Through the Looking-Glass As a Satire of Logocentrism

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Through the Looking-Glass As a Satire of Logocentrism Transcultural Studies, 6-7 (2010-2011), 91-101. JESSICA DURHAM JABBERWOCKY AND DIFFÉRANCE: THROUGH THE LOOKING-GLASS AS A SATIRE OF LOGOCENTRISM I argue that Lewis Carroll’s Through the Looking-Glass may be read as a satire of logocentric thought. In this essay I apply Jacques Derrida’s theorizing of différance and G. W. F. Hegel’s insights into the relational structure of meaning in a reading of excerpts from Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland (1865) and its sequel Through the Looking-Glass (1871), with a particular fo- cus on the nonsense poem “Jabberwocky.” Charles Lutwidge Dodson, who published under the pseudonym of Lewis Carroll, was a mathematician and logician who taught at Oxford for much of his life. Through the Looking-Glass was published in 1871 as a sequel to Alice in Wonderland. The sequel contains the nonsense poem “Jabberwocky,” which is one of the most famous nonsense-poems in English literature. I begin with a reading of an early scene from Alice in Wonderland which I argue exemplifies the relational structure of subjectivity, first theorised in Hegel’s Phenomenolo- gy of Spirit. I then apply a selection of insights from the work of Derrida and Hegel to the opening scenes of Through the Looking-Glass. I examine the way “Jabberwocky” supports Derrida’s theorizing of meaning as the product of difference. Finally, I conclude with a reading of the character Humpty Dumpty as a satire of logocentric literary criticism. I will begin with a definition of logocentrism. Derrida critiques what he calls the logocentrism in the systems and methods of knowledge production in the Western tradition, including philosophy and critical theory. Logocentrism relies on presence, a term for the various centers around which our knowledge systems have been built: an origin, center, truth, certainty, identity, essence, a stable point, a fixed point, a foundation.1 ‘Transcendental signified’ is Derri- da’s term for this central element that does not change when its system does, that is itself the reference that grounds these systems.2 Derrida states: The center also closes off the play which it opens up and makes possible. As center, it is the point at which the substitution of contents, elements, of terms is no longer possible. At the center, the permutation of the transfor- 1. Jonathan Culler, On Deconstruction: Theory and Criticism after Structuralism. 25th anni- versary ed. (Ithaca: Cornell Univ. Press, 2007), p. 92. 2. Jacques Derrida, “Structure, Sign and Play in the Discourse of the Human Sciences,” in Writing and Difference, Alan Bass (trans.) (London: Routledge, 1978), p. 280. 92 Transcultural Studies mation of elements (which may of course be structures enclosed within a structure) is forbidden.3 The other elements of a system can be substituted or altered, yet the center remains: this is the way in which logocentric systems of knowledge operate. Previous knowledge systems produced ontologies, taxonomies, and hierar- chies. Each system was intended to solve the problems emerging in the previ- ous systems by producing better, more inclusive taxonomies, and new sets of more useful hierarchies. Derrida comments: The entire history of the concept of structure, before the rupture of which we are speaking, must be thought of as a series of substitutions of center for center, as a linked chain of determinations of the center. Successively, and in a regulated fashion, the center receives different forms or names. The history of metaphysics, like the history of the West, is the history of these metaphors and metonymies. Its matrix... is the determination of Be- ing as presence in all senses of this word.4 The history of literary theory exemplifies this. The contemporary study of literature has its origins in the study (exegesis) of Biblical texts to determine their meaning. Prior to the twentieth century, the primary methods of textual analysis were by reference to the author’s biography or the historical condi- tions of the author’s society.5 With the rise of Russian formalist literary theory and New Criticism in the early twentieth century, meaning was thought to be best determined through a close-reading of the language of the text alone.6 In each of these systems we find emerging a desire to fix the meaning of a text, to quell its alarmingly infinite readings, to find the definitive reading with refer- ence to the stability of an authority, successively: God, the author’s life, or linguistic devices. Among the great insights of deconstruction, and poststructuralism, is the idea that discourse produces the effects it apparently describes. What this means is that the way we frame a question, an issue, or a body of knowledge – the exclusions we perform in order to constitute that body of knowledge – cre- ate the knowledge that is contained, the knowledge we have ostensibly “found.” Previous thought systems did not acknowledge this. Exclusions and acts of framing were performed, then denied. Exclusions were made blindly, without a corresponding self-critical function. Insides and outsides were creat- ed, both of whose objects these systems would comprise, and which were priv- ileged within their hierarchies. It was then argued that what remained inside had the prediscursive features of a logocentric center: truth, origin, reality, sta- 3. Ibid., p. 279. 4. Ibid. Emphasis in the original. 5. Julie Rivkin and Michael Ryan (eds), Literary Theory: An Anthology, 2nd ed. (Malden: Blackwell, 2004), p. 3. 6. Ibid., p. 6. .
Recommended publications
  • Alice's Adventures in Wonderland
    Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll With 42 Illustrations by John Tenniel All in the golden afternoon Full leisurely we glide ; For both our oars, with little skill, By little arms are plied, While little hands make vain pretence Our wanderings to guide. Ah, cruel Three ! In such an hour, Beneath such dreamy weather, To beg a tale of breath too weak To stir the tiniest feather ! Yet what can one poor voice avail Against three tongues together ? Imperious Prima flashes forth Her edict “ to begin it” : In gentler tones Secunda hopes “ There will be nonsense in it ! ” While Tertia interrupts the tale Not more than once a minute. Anon, to sudden silence won, In fancy they pursue The dream-child moving through a land Of wonders wild and new, In friendly chat with bird or beast— And half believe it true. And ever, as the story drained The wells of fancy dry, And faintly strove that weary one To put the subject by, “ The rest next time—” “ It is next time ! ” The happy voices cry. Thus grew the tale of Wonderland : Thus slowly, one by one, Its quaint events were hammered out— And now the tale is done, And home we steer, a merry crew, Beneath the setting sun. Alice ! A childish story take, And, with a gentle hand, Lay it where Childhood’s dreams are twined In Memory’s mystic band, Like pilgrim’s wither’d wreath of flowers Pluck’d in a far-off land. CONTENTS CHAPTER PAGE I Down the Rabbit-Hole 7 II The Pool of Tears 14 III A Caucus-Race and a Long Tale 22 IV The Rabbit Sends in a Little Bill 29 V Advice from a Caterpillar 38 VI Pig
    [Show full text]
  • THE LAND BEYOND the MAGIC MIRROR by E
    GREYHAWK CASTLE DUNGEON MODULE EX2 THE LAND BEYOND THE MAGIC MIRROR by E. Gary Gygax AN ADVENTURE IN A WONDROUS PLACE FOR CHARACTER LEVELS 9-12 No matter the skill and experience of your party, they will find themselves dazed and challenged when they pass into The Land Beyond the Magic Mirror! Distributed to the book trade in the United States by Random House, Inc. and in Canada by Random House of Canada Ltd. Distributed to the toy and hobby trade by regional distributors. Distributed in the United Kingdom by TSR Hobbies (UK) Ltd. AD&D and WORLD OF GREYHAWK are registered trademarks owned by TSR Hobbies, Inc. ©1983 TSR Hobbies, Inc. All Rights Reserved. TSR Hobbies, Inc. TSR Hobbies (UK) Ltd. POB 756 The Mill, Rathmore Road Lake Geneva, Cambridge CB14AD United Kingdom Printed in U.S.A. WI 53147 ISBN O 88038-025-X 9073 TABLE OF CONTENTS This module is the companion to Dungeonland and was originally part of the Greyhawk Castle dungeon complex. lt is designed so that it can be added to Dungeonland, used alone, or made part of virtually any campaign. It has an “EX” DUNGEON MASTERS PREFACE ...................... 2 designation to indicate that it is an extension of a regular THE LAND BEYOND THE MAGIC MIRROR ............. 4 dungeon level—in the case of this module, a far-removed .................... extension where all adventuring takes place on another plane The Magic Mirror House First Floor 4 of existence that is quite unusual, even for a typical AD&D™ The Cellar ......................................... 6 Second Floor ...................................... 7 universe. This particular scenario has been a consistent .........................................
    [Show full text]
  • Saki / H.H. Munro 1870-1916 Bios
    Saki / H.H. Munro 1870-1916 Bios http://www.litgothic.com/Authors/saki.html Up to now, little has been known about Hector Hugh Munro except that he used the pen name “Saki”; that he wrote a number of witty short stories, two novels, several plays, and a history of Russia; and that he was killed in World War I. His friend Rothay Reynolds published “A Memoir of H. H. Munro” in Saki’s The Toys of Peace (1919), and Munro’s sister Ethel furnished a brief “Biography of Saki” for a posthumous collection of his work entitled The Square Egg and Other Sketches (1924). A. J. Langguth’s Saki is the first full-length biography of the man who, during his brief writing career, published a succession of bright, satirical, and sometimes perfectly crafted short stories that have entertained and amused readers in many countries for well over a half-century. Hector Munro was the third child of Charles Augustus Munro, a British police officer in Burma, and his wife Mary Frances. The children were all born in Burma. Pregnant with her fourth child, Mrs. Munro was brought with the children to live with her husband’s family in England until the child arrived. Frightened by the charge of a runaway cow on a country lane, Mrs. Munro died after a miscarriage. Since the widowed father had to return to Burma, the children — Charles, Ethel, and Hector — were left with their Munro grandmother and her two dominating and mutually antagonistic spinster daughters, Charlotte (“Aunt Tom”) and Augusta. This situation would years later provide incidents, characters, and themes for a number of Hector Munro’s short stories as well as this epitaph for Augusta by Ethel: “A woman of ungovernable temper, of fierce likes and dislikes, imperious, a moral coward, possessing no brains worth speaking of, and a primitive disposition.
    [Show full text]
  • In Commemoration of Hector Munro, 'Saki' Transcript
    The grinning shadow that sat at the feast: In commemoration of Hector Munro, 'Saki' Transcript Date: Tuesday, 14 November 2006 - 12:00AM The Grinning Shadow that sat at the Feast: an appreciation of the life and work of Hector Munro 'Saki' Professor Tim Connell Hector Munro was a man of many parts, and although he died relatively young, he lived through a time of considerable change, had a number of quite separate careers and a very broad range of interests. He was also a competent linguist who spoke Russian, German and French. Today is the 90th anniversary of his death in action on the Somme, and I would like to review his importance not only as a writer but also as a figure in his own time. Early years to c.1902 Like so many Victorians, he was born into a family with a long record of colonial service, and it is quite confusing to see how many Hector Munros there are with a military or colonial background. Our Hector’s most famous ancestor is commemorated in a well-known piece at the Victoria and Albert Museum. Tippoo's Tiger shows a man being eaten by a mechanical tiger and the machine emits both roaring and groaning sounds. 1 Hector's grandfather was an Admiral, and his father was in the Burma Police. The family was hit by tragedy when Hector's mother was killed in a bizarre accident involving a runaway cow. It is curious that strange events involving animals should form such a common feature of Hector's writing 2 but this may also derive from his upbringing in the Devonshire countryside and a home that was dominated by the two strangest creatures of all - Aunt Augusta and Aunt Tom.
    [Show full text]
  • AUDIOBOOKS Alice in Wonderland Around the World in 80 Days at the Back of the North Wind Birthday of the Enfanter Blue Cup Cruis
    AUDIOBOOKS Alice In Wonderland Around the World in 80 days At the Back of the North Wind Birthday of the Enfanter Blue Cup Cruise of the Dazzler Devoted Friend Dragon Farm Dragons - Dreadful Dragon of Hay Hill Dragons - Kind Little Edmund Dragons - Reluctant Dragon Dragons - Snap-Dragons Dragons - The Book of Beasts Dragons - The Deliverers of Their Country Dragons - The Dragon Tamers Dragons - The Fiery Dragon Dragons - The Ice Dragon Dragons - The Isle of the Nine Whirlpools Dragons - The Last of The Dragons Dragons - Two Dragons Dragons - Uncle James Eric Prince of Lorlonia Ernest Fluffy Rabbit Faerie Queene Fifty Stories from UNCLE REMUS Fisherman and his Soul Fisherman and The Goldfish Five Children and It Gentle Alice Brown Ghost of Dorothy Dingley Goblin Market Godmother's Garden Gullivers Travels 1 - A Voyage to Lilliput Gullivers Travels 2 - A Voyage to Brobdingnag Gullivers Travels 3 A Voyage to Laputa, Balnibarbi, Luggnagg, Glubbdubdrib, and Japan Gullivers Travels 4 A Voyage to the Country of the Houynhnms Hammond's Hard Lines Happy Prince Her Majesty's Servants Horror of the Heights How I Killed a Bear Huckleberry Finn Hunting of The Snark King of The Golden River Knock Three Times Lair of The White Worm Little Boy Lost Little Round House Loaded Dog Lukundoo Lull Magic Lamplighter Malchish Kibalchish Malcolm Sage Detective Man and Snake Martin Rattler Moon Metal Moonraker Mowgli Mr Papingay's Flying Shop Mr Papingay's Ship New Sun Nightingale and Rose Nutcracker OZ 01 - Wizard of Oz OZ 02 - The Land of Oz OZ 03 - Ozma of Oz
    [Show full text]
  • The Best of Lewis Carroll (Alice in Wonderland, Through the Looking Glass, the Hunting of the Snark, a Tangled Tale, Phantasmagoria, Nonsense from Letters) Online
    yaTOs (Download pdf) The Best of Lewis Carroll (Alice in Wonderland, Through the Looking Glass, The Hunting of the Snark, A Tangled Tale, Phantasmagoria, Nonsense from Letters) Online [yaTOs.ebook] The Best of Lewis Carroll (Alice in Wonderland, Through the Looking Glass, The Hunting of the Snark, A Tangled Tale, Phantasmagoria, Nonsense from Letters) Pdf Free Lewis Carroll ePub | *DOC | audiobook | ebooks | Download PDF Download Now Free Download Here Download eBook #1419651 in Books 2011-11-07Original language:EnglishPDF # 1 1.70 x 6.50 x 9.30l, 1.70 #File Name: 0890097003440 pages | File size: 46.Mb Lewis Carroll : The Best of Lewis Carroll (Alice in Wonderland, Through the Looking Glass, The Hunting of the Snark, A Tangled Tale, Phantasmagoria, Nonsense from Letters) before purchasing it in order to gage whether or not it would be worth my time, and all praised The Best of Lewis Carroll (Alice in Wonderland, Through the Looking Glass, The Hunting of the Snark, A Tangled Tale, Phantasmagoria, Nonsense from Letters): 1 of 1 people found the following review helpful. Wonderful books for a wonderful priceBy llamapyrLewis Carroll must've been the greatest children's book author of his time. I really admire his writing style and the creativity of his books, having grown up on them since I was 6. I've got a bunch of his novels in hardcover and paperback sitting on my shelves, so it seemed only right to add some digital versions to my library :)Anyway, I came here looking for Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass and found this set, and for a mere 99 cents it seemed worth a look.
    [Show full text]
  • ARTICLE: Jan Susina: Playing Around in Lewis Carroll's Alice Books
    Playing Around in Lewis Carroll’s Alice Books • Jan Susina Mathematician Charles Dodgson’s love of play and his need for rules came together in his use of popular games as part of the structure of the two famous children’s books, Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking-Glass, he wrote under the pseudonym Lewis Carroll. The author of this article looks at the interplay between the playing of such games as croquet and cards and the characters and events of the novels and argues that, when reading Carroll (who took a playful approach even in his academic texts), it is helpful to understand games and game play. Charles Dodgson, more widely known by his pseudonym Lewis Carroll, is perhaps one of the more playful authors of children’s literature. In his career, as a children’s author and as an academic logician and mathematician, and in his personal life, Carroll was obsessed with games and with various forms of play. While some readers are surprised by the seemingly split personality of Charles Dodgson, the serious mathematician, and Lewis Carroll, the imaginative author of children’s books, it was his love of play and games and his need to establish rules and guidelines that effectively govern play that unite these two seemingly disparate facets of Carroll’s personality. Carroll’s two best-known children’s books—Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland (1865) and Through the Looking- Glass and What Alice Found There (1871)—use popular games as part of their structure. In Victoria through the Looking-Glass, Florence Becker Lennon has gone so far as to suggest about Carroll that “his life was a game, even his logic, his mathematics, and his singular ordering of his household and other affairs.
    [Show full text]
  • Derrida's Objection to the Metaphysical Tradition
    CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk Provided by Scholarship@Claremont Claremont Colleges Scholarship @ Claremont CMC Senior Theses CMC Student Scholarship 2015 Derrida's Objection To The etM aphysical Tradition Christopher A. Wheat Claremont McKenna College Recommended Citation Wheat, Christopher A., "Derrida's Objection To The eM taphysical Tradition" (2015). CMC Senior Theses. Paper 1188. http://scholarship.claremont.edu/cmc_theses/1188 This Open Access Senior Thesis is brought to you by Scholarship@Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion in this collection by an authorized administrator. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Claremont McKenna College Derrida’s Objection to the Metaphysical Tradition Submitted to Prof. James Kreines And Dean Nicholas Warner By Christopher Wheat For Senior Thesis Spring 2015 4/27/15 Table of Contents: Acknowledgements……………………………………………………………………2 Abstract………………………………………………………………………………..3 Introduction……………………………………………………………………………4 The Metaphysical Tradition…………………………………………………………...6 Derrida’s Objection…………………………………………………………………..16 Metaphysics Given the Abandonment of the Metaphysical Tradition………………26 Conclusion………………………………………………….………………………..31 Bibliography…………………………………………………………..……………..33 1 Acknowledgements: I would like to thank Professor Kreines for his generous assistance in my thesis and initial research of deconstruction, and for helping to nurture my interest in philosophy over the course of my college career. I would also like to thank Professor Rajczi, Professor Schroeder, Professor Kind, Professor Kincaid, and Professor Gaitskill. In addition to my professors, my friends and family have supported and influenced me in ways I could never begin to repay them for, and hope that this thesis is only a small reflection of what they have taught me. 2 Abstract Derrida’s deconstruction of the philosophic tradition shows us not only the importance of pursuit of knowledge, but also the importance of questioning the assumptions on which such a pursuit is based.
    [Show full text]
  • Annihilating Nihilistic Nonsense Tim Burton Guts Lewis Carroll’S Jabberwocky
    Annihilating Nihilistic Nonsense Tim Burton Guts Lewis Carroll’s Jabberwocky Alice in Wonderland seems to beg for a morbid interpretation. Whether it's Marilyn Manson's "Eat Me, Drink Me," the video game "American McGee's Alice," or Svankmajer's "Alice" and "Jabberwocky," artists love bringing out the darker elements of Alice’s adventures as she wanders among creepy creatures. The 2010 Tim Burton film is the latest twisted adaptation, featuring an older Alice that slays the Jabberwocky. However, unlike the other adaptations, Burton’s adaptation draws most of its grim outlook by gutting Alice in Wonderland of its fundamental core - its nonsense. Alice in Wonderland uses nonsense to liberate, offering frightening amounts of freedom through its playful use of nonsense. However, Burton turns this whimsy into menacing machinations - he pretends to use nonsense for its original liberating purpose but actually uses it for adult plots and preset paths. Burton takes the destructive power of Alice’s insistence for order and amplifies it dramatically, completely removing its original subversive release from societal constraints. Under the façade of paying tribute to Carroll’s whimsical nonsense verse, Burton directly removes nonsense’s anarchic freedom and replaces it with a destructive commitment to sense. This brutal change to both plot and structure turns Alice into a mindless juggernaut, slaying not only the Jabberwock, but also the realm of nonsense, non-linear narrative and real world empires. At first, nonsense in Lewis Carroll’s books seems to just a light-hearted play with language. Even before we come into Wonderland, the idea of nonsense as just a simple child’s diversion is given by the epigraph.
    [Show full text]
  • Education As the Possibility of Justice: Jacques Derrida
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 422 198 SO 028 563 AUTHOR Biesta, Gert J. J. TITLE Education as the Possibility of Justice: Jacques Derrida. PUB DATE 1997-03-00 NOTE 35p.; Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association (Chicago, IL, March 24-28, 1997). PUB TYPE Reports - Descriptive (141) Speeches/Meeting Papers (150) EDRS PRICE MF01/PCO2 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS *Educational Philosophy; *Educational Theories; Epistemology; Hermeneutics; Higher Education; *Justice; *Philosophy IDENTIFIERS *Derrida (Jacques); Poststructuralism ABSTRACT This paper is an analysis of the ongoing work of philosopher Jacques Derrida and the immense body of work associated with him. Derrida's copious work is difficult to categorize since Derrida challenges the very concept that meaning can be grasped in its original moment or that meaning can be represented in the form of some proper, self-identical concept. Derrida's "deconstruction" requires reading, writing, and translating Derrida, an impossibility the author maintains cannot be done because translation involves transformation and the originality of the original only comes into view after it has been translated. The sections of the paper include: (1) "Preface: Reading Derrida, Writing after Derrida"; (2) "Curriculum Vitae"; (3) "(No) Philosophy"; (4) "The Myth of the Origin"; (5) "The Presence of the Voice"; (6) "The Ubiquity of Writing"; (7) "Difference and 'Differance'"; (8) "Deconstruction and the Other"; (9) "Education"; (10) "Education beyond Representation: Gregory Ulmer's 'Post(e)-pedagogy"; and (11) "Afterword: Education as the Possibility of Justice." (EH) ******************************************************************************** * Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made * * from the original document. * ******************************************************************************** Education as the Possibility of Justice: Jacques Derrida.
    [Show full text]
  • The Musical Misadventures of a Girl Named Alice Book by JAMES DEVITA Music and Lyrics by BILL FRANCOEUR Based on the Novel Through the Looking Glass by LEWIS CARROLL
    The Musical Misadventures of a Girl Named Alice based on the novel Through the Looking Glass by Lewis Carroll Book by JAMES DEVITA Music and Lyrics by BILL FRANCOEUR © Copyright 2002, JAMES DeVITA PERFORMANCE LICENSE The amateur acting rights to this play are controlled exclusively by PIONEER DRAMA SERVICE, INC., P.O. Box 4267, Englewood, Colorado 80155, without whose permission no performance, reading or presentation of any kind may be given. On all programs and advertising this notice must appear: “Produced by special arrangement with Pioneer Drama Service, Inc., Englewood, Colorado.” COPYING OR REPRODUCING ALL OR ANY PART OF THIS BOOK IN ANY MANNER IS STRICTLY FORBIDDEN BY LAW. All other rights in this play, including those of professional production, radio broadcasting and motion picture rights, are controlled by Pioneer Drama Service, Inc., to whom all inquiries should be addressed. WONDERLAN D! The Musical Misadventures of a Girl Named Alice Book by JAMES DEVITA Music and Lyrics by BILL FRANCOEUR based on the novel Through the Looking Glass by LEWIS CARROLL CAST OF CHARACTERS ALICE .............................................. the same one that chased the rabbit down the hole TROUBADOUR* .............................. quite the singer MOTHER’S VOICE .......................... offstage RED KING ....................................... soporific monarch WHITE KING .................................... defender of the crown RED QUEEN .................................... vicious, nasty temper WHITE QUEEN ...............................
    [Show full text]
  • Through the Looking-Glass: Translating Nonsense
    Through the Looking-Glass: Translating Nonsense In 1871, Lewis Carroll published Through the Looking- Glass, and What Alice Found There, a sequel to his hugely popular Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. In this sequel, Alice sees a world through her looking-glass which looks almost the same as her own world, but not quite. I'll tell you all my ideas about Looking-glass House. First, there's the room you can see through the glass – that's just the same as our drawing-room, only the things go the other way. [...] the books are something like our books, only the words go the wrong way[...] Alice goes through the mirror into the alternative world, which, not unlike Wonderland, is full of weird and wonderful characters. She finds a book there, which is “all in some language I don't know”. Below are the first few lines of the book – can you read it? Just the same, only things go the other way... ‘Some language I don’t know’, ‘the words go the wrong way’. Alice might almost be talking about the practice of translation, which makes a text accessible to a reader unfamiliar with the original language it was written in. And translation, too, can often feel like it is almost the same as the original, and yet somehow also different. We might say that translation is like Alice’s looking-glass: it reflects the original but in distorted and imaginative ways. Can you think of any other similes for translation? Translation is like ....................................................................................................................... because
    [Show full text]