Burkina Faso Revenue Through Cotton Livelihoods, Trade and Equity (RECOLTE) Project
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Foreign Agricultural Service, United States Department of Agriculture of Agriculture Burkina Faso Revenue through Cotton Livelihoods, Trade and Equity (RECOLTE) Project Final Evaluation January 2020 This publication was produced at the request of the United States Department of Agriculture. It was prepared independently by the Center for Studies, Research and Training on Economic and Social Development (CERFORDES) and authored by Dr. Yaro Yacouba RECOLTE Final Performance Evaluation Report The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Food for Progress Project, OGSM: FCC- 686-2013/027-00 or Revenue through Cotton Livelihoods, Trade, and Equity (RECOLTE), aims to increase organic cotton production and trade in agricultural products at the local, regional and international levels. The $12 million project aims to reach 10,000 producers in the eight production areas in 16 provinces of Burkina Faso. It is implemented by CRS in partnership with the National Union of Cotton Producers of Burkina Faso (UNPCB) and Texas A&M - AgriLife Research. RECOLTE also works in collaboration with the Institute for Environmental and Agricultural Research (INERA), as well as with the Ministry of Agriculture and Food Security and the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Handicrafts. The project worked closely with the office of the President of Faso, which led to the organization of the first edition of the International Cotton and Textile Exhibition (SICOT) in Koudougou. Agreement Number: FCC-686-2013/027-00 Project Duration: 2013-2020 Implemented by: Catholic Relief Services Evaluation Authored by: Dr. Yaro Yacouba of the Center for Studies, Research and Training on Economic and Social Development (CERFORDES) 1 Table of Contents LIST OF TABLES AND GRAPHS ................................................................................................................. 4 ACRONYMS ..................................................................................................................................................... 6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .............................................................................................................................. 9 SUMMARY ................................................................................................................................................... 10 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................ 19 I. NATIONAL CONTEXT AND CONTEXT OF THE PROJECT ............................................................ 20 1.1. Project description ............................................................................................................ 20 1.2. Strategic objectives ........................................................................................................... 21 1.3. Project activities ................................................................................................................ 21 1.4. Project beneficiaries ......................................................................................................... 22 1.5. Objective and scope of the final evaluation .................................................................... 22 II. METHODOLOGY OF THE FINAL EVALUATION ............................................................................ 22 2.1. Data collection ................................................................................................................... 22 2.1.1. Consultation with the RECOLTE project staff ...............................................................................................................23 2.1.2. Literature review .....................................................................................................................................................................23 2.1.3. Interviews with key informants .........................................................................................................................................23 2.1.4. Organization of focus groups ..............................................................................................................................................24 2.1.5. Survey of the organic cotton producer groups.............................................................................................................24 2.2. Data quality assurance ..................................................................................................... 25 2.3. Data processing and analysis ........................................................................................... 26 2.4. Challenges encountered ................................................................................................... 27 2.5. Evaluation limitations ...................................................................................................... 28 2.6. Extrapolation of results .................................................................................................... 28 III. RESULTS OF THE FINAL EVALUATION ........................................................................................ 29 3.1. Relevance ........................................................................................................................... 29 3.1.1. Alignment of the project with government priorities and producers’ needs ................................................... 29 3.1.2. Alignment of the project with the cotton producers’ and the cotton production sector’s development strategies ................................................................................................................................................................................................30 3.1.3. RECOLTE project and government priorities: enthusiasm and commitment .................................................. 34 3.1.4. Relevance of the project within the current economic, cultural and political context ................................ 36 3.1.5. Analysis of the stakeholders’ level of satisfaction .......................................................................................................37 3.1.6. Compliance of the project with government policies and programs ...................................................................39 3.1.7. Alignment of the project with other organic cotton projects and programs ................................................... 40 3.1.8. Government support and beneficiaries’ ownership of the project........................................................................40 3.2. Household vulnerability and resilience to shocks .......................................................... 42 3.2.1. Types of shocks experienced by households ..................................................................................................................42 3.2.2. Household and community resilience competencies among RECOLTE beneficiaries ................................... 45 3.3. Effectiveness ...................................................................................................................... 49 3.3.1. Effectiveness of CRS’ project management ....................................................................................................................49 3.4. Effectiveness of UNPCB’s project management ............................................................ 51 3.4.1. Effectiveness in project design and implementation ................................................................................................. 51 2 3.4.2. Effectiveness of implementation ........................................................................................................................................53 3.5. Efficiency ........................................................................................................................... 75 3.5.1. Profitability of activities .......................................................................................................................................................75 3.5.2. Achievement of objectives ....................................................................................................................................................77 3.6. Sustainability ..................................................................................................................... 78 3.6.1. Level of ownership of the project by UNPCB and project activities likely to continue ................................. 78 3.6.2. Level of ownership of the achievements by the stakeholders .................................................................................80 3.6.3. Main factors likely to impact sustainability ..................................................................................................................81 3.6.4. Sustainable strategies for communities and central government support ...................................................... 82 3.6.5. Use of fair-trade premiums ..................................................................................................................................................82 3.7. Impact ................................................................................................................................ 82 3.7.1. Changes attributable to the project ................................................................................................................................. 83 3.7.2. Changes likely to persist after the end of the