On the Development of Greek Historiography and the Plan for a New Collection of the Fragments of the Greek Historians
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK HISTORIOGRAPHY AND THE PLAN FOR A NEW COLLECTION OF THE FRAGMENTS OF THE GREEK HISTORIANS HISTOS The Online Journal of Ancient Historiography Edited by Christopher Krebs and †John Moles Histos Supplements Supervisory Editor: John Marincola *. Antony Erich Raubitschek, Autobiography of Antony Erich Raubitschek . Edited with Introduction and Notes by Donald Lateiner (01*2). 0. A. J. Woodman, Lost Histories: Selected Fragments of Roman Historical Writers (01*5). 6. Felix Jacoby, On the Development of Greek Historiography and the Plan for a New Collection of the Fragments of the Greek Historians . Translated by Mortimer Chambers and Stefan Schorn (01*5). ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF GREEK HISTORIOGRAPHY AND THE PLAN FOR A NEW COLLECTION OF THE FRAGMENTS OF THE GREEK HISTORIANS FELIX JACOBY THE *;5< TEXT WITH THE EDITORIAL ADDITIONS OF HERBERT BLOCH TRANSLATED BY MORTIMER CHAMBERS A N D STEFAN SCHORN HISTOS SUPPLEMENT 6 NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE 0 1 * 5 Published by H I S T O S School of History, Classics and Archaeology, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE* ?RU, United Kingdom ISSN (Online): 012<-5;<6 (Print): 012<-5;55 ‘ÜBER DIE ENTWICKLUNG DER GRIECHISCHEN HISTORIOGRAPHIE UND DEN PLAN EINER NEUEN SAMMLUNG DER GRIECHISCHEN HISTORIKER- FRAGMENTE’, IN F. JACOBY, ABHANDLUNGEN ZUR GRIECHISCHEN GESCHICHTSCHREIBUNG , HERAUSGEGEBEN VON HERBERT BLOCH COPYRIGHT © *;5< E. J. BRILL, LEIDEN, THE NETHERLANDS ENGLISH TRANSLATION COPYRIGHT © 01*5 MORTIMER CHAMBERS AND STEFAN SCHORN TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface ………………….……………………………… vii Abbreviations ……………………………………………ix On the Development of Greek Historiography and the Plan for a New Collection of the Fragments of the Greek Historians ……………..….………………….… * Bibliography ………….......………………………….….. ?6 Index ……………………………………………………?; PREFACE his translation of Felix Jacoby’s paper on the development of Greek historical writing (‘Über die TEntwicklung der griechischen Historiographie und den Plan einer neuen Sammlung der griechischen Historikerfragmente’), probably the most important discussion of this question in the twentieth century, is based on the essay as edited by Professor Herbert Bloch in his selection of Jacoby’s essays and reviews, in F. Jacoby, Abhandlungen zur griechischen Geschichtschreibung, ed. H. Bloch (Leiden, Brill, *+,-), *-–-/. In editing the essay Professor Bloch included references to other writings by Jacoby, especially in his multi-volume Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker (Berlin–Leiden, *+2/-,3), cited as FGrHist , his Atthis: The Local Chronicles of Ancient Athens (Oxford, *+5+), cited as Atthis , and his articles in Pauly’s Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft (Stuttgart, *3+5–*+36), cited as RE . Professor Bloch’s additions are normally placed within square brackets; he also cited later writings in his ‘Anhang vom Herausgeber’, Abhandlungen , 52/–-. These are often references to historians whose remains have been gathered up in FGrHist or articles in RE . Sometimes it was necessary to include them in the main text, which may disturb some readers, in order not to change the numbering of the footnotes. The page numbers in the right-hand margins are those of this essay as it appeared in the Abhandlungen . We have also benefited from Leone Porciani’s ‘aggiornamento bibliografico’ in Aspetti dell’opera di Felix Jacoby , ed. C. Ampolo (Pisa, 266-) 55,–,,, which assisted us in assigning numbers (in square brackets at the time of their first mention in the essay) to the many authors who had not been assigned their numbers within FGrHist when Jacoby published this article in *+6+. We did not, however, include viii Felix Jacoby his references to collections of fragments published after Jacoby except for references to FGrHist Continued . To assist readers who may not know Greek, we have usually given brief translations of Greek names and terms within square brackets. In the transliteration of Greek words and names, we have sometimes used forms familiar in English (Herodotus, Thucydides, Aristotle) but have usually followed Jacoby’s spelling (Hekataios, Hellanikos), which is closer to the original Greek. For the titles of works ending in –ka we have chosen to transliterate the title itself rather than insert a translation; the reader should be aware that this neuter plural suffix is equivalent to ‘things’ or ‘matters’, so that a term such as Makedonika will mean something like ‘Macedonian matters’ or ‘Macedonian affairs’. English translations in the text are by A. de Sélincourt– J. Marincola (Harmondsworth, 266/) for Herodotus; by C. F. Smith in the Loeb Classical Library (London and Cambridge, Mass., *+23–/6) for Thucydides, and by C. H. Oldfather, also of the Loeb Classical Library, volume * (London and Cambridge, Mass., *+//) for Diodorus. We are grateful to Brill Publishers and Jennifer Pavelko, Senior Acquisitions Editor for Classical Studies and Philosophy, for permission to use the original German text of this essay. We thank Professors Stanley Burstein (Los Angeles), John Marincola (Tallahassee), and Guido Schepens (Leuven) for reading, and often improving, our translation. We also thank Alexander Skufca of Florida State University for compiling the Index, and the Histos team for their help in bringing this translation to a wider audience. We take full responsibility for any remaining errors or infelicities. MORTIMER CHAMBERS STEFAN SCHORN 2- October 26*, ix ABBREVIATIONS Abhandlungen F. Jacoby, Abhandlungen zur griechischen Geschichtschreibung , ed. H. Bloch (Leiden, *+,-). Atthis F. Jacoby, Atthis: The Local Chronicles of Ancient Athens (Oxford, *+5+). FGrHist F. Jacoby, Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker , *, vols. in / parts (Berlin and Leiden, *+2/–,3). FHG C. and Th. Müller, Fragmenta Historicorum Graecorum , , vols. (Paris, *35*–C6). RE A. Pauly, G. Wissowa and W. Kroll, Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertums- wissenschaften (Stuttgart, *3+5–*+C3). On the Development of Greek Historiography and the Plan for a New Collection of the Fragments of ∗ the Greek Historians The Müller Collection (9 he need for a new collection of the fragments of the Greek historians requires no special explanation. TAnyone who is compelled to work long with Müller’s five volumes—even with all approval for the creator of a useful and until now indispensable resource—will have complained often enough about the lack of independence, the failure of criticism, and the incompleteness of the collection; perhaps even more often, about the inconvenient, at many times absolutely arbitrary order of the fragments and the authors. Even if one disregards the first volume and forgives the combining, in a totally illogical way, of historians of different types and of various times as a consequence of external necessities, one will still be unable to judge the organisation favourably: the chronological ∗ Klio & ((&)&) +)–(-.. Lecture, delivered + August [(&)+], to the International Congress for Historical Sciences [Berlin]. I have retained the form of the lecture, but here I offer my complete manuscript, which because of the limits of time in the meeting I could deliver only in selection and often severely shortened. I have occasionally expanded the notes; I have done the same to one section of the text, on which the discussion after the lecture especially concentrated (see below, pp. 78ff.). Hekataios [FGrHist (]; a horographer (Charon) [ FGrHist -9-]; an ethnographer (Xanthos) [ FGrHist ;98]; three genealogists (with Hellanikos [FGrHist 7, .-.a, 9)(a, 978a, 9+;a], as the first of them!) [Pherekydes, FGrHist .; Akusilaos, FGrHist -]; and a late mythographic compilation [the Bibliotheca of Apollodoros]; three books about the history of Sicily [Antiochos, FGrHist 888; Philistos, FGrHist 889; Timaios, FGrHist 899]; three Ἑλληνικά [Hellēnika ]: Ephoros, FGrHist ;); Theopompos, FGrHist ((8; Phylarchos, FGrHist +(]; Atthidographers [FGrHist .-.; .-8; .-7; .-;; .-+; ..7]. And to conclude the chaos, as an appendix the Marmor Parium [FGrHist -.&] and the Rosetta Stone. - Felix Jacoby boundaries of the separate books are not useful and are usually wrongly determined; the ordering of the authors is often arbitrary and breaks up the principle of arrangement or is simply erroneous, as for example when Asklepiades of Tragilos [ FGrHist (-] appears among five namesakes in Book 9, which contains the writers ‘from the fall of Corinth to Caesar Augustus’; or when Euphantos of Olynthos [FGrHist ;7] is placed in the epoch, itself poorly chosen, -7;–(79 BC . Anyone who wants to read the writers about (; Persia will find most of them in Volume II, but in various places [ FGrHist 9+)–9&9]; one is in Volume IV (Baton of Sinope [ FGrHist -9+]); Ktesias [ FGrHist 9++] is wholly missing: one must seek him out in a strange union with Eratosthenes [ FGrHist -7(] in the appendix to another publication. And again, the historians of Alexander are in yet another, as if they did not belong to the historians at all. The Principle of a New Collection For me, who for many years have been at work on the collecting and re-editing of the fragments of the historians, and who because of the size of the project will still be long engaged on it before publication can be considered, the question naturally arose as I was beginning to collect the material: how could one finally group in a clear and scientific manner the profusion of names, which often in effect are only names? To discover a principle that would unite these two virtues appeared to me, even more clearly the longer I considered