CAUTION: This Email Originated Outside Our Organization; Please Use Caution

From: Alexis Gonzalez To: Debra Black Subject: George Floyd Date: Saturday, June 20, 2020 1:16:14 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Alexis Gonzalez, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 15 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

3. Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because as a woman of color, I experienced racial bias on a frequent basis. I’ve been told to “go back to my country”, despite the fact that I was born in this country. I’ve been told to “speak english because I’m in America”, when people hear me speak in Spanish. Although I am not African American, I can understand on a very personal level the consequences of discrimination and the pain of racial injustice.

Sincerely, Alexis Gonzalez

Sent from my iPhone From: Ally & Andre Vega To: [email protected]; Denis Bertone; Debra Black; Emmett Badar; Eric Weber; John Ebiner; publiccomments; Ryan Vienna Subject: Equality for all in San Dimas Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 9:00:53 PM Attachments: Ally and Andre 1.png

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: Our names are Ally and Andre Vega, and we have been a resident and business owner in San Dimas for the last 5 years. We would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. We support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

We support this resolution because everyone should feel safe and represented in this community no matter which race or background that you come from.

As members of the San Dimas community, we call on you, our leaders, to represent the values of our community and take a stand for justice. Please include our comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration. 1. Sincerely, Ally and Andre Vega --

From: AM Lee To: Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Social Responsibility towards our Community in regards to racism Date: Sunday, June 21, 2020 12:24:44 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Amanda Lee, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for almost 10 years now. My family and I were actually so happy that we found a house in this city because we quite enjoyed the atmosphere, the local businesses, and many of the city events. My family would currently like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

Why is something that happened in another State important for our quiet little town in California? Floyd’s death among many other that have happened has resonated not only throughout the United States, but around the world. It is very important that WE as a community acknowledge that racism is still rampant but also that we CAN fight it and correct such behavior and make a better world for everyone. I would like to live in a community where my Brother-In-Law doesn’t feel the need to have me meet him at his car before entering my house because he is afraid a neighbor might call the cops.

I am going to be quite frank - I have become quite alarmed with some of the comments made by fellow city residents and even business owners over the past few months. From flat out hateful comments online to hurtful ignorance, I fear for our communities social health. Already I have seen more and more residents showing off their confederate flags or taking a stance against POC right within my neighborhood here in Old Town San Dimas. I personally grew up in a predominately white community near Yosemite where we had our own KKK group - seeing this flag was a common thing as members often used it to signify their status. Seeing this flag within my current community is NOT something I ever wanted to experience again. I am afraid of these neighbors retaliating against me for supporting BLM or having a different opinion. I am even sometimes scared to have my kids out for a walk when they neighbors are hanging out in their front yard. I am scared for my Brother-in-law when he comes for a visit, or my beautiful little niece.

We are seeing a shift in population in regards to ethnicity and culture without our community over the past 10 years and it is beautiful. More Korean families and business owners have moved into our beautiful city, Indian families, Taiwanese families - many seeking more open spaces and quieter neighborhoods away from the hub-bub of area’s closer to down town LA. Our fabulous school district also draws some amazing families into the area along with a variety of churches and faiths available locally. Our city has so much to offer, I would hate to see our city slandered and besmirched by hate and our lack of response to such things. It is so important to support our community in these times by acknowledging that we SEE and HEAR these stories and are not trying to pass them off as something that would never happen here. I ask that our city please, PLEASE consider the fact that so many of your residents are looking to you for guidance.

Sincerely, Amanda Lee W. 2nd Street, San Dimas CA 91773 From: Ryan Vienna To: AM Lee Cc: publiccomments; Jeff M. Malawy; Debra Black; Emmett Badar Subject: Re: ACTION NEEDED: Racial Injustices Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 12:25:44 AM

Amanda,

Thank you for clarifying.

Ryan A. Vienna Mayor Pro Tem City of San Dimas

From: AM Lee Sent: Monday, June 22, 2020 12:24 AM To: Ryan Vienna Subject: Re: ACTION NEEDED: Racial Injustices

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

This post was made in San Dimas Buzz on Facebook by a resident (not the Council Member Ryan Vienna). It sparked outrage among many of us but sadly also showed that many residents were willing to disregard this hate message as something that wasn’t worth getting upset about.

Amanda Lee

On Mon, Jun 22, 2020 at 12:19 AM Ryan Vienna wrote: Amanda,

Please clarify the screen shot that reads “Ryan’s Post”. Ryan who?

Thanks,

Ryan A. Vienna Mayor Pro Tem City of San Dimas

From: AM Lee Sent: Monday, June 22, 2020 12:13 AM To: Brad McKinney; Denis Bertone; Debra Black; Emmett Badar; Eric Weber; John Ebiner; publiccomments; Ryan Vienna Subject: ACTION NEEDED: Racial Injustices

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution. Dear Mayor Badar and City Council,

It has come to the communities attention that some changes have occurred in regards to a proposal that has been set forth in regards to our Cities response to the current events. Not only one proposal, but a third.

Having read all three proposals thoroughly I must say I, a resident of San Dimas for the past 10 years, am quite taken aback.

A few things: 1. The current events and social demand for change is so much MORE than Floyd’s death. He is the catalyst that has caused all of use to watch in horror as the unthinkable has happened. No longer can we turn our heads and say “well what happened before?” Or “They were afraid for their lives, so they responded.” This is NOT political, this is NOT new, this is NOT isolated.

Let’s say that again - this is NOT ISOLATED. The fact that Council Member Vienna has alluded to this not being a problem for our “sleepy town” is absolutely outrageous. This tells me that one is either turning their head the other way or they are not watching what is actually happening. Either option is not in the best interest of our city and it’s citizens.

2. Racism... Xenophobia... Hate... To assume this does not exist in our community is, quite frankly, absurd. NextDoor and Facebook Groups are full of fellow residents that are spewing hateful comments and backwards attitudes. Some justify the use of hateful terms and images, others state “it isn’t a big deal”. Did you know that KKK was carved into the sidewalk at a local park right here in our city? (Images attached below). Did you know several residents are freely hanging and displaying their confederate flag? Others are ripping down BLM posters and signage that are staked on private property. To assume this hate doesn’t touch our city is ignorant and harmful. To take this stance clearly states that this hate and such actions are acceptable and “no big deal”. Is this what our city represents?

3. The fact that Council Member Vienna chose to switch the proposal completely to support police officers, their actions, and the system as a whole as opposed to confronting the social injustices that are happening not only throughout the USA, but right here in Los Angeles County AND our sleepy town of San Dimas is quite upsetting. This proposal is meant to assure residents that the city hears them and their fears. It is meant to assure the residents that the City has their best interest at heart.

It would seem that perhaps Vienna should excuse himself from this case as his interests are conflicted - that is, he has a duty to represent the LAC Sheriff Department in this situation and NOT the city. This has become quite apparent with his unexpected proposal change.

As a resident of San Dimas I am saddened that our City Council is choosing to ignore racism, pretend it isn’t a problem, excuse it as another persons problem. I moved from an area with an active (and proud) KKK group. I refused to move back or even buy vacation property there because of this. My family (mixed race) and my sisters family (also mixed race) can only visit with fear and worry for our family and children. I can only hope this is not how I must also feel in this town.

Sincerely, Amanda Lee San Dimas City Resident

IMAGES

From: AM Lee To: Brad McKinney; Denis Bertone; Debra Black; Emmett Badar; Eric Weber; John Ebiner; publiccomments; Ryan Vienna Subject: ACTION NEEDED: Racial Injustices Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 12:13:33 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and City Council,

Having read all three proposals thoroughly I must say I, a resident of San Dimas for the past 10 years, am quite taken aback.

Sincerely, Amanda Lee San Dimas City Resident

IMAGES

From: Amy Torres To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: San Dimas MUST adopt a resolution condemning the killing of George Floyd, and denouce racism and injustice. Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 6:01:42 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

My name is Amy Torres, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for nearly 25 years, and an employee of Bonita Unified School District for well over 10 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I think that crimes against people of color have persisted for too long. It is outrageous that people fear for their lives just because of the color of their skin. It is time to take an ANTI-RACISM stance.

“I vehemently oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd’s memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue.”

Sincerely,

Amy Torres From: ana benitez To: Debra Black Subject: Please adopt resolution against racism Date: Sunday, June 21, 2020 10:07:23 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Ana Benitez and I have been a resident in San Dimas for4 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I myself have had some racist experiences in this city. I think it’s time to tackle this issue in this city because it happens more than most community members care to admit. I also think we are all entitled to live in a safe environment in which we are not looked down for our background, skin color, and cultures.

Sincerely, Ana Benitez

Sent from my iPhone From: ana benitez To: Debra Black Subject: Oppose resolution from councilmembers Vienna and Weber Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 1:21:15 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

I vehemently oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, blatantly disrespects George Floyd’s memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue through an exercise that was meant to bring unity for all people in San Dimas. This resolution dismisses what the minority and Black community has expressed about San Dimas. It is not the moment to make this about supporting the police. It’s the moment to support our community that is in need.

Sincerely, Ana Benitez

Sent from my iPhone From: Angie To: Eric Weber; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Emmett Badar; Debra Black Cc: Ryan Vienna Subject: John Ebiner’s resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 1:48:21 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

I have been a resident of San Dimas for 21 years.

I would like to see our city take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feels safe and the first step would be adopting the resolution proposed by councilmember John Ebiner which condemns the killing of George Floyd (by specifically putting his name in the resolution) and denouncing racism and injustice at the city Council meeting on June 23, 2020.

I support this resolution because I want to know the city I live in stands up for basic human rights for all citizens.

In the words of Bobby Kennedy from the speech he gave the night Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated, in 1968, the year I was born, “what we need in the United States is not violence and lawlessness but is is love and wisdom and compassion for toward another-a feeling of justice to those who still suffer within our country whether they be white or black... the vast majority of white people and the vast majority of black people in this country want to live together; want to improve the quality of their life and want justice for all human beings that abide in our land.”

As a member of the San Dimas community I call on you, the elected city officials to represent the values of our community. and take a stand for justice.

Please include my comments for the record.

Thank you for your consideration and attention to this matter.

Sincerely, Angela Torres

From: Angie Wilson To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black Subject: Resolution Proposed by Council Member Ebiner Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 1:09:10 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Angie Wilson, and I have been a resident and business owner in San Dimas for 15years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because my husband and I have been stopped randomly with no reason given as to why the stop was made over the years. We have recently started a family and am gravely concerned on what will happen to my boy when he grows...will he be subject to this kind of behavior? Should I start potty training my child and train him on how to respond when he gets stopped by a police officer?

Sincerely, Angie Wilson Owner of D & A Wilson Consulting Services Inc. From: anthony vasquez To: Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; [email protected]; publiccomments; Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Debra Black Subject: Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 11:41:41 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Anthony Vasquez, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 5 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice. 2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas. 3. Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program. 4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

Important: I support this resolution because it’s important to acknowledge those in our community that feel they don’t have a voice.

I strongly oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it fails to acknowledge George Floyd’s tragic death, disrespects our community and undermines the process agreed upon by our City Council and encourages further division on an issue that was supposed to bring us together. Invitations to discuss these incidences over coffee is not enough.

Sincerely, Anthony Vasquez

Sent from my iPhone From: telic1bjl To: publiccomments; Debra Black; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; BettyJean Lamb Cc: BJ Lamb Subject: Proposed Resolution: RESOLUTION 2020-XX A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN DIMAS, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, CALLING FOR UNITY, DIALOGUE, AND ACTION TO ABOLISH RACISM, WHEREVER IT MAY EXIST, AND TO ENSURE JUSTICE AND RESPECT FOR ALL MEMBER... Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 4:49:31 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

1. I fully support Councilman John Ebiner's resolution & its contents because I think it is extremely important to name George Floyd instead of taking away his name, thereby dehumanizing & marginalizing him as Councilmembers Ryan Vienna & Eric Weber have done in their draft resolutions.

I also think it is important that the city take appropriate action to combat racism here by establishing a civilian commission or committee to listen to & deal with the race issue specifically as it relates to The City of San Dimas, & work with City Council, the city's Public Safety Commission, & the San Dimas station of the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department.

Real action rather than just words is critical to making significant change & improving the lives of people of color in our city. Councilman Ebiner's proposed resolution does that.

I do, however, wish the resolution had gone further in condemning police brutality, & ingrained racism in police departments, & banned the use of weapons of war such as CS tear gas by law enforcement in our city.

2. I totally oppose Councilman Vienna's version of the resolution because it is so watered down & gives preference to police over civilians as to be meaningless & does not call for meaningful & specific actions to improve race relations in The City of San Dimas.

Simply saying all residents of the city should strive to be color blind is nice & touchy feely but actually does nothing.

As I read it Councilman Vienna's proposed resolution is also more concerned with the resultant peaceful black lives matter protests, riots & looting, & police officers who were hurt than in actually addressing the root cause issue of racism in law enforcement agencies & in the City of San Dimas or as opposed to condemning the police brutality that caused George Floyd's death, or was used here by LAPD & LASD in trying to control the protests by use of excessive force in which a reporter on the scene was blinded by rubber bullets. That councilmembers should never have happened either yet has been going on since I was a college student at UCLA, UC Berkley, & Kent State in the 1970s. Enough is enough!

Sincerely:

Betty-Jean Lamb

Resident, Via Verde, The City of San Dimas

From: Bianca Mota To: Brad McKinney; Denis Bertone; Debra Black; Emmett Badar; Eric Weber; John Ebiner; [email protected]; Ryan Vienna Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 10:56:16 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Bianca Mota, and I have been a resident of Covina for 3 years. My husband worked in San Dimas at Trader Joe’s for 11 years. I would like to see the City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because black men and women have been systematically oppressed for too long. They need to know that their city stands behind them. They need to know that you feel, too, that Black Lives Matter. It is time we all take a stand in defense of our black brothers and sisters. It is time that we truly fight for equality. It is time we acknowledge that racism still exists. It is time that we fight for justice and we must stand on the right side of history.

Sincerely,

Bianca Mota From: Billie Lopez To: Emmett Badar Cc: Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Councilmember Ebiner"s Resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 8:16:31 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Billie Lopez, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 17 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because we are experiencing a time in history where every voice, every small town like San Dimas has an opportunity and responsibility to stand up against the systemic racism that is still so prevalent today.

I strongly oppose Councilmember Vienna's proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd's memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue.

Sincerely, Billie Lopez From: [email protected] To: Ryan Vienna Cc: publiccomments Subject: Fwd: Draft Resolutions Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 3:20:35 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

-----Original Message----- To: [email protected] Cc: [email protected] ; [email protected] Sent: Mon, Jun 22, 2020 3:03 pm Subject: Draft Resolutions

Dear Councilman Vienna:

On Saturday, June 20,2020, Jean and I read the draft resolutions written by Councilman Eric Weber and Councilman John Ebiner contained in the City agenda in the supporting information for the Council meeting on Tuesday, June 23. On Monday, June 22,2020, we read an additional draft resolution on Facebook by Councilman Ryan Vienna. We thank all three councilman for their time and efforts in drafting these resolutions.

Of the two draft resolutions on Saturday, we felt John Ebiner's was more strident in tone than the draft resolution submitted by Eric Weber. On Monday, we read the draft resolution by Ryan Vienna. We felt Ryan Vienna took meaningful parts of both draft resolutions and added more specific details.

As a result of reading all three draft resolutions, we are supportive of the draft resolution written by Ryan Vienna.

Respectfully,

Bob and Jean Olander From: Brian Birmingham To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Support for Council member Ebiner"s Resolution Proposal Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 12:20:13 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Brian Birmingham and I have recently become a resident of San Dimas. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because it is critical for all governments - local, state, and federal - to change the status quo for the better. This resolution is an essential step in the right direction in the fight against racial inequality and injustice.

Sincerely, Brian Birmingham From: Brittany Allison To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Public Comment re: Resolutions on San Dimas’ response to the killing of George Floyd Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 1:03:11 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Brittany Allison, and I have been a resident in various cities of East San Gabriel Valley my entire life. My family and I spend time in San Dimas, we patronize the business of San Dimas, we have friends and family that live in San Dimas. I care deeply about the success of San Dimas and the ability for those who reside in San Dimas to thrive. I would like to see the City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe and heard by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. In order for a resolution to actually mean anything to the black community and those that are care to see a more just society, it must specifically:

1. Name “George Floyd” and condemn his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice. Calling this killing a “tragic death” or stating that the officers “appear” to have used excessive force is offensive to the community, as it should be to members of law enforcement that hold any sense of loyalty or service to the community they serve. 2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas. I have seen it. My friends have seen it. Claiming otherwise is denying the truth that too many live daily. 3. Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program. 4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely. Attempting to conflate these issues is a clear and deliberate attempt to minimize the harm that we all saw in the video of George Floyd being killed while others stood by.

I support this resolution because it shows San Dimas council is willing to see that this is an issue of humanity, not politics, and that calling for citizens to get involved, as in a citizens review board, is an expression of how democracy should function.

I implore you to support the resolution as written by Councilmember Ebiner and to oppose the resolutions written by Councilmember Vienna and Councilmember Weber, as the latter two fail to support and empower the members of the San Dimas community that have been disenfranchised for far too long.

You have a chance now to take a stand for justice, to take the first step towards an equitable, just, and welcoming community. Please include my comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely, Brittany Allison From: Caitlin Malone To: publiccomments Subject: San Dimas resident Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 4:42:46 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Caitlin Lopez, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 3 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate

I support this resolution because I am a mother and never want someone’s child to be mistreated for the color of their skin. I can not imagine fearing my sons life for just walking down the street in a hoodie

Sincerely,

Caitlin Lopez

From: Chloe Jones To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Resolution Support Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 3:22:45 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Chloë Jones, and I have been a resident and student in San Dimas for 5 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely. From: Chris Dettmar To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: In support of Councilmember Ebiner"s proposal Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 10:28:02 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Chris Dettmar, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 3 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically 1. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

2. Creates a Civilian Review Board, with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program.

3. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I have not had to struggle with the systemic racial issue my friends and colleagues that are people of color have. I acknowledge that I have my own unintentional racial biases just like everyone else. We all must realize as a city that everyone has these biases, and only through collective review from a diverse community can we ensure that the biases of the individuals do not lead to systemic biases and racism in our community services. George Floyd is not unique, this was not an isolated incident. Minniapolis is not unique, similar systemic biases exist everywhere in our country, including here.

I also oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it shifts focus away from the systemic issues we wish to address and onto the marginalized individuals who are justifiably angry at generations of being ignored and abused by the people whose duty it is to protect and serve them.

Sincerely, Christopher Dettmar From: Christian Hartnett To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: JUSTICE FOR GEORGE FLOYD/City Coucil resolution Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 9:02:55 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Christian Hartnett, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for over 20 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I truly believe it is an important piece, however small, in the large, complicated puzzle to solve systemic racism and the harm it has inflicted on our society for hundreds of years.

I also oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it downplays the role of systemic racism in our country and does nothing to heal the pain from this issue.

Sincerely,

Christian Hartnett From: Christine Parra To: Ryan Vienna Cc: publiccomments Subject: Resolution Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 5:20:13 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Hello Councilmember Vienna - here are my thoughts, though you probably don't need any more at this point. That Facebook post was a bit rough. Sad that people can no longer write without sarcasm and vitriol.

I've compared all 3 versions and have the following comments:

The document makes more sense with George Floyd's name in it. I will not accuse you of the things that folks on Facebook were for removing it; I'm sure you had a valid reason. But it does read better, and if the purpose of the document is to assuage the community, it makes sense. I prefer your first paragraph to the others if you add his name. In your second paragraph, the words "appears to be" are an understatement. It was truly an excess of force. I do like that you added the bit about the other officers that didn't intervene - the other 2 versions didn't include that. It would seem that the next few paragraphs were brought up to move on to the next point, which is that everyone is entitled to protection under the law. While I totally agree with you on this point, and it certainly makes sense with the title of the resolution which along with wanting to abolish racism also wants to ensure justice and respect for ALL members of our community, it might not be well received. I am truly torn about this point, because your words make perfect sense with the title and I absolutely feel that the riots and deaths that followed George Floyd's murder were completely unfair to the rest of the communities affected by those acts of violence. But it seems the wrong time to bring this up. I would leave out the paragraph about the support for our dedicated law enforcement personnel - though I totally agree it is not mutually exclusive to support everyone, it again seems like the wrong time to include this paragraph. I love the paragraph about "racism, hate, prejudice and violence in all its forms..." Because truly, one can be prejudiced in so many other ways besides racism. Great wording. I do like Councilman Weber's Section 1 - I feel that it's important to specifically say you denounce the actions that caused George Floyd's death. I like your section 1, but think it should be section 2. Your section 2 is good, but I like that the other 2 versions include the language "the city council will assist in..." It shows your endorsement and involvement of the process you are putting forth in section 2.

I honestly don't think a resolution will do anything to reduce racism anywhere in the city, state or planet, but if the city council feels that it's necessary to make a public statement decrying racism, then I get it. However, this is a matter of the darkness of human hearts, and no resolution by any city will help that, or racism would be eradicated by now. Only God can change a heart. Let's pray he does a lot of that soon. I hope my thoughts were helpful to you.

Sincerely, Christine Parra From: [email protected] To: Debra Black Subject: In support of councilman Ebiner"s resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 2:22:41 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

I have been a resident of San Dimas for 19 years.

I support this resolution because I want to know the city I live in stands up for basic human rights for all citizens.

As a member of the San Dimas community I call on you, the elected city officials to represent the values of our community. and take a stand for justice.

Please include my comments for the record.

Thank you for your consideration and attention to this matter.

Sincerely, Christopher Torres From: Emmett Badar To: Cristina Stables; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments; Ryan Vienna Subject: Re: Support - Ebiner Resolution on June 23 Date: Saturday, June 20, 2020 6:00:30 PM

Ms. Stables, thank you for your caring about your community. As you are aware the city council will be discussing a possible proclamation dealing with the disturbing crisis that our nation is faced with during this time of our history. I will ensure that your email is entered into the official record. Thanks once again for caring about your community. Emmett Badar Mayor

Sent from my iPhone City of San Dimas

From: Cristina Stables Sent: Saturday, June 20, 2020 1:14:43 PM To: Emmett Badar ; John Ebiner ; Eric Weber ; Brad McKinney ; Debra Black ; publiccomments ; Ryan Vienna Subject: Support - Ebiner Resolution on June 23

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Maria Cristina Stables and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 45 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I'm a dark skinned Mexican American woman and despite raising my daughter in San Dimas who attended Ekstrand, Lone Hill and San Dimas High School, I've frequently been treated differently or less than due to my skin color and/or my heavy accent that I still have to this day. And, yes I've even experienced this in the halls and at the service desks of City Hall and in our great city too. We can be better than this. This is our moment. This is your moment as a council. As a member of the San Dimas community, I call on you, our leaders, to represent the values of our community and take a stand for justice. Please include my comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely,

Maria Cristina Stables

196 W Via Vaquero From: Crystal Jones To: Emmett Badar; publiccomments Cc: [email protected]; Denis Bertone; [email protected]; John Ebiner; Debra Black; Brad McKinney Subject: Resolution Denouncing Racism & Murder of George Floyd Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 12:22:42 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Crystal Jones-Bacon, and I have been a resident of the City of San Dimas for five years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Eibner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

1. Specifically names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers.

2. Confirms that the death of George Floyd has been universally acknowledged as wrong and in that recognition, it has caused the revisiting/dialogues regarding racial injustices which remain within our country and our City of San Dimas.

3. Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could serve to assist in policy recommendations, a sounding board for community safety concerns not brought to current committees and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program.

4. Does NOT address looting, rioting or violence against police officers. While we do understand and wholeheartedly believe that such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner because this resolution truly takes into account the voices of the many community members whom Mr. Ebiner spoke with to garner a true perspective of the community. While I understand that this/no resolution is truly the fix for any amounts of trauma which have occurred within our city and experienced by people of color, this resolution is a statement that the city truly sees, hears and will be working further to understand the experiences of its residents and voting constituents.

Further, it is at times like these, when the tides begin to change, that we as Americans must all take time to reevaluate ourselves and discern any faults/contributions which we may be responsible for. It is in these times that I stop to ask myself and your council to consider in the decades to come what your children, grandchildren and their children will speak of when they discuss which side of history you have voted on. I am reminded of President Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address when he stated “that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom -- and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.” With this we understand that freedom is only a notion if it is notequal for all.

Additionally, I am disappointed in the resolution which has been drafted and presented by Councilmember Ryan Vienna. While I had also hoped that a singular resolution could be drafted, it was disheartening to see Mr. Vienna agree to have a sub-committee appointed then circumvent the process and later present his own resolution. I am new to the City Council and its workings and while I am not sure of the “normal” process this just appeared to be not really the best idea. While I do understand that we are all approaching this situation with our own internal beliefs and backgrounds, I just do not feel that this resolution truly reflects the residents and truly diverse community of San Dimas. I do understand though and am sorry that Mr. Vienna, may have not understood how hurtful and offensive his resolution draft would be to us, the people of color within the city limits. This resolution further causes excessive division amongst the residents when the sole purpose of the resolution was to acknowledge and bring people together, not add fuel to a fire as it was never our intention to make this an issue against any peace offices.

As a member of the San Dimas community, I call on you, our elected leaders, to truly hear the requests of your residents and to represent the values of our community, but beyond that I call on you all to say enough is enough and stand on the side of true justice. Please include my comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely,

Crystal D. Jones-Bacon From: David Estrada To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: City Council Meeting Agenda Item 5c: My Support of Resolution Proposed by Councilmember John Ebiner Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 3:57:14 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

June 20, 2020

RE: City Council Meeting of June 23, 2020 Agenda Item 5c. My Support of Resolution Proposed by Councilmember John Ebiner

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is DAVID ESTRADA, and I have been a resident of San Dimas for 40 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember John Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020 (Agenda Item: 5c). I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

I support this resolution as part of our solidarity with all those who are outraged with the brutal murder of George Floyd and with all those who are supporting the efforts being waged to advance equality and multi-racial unity. In this context, the responses to the killing of Floyd have not just been about his unjust murder but are the result of years of racial and economic disparities.

As members of the San Dimas community, I call on this council to represent the values of our community and to take a stand for justice. Please include my comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely

David Estrada 1360 Eaton Rd. San Dimas, CA 91773

Copies:

Mayor Emmett Badar: [email protected] Mayor Pro Tem Ryan Vienna: [email protected] Councilmember Denis Bertone: [email protected] Councilmember John Ebiner: [email protected] Councilmember Eric Weber: [email protected] City Manager: [email protected] City Clerk: [email protected] Public Comments: [email protected] From: Arringtondm To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: resolution Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 6:29:51 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Dorothy Arrington, and I have been a parent of a student in San Dimas for 10 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Council member Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because my children have attended the Bonita Unified school district for over 10 years and have experienced first hand racism. From being called nigger, from their peers to teachers being complicit in allowing the students behavior by saying oh "they didn't really mean that". Teachers themselves making crude comments for the sake of humor. San Dimas high in particular needs sensitivity training as well as implicit bias training. Staff and students alike are raised in a community that allows the mistreat of black students and families .

I also oppose Council member Vienna’s proposed resolution because it does not address the issue and causes further division. This issue didn't just start 30 days ago it started hundreds of years back, when blacks were made slaves and then seen as 3/5 of a person, never equal. Blacks just want to matter, nothing more, just matter. So when people say all lives matter or blue lives matter, you fail to acknowledge that black lives matter this never took away from other lives we know that other lives matter. Finally there are no blue people walking around so to say that blues lives matter which is a profession you in essence say that a profession matters more than an actual black life, because a person can change a profession but blacks can never change.

As a member of the San Dimas community, I call on you, our leaders, to represent the values of our community and take a stand for justice. Please include my comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Dorothy Arrington From: Ed Wolfe To: Debra Black Subject: John Ebiner"s resolution for Tuesday Night"s meeting. Date: Sunday, June 21, 2020 9:48:55 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Good evening to all of you, friends and colleagues:

I hope that all of you have enjoyed a great Father's Day weekend with your family and friends (while being safe and socially distant!). I received a request from Isabel Ebiner and 12 other signatories asking for support of Council Member Ebiner's resolution that will be, as I understand it, considered at Tuesday night's meeting.

As most of you who know me (and many of you do!), you will recall that I have been relatively silent on political issues as most of my activism was taking place in the late 1960's, the early 70's and then again as a BUSD educator in the 80's and 90's in support of BUSD's teachers and clerical staff. My days of being the face of issues have long since passed with the exception of coming to the City Council to request support for my Lone Hill Wind Ensemble to represent the State of California at the prestigious "Festival of the States" in Washington DC, which your Council so graciously did!

As the Chairperson of the San Dimas Senior Commission and as the president of our Senior Commission Foundation it has been my pleasure to address you on various awards, events, funding efforts and social issues while working closely with both Theresa and Hector.

As to this issue that John Ebiner is proposing, I can support it as a resident of San Dimas since 1977, music educator for BUSD from 1977-2007, Member of the Senior Commission for 5 terms of office and chairman for three of those 5 terms. I am also a member of the Chamber of Commerce as you know that I own http://www.edwolfemusic.com as an educational resource for young musicians, direct the San Dimas Jazz Workshop Big Band, and also direct the San Dimas Brass Ensemble that provides carols yearly at our Winter Extravaganza.

The resolution proposed condemns the killing of George Floyd, denounces racism and injustice and more specifically addresses 4 areas of concern: 1- It names "George Floyd" condemning his death which is seen all over the world as wrong and has spurred activism for the last 25 days throughout the US and the world.

2- It acknowledges that racism exists in every community and even in our great city.

3- It creates a "Civilian Review Board" with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff's station and the community with the ability to suggest policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of a county-wide Body Worn Camera Program. (As the solo euphonium player with the LASD Sheriff's Concert Band, I can support this item and would possibly be willing to serve).

4- It does not address violence against officers which is inexcusable and repugnant but could probably be better addressed as a separate issue and resolution in the future. As a former educator of 51 years, I have been privy to all kinds of societal issues with students, with their parents, with administration, with colleagues and with community members. There have been in that half century many instances of bullying, of racism, of domination and of unfair treatment of every sort possible. I have tried to deal with each instance fairly and with compassion but with a firm conviction. I support this resolution because it is another step towards healing a community that has some wounds and inconsistencies. I especially want to see more equality for those who are in need...our poor, our infirm and our senior citizens.

As a leader in our community, I also take my responsibilities seriously as I know that you all do, and I know that you all respect and represent the values of our community and its citizens. Continue to take a stand for justice and equality and support John's well considered resolution on Tuesday night. You may include these comments as appropriate for the record and I look forward to your action on this matter this week.

Thank you and all my best to you and yours: Ed Wolfe http://www.edwolfemusic.com San Dimas Senior Citizen Commission Chairman From: Emily Ebiner To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: San Dimas Resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 9:51:39 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Emily Ebiner, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 23 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism, injustice, and violence at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

I support this resolution because there is a present-day national movement that denounces racism and injustice, and we as a city should strive to be an inclusive, accepting place for every member of our community. Everyone should feel safe and welcome in San Dimas.

Sincerely, Emily Ebiner From: Emma Haas To: [email protected] Cc: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Re: George Floyd Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 12:24:33 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Emma Haas, and I have been an educator in San Dimas for 3 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because the children I work with should never feel that their lives don’t matter, or be scared to walk in their neighborhood, or be afraid of law enforcement being their enemy.

I also vehemently oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because by not saying George Floyd’s name, we are missing the heart and soul of the issue. It also undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd’s memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue.

Sincerely, Emma Haas Sent from my iPhone From: Eric Nakano To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Support Councilman Ebiner"s Resolution only Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 2:30:21 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Eric and I am a lifelong resident of San Dimas. I am writing to ask that you support the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner. His resolution:

Was the only resolution that incorporated direct feedback from black residents of San Dimas - the others do not

Names George Floyd - I’ve reviewed resolutions from over a dozen cities and EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM names George Floyd and other victims such as Breonna Tayor, Sean Taylor, and others; the reason for this is because for years black men and women of police violence have been nameless and it is important that we recognize the significance of this moment and name George Floyd and other victims

Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas which is something I have personally heard from multiple residents

Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community with specific reporting to the City Council to monitor incidents

Moreover, I stand against violence against our law enforcement officers but do not believe that language supporting law enforcement belongs in this resolution. This is echoed in EVERY SINGLE resolution I have reviewed.

The reason for this is that it is a separate topic and deserves its own resolution. Just as I would not support language in a resolution that honors slain retired officer David Dorn that discusses police excess or protestors, I believe the effort to insert language commending police is misguided and inappropriate.

Therefore, I am against the Council considering Councilman Vienna’s resolution for those reasons and for the reason that this was not a part of the agreed to process by the City Council which assigned only two members: Eric Weber and John Ebiner, the authority to draft a resolution for consideration.

Thank you for taking this up, Eric Nakano From: Carrillo, Estrella To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Resolution on Racism and the killing of George Floyd Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 9:59:47 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Estrella Carrillo, and after 12 years of teaching internationally, I chose to return to my home state of California to be a teacher in San Dimas, and have been doing so for 1 year. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

1. Names "George Floyd" and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd's death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

3. Creates a "Civilian Review Board," with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff's station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because as a person who today is helping shape the San Dimas leaders of tomorrow, we need for everyone to believe that every life is sacred, that everyone has a voice, and that discrimination of any form violates the values that we as Americans hold dear.

Best regards,

Ms. Estrella Carrillo Engish 9, English 1A & English 1C Dual Enrollment San Dimas High School, Mt. San Antonio College From: Carrillo, Estrella To: Emmett Badar; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Proposed Resolution on Racism Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 10:11:45 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Estrella Carrillo, and I am a teacher in San Dimas who is gravely concerned about the current and future stance of the city in regards to equality and justice. As such, Councilmember Vienna's proposed resolution further adds to my concern for a few reasons. Firstly, Councilmember Vienna undermined the process the City Council agreed upon by crafting his own letter as opposed to supporting the members who rightfully authored letters. Secondly, Councilmember Vienna's letter blatantly disrespects George Floyd's memory and our community. Thirdly, this letter encourages further division on this issue through an exercise that was meant to bring unity for all people in San Dimas. I strongly oppose his letter and hope the council will as well.

Best regards,

Ms. Estrella Carrillo Engish 9, English 1A & English 1C Dual Enrollment San Dimas High School, Mt. San Antonio College ______From: Carrillo, Estrella Sent: Monday, June 22, 2020 9:59 PM To: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected] Subject: Resolution on Racism and the killing of George Floyd

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely. I support this resolution because as a person who today is helping shape the San Dimas leaders of tomorrow, we need for everyone to believe that every life is sacred, that everyone has a voice, and that discrimination of any form violates the values that we as Americans hold dear.

Best regards,

Ms. Estrella Carrillo Engish 9, English 1A & English 1C Dual Enrollment San Dimas High School, Mt. San Antonio College From: Frankie Lopez To: Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: George Floyd Resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 9:32:06 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

To Mayor Badar and City Council Members,

My name is Frankie Lopez and I have been a resident of San Dimas for 27 years. I feel very strongly that the resolution proposed by Councilman Ebiner should be adopted in order to condemn the murder of George Floyd and actively acknowledging and condemning racism and injustice here in San Dimas.

The resolution chosen at the June 23 City Council meeting must name George Floyd. For too many years, black people and crimes against them have been just another anonymous death and have remained nameless. The resolution must condemn his murder by the police and not address violence against police. This violence does exist but that is not the purpose of this resolution and it takes away from the matter at hand, which is racism and police violence against black people.

The resolution also needs to create a Civilian Review Board with the intentions of encouraging a positive relationship between the community and the police force in San Dimas. This committee can make recommendations on policy and help implement programs such as the program for police to wear body cameras.

Lastly, this resolution MUST acknowledge the racism that exists and thrives in San Dimas. It is not enough to not be racist, our city and our City Council must be anti-racist.

I support this resolution because, growing up in San Dimas, I have seen with my own eyes that racism exists here and it is not subtle. I have seen students in the high school be outwardly racist and have seen no action taken against them. This city is predominantly and we need to ensure that the black residents and people of color do not feel threatened by their own peers and neighbors. We need to make a statement that shows how outraged we are as a community and that we plan on taking action to change things and not continue to be passive about this issue.

I also strongly and firmly oppose Councilman Vienna's proposed resolution because it minimizes the issues at hand. Not only did he undermine the process in which this resolution was supposed to be created, his resolution disrespects and does not honor George Floyds memory, and it fails to take a strong stance opposing police brutality and racism and that it exists in San Dimas.

I would rather have no resolution at all than Councilman Vienna's or Councilman Weber's. You have a responsibility to serve your community, and that includes your black and brown community members.

Thank you Frankie Lee Lopez [email protected]

From: Gayle Cervantes To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments; Eric Weber Subject: proposed resolution Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 6:48:09 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution. Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Gayle, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 42 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice. 2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas. 3. Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program. 4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I do not want to see what happened in other cities to happen in our city. I have been born and raised in San Dimas and I am proud of our city, and if we make this stance, we will be leading the frontline of what is right and just. Many people look at our city for our engagement with the community. We have an opportunity to show how serious we are with denouncing racism and making it clear to the public. I am proud of San Dimas and would like for you to hear our cries for justice.

Sincerely, Gayle Cervantes From: grace hartnett To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: JUSTICE FOR GEORGE FLOYD/City Coucil resolution Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 9:07:31 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Grace Hartnett and I would like to see San Dimas take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I also oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it downplays the role of systemic racism in our country and does nothing to heal the pain from this issue.

Sincerely,

Grace Hartnett From: Heather Thomas To: Ryan Vienna Cc: Emmett Badar; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Re: Resolution Special Meeting of the City Council Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 3:21:47 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

Hello, my name is Heather Thomas, I am a business owner in the city of San Dimas going on two years. In my prior email I expressed a call to a resolution. Now, I would like to see the concrete step of adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner be adopted at the meeting tonight June 23, 2020. I support that this resolution:

1. Identifies George Floyd by name and as a Black bodied person who was inhumanly murdered.

2. Acknowledges that racism is everywhere, and also here in San Dimas.

3. That a Civilian Review Board be established that fosters a relationship between the Sheriff station and the community.

4. That this resolution does not address violence against police officers or damaged property. While violence against person and property is inexcusable, this topic would be more appropriately addressed in a separate resolution.

I wholeheartedly oppose Councilmember Vienna's proposed resolution. It undermines the process agreed upon, language used minimized the inhumane acts against George Floyd as a black bodied man and systemic racism as an isolated incident, and it further promotes division.

My hope is that our community would continue to grow and move forward in hearing and valuing the experiences of our black and brown neighbors, in order to continue identifying community needs beyond that of the police department. I hope that the council will take a lead and represent the values of our community and be a voice for social change and stand for justice. Thank you for your time and consideration!

Sincerely, Heather Thomas, PT, DPT, OCS, 200 RYT Doctor of Physical Therapy Orthopedic Clinical Specialist Prenatal/Postnatal & Pelvic Health 200 hour Registered Yoga Teacher 949.409.1411 www.myphysiofly.com www.unitedyogastudio.com

"The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago, the second best time is now."

On Mon, Jun 15, 2020 at 3:52 PM Heather Thomas wrote: To whom it may concern,

My name is Heather Thomas, I am a business owner of a small physical therapy practice located in United Yoga Studio in San Dimas, which I am also a member and teacher at.

I am writing this email that you would greatly consider the need of San Dimas to adopt a resolution.

A personal experience I would like to share. Prior to obtaining a business licence I was told by four women of color, two outside of San Dimas, how challenging the process was, how long it took and how many questions they were asked. When the time came I blocked off my schedule and prepared for a few back and forth to get it. The day I went, I was in and out in less than 15 minutes with very few questions asked of me. I reflected on how different my experience was to theirs. Initially I figured it was I had learned from their experiences or that I was getting a licence for a business inside an established business. But I couldn’t help but wonder if my ease of obtaining a San Dimas business licence was at all attributed to being a white appearing woman of tall stature. Perhaps it was, perhaps it wasn’t, but it creates pause for reflection of my own implicit bias and those that may have taken place in my process that day. That was a year ago, and this experience resurfaced now. My ease being white contrasting the accounts of our black and brown neighbors. Sometimes when it seems a resolution is not needed, is when it is in fact needed the most.

My hopes are that the community and staff will be educated on anti-racism versus “not being a racist” as well as exploring explicit and implicit bias. That the experiences of people of color in our neighborhood are welcomed, heard, valued and that we would learn what can be done and how we can work together. That the council would take a lead on being a voice for social change, speaking out publicly about inequality and taking a stand against police brutality and systematic racism. I strongly support a public statement from city council members and that a resolution be drafted and adopted. I am proud to have a business in this city and have hopes that we continue to grow as a community!

Thank you for your time reading my story, and your consideration of a resolution.

Best, -- Heather Thomas, PT, DPT, OCS, 200 RYT Doctor of Physical Therapy Orthopedic Clinical Specialist Prenatal/Postnatal & Pelvic Health 200 hour Registered Yoga Teacher 949.409.1411 www.myphysiofly.com www.unitedyogastudio.com

"The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago, the second best time is now."

-- Heather Thomas, PT, DPT, OCS, 200 RYT Doctor of Physical Therapy Orthopedic Clinical Specialist Prenatal/Postnatal & Pelvic Health 200 hour Registered Yoga Teacher 949.409.1411 www.myphysiofly.com www.unitedyogastudio.com

"The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago, the second best time is now." From: Isabel Ebiner To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Eric Weber; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: I support Councilmember Ebiner’s resolution. Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 2:17:03 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

As my last email was quite long, I wanted to summarize: I support Councilmember Ebiner’s resolution, and I respectfully ask that you say his name, George Floyd, in the resolution that may be passed tonight.

Best, Isabel Ebiner W 4th Street, San Dimas

-- "In this world, choosing authenticity and worthiness is an absolute act of resistance. Choosing to live and love with our whole hearts is an act of defiance." --Brene Brown From: Isabel Ebiner To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Eric Weber; John Ebiner; Denis Bertone; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: I hope you read every word of this. Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 2:12:52 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

I am writing in support of Councilmember Ebiner's resolution condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, and I oppose Councilmember Weber’s resolution. In talking with many of my neighbors and members of the community, including Black members of our community, regarding the importance of this issue, I have realized this resolution is both a symbol and an action for San Dimas.

The symbolism of this resolution lies in the message that the community needs to hear right now. This is an opportunity--so, what message do we want to send? Do we say "George Floyd" and tell our Black neighbors that their lives matter? Or do we deny George Floyd's humanity and strip away his name, an act that has its origins in slavery? Do we acknowledge the painful stories of discrimination and racism that our residents experienced in our own City and so courageously shared? Or do we pretend that those collective experiences were trivial?

The action we are asking for is the creation of a Civilian Review Board that will protect all parties--law enforcement and community members--and foster positive relationships between both groups. It is my understanding that the Public Safety Commission addresses broad concerns beyond just law enforcement, addressing general safety issues in the community at large. We are asking for a Board that is solely dedicated to the community's relationships with the San Dimas Sheriff's Station. Yes, the County already has Civilian Boards. Your constituents are asking for one right here in San Dimas. We are saying this will help us feel safer. Please, help us feel safer in our own community.

Ultimately, we, the people, are asking for a resolution that names George Floyd, acknowledges that racism exists in San Dimas, creates a Civilian Review Board, and does NOT address violence against police officers.

I vehemently oppose Councilmember Vienna's proposed resolution, which I found to be both divisive and offensive (perhaps unintentionally). Not only did Councilmember Vienna undermine the process that the Council agreed to in the recent Special Meeting, but his draft also disrespected George Floyd's memory and incited even greater division in our community. And while I am deeply troubled by Councilmember Vienna's actions on this matter, his proposed resolution appears to have angered so many members of our community into taking action for racial justice. I believe this recent engagement by citizens who are not typically involved will only push our City to be better. As a resident of San Dimas and a mother, I plan to raise my children here, and I am fighting like hell for a San Dimas that I can believe in. I call on this City Council to represent the values of our community and take a stand for justice. Please include my comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration.

Best, Isabel Ebiner W 4th Street, San Dimas

-- "In this world, choosing authenticity and worthiness is an absolute act of resistance. Choosing to live and love with our whole hearts is an act of defiance." --Brene Brown From: Jerolyn Prust To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: George Floyd Resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 4:25:48 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Jerolyn Prust, and I have been a teacher in San Dimas for 3 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

Important: I support this resolution because I am concerned about the lack of respect our minority cultures are experiencing at our public schools. I do NOT understand how any city would NOT adopt such a resolution and I have real concerns about the draft put forth by one of your members, Mr. Vienna, which includes charged language intended to be divisive and dismissive of the global movement we have witnessed of people wanting racial justice for all. Here is a moment where you can do what is right and make a statement for equality.

Sincerely, Jerolyn Prust teacher at San Dimas High From: J D To: Emmett Badar Cc: Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 12:18:01 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Jon Doyle, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 4 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I want my family, neighbors, and friends to take some comfort knowing that our city condemns racism and police brutality. We must identify these issues as problems so that we can take steps toward fixing them.

I also oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd’s memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue.

Sincerely, Jon Doyle From: Emmett Badar To: Jose Calderon; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; [email protected]; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Re: Comment for the Record in Support of Councilmember Ebiner"s resolution on the Killing of George Floyd Date: Saturday, June 20, 2020 6:10:56 PM

Mr. and Mrs. Calderon, thank you for your recent email concerning your support for a proclamation from the City of San Dimas on issued that are facing our community. As you know this concern will before the council on Tuesday evening. I will ensure that your email will be entered into the official record on this very important issue prior to council consideration of this matter. Thank you for caring about your community. Emmett Badar Mayor

Sent from my iPhone City of San Dimas

From: Jose Calderon Sent: Saturday, June 20, 2020 1:36:25 PM To: Emmett Badar ; Ryan Vienna ; Denis Bertone ; John Ebiner ; [email protected] ; Brad McKinney ; Debra Black ; publiccomments Subject: Comment for the Record in Support of Councilmember Ebiner's resolution on the Killing of George Floyd

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

Our names are Jose and Rose Calderon, and we have been residents in San Dimas for twenty-five years. We would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. We support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

We support this resolution as part of our solidarity with all those who are outraged with the brutal murder of George Floyd and with all those who are supporting the efforts being waged to advance equality and multi-racial unity. In this context, the responses to the killing of Floyd have not just been about his unjust murder but are the result of years of racial and economic disparities. As Darnell Hunt, Dean of Social Sciences at UCLA proposes from his years of research: “The George Floyd case was not the cause … the police killings are the symptoms … the underlying cause is white supremacy, racism, and things the U. S. has not fundamentally dealt with.”

In this light, we support this resolution as part of our efforts to stand against all those who seek to divide our communities and who seek to scapegoat everyone from our Asian American communities to our people of color, poor, immigrant, physically and mentally challenged, LGBTQ, and refugee communities. We support this resolution as part of our commitment to build unity in our diverse communities and to turn around the sources of our diverse communities’ disparities through advancing "people first" policies that are in the interests of providing a quality of life for all.

We support this resolution as part of our standing with all those who are calling to turn these conditions around and who are committed to remember the spirit of Floyd by fighting for justice, not only for his family, but for future generations. We support this resolution as part of standing with Darnella Frazier, the 17-year old who courageously documented the murder of George Floyd. Finally, we support this resolution as part of standing with all those families and communities who have faced the loss of life of family members and friends.

As members of the San Dimas community, we call on this council to represent the values of our community and to take a stand for justice. Please include our comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely

Jose and Rose Calderon 613 N. Northcape Ave. San Dimas, CA 91773 J From: Julie Henry To: Emmett Badar; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Ryan Vienna; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; publiccomments Subject: Resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 1:31:57 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Julie Henry and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 30 years and a teacher in the Bonita Unified School District for 16 years. I am also proud to say that I have been married to my husband for 35 years and have raised two beautiful daughters here, who attended Shull, Lone Hill and San Dimas High School. Underlying these life accomplishments is the fact that I am in an interracial relationship with my husband who is African Caribbean American, which makes my daughters of mixed culture. I put it this way, because the incredible richness of our lives is built on the diversity of our situation and of our family, friends and the community around us, The color of our skin should have nothing to do with the way any of us are looked at or treated. I say that for those in my family who have not always had the same benefits that I have had simply because I was born into white privilege in this country when they were not. I cannot and will not ever know what it is like to be a person of color living in San Dimas, but I do have first hand knowledge based on the closeness to my own family and their experiences.

That being said, I want us all to acknowledge that there is incredible sadness and anger in our country right now that racism continues to rear its ugly head. People cannot take it anymore and feel they must speak up. I am writing this message to you, because I feel the same way. I support the peaceful protests that have been going on nationwide and in our own city. Just listening to the people who called in during the last City Council meeting, especially the young people who are our future, left me heartbroken and in tears. Their cries to end racial slurs, derogatory jokes and comments and racially motivated bullying are not being heard or acted upon and this situation must change. We, as a community, are coming forward in support of this ideal and we are respectfully asking that you as our representatives in City Council do the same.

I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I strongly oppose Councilmember Weber's proposed resolution because it dishonors George Floyd by not naming him and states that what happened to him was an isolated incident, which leads me to believe that he is unwilling to acknowledge that racism exists here in San Dimas or even in the country.

I vehemently oppose Councilmember Vienna's resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd's memory and our community and encourages further division on this issue through an exercise that was meant to bring unity for all people in San Dimas.

The purpose of this resolution is for the city to stand up in support of all of our community members, especially those who are suffering in the light of the recent tragedy of George Floyd's death and those marginalized in their own life experiences living in our town. The city needs to recognize that racism and bias does exist, even in San Dimas, and condemn racism and injustice in all its forms.

I want to have hope that you all, as Mayor and Members of the City Council, will listen to our collective voices, take our depp-felt expressions to heart and remember that you were voted in by the people of our city to serve and protect all of the people who live, work, attend school and grow up and grow old here. Passing the resolution as proposed by Councilmember Ebiner will show that the City of San Dimas is willing to do just that.

Sincerely, Julie Henry (909) 851-6256 [email protected]

"Prejudice is an emotional commitment to ignorance." --Nathen Rustein

From: Kandice D To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Black Lives Matter and San Dimas agrees! Date: Sunday, June 21, 2020 10:22:27 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

To the Mayor and the members of the city council: My name is Kandice Draayer, and I have been a registered nurse in San Dimas for five years. I love this pretty little city and all of the residents, but I do not support the racism that prevails here. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, which condemns the killing of George Floyd and denounces racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely. I vehemently oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, it blatantly disrespects George Floyd’s memory, and our community, and encourages further division on this issue through an exercise that was meant to bring unity for all people in San Dimas. I have witnessed racism at the hands of nurses, doctors, the medical system, and the government first- hand as an RN. I have watched my neighbors with black skin be thrown to the ground and arrested for minor infractions. While working in the ER, locally, I have heard multiple Sheriff's officers joking about not administering Narcan to people overdosing on heroin. Nothing is funny, nothing is a joke. Our Sheriff's department works hard for us and they need to be held accountable for the ones in their ranks who discredit their reputation. I know that this beautiful city is above this. Police violence is real, the entitlement to the violence is real, and the culture of acceptance of police being jury, judge, and executioner must stop in the smallest of places in order to set an example. This beautiful city is full of beautiful people who believe in justice and recognize that justice does not serve the poor or minorities. We are better than this. We applaud our police for protecting us, and we condemn them for overstepping and taking lives. San Dimas stands for equality and equity.

Thank you,

Kandice Draayer From: Romo Family To: Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; [email protected] Cc: Emmett Badar Subject: A call to end racism in San Dimas Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 10:00:53 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Karen Romo and I have been a School Psychologist in San Dimas for 6 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020.

I support a resolution that specifically: o Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice. o Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas. o Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program. o Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I work very closely with children on a daily basis and the trauma that systemic racism and the current climate in America has is continually taking a toll on our students of color. I can no longer sit back and let this continue. This is an opportunity for all of us to stand up for all our students of color because they deserve to live in a community without racism and free from daily trauma via ongoing racism and micro-aggressions.

Sincerely, Karen Romo From: Kate Torres To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: San Dimas MUST adopt a resolution condemning the killing of George Floyd, and denouce racism and injustice Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 6:11:10 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

My name is Kate Torres, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for my whole life. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

Sincerely,

Kate Torres

From: Kathy Cavanaugh To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Kathy Cavanaugh Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 4:52:29 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

I want to follow up on my e-mail to give my address as a 27 year resident confirmation

607 Belleview Avenue From: Kathy Cavanaugh To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: City Council Meeting Agenda Tuesday June 23rd 7:00pm Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 4:44:32 PM Importance: High

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Good afternoon, My name is Kathy Cavanaugh and I am a resident of the wonderful City of San Dimas.

I would like to address

5. OTHER BUSINESS "C"

I am opposed to the resolution presented by John Ebiner that takes on a "national" tone. I believe our City Council is constructed to maintain the City of San Dimas, only. Our country as a whole has a governing body, that we as a whole elect.

I am In favor of the resolution presented by Eric Weber that speaks of a coming together of a community. A community that is "ALL IN" for the good of their city, which may in turn speaks volumes to a country.

Though the thought of ABOLISHING (Formally put an end to) racism is a good one, it is not found in a stated resolution. This is something that commands a CHANGE OF HEART in people and I believe that is accomplished by modeling "justice, "respect", "kindness", and "love", even then a heart that is set on racism cannot be changed.

I thought, "how would the City of San Dimas carry this out?". Would there be interviews of people who wanted to purchase or rent a home here? Would there be people that would be forced to leave here, if they were found to harbor racists thoughts? What would that look like?

We would do well with raising our eyes to our Creator, and welcoming Him and His word back into our government. Even then, we do the best we can, and we are still imperfect.

God's bountiful blessings on our City Of San Dimas

From: Leaming, Leslie To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Resolution Regarding George Floyd and Racism in San Dimas Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 3:58:24 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council,

My name is Leslie Leaming and I am a History and Computer Science teacher at San Dimas High School. I feel compelled to voice my opinion on the issue of the passage of a resolution to condemn the murder of George Floyd and racism that exists not only at the national level but also at the local level within the City of Sam Dimas.

I am aware that a committee was established including Councilmembers Ebiner and Councilmember Weber to draft a resolution regarding this issue. For reasons I don't fully understand, there was lack of agreement between the two councilmembers on this task causing both of them to draft their own resolution.

I am writing to encourage the City Council and Mayor to accept and pass Councilmember Ebiner's resolution. Councilmember Weber's resolution fails to mention the name of George Floyd, which must be part of the resolution. For too long the names of those killed at the hands of law enforcement have been forgotten. Erasing the names of those human beings and refusing to say their names publicly keep these individuals such as George Floyd invisible. If you don't say his name he only becomes part of the 1000's of Black people whose identity has been lumped into a nameless group. George Floyd was an individual and deserves to have his name stated just like those that came before that have also become invisible. This was not an isolated incident. If you say their names - all of them - you would know that.

I also encourage the City Council and Mayor to pass Councilmember Ebiner's resolution because it condemns racism and police brutality. Additionally, the resolution calls for the establishment of a citizen review board to make recommendations on reforms regarding policing in the city of San Dimas. While it appears that some Councilmembers do not believe any of this is a problem in San Dimas, it just shows that the City Council is failing to listen and learn the stories of the Black citizens of San Dimas.

I find it questionable why all these elements would be objectionable as part of a resolution. As a teacher, what am I to say to my students that ask me about what has San Dimas done to deal with the issue of racism and police issues in the city of San Dimas? The issues of racism and policing are not only on our campus but within the community as a whole.

Lastly, I want to state that I am opposed to and disappointed that Councilmember Vienna took it upon himself to draft his own resolution without the authority to do so as according to the rules because he did not like what either draft resolution stated. The draft resolution he constructed is obviously solely from the perspective of someone that is a member of the LA Sheriffs. His resolution does nothing to address the issues at hand and everything about what the problem actually is. His document is tone deaf to the issues and will only continue to dismiss the concerns of the Black community of San Dimas. Councilmember Vienna has an obvious bias and conflict of interest and therefore his draft resolution should not even be considered.

It is of my opinion that if Councilmember Ebiner's resolution is not passed, NO resolution should be passed.

Thank you for reading my comments,

Leslie Leaming

Teacher - San Dimas High School

Sent from Mail for Windows 10

From: Luz Villarreal To: publiccomments Subject: test Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 2:39:03 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution. From: Martin Bacon To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: June 23rd Council Meeting Re: Racism of Resolution Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 8:10:47 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Martin Bacon and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 4 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I am a Black man living in San Dimas and I would like to see and experience the change that San Dimas always talks about. I would like to feel comfortable in my own city and not have myself and my family experience racism. I will spread the word to everyone I know and be more involved to get the right people in charge of this city.

I also oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because he does not care about black people or minorities. He does not show compassion nor does he fight for right or wrong. I will make it my mission to get him out of office until he stands on the right side; THE MORAL SIDE of humanity. I will spread the word of how San Dimas, the city I live in works as the Old South. All we and everyone wants is to have the same rights and privileges as everyone else. For my family to not be worried about racial slurs or violence. Also I vehemently oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd’s memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue.”

Sincerely, MARTIN A. BACON

-- Martin Bacon Head Football Coach Montclair High School From: Melissa Turner To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: George Floyd Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 12:08:06 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Melissa Vercautren, and I have been an educator in San Dimas for over 6 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

Sincerely, Melissa Vercautren

-Melissa Turner Vercautren

Sent from my iPhone From: Mia Sanderson To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 9:42:48 AM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the city counsel: My name is Mia Sanderson, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for over 19 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Counsel meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically

1. Names “George Floyd“ and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that Racism exists even here in San Dimas.

3. Creates a “Civilian Review Board”. With the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriffs station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county- wide Body Worn Camera program.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because even in this small town of San Dimas I see stereotyping, name calling, discrimination, and poor attitudes about members of our community. People ripped posters with George Floyd’s name as well as multiple others next to my house off of the fence. As someone studying to receive a Masters to work with children I want to live in a town that not only demonstrates and supports racial equality and justice for those victims; but is doing their part to make this society a better place for our children of all races.

I also oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Counsel agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd’s memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue.

Sincerely, Mia Sanderson From: Michael Ghaly To: Brad McKinney; Denis Bertone; Debra Black; Emmett Badar; Eric Weber; John Ebiner; publiccomments; Ryan Vienna Subject: Resolution Date: Saturday, June 20, 2020 7:26:25 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Michael Ghaly, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for 18 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice. 2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas. 3. Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county- wide Body Worn Camera program. 4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I have experienced racism in San Dimas and know many other people personally who have as well.

Sincerely, Michael Ghaly From: Michael Gonzales To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Brad McKinney; Debra Black Subject: Fwd: San Dimas Resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 4:48:20 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Michael Gonzales and I have been a resident of San Dimas for 5 years. I would like to see our city take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community are safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner. This specifically condemns the killing of George Floyd and denounces racism and injustice, being decided at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I am a firm believer in equality and respectful treatment regardless of race. Listening to the feedback from phone calls at the last city council meeting, it is apparent that racism occurs in this city. As a resident who frequents local establishments, I have witnessed and overheard racist comments. This should not be tolerated and needs to be acknowledged by you specifically. You are each in an elected position of power, in which you are able to make positive change. I respectfully urge you to put aside any of your personal opinions and view this from a perspective other than your own. It is time to learn from the past and move forward, for ourselves, for each other and for our future generations.

I also oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution for multiple reasons. First, this resolution does not mention George Floyd's name, but merely states "a person." In doing so, the resolution disrespects his life and memory. Second, this resolution blames the death of George Floyd for the civil unrest that has ensued. It overlooks the fact that this is not the first instance of police brutality and racism. It does not mention the right to peaceful protest and demonstrations by those that see this as a deep injustice. It focuses on the actions by looters and non-peaceful protesters. While this resolution recognizes racism, it is deeply flawed and leads to further division surrounding the issues at hand. This resolution should focus on the loss of George Floyd's life and take leadership in denouncing racism in this city. It is the right of all residents to equality and fair treatment by police officers. It is furthermore everyone's right to peaceful protests and demonstrations. This act of police violence and homicide cannot and should not be taken lightly.

Sincerely, Michael Gonzales From: United Yoga Studio To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 3:15:33 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Michelle Pasos, and I was a resident from 2013-2017 andI have been a business owner in San Dimas for 4 years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because as a brown woman who was raised in Glendora I have personally experienced racism since I was 6 years old. It was painful being called derogatory names and having swastikas and confederate flags being drawn on my journal. I grew up wearing sunblock, bleaching my hair and wearing green contacts because I was conditioned to think being white was right, better and more beautiful.

It's taken time to decolonize myself and be proud of who I am and where I come from but the truth is there are far too many people in our culture that continue to be a part of the problem. As an adult, I now experience more covert racism in forms of unconscious insults, microassaults & microinvalidation. However, the pain I have and continue to experience does not compare to what my fellow black family and friends face daily. I have seen first hand my brother in law being pulled over countless times just because he is black. He played football at Utah State, he has a B.S. in Sociology, he is a committed father and husband, and overall lovable human being yet he will still randomly get pulled over in our community simply for the color of his skin. This is not surprising amongst the circles I have grown up in and has to stop.

I strongly oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because he acted unprofessionally and without integrity. As a representative of this city, he should be condemning the murder of George Floyd by law enforcement. His resolution instead is hurtful, disrespectful and contributes to the struggle of the black and brown community.

Sincerely, Michelle Pasos

-- United Yoga Studio 654 W. Arrow Highway San Dimas, CA 91773 909.451.9750

Connect with us on Instagram & Facebook @unitedyogastudio

"Educating, Encouraging, & Empowering the heart, mind, and body" From: Misty Taylor To: Brad McKinney; publiccomments Subject: FW: Support of Councilmember Ebiner"s resolution Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 12:56:36 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

From: Misty Taylor Sent: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 12:54 PM To: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected] Subject: Support of Councilmember Ebiner's resolution

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Mistyanne Taylor, and I have been a resident in San Dimas for going on 3 years now; I was previously a resident of La Verne. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas. In not acknowledging that there is racism is hurtful those that have experienced it, and is detrimental to the safety of ALL San Dimas residents.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I believe that being open and transparent with community policing will lead to better understanding by the public and its safety. By involving the community you will invite the public to participate and assist in the overall wellbeing of the community.

I oppose the resolution put forth by Councilmember Vienna because not only does his resolution undermine the process the City Council agreed upon, its failed to address a number of issues, such as naming George Flyod, allowing civilian oversite and participation in our community. It also does not address the use of body-worn cameras or vehicle mounted camera for the safety of the public and our police force.

Sincerely,

Mistyanne Taylor

“Let us be grateful to the people who make us happy; they are the charming gardeners who make our souls blossom.” ― Marcel Proust

Sent from Mail for Windows 10

Dr. Nicole M. Vienna 117 E. Commercial St. San Dimas, Ca. 91773

June 19, 2020

Dear City Council Members,

1. I see no need for a City of San Dimas Resolution on racism, hatred or violence. The city decided not to take a stand on a different state issue that impacted our local community (SB54). Why this one? Why now? It feels discriminatory. Particularly, it feels like councilmember Ebiner is grandstanding on this issue and being selective in which minority group he supports.

2. Should you determine a resolution is warranted, I do not support specifically mentioning a particular victim’s name, unless you also intend to specifically mention the names of the police officers killed and injured during subsequent riots. Their lives are no less important. And we should not stand divided nor perpetuate discriminatory behavior. The city needs to lead by example.

3. We all agree racism, hatred & police brutality is wrong.

4. We all agree the death of the victim in Minneapolis was tragic.

5. We all agree what happened to the murdered police officers was tragic.

6. It seems that many of the callers, as of late, have experienced racism within the school district. While the council may decide to take a stand and make note, I believe additional training and reform should be offered to school-teachers and administrators who are first-line support systems to our students.

I urge you to listen to your constituents and make sure the resolution represents a balanced view of the community and stop pandering to special interest groups.

Respectfully,

Dr. Nicole M. Vienna (626) 709-3494 From: NIKHIL-RAJ KULKARNI To: Emmett Badar Cc: Ryan Vienna; Denis Bertone; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Subject: Support of Councilmember Ebiner"s Resolution Date: Monday, June 22, 2020 4:51:40 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council,

My name is Nick Kulkarni and as someone who grew up in San Dimas and lived there for 10 years, I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020.

I support a resolution that specifically: 1. Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice.

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because it specifically condemns George Floyd's killing using George Floyd's name. I believe that it is important to specifically condemn George Floyd's killing at the hands of police officers in Minneapolis because doing so demonstrates that the City of San Dimas is against such acts and condemns the Minneapolis police officers who committed them. I also believe that racism is prevalent in the city of San Dimas and it is important to me that our City leadership acknowledges said racism because not acknowledging it does as much harm as endorsing it. I also support this resolution because it creates a Civilian Review Board. I strongly believe in creating a Civilian Review Board that is composed of laymen. These laymen should not be associated with the City of San Dimas, the Council, the Police Department, or any other local, state, or federal government or law enforcement system. The members of this board should be volunteers. They should not have any personal, political, or business relationships with the City, the Council or the Police Department.

As a member of the San Dimas community, I call on you, our leaders, to represent the values of our community and take a stand for justice. Please include my comments for the record. Thank you for your consideration. -- Nikhil Kulkarni, MPH [email protected] | (626) 622 -4618

From: Patricia A. Teunisse To: Emmett Badar; Ryan Vienna; [email protected]; John Ebiner; Eric Weber; Brad McKinney; Debra Black; publiccomments Cc: [email protected] Subject: Tonight"s Vote on a Resolution to Address Racism in the City of San Dimas Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 2:47:50 PM

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council:

My name is Patricia A. Teunisse, and I have been a resident, home owner and business owner in San Dimas for over thirty (30) years. I would like to see our City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically:

2. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas.

4. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because I believe that the people of San Dimas strive to be a welcoming and inclusive community. The color of my skin is a little bit browner than the majority in the City of San Dimas but nonetheless I have believed, for the last thirty years, that our community wants to protect all who live here. Systemic racism and bias continue to infect our society and during these difficult times I find myself feeling, for the first time, less welcome. This resolution would reaffirm our commitment to protecting the least of us.

I oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd’s memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue. The failure to specifically call out George Floyd’s name and memory dulls the impact his tragic and fully avoidable death has had on the nation and on this community. The inclusion of a police support declaration is a rank deflection of the most tragic kind. Of course we support our law enforcement officers who do the job they are entrusted with well and with honor. That is not the point at this time of national mourning – it’s defensive and thus distracts from the real point – a police officer callously and casually took the life of 46 year old George Floyd whose children loved him and whose family mourns him. This is police brutality and failure to honor the most basic mission of our law enforcement agencies – to protect and serve!

Yours sincerely,

Patricia A. Teunisse

921 W. Cienega Ave. San Dimas CA 91773

Sent from Mail for Windows 10

From: Brad McKinney To: publiccomments Subject: FW: END RACISM! Date: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 2:53:51 PM

From: Pauline Wheelis Sent: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 2:46 PM To: Brad McKinney Subject: Fw: END RACISM!

CAUTION: This email originated outside our organization; please use caution.

Dear Mayor Badar and Members of the City Council: My name is Pauline Wheelis and I have been a resident in the great city of San Dimas for my whole life of 22 years. I would like to see our beautiful City take concrete steps to ensure all members of our community feel safe by adopting the resolution proposed by Councilmember Ebiner, condemning the killing of George Floyd and denouncing racism and injustice, at the City Council meeting on June 23, 2020. I support a resolution that specifically: Names “George Floyd” and condemns his killing by Minneapolis police officers. George Floyd’s death has been universally acknowledged as wrong, and it is his death that has awoken the American consciousness in this moment of history to fight for racial justice. Acknowledges that racism exists even here in San Dimas. Creates a “Civilian Review Board,” with the specific goal of fostering positive relationships between the Sheriff’s station and the community. The Board could make policy recommendations and disseminate information regarding the implementation of the county-wide Body Worn Camera program. Does NOT address violence against police officers. While such violence is inexcusable, this is a different topic and should be addressed in a separate resolution entirely.

I support this resolution because Jesus taught that we should love our neighbor as ourselves. How can we follow Christ’s teachings and not love and respect all people made in his wondrous image. I’ve lived in San Dimas my whole life and I know how awesome our city is.. why can’t we make it better by fully including all persons of all ethnic backgrounds and ensure their safety.

I vehemently oppose Councilmember Vienna’s proposed resolution because it undermines the process the City Council agreed upon, disrespects George Floyd’s memory and our community, and encourages further division on this issue.

Sincerely, Pauline Wheelis

Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone