EIS 1767
AA066857
Assessment of mineral resouru's in the Eden CRA study area MSW DEPT P1KARY IUS1RIES
AA066857
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 :0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ( 0 0 0 0 0
I
0 (
0 I
I I
I I
Assessment of Mineral Resources in the Eden CRA Study Area A report undertaken for the NSW CRAIRFA Steering Committee 27 February 1998 ASSESSMENT OF MINERAL RESOURCES IN THE EDEN CRA STUDY AREA
BUREAU OF RESOURCE SCIENCES
GEOLOGICAL SURVEY OF NSW DEPARTMENT OF MINERAL RESOURCES
A report undertaken for the NSW CRA/RFA Steering Committee Project Number NE 08/ES
27 February 1998
REPORT STATUS This report has been prepared as a working paper for the NSW CRAIRFA Steering Committee under the direction of the Economic and Social Technical Committee. It is recognised that it may contain errors that require correction but it is released to be consistent with the principle that information related to the comprehensive regional assessment process in New South Wales will be made publicly available. For more information and for information on access to data contact the:
Resource and Conservation Division, Department of Urban Affairs and Planning GPO Box 3927 SYDNEY NSW 2001 Phone: (02) 9228 3166 Fax: (02) 9228 4967 Forests Taskforce, Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet 3-5 National Circuit BARTON ACT 2600
Phone: 1800 650 983 Fax: (02) 6271 5511
© Crown copyright [June 1997]
This project has been jointly funded by the New South Wales and Commonwealth Governments. The work undertaken within this project has been managed by the joint NSW / Commonwealth CRAIRFA Steering Committee which includes representatives from the NSW and Commonwealth Governments and stakeholder groups.
The project has been overseen and the methodology has been developed through the Economic and Social Technical Committee which includes representatives from the NSW and Commonwealth Governments and stakeholder groups.
The collection of information and drafting of this report were undertaken cooperatively between officers of the Geological Survey of New South Wales and the Bureau of Resource Sciences: Geological Survey of New South Wales David Suppel, Greg MacRae, Adelmo Agostini, Roger McEviliy, Alex Ramsland. Bureau of Resource Sciences Yanis Miezitis, Subhash Jaireth, Aden McKay, Keith Porritt, Don Perkin, Lloyd David, Stuart Girvan, Andrew Lucas, Tim Johns, Neil Corby (Australian Geological Survey Organisation).
ISBN 0-7313-1575-8
Disclaimer While every reasonable effort has been made to ensure that this document is correct at the time of printing, the State of New South Wales, its agents and employees, and the Commonwealth of Australia, its agents and employees, do not assume any responsibility and shall have no liability, consequential or otherwise, of any kind, arising from the use or reliance on any of the information contained in this document. CONTENTS
8.7 VOLCANIC HOSTED MASSIVE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY SULPHIDE BASE METAL DEPOSITS (FIGURE 10) 28 8.8 TUNGSTEN MOLYBDENUM VEIN INTRODUCTION 1 DEPOSITS (FIGURE 11) 28 8.9 TUNGSTEN SKARN DEPOSITS (FIGURE ADMINISTRATION OF MINING AND 12) 32 EXPLORATION TITLES 2 8.10 T[N VEIN DEPOSITS (FIGURE 13) 32 2.1 MINERAL EXPLORATION AND MINING 2 8.11 SEDIMENT HOSTED COPPER DEPOSITS 2.2 CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL AND SANDSTONE URANIUM DEPOSITS (FIGURE 14) EXTRACTION 3 32 8.12 CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS AND DIMENSION STONE (FIGURE 15) 35 GEOLOGICAL SETTING 4 8.13 PYROPHYLLITE (FIGURE 5) 35 3.1 MAJOR EVENTS 4 8.14 POTENTIAL FOR OTHER COMMODITIES IN THE EDEN REGION 35 HISTORY OF MINING AND 8.15 SUMMARY OF POTENTIAL MINERAL MINERAL EXPLORATION 8 RESOURCES, EDEN REGION 3
KNOWN MINERAL RESOURCES AND CONCLUSIONS 41 MINERAL PRODUCTION 10 5.1 CURRENT QUARRYING AND MINING 10 5.2 MAJOR HISTORIC MINING AREAS 10 Figures 1 Exploration expenditure in the Eden region MINERAL EXPLORATION AND during 1969-1995 LAND ACCESS 16 2 Industrial mineral and construction material sites 3 Relation between levels of resource potential MINERAL POTENTIAL ASSESSMENT and levels of certainty METHODOLOGY 19 4 Slate belt gold tracts 5 Epithermal gold tracts 6 Gold in alkaline rocks tracts POTENTIAL MINERAL RESOURCES, 7 Granite hosted gold tracts EDEN REGION 21 8 Alluvial gold tracts 8.1 SLATE-BELT GOLD (FIGURE 4) 21 9 Porphyry copper-gold tracts 8.2 EPITHERMAL GOLD-SILVER DEPOSITS 10 Volcanic hosted massive sulphide base metals (FIGURE 5) 21 tracts 8.3 GOLD DEPOSITS ASSOCIATED WITH 11 Tungsten-molybdenum veins tracts ALKALINE ROCKS (FIGURE 6) 24 12 Tungsten skarn tracts 8.4 GRANITE HOSTED GOLD DEPOSITS 13 Tin veins tracts (FIGURE 7) 24 14 Sediment hosted copper and sandstone 8.5 PLACER GOLD DEPOSITS (FIGURE 8) 24 uranium tracts 8.6 PORPHYRY COPPER-GOLD DEPOSITS 15 Construction materials tracts (FIGURE 9) 28 CONTENTS
Tables 1 Summary of geological and mineralising events 2 Identified resources in the Eden region 3 Summary of potential mineral resources as assessed by BRS abd NSW DMR for the various tracts in 1997
Maps back pocket 1 Geology of Eden CRA 2 Mineral occurrences, deposits, and major faults 3 Composite mineral potential 4 Cumulative mineral potential 5 Weighted composite mineral potential
Appendices 42 Methodology for assessment of potential (undiscovered) mineral resources Mineral resource assessment and mineral deposit models Metadata sheets Mineral occurrences, old mines, deposits and current operations within the region and outside the region Mining titles in the Eden region
References 103
Addendum 1 105 An Economic Assessment of Selected Forest Uses in the Eden Region of New South Wales: Interim Report I .I EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
I This report has been prepared for the joint particular types of mineral deposits. An Commonwealth/State Steering Committee which assessment of the potential resources of an area is oversees the comprehensive regional assessments then an estimate of the likelihood of occurrence of I of forests in New South Wales. mineral deposits which may be of a sufficient size and grade to constitute a mineral resource. The comprehensive regional assessments (CRAs) provide the scientific basis on which the State and In this study mineral potential tracts were I Commonwealth governments will sign regional identified for eleven types of metallic mineral forest agreements (RFAs) for the major forests of deposits (which included different styles of gold, New South Wales. These agreements will silver, base metal, tungsten, and tin deposition), for • determine the future of the State's forests, pyrophyllite (a mineral used in the ceramics • providing a balance between conservation and industry) and for construction materials. The tracts ecologically sustainable use of forest resources. were then combined to present a weighted composite mineral potential of the region. This This report was undertaken to provide a regional result provides some perspective to the relative I assessment of the mineral resources of the Eden region, which occupies the southeastern corner of economic significance between different types of mineral deposits (an area with high potential for New South Wales. The assessment is based on the • gold mineralisation would rate higher than an area known mineral occurrences and resources of the I region and on the potential for undiscovered with high potential for pyrophyllite, given the relative market prices of the two commodities). mineral resources, based on mineral exploration, I geology and other geoscientific information of the Seven hardrock quarries, three construction I area. sandpits and numerous pits winning unprocessed road materials currently operate in the Eden The assessment of the mineral resource potential region, and milling of pyrophyllite occurs on a I was conducted for the whole of the Eden region limited scale at Back Creek west of Pambuia. and is based on data and recent geological reports provided by the NSW Department of Mineral In the past, production of metals from the Eden Resources (DMR). Professional staff of the region has been largely from alluvial and primary Commonwealth Bureau of Resource Sciences gold deposits and granite-hosted bismuth- (BRS), the Geological Survey of NSW (a division molybdenum deposits. The study indicates that the of DMR) collaborated in the preparation of the highest potential for future discoveries is for I assessment. The Australian Bureau of Agricultural epithermal gold-silver, granite-hosted gold, and and Resource Economics (ABARE) provided an slate-belt gold. economic assessment of mineral resources and mining. The methodology adopted by BRS and DMR to I assess the mineral potential of the region followed that developed by the United States Geological Survey, which has been used for mineral resource assessments of forest areas in North America and I elsewhere. This methodology identifies geological I units (referred to as tracts) which could contain I 27th February 1998 Eden Region Mineral Assessment
1. INTRODUCTION
The Eden region comprises an area of about 8100 niagnetics and landsat images. square kilometres and occurs in the southeastern It is important to note that Eden has not been corner of New South Wales (Map 1). It extends subjected to a regional coverage of detailed high from east of Bombala and Nimmitabel to the coast, resolution airborne geophysical survey; such and from the Victorian border to just north of surveys would generate new data and an improved Bermagui. Known mineral resources and potential understanding of mineral deposition in the region. (undiscovered) mineral resources have been assessed as part of the Comprehensive Regional Conclusions published on the Lachian Fold Belt in Assessment (CRA) of the forest areas in the Eden a 1995 issue of Economic Geology were also region. This region is referred to in this report as considered in this assessment. 'Eden', or 'the Eden region'. Appendix C contains data documentation for The assessment of the mineral resources was mineral occurrence locations, geological and conducted on a regional scale for the whole of airborne geophysical data, and for mining Eden and is based on data and recent geological tenements. reports provided by NSW Department of Mineral Resources (DMR). Professional staff of the Bureau of Resource Sciences (BRS), the Geological Survey of NSW (a division of DMR), and the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics (ABARE) collaborated in the preparation of this assessment. DMR reports on the Bega-Mallacoota 1:250 000 geological sheet (Lewis et al 1994), the Bega metallogenic 1:250 000 sheet (Herzberger and Barnes, 1975), Geology of New South Wales (Scheibner and Basden, 1996) and other published reports and unpublished reports by exploration companies were some of the sources of information on identified mineral resources in Eden. These reports describe the geology, mineral resources and mineral exploration of Eden. Prior to the assessment of mineral resources, the DMR compiled the available geoscientific data for the region. Assembled data on which the mineral resource assessment is based include: an updated mineral occurrence dataset for the region, a seamless coverage of digital 1:250 000 geological maps for surface and solid geology, and Eden Region Mineral Assessment 27th February 1998 2. ADMINISTRATION OF MINING AND EXPLORATION TITLES
in the land grants, and in those cases the minerals are owned privately.
Mineral exploration and mining in New South 2.1.1 Exploration Licences Wales is principally governed by the Mining Act Exploration Licences enable mineral exploration 1992. Exploration and mining for petroleum is and prospecting to be undertaken. The size of governed by the Petroleum (Onshore) Act 1991. areas which can be granted ranges from about 3 Both Acts are administered by the Department of square kilometres (one unit) to about 300 square Mineral Resources and provide for a range of kilometres (100 units). A unit is an area bounded conditions to be included in the tenures granted for by a minute of longitude by a minute of latitude. exploration and mining to cover requirements for Areas of more than 100 units can be granted in exploration and mining methods, professionalism special cases. Exploration licences are normally in carrying out operations, reporting and care of granted for a period of two years and may be environment, and to address land owner and renewed for further periods. These licences allow occupier interests. The provisions of the for geological and geophysical surveying, Petroleum (Onshore) Act 1991 are rather similar to sampling, drilling, trenching and other exploration those of the Mining Act 1992 and will not be techniques as applied for by the applicant. Before elaborated upon further. any private lands are entered under an exploration Under the Mining Act 1992 there are three licence the owner and any occupier must be principal forms of title, Exploration Licence, notified and an access agreement entered into by Assessment Lease and Mining Lease. To cater for the exploration licence holder and the land owner the smaller operations, a Mineral Claim is a title and occupier. All exploration licences contain which can be granted for prospecting and mining conditions, including ones specifying the amount in areas up to two hectares in size. In the opal required to be expended on exploration during the fields an Opal Prospecting Licence can also be period of the licence. A security deposit must also granted to assist in the search for opal within larger be lodged to cover the exploration licence holder's paddock size areas but these are short term titles, obligations to comply with the licence conditions. usually of 28 days duration. 2.1.2 Assessment Leases Under the Mining Act, tenures for exploration and mining can be granted over both Crown and The Assessment Lease is a relatively new tenure private land, and over both Crown and privately for New South Wales having been introduced by owned minerals. Although most minerals are the Mining Act 1992. The purpose of this tenure is owned by the Crown, there are cases, particularly to enable detailed evaluation of mineral deposits to where original land grants occurred in the 1 800s, be carried out after the normal period of where the minerals were not reserved to the Crown exploration but where, for some special reasons, 27" February 1998 Eden Region Mineral Assessment S the project is not ready to be applied for under Depending upon circumstances, a commission of Mining Lease. Such reasons can be of an inquiry to hear views about the particular project economic nature eg. the deposit found is not can be required and the recommendations of the presently economic to develop, or could be inquiry are taken into consideration as to whether practical reasons such as a need to develop specific or not development consent should be granted and, processing methods to extract a particular mineral if so, upon what conditions. from the host rock. There is no maximum size for In granting mining leases, the views of all an assessment lease, size and dimensions of areas appropriate Government departments and being such as are necessary and appropriate. authorities are obtained and appropriate conditions These titles can be granted for a period of five to meet respective requirements are formulated for years and renewed for a further period of five inclusion in the lease documents. years. Similar conditions on expenditure, reporting of progress and security are required as Records of all titles and applications for titles 5 in exploration licences. Where access to lands is under the Mining Act are kept by the Department required appropriate access arrangements and of Mineral Resources as required by the Act. consents must be obtained.
2.1.3 Mining Leases Mining Leases are granted to enable mining A number of State and Local Government agencies operations to be carried out. There is no maximum control the extraction of construction materials. size for a mining lease and dimensions and area Some materials, like clay and shale, are classed as can be such as are needed and appropriate for the minerals under the Mining Act 1992 and can be particular mining operation. Mining leases are extracted under mining titles issued by the generally granted for a period of twenty one years Department of Mineral Resources. Other materials but can be granted for longer or lesser periods, such as sand and gravel, and crushed rock, can be depending upon circumstances. Leases can be extracted from Crown Land under titles issued by renewed. Mining leases enable operations, subject agencies such as State Forests and the Department to appropriate conditions, to be undertaken by of Land and Water Conservation. In each case, open cut (surface) or underground methods. development consent must be obtained from the Royalty is payable on all minerals recovered at the local Council before extraction can proceed. rate prescribed by the Mining Act 1992 or at such additional rates as may be specified. The holders Where construction materials are present on of mining leases are required to lodge a security private land, they may be extracted by the land deposit with the Minister commensurate with the owner or by a private company which has an size of the mining operation to ensure compliance agreement with the land owner after obtaining with conditions of the lease. development consent from the local Council. The Department of Mineral Resources has a 2.1.4 Compliance with Other Legislation recognised and accepted role in assessing the State's resources of construction materials and Applicants for and holders of titles under the providing advice on their management and Mining Act 1992 are required to comply with the extraction. It is also responsible under the Mines provisions of other appropriate legislation such as Inspection Act 1901 (as amended) for ensuring the the Environment Planning and Assessment Act safe operation of the State's mines and quarries. 1979 and the endangered flora and fauna legislation. In particular, mining lease applicants are required under the Environment Planning and Assessment Act to obtain development consent before a mining lease can be granted under the Mining Act 1992. The lodgement of the development consent application normally includes the submission of an environment impact statement which is put on display for public comment as part of the application processing. Eden Region Mineral Assessment 271h February 1998
3. GEOLOGICAL SETTING
The Eden region occurs within the Eastern Belt of Following this deformation event, the Yalmy Group, the Lachian Fold Belt (LFB) in south eastern a uniform progression of quartz-rich marine Australia. Major geological and mineralising events sandstones was deposited. Rare mafic volcanic are described in Table 1. The table is based on the detritus has been identified in the Yalmy Group. work of Lewis etal. (1994) The geology of much of The rocks probably represent a (more proximal) the region, particularly the heavily forested areas, is turbidite facies with sediment input from the still not known in detail. Wagga—Omeo belt to the west and north-west. Most areas show a progressive thinning of beds up- 3.1 MAJOR EVENTS sequence as the sediment input decreased. Typically the rocks start with thick-bedded sandstone and Major geological events, rock units and mineralising become thinner-bedded and finer grained, finishing events for the Eden region are: with fine sandstone or siltstone.
3.1.1 Late Cambrian to Early Silurian 3.1.3 Middle Silurian to Early Devonian In the earliest phase of development of the Eden A period of deformation (Quidongan) in the Middle region, two separate terranes existed. They were the Silurian is evident from an angular unconformity Mainland (Molong-Monaro) Terrane, the more separating the Yalmy Group from the overlying extensive unit which covers most of the study area, Bredbo Group. This deformation caused some and the Narooma Terrane of much more limited warping and broad folding. The areal extent and extent, mainly occurring north of the study area intensity of deformation is not known. (Scheibner & Basden, 1996). Both terranes ranged in age from the Late Cambrian to Early Silurian and Deposition of the Bredbo Group was in a shallow were accreted before the Late Silurian granite marine basin probably caused by extensional tectonic activity which created widespread rifling emplacement. with contemporaneous extrusive and shallow The earliest known deposition in the study area intrusive volcanic activity. The sequence consists of commenced with a monotonous sequence of felsic volcanics, sandstone, siltstone and limestone. sandstone and siltstone of the Adaminaby Group, The main outcrops are west of the study area in the deposited in a major turbidite fan system. These Cooma and Quidong areas. rocks are conformably overlain by a predominantly shaly sequence, the Bendoc Group. The earliest basin deposits include thin calcareous rnudstone, reefal limestone pods and reworked A separate rock sequence, the Wagonga Group, volcanic sandstone. These basal units are followed deposited in the Narooma Terrane, is represented by by several cycles of thick volcanic accumulations abyssal oceanic sediment and mafic volcanics. and monotonous thin-bedded mudstone/ashstone. Many of the volcanic units are rhyolitic to dacitic 3.1.2 Early to Middle Silurian crystal-rich volcanic sandstone, a mix of primary (ignimbrite) and secondary deposits plus some lava On the Mainland Terrane an Early Silurian flows. Green slaty shale forms most of the final deformation (Benambran deformation, Table 1) depositional cycle. These are interbedded with caused folding and thrusting in Ordovician reworked volcanic sandstone, massive limestone, sequences resulting in the development of an fine feldspathic sandstone, shale and basalt flows. angular unconformity in the west of the Eden region.
7 Table 1: Summary of Geological and Mineralising Events
AGE GEOLOGICAL MAJOR GEOLOGICAL UNITS MAGMATISMNOLCANISM MAJOR GEOLOGICAL EVENTS MINERALISING EVENTS TIMESCALE (Ma)
erosion and alluvial deposition 4 Quatemary -alluvial gold, diamonds?, diatomite 1.78 : Monaco volcanics eruption of basalts Tertiary 65
Cretaceous Au in alkaline intrusives 141 S ------alkaline intrusive Jurassic complex emplacement 205 ------
Triassic 251
Permian 298
Carboniferous Kanimblan deformation slate belt Au - - -
354 sediment hosted Cu and U - - Merrimbula Group A epithercnal Au Ag Boyd Volcanic Complex bimodal volcanism and A Devonian type granite intrusion Tabberabberan deformation slate belt Au 410
I and S type granite - volcanogenic massive Bredbo Group W Mo Sn veins intrusions sulphides Silurian porphyry Cu Au - Quidongan deformation shear-hosted Au Yalmy Group I S V 434 m - -- - -- -- a. - Benambrandetormation -- - CD Bendoc Group Ordovician
Adaminaby Group Wagonga Group 490 oceanic basalts Cambrian CD 545 1 U)
> Cl) C') CD Ma - million years ago U) CI) 3 CD H I- 27th Eden Region Mineral Assessment February 1998 I
FJ Erosion has removed part of the group; however, 3.1.5 Middle to Late Devonian the rocks at the top of the existing sequence are By the Middle to Late Devonian the whole of the interpreted as the start of a post-volcanic late- study area was a land mass with a moderate relief basinal sand sheet. The Bredbo Group of this and possible shallow seas or large lake systems region extends through the late Silurian. along the eastern margin. Extensional tectonism Intrusion of granite plutons related to the Bega and started in the Late Devonian along with rifting and Berridale Batholiths occurred in the period from bimodal volcanism (Boyd Volcanic Complex). the Late Silurian to Early Devonian. The granites The main areas of subaerial, mostly silicic, of the Lachian Fold Belt have been the subject of volcanism were along the eastern part of the Eden major geochemical studies by Chappell, White and region. Inland, subaerial volcanics were erupted co-workers. They have classified the granites as S- on to the areas around Bombala (west of the study type (derived from melting of sedimentary rocks) area). Thick ignimbrite sheets were laid down as and I-type (derived from melting of igneous source valley fill, coalescing and extending on to the rocks). A third type, A-type (alkaline type) also surrounding plains. Basalt lava flows and clastic occurs in the Eden region, however the majority of deposits developed as interbedded units. Intrusion the granites are I-type (Chappell et al, 1991). of subvolcanic A-type granites (Gabo Island and Styles of mineral deposits developed during this Mumbulla Suites) was coeval with volcanism. phase of activity were: With the cessation of igneous and volcanic activity tungsten-molybdenum-bismuth mineralisation the area returned to a stable landmass with associated with granitic rocks, moderate relief, some rift valleys, plus shallow marine or lake conditions in the east. A change in Iporphyry copper-gold and related styles related climate led to the onset of fluvial conditions and to granitic rocks deposition of the Merrimbula Group. Following volcanogenic massive sulphide base metal the initial phase of fluvial deposition, typified by deposition associated with the Bredbo and conglomerate, pebble sandstone, coarse sandstone Yalmy Groups, and mudstone there was a rise in sea level. Most of the shallower areas were inundated and granite hosted gold deposits, sediments typical of shallow marine to lagoonal tin deposits related to granitic intrusion, conditions were deposited as the Bellbird Creek Formation. Further eustatic change reinstated the granitic rocks represent possible sources of fluvial conditions, and the clastic deposits laid hard rock aggregate and dimension stone, down indicate an orderly progression from sheet limestone deposits in the Bredbo Group, sand and mud of delta to a series of channel sand slate-belt gold associated with the Adaminaby and overbank mud. and Yalmy Groups. Known and possible styles of mineral deposition associated with this period are: 3.1.4 Early to Middle Devonian epithermal gold-silver related to the Boyd A major compressional deformation Volcanic Complex, (Tabberabberan deformation, Table 1), occurred in pyrophyllite in altered volcanics of the Boyd the Early to Middle Devonian and was responsible Volcanic Complex, for crustal shortening by folding and thrust I emplacement of metamorphic complexes such as sandstone- hosted copper and/or uranium, which the Jerangle Metamorphic Complex. Foliation of may be present in the Merrimbula Group, I granites of the Berridale Batholith was also felsic and mafic volcanics of the Boyd Volcanic effected by this phase of deformation. Later Complex representing sources of hard rock I activity included strike slip movement on the aggregate. major transcurrent faults (Tantawangalo, I Burragate, Berridale and Wadbilliga). The extent 3.1.6 Early Carboniferous to Jurassic and styles of mineralisation related to this deformation are not well documented. A significant period of compressional deformation (Kanimblan deformation, Table 1), during the I Carbon iferous generated a pattern of upright to I I U • 27th February 1998 Eden Region Mineral Assessment slightly overturned moderate to tight folds with a diamonds and sapphires related to Tertiary • series of imbricate thrust faults such as the igneous activity, Budawang Thrust System. • gold in Tertiary to Recent deep leads/placers, Mineral deposits associated with this period are: deposits of sand and gravel represent, a slate belt gold associated with Adaminaby significant source of construction materials, and 0 Group rocks related to the Carboniferous basalt is a source of aggregate, deformation. peat deposits in upland swamps, . 3.1.7 Jurassic to Cretaceous diatornite deposits associated with Tertiary volcanism, The initial rifling of the Tasman Sea in the Middle 0 Jurassic caused some underplating, heat generation I bauxite deposits on deeply weathered basalts, and subsequent intrusion of rnonzonite syenite and I clay deposits associated with sub-volcanic lake . composite. breccias. A Jurassic. intrusion. occurs at sediments. Jingera Rock (Jingera Rock Syenite Complex). The presence of a few trachyte dykes about Jingera Rock indicates that volcanic activity took place, • but these rocks have been removed by erosion. • Rifling of the Tasman Sea continued through to the Late Cretaceous when a second period of monzonite and syenite intrusion occurred at Tanja (Tanja Syenite Complex) and Mount Dromedary • (outside the study area). Styles of mineral deposition known to be associated, (or possibly associated) with rocks of • this period are: O gold in alkaline intrusions, tin and possibly gold associated with the Tanja • Syenite Complex, • nepheline syenite in the Jingera Rock Syenite Complex. 0 3.1.8 Tertiary to Recent The Monaro Volcanics form a blanket of basalt • lavas (of the alkali basalt-basanite-nephelinite association) which erupted from numerous small vents aligned along fracture zones to form a north- . south trending tableland during the Eocene to Oligocene (about 50 to 25 million years ago). Lake and associated fluviatile sediments are usually preserved under the blanket basalt lava • flows. . Quaternary deposits cover much of the map area. On land they are present either as valley fill, hilislope or alluvial fan deposits, aeolian deposits or residual soils. Along the coast there are a O variety of deposit types such as tidal deltas, barrier sands, estuarine muds and shelf sediments. Mineral deposit types associated with rocks of these periods are:
7 Eden Region Mineral Assessment 27th February 1998
4. HISTORY OF MINING AND MINERAL EXPLORATION
The region has a history of over 140 years of of alluvial gold production is suggested for the mining for gold and base metals. About 200 region, of which the Montreal workings produced mineral occurrences, deposits, and old mines have in excess of 239 kg of gold. been recorded. Production figures and exploration Limited base metal mining has also been details for all deposits are contained on mineral undertaken at various times. Lead, zinc, and occurrence summary forms compiled by McEvilly copper production is recorded from a few isolated (1997) and in the Department of Mineral deposits but was not significant. Silver production Resources metallic mineral occurrence digital was significant in the Wolumla and Yambulla database METMD4. A brief history of mining in Gold Fields but not elsewhere in the Eden region. the area is outlined below. Molybdenite is recorded in a number of places Estimated total reef production of gold from the with the most significant deposits occurring at Eden region is in the order of 4000 kg. Alluvial Whipstick. Limited tin production is recorded in gold has also been recovered but there is little the Cathcart and Bega areas. recorded information. The only significant alluvial production came from two main fields, of which the most productive area of one (the Little Plains Exploration expenditures in the Eden region for River workings) is outside the region. The other the period from 1969 to 1995 are shown in Figure field, the Montreal alluvial workings, is situated on the extreme northern margin. A figure of 500 kg
8 ....l......
t') -1 1u0000u -n CD Cr Recalculated Expenditure $1995 - - 900000 ------Actual Expenditure $ -s CD CD 800000 OD
700000 - -
,600000
500000 - -- - - -- - CL
400000 fl --- ------ ------ ---- ------ -- j \ -
/ ' I 300000 -- ------I / -- I / I .- - / II 200000 ------/-\ /
100000 \ , / / I I I I I I I I I I I I I I CD 0 :3 0) CD C'-1 CO U) (0 N- 00 0) CO 10 CO N- CO 0) CD 0-I CO - Cr) (0 N- N- N- N- N- N- N- N- N- N- CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CX) CO CO 0) 03 0) 0) 0) (3) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) (M 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) CD CD 0 Year :3
:3 CD Figure 1: Exploration expenditure in the Eden region during 1969 - 1995. 1 > CI) Cl) CD Cl) C,)
CD Im :3 Eden Region Mineral Assessment 27" February 1998 5. KNOWN MINERAL RESOURCES AND MINERAL PRODUCTION
supply shortfalls for the foreseeable future although shortages of other construction materials may occur by the year 2000. Seven hard rock quarries, three construction sand Annual value of mineral production from some 20 pits and numerous pits winning unprocessed road quarries in the Eden region area is estimated at materials currently operate in the Eden region $4.8 million from records for 1994-95 and 1995- (Figure 2). Mining of pyrophyllite occurs on a 96 financial years (from information supplied to limited scale at the Back Creek Mine, west of the Royalty Branch of the Department of Mineral Pambula. Remaining reserves are some Resources). Of this amount some 70% is from 30 000 000 tonnes at various grades. hard rock aggregate production, 20% is from unprocessed road materials with the remainder In the recent past, mining of industrial (filter) sand at Eden and peat at Killarney has been undertaken. from construction sand, loam and pyrophyllite production. The actual value of production is Historically, phosphate has been mined at Wiles Phosphate Mine near Cathcart, chlorite (marketed considered to be greater than $4.8 million because as pyrophyllite) at Cobargo, kaolin at Greigs Flat some operations have not provided production and structural clay/shale near Tathra. Important records to the Department. Value of mineral industrial mineral deposits with potential for production from State Forests is estimated at $1.2 exploitation include the Back Creek pyrophyllite million for 1995-96 financial year. deposit and the Killarney peat deposit. Reported resource figures from company reports Significant construction material deposits currently are given in Table 2. The figures presented do not supplying the study area are hard rock aggregate necessarily constitute reserves as defined by the deposits near Nimmitabel (Tertiary basalt), Australasian Code for Reporting of Identified Bombala (Tertiary basalt, Devonian granite) and Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves. Eden (Eden Volcanic Complex), and construction sand deposits at Nullica and Bega. In 1994-95 production of hard rock aggregate was about 170 000 tonnes and of construction sand was about 20 000 tonnes. An assessment of construction material availability and supply for the far south coast including the Eden study area (MacRae, 5.2.1 Panbula Gold Field 1994) indicated that shortages of major The Panbula Gold Field was proclaimed in 1890 construction materials may occur in the area by the with total production between 1889 and 1965 year 2000 unless new sources are developed. The around 1879 kg of gold, based on reported development of a major hard rock aggregate production and reasonable estimates for those quarry at Nimmitabel has alleviated potential years where accurate records are for some reason 27' February 1998 Eden Region Mineral Assessment
Figure 2: Industrial Mineral and Construction Material Sites
286
290 312 ME 311 )2'91 295 -29 319 .
322 257
250
NIMMITABEL
325 10
326 ç'327 237
328 234 BEGA ®224
216,L 217 218 220 AWL 2104A 219 31 209 ,43 42 206k 330 0 , 208 331 207 .55 2 204 329k 13 335 • 56 BOMBALA 183 57 182 138 179,180 ,i 19 jii7,i76 .63 148 1 15 104 130 141 1 150 65 123 111 18 62 115116 4117 111 114 109 • EDEN 67 107 108
68
A LEGEND 106 Industrial Mineral Sites Construction Materials o Dimension Stone Umestne * Clays Pyrophyttite Peat ® Gemstones ] Other Industrial Minerals Localities Eden CRA Study Area Boundary Eden CRA Study Area with 15km Buffer Zone Occurrence Information: Appendix D
20 0 20 40 60 Kilometers Eden Region Mineral Assessment 271h February 1998 S deficient. The bulk of production occurred in the 5.2.3 Yambulla Gold Field years 1892 to 1915. The available information for Information on the Yambulla Gold Field is the Panbula Gold Field in comparison with some somewhat lacking in comparison to both the other areas is generally quite good. As is true in Wolumla and Panbula Gold Fields. Workings are many gold fields, much ground was pegged in the scattered over a much wider area and production initial rush and soon after abandoned when returns figures are limited or absent for some areas. The did not live up to expectations. This is evidenced total recorded production for the field is around by numerous smaller pits in the area. Some 760 kg of gold, mostly produced between 1899 companies were floated simply by holding leases and 1912. Silver is present in reasonable in the area, and with ensuing amalgamations, quantities in many of the historical assays but abandonments, and unreliable or absent production production is believed to be small. The majority of records, accurate locations and production figures Au came from the Yambulla or Solomons Mine are not always possible. With amalgamation of which produced around 252 kg of gold, possibly licences and connection of shafts on different more. Recent exploration drilling has delineated a licences underground, some records for larger resource of 197 000 tonnes at 3.1 g/t of gold in the mines include production from smaller ones. area of the old GL 7 mines, with some economic Due to the fine grain size of the gold in all of the grade intersections recorded in other areas. mines, a significant quantity was lost in local treatment by ordinary milling appliances, 5.2.4 Montreal Alluvial Workings sometimes washed down the Pambula River in tailings, and for this reason ore was sometimes The Montreal workings were in Quaternary beach sent elsewhere for more efficient extraction. It sands and adjacent auriferous Tertiary gravels just was not until 1896 that the first cyanide treatment north of Bermagui and produced in excess of plants appeared on the field. The Falkner Mine 239 kg of gold. The bulk of production came from was the richest and produced around 60% of the the gravels. The find was rich but limited in extent gold in the field. and was worked out quickly between 1880 and 1884. Workings include numerous shallow pits, Recent exploration drilling has returned a number shafts, adits, and drives within an outcrop of of economic intersections in the area of the old weakly consolidated gravels behind the beach. mines, however no viable resource has yet been The sediments in Wallaga Lake to the west were delineated. This of course does not preclude the also worked following the same lead, but possibility of an economic resource being production was hampered by heavy water delineated in the future. problems. The source of the gold is believed to be the gold-bearing veins on Mount Dromedary. 5.2.2 Wolumla Gold Field The Wolumla Gold Field was discovered in 1896 5.2.5 Whipstick Molybdenite Mines and worked until 1939 with the bulk of production The bismuth-molybdenite deposits at Whipstick between 1896 and 1908. Total recorded rank amongst the largest producers in the State. production is 668 kg of gold and 102 kg of silver. They were worked intermittently between 1891 to The workings include numerous adits, shafts, pits, 1927, and 1941 to 1943. Gold and silver has been costeans etc scattered throughout the field for produced in small quantities also. Workings much the same reasons highlighted in the consist of numerous shafts, adits, and pits scattered discussion on the Panbula Gold Field. The adits over about 2 km. Estimated production is about mostly delve into the side of a hill subsequently 17 000 tonnes of ore, which yielded about called Mount Momsen around and on which most 200 tonnes of bismuth and 100 tonnes of of the mines are located. The main producer molybdenite concentrates (Weber, Paterson & however was the Pacific or Eureka Mine located Townsend, 1978). The deposits were originally just to the south with a recorded production of 345 worked for bismuth, gold, and silver, with kg gold. Recent exploration drilling in the area of production of molybdenite beginning in 1912. Momsens Hill has defined an indicated resource of Minor amounts of uraninite (uranium oxide 75 000 tonnes at 0.75 glt of gold, with economic mineral) are disseminated in the ore zones (Willis grade intersections also being recorded in old mine and Stevens, 1971). areas to the east and south.
12 27" February 1998 Eden Region Mineral Assessment
5.2.6 Mineral Exploration 1969 to 1995 Figure 1 shows exploration expenditure for the decline in expenditure which immediately follows Eden study area between 1969 and 1995. Some of the peaks of 1982 and 1988 corresponds to this expenditure relates to titles which are partly relinquishment of exploration licences primarily outside the Eden region. The bulk of exploration due to negative assessments of drilling results in conducted since 1969 has been for gold, with these areas. The peaks of 1992 and 1994 reflect a limited exploration undertaken for base metals, resurgence of exploration interest in these molybdenite, platinum group minerals, historically productive areas. The peak of 1971 is pyrophyllite, and dimension stone. Note that in part due to exploration undertaken in the exploration expenditure for the 1970s is Quidong area, the focus of which lay outside the understated due to missing records. Eden Study Area. Areas which have received the most detailed Most other scattered gold occurrences have been investigations have been the historically more investigated to a lesser extent over the period. productive gold fields. The Pambula, Wolumla, There has been limited exploration conducted in and Yambulla areas received significant the period for other metals (mainly copper, lead, exploration attention during the 1980s, culminating zinc, and molybdenum), a minor amount of in drilling programs which largely correspond to exploration has been undertaken for pyrophyllite in the peaks of 1982, 1985, and 1988. The sharp the Pambula area, and minor exploration has been undertaken for quality dimension stone throughout the Eden Study Area at various times.
13 ni CD
Table 2: Identified Resources in the Eden Region CD 12. Name Commodity Status Resource Amount Wolumla Goldfield - Mount Momsen (198) gold prospect 75000 t © 0.75 glt CD-' Yambulla Goldfield - Golden Rhine (73) gold prospect 197000 t @ 3.11 g/t 0) > C', Crofts Hardrock Quarry (119) hard rock aggregate prospect 4.7 Mt U, CD U) Heffernan-Milliner Quarry (118) hard rock aggregate prospect 10.4 Mt (n CD Wheatleys Quarry (209) hard rock aggregate prospect 300000 t Brogo Quarry (241) hard rock aggregate operating 100000 t Ferndale Quarry (54) hard rock aggregate operating 150000 t Greens Road Granite Quarry (248) hard rock aggregate operating 250000 t Lefts Mountain Road Quarry (67) hard rock aggregate operating 40000 Nicholsons Quarry (62) hard rock aggregate operating 1 Mt Nimmitabel Quarry (9) hard rock aggregate operating 7.5 Mt Nullica Quarry (116) hard rock aggregate operating 150000 t Thompsons Basalt Quarry (55) hard rock aggregate operating 100000 Killarney Swamp Peat (63) peat prospect 3 Mm3 Jacksons Bog Peat (59) peat prospect 112800 m3 Back Creek Pyrophyllite Quarry (148) . pyrophyllite operating 30 Mt Bega South Sand Pit (Kingswood) (216) sand - construction operating 20000 Boydtown Sand Pit (107) sand - construction operating 100000 Narira Creek Sand Pit (252) sand - construction operating 5000 t Nullica River Sand Pit (108) sand - construction operating 10000 Wolumla Creek Pit (208) sand - construction operating 2000 Eden Rubbish Tip (150) silica - industrial sand prospect 10000 Sou th Pambula Soil Pit (181) soil, loam operating 10000 [t M Fr Table 2 (continued): Identified Resources in the Eden Region
Name Commodity Status Resource Amount Walshs Gravel Pit, Coral Park (204) unprocessed construction materials operating 2500 t Wendts Quarry (247) unprocessed construction materials operating 35000 t Pericoe Quarry (Ill) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Nimmitabel (10) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Old Lefts Mountain Road Quarry (68) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Thorn Hill Pit (217) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Costins Pit (251) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Pambula (177) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Wheatley No 1 & 2 Pits (210) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Tathra Pit (220) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Culwulla Pit (234) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Tomahawk Pit (15) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Green Cape Road Quarry (106) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown Old Hut Creek Road Quarry (114) unprocessed construction materials operating unknown m (D ( 9 ) Location number for Nimmitabel quarry as shown on Map 2. Locations for industrial minerals and construction minerals also shown on Figure 2 0 (a 9.
CD -I 0) > U) Cl) CD (n (I) 3 CD
01 Eden Region Mineral Assessment 2711 February 1998 6. MINERAL EXPLORATION AND LAND ACCESS
drilling program, 140 years after the first 6.1.1 Mineral Exploration discoveries. Mineral exploration is a long term and ongoing process. Exploration is extremely costly, it is a 6.1.2 Land access commercially high risk activity, and areas often New information, new concepts and better have to be explored many times over before the understanding of geological processes continually initial clue that leads to a discovery is found. change the perceived prospectivity of areas and Various types of fine grained low grade gold regions. New models are continually being deposits can be particularly difficult to locate. In developed and refined. Continued access to land is places disseminated gold and gold-copper deposits therefore a significant issue for the mining industry are associated with smaller high grade gold and for future mineral development. deposits which have been mined out as at Cadia and Peak Hill in NSW, at Kidston in Queensland, In order to examine the implications of alternative and Morning Star in Victoria. land access arrangements for exploration and mining in the region it is important to understand The advent of Carbon-In-Pulp and Carbon-In- both the nature of exploration and its likely costs Leach gold extraction technologies in the 1970s and benefits. provide examples of the way in which technological (and economic) change can affect Generally, exploration can be defined as the exploration. These technologies dramatically process of searching for and assessing mineral changed the costs of gold recovery and also deposits. Although discovery and delineation are reduced the risks associated with exploration for the primary reasons for exploration, lack of gold-oxide ores by allowing gold to be mined discovery from an exploration program does not profitably at much lower grades. This triggered imply that the effort yielded no benefit. intensive, Australia-wide exploration for bulk gold Information gained from exploration will usually oxide deposits at considerably lower cut off grades increase the understanding of a region's geology. than were previously considered economic (Blain From the perspective of a private firm, the 1992). Carbon-In-Pulp and Carbon-In-Leach potential benefits from an exploration program processing are also used for treatment of low grade derive from the economic returns that will accrue primary gold ores. from the discovery of an economic deposit. Persistent exploration and re-evaluation of the Because exploration is a high risk activity (that is, geology of a district can also lead to discoveries. there is a small probability of any one venture The very promising Ridgeway gold-copper deposit being successful), companies will approach near Cadia Hill is concealed by a blanket of exploration in a sequential and systematic fashion. Tertiary basalt and was recently discovered by a This enables the decision to abandon or keep exploring in the area to be made in a efficient manner. The typical sequence of events that 1 • 27 h February 1998 Eden Region Mineral Assessment underpin a modern exploration program are shown The cost and duration of exploration programs will below. vary from company to company and across commodities. Clark (1996) suggests that the . development of a typical major deposit (worldwide) involves a 5-20 year lead time. This MODERN MINERAL EXPLORATION: estimate results from a typical 3-10 years THE TYPICAL SEQUENCE OF exploration program prior to the mine development EVENTS phase. 1. Global considerations It is important to note that the exploration process Assessment of political stability starts with assessments of very large regions and is Assessment of security of title then systematically narrowed down as the exploration target becomes better defined. The Assessment of access and restrictions direct costs facing explorers increase as the target Assessment of financial climate, restrictions area becomes smaller and exploration methods or inducements more intense. The environmental impact Determination of geoscientific framework and associated with exploration also increases as the availability of information area being explored becomes smaller and the exploration methods used become more invasive 2. Preliminary investigations (for example, drilling). Review regional geoscientific data (geology, geophysics, satellite imagery) Modern exploration, which is increasingly using remote sensing from satellites or aircraft, is able to Formulation of geological concepts and proceed to surface phases with no land selection of prospective areas disturbance. The early stages of a surface Examination of known mineralisation exploration program involve activities such as mapping, geophysical measurements and 3. Reconnaissance exploration geochemical sampling of stream sediments which Acquisition of exploration tenements are likely to have relatively little effect upon the Collection and assessment of geoscientific environment. Follow-up investigations that would data over the tenement require other techniques and that may have some localised and temporary effects may include (see o Examination of available regional geoscientific data ABARE, AGSO and BRS (1993): Conducting of geoscientific surveys required rock chip sampling; to augment available data collecting soil samples; and Selection of target areas, for more detailed exploration electrical, gravity, magnetic, seismic or radiometric ground surveys. 4. Detailed exploration If the results of this work were positive, additional Detailed geoscientific surveys to detect and follow-up work probably would include some delineate anomalies drilling. However, it should be noted that not all Drilling of anomalies in search of significant exploration results in drilling. In a submission to mineralisation the Industry Commission 'Mining and Metals Delineation of mineral deposits by further Processing' inquiry, the Australian Minerals drilling and other methods to determine Industry Council reported that less than 10 per cent configuration, approximate tonnage, grade, of exploration projects in Australia reach the metallurgical characteristics of the deposits surface exploration phase, and only around one per Pre-feasibility studies cent reach the subsurface exploration phase Acquisition of mining tenements, if justified, at (Industry Commission, 1991). appropriate stage of program. In contrast to exploration, mining itself generally Source: ABARE, AGSO and BRS (1993). involves greater disturbance to the land surface in the immediate area of the mine and could leave significantly changed landforms when mining is
17 Eden Region Mineral Assessment 27th February 1998 finished. Mining is generally therefore seen as posing greater difficulties in terms of compatibility with other uses. Many potential environmental effects of mining activities can be eliminated or mitigated, though at an additional cost. For example, water pollution is another potential threat to the environment from mining. However, this can be controlled by using well established techniques like impoundment and evaporation of tailings, sedimentation, filtration and pH neutralisation. Dust and noise control are also important in areas close to residences. Rehabilitation of mine sites at the completion of operations can restore many of the features of the landscape that existed before mining began, substantially assist the re-establishment of vegetation, and reduce the potential for pollution from the abandoned mine site.
18 271h February 1998 Eden Region Mineral Assessment
7. MINERAL POTENTIAL ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY
The mineral potential of the study areas has been characteristics known to be associated with assessed by determining the types of mineral specific types of mineral deposits are then deposits likely to be found within the geological identified. In particular, the assessment draws on framework known or believed to exist there. The regional and local characteristics of mineral general methodology used was developed by the deposit models to establish whether or not specific United States Geological Survey (USGS), and has types of mineral deposits are likely to occur. been used successfully for mineral resource The mineral potential of an area, that is the assessments of forest areas in North America and likelihood of it having a particular type of mineral elsewhere. This approach identifies geological deposit, is ranked as high, moderate, low or units (tracts) which could contain particular types unknown, based on professional judgments of of mineral deposits. A summary of the qualitative geoscientists involved in the assessment. If there assessment methodology is described in are insufficient data to classify the areas as having publications by Marsh, Kropschot and Dickinson high, moderate or low potential then the mineral (1984), Taylor and Steven (1983), and by Dewitt, resource potential is categorised as unknown. To Redden, Wilson and Buscher (1986). reflect the differing amounts of information A qualitative assessment of the potential resources available, the assessments of mineral potential are of an area is an estimate of the likelihood of also categorised according to levels of certainty, occurrence of mineral deposits which may be of denoted by letters A to D in order of increasing sufficient size and grade to constitute a mineral certainty (Figure 3). That is, A denotes the lowest resource. The term 'mineral resource' is restricted level of certainty and D the highest. The method is to material, the extraction of which is judged to be described in more detail in Appendix A. potentially viable in the next 25 years. Only the Assessments similar to the procedure used here in deposit types judged to be most likely to constitute this report for the Eden region are commonly used significant resources in the region have been by companies to choose the selection of areas for assessed in detail. exploration. It is important to note, however, that An assessment of potential mineral resources of a the assessment of potential resources is subject to region combines knowledge of its geology, the amount and the quality of data available to the geophysics, geochemistry, mineral deposits and assessors. As geological knowledge of an area is occurrences with current theories of mineral never complete, it is not possible to have a 'final' deposit genesis and results of mineral exploration. assessment of potential mineral resources at any The assessment process requires a study of given time. The mineral resource potential of available geoscientific data to determine the areas needs to be monitored and reassessed history of geologic processes and environments. Geologic environments judged to have
19 Eden Region Mineral Assessment 271h February 1998 periodically to take account of new data, advances Belle near Kalgoorlie, WA; Century in the Mount in geological understanding including new mineral Isa Inlier, QId.) or in areas not previously known discoveries. Advances in mineral exploration and to be of very high potential (eg Olympic Dam on mining technologies, and changes in mineral the Stuart Shelf, SA). Thus continued access to markets are other factors which may change the land for regulated exploration, which is a transient mineral resource potential of an area. process rather than a long-term land use, is an important issue for the minerals industry and for Because of incomplete geological knowledge, the future mineral development. discovery rate in Australia is roughly of the order of one mine for one thousand exploration Geological areas (or 'tracts') in the Eden region, programs. Thus areas are explored, often judged to contain geological environments repeatedly, before a mineral deposit is found. permissive of the formation of specific types of Increased geological knowledge and other factors mineral deposits are delineated and the mineral can result in discoveries of world class deposits potential is ranked (see Figures 4 to 15). both in highly prospective areas (eg Kanowna
Figure 3: Relationship between Levels of Resource Potential and Levels of Certainty
H/D H/C H/B U/A
HIGH HIGH POTENTIAL HIGH POTENTIAL POTENTIAL
M/D M/C M/B
MODERATE MODERATE MODERATE POTENTIAL POTENTIAL POTENTIAL
UNKNOWN LID LJC LIB POTENTIAL
LOW POTENTIAL LOW LOW
N/D POTENTIAL POTENTIAL
NO POTENTIAL