Print Culture and the Globalization of the Occult in the Long Nineteenth Century
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Secrecy Redefined: Print Culture and the Globalization of the Occult in the Long Nineteenth Century Submitted by Lori Lee Oates to the University of Exeter as a thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History In March 2016 This thesis is available for Library use on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. I certify that all material in this thesis which is not my own work has been identified and that no material has previously been submitted and approved for the award of a degree by this or any other University. Signature: ………………………………………………………….. 2 Abstract This thesis seeks to examine the relationship between occult religion and the global circulation of texts. For some time now, scholars have rejected the secularism thesis or the idea that there has been a decline of religion in the post-Enlightenment period. Today, we largely accept that religion did not actually decline or disappear but, rather, it has changed form. Religion shifted from traditional religious institutions to become an aspect of aesthetic culture, available through the commercial economy. My work explores how the relationship between the book and commercial religion emerged and evolved during the long nineteenth century. Occultism has long been viewed as an aspect of the rise of secular society following the Enlightenment. This thesis proposes a new lens through which we can view the evolution of occultism, seeing it as a response to growth in global networks of empire and the commercialization of religion through the printed word. It explores how the nature of the transmission of occultism shifted, particularly during the final decades of the nineteenth century. Antoine Faivre’s foundational text Access to Western Esotericism (1994) put forward the concept of the transmission of occultism as something that occurs between a disciple and an initiate. My thesis, however, argues that the widening of print activity and literacy expanded the opportunities for initiation into magic to occur more broadly, changing the nature of who could become an initiate. As such, secrecy around magic became redefined. It shifted from being a pursuit of the literate elite to something that was widely available. This analysis is delivered in four chapters. The introduction examines the relationship between literature and nineteenth-century occultism. It also discusses the influence of globalization. Chapter one discusses the occult in post-revolutionary France and the influence of Egyptian orientalism on French occultism. Chapter two addresses Victorian occultism and discusses the context of a growing Victorian literary industry. Chapter three addresses the Theosophical Society as an agent of globalized and commercialized religion. It also addresses the importance of British imperialism in India. Finally, chapter four discusses the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn and the resurgence of Egyptian orientalism and elitism in British occultism. 3 Acknowledgements This project began in 2009 when I entered the M.Phil. (Humanities) program at Memorial University of Newfoundland. I had developed a fascination with the texts of what was being loosely called New Age religion. Many of the texts I was reading were New York Times best sellers including Return to Love, The Power of Now, and Eat Pray Love. A lot of these texts had gained popularity through Oprah Winfrey’s book club. I was curious about this fascination with religion that was manifesting itself in the private sector and on television. Discovering why this shift in religion had taken place became the work of my M.Phil. Degree. However, I felt far from done with the topic. I am extremely grateful that in 2012 the University of Exeter offered me an international doctoral studentship to pursue this research further. This enabled me to go back to the nineteenth-century roots of contemporary religion and start a broader examination of the trajectory of religion. As such, my debts are many and they exist on both sides of the Atlantic Ocean. Beyond the generous funding provided at the University of Exeter, thanks are also extended to the Society for the Study of French History (SSFH) that awarded me a research grant to visit the Bibliothèque National de France. I also received conference bursaries from the North American Victorian Studies Association (NAVSA) and SSFH. I was fortunate to receive a scholarship to visit the Gladstone Library in 2014. I gratefully acknowledge the support of my supervision team, Professor Regenia Gagnier, Richard Noakes, Joseph Crawford, Catherine Rider, and Laura Sangha. There are not enough words to express how much I have learned from Regenia about globalization, the future of the humanities, and overall academic project management. It was Richard who had the vision and foresight to see that not only could a global and imperial history be done of the nineteenth-century occult but indeed one needed to be done. Joe provided much needed insight on European and literary history. Catherine and Laura provided excellent academic advice as mentors. It was Sean McGrath at Memorial University of Newfoundland who wisely introduced me to the literature of Western Esotericism and essentially put me on this path. I was also very fortunate to draw on the expertise of Seamus O’Neill, Jennifer Dyer, Jay Foster, Professor Kim Parker, Alison Butler, and Michelle Rebidoux during my time at Memorial. Thanks are also extended to my many colleagues at the Exeter Centre for Global and Imperial History and the Centre for Victorian Studies. My time at Exeter has been spent largely marveling at the quality of the other scholars in the room. Finally, thank you to my internal and external examiners, Paul Young and Professor Rohan McWilliam respectively. I have attended many conferences during the time that I worked on this project. Thanks are extended for the feedback I received from the American Academy of Religion (regional meeting), Association for the Study of Esotericism, European Society for the Study of Western Esotericism (ESSWE), SSFH, NAVSA, Canadian Historical Association, Social History Society, Nineteenth-Century Postgraduate Seminar, and the Sophia Centre Conference on Celestial Magic. In particular, I wish to thank the committee members of SSFH and the board members of ESSWE. I would like to thank Jean-Pierre Brach at the Sorbonne for his support during my research trips to Paris. Also, I would like to thank Henrick Bogden at the University of Gothenburg for his advice at the ESSWE thesis workshop in 2014. I would be remiss if I did not mention Ex Historia and the participants in the Postgraduate Research Conferences at the University of Exeter. Thanks to my proofreader and long 4 time colleague Geoff Meeker. Thanks are extended to the staff at the Rare Books reading room of the British Library, history room at the Bibliothèque National de France, and the Gladstone Library. Thanks to the archivists at Knebworth House, Hertfordshire Archives, and Freemason’s Library in London. The editors at the International Association for the Preservation of Spiritualist and Occult Periodicals were critical in providing me with online access to various occult periodicals. My final debt is also my oldest. That is to my family in Newfoundland, Canada. Two generations ago the Oates and O’Leary clans were families of fish harvesters on the southern shore of Newfoundland, which was a very honourable profession in that time and place. However, to them it would have seemed unlikely that anyone from my generation would end up in a fully funded PhD. program at a Russell Group university in Britain. I have no doubt that it was my parents’ belief in hard work and education that has brought me here. We have always been a family of avid readers and I was raised to believe books and reading are important. It is hardly a surprise then that I would become a historian of circulation of texts. Finally, it is my nephew Parker Simon that represents the future of our family. So it is to him that I dedicate this work. 5 Table of Contents Abstract .............................................................................................................. 2 Acknowledgements ........................................................................................... 3 Introduction ....................................................................................................... 7 Imperialism and Global Connectivity ............................................................ 16 The Nineteenth-Century Occult and Print ..................................................... 38 Re-Conceptualizing the Globalization of the Occult .................................... 43 Definitions ........................................................................................................ 48 Occultism ......................................................................................................... 48 Esotericism ...................................................................................................... 50 Religion ............................................................................................................ 54 New Age ........................................................................................................... 56 New Capitalism ................................................................................................ 58 Methodology ...................................................................................................