Harvard Theological Review

ANDOVER-HARVARD THEOLOGICAL LIBRARY M D C C C C X CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS

VOLUME VIII

ISSUED QUARTERLY BT

THE FACULTY OF DIVINITY IN HARVARD UNIVERSITY CAMBRIDGE, MASS.

CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS 1915

The Harvard Theological Review has been partially endowed by a bequest of the late Miss Mildred Everett, "for the establish- ment and maintenance of an undenominational theological review, to be edited under the direction of the Faculty of the Divinity School of Harvard University. ... I make this provision in order to carry out a plan suggested by my late father, the Rev. Charles Carroll Everett." During the continuance of The New World, Dr. Everett was on its editorial board, and many of his essays, now collected in the volume entitled Essays, Theological and Literary, appeared first in its pages. Sharing his belief in the value of such a theological review, and in devotion to his honored memory, the Faculty of the Harvard Divinity School, of which he was a member from 1869, and its Dean from 1878 until his death in 1900, has accepted the trust, and will strive to make the Review a worthy memorial of his comprehensive thought and catholic spirit.

The Review is edited by a committee of the Faculty of the Harvard Divinity School consisting of Professors William W. Fenn, Kirsopp Lake, Frederic Palmer, and James H. Ropes.

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.234, on 29 Sep 2021 at 17:56:59, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0017816000008270 Volume VIII Number 1 CONTENTS FOR JANUARY, 1915 THE MODERN MISSIONARY James L. Barton 1 THE PROTESTANT MISSIONARY PROPAGANDA IN INDIA . . J. P. Jones 18 IMMORTALITY Howard N. Brown 45 THE RUSSIAN DOUKHOBORS AND THEIR RELIGIOUS TEACHINGS Aurelio Palmieri 62 EXCAVATIONS IN PERSIA John P. Peters 82 AFTER SIX DAYS: A NEW CLUE FOR GOSPEL CRITICS Benjamin W. Bacon 94 REVIEWS AND NOTICES 122

Volume VIII Number 2 CONTENTS FOR APRIL, 1915 MYSTICISM IN PRESENT,?Il*xJi4BLrGioN Rufus M. Jones 155 "TWE~ ETHICAL VALUE OF ORIENTAL RELIGIONS UNDER THE ROMAN EMPIRE Clifford Herschel Moore 166 THE ATONEMENT AND THE MODERN PULPIT . William F. Lofthouse 182 RELIGIOUS RESERVE Edward F. Hayward 205 THE CONTRIBUTION OF PROFESSOR ROYCE TO CHRISTIAN THOUGHT John Wright Buckham 219 SIR OLIVER LODGE'S BRITISH ASSOCIATION ADDRESS Edwin H. Hall 238 REVIEWS AND NOTICES 252

Volume VIII Number 3 CONTENTS FOR JULY, 1915 JOHANNES WEISS: IN MEMORIAM F. Crawford Burkitt 291 THE PERMANENT SIGNIFICANCE OF MIRACLE FOR RELIGION William Adams Brown 298 THE FUNCTION OF THE EDUCATED AND OF THE LTNEDUCATED MINISTRY Francis J. McConnell 323 EVOLUTION AND THE OTHER WORLD Paul Elmer More 339 THREE NOTABLE DREAMS George Batchelor 357 RECENT CHURCH UNION MOVEMENTS IN CANADA Daniel James Fraser 363 WHAT AILS THE CHURCH ? Thomas N. Carver 379 REVIEWS AND NOTICES 400

Volume VIII Number 4 CONTENTS FOR OCTOBER, 1915 THE POSITION AND PROSPECTS OF THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH Alfred Fawkes 439 THE CONFLICT OF MORAL OBLIGATION IN THE TRILOGY OF ^ESCHYLUS Benjamin Apthorp Gould Fuller 459 FRA SALIMBENE AND THE FRANCISCAN IDEAL . . . Ephraim Emerton 480 REFLECTIONS OF RITUAL IN PAUL Benjamin W. Bacon 504 RECENT EXCAVATION AND EXPLORATION IN PALESTINE George L. Robinson 525 REVIEWS AND NOTICES 553

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.234, on 29 Sep 2021 at 17:56:59, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0017816000008270 INDEX OF AUTHORS BACON, BENJAMIN W. . . After Six Days: A New Clue for Gospel Critics . 94 Reflections of Ritual in Paul 504 BARTON, JAMES L. . . . The Modern Missionary 1 BATCHELOR, GEORGE . . Three Notable Dreams 357 BROWN, HOWARD N. . . Immortality 45 BROWN, WILLIAM A. . . The Permanent Significance of Miracle for Re- ligion 298 BUCKHAM, JOHN W. . . The Contribution of Professor Royce to Chris- tian Thought 219 BUHKITT, F. CRAWFORD . Johannes Weiss: In Memoriam 291

CARVER, THOMAS N. . . What Ails the Church? 379

EMERTON, EPHRAIM . . . Fra Salimbene and the Franciscan Ideal . . . 480

FAWKES, ALFRED .... The Position and Prospects of the Roman Cath- olic Church 439 FRASER, DANIEL J. . . . Recent Church Union Movements in Canada . 363 FULLER, BENJAMIN A. G. . The Conflict of Moral Obligation in the Trilogy of ^Eschylus 459

HALL, EDWIN H Sir Oliver Lodge's British Association Address . 23S HATWARD, EDWARD F. . Religious Reserve 205

JONES, J. P The Protestant Missionary Propaganda in India 18 JONES, RUFUS M. . . . Mysticism in Present-Day Religion 155

LOFTHOTJSE, WILLIAM F. . The Atonement and the Modern Pulpit . . . 182

MCCONNELL, FRANCIS J. . The Function of the Educated and of the Un- educated Ministry 323 MOORE, CLIFFORD H. . . The Ethical Value of Oriental Religions under the Roman Empire 166 MOBE, PAUL E Evolution and the Other World 339

PALMIERI, AURELIO . . . The Russian Doukhobors and their Religious Teachings 62 PETERS, JOHN P Excavations in Persia 82

ROBINSON, GEORGE L. . Recent Excavation and Exploration in Pales- tine 525

JANUARY, 1915

THE MODERN MISSIONARY James L. Barton 1 THE PROTESTANT MISSIONARY PROPAGANDA IN INDIA J. P. Jones 18 IMMORTALITY Howard N. Brown 45 THE RUSSIAN DOUKHOBORS AND THEIR RELIGIOUS TEACHINGS Aurelio Palmier I 62 EXCAVATIONS IN PERSIA John P. Peters 82 AFTER SIX DAYS: A NEW CLUE FOB GOSPEL CRITICS Benjamin W. Bacon 94 REVIEWS AND NOTICES 122

CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS

LONDON: HUMPHREY MILFORD OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS 1915 Issued Quarterly. $2.00 a Year. 50 cents a Copy. Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.35.234, on 29 Sep 2021 at 17:56:59, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0017816000008270 REVIEWS Books on the Old Testament and the Apocrypha:— GEORGE BUCHANAN GRAY. A Critical Introduction to the Old Testa- ment. GEORGE FOOT MOORE. The Literature of the Old Testament. HOMER B. SPRAGUE. The Book of Job. Le Liere du Prophete Amos. Max Kellner. H. A. W. METER and H. H. WENDT. Die Apostelgeschichte. Kritisch- exegetischer Kommentar iiber das Neue Testament. 3. E. Frame. K. F. PROOST. Die Bergrede. Hare Herkormt en Strekking. G. F. Moore. ALEXANDER NAIRNE. The Epistle of Priesthood: Studies in the Epistle to the Hebrews. E. F. Scott. CRAIG S. THOMS. The Workingman's Christ. Charles P. Fagnani. CHARLES AUGUSTUS BRIGGS. Theological Symbolics. Albert Temple Swing. ERNST VON DOBSCHUTZ. The Influence of the Bible on Civilization. George E. Horr. W. E. SooTHiLL. The Three Religions of China. George F. Moore. EDOUARD LEROY. The New Philosophy of Henri Bergson. Ralph Barton Perry. GEORGE ROWLAND DODSON. Bergson and the Modern Spirit: An Essay in Constructwe Thought. Ralph Barton Perry. W. B. SELBIE. Schleiermacher: A Critical and Historical Study. William Adams Brown. FREDRICH VON HUGEL. Eternal Life: A Study of its Implications and Ap- plications. Charles F. Dole. ELWOOD WORCESTER. Religion and Life. Frederic Palmer. BENJAMIN W. BACON. Theodore Thornton Munger: New England Minister. HENRY C. VEDDER. The Reformation in Germany. Preserved Smith. G. B. TATHAM. The Puritans in Power. A Study in the History of the Eng- lish Church from 1640 to 1660. Henry B. Washburn. W. B. SELBIE. English Sects. A History of Nonconformity. Williston Walker. WASHINGTON GLADDEN. Present Day Theology. W. W. Fenn. S. HERBERT. The First Principles of Evolution. Herbert V. Neal. JOHN BROWNLIE. Hymns of the Early Church. Henry Wilder Foote. WILLIAM DE WITT HYDE. The Quest of the Best. George T. Smart.