Steigmann-Gall on Poewe, 'New Religions and the Nazis'

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Steigmann-Gall on Poewe, 'New Religions and the Nazis' H-German Steigmann-Gall on Poewe, 'New Religions and the Nazis' Review published on Tuesday, May 1, 2007 Karla Poewe. New Religions and the Nazis. New York: Routledge, 2006. xii + 218 pp. ISBN 978-0-415-29025-8; ISBN 978-0-415-29024-1. Reviewed by Richard Steigmann-Gall (Department of History, Kent State University) Published on H-German (May, 2007) Many a Slip Twixt Cup and Lip This volume seeks to explore the "contribution of new religions to the emergence of Nazi ideology in the 1920s and 1930s" (p. i). Its author, Karla Poewe, has set for herself a prodigious goal: to demonstrate that "leading cultural figures such as Jakob Wilhelm Hauer, Mathilde Ludendorff" and other fringe religious figures in the Weimar Republic "wanted to shape the cultural milieu of politics, religion, theology, Indo-Aryan metaphysics, literature and Darwinian science into a new genuinely German faith-based political community. Instead what emerged was a totalitarian political regime known as National Socialism, with an anti-Semitic worldview" (p. i). In other words, she seeks not only to explore the milieu of pagan-Germanic "Faithlers" within the Third Reich, a small group about whom a great deal is already known, but to demonstrate that they invented Nazism as an ideology. Elsewhere Poewe puts this ambition more plainly: "Although the book concentrates on [Jakob Wilhelm] Hauer, it shows more broadly how young intellectuals and founders of new religions shaped the ideology and organizations of an emergent National Socialist state" (p. 10). Any lingering ambiguity as to her scholarly goal is put to rest when she contends that Hauer and others of his ilk "not only intended to destroy 'womanish' Christianity so that a new knowledge might emerge but they were instrumental in creating that new knowledge. We know it as Nazism" (p. 14). Even as the argument for taking ideology seriously in the Third Reich gains increasing traction, the Nazi Weltanschauung is conventionally deemed far too amorphous to have its precise intellectual genealogy or antecedents reliably traced. In this regard, scholars frequently contrast National Socialism to Marxism, which was notable for a series of programmatic writings that established a much more delineated set of tenets and beliefs upon which a Marxist politics could reliably be founded. Not so Nazism, or the larger phenomenon of fascism for that matter.Mein Kampf is arguably the closest thing to a Nazi version of Das Kapital in the sense of a foundational text, and while Alan Bullock's tendency of discounting Nazi ideology is deservedly on the wane,[1] Hitler's writing is so meandering and uninterested in defining its terms that it defies answers to the question of precisely where its author obtained his core beliefs. An older generation of scholarship interested in Nazi ideology thought in terms of "proto-Nazis" or "pre-fascists," an approach that has been problematized since its conception. It is not for nothing, therefore, that in spite of an environment more favorable to the ideological, no current scholarly trend considers (or reconsiders) the "intellectual origins of Nazism." Karla Poewe claims to find those origins. She does this by delineating, in the first half of the book, the worldviews of Hauer and others responsible for establishing "Deutsche Glaube," a variety of paganist thinking that found a window of opportunity in the marketplace of Weimar culture and attempted to Citation: H-Net Reviews. Steigmann-Gall on Poewe, 'New Religions and the Nazis'. H-German. 09-30-2014. https://networks.h-net.org/node/35008/reviews/45057/steigmann-gall-poewe-new-religions-and-nazis Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 1 H-German take advantage of the new Third Reich to further its religious ambitions. The second half of the book concerns itself more with developments on the ground. Poewe seeks in this section to demonstrate that leading members of the party subscribed to these views by teasing out the web of associations in which this circle traveled. In this way she attempts to demonstrate that it was not just a set of loosely defined ideas, but social connection that belies Hauer's status as the true locus of Nazi ideology. Poewe's book demonstrates that Hauer was an important figure in the paganist milieu, an individual who could periodically rely upon a few contacts in some high places in the Nazi state. This part of the analysis, although not particularly original, nonetheless demonstrates effectively that Hauer could occasionally draw on some associates within the party to his own benefit. The book also demonstrates that he clearly attempted to position himself as a man of consequence and import in the emergent völkisch movement. More than that, ample evidence is offered, primarily through correspondence and letters, that Hauer was a man of great ambition, one in the middle of a loose cohort of ideologues who hoped to bring about a cultural and political revolution. Poewe can be convincing in her critique of others' works on this topic, most especially that of Margarete Dierk, who published in 1986 the only political biography of Hauer, but who was herself the product of a Nazified university system. The book's arguments pursue a series of other scholars as well, with varying degrees of success. In particular, the analysis is somewhat less convincing in taking on Werner Ustorf's portrayal of Hauer as Christian incomplete in his apostasy (p. 26). Whether or to what degree he remained a nominal Christian can admittedly not be a very good indicator of his inner state of mind, a point that Poewe makes effectively. But that conclusion only raises the problem of whether Hauer's pronouncements can be a more useful guide. The last point is particularly germane in this case, because any author who treats this topic has a great deal of explaining to do when it comes to Hauer's frequently contradictory utterances. Hauer was not simply a stereotypical, Janus-faced Nazi politician speaking out of both sides of his mouth for the sake of expediency. The problem is much more fundamental than that. In Poewe's analysis, two issues are most central: first, that true antisemitism must also be anti-Christian; second, that Hauer, as an alleged founder of Nazi ideology, was therefore both. Unfortunately, the book's own evidence shows that he was highly inconsistent and even contradictory, on both counts. Although the usual rantings against the Church and Christian religion to be expected from paganistic "Faithlers" are cited, the book also demonstrates that Hauer still felt protective of the religion he allegedly rejected. In his search for a new religion, he describes how "nearer [!] I came to the person of Jesus" (p. 65). Elsewhere, Poewe's analysis itself contends that "Hauer did not like the church because most of its clerics were non-Christians" (p. 57). She also demonstrates that Hauer was not consistently antisemitic. At one point, we are treated to Hauer's defense of a Jew banned from a public lecture (p. 59). On another occasion Poewe herself admits: "Yet Hauer did not regard himself as anti-Semitic. Nor did all of his followers" (p. 95). Surely this is not a simple matter of detail for someone we are told was a foundational author of the Nazi worldview. The ways in which Poewe's intepretations try to reconcile such inconsistencies are rather remarkable. Regarding Hauer's poorly developed sense of Jew-hatred, Poewe asks: "Can one live a lie not knowing that one is doing so? I think the answer is yes" (p. 95). It would be hard to find a definition of historical method that can carry the burden of such a formulation. On other occasions, the author tries to explain away such inconsistencies by arguing that Hauer's correspondence was intended to hide his "true" feelings when Nazism was still just a movement, that he was not always Citation: H-Net Reviews. Steigmann-Gall on Poewe, 'New Religions and the Nazis'. H-German. 09-30-2014. https://networks.h-net.org/node/35008/reviews/45057/steigmann-gall-poewe-new-religions-and-nazis Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 2 H-German "on the level" regarding correspondence on his political views (p. 28). At one point she states: "His view that German Faith should become the essence of National Socialism ... was not openly expressed until the end of 1933" (p. 35). If we take this argumentprima facie, on the presumption that it was too dangerous for Hauer to "unfurl his true colors" sooner, by what method can we reliably determine when his "real" views are being expressed? Poewe not only diminishes her ability to rely upon his political and religious utterances when she claims they are "genuine," but also fatally undermines her main ambition of demonstrating that Hauer helped form the basis of Nazi thinking. Not only would a "true Nazi" uphold his views and his party membership publicly during the Weimar Republic, neither of which Hauer did, such individuals were also much more consistent in their basic ideological views. In her defense, Poewe admits that her book is "not a smoothly written history" (p. 16). The biggest problem of all, however, is that the author simply never demonstrates that Hauer took a hand in shaping Nazi ideology. He was a fellow-traveler, intent on riding the coattails of Nazi success and, like a great many "little Führers" swimming in Hitler's wake, attempting to claim some of the glory. Proof of Hauer's place in Nazism rests far too much on assertions made by Hauer, such as his profession that "[t]he German Faith Movement has today become a movement that has penetrated the whole of our Volk" (p.
Recommended publications
  • The Knives Are out the Reception of Erich Ludendorff’S Memoirs in the Context of the Dolchstoß Myth, 1919–1925
    Portal Militärgeschichte, 2021 Fahrenwaldt ––– 1 Aufsatz Matthias A. Fahrenwaldt The Knives Are Out The Reception of Erich Ludendorff’s Memoirs in the Context of the Dolchstoß Myth, 1919–1925 DOI: 10.15500/akm.18.01.2021 Zusammenfassung: Erich Ludendorff was the dominant figure of the German war effort in the second half of the Great War. After the military collapse he was one of the main proponents of the Dolchstoßlegende, the main liability of the Weimar Republic. This article investigates what role his 1919 memoirs Meine Kriegserinnerungen played in advancing this myth. Erich Ludendorff was one of the main advocates of the Dolchstoß myth. Introduction1 The narrative about the German defeat in the Great War proved to be the Weimar Republic’s biggest burden. The nationalist right championed the version that while the army was undefeated in the field, it was ‘stabbed in the back’ by the revolutionary home 1 This article is a significantly shortened version of my MSt dissertation as submitted to Oxford University. The thesis was supervised by Myfanwy Lloyd whose feedback on a previous version of this article is also much appreciated. Portal Militärgeschichte, 2021 Fahrenwaldt ––– 2 front. This so-called Dolchstoß myth was promoted by the German supreme command when defeat was inevitable, and the myth – with slightly evolving meaning – endured throughout the Weimar Republic and beyond. The aim of this article is to understand the role that Erich Ludendorff’s published memoirs Meine Kriegserinnerungen played in the origin and evolution of the stab-in-the-back myth until 1925, the year of the Dolchstoßprozess.
    [Show full text]
  • The Monita Secreta Or, As It Was Also Known As, The
    James Bernauer, S.J. Boston College From European Anti-Jesuitism to German Anti-Jewishness: A Tale of Two Texts “Jews and Jesuits will move heaven and hell against you.” --Kurt Lüdecke, in conversation with Adolf Hitleri A Presentation at the Conference “Honoring Stanislaw Musial” Jagiellonian University, Krakow, Poland (March 5, 2009) The current intense debate about the significance of “political religion” as a mode of analyzing fascism leads us to the core of the crisis in understanding the Holocaust.ii Saul Friedländer has written of an “historian‟s paralysis” that “arises from the simultaneity and the interaction of entirely heterogeneous phenomena: messianic fanaticism and bureaucratic structures, pathological impulses and administrative decrees, archaic attitudes within an advanced industrial society.”iii Despite the conflicting voices in the discussion of political religion, the debate does acknowledge two relevant facts: the obvious intermingling in Nazism of religious and secular phenomena; secondly, the underestimated role exercised by Munich Catholicism in the early life of the Nazi party.iv My essay is an effort to illumine one thread in this complex territory of political religion and Nazism and my title conveys its hypotheses. First, that the centuries long polemic against the Roman Catholic religious order the Jesuits, namely, its fabrication of the Jesuit image as cynical corrupter of Christianity and European culture, provided an important template for the Nazi imagining of Jewry after its emancipation.v This claim will be exhibited in a consideration of two historically influential texts: the Monita 1 secreta which demonized the Jesuits and the Protocols of the Sages of Zion which diabolized the Jews.vi In the light of this examination, I shall claim that an intermingled rhetoric of Jesuit and Jewish wills to power operated in the imagination of some within the Nazi leadership, the most important of whom was Adolf Hitler himself.
    [Show full text]
  • Einleitung TEIL I IM DRITTEN REICH HITLER BUDDHA
    © 2008 AGI-Information Management Consultants May be used for personal purporses only or by libraries associated to dandelon.com network. Einleitung 17 TEIL I HITLER BUDDHA KRISHNA IM DRITTEN REICH 21 Heinrich Himmler: indische Götter inspirieren den SS-Führer 23 Der Architekt des Massenmordes: gottgläubig und okkult 24 Der Reichsführer-SS vergleicht Hitler mit dem indischen Gott Krishna 26 »Kschatrijakaste, das müssen wir sein. Das ist die Rettungs 27 Morden als spirituelle Disziplin: Der Pilger Kamanita 31 »Ich bewundere die Weisheit der indischen Religionsstifter« 32 Das SS-Ahnenerbe:die Religionsschmiede des Schwarzen Ordens 35 Der »Vorzeitforscher«Herman Wirth: Die Arier in vedischen Quellen 37 Der Indologe Walther Wüst: Die Konstruktion einer indo-arischen Weltreligion 39 Religion ist machbar! 41 Adolf Hitler als der Bluterbe des Buddha Shakyamuni 42 Die Inkarnationsdebatte innerhalb des SS-Ahnenerbes 46 Hitler, ein sakraler, indo-arischer Weltenherrscher 49 >>Auchüber Indien schwebt das Sonnenzeichen des Hakenkreuzes<< 54 Orientalisten als nationalsozialistische »Kirchenväter« 56 Das SS-Ahnenerbe, eine indo-arische Academia Universalis 59 Inhalt 6 Der Rassentheoretiker Hans E K. Günther: Ein Ariernachweis für Buddha 61 Der arische Buddha 62 Dschingis Khan als arisches Vorbild 64 Der Polittheologe Friedrich Hielscher: Lehrmeister Asien 65 Krieg als Religion: ein indo-arisches »Ahnenerbe« 72 Jakob Wilhelm Hauer: Ein Indologe gründet die >>neue deutsche Glaubensbewegung« 73 Indo-arische Fundamente für eine »NS-Religion« 77 Der Krieger
    [Show full text]
  • Antisemitism in Right-Wing Extremism Antisemitism in Right-Wing Extremism Table of Contents
    Antisemitism in right-wing extremism Antisemitism in right-wing extremism Table of contents 1 Introduction 5 2 Definition 7 3 Manifestations and expressions 10 3.1 Antisemitism in violence-oriented right-wing extremism 10 3.2 Antisemitism among right-wing extremist political parties 11 3.2.1 Nationaldemokratische Partei Deutschlands (NPD) 11 3.2.2 DIE RECHTE 13 3.2.3 Der III. Weg 15 3.3 Antisemitism in the New Right 16 3.4 Antisemitism in right-wing extremist worldview organisations 18 3.5 Antisemitism in right-wing extremist music 20 3.6 Antisemitism in right-wing extremist publications 21 3.7 Antisemitism on the Internet 22 4 Conclusion 24 Imprint 27 3 4 1 Introduction For more than one hundred years, antisemitism has been among the ideological cornerstones of nationalist and völkisch political movements in Germany. Before, hostility towards Jews had been expressed through religiously and economically motivated patterns of argumentation and had been socially and politically motivated. Since the late 19th century, however, Jews or the people considered to be Jews were mainly rejected based on ethno-racist reasoning. This development culminated in the race doctrine propagated by the National Socialists. According to that doctrine, Jews were regarded as “vermin on the people’s body” to be systematically killed in the Holocaust later on. However, antisemitism as such is no relic of National Socialism but rather a constant and Europe-wide phenomenon with a long history. Besides widespread latent antisemitism, i.e. a tacit agreement with anti-Jewish views or a vague aversion to Jews, to the present day, hostility towards Jews has time and again become evident in criminal offences motivated by antisemitism.
    [Show full text]
  • Creating the Paradigm: Historical Preconditions of Modern Asatru
    chapter 1 Creating the Paradigm: Historical Preconditions of Modern Asatru Modern Asatru, as well as the current popular appeal of ‘Germanic’ or ‘Nordic’ themes and images, are outcomes of and contributors to a discourse of Germanic myth. This discourse is related to a general tendency to conflate cul- ture, religion and ethnicity, or to culturalize and ethnicize religion and simul- taneously sacralize culture. In this chapter I argue that we can identify two prior eras, two points of crystallization, where similar tendencies were promi- nent and which were formative for later religious and ideological appropria- tions of Germanic myth: German Romanticism around 1800 and völkisch nationalism in the first third of the 20th century. The first formative moment was defined by the scholarship of Johann Gottfried Herder, Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, and other intellectuals of German Romanticism. They were the first to systematize ideas about a holistic unity of natural environment, language and history located in a deep past and in rural populations. This unity and its expression in an indigenous mythological heri- tage were perceived as the necessary foundation for a proper nation or Volk. This Romantic constellation proved to be exceptionally malleable, productive and persistent. It influenced both cultural pluralism and exclusionist ideolo- gies with affinities to racism and anti-Semitism. It inspired nationalist move- ments not only in Germany, but in Scandinavian, Anglo-Saxon and Baltic countries as well. Moreover, it provided the basis for European and North American counter-cultural movements as diverse as Anglo-Saxonism and modern witchcraft (Wicca). It is no coincidence that the years after 1900 – our second point of crystallization – have been characterized as ‘neo-Romantic.’ Romantic ideas about a unity of the Volk were radicalized in the German völkisch movement and turned into an alternative religion around 1910.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal of Contemporary History
    Journal of Contemporary History http://jch.sagepub.com/ Reassessing The Holy Reich: Leading Nazis' Views on Confession, Community and 'Jewish' Materialism Samuel Koehne Journal of Contemporary History 2013 48: 423 DOI: 10.1177/0022009413481827 The online version of this article can be found at: http://jch.sagepub.com/content/48/3/423 Published by: http://www.sagepublications.com Additional services and information for Journal of Contemporary History can be found at: Email Alerts: http://jch.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts Subscriptions: http://jch.sagepub.com/subscriptions Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav >> Version of Record - Jul 22, 2013 What is This? Downloaded from jch.sagepub.com at Deakin University on July 28, 2013 Article Journal of Contemporary History 48(3) 423–445 Reassessing The Holy ! The Author(s) 2013 Reprints and permissions: sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav Reich: Leading Nazis’ DOI: 10.1177/0022009413481827 Views on Confession, jch.sagepub.com Community and ‘Jewish’ Materialism Samuel Koehne Alfred Deakin Research Institute, Deakin University, Australia Abstract Returning to the Journal of Contemporary History debate on The Holy Reich, this article argues that the notion of ‘positive Christianity’ as a Nazi ‘religious system’ has been largely invented. It offers a close analysis of significant public statements on National Socialism by three leading Nazis: Adolf Hitler, Gottfried Feder and Alfred Rosenberg. In doing so, it demonstrates that in historical context the three key ideas from Point 24 of the NSDAP programme that were meant to form the content of this ‘type of Christianity’ were not promoted as Christian.
    [Show full text]
  • From Ludendorff's Gotterkenntnis to Sigrid Hunke's
    SCIENTIFIC NEO-PAGANISM AND THE EXTREME RIGHT THEN AND TODAY: FROM LUDENDORFF’S GOTTERKENNTNIS TO SIGRID HUNKE’S EUROPAS EIGENE RELIGION by Karla Poewe and Irving Hexham This paper was published as: “Jakob Wilhelm Hauer's New Religion and National Socialism.” Karla Poewe and Irving Hexham. Journal of Contemporary Religion, 20 (2) 2005: 195-215 1 ABSTRACT During the Weimar Republic, flourishing new religions were harnessed to usher in the cultural revolution from the right that was soon dominated by the Nazis. J. William Hauer’s Deutsche Glaubensbewegung, an umbrella group for numerous new religions from versions of Hinduism to Nordic Neo-Paganism, all collaborated, at some point, with Hitler and his party. This paper shows the continuity of core ideas from Mathilde Ludendorff’s Gotterkenntnis to Hauer’s Glaubensbewegung and, importantly, Sigrid Hunke’s Unitarier. It shows, further, the close connections between these forms of neo-paganism and the present day European New Right. The paradoxical co-occurrence in fascism of a religious populism and a metapolitical elitism, philosophical vitalism and dreams of national or European rebirth, has its roots in these French and German forms of neo-paganism. 2 Biographical Details: Karla Poewe is professor of anthropology in the Anthropology Department of the University of Calgary. She has published eight books, sometimes co-authored with Irving Hexham, among them, New Religions as Global Cultures (1997), Charismatic Christianity as a Global Culture (1994), Matrilineal Ideology (1981). Research was conducted in Zamibia, Namibia, South Africa and, for this paper, Germany. Irving Hexham is professor of Religious Studies at the University of Calgary.
    [Show full text]
  • Ludendorffs Kampf Gegen Die Hitler-Diktatur
    Neu zusammengestellt und neu herausgegeben von Matthias Köpke Ludendorffs Kampf gegen die Hitler-Diktatur Eine Dokumentation von Gunther Duda zu Erich Ludendorffs 130. Geburtstag. Eine Fortsetzung in sieben Teilen, erschienen in „Mensch und Maß“ des Jahres 1995! Neu herausgegeben im Eigenverlag, 2018. Youtube-Internetkanal Esausegen unter: www.youtube.com/user/Genesis2740blessing Alle Beiträge in vorliegender Schrift sind der Zeitschrift „Mensch und Maß“ entnommen. Diese Schrift erscheint im Verlag Hohe Warte, damals (1995) war der Verleger Franz Karg von Bebenburg. Die Quellennachweise: „Mensch und Maß“ Nr. 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13 und 15/1995. Man beachte auch die Literaturhinweise am Ende dieser Schrift. Erich und Mathilde Ludendorff „Wehe dem Volk, dem die Geschichte nicht Lehrmeisterin sein kann!“ Diese Schrift dient der geschichtlichen Forschung und wissenschaftlichen Dokumentation Zusammengestellt durch: Matthias Köpke, Eigenverlag 2018, 17291 Nordwestuckermark, Germany. E-mail: [email protected] 1. Auflage Diese vorliegende Schrift und deren Verfasser beanspruchen für sich den Esausegen gemäß 1. Mose (Genesis) 27, 40 und stehen somit unter dem Schutz des Esausegens als oberste gesetzliche Regelung für alle Jahwehgläubigen! Nähere Informationen zum Esausegen sind in den Werken: „Das wahre Gesicht von Jakob dem Betrüger“, „Der jüdische Sinn von Beschneidung und Taufe“, „Der Papst oberster Gerichtsherr in der BR Deutschland“ und „Das offene Tor“ von Matthias Köpke, jeweils als E-Book und Freeware unter www.archive.org oder www.scribd.com enthalten! Dasselbe gilt für die anderen Werke von Köpke. Dieses eBook ist Freeware. Weitergabe, Vervielfältigung, Ausdruck und Speicherung in elektronischen Medien sind für Privatpersonen und Bildungseinrichtungen frei. Die gewerbliche bzw. kommerzielle Nutzung bedarf der vorherigen schriftlichen Zustimmung des Autors.
    [Show full text]
  • New Religions and the Nazis
    NEW RELIGIONS AND THE NAZIS KARLA POEWE New Religions and the Nazis This book highlights an important but neglected part of Nazi history—the contribution of new religions to the emergence of Nazi ideology in 1920s and 1930s Germany. Karla Poewe argues that Nazism was the unique consequence of post-World War I conditions in Germany, a reaction against the decadence of nineteenth-century liberalism, the shameful defeat of World War I, the imposition of an unwanted Weimar democracy, and the postwar punishment of the Treaty of Versailles. Aiming towards national regeneration, leading cultural figures such as Jakob Wilhelm Hauer, Mathilde Ludendorff, Ernst Bergmann, Hans Grimm, and Hans F.K.Günther wanted to shape the cultural milieu of politics, religion, theology, Indo-Aryan metaphysics, literature and Darwinian science into a new genuinely German faith-based political community. Instead what emerged was a totalitarian political regime known as National Socialism, with an anti-Semitic world-view. Looking at modern German paganism as well as the established Church, Poewe reveals that the new religions founded in the pre-Nazi and Nazi years, especially Jakob Hauer’s German Faith Movement, would be a model for how German fascism distilled aspects of religious doctrine into political extremism. New Religions and the Nazis addresses one of the most important questions of the twentieth century—how and why did Germans come to embrace National Socialism? Researched from original documents, letters and unpublished papers, including the SS personnel files held in Berlin’s Bundesarchiv, it is an absorbing and fresh approach to the difficulties raised by this deeply significant period of history.
    [Show full text]
  • Nordic Ideology in the SS and the SS Ahnenerbe 53 Momentum and Drew from Ahnenerbe Resources
    NordiN ordicc ldeologyIdeology inin thethe SSSS andand ththee SSSS AhnenerbeAhnenerbe Horst JJungingerunginger 1.1. TheThe HistoriographHistoriographyy ofof thethe ChurchChurch StruggleStruggle andand itsits MisrepresenMisrepresen­• tationstations TheThe conceptualconceptual frameworkframework ofof ththee so-calledso-called historiographhistoriographyy ofof ththee churchchurch strugglestruggle hashas shapedshaped thethe scholarlyscholarly occupationoccupation withwith ththee religiousreligious developmentdevelopment iinn ththee ThirdThird ReicReichh ttoo a largelarge extent.extent. TwoTwo fallaciousfallacious equationsequations inin particularparticular affectedaffected ththee post-wapost-warr debatedebate eveneven withinwithin secularsecular historicahistoricall scholarship.scholarship. TueThe firstfirst waswas ththee identificationidentification ooff NationalNational SocialismSocialism witwithh NationalNational SocialistSocialist Paganism.Paganism. InIn ththee continuationcontinuation ofof ththee formerformer quarrelsquarrels betweebetweenn churchchurch andand statestate overover thethe impactimpact ofof aa numbernumber ofof measuresmeasures taketakenn againstagainst churchchurch interests,interests, thethe NaziregimeNa2i regime appearedappeared fromfrom aa certaincertain perspectiveperspective asas politicapoliticall fulfihnentfulfilment ofof thethe warstworst ofof anan anti-Christiananti-Christian heathendoheathendomm aimingaiming ttoo annianni­• hilathilatee ChristianityChristianity inin GermanyGermany asas aa whole.whole. Secondly,Secondly,
    [Show full text]
  • Paganism, Christianity and the First Nazi Christmas
    Draft version: this is the ‘final version of the contribution as accepted for publication (subsequent to revision arising from peer review but prior to editorial input)’ [CEH/CUP copyright agreement]. The revised version has been published by Cambridge University Press as ‘Were the National Socialists a Völkisch Party? Paganism, Christianity, and the Nazi Christmas’ in Central European History 47 (2014): 760–90. All rights reserved © Conference Group for Central European History of the American Historical Association, 2014. http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayJournal?jid=CCC. Were the Nazis a Völkisch Party? Paganism, Christianity and the First Nazi Christmas Samuel Koehne he consideration of movements and sub-cultures within particular societies has always formed an integral part of intellectual history. In studies of TNazis m and religion in recent years, there has been a trend towards arguing a deliberate disjunction or separation of the Nazi Party from the longer German anti- Semitic völkisch movement (dating from the nineteenth century) from which Nazism itself arose––a perspective that is challenged in this essay. While there are excellent studies on the heterogeneous nature of Christian response to the Nazis, there has not been a comparable approach in examining how the Nazis viewed religion.1 Yet this is certainly needed, as one of the consistent features of the völkisch movement was its diversity. Roger Griffin argued a “striking feature of the sub-culture…was just how prolific and variegated it was” such that “the only denominator common to all was the myth of national rebirth.” 2 It contained a colourful, varied and often bewildering range of religious beliefs.
    [Show full text]
  • Jews and Protestants
    Jews and Protestants Jews and Protestants From the Reformation to the Present Edited by Irene Aue-Ben-David, Aya Elyada, Moshe Sluhovsky and Christian Wiese Supported by the I-CORE Program of the Planning and Budgeting Committee and The Israel Science Foundation (grant No. 1798/12) Die freie Verfügbarkeit der E-Book-Ausgabe dieser Publikation wurde ermöglicht durch den Fachinformationsdienst Jüdische Studien an der Universitätsbibliothek J. C. Senckenberg Frankfurt am Main und 18 wissenschaftliche Bibliotheken, die die Open-Access-Transformation in den Jüdischen Studien unterstützen. ISBN 978-3-11-066108-8 e-ISBN (PDF) 978-3-11-066471-3 e-ISBN (EPUB) 978-3-11-066486-7 Despite careful production of our books, sometimes mistakes happen. Unfortunately, the CC license was not included in the original publication. This has been corrected. We apologize for the mistake. Dieses Werk ist lizenziert unter der Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Lizenz. Weitere Informationen finden Sie unter http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Das E-Book ist als Open-Access-Publikation verfügbar über www.degruyter.com, https://www.doabooks.org und https://www.oapen.org. Library of Congress Control Number: 2019955542 Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available on the Internet at http://dnb.dnb.de. © 2020, Aue-Ben-David et al., published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston Cover image: ulimi / DigitalVision Vectors / gettyimages.de Printing and binding: CPI books GmbH, Leck www.degruyter.com Open-Access-Transformation in den Jüdischen Studien Open Access für exzellente Publikationen aus den Jüdischen Studien: Dies ist das Ziel der gemeinsamen Initiative des Fachinformationsdiensts Jüdische Studien an der Universitäts- bibliothek J.
    [Show full text]