What Can History Tell Us About the Future? Using Recent Observations and Paleoclimate Proxies to Constrain Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

What Can History Tell Us About the Future? Using Recent Observations and Paleoclimate Proxies to Constrain Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity

Montclair State University Montclair State University Digital Commons Sustainability Seminar Series Sustainability Seminar Series, 2021 Mar 1st, 3:45 PM - 3:00 PM What can history tell us about the future? Using recent observations and paleoclimate proxies to constrain equilibrium climate sensitivity Kate Marvel Columbia University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.montclair.edu/sustainability-seminar Part of the Sustainability Commons Marvel, Kate, "What can history tell us about the future? Using recent observations and paleoclimate proxies to constrain equilibrium climate sensitivity" (2021). Sustainability Seminar Series. 3. https://digitalcommons.montclair.edu/sustainability-seminar/2021/spring2021/3 This Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by the Conferences, Symposia and Events at Montclair State University Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Sustainability Seminar Series by an authorized administrator of Montclair State University Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Doctoral Program in Environmental Science & Management and MSU Sustainability Seminar Series Present: What can history tell us about the future? Using recent observaons and paleoclimate proxies to constrain equilibrium climate sensi/vity Kate Marvel, Columbia University WHEN: March 1, 3:45 pm WHERE: Online via Zoom Dr. Marvel uses climate models, observaons, paleoclimate reconstruc/ons, and basic theory to study climate change. Her work has iden/fied human influences on present-day cloud cover, rainfall paerns, and drought risk. She is also interested in future climate changes, par/cularly climate feedback processes and the planet's sensi/vity to increased carbon dioxide. Dr. Marvel teaches in Columbia's MA in Climate & Society Program and writes the "Hot Planet" column for Scien&fic American. Named one of "15 Women Who Will Save the World" by Time Magazine, she has been profiled by the New York Times and Rolling Stone, and her 2017 TED talk has been viewed over one million /mes. Before becoming a climate scien/st, she received a PhD in theore/cal par/cle physics from Cambridge University, where she was a Gates scholar. Despite improvements in compu/ng power, climate modeling, and basic theore/cal understanding, the Earth’s physical response to a doubling of atmospheric carbon dioxide remains uncertain. Can observaons be useful in constraining this theore/cal quan/ty? We have high-quality informaon on recent trends: greenhouse gas concentraons have increased since the industrial revolu/on, and the planet has warmed in response. But I will argue that this recent history provides only weak constraints on the eventual climate sensi/vity: observaons of a transient climate are poor predictors of a future equilibrium state. Reconstruc/ons of past equilibria both colder (the Last Glacial Maximum) and warmer (the mid-Pliocene) than the present provide stronger constraints, sugges/ng that the extremely high climate sensi/vi/es of some state-of-the-art climate models are unrealis/c. I’ll present a framework for facilitang apples-to-apples comparisons of past and future climate and discuss how to understand, reduce, and communicate the uncertain/es associated with future climate response. for more informaon, please contact Dr. Mark Chopping at [email protected] .

Copy Link

Recommended publications

Observed and Projected Changes to the Precipitation Annual Cycle
1JULY 2017 M A R V E L E T A L . 4983 Observed and Projected Changes to the Precipitation Annual Cycle KATE MARVEL Columbia University, and NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies, New York, New York MICHELA BIASUTTI Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia University, Palisades, New York CÉLINE BONFILS AND KARL E. TAYLOR Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, California YOCHANAN KUSHNIR Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia University, Palisades, New York BENJAMIN I. COOK NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies, New York, New York (Manuscript received 2 August 2016, in ﬁnal form 8 February 2017) ABSTRACT Anthropogenic climate change is predicted to cause spatial and temporal shifts in precipitation patterns. These may be apparent in changes to the annual cycle of zonal mean precipitation P. Trends in the amplitude and phase of the P annual cycle in two long-term, global satellite datasets are broadly similar. Model-derived ﬁngerprints of externally forced changes to the amplitude and phase of the P seasonal cycle, combined with these observations, enable a formal detection and attribution analysis. Observed amplitude changes are in- consistent with model estimates of internal variability but not attributable to the model-predicted response to external forcing. This mismatch between observed and predicted amplitude changes is consistent with the sustained La Niña–like conditions that characterize the recent slowdown in the rise of the global mean temperature. However, observed changes to the annual cycle phase do not seem to be driven by this recent hiatus. These changes are consistent with model estimates of forced changes, are inconsistent (in one ob- servational dataset) with estimates of internal variability, and may suggest the emergence of an externally forced signal.
[Show full text]
FYE Int 100120A.Indd
FirstYear & Common Reading CATALOG NEW & RECOMMENDED BOOKS Dear Common Reading Director: The Common Reads team at Penguin Random House is excited to present our latest book recommendations for your common reading program. In this catalog you will discover new titles such as: Isabel Wilkerson’s Caste, a masterful exploration of how America has been shaped by a hidden caste system, a rigid hierarchy of human rankings; Handprints on Hubble, Kathrn Sullivan’s account of being the ﬁ rst American woman to walk in space, as part of the team that launched, rescued, repaired, and maintained the Hubble Space Telescope; Know My Name, Chanel Miller’s stor of trauma and transcendence which will forever transform the way we think about seual assault; Ishmael Beah’s powerful new novel Little Family about young people living at the margins of society; and Brittany Barnett’s riveting memoir A Knock at Midnight, a coming-of-age stor by a young laer and a powerful evocation of what it takes to bring hope and justice to a legal system built to resist them both. In addition to this catalog, our recently refreshed and updated .commonreads.com website features titles from across Penguin Random House’s publishers as well as great blog content, including links to author videos, and the fourth iteration of our annual “Wat Students Will Be Reading: Campus Common Reading Roundup,” a valuable resource and archive for common reading programs across the countr. And be sure to check out our online resource for Higher Education: .prheducation.com. Featuring Penguin Random House’s most frequently-adopted titles across more than 1,700 college courses, the site allows professors to easily identif books and resources appropriate for a wide range of courses.
[Show full text]
Columbia University Task Force on Climate: Report
COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY TASK FORCE ON CLIMATE: REPORT Delivered to President Bollinger December 1, 2019 UNIVERSITY TASK FORCE ON CLIMATE FALL 2019 Contents Preface—University Task Force Process of Engagement ....................................................................................................................... 3 Executive Summary: Principles of a Climate School .............................................................................................................................. 4 Introduction: The Climate Challenge ..................................................................................................................................................... 6 The Columbia University Response ....................................................................................................................................................... 7 Columbia’s Strengths ........................................................................................................................................................................ 7 Columbia’s Limitations ...................................................................................................................................................................... 8 Why a School? ................................................................................................................................................................................... 9 A Columbia Climate School .................................................................................................................................................................
[Show full text]
Discerning Humanity's Imprint on Rainfall Patterns
Research Highlights Photograph by George A. Kitrinos Discerning Humanity’s Imprint on Rainfall Patterns T’S the perfect storm. At a time when global demand for water is they could magnify existing problems with water scarcity, I rising rapidly due to population growth, urbanization, industrial food shortage, and possibly even political instabilities, thereby activities, and expanded use of crop irrigation systems, climate transforming an environmental concern into a global security change may be altering the timing, location, and amount of rain issue. Are these changes indicative of global warming, as predicted and snow that fall on large swaths of the planet. Computational by models? Are the pattern shifts caused by naturally occurring models indicate that increases in global surface temperatures fluctuations or human-induced (anthropogenic) forces, such as will redistribute rainfall in two ways. First, warmer air, which greenhouse-gas emissions and ozone depletion? Determining holds more water vapor, will intensify existing precipitation and the answers to these questions may help policy makers develop drought conditions. That is, more rain will fall in wet areas, strategies for mitigating or adapting to the changes. However, and evaporation will increase in drier areas. Second, shifts in extracting this information from global precipitation data can atmospheric circulation patterns will push storm paths and be challenging. subtropical dry zones toward the poles. The models that scientists use for climate predictions are Satellite records for the past few decades show that rainfall generally poor at simulating the exact location and magnitude of patterns worldwide are changing. If the observed trends continue, Earth’s major precipitation features.
[Show full text]
Date: 206 Part III: the Global Climate Challenge and U.S
by Date: 206 Part III: The Global Climate Challenge and U.S. Policy Response Climate Convexity: The Inequality of a Warming World AUTHOR Trevor Houser* ABSTRACT In the past two centuries, global fossil fuel combustion has increased carbon dioxide concentration to unprecedented levels, which has increased Earth’s temperatures and the frequency of extreme climate events. If left unaddressed, the climate crisis will not only become more costly to global health and to the global economy, but also will exacerbate inequality within the U.S. and around the world. This chapter describes recent changes in the climate and how scientists predict those changes will evolve in the years ahead. I then describe recent advances in econometric research that, when paired with high-resolution climate models, help us understand the impact of those changes in the climate on society. Finally, I conclude with recommendations for how U.S. policymakers can use this research to address the unequal threat of climate change, both domestically and internationally, and build a more just and sustainable future. * Partner, Rhodium Group; Co-Director, Climate Impact Lab Disclaimer: The views expressed in this chapter are the author’s alone. Acknowledgement: The author would like to thank Rhodium Group’s Michael Delgado, Hannah Hess, Brewster Malevich, Diana Gergel, and Matt Goldklang for their research support and helpful review comments, as well as the team at the Climate Impact Lab for their incredible work advancing climate econometrics over the past seven years. Climate Convexity: The Inequality of a Warming World 207 Introduction Recent research advances at the intersection of climate science and economics make it clear that the cost of inaction on climate change in the United States is not only greater than the cost of action, but that inaction exacerbates income inequality within the United States and around the world.
[Show full text]
Climate Change, Catastrophe, Regulation and the Social Cost Of
CLIMATE CHANGE, CATASTROPHE, REGULATION AND THE SOCIAL COST OF CARBON by Julian Morris March 2018 Reason Foundation’s mission is to advance a free society by developing, applying and promoting libertarian principles, including individual liberty, free markets and the rule of law. We use journalism and public policy research to influence the frameworks and actions of policymakers, journalists and opinion leaders. Reason Foundation’s nonpartisan public policy research promotes choice, competition and a dynamic market economy as the foundation for human dignity and progress. Reason produces rigorous, peer- reviewed research and directly engages the policy process, seeking strategies that emphasize cooperation, flexibility, local knowledge and results. Through practical and innovative approaches to complex problems, Reason seeks to change the way people think about issues, and promote policies that allow and encourage individuals and voluntary institutions to flourish. Reason Foundation is a tax-exempt research and education organization as defined under IRS code 501(c)(3). Reason Foundation is supported by voluntary contributions from individuals, foundations and corporations. The views are those of the author, not necessarily those of Reason Foundation or its trustees. CLIMATE CHANGE, CATASTROPHE, REGULATION AND THE SOCIAL COST OF CARBON i EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Federal agencies are required to calculate the costs and benefits of new regulations that have significant economic effects. Since a court ruling in 2008, agencies have included a measure of the cost of greenhouse gas emissions when evaluating regulations that affect such emissions. This measure is known as the “social cost of carbon” (SCC). Initially, different agencies applied different SCCs. To address this problem, the Office of Management and Budget and Council of Economic Advisors organized an Interagency Working Group (IWG) to develop a range of estimates of the SCC for use by all agencies.
[Show full text]
Projects, Publications, Meetings & Donors to the Academy 2016–2017
Projects, Publications, Meetings & Donors to the Academy 2016–2017 With Appreciation . Academy projects, publications, and meetings are supported by gifts and grants from Members, friends, foundations, corporations, Affiliates, and other funding agencies. The Academy expresses its deep appreciation for this support and to the many Members who contribute to its work. Published by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, September 2016 Contents From the President 3 Projects, Publications & Meetings Science, Engineering, and Technology Overview 4 New Models for U.S. Science & Technology Policy 4 The Public Face of Science 7 Human Performance Enhancement 11 The Alternative Energy Future 13 Global Security and International Affairs Overview 16 New Dilemmas in Ethics, Technology, and War 17 The Global Nuclear Future 21 Civil Wars, Violence, and International Responses 27 Understanding the New Nuclear Age 30 The Humanities, Arts, and Education Overview 33 Commission on the Future of Undergraduate Education 33 Commission on Language Learning 38 The Lincoln Project: Excellence and Access in Public Higher Education 41 Commission on the Humanities and Social Sciences 47 The Humanities Indicators 48 Exploratory Initiatives 51 Regional Program Committees 56 Discussion Groups 59 Meetings and Events 61 Affiliates of the American Academy 72 Donors to the Academy 75 From the President dvancing knowledge and learning in service to the nation has been the mission A of the Academy since its founding in 1780. Through the study of social and scien- tific
[Show full text]
Projects, Publications, Meetings and Donors to the Academy
Projects, Publications, Meetings and Donors to the Academy SCIENCE, ENGINEERING, GLOBAL SECURITY AND AND TECHNOLOGY INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS 20 AMERICAN INSTITUTIONS, SOCIETY, AND THE PUBLIC GOOD EDUCATION AND THE THE HUMANITIES, 17 DEVELOPMENT OF KNOWLEDGE ARTS, AND CULTURE With Appreciation . Academy projects, publications, and meetings are supported by gifts and grants from Members, friends, foundations, corporations, Affiliates, and other funding agencies. The Academy expresses its deep appreciation for this support and to the many Members who contribute to its work. Published by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, September 2017 CONTENTS From the President 3 Projects, Publications & Meetings SCIENCE, ENGINEERING, AND TECHNOLOGY Overview 4 New Models for U.S. Science & Technology Policy 5 The Public Face of Science 7 The Alternative Energy Future 15 GLOBAL SECURITY AND INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS Overview 18 New Dilemmas in Ethics, Technology, and War 19 The Global Nuclear Future 25 Civil Wars, Violence, and International Responses 28 Understanding the New Nuclear Age 31 EDUCATION AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF KNOWLEDGE Overview 35 Commission on the Future of Undergraduate Education 36 The Lincoln Project: Excellence and Access in Public Higher Education 40 THE HUMANITIES, ARTS, AND CULTURE Overview 43 Commission on Language Learning 44 The Humanities Indicators 48 Commission on the Arts 50 AMERICAN INSTITUTIONS, SOCIETY, AND THE PUBLIC GOOD Overview 53 Making Justice Accessible: Data Collection and Legal Services for Low-Income Americans 54 EXPLORATORY INITIATIVES 55 LOCAL PROGRAM COMMITTEES 69 DISCUSSION GROUPS 72 MEMBER EVENTS 74 AFFILIATES OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY 88 Donors to the Academy 91 Academy Leadership 100 FROM THE PRESIDENT n the spring of 1780, as American forces suffered a devastating loss in the Siege Iof Charleston, John Adams, James Bowdoin, and sixty other visionaries found- ed the American Academy of Arts and Sciences.
[Show full text]
Scientists See Fingerprint of Warming Climate on Droughts Going Back to 1900 1 May 2019
Scientists see fingerprint of warming climate on droughts going back to 1900 1 May 2019 drier, and wet ones will become wetter. Some recent studies suggest that human-induced warming has intensified droughts in particular regions, including a now near 20-year ongoing drought in the southwestern United States. However, the last report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change says confidence in attributing specific ongoing events directly to humans is still chancy. The new study combines computer models with long-term observations to suggest that systemic changes in what scientists call the hydroclimate are already underway across the world, and have been for some time. The researchers looked not simply at precipitation, but rather soil moisture, a more subtle measure that balances precipitation against Regions projected to become drier or wetter as the world warms. More intense browns mean more aridity; greens, evaporation, and is the quality most directly more moisture. (Gray areas lack sufficient data so far.) A relevant to farming and forestry. They used tree new study shows that observations going back to 1900 rings going back 600 to 900 years to estimate soil confirm projections are largely on target. Credit: Adapted moisture trends before human-produced from Marvel et al., Nature, 2019 greenhouse gases started rising, then compared this data with 20th-century tree rings and modern instrumental observations, to see if they could pick out drought patterns matching those predicted by In an unusual new study, scientists say they have computer models, amid the noise of natural yearly detected the fingerprint of human-driven global or decadal regional weather variations.
[Show full text]
12Th National Conference: Environment and Security
VISION CONTENTS The 12th NCSE National Conference on Science, Policy and the Environment explores the Summary Agenda 5 connections between climate disruption, food, Locations, Featured Speakers, and Times energy, water, public health and the security of Planning Committee 6 communities, here in the U.S. and around the world. The complex relationships between these themes are Advisory Group 7 reflected in the many cross-cutting sessions that Wednesday, January 18 9 bring together leaders from the scientific, Agenda and Plenary Speaker Biographies diplomatic, development, conservation, business, military, educational, and policy communities. Symposia 16 Locations, speakers, and Overview of Topics Whatever your background, I hope that you will be challenged in a constructive way to consider these Thursday, January 19 25 issues from new and different perspectives; work Agenda and Plenary Speaker Biographies across traditional boundaries; and, bring a solutions- oriented "can do" attitude to developing outcomes. Breakout Workshops 35 Locations, Speakers, and Overview of Topics Look around and you will see many knowledgeable individuals with whom you can begin new Friday, January 20 45 relationships to advance your work and launch Agenda and Plenary Speaker Biographies initiatives to redefine the relationship between security and the environment. These are individuals Environment and Security Exhibition 50 with whom you can help build a more secure world; Poster Session 52 a world where the essential needs for food, energy, Titles and Authors water, and health can be achieved in healthy ecosystems and sustainable communities. Collaborating Organizations 54 Perhaps this is your first NCSE conference, or Staff and Volunteers 55 perhaps you have been to all twelve (and there are many who have).
[Show full text]
Introduction Climate Change and Extreme Weather
Submission to Australian Senate Extreme Weather Inquiry Introduction I am a pretty ordinary Australian with no special skills or experience in agriculture, health, transport or disaster management. Neither have I been placed in any urgent life threatening instance from extreme weather to speak from personal experience. I am in fact fairly risk adverse at my present age in life. I used to take more risks in my youth. I even cycled from Sydney to Canberra, without a bicycle helmet, in the 1970s to camp on the lawns of parliament house. The issue was uranium mining. There were efforts made then to discuss Australia's energy future and energy alternatives. I helped (in a small way) construct a demonstration solar hot water system in front of parliament house. But most politicians were not listening to my small voice then. My voice grew stronger at the end of the 1990s with the advent of the internet. I had become a web developer and web content administrator, a citizen journalist and blogger writing stories from the streets, on issues and from people who were largely ignored by the mainstream media. Around 2003 I started to take an especially keen interest in the climate change issue, educating myself by reading scientific reports and studies, and writing up and communicating the issues raised online. I was still a small voice, but somewhat more amplified than in 1976. Climate change and Extreme Weather From my extensive layperson's reading, I have no doubt we are changing the climate through greenhouse gas emissions. And one of the results of that is more frequent and intense extreme weather events.
[Show full text]
Open Letter to President Biden: a People’S Vaccine—Free and Fair for All—To End the COVID-19 Crisis
Open Letter to President Biden: A People’s Vaccine—Free and Fair for All—to End the COVID-19 Crisis A safe, effective and accessible COVID-19 vaccine is vital to bring an end to today’s dual economic and health crisis – so our families are safe, so people can get back to work, so we can live our lives again. No one anywhere is safe from this disease until everyone everywhere is safe. As a cross-section of leaders from public health, business, faith-based, racial justice and labor organizations, public service, entertainment and economics, we join our voices to call on President Biden to commit to a People’s Vaccine, which provides protection as a global public good, freely and fairly available to all, prioritizing those most in need worldwide. President Biden has tremendous power to help decide who gets access to protection from this virus, when and at what cost. With this power comes an historic opportunity for America to lead again by leveraging the strength, know-how and generosity of our people to combat this disease here at home and wherever it resides. A People’s Vaccine is a medical necessity, an economic priority, and a moral imperative. The COVID-19 virus ruthlessly exploits existing inequalities, disproportionately affecting seniors, frontline healthcare and other essential workers, communities of color, people living in poverty, and people at more risk due to pre-existing conditions. Conflict over access to a vaccine that is distributed based on one’s wealth or nationality - rather than on need - will risk millions of lives, delay our economic recovery and exacerbate the crisis.
[Show full text]