practices they introduced in the medical discipline. In order to undertake this study, all of these aspects had to be taken into account. The materiality of the book, as well as the spatiality of its circulation and the sociality of the exchanges are all indispensable to our understanding of this case study.
    [Show full text]
  • The Institution
    Date : 25/07/2008 Actions for children’s access to reading in France, Africa and the Arab world VIVIANA QUINONES French national Library, Centre for Children’s Literature - La Joie par les livres Paris, France Meeting: 85. Literacy and Reading in co-operation with the Public Libraries and Library Services to Multicultural Populations Simultaneous Interpretation: Not available WORLD LIBRARY AND INFORMATION CONGRESS: 74TH IFLA GENERAL CONFERENCE AND COUNCIL 10-14 August 2008, Québec, Canada http://www.ifla.org/iv/ifla74/index.htm This paper describes how the French National Centre for Children’s Literature – La Joie par les livres works to support children’s access to reading in France as well and in Africa and in the Arab world. The institution La Joie par les livres (“The Joy of reading” : the name is a programme in itself…) was founded in 1962 by a benefactor, Anne Gruner-Schlumberger, and Geneviève Patte who directed it until 2001. The intention was to offer children in a working class neighbourhood a place inspired by the Anglo-Saxon model of public reading : free access to books, readers encouraged to choose books freely, to critical thinking, to autonomy… In a wider sense, the intention was to contribute to the recognition and the development of children’s libraries in France. La Joie par les livres was taken over by the French state in 1972, first by the Ministry of Education, then by the Ministry of Culture. Since January 2008 La Joie par les livres has become part of the Bibliothèque nationale , proving the acknowledgement of the importance of children’s literature in France, and the importance given to children’s reading.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 2, Number 4
    The Library Chronicle Volume 2 Number 4 University of Pennsylvania Library Article 1 Chronicle December 1934 Volume 2, Number 4 Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/librarychronicle Part of the Arts and Humanities Commons, and the Library and Information Science Commons Recommended Citation (1934). Volume 2, Number 4. University of Pennsylvania Library Chronicle: Vol. 2: No. 4. Retrieved from https://repository.upenn.edu/librarychronicle/vol2/iss4/1 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/librarychronicle/vol2/iss4/1 For more information, please contact [email protected]. The University of Pennsylvania LIBRARY CHRONICLE Issued Four Times a Year By and For the Friends of the Library Of the University of Pennsylvania C. Seymour Thompson, Editor Vol. 2 No. 4 December, 1934 SHAKESPEARE AND BIOGRAPHY By Dr. Felix E. Schelling 1 A good many years ago a book which I had written at- tained the honor of a review at the hands of no less a person- age than the late Andrew Lang, whom to designate even to a younger generation would be an affront. My book was con- cerned with a more or less complete account of the writings in prose, verse, and drama during the lifetime of Shakespeare, and Mr. Lang made himself very merry by a devastating pleasantry to the effect that this book is made up of an account of a great many authors of whom everybody has already heard quite enough, and of a great many more of whom no- body has ever heard or even wished to hear.
    [Show full text]
  • '68 and the ›Radical Revolution‹ in French Children's Books
    The Publishers’ Spring? May ’68 and the ›Radical Revolution‹ in French Children’s Books Sophie Heywood To cite this version: Sophie Heywood. The Publishers’ Spring? May ’68 and the ›Radical Revolution‹ in French Chil- dren’s Books. Jahrbuch der Gesellschaft für Kinder- und Jugendliteraturforschung 2018, 2018, 10.23795/JahrbuchGKJF2018-. hal-02537047 HAL Id: hal-02537047 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02537047 Submitted on 15 Apr 2020 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. jahrbuch der gesellschaft für kinder- und jugendliteratur- forschung | gkjf 2018 beiträge | Jahrbuch der GKJF 2018 | thema: 1968 The Publishers’ Spring? May ’68 and the ›Radical Revolution‹ in French Children’s Books sophie heywood The years around May ’68 (c. 1965 – c. late-1970s) are widely understood to represent a watershed moment for children’s books in France. An important factor was the influ- ence of a new fringe of avant-garde publishers that attracted attention across their trade in and beyond France. Using archives and interviews and accounts of some of the books produced and their reception, this article presents case studies of the most influential publishing houses as a series of three snapshots of the areas of movement in the field.
    [Show full text]
  • No. 180 Mark Curran, the French Book Trade In
    H-France Review Volume 19 (2019) Page 1 H-France Review Vol. 19 (September 2019), No. 180 Mark Curran, The French Book Trade in Enlightenment Europe I: Selling Enlightenment. London: Bloomsbury, 2018. 231 pp. Illustrations, maps, charts. £110.00 U.K. (hb). ISBN: 9781441178909; Simon Burrows, The French Book Trade in Enlightenment Europe II: Enlightenment Bestsellers. London: Bloomsbury, 2018. xvi + 254 pp. Illustrations, maps, charts. £110.00 U.K. (hb). ISBN: 9781441126016. Review by Geoffrey Turnosvky, University of Washington. When the June 1784 “Acte de Cautionnement” put a plan in motion for dissolving the Société typographique de Neuchâtel, the end of a tumultuous and unsuccessful fifteen-year run in the book trade was in sight, though it would take another ten years to fully dismantle the enterprise. The print shop/wholesaler was founded in 1769 by its three directors, Jean-Elie Bertrand, Frédéric-Samuel Ostervald, and Samuel Fauche, who gave the operation the lofty and fashionable name of société (though they were its only members) and who ambitiously reached out to bookdealers across Europe in search of clients. But the STN was never able to establish the stability it sought. Its outreach was mostly rebuffed, and it lurched from one business model to the next based on the vagaries of the market, on shifting politics, and on the particularities of its geographic situation. It built up an enormous stock, though this spoke to its struggles to sell its wares more than to its success. An inventory from June 1786 recorded 1,805,427 unwanted sheets needing to be liquidated (the printed feuille was the basic unit by which a book’s price was determined).
    [Show full text]
  • E-Book Lending in Libraries
    E-books Lending in Libraries, legal obstacles and opportunities INCONECSS, Berlin 19 April 2016 Michel Fraysse [email protected] Is there a right to e-read ? The legal landscape The « resistance » against e-books and e-reading How to promote e-reading Legal perspectives for the future 22/04/2016 2 Is there a right to e-read ? In 2013, The Eblida (European Bureau of Library, Information and Documentation Associations) launched a right to e-read campaign : « European citizens have the right to e-read ! They should benefit from this right in libraries. It should therefore be possible for libraries to legally lend e-books ». «We need an updated, modern copyright framework ! “ In 2014, IFLA launched an eLending background paper, with a set of guiding principles on copyright, e-lending and definition of ebooks, “A library must have the right to license and/or purchase any commercially available eBook without embargo » 22/04/2016 3 The legal landscape behind the curtain Is there really « a right to e-read » ? Do copyright laws recognize the right to e-read and e-lending ? The legal answer is NO (at the moment…) What are the main legal obstacles ? 22/04/2016 4 The 2 main legal obstacles 1 There is no « right to publish » on digital format The « Milan Kundera anguish » : Milan Kundera contractually forbids e-version of his novels (see http://www.complete-review.com/saloon/archive/201207b.htm#ct1 and http://www.franceculture.fr/emissions/repliques/le-livre-son-passe-son-avenir ) Mr X. Professor of Law at Toulouse 1 Capitole university « I’ll never let my publisher sell an electronic version of my book unless you demonstrate I won’t lose money with the sales of the printed version » 2 There is no legal obligation to offer e-lending even if the e-book version is available for sale Compare with print books : in France, a 2003 Act (« loi ») on print books lending (Transposal of European Directive 19 November 1992) but nothing for ebooks According to this « loi », an author cannot contest the loan of his books by a lending library.
    [Show full text]
  • PDF 1.0 As Well As Ambassadors of the Book.”
    July 2012 The image cannot be displayed. Your computer may not have enough memory to open the image, or the image may have been corrupted. Restart your computer, and then open the file again. If the red x still appears, you may have to delete the image and then insert it again. Rare Books and Manuscripts Section N e w s l e t t e r Section's Homepage: http://www.ifla.org/en/rare-books-and-manuscripts Contents News 2 In Memoriam – Richard Landon 3 2012 Annual Meeting in Helsinki 4 Upcoming Meetings/Conferences 6 Conference Reports 9 From the Libraries 15 Exhibitions 26 Publications 39 Online Collections and Projects 40 Cooperation 44 People 46 IFLA Rare Books and Manuscripts Section Newsletter / July 2012 / Page 1 News Section Holds Midterm Working Meeting in Antwerp The Rare Books and Manuscripts Section held a one-day business meeting in Antwerp on 3 February 2012 to discuss digitization guidelines, strategic plan, and a satellite meeting in 2013. Pictured here taking refuge from an intense snow storm are (left to right): Isabel Garcia-Monge (Spanish Bibliographical Heritage Union Catalogue), Raphaële Mouren (ENSSIB Ecole nationale supérieure des sciences de l'information et des bibliothèques), Edwin C. Schroeder (Beinecke Rare Book & Manuscript Library, Yale University), Wolfgang-Valentin Ikas (Bayerische Staatsbibliothek), Krister Östlund (Uppsala University Library), Garrelt Verhoeven (University of Amsterdam), and Sirkka Havu (National Library of Finland). Sirkka Havu is hosting an all-day session at the National Library of Finland on Monday, 13 August, on “Marketing Rare and Special Collections in a Digital Age.” (See p.
    [Show full text]
  • Diplomatic, Political, Educational and Military Connections Existed Between Scots, Scotland and the Rest of Europe
    SCOTTISH TRAVELLERS ABROAD, 1660-1688 Diplomatic, political, educational and military connections existed between Scots, Scotland and the rest of Europe. This paper concentrates on the connections fostered between Scots and the European continent by travel. A great number of young gentlemen travellers left the British isles to travel abroad during the reigns of Charles II and James II. Young British gentlemen travelled for many and varied reasons. Many travelled for their education, often in company with a tutor. Rarely did a Briton travel in an area totally lacking in support networks of friends and social contacts; continental Europe was awash with members of Britain's ruling elite who travelled together or formed enclaves in almost every major town and city throughout western Europe. Much has been written on the subject of the British tourist abroad. By 'British' most scholars have meant 'English'. Where discussions of Scots have occurred these have usually been as an adjunct to, or an extension of, constructs associated with the English travel experience. Similarly, so great an emphasis has been placed upon the 'Grand Tour' of the eighteenth century that the travelling networks and experiences of the late seventeenth century have often been treated as a mere preamble to the better established routes of the following century. The disposition and personality of Scottish travellers in this period ranged from the strongly anti-English, pro-French Walter Scot, Earl of Tarras, to the anglophile James Douglas Hamilton, Earl of Arran. Scottish travellers were exclusively male, though many Scottish women lived abroad on a permanent basis. I Whatever their proclivities it was the duty and pleasure of all young noblemen to traveJ.2 The appeal of travel was further increased by the fact that Scots, all over the European continent, had little trouble finding co-religionists and other Britons of comparable social status wherever they travelled.
    [Show full text]