American Languages
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SENRI ETHNOLoGIcAL STuDIEs No. 39 NATIVE MIDDLE AMERICAN LANGUAGES AN AREAL-TYPOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE by Yoshiho YASUGI National Museum of Ethnology, Osaka 1995 Acknowledgments I wish to express my deep appreciation and gratitude to Lyle Campbell for his valuable comments and suggestions. This work is an outgrowth of my doctoral dissertation, entitled "An Areal-Typological Study of Middle American Indian Languages" (The Graduate University for Advanced Studies, 1993). Chapters 2, 3 and 6 were written as part of the proj ect titled "A Comprehensive Study of the Func- tion and Typology of Language" headed by Masayoshi Shibatani, with a grant-in- aid from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture of the Japanese Govern- ment. I would like to thank Tasaku Tsunoda, a member of my dissertation commit- tee, for supplying numerous references as well as for his helpful comments and criticisms on earlier versions of this study. I owe a considerable debt to him for pointing out to me that the square proposed in Chapter 6 has a cyclic nature and that this is a new type of relation. I would like to acknowledge the advice and sup- port of the other members of my committee: Etsuko Kuroda, Osahito Miyaoka, Hiroyasu Tomoeda, Osamu Sakiyama, and Yasuhiko Nagano. I am so much in- debted to them that it is unlikely that I will be able to repay their kindness fully. Since English is not my native language, I frequ'ently do not perceive subtle differences in meaning and cannot always chOose the best possible phrasing. Even worse, I feel that my logic significantly differs from that of native English speakers. Although faced with these diMculties, I elected to write this monograph in English given the predominance of English in the academic world, with the result that at times I felt linguistically handicapped. Jaan Ingle aided me in bvercoming these obstacles, and I wish to acknowledge her help in editing and proofreading the final version of this monograph. iii Contents page Acknowledgments iii Table of Contents v List of Tables Vll List of Maps Vll List of Figures viii Key to Abbreviations and Symbols Viii PART I 1. Introduction 3 2. PhonologicalSystems 11 2.1. PhonologicalDescriptions 12 2.2. Consonant System Typology 14 2.2.1. Statistical Survey 15 2.2.2. StopSystems 21 2.2.3. Fricative Systems 30 2.2.4. Nasal Systems 36 2.2.5. Liquid Systems 40 2.2.6. GlideSystems 43 2.3. Vowel System Typology 45 2.3.1. Statistical Survey 47 2.3.2. Typological Survey 48 2.3.3. ToneSystems 54 2.4. Summary 57 3. Areal Features and Linguistic Universals 59 3.1. Areal Features of Phonological Systems 59 3.1.1. Possession of Rare Traits 59 3.1.2. LackofCommonTraits 64 3.2. Linguistic Universals 65 3.2.1. Stops and Fricatives 65 3.2.2. Nasals 69 3.2.3. Liquids 70 3.2.4. Vowels 71 3.3. Summary 75 4. NumeralSystems 77 4.1. Some Problems in the Description of Counting Methods 78 4.2. Materials and Their Analysis 81 4.3. Discussion 83 v vi Native Middle American Languages 4.3.1. Uto-Aztecan 85 4.3.2. 0tomanguean 93 4.3.3. Mayan 97 4.3.4. Mixe-Zoquean 1OO 4.3.5. 0therLanguages 101 4.4. Summary 103 5. WordOrderTypology 107 5.1. Linguistic Materials and Their Analysis 107 5.2. Language Types and Language Classification 109 5.3. Discussion 115 5.3.1. S/O/VOrder 115 5.3.2. The Relative Order of S/O/V and Pr/Po 120 5.3.3. Coexistence of Po and Pr 123 5.3.4. GN/NG 125 5.3.5. AN/NA 126 5.3.6. PN/NP 128 5.3.7. DN/ND 129 5.3.8. QN/NQ 129 5.4. Summary 130 6. Toward a New Typology of Language: Typology of the Syntactic Relations of Cross-Referencing Pronominals 133 6.1. PersonMarkingSystem 134 6.2. PronominalSquare 135 6.3. Types of Pronominal Square 137 6.4. Discussion 147 6.5. Summary 151 7. Conclusions 153 PART II Database 1: Phonological Systems 167 Database 2: Numeral Systems 241 Database 3: Word Order Typology 345 Notes 407 Appendices 1. PhonemeCharts 411 2. Distribution of Number of Consonants in Native Middle American Languages 412 3. Vowel Inventories of Native Middle American Languages 418 Maps 429 Bibliography 447 Language Index 475 Subject Index 480 Contents vii Tables 1. Classification of Native Middle American languages 2. Distribution in terms of number of consonants in the system 3. Number of stop series 4. Manner contrasts in stops 5. Manner contrasts in fricatives 6. Voiceless stops: number of places of articulation and number of languages 7. Voiced stops: number of places of articulation and number of languages 8. Prenasalized stops: number of places of articulation and number of languages 9. Lenis stops: number of places of articulation and number of languages 10. Fricatives: number of places of articulation and number of languages 11. Nasals: number of places of articulation and number of languages 12. Number of phonemes and variations 13. Number of phonemes and languages in regards to voiceless stops 14. Number of voiceless and voiced stops and number of languages 15. Number of voiceless and prenasal stops and number of languages 16. Number of fortis and lenis stops and number of languages 17. Types of afuicate and sibilant combinations 18. Nasal types 19. Number of nasals and number of languages 20. Distribution of /y/ and /w/ 21. Distribution in terms of number of vowels in the system 22. Symmetrical and asymmetrical systems 23. Number of oral stops and number of languages 24. Number of fricatives and number of languages 25. Number of nasals and number of languages 26. Number of normal length vowels and number of languages 27. The numerals from 1 to 10 in Northern Uto-Aztecan 28. Numeral systems in Northern Uto-Aztecan 29. Distribution of word-order types' 30. Connection between s/v/o and S/V/O 31. Distribution of word order type by type Maps 1. Distribution of Native Middle American languages 2. Distribution ofvowel systems 3. Distribution of vowel quantity and nasality 4. Distribution of glottalized, prenasalized, and fortis-lenis consonants 5. Distribution of /kW/, /q/ and retroflexed consonants 6. Distribution of methods of counting from 1 to 10 7. Distribution of methods of counting from 10 to 20 8. Distribution of methods of counting from 20 on 9. Distribution of methods of forming the word for 100 viii Native Middle American Languages 10. Distribution of methods of counting from 10 to 20 in Mayan languages 11. Distribution of methods of counting from 20 on in Mayan languages 12. Distribution of different words for 20 13. Distribution of methods of counting from 20/21 to 39/40 14. Distribution of methods of counting from 40/41/ to 59/60 15. Distribution of methods of counting from 60/61 to 79/80 16. Distribution of methods of counting from 80/81 to 99 17. Distribution of SOV, SVO, VOS, and VSO Figures 1. Stela 2, Chiapa de Corzo 2-14. Pronominalsquares Key to Abbreviations and Symbols ABS : absolutive ACC : accusatlve . ACT : active AG : agent ART : article AUX : auxiliary C : consonant(s) CL : clitic COMP : completive CONJ : conJunctlon DEF : definite article DEM : demonstrative DEP : dependency marking DIMIN : diminutive DIR : directional DIS : distal DISTR : distributor ERG : ergatlve EXP : experlencer . FEM : feminine FUT : future G : geminated vowel(s) GEN : gemtlve HAB : habitual IMPERF : imperfect INCOMP : incompletive L : long vowel(s) LOC : locative Contents iX MASC masculine MOOD mood N nasalized vowel(s) NCL noun classifier NUCL numeral classifier NONREFL non-reflexive OBJ object PASS passlve PAST past PERF perfective PL plural POSS possesslve POSSD possessed PRON pronoun PROX : proximate (past, future) REALIZED realized REC recent past REF reflexive SG singular SUBJ subj ect TP topicalization V : vowel(s) // phonemic transcription [] phonetic transcription PART I Chapter 1 Introduction Middle America is a multilingual region, where various indigenous languages are still spoken by more than eight million people. The most populous group among them are the speakers of Mayan languages, followed by speakers of Uto- Aztecan and Otomanguean languages. .These groups speak many languages altogether. Smaller groups include the Mixe-Zoquean and the Totonacan, and there are many other isolated languages and small language families. In Central America there is one Arawakan (Garifuna) and a few Chibchan languages which belong with South American language families linguistically; other Central American languages include Misumalpan, Xinca, Lencan and Tol (commonly call- ed Jicaque). Most of these are in danger of extinction or are already dead. Middle America is a politico-geographical construct. As commonly viewed, it includes Mexico and Central America, although northern Mexico is sometimes ex- cluded while the Antilles are sometimes included. Central America extends from Guatemala through Panama. Mesoamerica is another term used in anthropology and linguistics in connection with Middle America. Mesoamerica is, roughly speak- ing, the central part of Middle America, extending from north central Mexico through the western part of El Salvador and Honduras. It was designated a cultural area by Kirchhoff on the basis of its many shared .cultural features [KIRcHHoFF In this study I have chosen 1943]. the languages of :Middle America from the northern Mexican border to the south of Panama. However, it should be noted that, linguistically speaking, Middle America is arbitrarily designated a geographical area. Neither genetic nor'areal linguistic classifications coincide with these boun- daries. On the other hand, it has been shown that Mesoamerica is a linguistic area. Campbell et al. have demopstrated that Mesoamerica is a linguistic area in the sense of others recognized in the literature, such as the Balkans or South Asia [CmeBELL, KAuFMAN, and SMiTH-STARK 1986].