Black Lives Matter and Ethnographic Museums
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ICME NEWS ISSUE 90 AUGUST 2020 black lives matter and etHnographic museums A statement from ICME Committee Announcements AND NEWS / Exhibitions and Conferences: Announcements and Reviews / ARTICLES / NOTICES ICME NEWS 90 AUGUST 2020 2 CONTENTS Words from the Editor .........................................................3 ICME Board Announcements and News Black Lives Matter and Ethnographic Museums: A Statement from ICME .........................................................4 Postponement of the 2020 ICME Conference ........................5 Exhibitions and Conferences: Announcements and Reviews Conference Review: Absence and Belonging in Museums of Everyday Life – Laurie Cosmo ...............................................6 Conference Review: Beyond collecting; new ethics for museums in transition – Flower Manasse .................................13 Conference Announcement: Anthropology and Geography ......15 Conference Announcement: Mapping South-South Connections ..........................................................16 Film Review: Bang the Drum – Jenny Walklate .......................17 Articles How can Museums Challenge Racism and Colonial Fantasies? - Boniface Mabanza in conversation with Anette Rein ............19 Getting out, getting in: Amerindian and European perspectives around the museum - Rui Mourão .........................25 Kurmanjan Datka. Museum of Nomadic Civilization, The Kyrgyz Republic - Aida Alymova and Gulbara Abdykalykova .............29 Beyond Trophies and Spoils of Wars - Staci-Marie Dehaney ........33 The Village Museum: Rural settings in an Urban Environment - Wilbard Lema & Flora Vicent .................38 Notices UK Heritage Organisations Issue Joint Statement in Response to Black Lives Matter Movement .......................42 Launch of Online Resource on Repatriation Issues – MEG Group ..........................................................................43 Contact ICME News ..............................................................44 On the cover: The Genocide Monument outside the National Museum of Namibia in Windhoek (Photo: J. Silvester) ICME NEWS 90 AUGUST 2020 3 words FROM THE EDITOR This edition of the ICME access to debates and virtual newsletter carries a statement exhibitions and events that from the ICME Board. It argues are now being posted online. that ethnographic museums have a responsibility to play Museums across the world are a leading role in combating being challenged to find new injustice and ignorance, but ways to be both accessible and that this will require critical meaningful to their publics. In reflection and new forms of the next newsletter we would action. The features in this like to showcase some of the edition of the newsletter ways in which ethnographic include an interview with museums have engaged with Dear ICME members, Boniface Mabanza in which the cultural impact of the he reflects on the implications virus. We would also like to Welcome to the 90th Edition of the Black Lives Matter share some of the imaginative of our ICME newsletter. The movement on museums. We ways in which museums Black Lives Matter movement also have an introduction to have continued to provide a has placed demands on the new web site created by service. The editorial team Ethnographic Museums to the Museum Ethnographers is committed to making the acknowledge the fact that Group (MEG) in the UK which newsletter reflect different many collections contain provides resources on the perspectives from many objects that were removed repatriation of artifacts. different parts of the world. from their owners in the context However, to achieve this goal of colonial violence. Many We are also living through a we rely on our members. So ethnographic museums have time when COVID-19 is making please, contact a member of released statements stating a us all radically rethink our the editorial team if you would commitment to confront the assumptions about travel like to suggest or provide an history of their collections (and and communication. On the article for the next newsletter. the newsletter includes one joint one hand the pandemic is statement made by a number forcing us to explore new Jeremy Silvester of UK heritage institutions). ways to network through the Some museums now see the internet and encouraging repatriation of artifacts as an international dialogue on ethical obligation, but one virtual platforms. On the that also creates opportunities other hand, these initiatives for developing new creative are also reinforcing the digital collaborative projects. divide, particularly in terms of ICME NEWS 90 AUGUST 2020 19 ARTICLES How can Museums Challenge Racism and Colonial Fantasies? Boniface Mabanza in conversation with Anette Rein (March, 2020)1 Dr Anette Rein and Dr Theol. Boniface Mabanza (Photo: Laura Plönnigs) Rein: So how do you define racism? classification of people, combined with spontaneous meetings and Mabanza: Racism has two basic with the existing cultural, economic, expressions of sympathy. Do you elements: 1. racialisation: the cate- political and military instruments have the impression that something gorisation of people on the basis of of power, have made it possible for has changed, and that the topic of external characteristics such as skin some Europeans to enslave, colonise racism as a mechanism of marking colour or cultural attributes. 2. The and exploit. Racification has served to and exclusion has arrived in the con- use of instruments of power to make justify this colonial exploitation and sciousness of the population - as the racialisation effective. Behind this this brutality of enslavement ... reactions in the Frankfurt football lies a history that has been shaped by stadium on 20.2.2020 let us hope? Europe in its encounters with the rest Large parts of the population For Germany as a whole, I cannot yet of the world. In short, it can be said reacted to the murders in Hanau, say that the context has been sensi- that hierarchisation, racialisation and Germany, in February this year tized. I would say that here there is ICME NEWS 90 AUGUST 2020 20 The "Reiter" statue in storage at the National Museum of Namibia after its removal (Photo. Randy Mwatondange) both. There is the development that we people meet with massive rejection from the public eye. Wouldn’t it make are becoming increasingly aware of the because the discourses of the right- much more sense to place the corre- racist socialization we are experiencing wing forces are spreading, so that many sponding history under the existing in Germany. On an institutional level, see the presence of people who look street signs to explain why a new this is expressed by the fact that there different or come from somewhere name was introduced? are more and more institutions that else as a threat to themselves, to their An example from Namibia shows us are conducting anti-racism training in life situation, to their culture, to their how it could also work in the German order to work sensitively with diversity. comfort - and express this. It goes so context: In Namibia, there was an Even sports associations are attaching far that, according to my observation, equestrian monument that had been more and more importance to the there are many people who think that inaugurated in 1912 in the then colony training of trainers in order to deal all non-white people only came to Ger- of German South West Africa at a very constructively with diversity, due to the many after 2015. The fact that Germany prominent location in Windhoek. In large presence of people with migra- has a long history with Africa and with 2013 it was moved to the inner court- tion biographies. Due to the experience black people living here has increasing- yard of the Alte Feste, which houses the of the two world wars, especially after ly been pushed into the background. National Museum of Namibia. When the Second World War, there are many the government decided to implement people in Germany who are sensitive As a result of the postcolonial dis- it, white groups, mainly from the com- and also able to react immediately to courses of the last decade, street munity of German descent, protested. racist thinking and racist behaviour. names of people who were greedy They wanted to keep the representative and murderous during the colonial of the then German “Schutztruppen” But there is also the counter-devel- period as merchants, military or at exactly this place. However, the opment since 2015, that "non-white" explorers in Africa are to disappear government wanted to build a symbol ICME NEWS 90 AUGUST 2020 21 of Namibia’s independence (since 1990) from West Africa. He changed elemen- the global North until the 1930s. In there - a genocide memorial. They tary school several times, because he 2005, when a German zoo invited Af- argued that the aim was not to erase was directly confronted with it by the rican musicians and traders, among the equestrian monument from the pupils. He fought because he could not others, to offer their wares, weave memory of mankind, but to keep it in a stand it. I understand him when he told plaits and make music for four days museum where the historical context me: “I cannot hear the word, I cannot on the zoo grounds under the motto could be better conveyed than on the accept it if someone speaks the word “African Village”, ethnologists and street. This is also my suggestion with in my presence”. I feel the same way. activists published the problematic regard to Lüderitz and von Trotha etc. But when it is told