Deerfoot Trail Study
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Phase 1 June 2016 Deerfoot Trail Online Mapping Tool What We Heard Study Report Table of Contents What we heard and what we asked ............................................................................................ 2 Verbatim Comments .................................................................................................................. 4 Stoney Trail North .................................................................................................................. 4 Country Hills Boulevard .......................................................................................................... 6 96 Avenue N.E. / Airport Trail ................................................................................................. 7 Beddington Trail N.E. ............................................................................................................10 64 Avenue N.E. .....................................................................................................................16 McKnight Boulevard N.E........................................................................................................20 32 Avenue N.E. .....................................................................................................................36 16 Avenue N.E. / Highway 1 ..................................................................................................44 Memorial Drive N.E. ..............................................................................................................49 Blackfoot Trail / 17 Avenue S.E. ............................................................................................58 Barlow Trail / Peigan Trail S.E. ..............................................................................................65 Glenmore Trail S.E. ...............................................................................................................71 Heritage Drive S.E. ................................................................................................................86 Southland Drive S.E. .............................................................................................................91 Anderson Road / Bow Bottom Trail S.E. .............................................................................. 100 Douglasdale Boulevard S.E. ................................................................................................ 135 Barlow Trail S.E. .................................................................................................................. 140 130 Avenue S.E. ................................................................................................................. 145 McKenzie Towne Boulevard S.E. ........................................................................................ 148 Stoney Trail South ............................................................................................................... 150 West of Deerfoot Trail .......................................................................................................... 153 East of Deerfoot Trail ........................................................................................................... 161 Page 1 of 167 What we heard and what we asked From June 1 – 30, 2016, participants were asked to provide input about their experiences using Deerfoot Trail by completing an online questionnaire, pinning comments to an online map or attending one of six open houses. The online mapping tool asked participants to drop pins in the areas where they experience the greatest congestion and use the comment box to explain the issue. Comments were limited to 140 characters. A total of 3,364 pins were dropped on the study area online maps. The project team reviewed every comment and categorized all comments by location. This report summarizes the themes that were heard most frequently for each location, and verbatim comments are provided after each summary. Comments that mentioned more than one idea were included in a maximum of three themes. In the verbatim reports, the comments are listed under the theme mentioned first and only recorded one time. Comments related to concerns outside the study area have not been plotted on the maps in this report, but have been recorded in the verbatim comments for the project team’s analysis. The map became so populated with comments that a clean map was posted halfway through the engagement period. Because the maps became so crowded, many of the pins were located a distance from where the comment references. The project team reviewed every comment and allocated it to the closest intersection unless a more specific location was referenced within the comment. May 30 – June 15, 2016 online comment map June 15 – 30, 2016 online comment map Page 2 of 167 Page 3 of 167 Verbatim Comments The verbatim comments have been sorted by interchange and then by theme. Some comments provided feedback on more than one topic. Up to three topics were themed for each comment, and in the verbatim report the comment is found only one time under the first topic mentioned. These have been reported by the first mentioned theme in the verbatim report but please note the first three themes have been recorded by the project team. Some verbatim responses have been spell checked to ensure readability. Stoney Trail North Additional lane(s) needed Needs a carpool lane to free up some space plus it can also be a bike lane. NB & SB Hwy. 2 add center HOV + additional core lane (HOV + 4 core lanes). HOV lanes should NOT replace / reduce # of existing core lanes. Changes to retaining wall required Install Glare Screens on the concrete median between N and Southbound lanes to avoid distraction and secondary accidents in the opposite lanes. Close Access If Deerfoot is to be a freeway limiting of exits and merges is a must. Page 4 of 167 Don’t like non-Calgarians using roadway Airdrie commuters don't pay Calgary taxes, so why do they get a better connection into the city than most residents of Calgary? Install lights Deerfoot is not a freeway. Install light controlled intersections on Deerfoot. Get some order on this road. Use Stoney as your freeway. Interchange design WOW, build a humungous interchange... now, the people that just bypassed Calgary and hit NB highway 2 have to interact with dumbass mall traffic. Likes current state Love free-flowing interchanges. Thank you for this! Well done here! :) Works well! On / off ramps Stoney to Deerfoot south and Deerfoot to Country hills south, connect the onramp to the off- ramp continuous. Poor road design Need to decide if Deerfoot is a freeway or a feeder road and design according to road type. It can't serve all purposes. Signal / sign change needed Replace "SLOWER TRAFFIC KEEP RIGHT" signs with "KEEP RIGHT EXCEPT TO PASS" signs. a sign with travel times to Memorial and Glenmore before the Stoney exit so if it was slow, people could avoid Deerfoot. Speed Get the tandem dump trucks to slow down to the speed limit and stop passing everything in sight. Tolls Put in a toll lane to stop Airdrie from using Calgary amenities for Airdrie taxes. Toll road starting at entrance to Calgary City limits. There is a lot of wear on other roadways in Calgary due to Airdrie commuters. Trucks Add signage not allowing trucks in left lane. Page 5 of 167 Country Hills Boulevard Additional lane(s) needed Similar to Hwy 401. Extend 4th lane from Stoney Trail to C H Blvd. for smoother access to CH Blvd. Lack of consistency Every single interchange on Deerfoot is completely different. How are we supposed to know what to expect? Dynamite every one of them. Signal / sign change needed Add signage similar to what is in Edmonton - 110 km/h at the top of the ramp. Most people do 80, which is dangerous for traffic on highway. Speed Limit signs in this area use a random smattering of non-standard fonts. Shows incompetence of current operator. Signage leads you to the right lane for CHB only to have that lane end. Lane then restarts at exit. This causes very dangerous lane changes. Get rid of the traffic lights! What is with Calgary and their traffic lights at major interchanges? More lights. Build a 4-leaf clover. You are halfway there already. Speed Page 6 of 167 Revise the speed limit on Deerfoot to 80 km/h because all the ramps onto and off are not designed to handle the 100-km limit. Tolls Toll lane for express lane, automatic/electronic charge just like the ones in the US. Volume of traffic – peak hours Merging from Country Hills Blvd onto Deerfoot is a nightmare during rush hour only to have to split off onto airport trail. Want express lanes Given the number of major interchanges in close proximity, it would make sense to use an express/collector system for Deerfoot. 96 Avenue N.E. / Airport Trail Additional lane(s) needed Extending Airport Trail NE straight out to Stoney Trail, east of the airport would reduce congestion on Deerfoot. 96th Ave S to Deerfoot, make a lane instead of merge...this is dangerous. From end to end.... should increase to 4 lanes both ways... Close access Page 7 of 167 Close airport trail westbound at Deerfoot - never should have been opened - too much residential. HOV (High Occupancy Vehicle) NB & SB Hwy. 2 add center HOV + additional core lane (HOV + 4 core lanes). HOV lanes should NOT replace / reduce # of existing core lanes. Interchange design Install Glare Screens on the concrete median between N and Southbound lanes to avoid distraction and secondary accidents in the opposite lanes.