Nation and Memory in
Russia, Poland, and Ukraine
Lecture 11
The Great War
Week 1, Spring Term
Outline
1. National concepts and war aims 2. Galicia: Atrocities, occupation, reconquest 3. The February Revolution 4. Outlook
Putzger, Historischer Weltatlas, pp. 106-107
Pavel Miliukov, leader of the liberal party (Kadets)
Russian Concepts 1914
Tsar and supporter of autocracy
Society
• Strengthening of the authority of the Tsar
Constitutional reforms, participation of society
• Territorial gains in West and
South (Constantinople)
Territorial gains in West and
South (Constantinople)
• Defeat of Germany and Austria Defeat of Germany and Austria • Occupation of East Galicia and Occupation of East Galicia and
Bukowina – Liberation of Russian (East Slavic – Ruthenian) population
Bukowina – Liberation of Russian (East Slavic – Ruthenian) population
• To win the support of the Poles To win the support of the Poles –
– Promise of autonomy of unified ethnic Polish territory under tsarist rule
Promise of autonomy of unified ethnic Polish territory under tsarist rule
Józef Piłsudski
Roman Dmowski
Polish Concepts 1914
- Piłsudski
- Dmowski
- • Independence
- • Autonomy of a unified
Poland under tsa
• Together with Russia
• Together with Austria and
Germany
• Polish nation state, exclusive, mainly Polish Catholics
• Federation of Poland with
Ukraine, Lithuania etc., inclusive
• Assimilationist
• Rights of minorities
• “Piast Poland” – territory in the West
• Enemy No. 1: Germany
• Jagiellonian Poland – territory in the East
• Enemy No. 1: Russia
Ukrainian Concepts 1914
- Russian Ukraine
- East Galicia
- • Defeat of Austria
- • Defeat of Russia
• Autonomy of ethnic • Autonomy (Ukrainian
Ukrainian territory in a Crownland) in Austria, constitutional or democratic Russia partition of Galicia and Lodomeria
• Unification of Ukraine
• Unification of Ukraine under Austrian under Tsar Emperor
Outline
1. National concepts and war aims 2. Galicia: Atrocities, occupation, reconquest 3. The February Revolution 4. Outlook
1914
Multiethnic borderland Confessions/Religions
Crownland Galicia and Lodomeria
Lviv/Lwów/Lemberg
• 8,016,000 inhabitants • 46.5% Roman-Catholic • 42.1% Greek-Catholic • 10.9% Jewish
212,000 inhabitants 51% Roman-Catholic 28% Jewish 19% Greek-Catholic
East Galicia
West Galicia
5,235,000 inhabitants 25.3% Roman-Catholic 12.4% Jewish
2,689,000 inhabitants • 88.6% Roman-Catholic • 7.9% Jewish • 3.2% Greek-Catholic
61.7% Greek-Catholics
Synagogue 'Golden Rose'
One of the Khasidic synagogues
Jewish hospital
Progressive synagogue 'The Temple'
Одна из экзекуций
О. Роман Березовский и крестьяне Лев Кобылянский и Пантелеймон Жабяк
(См.стр. 31). http://www.talergof.org.ua/foto/1-114.html
World War I
Destroyed Jewish settlement in Galicia, 1914 Österreichisches Staatsarchiv, Kriegsarchiv http://kurier.at/thema/erster-weltkrieg/fuer-kaiser-und-vaterland- juedisches-leben-und-sterben-im-ersten-weltkrieg
Saving sacred objects from the fire,
1914 © Österreichisches Staatsarchiv/Kriegsarchiv
Russian Occupation Policy
Making East Galicia Russian: Russification Ukrainians as Little Russians Persecution of Ukrainophiles Church Policy Co-operation with Polish Elites: limited success
Discrimination of Jews
Outline
1. National concepts and war aims 2. Galicia: Atrocities, occupation, reconquest 3. The February Revolution 4. Outlook
Revolutions in Russia
Alexander Kerenski
Vladimir I. Lenin
Consequences of the February
Revolution
For Poles full independence now a realistic option Austrian/German offers no longer very attractive In Galicia: weakens Polish loyalty to Habsburg dynasty
(also result of death of Emperor Franz Josef)
Ukrainians in Galicia: still loyal – need Austrian support against Poles
Most Jews loyal to Austria
Outline
1. National concepts and war aims 2. Galicia: Atrocities, occupation, reconquest 3. The February Revolution 4. Outlook
Brutalisation of political and ethnic conflicts (also availability of weapons and trained soldiers)
Defeats and war related problems undermine loyalty to Austrian and Russian Empire
Possibility of national autonomy or independence have a mobilising effect on ethnic minorities in Empires
Question: who will profit more from destabilisation of old imperial order? Will there be socialist or national revolutions?
What we demand in this war, therefore, is nothing peculiar to ourselves. It is that the world be made fit and safe to live in; and particularly that it be made safe for every peace-loving nation which, like our own, wishes to live its own life, determine its own institutions, be assured of justice and fair dealing by the other peoples of the world as against force and selfish aggression.
XIII. An independent Polish state should be erected which should include the territories inhabited by indisputably Polish populations, which should be assured a free and secure access to the sea, and whose political and economic independence and territorial integrity should be guaranteed by international covenant.
8 January, 1918 President Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen
Points (Delivered in Joint Session of the Congress, January 8, 1918)