Genotypic and Epidemiological Characterization of Mycobacterium Tuberculosis Complex in Ghana
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Genotypic and Epidemiological Characterization of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Complex in Ghana INAUGURALDISSERTATION zur Erlangung der Würde einer Doktors der Philosophie vorgelegt der Philosophisch-Naturwissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Universität Basel von Adwoa Asante-Poku Wiredu aus Santasi (Ghana) Originaldokument gespeichert auf dem Dokumentenserver der Universität Basel edoc.unibas.ch Basel, April 2015 Genehmigt von der Philosophisch-Naturwissenschaftlichen Fakultät auf Antrag von Prof. Dr. Sébastien Gagneux und Prof. Dr. Bouke de Jong. Basel, 9th December, 2014 Prof. Dr. Jörg Schibler Dekan ii Table of content Acknowledgment Research Summary List of Tables List of Figures Abbreviations Chapter 1 Introduction 1 1.1. History and global burden TB 1 1.1.1. Historical facts of TB 1 1.1.2. The global burden of TB today 3 1.1.3. TB in Ghana 7 1.2. Causative agent of TB 10 1.3. Mycobacterium africanum 14 1.4. Pathogenesis of TB 19 1.5. Diagnosis and treatment of TB 23 1.5.1. Diagnosis of TB 23 1.5.2. Treatment of TB 28 1.6. Drug resistance 32 1.7. The nature of genetic diversity within MTBC 36 1.8. Genotyping techniques for identification of MTBC 39 1.9. Consequences of genetic diversity within MTBC 46 Chapter 2: Rationale, Goals and Objectives 2.1. Rationale 49 2.2. Goal 50 2.3. Objectives 51 Chapter 3: Drug susceptibility pattern of Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates from Ghana; correlation with clinical response 52 3.1. Abstract 53 3.2. Introduction 55 3.3. Methods 57 iii 3.4. Definitions 58 3.5. Results 61 3.6. Discussion 65 3.7. Conclusion 67 3.8. Acknowledgement 67 Chapter 4: Establishment of Genotype MTBDRplus for Rapid Detection of Drug Resistant Tuberculosis in Ghana 69 4.1. Abstract 70 4.2. Introduction 71 4.3. Methods 73 4.4. Results 76 4.5. Discussion 81 4.6. Summary 82 4.7. Acknowledgement 82 Chapter 5: Evaluation of customised lineage-specific sets of MIRU-VNTR loci for genotyping Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex isolates in Ghana 83 5.1. Abstract 84 5.2. Introduction 85 5.3. Methods 88 5.4. Results 93 5.6. Discussion and Conclusion 97 Chapter 6: Mycobacterium africanum is associated with patient ethnicity in Ghana 6.1. Abstract 102 6.2. Introduction 103 6.3. Methods 107 6.4 Results 110 6.6. Discussion 116 6.7. Conclusion 120 6.8. Acknowledgement 120 Chapter 7: Mycobacterium africanum is associated with HIV and patient ethnicity in Ghana 7.1. Abstract 121 iv 7.2. Introduction 122 7.3. Methods 124 7.4. Results 127 7.6. Discussion and conclusion 130 Chapter 8: General Discussion 133 Conclusion 145 Outlook and future research work 146 References 150 Curriculum Vitae v Acknowledgements Praise be to God!! This PhD thesis is embedded in a bigger collaboration between the following establishments: the Noguchi Memorial Institute for Medical Research (NMIMR) Ghana, National Tuberculosis programme, Ghana and the Swiss Tropical Institute (SwissTPH). Thus many people in different disciplines contributed to the success of this work and to them all I extended my sincere gratefulness. My first and foremost gratitude goes to Prof. Sebastien Gagneux of the Swiss TPH for mentoring this work. I will forever be grateful to him for accepting to supervise and mentor me. He provided me with the finest scientific counseling and guidance that I could ever wish for. I learnt when to write scientifically and when to be creative in writing and most importantly how to present a story. I particularly thank for him for the fine lessons that I obtained in ʽgood manuscript writingʼ. The time you dedicated to my work both here in Switzerland and back home in Ghana is priceless. Thank- you. I will forever be indebted to Prof Dorothy Yeboah-Manu. She took me in as a sister and nourished my scientific career and pushed me to the limit. I thank her for all her love, patience and understanding which saw me move from a low scientific level to where I am today. ʽAunty Dorothyʼ, ʽMama Dorʼ may God richly bless you!! To the director of my institute, Prof. Kwadwo Koram, thank you for all the personal interest you took in my work and also providing me with the enabling working environment. The work presented here would not have been possible without the approval and the commitments of the following people: Dr Frank Bonsu, programme manager, National tuberculosis programme, Ghana, Dr Audrey Folson, Head, chest clinic Korle-bu teaching Hospital, Dr Akosua Baddo, Korle-bu teaching Hospital, Lt Col Dr Clement Laryea, 37 vi Military hospital and the staff of Ghana health service whose dedication provided an enabling environment to work. It was a pleasure to share scientific and less scientific moments with the TB research unit Swiss TPH: Sonia Borrell, Mireia Coscolla, Daniela Brites, Andrej Tanner, Sebastien Gygli, Liliana Kokusanilwa Rutaihwa, Rhastin Castro, Julia Feldmann and Miriam Reinhard during the laboratory work and for the exchange of ideas during the writing process. A special thank you goes to Sonia who patiently trained me both at NMIMR and at Swiss TPH. We forever share a special bond. Throughout the PhD studies, many trips were taken to several health facilities and communities for participant recruitment and sample collection. These activities were feasible because of the dependable support of TB research team at NMIMR: Isaac Darko Otchere, Stephen Osei-Owusu, Esther Sarpong, Haruna Gyiru, and the entire Buruli ulcer team especially Samuel Aboagye. God bless you. I do appreciate the contribution of staff of the Bacteriology department of NMIMR to the work My special thanks goes to Bijaya Malla, David Stucki, colleague PhD students whom I shared many laughters throughout my stay in Basel. Thank you for your encouraging friendship during the studies. I extend many thanks to senior scientists at the NMIMR and Swiss TPH who in one way or other were very helpful: Dr Michael Ofori, Prof. Kwasi Addo, Dr Jim Brandful, Prof William Ampofo, and Dr Jan Hattendorf. To the love of my life Abeku, thank you very much for all the love and support I have received from you throughout my career development. I hope this PhD will be very beneficial vii to the family. Nana Baa and Efua, mommy will finally close the laptop and listen to you now; your strength kept me going. Thank you for being such wonderful and special gifts. Mummy loves you dearly despite her absence from time to time. Finally I will like to thank my parents and siblings: Prof and Mrs Asante-Poku, Abena and Ama. Thank-you, dad and mom for believing in me. Your little girl has finally made it. A special thanks goes to my nephew: Yaw Arko Amoateng for always checking up on your ʽfavourate auntyʼ. Thanks for your encouragement I was sponsored by the Ghana Government and the Amt für Ausbildungsbeiträge of the county Basel-Stadt. viii Research Summary Tuberculosis (TB) remains a public health challenge. In 2013, TB was estimated to have caused 9 million incident cases of which 1.1 million were coinfected with HIV and 1.5 million deaths worldwide. For the effective control of TB, the use of simplified diagnostic tools for case detection diagnosis of drug resistant TB and understanding the effects of comorbidities such as HIV on the prevalence of TB is paramount. Ghana, housing six of the seven phylogenetic lineages of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) with high TB/HIV prevalence provides a unique opportunity to study and better understand the dynamics of TB. In the context of TB control, we studied the level of drug resistance using phenotypic drug susceptibility testing (DST) and correlated the DST results with patient treatment outcome (Chapter 3). We found a low rate of multidrug-resistant (MDR)-TB rate (1.9%), high isoniazid (INH) mono resistance (15%) and the dependence of treatment outcome on the susceptibility to rifampicin (RIF). For the rapid diagnosis of MDR cases, we further evaluated the accuracy of a molecular base diagnostic tool (Genotype MTBDRplus) and compared it with the gold standard phenotypic DST method (Chapter4). We found 100% correlation for detection of both MDR and RIF mono resistance and 83% for INH mono resistance. The remaining 17% INH resistance detected by standard phenotypic DST but not Genotype MTBDRplus are likely due to molecular mechanisms whose targets are not interrogated by Genotype MTBDRplus. The high overall sensitivity and the relative short turn- around time of Genotype MTBDRplus makes it a valuable addition to diagnostic algorithm in Ghana. The control of TB also depends on understanding the patterns and dynamics of TB transmission to reduce source of infection. Existing tools for studying transmission such as MIRU-15 used for routine molecular epidemiological studies have been shown to exhibit varying discriminatory power among the different human-associated MTBC lineages. We ix established a robust and cost-effective PCR based reduced but lineage-specific set of MIRU- VNTR loci with high discrimination power in the main MTBC circulating in Ghana (Chapter 5). This assay will help identify risk factors that enhance transmission and patient groups at increased risk of developing TB. In addition, this assay can be used to differentiate between exogenous re-infection from true relapse cases. SNP- based genotyping and spoligotyping established that M. africanum (MAF) still causes 20% of all TB cases in Ghana (Chapter 6 and 7). Reasons for the restriction of MAF to West Africa have eluded researchers for many years. Using retrospective isolates, we provide for the first time plausible reason why MAF is restricted to parts of West Africa. We showed a significant association between MAF and the Ewe ethnic group. This association was confirmed using prospective isolates and supports possible host pathogen coevolution inn TB.