Technology, Television, and Competition : the Politics of Digital TV
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
This page intentionally left blank Technology, Television, and Competition In the late 1980s and 1990s, the advanced industrial countries considered replacing the existing analog television infrastructure with a new digital one. A key common feature to the debates over digital TV (DTV) in the United States, Western Europe, and Japan was the eventual victory of the ideas of digitalism (the superiority of everything digital over everything analog) and of digital convergence (the merging of computing, telecommuni- cations, and broadcasting infrastructures made possible by digi- talization) in public debates over standards. Jeffrey Hart’s book shows how nationalism and regionalism combined with digital- ism to produce three different and incompatible DTV standards in the three regions, an outcome which has led to missed oppor- tunities in developing the new technologies. Hart’s bookcon- tributes to our understanding of relations between business and government, and of competition between the world’s great eco- nomic powers. is Professor of Political Science at Indiana Uni- versity, Bloomington. His publications include The New Inter- national Economic Order (1983), Rival Capitalists (1992), Global- ization and Governance (1999), Managing New Industry Creation (2001), and The Politics of International Economic Relations (2003). Technology, Television, and Competition The Politics of Digital TV Jeffrey A. Hart Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge , United Kingdom Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.or g/9780521826242 © Jeffrey A. Hart 2004 This book is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provision of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published in print format 2004 isbn-13- 978-0-511-07369-4 eBook (NetLibrary) isbn-10- 0-511-07369-0 eBook (NetLibrary) isbn-13- 978-0-521-82624-2 hardback isbn-10- 0-521-82624-1 hardback Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of s for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this book, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate. To my wife Joan Contents Preface page ix Acknowledgments x List of acronyms xi 1 Introduction 1 2 The institutional setting for advanced TV 17 3 Digital convergence: consumer electronics 60 4 HDTV in Japan 84 5 HDTV in the United States 100 6 HDTV in Europe 118 7 Digital television in the United States 150 8 Digital television in Europe and Japan 181 9 Examples of global standards 207 10 Conclusions 221 Index 233 vii Preface High definition television (HDTV) became a contentious issue in Amer- ican politics after the European Community rejected a bid in 1986 by the Japanese national broadcasting company, Nippon Hoso Kyokai (NHK), to have its HDTV production method adopted as an international stan- dard. The US government supported the Japanese effort initially, but after the European rejection many people in the United States began to question that support. For some, the Japanese HDTV initiative raised concerns about the relative decline in US competitiveness, even in high technology industries, and the need to respond more effectively to the in- creased competition from Japan and Western Europe. For others, HDTV was important because it might affect a wide range of industries – broad- casting, film, video, consumer electronics, computers, and telecommu- nications – and therefore needed to be considered more carefully before buying into the Japanese approach. As a result, the United States began a process to choose a standard for advanced TV that tookuntil April 1997 to reach its conclusion. The US choice of a digital television (DTV) stan- dard forced both Japan and Europe to reexamine their earlier decisions on HDTV. This bookis about the forces behind these events. ix Acknowledgments The research for this bookwas supported by grants and contracts from the Office of Technology Assessment of the US Congress, Motorola, Inc.; the Berkeley Roundtable on the International Economy; the Elec- tronic Industries Association; the National Center for Manufacturing Sciences; the Advanced Research Projects Administration of the Depart- ment of Defense; the Technology Transfer Institute; the College of Arts and Sciences of Indiana University; the West European Studies Depart- ment of Indiana University; the Alfred Sloan Foundation; and Stanford Resources, Inc. I would like to thank the following individuals for their help and encouragement: Fran¸cois Bar, Michael Borrus, Joel Brinkley, Joseph Castellano, Alan Cawson, Stephen Cohen, Dale Cripps, Warren Davis, Joseph Donahue, Hernan Galperin, Darcy Gerbarg, Larry Irving, Greg Kasza, Hans Kleinsteuber, Ellis Krauss, Stefanie Lenway, Junji Matsuzaki, David Mentley, J¨org Meyer-Stamer, Ed Miller, Tom Murtha, Russ Neuman, Elie Noam, Greg Noble, Jerry Pearlman, Aseem Prakash, Harmeet Sawhney, William Schreiber, Pete Seel, Gary Shapiro, Marko Slusarczuk, Alvy Ray Smith, Sid Topol, Laura Tyson, Adam Watson- Brown, and John Zysman. Thanks also to the anonymous readers of the manuscript for their suggestions and advice. Research assistance for this bookwas provided by the following current and former students at Indiana University: George Candler, Youngmin Jo, Sangbae Kim, MarkMarone, Craig Ortsey, Khalil Osman, Aseem Prakash, and Robert Reed. John Thomas co-authored an earlier version of chapter 6. x Acronyms ABC American Broadcasting Corporation ACATS Advisory Committee on Advanced Television Services ACTV Advanced Compatible Television AEA American Electronics Association ALTV Association for Low-Power Television AMST Association of Maximum Service Telecasters ANSI American National Standards Institute ARD Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Rundfunkanstalten Deutschlands ARPA Advanced Research Projects Agency (see also DARPA) ATM asynchronous transfer mode ATRC Advanced Television Research Consortium ATSC Advanced Television Standards Committee AT&T American Telephone and Telegraph ATTC Advanced Television Testing Center ATV advanced television BBC British Broadcasting Corporation BCG Boston Consulting Group BDB British Digital Broadcasting BIB British Interactive Broadcasting BRITE Basic Research in Industrial Technologies for Europe BSB British Satellite Broadcasting BSkyB British Sky Broadcasting BSS broadcast satellite services BTA Broadcasting Technology Association CATV community antenna television CBS Columbia Broadcasting System CCD charge-coupled device CCIA Computer and Communications Industry Association CCIR Comit´e Consultatif International de Radio-Diffusion CECC Consumer Electronics Capital Corporation CEMA Consumer Electronics Manufacturers Association xi xii List of acronyms CENELEC European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization CEO chief executive officer CICATS Computer Industry Committee on Advanced Television Standards CIF common image format CLT Compagnie Luxembourgeoise de T´el´evision CNCL Commission Nationale de la Communication et des Libert´es COFDM coded orthogonal frequency division multiplex CompTIA Computer Technology Industry Association COO chief operating officer CRT cathode ray tube DARPA Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (see also ARPA) DBS direct broadcast satellite DG Directorate General (European Union) DIVINE digital video narrowband emission DM deutsche mark DSS digital satellite service DTH direct to home DTN Digital Television Network DTV digital television DTVJ DirecTV Japan DVB Digital Video Broadcasting DVD digital versatile disk EBU European Broadcasting Union EDTV enhanced definition television EIA Electronic Industries Association EIAJ Electronic Industries Association of Japan EPG electronic program guide ESPRIT European Strategic Program for Research and Development in Information Technology ETSI European Telecommunications Standards Institute EU European Union Eureka European Research Coordinating Agency FCC Federal Communications Commission FSF Free Software Foundation FSS fixed satellite services GA Grand Alliance GDL Grand Duchy of Luxembourg GI General Instrument List of acronyms xiii GNU Gnu’s Not Unix GPL General Public License HBO Home Box Office HD-MAC high definition multiplexed analog components HDTV high definition television HTML hypertext markup language IBA Independent Broadcasting Authority (UK) IDTV improved definition television IEEE Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers INTV Association of Independent Television Stations ISDB integrated services digital broadcasting ISDN integrated services digital network ITC Independent Television Commission ITU International Telegraphic Union JESSI Joint European Semiconductor Silicon Initiative JSAT Japan Satellite Broadcasting JSB Japan Satellite Broadcasting LPTV low power television MAC multiplexed analog components MHz megahertz MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology MITI Ministry of International Trade and Industry MMBG Multimedia Betriebsgesellschaft MOU memorandum of understanding MPAA Motion Picture Association of America MPEG Motion Picture Experts Group MPT Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications MST Association of Maximum Service Telecasters MSTV Association for Maximum Service Television MTV Music Television MUSE multiple sub-Nyquist sampling encoding NAB National