Transportation Department Report to ISC: UNRESTRICTED Council C2011-05 2011 February 07 Page 1 of 6 AIRPORT TRAIL UNDERPASS
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Transportation Department Report to ISC: UNRESTRICTED Council C2011-05 2011 February 07 Page 1 of 6 AIRPORT TRAIL UNDERPASS SUMMARY/ISSUE 2. Options and a validated estimate for the Investigate the Airport Trail underpass cost of constructing the tunnel demand, design, construction process, costs (underpass) portion only; the cost of and funding options. adding the connections to the roadway system within five years; and for the cost PREVIOUS COUNCIL DIRECTION/POLICY of constructing the entire link now. At the Combined Meeting of Council on 2010 3. An analysis of funding options (including November 08, Council moved that with private funding, 3P opportunities, etc.) for respect to Alderman Stevenson’s NM2010-42 the three scenarios listed above, the following be adopted: including an estimate of potential interest charges or other tax supported costs for NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that each. the Administration is directed to immediately 4. The impact on the current 10 year Capital commence negotiations with the Calgary Plan of adoption of each of the above Airport Authority to identify the process to scenarios. construct the underpass, 5. Rail options with or without the tunnel. AND FURTHER BE IT RESOLVED that AND FURTHER BE IT RESOLVED that Administration adds to their work program the Council authorize the additional $250,000 of preliminary design of the ultimate Airport Trail the existing funding from Program 686 underpass from Barlow Trail to Métis Trail (Airport Trail; Deerfoot Trail to Harvest Hills including the approach roadway and a Boulevard) to undertake the work required to provision for future Primary Transit, bring this report to Council. AND FURTHER BE IT RESOLVED that ADMINISTRATION RECOMMENDATIONS: based on the preliminary design of the That Council: ultimate Airport Trail underpass, the 1. Direct Administration to award RFP 10- Administration is directed to prepare a report 1940 for detail design to the highest rated outlining the construction schedule, an proponent, waive the circulation period to estimate of the full cost of the underpass, any Council and proceed with design of the incremental stages thereof and the necessary Airport Trail underpass, four lane road financing including; from Barlow Trail to Métis Trail, and two lane road from Métis Trail to 60 Street NE 1. An analysis of transportation options for (Option 3C); as per the recommended access to the Calgary International cross-section configuration (Attachment Airport. This analysis to include among 1); others a discussion from a City of Calgary 2. Authorize construction of Option 3C upon and Calgary Region perspective of the City Manager, the General Manager, currently available road and transit links Transportation and the General Manager, including planned roadways (SW Ring Corporate Services: Road) to the airport; links currently under (a) Concluding negotiations in regard to construction (96 Avenue Connector) and the occupancy agreement, taking into links to be provided as a result of consideration report C2011-06 Airport Developer obligations (11 Street NE/128 Trail Underpass Supporting Avenue NE bridge over the Deerfoot Information; and Trail). (b) Based on successful conclusion of Approvals: GM (Malcolm Logan), Director (Don Mulligan), Manager (Anne Cataford), Author (Naveed Butt/Amanda Coates) Transportation Department Report to ISC: UNRESTRICTED Council C2011-05 2011 February 07 Page 2 of 6 AIRPORT TRAIL UNDERPASS 2(a), advise Council, proceed with INVESTIGATION construction and conclude At the first meeting of the newly elected negotiations in regard to any other Council in 2010 November, Administration agreement(s) necessary to complete was instructed to urgently investigate the the construction, operation and construction of the Airport Trail underpass in maintenance of the underpass; conjunction with the construction of the new agreements to include additional terms Calgary International Airport fourth runway. and conditions as deemed necessary and to be in content and form satisfactory to Administration has completed an updated the aforementioned parties and the City review of design considerations, costs and Solicitor respectively. procurement options (Attachment 1) and has identified the results of stakeholder 3. Approve a budget appropriation for engagement (Attachment 2). Administration Program 855 Airport Underpass not to has included a summary of previous Council exceed $294.8 million (including $36.0 and Land Use, Planning and Transportation million in bridge financing costs). Committee (LPT) reports on this project Appropriation to include: (Attachment 3). $78.5 million in 2011, $106.6 million in 2012, Timing $69.6 million in 2013, In conjunction with construction of the new $18.7 million in 2014, runway, the Calgary Airport Authority (The $6.1 million per year in 2015-2017 Authority) is closing Barlow Trail between inclusive; and Airport Trail and McKnight Boulevard, which is $3.1 million in 2018. on airport lands. The City has been working Funding to come from: closely with The Authority to coordinate a. Reserve for Future Capital ($25 transportation improvements in the northeast million in 2011), to ensure mobility is maintained after the b. Municipal Sustainability Initiative closure of Barlow Trail in 2011 April. (MSI) Innovation Fund ($123 million in 2018), The Calgary Transportation Plan (CTP) long c. MSI Contingency Fund ($50 range network identifies an Airport Trail link million in 2018); and under the fourth runway. This is also identified d. Reallocation of $97 million from in the 2004 Calgary International Airport Transportation unallocated MSI, Master Plan. Transportation Infrastructure Program 543 Provincial Ring Road Three macro options exist for Council’s Connectors, and other consideration: Transportation Capital Programs to Program 855 Airport Option 1: Do nothing - Abandon the Airport Underpass. Trail link and over time augment the northeast transportation network as necessary. 4. Give first reading to Borrowing Bylaw Number 1B2011 for $173 million MSI Option 2: Build later - Likely using a tunnel funded bullet debt for a term up to seven boring approach. years to finance the construction of the Option 3: Build now - In conjunction with the project and return to Council, when runway development project. appropriate to do so, for second and third reading (Attachment 4). Approvals: GM (Malcolm Logan), Director (Don Mulligan), Manager (Anne Cataford), Author (Naveed Butt/Amanda Coates) Transportation Department Report to ISC: UNRESTRICTED Council C2011-05 2011 February 07 Page 3 of 6 AIRPORT TRAIL UNDERPASS The opportunity to build in conjunction with Administration developed cost estimates for the runway currently exists, however The City the three macro options related to the Airport must act immediately in order to proceed with Trail underpass. Each cost is for this option. infrastructure, independent of project financing costs and is expressed in 2011 Design dollars. Administration has been working with The Option 1: Do nothing – requiring a series of Authority and Transport Canada to improvements in the surrounding road understand the airport’s needs and technical network, estimated to cost $325-$425 million requirements in relation to the tunnel. The in current dollars (excluding financing Authority has updated their design for the charges). Completed over the course of 2011 fourth runway and associated taxiways and - 2040 (or in the region thereof). has advised that the required length of the tunnel has been reduced from 720 meters to Option 2: Build later – requiring bored 615 meters. tunnels and a series of network improvements, estimated to cost $1,545- Administration has confirmed that Transport $1,645 million (excluding financing charges). Canada regulation TP 312 Aerodromes Completed in the region of the 2015 - 2040 Standards and Recommended Practices horizon. renders a segmented tunnel as an Option 3: Build now – tunnel structure with unacceptable design. additional network improvements, phased construction as follows: The proposed design must accommodate the A. Build underpass structure and four lane projected long term travel demand for Airport road from Barlow Trail to 36 Street NE. Trail, taking into consideration the land use Estimated cost $198.6 million. and development pattern and transportation network as contained in the CTP and the B. Build underpass and four lane road from Municipal Development Plan. Peak travel 36 Street NE to Métis Trail. Estimated through the underpass has been investigated cost $208.6 million. for automobiles, trucks and transit users. C. Build A, B and a two lane road from Métis Trail to 60 Street NE. Estimated cost Based on the projected usage, a six lane $222.6 million. (Road already being cross-section is recommended. The proposed completed from 60 Street NE to Stoney underpass cross-section allows flexibility for Trail, targeted for 2011 completion). future conversion from bus based to rail based transit. The cost for Option 3C including additional considerations in relation to construction Phasing and Costs insurance, some property, and delay costs is Construction of Airport Trail would be done in $258.8 million (excluding financing charges of a series of phases. Two phases are currently $36.0 million). Additional costs have been underway: estimated to cover The Authority’s redesign, Airport Trail from 60 Street NE to Stoney project integration, as well as further Trail will be completed in 2011. contingencies for potential delay. Targeted completion