DOCSLIB.ORG

Putting the Democracy Into Edemocracy

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Putting the Democracy Into Edemocracy Putting the Democracy into eDemocracy: An investigation into the arguments for the democratic potential of the Internet ALLISON VERITY ORR 2120304 1 CONTENTS Contents ................................................................................................................................................ 2 CHAPTER 1 – INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................... 5 Overview ......................................................................................................................................... 10 The Internet ..................................................................................................................................... 13 A Brief History of the Internet ......................................................................................................... 15 Language and the Internet .............................................................................................................. 18 CHAPTER 2 - METHODOLOGY .............................................................................................................. 26 Essentially Contested Concepts ....................................................................................................... 29 Constellations of Concepts .............................................................................................................. 30 Political Disagreement and Rhetorical Arguments .......................................................................... 30 Conceptual Change and Legitimation ............................................................................................. 35 CHAPTER 3 – MYTHS, MODERNITY AND PROGRESS ........................................................................... 40 The Mythology of the Internet ........................................................................................................ 41 Progress ........................................................................................................................................... 43 Progress, Democracy and the Internet ............................................................................................ 47 Modernity ........................................................................................................................................ 50 Modernity, myths and the Internet ................................................................................................. 54 Myth: The Internet Cannot be Controlled ................................................................................... 58 Myth: The Internet is Anarchic .................................................................................................... 64 Myth: The Internet has no Gatekeepers ..................................................................................... 69 Myth: The Internet Challenges Corporatised Media ................................................................... 73 Myth: Everyone has Access to the Internet ................................................................................ 77 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 80 CHAPTER 4 –DEMOCRACY ................................................................................................................... 81 Democracy ....................................................................................................................................... 81 The Democratic Crisis ...................................................................................................................... 86 Democratic Theory and the Internet ............................................................................................... 92 CHAPTER 5 – DIRECT DEMOCRACY ..................................................................................................... 96 Direct Democracy ............................................................................................................................ 98 2 Direct Democracy and the Internet ............................................................................................... 100 The Problems of Direct Democracy ............................................................................................... 103 Size and System Capacity .......................................................................................................... 104 Complexity and Competence .................................................................................................... 109 The Need for Leadership ........................................................................................................... 114 The “Tyranny of the Majority” .................................................................................................. 116 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 123 CHAPTER 6: REPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY...................................................................................... 125 Representative Democracy ........................................................................................................... 126 Representation .............................................................................................................................. 129 Representative Democracy and The Internet................................................................................ 133 a) The Internet and Representation: Communication............................................................... 133 b) Representative Democracy and the Internet: Information ................................................... 145 The Problems of Simplifying Representation ................................................................................ 152 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 157 CHAPTER 7 – PARTICIPATION ............................................................................................................. 160 Participation .................................................................................................................................. 162 Participation and the Internet: Who Participates ......................................................................... 166 A New Participatory Democracy? .................................................................................................. 172 Why do(n’t) People Participate? ................................................................................................... 176 Web 2.0 and “Viral Democracy”.................................................................................................... 181 2008 Obama campaign: A Diminished View of Participation? ...................................................... 190 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 199 Chapter 8 - DELIBERATION AND THE PUBLIC SPHERE ....................................................................... 201 The “Deliberative Turn” and the Public Sphere ............................................................................. 202 Deliberative Democracy and The Internet .................................................................................... 206 The Internet and the Public Sphere............................................................................................... 213 Locating a Public Sphere Online .................................................................................................... 218 Locating Deliberation Online ......................................................................................................... 222 a) Diversity of Views .................................................................................................................. 222 b) Engaging the Unengaged ...................................................................................................... 226 The Legitimacy of Deliberative Democracy ................................................................................... 232 3 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 235 CHAPTER 9 - CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................... 237 REFERENCES ...................................................................................................................................... 241 4 CHAPTER 1 – INTRODUCTION In the last decades of the twentieth century, and into the new century, there has been a sense that Western democracies are suffering a crisis of disengagement. Lower citizen turnout at elections, dwindling party membership, and declining trust in democratic institutions has lead to a perception that democracy is in need of renewal. Across the same time period, the Internet has emerged to occupy an ever-increasing role in our daily lives. From access to multiple forms of media and unprecedented opportunities for information sharing and distribution, to easy and cheap communications with the world, it has had an enormously engaging impact on our world. The confluence of these two trends
Load more

Recommended publications
  • O Crystal, D., Internet Linguistics: a Student Guide
    BOOK REVIEWS c CRYSTAL, D., INTERNET LINGUISTICS: A STUDENT GUIDE. (NEW YORK, ROUTLEDGE. 2011. PP. IX, 179) Review by Sean Rintel School of Journalism and Communication, The University of Queensland ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ I approached this book as a teacher of novices, taking seriously David Crystal’s proposition that Internet Linguistics:A Student Guide is an introduction to a nascent field for someone with no subject-matter knowledge beyond raw experience and no language research expertise beyond simple thematic analysis. From that perspective, Crystal succeeds in building an easily grasped overview of the way in which the linguistic discipline might approach the Internet as a principled research enterprise. Generalist overviews of fields of research always encounter debates over disciplinary roots, inclusion and exclusion of fields,
    [Show full text]
  • Internet Linguistics (Ling 004B) Syllabus
    Swarthmore College Works Digital Humanities Curricular Development Faculty Development 2020 Internet Linguistics (Ling 004B) Syllabus Miranda Weinberg Swarthmore College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://works.swarthmore.edu/dev-dhgrants Part of the Linguistics Commons Recommended Citation Miranda Weinberg. (2020). "Internet Linguistics (Ling 004B) Syllabus". Internet Linguistics. https://works.swarthmore.edu/dev-dhgrants/38 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. This work is brought to you for free by Swarthmore College Libraries' Works. It has been accepted for inclusion in Digital Humanities Curricular Development by an authorized administrator of Works. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Internet Linguistics Ling 004B Spring 2020 Course meetings Mondays 1:15-4:00 pm Sci Center 103 Instructor Dr. Miranda Weinberg [email protected] Office: Pearson 103, office hours Thursdays 1-3pm Course Description Despite predictions to the contrary, it seems that the internet has not destroyed English. But how has the internet changed language use, and the study of linguistics? This course will be an exploration of the various forms that language takes online and in other digital formats, such as texting. We will explore questions such as: • Why do my parents insist on texting in full paragraphs? • Is the internet good or bad for the future of indigenous and minority languages? • Is there a difference in meaning between :), :-), ^_^,? • What are the differences and similarities between face-to-face and online communication? We will look at a range of sources and methods for investigating language use online, and use some of these methods in our own investigations of internet language.
    [Show full text]
  • QLD Senate Results Report 2017
    Statement of Results Report Event: 2016 Federal Election - Full Senate Ballot: 2016 Federal Election - Full Senate Order Elected Candidates Elected Group Name 1 George BRANDIS Liberal National Party of Queensland 2 Murray WATT Australian Labor Party 3 Pauline HANSON Pauline Hanson's One Nation 4 Matthew CANAVAN Liberal National Party of Queensland 5 Anthony CHISHOLM Australian Labor Party 6 James McGRATH Liberal National Party of Queensland 7 Claire MOORE Australian Labor Party 8 Ian MACDONALD Liberal National Party of Queensland 9 Andrew BARTLETT The Greens 10 Barry O'SULLIVAN Liberal National Party of Queensland 11 Chris KETTER Australian Labor Party 12 Fraser ANNING Pauline Hanson's One Nation Senate 06 Nov 2017 11:50:21 Page 1 of 5 Statement of Results Report Event: 2016 Federal Election - Full Senate Ballot: 2016 Federal Election - Full Senate Order Excluded Candidates Excluded Group Name 1 Single Exclusion Craig GUNNIS Palmer United Party 2 Single Exclusion Ian EUGARDE 3 Single Exclusion Ludy Charles SWEERIS-SIGRIST Christian Democratic Party (Fred Nile Group) 4 Single Exclusion Terry JORGENSEN 5 Single Exclusion Reece FLOWERS VOTEFLUX.ORG | Upgrade Democracy! 6 Single Exclusion Gary James PEAD 7 Single Exclusion Stephen HARDING Citizens Electoral Council 8 Single Exclusion Erin COOKE Socialist Equality Party 9 Single Exclusion Neroli MOONEY Rise Up Australia Party 10 Single Exclusion David BUNDY 11 Single Exclusion John GIBSON 12 Single Exclusion Chelle DOBSON Australian Liberty Alliance 13 Single Exclusion Annette LOURIGAN Glenn
    [Show full text]
  • Towards a Philosophy of Language Management David Crystal
    Towards a philosophy of language management David Crystal Keynote paper at the conference 'Integrating Content and Language in Higher education', Maastricht, 28 June 2006 Abstract Over the past twenty years, in a number of different domains, I have been preoccupied by the relationship between content and language. Finding myself the editor of a family of general encyclopedias in the late 1980s brought an encounter with 'knowledge' which had to be integrated with my professional linguistic concerns. This has since developed to include issues in document classification, search, e-commerce, and Internet security. Other directions of integration emerged in higher education, notably the need for a synergy between linguistic and cultural studies and between language and literature. And accompanying all this has been a major change in public attitudes to language, following the reaction against institutionalized linguistic prescriptivism and the evolution of a fresh understanding of the relationship between standard and nonstandard language. The varied nature of these examples suggests the need to consider the question of integration at an appropriately general level. and it is this - on analogy with established domains such as the philosophy of science or the philosophy of religion - that the title of my paper is intended to address. Integrating content and language. It is the story of my life - and especially during the last 20 years or so of it. [ have learned how difficult it is to do. And also how wOlthwhile it is to do it. [ cannot address the conference themes to do with the implementation of this aim in educational programmes, for I have not worked in that context for some time.
    [Show full text]
  • Language and the Internet
    This page intentionally left blank Language and the Internet David Crystal investigates the nature of the impact which the Internet is making on language. There is already a widespread popular mythology that the Internet is going to be bad for the future of language – that technospeak will rule, standards be lost, and creativity diminished as globalization imposes sameness. The argument of this book is the reverse: that the Internet is in fact enabling a dramatic expansion to take place in the range and variety of language, and is providing unprecedented opportunities for personal creativity. The Internet has now been around long enough for us to ‘take a view’ about the way in which it is being shaped by and is shaping language and languages, and there is no one better placed than David Crystal to take that view. His book is written to be accessible to anyone who has used the Internet and who has an interest in language issues. DAVID CRYSTAL is one of the world’s foremost authorities on language, and as editor of the Cambridge Encyclopedia database he has used the Internet for research purposes from its earliest manifestations. His work for a high technology company involved him in the development of an information classification system with several Internet applications, and he has extensive professional experience of Web issues. Professor Crystal is author of the hugely successful Cambridge Encyclopedia of Language (1987; second edition 1997), Cambridge Encyclopedia of the English Language (1995), English as a Global Language (1997), and Language Death (2000). An internationally renowned writer, journal editor, lecturer and broadcaster, he received an OBE in 1995 for his services to the English language.
    [Show full text]
  • LANGUAGE and TRANSLATION an Introduction to Language and Translation for Global Online Communications, Localized Websites and International Social Media
    LANGUAGE AND TRANSLATION An introduction to language and translation for global online communications, localized websites and international social media www.ibt.onl An IBT Online ebook publication© Inside your Ebook IBT Online : Go Global with Website Localization WHO SHOULD BE READING THIS EBOOK? 3 LANGUAGE IN THE WORLD 4 LANGUAGE IN EUROPE AND NORTH AMERICA 5 TRANSLATION INDUSTRY 6 TRANSLATION SUPPLIERS 7 TRANSLATION SERVICES 8 TRANSLATION TECHNOLOGY 10 TRANSLATION ONLINE (WEB PAGES, PRESENCE, HOSTING) 13 TRANSLATION ONLINE (SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION, 15 SOCIAL MEDIA) TRANSLATION TOP TEN TRENDS 19 NEXT STEPS AND ABOUT IBT ONLINE 21 Produced by IBT Online publications team. More resources available at: www.ibt.onl/resources www.ibt.onl Language and Translation 2 Who should be reading this? This ebook provides an introduction to language and translation for global online communications used for localized websites and international social media You should be reading this ebook, if you want an introduction to: Languages used for online communications, social media, localized websites and search engine optimization The translation service industry Translation suppliers and services Translation technologies Translation online This ebook is designed for business owners, marketing directors, international business development managers who are looking to grow their exports and business globally and would like guidance on how to manage language and translation in their target markets. This ebook is both informative and practical. It will
    [Show full text]
  • UK Here They Come
    Tuesday, December 6, 2005 Volume 132, Issue 14 Varsity players juggle rigorous academic and athletic schedules The University of Delaware's Independent Student Newspaper Since 1882 Sports Page 29 UK here they come ... Two students win prestigious award BY MARIAH-RUSSELL "I could go back to Kansas and my job in Staff Reporter retail clothing, or go to Egypt and study Arabic," In their spare time, they run · the Dead Sea he said. Marathon in Jordan and practice Brazilian Jiu-­ He chose the latter. Jitsu. On campus, they can be found giving tours Isherwood said he enjoyed his time in Egypt and researching in laboratories. so much that he spent 13 months of the past four But next year, they will both begin graduate years abroad, voyaging to Egypt, South Africa studies in England. And the British government and Morocco. In his travels, he researched will be picking up the tab - worth approximate­ African refugee camps, learned Arabic, worked ly $100,000. at a legal aid organization and taught English to Seniors Tom Isherwood and Jim Parris were refugees. named Marshall Scholars, making the university The following summer Isherwood went to one of only six schools to have more than one Morocco, where he lived with a host family and recipient Others include Georgetown, Stanford improved his Arabic. Then, last January, he and Yale Univeristies. began a seven-month stay in Egypt The Marshall Scholarship was founded by That spring, he worked as a research assis­ the British Parliament as part of the European tant for Dr. Barbara Harrell-Bond, a founder of Recovery Program in 1953.
    [Show full text]
  • Is Internet Really Ruining the English Language?
    http://elr.sciedupress.com English Linguistics Research Vol. 5, No. 2; 2016 “I Have Lost All Ability To Can”: Is Internet Really Ruining The English Language? Oyedokun-Alli Wasiu Ademola1 Ph.D 1Department of English and Literary Studies, Federal University, Oye –Ekiti, Nigeria Correspondence: Oyedokun-Alli Wasiu Ademola, Ph. D, Department of English and Literary Studies, Federal University, Oye –Ekiti, Nigeria Received: March 22, 2015 Accepted: May 6, 2016 Online Published: May 26, 2016 doi:10.5430/elr.v5n2p28 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.5430/elr.v5n2p28 Paper Presented At The 31st Annual National Conference Of The Nigeria English Studies Association (NESA), At The Federal University Lokoja, 26 -29 October, 2015. Abstract Language is an important instrument through which members of a given community express their thoughts, feelings and emotions; it is one of the most fundamental means of human communication and a primary object of the study of linguistics. It is perhaps no more than trite to suggest that the internet has become a fact of social life globally. However, proving this fact needs an ordered frame of reference. Internet linguistics is yet another domain of linguistics advocated by the English linguist, David Crystal. It studies “new language styles and forms that have arisen under the influence of the Internet and other New Media, such as Short Message Service (SMS) text messaging”, (Wikipedia). There have arisen great disputations on whether or not the use of the Internet is hindering language development. This paper examines these arguments in relation to students’ proficiency in language use, generally. To what extent can one generalize the findings in other climes within the Nigerian context? Using both the Critical Discourse Analysis theory and Braddock communication model, the study examines “sent” and “received” SMS and e-mails from the sample population, with a view to determining the impact on the users’ proficiency level in English language Keywords: Language, Internet linguistics, Text messaging 1.
    [Show full text]
  • The Business of Cities 2013
    The Business of Cities 2013 What do 150 city indexes and benchmarking studies tell us about the urban world in 2013? Authors: Tim Moonen, Greg Clark Editor: Rosemary Feenan November 2013 City Index es 2013 Contents 1. City Indexes, Benchmarks and Rankings in 2013 3 2. Global leaders: Consolidation of the ‘Big Six’ 18 3. Continental Systems of Cities and Dynamics in 2013 22 4. Emerging World Cities: A New Paradigm? 31 5. The Race for Investment in Cities 34 6. The Future of Cities: From Smartness to Resilience and Flexibility 37 7. Self-Government and the Fiscal Capacity of Cities. 39 8. Indexes: 10 Cities to Watch 41 9. Full Review 44 1 Comprehensive Studies 44 2 Finance, Investment and Business Environment Indexes 57 3 Macroeconomic Performance Indexes 91 4 Quality of Life Indexes 104 5 Knowledge Economy, Human Capital and Technology Indexes 136 6 Infrastructure and Real Estate Indexes 157 7 Environment and Sustainability Indexes 177 8 Image, Brand and Destination Power Indexes 194 9 Culture and Diversity Indexes 207 10 Cost of Living and Affordability Indexes 215 COPYRIGHT © JONES LANG LASALLE IP, INC. 1 © Greg Clark & The Business of Cities 2013. All Rights Reserved City Index es 2013 Foreword The urban world is in full swing. The number of people living in cities is increasing by more than the population of the UK, Colombia or South Africa each year, and the present and future performance of cities has never been more important. Cities are now the major sites where challenges around the new economy, sustainability and resilience, equality, infrastructure, leisure and culture are all played out.
    [Show full text]
  • Media, Power and Representation Clara Neary & Helen Ringrow
    Media, power and representation Item Type Book chapter Authors Neary, Clara; Ringrow, Helen Citation Neary, C., & Ringrow, H. (2018) Media, power and representation. In P. Seargeant, A. Hewings, & S. Pihlaja (Eds.), The Routledge Handbook of English Language Studies (pp. 294-309). London: Routledge. Publisher Routledge Rights Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 United States Download date 26/09/2021 08:09:56 Item License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/us/ Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10034/621529 1 Media, Power and Representation Clara Neary & Helen Ringrow ABSTRACT: As the influence of the media continues to grow – largely powered by ever- changing and increasingly rapid technological changes – continued investigation into how it uses language to create meaning is crucial. In addition, media institutions play a significant role in society as they simultaneously construct and maintain societal norms and values. Media English is a broad term referring to the ways in which language is used to construct reality on media platforms, ranging from the front cover of a print newspaper to magazine advertisements, radio programmes, text messages and tweets. This chapter summarises the key linguistic approaches to and debates within the study of Media English. It explains key contemporary media terminology; considers the dominance of English in Media English; and details research into media power and representation(s) in terms of social class, race, ethnicity, gender and so on. Both ‘traditional’ and ‘new’ media texts are considered while changes wrought by digitisation in general are discussed, particularly in terms of the rise of social media. The chapter concludes with a look at future directions in the study of Media English, highlighting new and developing research on the changing communicative choices and shifting contexts of media output.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction: Sociolinguistics and Computer-Mediated Communication
    Journal of Sociolinguistics 10/4, 2006: 419–438 Introduction: Sociolinguistics and computer-mediated communication Jannis Androutsopoulos University of Hannover, Germany This theme issue of Journal of Sociolinguistics comprises a number of empirical studies focusing on a range of ways in which people use language in computer-mediated communication (CMC). This introduction contextualizes the contributions to this issue by providing an outline of linguistically focused CMC studies. A critique of the research on the ‘language of CMC’ is given, and aspects of CMC research from a sociolinguistic viewpoint are presented: the move from the ‘language of CMC’ to socially situated computer- mediated discourse; its grounding in the notion of online community; and the application of sociolinguistic methodologies to its study. It is argued that CMC provides a new empirical arena for various research traditions in sociolinguistics; conversely, sociolinguistics can contribute to the interdisciplinary theorizing of CMC by demonstrating the role of language useandlinguisticvariabilityintheconstructionofinterpersonalrelationships and social identities on the Internet. KEYWORDS: Computer-mediated communication, sociolinguistics ‘WEBSLANG’ AND ‘NETSPEAK’: CHALLENGING NEW LANGUAGE MYTHS In early 2005 the Bild, Germany’s most popular tabloid newspaper, launched on its website a series of quizzes dedicated to language use on the Internet. Bearing headings such as ‘Do you understand Internet slang?’ and ‘Do you speak Chattish?’ these quizzes consist of a mixture
    [Show full text]
  • Advertisement of Applications to Change the Register of Political
    Advertisement REGISTER OF POLITICAL PARTIES The Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) has received applications to enter the logo of a registered political party under the provisions of the Commonwealth Electoral ACT 1918 (the Electoral Act). Seven seperate applications to register a logo against a party are displayed below in the order that they were received for registration. Application 1: Australian Christians Application 2: Australian Equality Party (Marriage) The image displayed here is the proposed The image displayed here is the proposed registered party logo for Australian Christians. registered party logo for Australian Equality Party (Marriage). Application 3: Australian Motoring Enthusiast Party Application 4: Liberal National Party of Queensland The image displayed here is the proposed The image displayed here is the proposed registered party logo for registered party logo for Australian Motoring Enthusiast Party. Liberal National Party of Queensland. Application 6: Online Direct Democracy Application 5: #Sustainable Australia (Empowering the People!) The image displayed here is the proposed The image displayed here is the proposed registered party logo for #Sustainable Australia. registered party logo for Online Direct Democracy (Empowering the People!) . Application 7: Renewable Energy Party The image displayed here is the proposed registered party logo for Renewable Energy . If you believe that the party logo shown against the party should not be registered because, under the Electoral Act: • the application does not relate to an eligible political party; or • the application is not in accordance with section 126 (including because subsection 126(2B) would be contravened); or • the application should be refused under section 129; or • the Electoral Commission should refuse to enter a logo of the party in the Register under section 129A.
    [Show full text]