Center for Thomistic Studies Report 2010-11 § FFrom tthth he Direect tor:
tnguriD hee 0201h -201 idemaca1 yc ear t brateelcerentChe tied 30s 30th reay as aduatrga ieachte ng- and rree HV DDUUUFF SK UR UUJ DDPP FLGHG DDWWHG WWRR ³³$$ 7JQLYL/ PVLPRK7 IIRRU WWKK LK7H UG QHOOL0 PXLQQ eped etsboth etsboth eped ieped lcaiortsihn knowknow edgl e of tof itadirthe on aandnd ageng ed tiw on-ch F\UDURSPHW OXF WWXX KVQLHU DDSS HKWJQL IIXX UXW HVLKWJQLWKJLOKJL+´HU IIIIIRRUUWW LK3HKW eparDhyosopl parrtt entm htand reentCe fforor istihomTor dieStuc ccodurntis ed tnioja ogpree rdeg ogpree gheamro . T rograPMA/AB m owlal ilaqus fifie phiSTUd yophoslphi doro(orsajm ubldo t)orsajme o earrnn AABa and hyosoplphiniMAan in sreay5 htfoead tnsi htfoead h randaste 6.5.d Studenntt ecers viece te ABhe afftt tplecomer e-rlalngit s entemquir s fforor eundTSUa rrggraduaatt egde reg ee aandnd tthehe MA afftt comer lalngitplecom rningaiemr entemriequr tofs MA/ABhe amrogPrMA aduatrgsophyoliPh. eaduat fos ulaegrSTU rinquiylrula ie nt ssiiadmo ion nti hto Ce ennter fforor stiomhT ist seiudtSc amamrProgMA amrprogMA/ABahtiW. am w, ce hetevseran denustse ennt thows yypicpic tantwylal sto ho-Tdyust quinas Aas m Aas quinas aatt ht rge aduaatt elevle , and enhaancence ectprosprihet s of ssiiadmof ppisharschol&ons reothats es itiseruniv es fforor .DPh udits. es. H\VLK7 DPRVODUDH UUNN DOHKWGH UUJJ WVH UHYHWQHPOORUQH IIRR QH&HKWU RUSV¶UHWQ h fortis wamrg h forfortis rtty st entud s aatt v louiar evs s oelev f graduaatt .orkwe
§ 22011 Aqqui inan s LLeect turure:
DKrr. teP er tfeeKr , proffessess ro osolphiof ostBatphyoso egollCon e tand ht 'ngiKe egollCs ie YewNn ,ytiCorkY VLKWGHUHYLOHG HUXWFH/VDQLXT$V¶UDH\ , TThh itsmio c PPersers Am:silaon agiMarr e n iMade iMade n HHeaveav vaHarorllHeen, rd? on 27 201yrJanua27 i1 oneJn Hs lalH aatt het Stof ytsiernivU Stof TSt hom. wtIas. agtnivas Ke eerK fftt ougrerovgnihik, philh lcaisophophil OFKWLZGQXRUJ URPXK\WLUDO DDQQ HYLWSHFHGG PHKWRWWRQHPWH/³HVDH LUUDP DDJJ IRH VGQLPHXUW $ PG HHU.´VWQHPLGHSPLWLP IWIW E HUDHSVHNDK6JQLWRXTVQLJHE Q2³H WKH yfihand rothe yfihand y yrarmou tiwhorsea h ackja yassack producnlyoou e ulema ule hicw, h iersts iurn tn i tn iurn iersts el odrpand nuces o offfffspsp ngir ng. yWhen homTyrarmou htiwsmihom , wwsminalopers hen y, a preyrarmou - odern,n, obobm bjj and mvitec casiaphyete philca o-osl tiwphy h odern,ma odern, subbjj vitec e enomphand lcaienologenom one, ydo etgou a agirarm e PVGQLPHXUWIR H+QLHGDP DDYY PHOXPDURQH D+UROOH+QLHGDP UUYY ´"GUD HHU. IWIW DQ THKWVUHZV JQLVXQRLWVHXT DDQQ PLUHKWR DDJJ KWHJ DDWW FH:³ \FQDQJHUSIR QDF ILIL \GDHUODPVLODQRVUHSGQ \OQHGGLK\ 7QLWQHVHUS HNLOPVLPRK7 DDQQ DEQUREQX KW@WFLGHUS,>GQD«\E DW VLKW LUUDPV DDJJ UURH DDWW QJHUSUHK DDQQ WRQVL\FQ monly ade i aveHn ed tnitdessibuten o bo soe ffrrruiuitffulul o ean rt iiathth tlliwt ofecepisteeatrghebe o-oslphiof ogr plphica ogr siessrog tnce 13he th ´\UXWQHF
§ OOrdrder ofof f SStt. Thomas
o mT ark i s 25t25tt ys earh the eentC, r for T Studistiomh iic itines aatted the rdeO r of f Stt. . TThoho asm o be awt, aw dderao VQRVUHSRW LWVHWHYDKRKZ ILIL RWGH ³³WW LHK KSHKWIRHXODYHOEDUDSPRFQ ´VDPRK7WQLD6IR\KSRVROLK ´ FFiiddeses et o atiR o §575, i)§57 ngitirwrheitn ngngieachts, phil, annt opyrh aywor iilof ffe.e. acE ientipiecrh entpress ent tiwed ah HEODGHP DDUU $VDPRK7IRHJDPLQDJQLU VDQLXT$ DDQQG WWKK RPH WW IRR X4³UHGU2HKW DQ VHWR3PXW PXWQD7V UD' ´HGX$ KWOODRGRWHU DDWW FXR\ DDQQ
KW, HKWQ, DDZZD OL¶G UDH\ODUXJXDQLV¶GU WGOLLW&KW WGHJHOLYLUSVDZUHWQH&HKW 'OLG&$KW X'ODQLGUD&\UHY$URQRKRW -6VHOOX -6OO eorgG. rMand rMand eorgeorgG. akrtSe Jre, Sinc. hente when avhe e ffoo owll histed paattt dingarawofnert tthehe boedalm tbo n-ioth terrnn iat onaalll nizecogryl rholasced s and to ffrr endi havhows, me ade blipossamrprogour nclie, rouudingncl IIRR )VUHGQX D%6&NL]HU%URWFL9U) ODKVUD0\R5KJX+U0GQ OO DDQQ -SRKVLEKFU$G OHDKFL0- SB, CrellMi SB, (2SB )010 .
he t1 201n I 201n t1 he znicogerertenChe Aed quinas erurtecLquinas eteP eeKrr fftt as allew s M lcheiMs. lMale oy and .rF . C WertobR . C Cerook. BSr, :
Q,³ DDZZ HKWJQLGUD Order of asomThSt. to rF C. rookerC w, hone hisor conntrir buut oi n as enarheto tan iliasBa iliasBa tan enarheto anssiena ice n tthehe St.foudyst mhoTSt. Aas iquinas oNn rtrth ca,iermAh fifi str aatt tthehe Ponnttififi alc instIal ttuteute udtSalaeviMedof iud ies ontroTn o tand hehen rhe e aatt the reentC fforor stihomT tais c Sttudiudi Wees. nizecogr e s tlelwas earyhe s hingeactof hing ad-and oronon in Tiatrtnisim oronon onnt oustHando on aandnd the energ ytsioener snowkathttirispof se- re ritno e w, ylFinal. entm ylFinal. w, e edglnowack iwe th udtiatrg e rFathte erookrC. ffuncunc it ons fforor assu ³WUUXX RQH UW VLKWQR´K PRFODXWFHOOHWQLV¶\WLVUHYLQX ´VVDSP
VLKWJQLNDPQ,³ DDZZ RWGUDZ heleicM yollaM w, e orhone seher rrvvi tce Co aattho ilho rhehigc educaatt oi ann md ore tyloadrbore iolhatCo urtculc e ane htnioniducated chdirAe socechdi ofe G-onestval QRWVXR+ DSH]LQJRFHUH:Q UWUW \OUDOXFL WLVUHYLQ8VLKWQRHUXQHWUHK\ GUDR%V¶\W e herws, ortecriDof ortecriDof herws, e ishe rchaiylentcurrs Wrchaiylentcurrs W. e rae eatrge ffulul fforor t rcahe we tiw chihwh shas she shas ttududi roued oitiadrtr ns wand are e heaarrrttened tbyened shtspecerhe e has owsh n ffoor iachetof orkwour orkwour iachetof ng pshiarscholand werH. w-dei tce:ivserngiganr ho er otsh,irpa Incarrnatnate cademAWord ycadem t, uilGytirhaChe d of Cof aatt ilho Womc en, tand to ht serdrOe DWOD0IR DDQQ R+HKWG DH\OWVXMVDKHUKFOXSH6\OR UQUQ ULPGDUXRGHQ DDWW ´QRL
erokorCFr. erokorCFr. user icasocheted llecaroton ht e eokroC anr d yollMa IIDD VGQDHYROIR\FDJHO¶VHLOLPD RSSXV UWUW IIRRU ervinUhe t ervinUhe Stofytiser mhoT. as ffrr stiom htotsearysteilreas entesrpe eseprheT.ent ntaatt oni rews e m tsujade VLKWRWURLUS HUXWFH/VDQLXT$V¶UDH\V
§ JJohhn Paul III FForum:
retenChe T retenChe fforor homT istihom Studic es behas expaen paandednded enriand ougrhtched oug tih news he th tiwp ionshiatelr tiwp th he ohJhe FoIIlPaun rrumum w, hose orctedirhose , iHJohn tttt erngi , i, s ehton UHWQH& IIDD HK7\WOXF R)HKWIRQRLVVLP UUXX ³VLP GQDWVUHGQXHKWHWRPRUSR7 HKWIRJQLG John pe Poof ht ghout ht Poof pe John IIlPauJohn tand eldevo hisop acyeglhis tias ffoormrms equipsand hetequips KFUXK& IIRR ZHQHKWU YH DDQQ ]LOHJ DDWW F67&HK7´QRL RF -evnsorespo d numa ofber htiwsentev t-11, Fohe rrumum i 20 10n 11, ngiudncli :
ber 9, emtSep ber 9, 0201ber T orabHonhe lorab iRe morutnSack HSV DDNN JQL X3QLKWLD)IRHOR5HK7³QRJ L/FLOEX IIHH L) IWIW IWII$VUDH<\ W HHS6V¶\GHQQH.)QKR-UH HU*HKWRWKFH DDWW 0QRWVXR+UH ODLUHWVLQL0 LFRVV$ DDWW ´QRL February 24, 2011 Dr. F. Russell Hittinger, William K. Warren Chair of Catholic Studies at the 8QLYHUVLW\RI7XOVDVSHDNLQJRQ³:KDW6W%HQHGLFW7DXJKWWKH'DUN$JHV² +LVDQG2XUV´
April 30, 2011 Conference at Houston Baptist University HQWLWOHG³+HDOWK&DUHLQD6HFXODU &XOWXUH 7KH&RQVFLHQFHRI3K\VLFLDQVDQG1XUVHVDW5LVN´
June 13-16, 2011 Workshop with Dr. Michael Waldstein, Max Seckler Professor of Theology at $YH0DULD8QLYHUVLW\RQ³7KH7KHRORJ\RIWKH%RG\´DQGOHFWXUHRQ³6W7KR PDV3KHQRPHQRORJ\DQG3RSH-RKQ3DXO,,´
§ Aquinas & the Arabs :
The CTS hosted the Fall Conference (11-12 September 2010) of The Aquinas and the Arabs Project, an international working group of scholars, organized by Richard C. Taylor, Marquette University, which is devoted to making known the important influence of philosophy in the Arabic tradition on the thought of Thomas Aquinas and his predecessors, colleagues, etc., in philosophy and theology in the Latin West during middle ages.
The group has two meeting per year, one in North America and the other in Europe, and publishes its findings in a variety of ways. Already in progress are a special edition of the journal The Thomist and a two volume work for Cambridge University Press by Taylor, R. E. Houser, Univer- sity of St. Thomas (TX), and Luis Farjeat, Panamerican University, Mexico City.
The conference was underwritten by the CTS, Dr. Dominic Aquila, VPAA, Fr. Joseph Pilsner, CSB, Dean, College of A&S, the John Paul II Institute and the Faculty Development Committee.
§ CCeenter t r CColloquiia:
he tnder U tnder he car rDfoe mohT. Oas sborne, tsborne, ioqulloChe a ffee ruat ed a rxtuima dentsutsfoe ertenC, ytlFacuer , tcula FSTU tcula yt and iouirustlli, gtinvs uested Huest ires. te lhs neie -up of sspe s:erak
. 2tSep arM adstulKk IRU3 IIHH 8HFL5\KSRVROLK3IRURVV QELH/³QRHNRSV\WLVUHYLQ8 ]LQ DDQQ HKWG $IR\WLOLELVVR3 LWQHLF6LURLU3$ IILL QRLWFLGHU3F ´Q
6. 1tSep 6. C intarMhris Profe, sors yophosliPhof reentC, ffoo istihomTr Sc tudu i TSUes, okpsT e on ODQ$³ \W\W 3ODFL 5 KWLD)HKWGQD\KSRVROLK H5 IOIO ¶HEPRFVQ$QRVQRLWFH µV Twenttyy OOpinipini momnsCo Am rn AModeongmon nggllo-A PriemA erssophohilcan ´¶
0. 3tSep 0. eacTr dlanowRy D, ean htof oJe instIIIlPauhn eutti fforor agirrMa e liamFand Studiyl es, X$HQUXREOH0 Q2³QRHNRSVDLODUWVX urtulC e andur tthehe ThTh iom stt TTradraddiittiion ´
. 14ctO eaniD HaaneDl K3 H&WQHGXWV' QW UH IIRR PRK7U QRHNRSV768VHLGXW6FLWVLP ³Q LLiininnggguuuiiststtiiicc H7 UPUP GLFQ,VDV ´VDQLXT$QLVHOELVQH6ODWQHG ´
. 21ctO lyeeDJohn PGX5 DDQQ UHWQH&ULDK&Q IIRR LPRK7U QRHNRSV768VHLGXW6FLWV 7³Q DDNN JQL \OVXRLUH6KWLD) ´\
. 12ovN MtoberR rein Associ, ssociaatt ssoProfee r of f P phyosolhi Bphy Ulay, tisernivor y spoke on ³ThThhooommmaasas QLXT$ HU*QRVDQ DDWW ´WLULS6IRVVHQ
ec. 2D remmoSselrahC , V$ VLVV WDWDDQQW3UURRIIHH \JRORHK7IRURVV RSV768 NNHH ³QR iS ggnn tthtsuseJfo h Pe rroo tehp ni MMaattttthh we ´
. 11Feb John rthyaCMc D, ean, Schean, osophyliPhfoool C, olihatC ytsiernivUc ermAof espokcaier &V¶HPX+³QR 7IRHYR/VXRLUX& UUXXWWKK LLL,, IR A TTrereatise ofof HHumuman NNatature ´
. 17Feb raeC anmdereNy Profe, enceciScalitilPofossorProfe ence exT, &Aas ytsiervinUM okspy one 5IRVWSHFQR&³ QLVWKJL5 WWKK ´VHJ$HOGGL0H
. 25Feb isonrorMonaldD 3 RU3 IIHH L5\KSRVROLK3IRURVV QRHNRSV\WLVUHYLQ8HFL ³³$$ QRHOWRWVLU VVHQLSSD+HKW ´\WL&HKWIR
ch 3Mar urtC kcHancois haC, osJandsophyoliPhforiha eph Meph emFre. liPhofrhaiCan phyoos at, LQ8WVUXKNFR5 JQLWQXR&³QRHNRSV\WLVUHYL QHPR:QRJ DDQQ PR:\K:G WQXR&QHP DNRR/ZH1$ DDWW DXW6QKR- UUWW X6µV¶OOL0 EEMM FH ´¶QHPR:IRQRLWF
ch 10Mar eJam eaglarCs LVV$ DWVL QW RU3 IIHH VFLV\K3IRURVV QRHNRSV768 ³$ OHKWHU DDZZ V\KSIRVZ - i-cs fifi en GHQXW 0RWHVLUHYLJRW DQ ´"
ch 31Mar lyeeDJohn 55XX QDPG H&ULDK&Q QW UH IIRR VLPRK7U QRHNRSV768VHLGXW6FLW HKWZR+³ IIRRUPUP UµDOX DDWW QRL ¶ODPLQDODQ IIDD RKVVOO UWUW ´
§ EEndowed Chhairs
Drr. R.. Edwaard d HHouser i ts enturrche occupannt hetof iB Wendshop ielWend Jn loN. irhaiCd aduarGn aduaatt -iPhe nam, hyosopl nam, named fforor t erevRstMohe endnd ilendeWe olNn 0190(d - 1981981), ffiiftft shobih p tof ociDhe ese -alGfoese v-oustonest Houst 0195(on -197 w5), amho, ententshmpliccomaotherhisongam derros, hted rgnteie aattion o-hatCof lhoosccil s i 9611n . Drr. Joho n Deely ho tdslho AankrFhe . RRudmudman irhaiC htatsophyoliPhn e Cenntt re fforor c istihomT c Sttudiudi hicwes, zialorimemh es htes ibutirtcone ons Mrof R. udmR tan holiatCo iateducc on ehtand tsinivU ytsiernivU homTSt.of hereherewas, he rsehe vr ed Bheted aroBheton d ffrr 3hai3195fd 3195om 3- B59. oth tthehhe erwsrhaicse e edwndoee edndo hrougt h tthehe g of tytosienerhe Scanh an FFle undoan aatt n.oi
CECENTER FFACUAACULLTYTTYY
§ JJohhn Deeely
naiqu7 A 196hDP A naiqu7 Inssna Schtutit ooe oslhiPfol hyopos as Inniqu6 A 196MA A as Inniqu6 In Schtutistas olooe osoplihPf hyosop s naiqu5 A 196AB A naiqu5 s SchuttitInss olooe osoplihPf hyosop
Publications:
6th ed edixpande edi oited 1n, st nesihC onitiede ofon ofcsiasB SSememiotics (ffororrtrt ngiomhc ffrr Bom eiijj nMeR:ngi inM -inUn erv Pytsier Fss)er orrtt .ngihcom
ZRUHKQ,³ HU3´HFLRYQZ IIDD VX6RWHF DDQQ 3 LOOLUWH3 SSii oaossrrCgn ids n olG Pbal errspespe veict ((NN Bew ,ckiswunrB J:N PictansarTJ: 201)srsheilubon 2010.
DPQ8HK7³ 2IRJQLNVD EEMM QL´\WLYLWFH HHiist eiBory, ngg,, a ririulaSingnd tty:y: A FFesesttscschriiffftt in HHonoonor of KKenneennetthh SchmiSchm ttzz, rauBlhaecMied. and obeRand rrtt E hingasW(Wood. thing iholatCheT:..CDon, nivUc foytiserniv mA ierm caa P 201ss)er 0.
DVV(HK7³ R)³HKWQL´VLVSLODUD3QLV\D IR´HXVV,ODLFHS6VHJ$UXR SemiSem ottiica 178- 0)201(1/4 g, uest- uest detedi by S P anilliretusan ohJd iHn tttt .erngi
66HH RLP WWLL Q$F RPWVRS$ODPLQ GGHH QU GGHHHIIILL WLQ QRLW RRII VQDUW´JQLHEQDPXK³ QHFV GGLL D3JQ WWUU FUDL KK\\ GQD ))HHP PVLQLP WWRR VXXSSHS UUVVHGGHHWWKK WQHLFQDH GLKG GGHHHIIILL LL RLWLQ DU³VDQR WWLL G´OLOL³ GQD´ODPLQDODQR G WWKK QUHGRPH GGKG GGHHHIIILL LL VDQRLWLQ L³ LJRFVHU³ WDQ ´VQ R6 XW JX$W6 1,GQH%K VVHU3V¶HQLWVXJ
Meddii PPleva olih sophhyy Redeefffiined anrSc( nt U:PAon, of Sytsiervin cr aantonn Pnton 201ss)er 0.
DPVLODH5³ DDQQ 3QL´\JRORPHWVLS(G DDXX &O GH \HOER& Th loutRe edge Cedge ommpanpani ton iSemo ottiics R( )eedgloutR 2010.
HGRPWVR3³ UQUQ RRIRJQLNVDPQXHKWVD\WL EEMM LWQHG, \WLYLWFH II\\ SHKWJQL HGRPWVRSIRHFQHVVHHYLWLVRS DVD\WLQUH WFQLWVLG KSIR\URWVLKHKWQLDUHZHQW ´\KSRVROLK acitoiSem (F(F183 arebru y 201 , 31)1 ±57.
VFLWRLPH6³ 6QHH6 \Q 9HK7 \OODFLQRUKF DDJQLQHSR´IRVDZHL9 UW HOFL IIRR XRMHKWU UQUQ OD CChinhinese SSemem itoi c Studdiies 4v , nool. 2 meecD(. ber 2010), 9±113.
iSem ottii s SeSec Syns nicchroen allly:y: tthehe ViView ffromrom 2010 O( tt Oaw ratna, Co,ir La:anad 2010eg .)as,
Meddii Pleva oslhiP ophhyy Reddefeffii Thned. De tenopmleveD ienoscopCof c SScicience AD 435 ±1644 ((fffromrom tthh bie rtthh uof Auguof istu tne o tthehe deatdeatthh off P oooins tt)) tanrSc( U:PAon, yytsierniv of Sc Ptanr pps)esron xxx, v + 508iiv .
H-³ IIIIH% UQUQD $GQDJQLWHH0WVUL)GUD IWIW ´UH ´ IIXX GHKVLOEXSVVHUGGDODUHQ H-HKWQL IIII H% UQUQ LURPH0GUD IRHXVV,OD Th A ierme Journcan al ooff SSemem otiottiics 26.1±4- (20 G estu10), EditE ed byy G Woril , xiximalhtia ± .ixii
QRVHVHK7³ ´VFLWRLPH6GQD\JRORLPH6Q WOXVQRFQLGHSROHYHG´ DDWW QRL H-KWLZQ IIII H% UQUQ QLGUD The ncaiermA JournalJourna ooff Semiottiics 26.1±4 (2010 , 17)4 ±25.
sretuecL & P saper :
HFQRFHK7 HFQRFHK7³ OHUIRVWSH DDWW QRL DDQQ OHUG DDWW QGH OSGHWLYQL´VFLWRLPHVQLVVHQ OSGHWLYQLVFLWRLPHVQLVVHQ )QRGHWQHVHUS\UDQHO UL \DG \DG PHYR1 PHYR1 o tber, tber, o ht 3e rd aniomR atssociAan iat on iotiSemof c Sttudiesudies atn lonaiat confferere helnce 4d ± N7 emovN ber 0 in201 in I0 Rasi a.aniom,
DGUDZR7³ 3µIR\UHYRFH5QUHGRPWVR3 WQHVHUS\UDQHOS´¶QRVUH3 DDWW RL D0\DGLU)VUXRK QR RW\D 13he t 13he ±±JHWQ,\D0 UQUQDDWW QR&ODQRL VVHUJ ³$ FR6GH]LODQRVUHSH' FXG("\WHLF DDWW ODVRSRU3ODQRL GOHK´V DDWW ernivU tsier aatt Abaatt O Cil BUEba cear, Sona,lce ipa oiatcilpubn; profon ngiceedpro s ffoorrtt .ngiomch
VUH3PRU)³ R5PRU)\WLODQRVUH3RWQRV HVHUS\UDQHOS´UHZRO)RWWRR WQH DDWW QRL DDWW HKW th MeelannuA ofngitMee mAhe t mAhe ierm caann iatiarM iatsocisAn on aydirFon , octO16 20ber 10, 15:1110, ± Walat15,:12 Ush ,ytsiernivU on, antC on, pub;oihOon, iatcil pron oceeof dingocee s ffororrtt .ngihcom
QDNRHEH6³ HKWIRVFLWRLPH6GQ st WQH& QHVHUSVVHUGGDGHWLYQL´\UXW UHEPHYR1\DGLU)QRGHWQ th, fforor eht PPR&³ URPHP DDWW NRHEH6PR7IRQRL HKWIRQRLVDFF2HKWQR th L%VL+IR\UDVUHYLQQ$ UWUW ´K ± 1 o-N2 ber 2010, mev ber 2010, ronsospber tbyed N ewhe Bew iarglu aann U tsierniv y of Soffii B a.iarglua,
roP ffessessional Se evicrional :
, roditE , e ATh A ierme Jourcan nal ooff Sem otiottiics
BaliroditE aro d, itoiSem c SociSociettyy ofof Am caierm sngieedProc
§ JJohhn PP... HiHitttingger
athhe C6 T 198hDP T C6 athhe Uiolath y otsiniverc f A rime cari ahe C8 T 197MA T C8 ahe Uilhota y otsiniverc f A rime cari rsnive U4 197AB U4 rsnive y otirs f N Dto meare
Publications:
iH tttt erngi , John. The VocaVoca it on ooff tthehe CaCatthoho Pil lhic osooppher: FFromrom MMariarittaain ttoo John Paul IIII Was. Washinggton, .CD A.:.C ierm AnaitiMarcan ssoc D:oniatissoc irsti buuted by y tthehe C Uiolhathe tsiervinc y of A ierm Pri essca , 2010.
IRZHLYH5³ Y(I DDQQ QKR-HSR3QRVODFLOHJ 3Q DDXX ´,,O Journal of f In disdisert ciipp il nary Studdiies o. (20-(20n22, 115:10)o. 19.
GDH5\K:³ ´"\OHH'G citoiSem a RQ VV,ODLFHS6VHJ$UXR)³R ´HXV -9.
³77KKH99RR WDF QRLW RRII WWKK D&H WWKK VROLK3FLOR RRSS 2 UHKS GG\\ ZR%¶VXHVV ´ in The VocaVocattiion ooff tthehe C c Pilatho P so-olihc pher :pher FFromrom iMar ttaai Jotn hn PPo aul IIII DontngshiWa. .:.C, A ierm AaitirMacan ocissn aatt : Dit s-ion butirt buted by y t C Uilhoathe ervinc of Aytsier Pierm 2esrca 010s, .010 sretuecL & Ps saper :
R0PRU)³ HK7 \FDUFRPH'RW\KFUDQR RPL6VHY 3QKR-³ DDXX LQLWVXJX$ ,,OX DDQQ RVWRR5 )VXRLJLOH5I UH 3´PRGH DDSS GHUHYLOHGUHS IIRR QR&HKWU IIHH QRHFQHUH atholC iathol itbuirtonCc ton ghtsiRo ghts vA. irMae vA:FLa, Mare iMar ytsiervinUa erSacand Hd Hearrtt Ma- or Sj S 20naryiemor 11., O3³ O3 DDWWRDDQQG )HKWQRHOWRWVLU$G DDPP QD\OL 3´VLOR3HKWGQ 3VLOR3HKWGQ DDSS UHYLOHGUH GHU IIRR HKWU Mettaaaphysiphysi loCcs umquioll . 0 +ZH1UHWVHKFQD0 DDPP HULKVS HJHOOR&V¶POHVQ$W6 3QKR-³ DX KWKJXRUKW\D:HKWGQD,,OX 9WVR3HK DDWW FL DDQQ QR&,, IIXX RLV GHUHYLOHGUHSD3´QR IIRR HHKWU Montthlhllyy Mee gnitMee H tous. A:xTon, e MarMarv Foie Creunda ls 1.201ub, RZHLYH5³ Y(IR DDQQ KR-HSR3QRVODFLOHJ ´,,OXD3QK Jourrnalnal ooff IInn erderdt diisciipp sdieStuarynil 22, no. :)0201(no. 115-19.115 QHHZWH%³ GR* DDQQ QLDWLUD0 UDVHD&G &QR DDWW DXQQ$´QRLWF$FLORK FLUHP$HKWIRJQLWHHPOD DDQQ QLDWLUD0 A iatssoci .0102on, XD3QKR-³ XD3QKR- H'QR,,OX DWK DDQQ H'QLDU%G DDWW Q,´K Q,K Th De effeense Lof iifffee oC. rpusrpus T,itsirhC eTx: xas giRxas tht o iLiffe,e, 0.201 c iolhatC" c tooR s ePap"on.iatreloTof r-annual ervidel ed fforor theh bi iermAannual caann merG xchangEan xchang Mu-e, nic Gnic eh, rmrm 20any 10., ens ckiD" ens aandnd ohJ IIlPaun on Sin aandnd vielderPap"on.iatilcieconR erv ed fforor the osoplhiP Symhy mmpopo umsi . C Oant Wao:ihon Ul siervinsh 20ytsi 10., an mewN" an gmoDon a tand emgrnlaEhe entem Miof vildeerPapnd." erv ed fforor the NNee mw omCan ora-emmom onit on Wo. erstcher A:MA, umss Cptium 201eglolon 0.e, roP ffessessional Se evicrional : enconferC Benc Aoare Maciermd, n Aiatiran A 2iatocissn 070on -2011 , ProtecriD P Pope IaulJohn FI fororum r t Ch rhue ich n tthhe Moderrnn Wor 20lWor08d -2011 ber ofMem of f B d oaro f D orstecri e RRhT, ewieve of WsiyaphtMe ashcs, tngiash ..CDon, hai CmirnteI hai Prhai Dyophoslhi, eparrtt entm Uent tiserniv, y of homTSt as, 20102010-2011 § RR.. Eddward Houser rsnive1 U 198hDP U rsnive1 y otirs f T otoron siverni6 U 197MA U siverni6 y otsi f T otrono itonP6 197LMS itonP6 ffiical titInscal SlaevaMedifoute S esiudt trsivein8 U 196AB U trsivein8 y ot f T asxe Publications: “Philip the Chancellor,” in Lagerlund, Henrik, ed., Encyclopedia of Medieval Philosophy (Heidelberg: Springer, 2010). Review of Ide M. Ni Riain, trans., Denis the Carthusian, Ecstatic Doctor, Virtues and Vices, (Dublin: Four Courts Press, 2009), for Journal of the History of Philosophy 48 (2010) 523-4. Lectures & Papers: “Dionysius the Carthusian (1402–1472) on the Layman’s Journey from Vice to Virtue,” South-Central Renaissance Association, Corpus Christi, TX, 20 March 2010. “Aquinas’s Use of Averroes and Avicenna in his De principiis naturae.” Conference for the international working group, Aquinas and the Arabs / Thomas d’Aquin et ses sources arabes, 11 September 2010, Center for Thomistic Studies, University of St. Thomas, Houston. “Avicenna and Aquinas’s De principiis naturae, c. 1-3,” Paris, Conference of Aquinas and the ‘Arabs,” CNRS, 20 May 2011. Professional Service: National Secretary for the American Catholic Philosophical Association, 2010 to present. Editorial Board, The Bonaventure Texts in Translation Series, Franciscan Institute, St. Bonaventure University, NY, 2001 to present. Editorial Board, Aquinas Translation Series, The Catholic University of America Press, 2007 to present. Aquinas and the Arabs / Thomas d’Aquin et ses sources Arabes Project, 2008 to present. Organizer of sessions on the Philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas at the International Congress on Me- dieval Studies, Kalamazoo, Michigan 1991 to present. § Steven J. Jensen Ph.D.1993 University of Notre Dame B.A. 1987 University of St. Thomas, St. Paul, MN Publications: The Ethics of Organ Transplantation (edited). Washington, DC: The Catholic University of America Press, 2011. Good and Evil Actions: A Journey through Saint Thomas Aquinas. Washington, DC: The Catholic University of America Press, 2010. “Introduction on Organ Transplantation,” in The Ethics of Organ Transplantation, edited by Steven J. Jensen. Washington, DC: The Catholic University of America Press, 2011. “Killing and Letting Die,” in The Ethics of Organ Transplantation, edited by Steven J. Jensen. Washington, DC: The Catholic University of America Press, 2011. H*³ WWWW Q,JQL ´QRVUH3JQLWF$HKWHGLVQ IIntent Phonitrnante Qlcaiosophlial uar ertuar llyy 0-71 (205 46110): sretuecL & P saper : HYR/³ IIRR $U UHJQL6 VODPLQ$ DDQQ DQLXT$G ´VD DDWW HWQ,KWHKW UQUQDDWW ODQRL GXW6ODYHLGH0QRVVHUJQR& WVH:VHLG ern UhigcMin ytsiernivan , May y 12-15, 2011. QDU*HK7³ HYLWFHOOR&HK7 QRLVXOO,GQ PVLODLWQHXTHVQR&IRGRR* DDWD´GRR*QRPPR&HKWVY W HKW th mA ierm caann Maarr Aiati isocsn aatt on CCi ce, CCenrnfeoon annton,ce, Oon, hio O 14robetchio -16,16, 2010. 2³ UUJJDQDU7 DDQQ WQDOSV DW H'GQDQRL DDWWWKK ´ DDWW&HKWW DDWW RL%FLORK -Ecaledim Et ih iemScs nar ndEon -off--LiL ffee ,esssui etiV Damnet Sniciomese s, HHertsian ostous, exTn, 1uJas, 2, 2ne 2 .0102, VQRLVVLP2³ VDDQQ &ULHK7G DDXX ´VHV DW HKW HWQ,KW UQDDWW VVHUJQR&ODQRL HHWVH:VHLGXW6ODYHLGH0QR UQUQ LKFL0 an Ug U ytsiernivan , May y 13- 20120116, 0. VQRLVVLP2³ ´VHVXD&ULHK7GQDV DDWW &HKW UHWQH& IIRR VHLGXW6FLWVLPRK7U D[H7QRWVXR+PXLXTROORFV \D0VD 2010. roP ffessessional Se evicrional : rTaloniatN erasurer ffororr th iermAe caann Cattholhol Phi Alphicaosolic isocs iati 200on, presot8 .ent § JJohhn FF... X.. KKnasas tirsnive5 U 197hDP U tirsnive5 y of T otoron y otsiverni2 U 197MA U y otsiverni2 of T otrono ol ConstoB0 197AB ConstoB0 ol egelol Publications: andsmiomTh and d TToleole eranc . (Scrannt UU:on tiserniv y of Scr Pant ss, 20eron 20 pss, 111), .40p. Q8HK7³ DDYY GLRY DDEE -QL¶QRLJLOH5µIR\WLOL 5QKR- DDZZ $¶VO UUJJ VWQHPX IIRRU QLGH´HFQDUHOR7 FFautautte,e, ddélélitt,, chépé et ccullpabpab regaé:tili sésicrords sur l es ffondonddemementtss de notre éth equi Es:irPa( Conitdi uujjas, .0)201as, s and quinaA s and tthehe Crryy ofof R helac S ibmu. itttt m rgonoed aph the probon of evemlprob .li sretuecL & P saper : ¶VDQLXT$³ JQLH%IRURWFHOOHWQ, DDQQG 'DDZZ UUD1V¶QRV DDWW &IRHYL ´\URWVL+ODUXWOX& DW RFHKW QR IIHH HFQHU K7³ PVLPRK DDQQ LV$G DDQQ OX& WWXX VHU UEHOH& V DW IRVUDH<JQL ]LOLYL&VVRUFDHXJRODL' DDWW QRL ´VQ DDWW WKH nivU of Sanytsierniv t ManManas,omTo Maya,li 20 11., HOR5HK7³ LQ,HKWQLPVLODH5HVQH6IR LWL DDWW WH0¶VDQLXT$IRQRL DDSSK S\UDQHOS´VFLV\K DDSS UH DDWW HKW PDKGUR)H nivU onCretenCaleviMedytsierniv onffererence cssiaphyetMheT, annasiquAfocs tId dernMos nteIdern rprerpre -t s, ers, 2rMas, .011ch, ³FFiide Retde RRets atttiio tand 02he th W& \UXWQH& $´OL5LWLK7 HY$´ODYLYH5FLWVLPRK7 W+WLL8L0 QRWVXR+\WLVUHYLQ8DLUD0 G) VUHGQXR) ub, lC ub, 2carMub, .010h, Q8HK7³ DDYY R-QL¶QRLJLOH5µIR\WLOLEDGLRY VWQHPXJU$¶VOZD5QKR IIRR 7U ´HFQDUHOR7 DDWWUHWQ,HXTROOR& U±QDDWW ODQRL Fau tildée,tFau labiplcuetéchép, aregré:ti séiorcds eslrsus ffonon entdem ds rtnoe ée thiqh ue; tinstIue; uutt atC t-e dquilhoa StE ierupudes eure (eure LECIs a RS), oche surr Yon, Franon, 20yrJanuace, 0.1, § CChhri istophphep er Marttin rd UofOx84 19lihP rd UofOx84 U ytiersnivrd rd Uof81 Ox 19lhiPB Ox rd Uof81 U ytrsiniverd UordfOx9 197MA UordfOx9 U yytiersniv Publications: RGQRFH6µ³ OHUDO ¶HQRL]LUFVHGDQX DDWWWWW YL DOOHGHQRL]DJHLSVDOOHGjWLY QRL]QHWQLD DDOO DFLWH¶OOHGHjWL 0(*QL Q$ SLUFVHGDUHGQ8µ³>´HEPRFVQ OHU ¶QRLWS DDWW OS[HIR\WLYL DDQQDDWWL L\WLODVXDFQLQRL QWHQQWW WLODQRL KWHGQD\W VFL QL@´HEPRFVQ$0(*QL GH $-RGDFUH0 zabetilE etthh comnsA be vamnnoirlie alldeoentvam psi lcopsi oggiia morrale R, 201om 0, AAe mr0, IortdiEando 978SBNe, 978-88-6081-716-7. sretuecL & P saper : esr addaddnoteeyK esr s aatt confferer oe ed onzanigrnce on Ced itsihr bybysophyoliPhan U dsierniv ntiPoad ffii a de CCci liha e and I rnteand naatt Analoi e ffürfüriademke ürr P e, Sphiosolhi annt o de Cagi C Olhio obetce, r 201 E iomt1: msi o anal un:coitianal pau pta a unara a fifi osli offii C ana.itsira § MMirela OOliva ersniv07 U. 20Dh.P U. ersniv07 tiers rbueirFfoy i. GBg ersg, (rman y)hosoplhiPy iersniv0 U0. 20.AB U0. iersniv0 ti (taresuchBfoy hyosoplihP )hy SD6D/³ $0 S± \WLVUHYLQ8´D]QHL me (oR ( ScalitiolPme ce)enic tirsnive8 U9. 19.AB U9. tirsnive8 ot (taresuchBfy SlcaitiolP S )eencic Publications: RFL5OXD3 V¶UXH ++HH VFLWXHQHPU RRII U& QRLWDHU aioumRueevR, ne isopholiPhde esrchauBe, tes 0201/2, (f(ffoort )ih .)ngicomh HHermerm teneutTi andcs tthhe IIll isul on ooff ranonitaslTran i, e(lcere.CLn d.) HHee eneurm ti rdek ÜÜbersebersettzuzung eruntG, arN rar 20bingüT, 11 (en, ffororrtthcom .)ngihcom e The EEnchanncha entmtnchan ooff HHermerm scieneut i, n ieutenrmE erivca ttatativa. FFeesttschrschriiffftt per Gaspare Mura, itnPo fifi aci banirU Ubani Pytiservinana Rsesr om, 201om 0.e, sretuecL & P saper : ¶VDQLXT$³ UDURSPHWQR&QLGUR:UHQQ, H+\U UPUP UHWQH&´VFLWXHQH IIRRU XTROOR&VHLGXW6FLWVLPRK7U PXL roP ffessessional SefP Se vicevicrional : R%ZHLYH5 $$68´VHLGXW6UXHRFL5³GUDR ollC aaboraboraatto rro ewiev, Maggaa nzzi o di FFii osolosoofffiia F anr, MielngAco an 20li, 20-03an § Thomas OOsbornee,, Jrr... itonP2 200MSL itonP2 fical titInscal SlaevaMedifoute S esiudt nive Uuk1 D 200hDP D Uuk1 nive ytiersniv ContosB5 199MA CContosB5 geello athoe Ch4 T 199AB T Ch4 athoe Uilatho y otsiverinc f A aacrime Publications: DVDPRK7³ WLZHFQHGXU3QRVXWRF6GQD 0HKWOO$WXRKW DDMM L9UR UWUW HX UHSP, V IIHH UD3\OHUH0URWF UWUW ´"ODL eTh Th tsiom ( 1:)020174 -24. DDQDIHLOHEQ8³ Q VDQLXT$VDPRK7QLQL6G DDQQ QRLWLGDU7FLWVLPRK7HKWG ´Q NNovaova te VVetetteraera ilngE, sh itidEsh 8on 201( 6:)020113 -626. FQR&HK7³ S R)DVDWSH UP J ´QJL6OD iSem caitoi (20(201790): 10):1 -21. sretuecL & P saper : 6VDPRK7³ F2GQDVXWRF6 NKNK FDU3QRPD ´QRVDH5ODFLWF FForschuorschungskskkolol umioqul ashomT. -ut,tinstI -ervinUut, aetsi ztae K loeu n. Mayy 2010. 6VDPRK7³ RF6 WWXX KNF2GQDV DDPP HKWQR 2EEMM ´HSR+IRWFH IInvinvit Taed lTa k. Kaatt ekihol etsiernivUe en.uveLti Mayayy 2010. roP ffessessional Se evicrional : ec SaloniatN ec aretrec y of At Ciermhe acan aatt Pihol Alcaihosoplhic atcisso t-2010.ia 0820on, ed tthetzanigrO he C Seioqullo eira s ffoor t hhe C etenhe r fo SistimhoTr es, 2uditc 2-2011.010es, § MMary CC.. SSommers tinive2 U 198hDP U tinive2 y otirsnive2 of T totoron califitonP6 197LMS califitonP6 titInscal SlevaMedifoute udt esiud y otsiverni2 U 197MA U y ootsiverni2 f T otrono CanmtiWh1 197AB CCanmtiWh1 eeglol Publications: R-VQHZ2³ QL´5V6&KSHVR NNewew Catholentlic EncyEncy aediopcl , Suppplplement 0, v201 2, 748. -76. ³T-syop XX7 UUYY\ LYRU3IRPHOERU3HK7 \ T QHPPR&¶VDQLXT$QLHFQHG \ ER-QR\UDWQ . Q,´ omThSt. as anas d tthehe roblP emrobl ooff EEvivi ihoC:l ce, HHii oost cedenroviP&ry, . oceedrP ddiings ooff tthh erimAe iMarcan ittaai o-ssAn aci on,ita 2011. Lectures & Papers: ³µ2XWRIWKH)XOOQHVVRI&RQWHPSODWLRQ¶ 7KH)DWHRI$TXLQDV¶,QQRYDWLRQVWRWKH&RQFHSWVRIWKHVita Contemplativa and the 9LWD $FWLYD´ For the 2010 South-Central Renaissance Conference. Exploring the Renaissance: An International Conference, Corpus Christi, TX , 18-20 March 2010. ³7KH$XWKRULW\RI:RPHQLQWKH&KXUFK $Q+LVWRULFDO3HUVSHFWLYH´.H\QRWH6SHHFKth Biennial General Assembly of the Galveston-Houston Archdiocesan Council of Catholic Women, St. Mary Church, La Porte, TX (April 24, 2010). ³&DWKHULQH RI 6LHQD¶V 9LVLRQ RI WKH /LIH-6DYLQJ %ULGJH´ for 3rd Annual Zambosco-Thomas Collo- quium: In Dialogue with St. Catherine of Siena & Florence Nightingale (February 22, 2011). ³7KRPDV$TXLQDVDQGWKH7ULXPSKRI³:RPDQO\¶&RXUDJH´)RUWKH0DU\7&ODUN&KDLURI&KULVWLDQ Philosophy Lecture, Manhattanville College, 07 April 2011. Professional Service: Elected to 3-year term on Executive Council, American Catholic Philosophical Association. Chaired sessions at Annual Meeting of the American Catholic Philosophical Association, Baltimore MD(5-7 November 2010), 4th International Medieval Congress, Kalamazoo, MI (12- 15 May 2011), Aquinas and the Arabs, Paris, France (19-20, 24 May 2011). External Reviewer on manuscript for Catholic University of America Press and on various promotion / tenure applications. CENTER STUDENTS § Dissertation Proposal Defenses: Jordan Olver, 12-Jul-10²Bonum Nostrum: The Necessary Will for Happiness and Love of Others (Dr. Jensen, Director, Dr. Hittinger and Dr. Houser) Sr. Anne Frances Ai Thuy Le, 24-Sep-10²Nudus Sequens?: St. Thomas Aquinas on Poverty and Christian Perfection (Dr. Sommers, Director, Dr. Martin and Dr. Osborne) Alexander Lynch, 8-Oct-10²5HDVRQ¶V5HODWLRQVKLSWRWKH3DVVLRQV(Dr. Houser, Director, Dr. Jen- sen and Dr. Martin) 'RPHQLF '¶(WWRUH, 7-Apr-11²Early Thomists on Demonstration with Analogous Terms (Dr. Os- borne, Director, Dr. Knasas and Dr. Sommers) Nelson, Ramirez, 9-May-11²&RQWHPSRUDU\ 7KRPLVWLF 3UREOHPV RQ $TXLQDV¶ 8QGHUVWDQGLQJ RI Truth (Dr. Knasas, Director, Dr. Houser and Dr. Jensen) Stephen Sparks, 9-May-11²The Indispensability of the Sign and the Scope of Semiosis: Exploring the Doctrinal Foundations of Semiotics, A Comparative Study of the Sign-Theory of John Poinsot and Charles S. Peirce (Dr. Deely, Director, Dr. Hittinger and Dr. Osborne) Congratulations to these successful candidates! § Dissertations in Progress: David Arias, Rediscovering Nature: an Expositional Defense of the Thomistic Reasoning to Substantial Form and First Matter per "viam motus" (Dr. Knasas, Director, Dr. Houser and Dr. Osborne) Casey Edler, Thomas Aquinas and the Kalam Cosmological Argument (Dr. Knasas, Director, Dr. Houser and Dr. Martin) Joseph Hattrup, 6XEVWDQFH DQG 3UHGLFDWLRQ LQ $ULVWRWOH¶V Categories and Metaphysics (Dr. Houser, Director, Dr. Martin and Dr. Osborne) Todd Konkel, Aquinas and De Ente et Essentia ch. 4 and the Real Distinction (Dr. Osborne, Director, Dr. Houser and Dr. Martin) Steven Pena, Onus Probandi: Ascertaining the Burden of Proof in Theistic Debate (Dr. Knasas, Direc- tor, Dr. Sommers, Dr. Martin) Aaron Somerville, Arguments for the Final End of Man in Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas (Dr. Os- borne, Director, Dr. Houser and Dr. Jensen) Scott Sullivan, Ex Nihilo Nihil Fit: A Defense of the Principle of Sufficient Reason (Dr. Knasas, Direc- tor, Dr. Houser and Dr. Martin) Jeffrey Zents, Abstractive Thomism and the Pyrrhonian Skeptical Tradition (Dr. Martin, Director, Dr. Knasas, Dr. Osborne) CONGRATULATIONS FOR THE FOLLOWING ACHIEVEMENTS § MA Degrees Awarded: May 2010: Daniel DeHaan, Jessica Jacobs August 2010: Lowell Davis December 2010: Geoffrey Meadows, Charles Robertson May 2011: John Macias August 2011: Phuc Luu § Successful completion of MA Comps: April 2010: Daniel DeHaan, Jessica Jacobs, Phuc Luu, Geoffrey Meadows, Charles Robertson April 2011: Heidi Bollich, John Boyer, John Macias § Successful completion of PhD Comps: $SULO 'RPHQLF'¶(WWRUH1DWKDQ3RDJH6WHSKHQ6SDUNV Studennt AActActc ivvitiess aandd AAAwwwarara ds DelianD§ DDelianD§ D. Haane viceer, ted Yhe arwArolaSchgounY d ffrrom the iermA ilhoatCcan osophliPhc lcaiosoph on iatssociA on aatt i s 84t th annu 5ngieetmalannu - meovN7 ber 0.201 LWVLXJQL/³UHSDSVL+ HUSS$FL QH6ODWQHGLFQ,VDQRLVQHK VQ DDWW ´VDQLXT$VDPRK7QLQRL EHKWHERWGHQLPUHWHGVDZ SWVHE DDSS UH ed taccep ed fforor esepr ntaattion aatt t conhe ffee encr bye schola ihtreundarschol rtrty-ffii e.v liwtI ll -pubbe hetn ihed sil ihed hetn roP ceeddiinggss hicw, sih eerpa -eewievr d ublip caatt ihTon.i heermsums blliwhe e atttt ng tngiend ytisernivUhe y f- niconssWio Madi rAson abiab c, iPersc, an, siurkTand Lh Laangnguagng euag tinstIon siermmI tinstIon ut (e Juneune 1J 1 - ustguA 2016, 1) aandnd th istihomTeh :nariSemc emTh eem is n tthhe ohilP sophhyy eetPof eacGr omThandheac uinaqAas s A( A- 7ustgu 20113, ehtegiE1) n eaduatrgn ed teclsee erws ntudest erws teclsee ed ffrr applixtysiongmamor canntts. Ts. 20he istihomT11 iSemc nar inar hets spoon hertWi spoon s sie'uttinstIspoon xtthh ann , w-wlua eek, intongl progviens, amamre for r g saduatr iudentte n phphs sophyolin lerand lerand aatted neipliscdied isemheTs. inar otdevs ted tngoriplexo ntihe itecsernt wetbon lanaeen ytytic oso-liphc phy and the AA-iletotsir aann istihomT artc n.oitdia Garol C§ C§ Garol kiosardG OHYH'³GHWQHVHUS K7JQLNQLK7ODFLWLU&JQLSRO KSRVROLK3IRHV8HKWKJXRUK Q(ODFLK QL\ULXT WWKK Z´PRRUVVDO&H \HNFLU7HYHW6U'KWLZ DDWW HKW HWQ,H UQDDWW QR&ODQRL IIHH RHFQHU NQLK7QR JQL DDWW \WLVUHYLQ8V¶QHHX4 OH%\ IIDD QRGQDOHU,WV -24 J ne, 20u24 11. nnASr. § nnASr. nn ceranFe LiAs .PO.e, US SDGHWQHVHU DDSS R+PRU)³ UH RU&SLKVGQHLU)RW\WLODWLSVR HKWJQLVVR DDWD´HSR+QLGORKVHUK7 W HKW nd MelannuA of tngiet th MexiewNe co ± TTtesW exa -iPhs helyteicSoalhicosopl dhel aatt exTPaso,lE M(as ar I1).201ch heon,itaddin eapere,rh paperp ³Contemmpp al ttaa iial radets errade T: llaClsaervinUhe tl ontemCo plaattion aandnd tI s ca-plimI HKWGHYLHFHU´VQRLW vY Rv S.es mi instIon tu At arwe ard fforor anutstO ding GGrara e StuStuatdu tdene PPaperaper aatt the 3 nnuA4th ngietMelonainatrnteIalnnu htof e iatiMarcaniermA n -aocissA onit , 14- Oct16 ober 2010. uuLc huP§ huP§ uuuuLc HVUXRFDJQLKFDHWHEOOLZ H+³H UPUP XGRUWQ,Q$VFLWXHQH \JRORHK7ODYHLGH0RWQRLWFX \ DDQQ LK3G ihyosopl iobraiNn enyenyK, hita enyKatermsums aptBa eglloCcaliogeolhTstiapt e. H -pube hed sil hed tthehe ffolol ng rentngiowl eir tnis he keraB HHandanddbobook ooff naienomD ti andon MMii stin strir es, .de, RH* UUJJ LUX.7H DDQQ UHND% VNRR%U IIRRUWUW JQLPRFK 0\OUDH PathanN§ eoagP connt ir buut erapthC(ed s- 11 20, 31- WVQ,HKWRW UX 0V¶URWFX DDQQ ODX IIRR D6\UQH+U V¶HU\D HHuu- manittii urtulC:es itonCe, nuittyy gehanCand sorPea( so 201n, 21 nd Ed.) earand d repapa ³³$$ DQQHFLY DDQQ RVDQLXT$G X6HKWQR EEMM 0WFH DDWWWWW WH0IRUH ´VFLV\KSDW DDWW VDQLXT$HKW DDQQ U$HKWGQ DDEE WHQLXT$¶GVDPRK7V U$VHFUXRVVHV DDEE QRFVH IIHH QHU WSH6QRWVXR+HFQ $ QLWFDUWVE$ he the ietlluB de iophoslphin alevedime ,10). 2/205 es rlhaC§ rlhaC§ es sonertobR ilpub ustugA"shed iust anne ciatVd oadeningrBA:IIan optionceCoadening n of tthehe Che hurrch?ch?" Studdii ritaPa stica v, ol 4-448, 31 435 hiT. ermsums he w blliw ngintesepre ugA"erpapa aniniustug istPrede naatt oi ann esiclcEd A:yogloesi ablactntrIn oblPre VXalnnidrequahetat?"meobl nteIIV rna-rna- on Calonit on ffee on Penr iratce Ocitsi rxfos, (d 8th ± 12th ugA 20ustug 11). en Steph§ Steph§ en sarkSp FLWRLPH6³GHKVLOEXS VF DDQQ PXKG DDQQ QDDWW WVRSQLHUX HGRPW UQUQ UHGLVQRF$ \WL DDWW QRL IR lamian umcitoisem GRPWVRSHKWVD HGQUHG ILIL QLHEQDPXKIRQRLWLQ ´JQ caiotiSem 201(I4.I/.1179 259:0)201 - 7 VFLWRLPHVRHK7³GQD IRQRLWF$HKWIR\GXW6HK7 ´VQJL6HQLYL'I itoiSem 200cs 8200 .eds, YewN(chiocrSband yeelD Y-YewN(chiocrSband ork AGEL, 9)200S: 66, PRK7FLWRLPH6³UHSDSVL+ HK7 PVLP HGRPWVR3 UQUQK7QLHGDUJS8 HWQHVHUS´WKJXRK7FLWVLPRK GH DDWW HKW teMealnnuA33rd ngit hetof iermA caann iatiarM i-isocsAn iat 20on, ctO22 0092. H, oustooust wXTn, darawas ted he Y .Rves GtitInsonSim etuaadrute Se Audt rdawent . § Alumu nnii Nottes e eserTSr. eserTSr. e OueA ..Pr, LDK& ¶'K3 DSH'VFLKWHRL%HKWIRUL UW WQHP 3QKR-HSR3IRW DDXX HU*HKWO DDWW KJL+ Dn ioolSch Dn umD ffrr VAesi w, delli, a 5ervil - HKWQRVNODWIRVHLUHV\DG ³D gnii ttyy ooff tthehe HHuum nosPeran ´ QL WKH e soceiD e off Ri ondchm tAV, Ashi. .tusug Markk Bark kkerer H5³GHWQHVHUS µ'K3 U$HKWJQLYHLUWH DDEE RVQLJLU2FL SHU3HKWIR DU K3IRQRLWD DDQQ PVDW ´VP DDWW QDVDQLXT$ G WWKK EDU$H VV777KK GVDPR ¶¶$$ QLXT VHEDUDVHFUXRVVHVWH Conffererenc ateenc U 11ST, - S beremept12 er 2010. on CuelSam on cdion SSSSSDQHHEVDK ¶'K3 RU3WQDWVLVV$GHWQLRS IIHH IRURVV \S \ IR\WLVUHYLQ8WD\KSRVROLK3I 0DU\ QL\ insgi beentmntpoi apsiH. D NNck,armsBi D apsiH. beentmntpoi insgi 2tsuguAn .011 Cony hntA Cony iasfriC KVLOEXSVDK ¶'K3 FVH'³GHK DU 6IRODVVLPVL'¶VHW VPUR)ODQRLWQHWQ,FLWVDORKF6 WDK: RK7GOXR: 6VDQLXT$VDP DD\\ ´" , HHii ts orryy ooff oslPhi ophhyy Q ertaru llyy, 28,2 ( liprA, 2011) 114 -158. ry Mae osR Mae ry LaydeHry onsmemn ¶'K3 GHKVLOEXSVDK UUll atmit Nore Norm veiat Founddatat The:onsi Case fforor H3¶VDQLXT$ WVLODQRVUH 11DD ZD/ODUXW QL[H/ RVODHK6 VNRR%QRWJQ QRVDH5ODFLWFDU3³GHKVLOEXSR X6Q IIIIIHH U X(GQDJQL HKWQL´DLQRPLDGX 200 ecePro9 ngsdie of f tthehe canierAm Catthhol Phiiol ciophoslc all Ass oniatoci on. n SmSmiamBenj htin KGHKVLOEXS µ'K3 SVLK DS DD\JRORHK7³GHOWLWQHUH Q GDH5$ VDQLXT$VDPRK7G HKWIRJQLG oRegne D oRegne ´HKWQL ngsdieecPro0102 of f ttheh canierAmhe Cattholhol Phii ophoslc oniatociAsscalioph . o Wd LereflA o WWd ethio GHKVLOEXS ¶$0 XJQD/QRLWSHFUH3³ DJ H DQG PUR)WSHFQR& DDWW RK7W6QLQRL QLVDPR WKH cePro0 201 cePro0 ngsdiece of f tthehe canierAm Catthhol Phiiol ciophoslc all Ass oniatoci on.