The Palestinian Shahid and the Development of the Model 21St Century Islamic Terrorist
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
California State University, San Bernardino CSUSB ScholarWorks Theses Digitization Project John M. Pfau Library 2008 The Palestinian Shahid and the development of the model 21st century Islamic terrorist Benjamin Timothy Acosta Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.lib.csusb.edu/etd-project Part of the Terrorism Studies Commons Recommended Citation Acosta, Benjamin Timothy, "The Palestinian Shahid and the development of the model 21st century Islamic terrorist" (2008). Theses Digitization Project. 3367. https://scholarworks.lib.csusb.edu/etd-project/3367 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the John M. Pfau Library at CSUSB ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses Digitization Project by an authorized administrator of CSUSB ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE PALESTINIAN SHAHID AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF 'THE MODEL 2.1st CENTURY ISLAMIC' TERRORIST A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of California State University, San Bernardino In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts in National Security Studies by Benjamin Timothy Acosta June 2008 THE PALESTINIAN SHAHID AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MODEL 21st CENTURY ISLAMIC TERRORIST A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of California State University, San Bernardino by Benjamin Timothy Acosta June 2008 Approved by: Date © 2008 Benjamin T. Acosta ABSTRACT Since the early 1990s, Palestinian organizations have drawn from many sources and incrementally refined the process of suicide terrorism. By making the modus operandi socially acceptable and even fashionable, Palestinian organizations have normalized the deployment of suicide homicide bombers. These organizations have optimized the progress individuals take from reasoning and justifying to rationalizing and actually committing suicide terrorism. Palestinian organizations have not only developed a strategic weapon for their war with Israel, but also provided Islamist-terror organizations, such as those within the global al-Qaeda network, with the model 21st Century terrorist, as well as efficient methods to produce such individuals. By mobilizing mass support in the Sunni world and empowering the individual through the concepts of jihad and istishhad, the shahid, as epitomized by Palestinians during al-Aqsa intifada, secured suicide terrorism's growing organizational partiality, ensured lethality, decreasing targeting discrimination, and frequency in the international arena. Thus, the phenomenon of the Palestinian shahid has become a driving force behind the increasing spread of suicide terrorism worldwide. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would very much like to thank the following scholars that have guided me through the wilderness of mirrors over the years: Ray Geigle (California State University- Bakersfield), Jonathan Fine (International Institute for Counter-Terrorism), Benny Morris (Ben-Gurion University of the Negev), Wafa Kays (Lebanese American University), Mark T. Clark (California State University-San Bernardino), and most of all my grandmother B. Zoe Acosta (Point Loma University). iv For Sabina and those who suffer as she does... TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT..................... ......................... iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS... ................................... iv NOTE ON TRANSLATION AND TRANSLITERATION............ ix GLOSSARY............................................... xii ABBREVIATIONS .......................'........... xvi CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION: SHAHIDFASHIONS .............. 1 CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW: APPROACHING RESEARCH ON SUICIDE-HOMICIDE ATTACKS................. .. 14 Definitional and Investigative Differences........ 16 Levels of Analysis................................ 19 The Palestinian Context........................... 27 CHAPTER THREE: METHODOLOGY: DEFINITIONS, CONCEPTS AND THE RELATION BETWEEN IDENTITY AND POLITICAL VIOLENCE Purpose of Study.................................. 33 Definitions....................................... 39 Concepts.......................................... 45 Identity Construction and Fluctuation in Pursuit of a Nation-State...................... 50 Producing the Contemporary Shahid.................. 57 CHAPTER FOUR: RAISING THE SHAHID WITH IDENTITY AND IDEOLOGY: PALESTINIAN SOCIETY, ORGANIZATIONS AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF A CULTURE OF MARTYRDOM..... '............... 62 Terror Organizations as the Voice of the Palestinians.................. 67 v The Hamas Terror Machine: Organizing Da'awa and Mechanizing Jihad........... 73 Breeding Efficiency: The Effects of Competition over Resistance........ 77 Political Culture and Irrevocable Beliefs.... 7 9 Political Islam Carries on as the Palestine Liberation Organization Acquiesces........... 84 The Palestinian Suicide-Homicide Bomber........... 8 6 The Culture of Martyrdom and Its Socio-Political Development............... 93 The Social Synthesis of Competing Political Ideologies: Palestinian Identity Solidified?............. 95 0 Palestinian Political Culture and Identity: Same Song, Different Genre........................ 104 CHAPTER FIVE: A STRATEGIC TERROR WEAPON (THE SUICIDE-HOMICIDE BOMBER) AS THE PARAMOUNT TERRORIST (THE SHAHID): MATCHING CAPABILITY TO MOTIVATION........ 110 Strategy Adopted and Adapted: Fitting Goals with Means.......................... 116 The Pioneer and the Refiners: Hezballah and the Palestinians.................... 121 Death by Ten Thousand Bee Stings............. 128 Contextualizing Success...................... 134 Balance of Terror?........................... 137 When Organizational Means Are Individuals' Ends....139 CHAPTER SIX: ALLAH, "PALESTINE," AND TRIBE: MOTIVATING INDIVIDUAL PALESTINIANS TO COMMIT MARTYRDOM.......................... 144 vi Absent a Profile.................................. 147 The Semantics of "Suicide" and "Martyrdom"........ 151 Between Altruism and Egoism.... J............. 156 The Institutionalization of "Victimhood"..... 157 Arab Prison, Islamic Escape: Killing to Die...160 "We Love Death-- It Brings Us Our 15 Minutes".......... 166 Motivations in Sum................................ 169 CHAPTER SEVEN: THE PALESTINIAN CULTURE OF MARTYRDOM AND SHAHID: PROVIDING THE MODEL FOR 21st CENTURY ISLAMIC TERRORISM............... 173 Exporting the Palestinian Shahid.................. 177 Direct Links and al-Qaeda's Palestinian Aura. ............. 184 The "Occupation" of Dar al-Islam, Defensive Jihad and Fard Ayn................ ......................18 9 Al-Qaeda's Adaptation of the Culture of Martyrdom..............................193 Framing Conflict............................. 196 Social Networks.............. 204 The Palestinian Legacy Today: Suicide Terrorism as a Global Phenomenon.......... 205 CHAPTER EIGHT: CONCLUSION: SUICIDE TERRORISM AS A FIXTURE OF THE 21st CENTURY?............. 210 The Three Pillars of Suicide Terrorism: Individuals'Ends as Organizations' Means to Collective Goals. .............................. .213 vii Countering Pillar One: Preempting Terror Organizations.............. 216 Countering Pillar Two: Deterring Collective Support for Suicide Terrorism................ 217 Countering Pillar Three: Un-Motivating Individuals to Commit Suicide Terrorism...... 219 Undercutting Istishhad with Individuality......... 221 APPENDIX A: PALESTINIAN SUICIDE-HOMICIDE ATTACKS IN ISRAEL (APRIL 1993 TO APRIL 2008).......... 225 APPENDIX B: SNAPSHOTS OF THE PALESTINIAN CULTURE OF MARTYRDOM....................... 234 BIBLIOGRAPHY Books, Articles, Reports, Statements and Other Documents................................... 238 DVDs, Videos, and Other Electronic Recordings..... 260 viii NOTE ON TRANSLATION AND TRANSLITERATION Translating and transliterating a Semitic language to a Germanic one is like trying to replicate a brilliant painting using a sculptor's tools. That both Arabic and English maintain a richness that increases the amount of meanings words have contextually further complicates matters. Each Arabic root-word has various forms that lead to any number of representations. Regional dialects make translation even harder. So for the purposes of this work, translations refer to a word's common use within the context of the topic at hand. Transliterations simply reflect an attempt to minimize confusion. Arabic and other foreign words are italicized throughout the text unless the word's English equivalent is identical (e.g. Sunni) or similar (al-Qaeda versus al-Qa'eda). Silent Arabic letters, such as the ta'marbuta and haa', are not written, unless a word's English equivalent is the identical; for example, instead of shahadah, just shahada is written, but Allah is written as it commonly is in English. Oftentimes translations denote Arabic letters that have no English equivalent with numbers. Avoiding such confusing methods, apostrophes signify these unique letters. For example, depending on the vowel within the word, either 'a, 'e or ’u denotes the Arabic letter ’ayn. Words are transliterated to English from Fousha (Modern Standard Arabic); however, proper nouns defer to an 'Ammiyya (Spoken Arabic) transliteration, in order to represent the colloquial form of Arabic that relates to the - individual or organization. For example, the Palestine Liberation Organization's Arabic name, Munazzmat al-Tahri.r al-Filastiniyya, employs the Arabic letter dHaa' to sound like a "z"—reflecting the Levantine dialect. Similarly, as an Egyptian, Ayman al-Zawahiri uses the Egyptian dialect for his name, which turns the dHaa' into a "zh" sound. Words like Hezballah, which