Word and Image in Alfonso D'aragona's Manuscript Edition of the Divina Commedia

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Word and Image in Alfonso D'aragona's Manuscript Edition of the Divina Commedia Word and Image in Alfonso d’Aragona’s Manuscript Edition of the Divina Commedia by Marcogildo Lettieri A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Italian Studies University of Toronto © Copyright by Marcogildo Lettieri 2019 Word and Image in Alfonso d’Aragona’s Manuscript Edition of the Divina Commedia Marco Lettieri Doctor of Philosophy Department of Italian Studies University of Toronto 2019 Abstract The purpose of this thesis is to examine the manuscript edition of the Divine Comedy prepared for Alfonso D'Aragona, known as Yates Thompson MS 36 and preserved in the British Library. This is one of the most famous illuminated manuscript of the Divine Comedy, with over 100 miniature illustrations of great artistic merit. Most of the scholarship available on the manuscript is of a historical nature, concerning as it does the authorship of the illustrations and the historical background of the production of the manuscript itself. Valuable as this scholarship is, it does not explain how the images and verbal text interact in both the aesthetic experience of the reader and the interpretation of the poem to which they lead when they work in unison. My task will be to consider the manuscript from a hermeneutical perspective based on the idea of visibile parlare. My analysis of the manuscript will be simultaneously grounded in the dominant theories of manuscript illumination of the late Middle Ages and in the phenomenology of the reading process for texts consisting of script and images related by reciprocal conditioning. Building on the historical research done so far, my thesis will discuss the visibile parlare of the manuscript in the contexts of the paleographic legacy of the fourteenth and early-fifteenth century scribes and rubricators of each canticle of the Divine Comedy, considered in the light of Husserl's and Dufrenne's phenomenology of the aesthetic experience and in relation to Jacques ii Maritain's and Umberto Eco's theories of art and scholasticism. The aesthetic and philosophical interpretation of each canticle will then be evaluated against the background of the interpretive process and textual exegesis of the early commentators of the Divine Comedy. iii Acknowledgments I would like to thank my committee members because without them this thesis would not have been possible. In particular, I would like to thank my thesis supervisor, Professor Domenico Pietropaolo, for having suggested this area of research and assisting with the methodological and critical basis of this study, and for having closely assisted with every step and procedure while providing constant and abundant comments and suggestions; Professor Salvatore Bancheri, Chair of the Department of Italian Studies, for his observations and recommendations at our biannual committee meetings and at many other times throughout the process; Professor Eloisa Morra for her insightful ideas and numerous contributions which have allowed this project to come to fruition. A sincere thank you also goes to the Department of Italian Studies at the University of Toronto, professors and administrative staff alike, for their continued support throughout the entire duration of the program. The images were taken from the British Library online MS viewer and are included by permission of the British Library. http://www.bl.uk/manuscripts/Viewer.aspx?ref=yates_thompson_ms_36_fs001a iv Table of Contents Contents Table of Contents.............................................................................................................................v Preface..............................................................................................................................................1 Physical Description of Manuscript.................................................................................................5 Chapter 1..........................................................................................................................................9 1.1 Visibile Parlare..............................................................................................................9 1.2 Art and Scholasticism and Il Problema Estetico di San Tommaso d'Aquino..............21 Chapter 2: Inferno..........................................................................................................................42 2.1 Canto I: The Three Beasts............................................................................................44 2.2 Canto V: Minos and the Colour Red............................................................................50 2.3 Canto VIII: Dante and Virgil, Intimacy and Companionship......................................63 2.4 Canto XIII: Suicide and the Renaissance....................................................................69 2.5 Canto XXXII: Ugolino: The Voyeuristic Experience..................................................81 Chapter 3: Purgatorio ...................................................................................................................87 3.1 Canto II: The Letter 'P'................................................................................................89 3.2 Canto X: The Nonvisual of the Visibile Parlare..........................................................94 3.3 Canto XVIII: Acedia and the Renaissance................................................................102 3.4 Canto XXII: Dante Rises Above Virgil......................................................................111 Chapter 4: Paradiso.....................................................................................................................130 4.1 Canto VI: Politics and the Roman Exmpire...............................................................132 4.2 Canto X: The Gazes of Dante and Beatrice...............................................................138 v 4.3 Canto XVII: Dante's Exile and his Poetry.................................................................153 4.4 Canto XXVII: A Living Man Reaches New Heights..................................................163 4.5 Canto XXXIII: Where is Saint Bernard?...................................................................170 Conclusion...................................................................................................................................180 Bibliography................................................................................................................................190 vi 1 Preface The majority of studies undertaken on illuminated manuscripts of Dante’s Divine Comedy have been of a historical nature, with emphasis on the authorship of the illustrations and the historical background of the creation of the manuscript. Although very relevant, these studies do not explain how the images and words interact in the aesthetic experience of the reader and in the analysis of the poem. This thesis will investigate whether the images and verbal text could provide a more rigorous and comprehensive evaluation of the Divine Comedy versus words alone, such as a critical edition with a commentary. This analysis will be grounded in the dominant theories of manuscript illumination of the late Middle Ages and in the phenomenology of the aesthetic experience considered in relation to Jacques Maritain’s and Umberto Eco’s theories of art and scholasticism. Before embarking on this exploration, it will be necessary to first provide a physical description of the manuscript analysed in this thesis, namely MS Yates Thompson 36. Information about its script and material will be provided to reveal its place in the manuscript tradition of the fifteenth century in Italy. The manuscript was illuminated by two artists: Priamo della Quercia and Giovanni di Paolo. Della Quercia was responsible for the miniatures in the Inferno and the Purgatorio, while di Paolo illuminated the Paradiso. Throughout this thesis, the styles and criticisms of both artists will be explored. This exploration will examine the choices of colours, shapes and scenes put forth by the artists. Furthermore, I will seek to answer whether an 2 illuminator can be as worthy a critic as literary commentators of the Divine Comedy. As Domenico Pietropaolo suggests, Dante's text was created with the intention to be illuminated: "The wayfarer, who had conceived the Vita Nuova on the structural image of the copyist, who was perhaps himself an amateur artist, and who so admired the skill of Oderisi da Gubbio as an illuminator of manuscripts, quite naturally reserved his first appreciation for the text as an observable phenomenon" (Pietropaolo, 203). Although many commentaries and critical editions of the Divine Comedy will be quoted throughout the thesis, Charles Singleton interpretation, particularly his development of Auerbach’s figural reading of the poem, will play a crucial role in my approach to Dante and his place in Western literature. That being said, all citations of the poem will be from Giorgio Petrocchi’s edition La Commedia secondo l'antica vulgata. In the fourth section of the first chapter, after providing a physical description of the manuscript and outlining the historical principles regarding illuminated manuscripts, the hermeneutical premises of Jacques Maritain’s Art and Scholasticism and Eco’s Il Problema Estetico in San Tommaso d'Aquino will be presented and developed. Utilizing these premises, this thesis will explore the validity of the claim that simple manuscripts without illuminations only
Recommended publications
  • The Political Persecution of a Poet: a Detail of Dante's Exile
    Parkland College A with Honors Projects Honors Program 2012 The olitP ical Persecution of a Poet: A Detail of Dante's Exile Jason Ader Parkland College Recommended Citation Ader, Jason, "The oP litical Persecution of a Poet: A Detail of Dante's Exile" (2012). A with Honors Projects. 44. http://spark.parkland.edu/ah/44 Open access to this Article is brought to you by Parkland College's institutional repository, SPARK: Scholarship at Parkland. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE POLITICAL PERSECUTION OF A POET A Detail of Dante's Exile By Jason Ader John Poling History 101 April 2012 Durante degli Alighieri, known throughout the world as simply Dante, was a fourteenth century Italian poet, philosopher, literary theorist, and politician. He is best known for his epic Commedia, which was later dubbed The Divine Comedy. Commedia is generally considered the greatest Italian literary work and a masterpiece of world literature.1 Due to the turbulent political atmosphere of his time and place, Dante spent over a third of his life living in exile. This paper will explore the details of Dante's exile and the influence that it had upon his work. Dante was born in Florence around 1265 to an aristocratic family of moderate wealth and status. Dante's father was a notary, and Dante was the only child of his father's first marriage. Dante's mother died when he was about thirteen years old. His father then remarried and his second wife bore another son and two daughters before he too died when Dante was about eighteen.2 It is thought that at around six years of age Dante entered school.
    [Show full text]
  • Dante's Political Life
    Bibliotheca Dantesca: Journal of Dante Studies Volume 3 Article 1 2020 Dante's Political Life Guy P. Raffa University of Texas at Austin, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/bibdant Part of the Ancient, Medieval, Renaissance and Baroque Art and Architecture Commons, Italian Language and Literature Commons, and the Medieval History Commons Recommended Citation Raffa, Guy P. (2020) "Dante's Political Life," Bibliotheca Dantesca: Journal of Dante Studies: Vol. 3 , Article 1. Available at: https://repository.upenn.edu/bibdant/vol3/iss1/1 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/bibdant/vol3/iss1/1 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Raffa: Dante's Political Life Bibliotheca Dantesca, 3 (2020): 1-25 DANTE’S POLITICAL LIFE GUY P. RAFFA, The University of Texas at Austin The approach of the seven-hundredth anniversary of Dante’s death is a propi- tious time to recall the events that drove him from his native Florence and marked his life in various Italian cities before he found his final refuge in Ra- venna, where he died and was buried in 1321. Drawing on early chronicles and biographies, modern historical research and biographical criticism, and the poet’s own writings, I construct this narrative of “Dante’s Political Life” for the milestone commemoration of his death. The poet’s politically-motivated exile, this biographical essay shows, was destined to become one of the world’s most fortunate misfortunes. Keywords: Dante, Exile, Florence, Biography The proliferation of biographical and historical scholarship on Dante in recent years, after a relative paucity of such work through much of the twentieth century, prompted a welcome cluster of re- flections on this critical genre in a recent volume of Dante Studies.
    [Show full text]
  • Painting in Renaissance Siena
    Figure r6 . Vecchietta. The Resurrection. Figure I7. Donatello. The Blood of the Redeemer. Spedale Maestri, Torrita The Frick Collection, New York the Redeemer (fig. I?), in the Spedale Maestri in Torrita, southeast of Siena, was, in fact, the common source for Vecchietta and Francesco di Giorgio. The work is generally dated to the 1430s and has been associated, conjecturally, with Donatello's tabernacle for Saint Peter's in Rome. 16 However, it was first mentioned in the nirieteenth century, when it adorned the fa<;ade of the church of the Madonna della Neve in Torrita, and it is difficult not to believe that the relief was deposited in that provincial outpost of Sienese territory following modifications in the cathedral of Siena in the seventeenth or eighteenth century. A date for the relief in the late I4 5os is not impossible. There is, in any event, a curious similarity between Donatello's inclusion of two youthful angels standing on the edge of the lunette to frame the composition and Vecchietta's introduction of two adoring angels on rocky mounds in his Resurrection. It may be said with little exaggeration that in Siena Donatello provided the seeds and Pius II the eli­ mate for the dominating style in the last four decades of the century. The altarpieces commissioned for Pienza Cathedral(see fig. IS, I8) are the first to utilize standard, Renaissance frames-obviously in con­ formity with the wishes of Pius and his Florentine architect-although only two of the "illustrious Si­ enese artists," 17 Vecchietta and Matteo di Giovanni, succeeded in rising to the occasion, while Sano di Pietro and Giovanni di Paolo attempted, unsuccessfully, to adapt their flat, Gothic figures to an uncon­ genial format.
    [Show full text]
  • The Chronicle of Dino Compagni / Translated by Else C. M. Benecke
    #m hbl.stx DG 737.2.C613 le i?mnP/!f? of Dino Compagni / 3 1153 0DSMS117 t, % n WRITTEN •T$' FIRST PRINTED • IN • 1726- PLEASE NOTE It has been necessary to replace some of the original pages in this book with photocopy reproductions because of damage or mistreatment by a previous user. Replacement of damaged materials is both expensive and time-consuming. Please handle this volume with care so that information will not be lost to future readers. Thank you for helping to preserve the University's research collections. THE TEMPLE CLASSICS THE CHRONICLE OF DINO COMPAGNI Digitized'by the Internet Archive in 2010 with funding from Boston Library Consortium Member Libraries http://www.archive.org/details/chronicleofdinocOOcomp mmyi CHRPNICE 92DINO COMPAGNI TRANSITED ^ELSE CM. BENECKE S§ FERRERS HOWELL MDCCCCVI PUBL15H6D- BY-^M D6NT- •AMP-CO : ALDlNe-HOUSe-LOMDON-W-O PRELIMINARY NOTE vii PRELIMINARY NOTE Though Dino Compagni calls his work a Chronicle, it is not (like Giovanni Villani's, for example) a Chronicle in the sense in which the term is now used to express a particular kind of narration dis- " tinguished from a history ; the terms " chronicle and "history" being in Dino's time interchange- able. Dino's book is in form the history of a particular fact, namely, the division of the Guelf party in Florence into the White and the Black Guelfs, with its attendant circumstances, its causes, and its results : but under this form is unfolded at the same time the history of the steps by which the wealthy traders of Florence (jfropolani, popolani grassi, and collectively popolo grasso) organised in the greater guilds (see Appendix II.) acquired and retained the control of the machinery of govern- ment in the city and its outlying territory (contado), excluding (practically) from all participation therein on the one hand the Magnates (i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • Download a Pdf File of This Issue for Free
    Issue 70: Dante's Guide to Heaven and Hell Dante and the Divine Comedy: Did You Know? What a famous painting suggests about Dante's life, legend, and legacy. Big Man in the Cosmos A giant in the world of which he wrote, laurel-crowned Dante stands holding his Divine Comedy open to the first lines: "Midway this way of life we're bound upon, / I woke to find myself in a dark wood, / Where the right road was wholly lost and gone." Of course, his copy reads in Italian. Dante was the first major writer in Christendom to pen lofty literature in everyday language rather than in formal Latin. Coming 'Round the Mountain Behind Dante sits multi-tiered Mount Purgatory. An angel guards the gate, which stands atop three steps: white marble for confession, cracked black stone for contrition, and red porphyry for Christ's blood sacrifice. With his sword, the angel marks each penitent's forehead with seven p's (from Latin peccatum, "sin") for the Seven Deadly Sins. When these wounds are washed away by penance, the soul may enter earthly paradise at the mountain's summit. Starry Heights In Paradiso, the third section of the Comedy, Dante visits the planets and constellations where blessed souls dwell. The celestial spheres look vague in this painting, but Dante had great interest in astronomy. One of his astronomical references still puzzles scholars. He notes "four stars, the same / The first men saw, and since, no living eye" (Purgatorio, I.23-24), apparently in reference to the Southern Cross. But that constellation was last visible at Dante's latitude (thanks to the earth's wobbly axis) in 3000 B.C., and no one else wrote about it in Europe until after Amerigo Vespucci's voyage in 1501.
    [Show full text]
  • Italian Poet, Born at Florence, 1265; Died at Ravenna, Italy, 14 September, 1321
    “Dante Alighieri” Catholic Encyclopedia Italian poet, born at Florence, 1265; died at Ravenna, Italy, 14 September, 1321. His own statement in the "Paradiso" (xxii, 112-117) that he was born when the sun was in Gemini, fixes his birthday between 18 May and 17 June. He was the son of Alighiero di Bellincione Alighieri, a notary belonging to an ancient but decadent Guelph family, by his first wife, Bella, who was possibly a daughter of Durante di Scolaio Abati, a Ghibelline noble. A few months after the poet's birth, the victory of Charles of Anjou over King Manfred at Benevento (26 February, 1266) ended the power of the empire in Italy, placed a French dynasty upon the throne of Naples, and secured the predominance of the Guelphs in Tuscany. Dante thus grew up amidst the triumphs of the Florentine democracy, in which he took some share fighting in the front rank of the Guelph cavalry at the battle of Campaldino (11 June, 1289), when the Tuscan Ghibellines were defeated by the forces of the Guelph league, of which Florence was the head. This victory was followed by a reformation of the Florentine constitution, associated with the name of Giano della Bella, a great-hearted noble who had joined the people. By the Ordinances of Justice (1293) all nobles and magnates were more strictly excluded from the government, and subjected to severe penalties for offences against plebeians. To take any part in public life, it was necessary to be enrolled in one or other of the "Arts" (the guilds in which the burghers and artisans were banded together), and accordingly Dante matriculated in the guild of physicians and apothecaries.
    [Show full text]
  • Di Piero Gualtieri
    Oltre Bianchi e Neri. I rapporti fra Pistoia e Firenze negli anni della vita politica di Dante di Piero Gualtieri Reti Medievali Rivista, 18, 1 (2017) <http://www.retimedievali.it> Dante attraverso i documenti. II. Presupposti e contesti dell’impegno politico a Firenze (1295-1302) a cura di Giuliano Milani e Antonio Montefusco Firenze University Press Reti Medievali Rivista, 18, 1 (2017) <http://rivista.retimedievali.it> ISSN 1593-2214 © 2017 Firenze University Press DOI 10.6092/1593-2214/5151 Dante attraverso i documenti. II. Presupposti e contesti dell’impegno politico a Firenze (1295-1302) a cura di Giuliano Milani e Antonio Montefusco Oltre Bianchi e Neri. I rapporti fra Pistoia e Firenze negli anni della vita politica di Dante di Piero Gualtieri Il rapporto fra Firenze e Pistoia alla fine del Duecento fu un rapporto profondo e complesso, che trovò diretta eco nella vita e nelle opere di Dante. Il contributo intende analizzare, dal punto di vista pistoiese, i principali ambiti di interazione (sociali e familiari, economici, istituzionali) fra i due contesti cittadini negli anni dell’impegno politico di Dante, evidenziando le reciproche in- fluenze e l’impatto che esse ebbero sulle vicende di entrambe al di là dell’importazione a Firenze del conflitto fra Bianchi e Neri. The relationship between Florence and Pistoia at the end of the Thirteenth century was a deep and complex one, and it had a direct impact on the life and the works of Dante. The paper aims at analysing from a Pistoian perspective the social, familiar, economic and institutional con- nections between the two cities in the years of Dante’s political engagement.
    [Show full text]
  • The Mariology of St. Bonaventure As a Source of Inspiration in Italian Late Medieval Iconography
    José María SALVADOR GONZÁLEZ, La mariología de San Buenaventura como fuente de inspiración en la iconografía bajomedieval italiana The mariology of St. Bonaventure as a source of inspiration in Italian late medieval iconography La mariología de San Buenaventura como fuente de inspiración en la iconografía bajomedieval italiana1 José María SALVADOR-GONZÁLEZ Universidad Complutense de Madrid [email protected] Recibido: 05/09/2014 Aceptado: 05/10/2014 Abstract: The central hypothesis of this paper raises the possibility that the mariology of St. Bonaventure maybe could have exercised substantial, direct influence on several of the most significant Marian iconographic themes in Italian art of the Late Middle Ages. After a brief biographical sketch to highlight the prominent position of this saint as a master of Scholasticism, as a prestigious writer, the highest authority of the Franciscan Order and accredited Doctor of the Church, the author of this paper presents the thesis developed by St. Bonaventure in each one of his many “Mariological Discourses” before analyzing a set of pictorial images representing various Marian iconographic themes in which we could detect the probable influence of bonaventurian mariology. Key words: Marian iconography; medieval art; mariology; Italian Trecento painting; St. Bonaventure; theology. Resumen: La hipótesis de trabajo del presente artículo plantea la posibilidad de que la doctrina mariológica de San Buenaventura haya ejercido notable influencia directa en varios de los más significativos temas iconográficos
    [Show full text]
  • Combat Trauma in Dante's Inferno Patrick
    A Hell of One’s Own: Combat Trauma in Dante’s Inferno Patrick Whalen Must you have battle in your heart forever? —Odyssey 12:132 ante Alighieri was twenty-four years old in 1289 when he saw combat in the Battle of Campaldino as a “feditore”, a cavalry soldier from Florence.1 From what we D know of the battle,2 Dante’s unit would have been one of the first to be engaged by the oncoming Aretine cavalry, and for the first several minutes of the battle, Dante would have faced the prospect of imminent death when he saw the men and horses of his unit dying as their resistance crumbled before the Aretine’s charge. The historian Herbert Oerter notes that the catastrophe of this initial attack actually saved the Florentine forces, and likely Dante with them, because it caused Corso Donati, the flamboyant commander of the Florentine reserves, to disregard his orders and commit to the battle immediately. His orders, on pain of death, were to wait for a signal from one of the senior officers, Guillaume de Durfort. But Guillaume was dying— bleeding out on the plain—and would never give the signal. As it happened, Corso’s reserve position was in defilade to the attacking Aretine’s northern flank. When Corso attacked, his cavalry pierced the unexpecting and unprotected flank of the Aretine force, causing massive chaos and an almost immediate disintegration of the Aretine attack. The battle was over in a few 1 Robert M. Durling and Ronald L. Martinez, Inferno (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996), 88.
    [Show full text]
  • Celebrating the City: the Image of Florence As Shaped Through the Arts
    “Nothing more beautiful or wonderful than Florence can be found anywhere in the world.” - Leonardo Bruni, “Panegyric to the City of Florence” (1403) “I was in a sort of ecstasy from the idea of being in Florence.” - Stendahl, Naples and Florence: A Journey from Milan to Reggio (1817) “Historic Florence is an incubus on its present population.” - Mary McCarthy, The Stones of Florence (1956) “It’s hard for other people to realize just how easily we Florentines live with the past in our hearts and minds because it surrounds us in a very real way. To most people, the Renaissance is a few paintings on a gallery wall; to us it is more than an environment - it’s an entire culture, a way of life.” - Franco Zeffirelli Celebrating the City: the image of Florence as shaped through the arts ACM Florence Fall, 2010 Celebrating the City, page 2 Celebrating the City: the image of Florence as shaped through the arts ACM Florence Fall, 2010 The citizens of renaissance Florence proclaimed the power, wealth and piety of their city through the arts, and left a rich cultural heritage that still surrounds Florence with a unique and compelling mystique. This course will examine the circumstances that fostered such a flowering of the arts, the works that were particularly created to promote the status and beauty of the city, and the reaction of past and present Florentines to their extraordinary home. In keeping with the ACM Florence program‟s goal of helping students to “read a city”, we will frequently use site visits as our classroom.
    [Show full text]
  • Dante Alighieri's Divine Comedy – Inferno
    DIVINE COMEDY -INFERNO DANTE ALIGHIERI HENRY WADSWORTH LONGFELLOW ENGLISH TRANSLATION AND NOTES PAUL GUSTAVE DORE´ ILLUSTRATIONS JOSEF NYGRIN PDF PREPARATION AND TYPESETTING ENGLISH TRANSLATION AND NOTES Henry Wadsworth Longfellow ILLUSTRATIONS Paul Gustave Dor´e Released under Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial Licence. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/us/ You are free: to share – to copy, distribute, display, and perform the work; to remix – to make derivative works. Under the following conditions: attribution – you must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author or licensor (but not in any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work); noncommercial – you may not use this work for commercial purposes. Any of the above conditions can be waived if you get permission from the copyright holder. English translation and notes by H. W. Longfellow obtained from http://dante.ilt.columbia.edu/new/comedy/. Scans of illustrations by P. G. Dor´e obtained from http://www.danshort.com/dc/, scanned by Dan Short, used with permission. MIKTEXLATEX typesetting by Josef Nygrin, in Jan & Feb 2008. http://www.paskvil.com/ Some rights reserved c 2008 Josef Nygrin Contents Canto 1 1 Canto 2 9 Canto 3 16 Canto 4 23 Canto 5 30 Canto 6 38 Canto 7 44 Canto 8 51 Canto 9 58 Canto 10 65 Canto 11 71 Canto 12 77 Canto 13 85 Canto 14 93 Canto 15 99 Canto 16 104 Canto 17 110 Canto 18 116 Canto 19 124 Canto 20 131 Canto 21 136 Canto 22 143 Canto 23 150 Canto 24 158 Canto 25 164 Canto 26 171 Canto 27 177 Canto 28 183 Canto 29 192 Canto 30 200 Canto 31 207 Canto 32 215 Canto 33 222 Canto 34 231 Dante Alighieri 239 Henry Wadsworth Longfellow 245 Paul Gustave Dor´e 251 Some rights reserved c 2008 Josef Nygrin http://www.paskvil.com/ Inferno Figure 1: Midway upon the journey of our life I found myself within a forest dark..
    [Show full text]
  • Civic Genealogy from Brunetto to Dante
    University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations 2016 The Root Of All Evil: Civic Genealogy From Brunetto To Dante Chelsea A. Pomponio University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations Part of the Medieval Studies Commons Recommended Citation Pomponio, Chelsea A., "The Root Of All Evil: Civic Genealogy From Brunetto To Dante" (2016). Publicly Accessible Penn Dissertations. 2534. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/2534 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/edissertations/2534 For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Root Of All Evil: Civic Genealogy From Brunetto To Dante Abstract ABSTRACT THE ROOT OF ALL EVIL: CIVIC GENEALOGY FROM BRUNETTO TO DANTE Chelsea A. Pomponio Kevin Brownlee From the thirteenth century well into the Renaissance, the legend of Florence’s origins, which cast Fiesole as the antithesis of Florentine values, was continuously rewritten to reflect the changing nature of Tuscan society. Modern criticism has tended to dismiss the legend of Florence as a purely literary conceit that bore little relation to contemporary issues. Tracing the origins of the legend in the chronicles of the Duecento to its variants in the works of Brunetto Latini and Dante Alighieri, I contend that the legend was instead a highly adaptive mode of legitimation that proved crucial in the negotiation of medieval Florentine identity. My research reveals that the legend could be continually rewritten to serve the interests of collective and individual authorities. Versions of the legend were crafted to support both republican Guelfs and imperial Ghibellines; to curry favor with the Angevin rulers of Florence and to advance an ethnocentric policy against immigrants; to support the feudal system of privilege and to condemn elite misrule; to denounce the mercantile value of profit and ot praise economic freedom.
    [Show full text]