Performance and Performativity in Pastoral Fulbe Culture
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Helsingin yliopiston digitaalinen arkisto Tea Virtanen PERFORMANCE AND PERFORMATIVITY IN PASTORAL FULBE CULTURE Research Series in Anthropology University of Helsinki Academic Dissertation Research Series in Anthropology University of Helsinki, Finland Distributed by: Helsinki University Press PO Box 4 (Vuorikatu 3A) 00014 University of Helsinki Finland Fax: + 358-9-70102374 www.yliopistopaino.helsinki.fi Copyright © 2003 Tea Virtanen ISSN 1458-3186 ISBN (print.) 952-10-1397-4 ISBN (pdf) 952-10-1398-2 http://ethesis.helsinki.fi Helsinki University Printing House Helsinki 2003 To the Memory of Alhaji Kongoro Each world whilst it is attended to is real after its own fashion. William James CONTENTS List of Illustrations vii Acknowledgements viii 1. Introduction 1 Shifting Perspectives 1 Gathering Information 7 From Cultural Performances towards the Performativity of Culture 10 Outline 23 2. Pulaaku: Performed or Embodied Culture? 25 Pulaaku, Performance and Shame 27 Pulaaku as Cultural Competence 31 Sharing Shame and Ideals 34 “Is Your Body Well?”: Pulaaku in Greetings 36 On How the Fulbe Greet 37 Greeting as a Model for Smooth Interaction 40 Reframing the Greeting Performance 42 3. People of the Blessed Cattle 48 Nomads, Jihad and the Process of Sedentarisation 48 Fulbe Routes to Cameroon 50 The Formation of Muslim Fulbe Chiefdoms in Adamawa 51 The Migration of the Cattle Fulbe to Cameroon 58 Tibati: Excursion into Local History 63 Later Arrivals: The Aku Wave of the 1970s 70 The Blessed Cattle 81 iv Contents 4. Recollecting Nigeria: Myth and History in the Present 85 Reshaping the Origins 85 “We Come after Arabs” 86 From Town to Bush 90 Creation of the Cattle 92 Myths and Islam in Adamaoua 96 Performing a Mythical History 99 Recollecting Nigeria 101 The Unspoken Pre-Muslim Past 102 The Two Landscapes 106 From Soro to Manslaughter: Cameroon and the Undisciplined Youth 113 Change and Continuity in Campsites 121 History in the Present 126 5. Schemes for Mobile Living 130 Culture on the Move 130 How to Do Things with Verbs 134 Nomads in the Hijju 137 6. Schemes for Lifetimes 145 Relating to Others through Hakkiilo 145 Young Lives 149 The Message of the Firstborn 154 Koggal of Faadi 154 Coming for the Bride 158 Celebrating the Firstborn 161 Displaying the Wealth of the New Mother: Bantal 169 Starting a Household: Defol 174 Married Men, Married Women 178 Mature Lives 181 From Autonomy to Social Personhood 187 7. Co-Wives through Milk: Gender and Pulaaku in Everyday Life 189 Gender, Generation and Shame 189 Milk and Money in Motion 198 Seclusion of Women: Puzzling Dependencies 214 Living up to Ideals 219 v Contents 8. “Our People”: Perceiving and Performing Relatedness 222 The Rhetorics of “Our Lineage” 223 Performing Patrikin 226 Maternal Connections 232 DenDiraagu: Relating through Play 237 Framing Relations in Everyday Life 239 The Limits of Respectable Relatedness 242 From Difference to Unity 246 9. Conclusion 249 Glossary 254 Bibliography 258 Name Index 268 vi LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Maps 1 Location of the Adamaoua Province and the Djerem Department in the Republic of Cameroon. 5 2 Migration route of Gaani. 75 3 Migration routes of Iisa and Hajara. 80 Figures 1 Kinship relations between Saani’s and Nayeeri’s people. 231 Photographs 1 A pastoral Fulbe camp after the harvest, the hut of the camp leader in the middle. 7 2 A pastoralist man milking a white daneeji cow, his son and a herder keeping him company. 83 3 Women’s huts in a dry season camp. 124 4 Pastoral Fulbe men and women gathered for a communal prayer led by a Hausa mallum at the end of Ramadan. 141 5 Bantal. A kinswoman showing the male representatives of the husband the objects that has been bought for the young wife. 172 6 A woman's wealth that has been displayed in her new hut for the defol ritual. 174 7 Milk-sellers on their way to the market. 200 8 Paternal half brothers visiting the Friday market of Tibati. 228 9 Joy of sakiikeeku. A pastoralist girl (right) carrying the baby of her older sister (left) during a visit. 236 All photographs by Tea Virtanen vii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS In the course of writing this book, as well as during the process of collecting material for it, I have received support and guidance from many people and institutions. Professor Karen Armstrong has followed this project throughout all of its stages; I thank her for patient and thorough supervision of my dissertation, as well as for visiting me at my field site in Cameroon. In addition, I am grateful to her for constantly helping me to write “proper” English. Professor Jukka Siikala’s encouragement was crucial in my decision to continue anthropological studies after my graduate thesis. He has been my mentor all these years; I thank him for his anthropological wisdom and inspiration. I am also grateful to Professor Siikala for his insightful comments as a preliminary examiner of my dissertation. I thank Professor Philip Burnham, my other preliminary examiner, for careful reading of my work. His critical comments, based on his regional expertise in my research area, were of great value at the phase of revising the dissertation manuscript. In the process of writing my dissertation, I have received valuable support and comments from several colleagues. In 1998 I participated in two seminars that gave me fresh perspectives on my work. I thank Mette Bovin for inviting me to a seminar organised by the Nordic Africa Institute, Crisis and Culture in Africa – with Special Emphasis on Pastoral Nomads and Farmers in the West African Sahel, in Uppsala, Sweden, where I had a welcomed opportunity to exchange ideas with other scholars doing research on the Fulbe. I thank Barbara Cooper for offering me an opportunity to attend a panel focusing on African pilgrims at the annual meeting of the African Studies Association, in Chicago, the United States, which encouraged me to discuss the theme of pilgrimage in my dissertation. I also want to thank Adeline Masquelier, Mirjam de Bruijn and Mariane Ferme for their comments on drafts and papers that I have presented in these seminars and elsewhere. I want to thank the members of the research community in Finland. I am grateful to Professor Matti Sarmela for his positive attitude towards my dissertation project, and to Professor Marja-Liisa Swantz for paving the way for all Finnish anthropologists doing research on Africa. I thank Timo Kaartinen and Tuulikki Pietilä who have read and commented on various seminar papers related to my dissertation. Special thanks go to Anna-Maria Tapaninen who has been an inspiring colleague, as well as a warm-hearted neighbour. I am indebted also to many others – teachers, researchers, viii Acknowledgements graduate students and secretaries – in Social and Cultural Anthropology at the University of Helsinki for their collective support through all these years; writing this study could hardly have been possible without this support. I also want to thank the staff of the Department of Finnish and Cultural Research at the University of Joensuu for their understanding attitude as I struggled with revising and editing the final manuscript. Warm thanks go to Professor Erkki Sevänen who kindly provided me with the needed facilities for bringing this project to an end. Tero Koistinen helped me with compiling this book, and Varpu Heiskanen assisted in converting illustrations into printable form; I am grateful to both of them. I thank Kaisu Kortelainen and Matleena Pekkanen for giving a helping hand whenever I needed it. My dissertation project was mainly funded by the Academy of Finland in 1994-1997 as part of the project Changing Gender Relations in Three African Communities directed by Professor Karen Armstrong. Additional funding was provided by the Graduate School of Anthropological and Ethnological Sciences, University of Helsinki, in 1997-1999. I also received a travel scholarship for a field trip to Cameroon in 1998 from the Scandinavian Institute of African Studies. In Cameroon I was privileged to have the opportunity to co-operate with many helpful people. I thank the staff of the Ministry of Scientific and Technical Research in Yaounde, especially Dr. Jean Blaise Nyobe, the research director, for providing me with a research permit in Cameroon. I thank the staff of Ngaoundere-Anthropos, a Cameroonian-Norwegian research program, for helping me with practical arrangements, and for inviting me to three of their seminars on cultures of the Adamaoua region, organised in Ngaoundere, Cameroon, in 1994-1995. Special thanks go to Professor Lisbeth Holtedahl and Mohammadou Djingui for their interest in my research project; their moral support was important in the course of my fieldwork. I am also grateful to Professor Saibou Nassourou, as well as to Professor Jean Louis Dongmo who was my Cameroonian supervisor during my fieldwork. I have also received help from several research assistants. I thank Magali Robert whose sad and untimely death I heard about while writing these lines. Mr. Robert, together with Tibiyea Philippe and Ngnandal Edouard, consulted materials stored in the National Archives in Yaounde for me; I am grateful for their valuable work. In addition, I thank Tibiyea Philippe for recording and transcribing part of the interviews, as well as for making me and my son feel at home in Cameroon. Ismaila Saidu, besides recording a few of the interviews, was my Fulfulde teacher; I thank him for his inspiring language lessons. I also appreciate the practical help of Miia Laurila at the preparatory phase of my fieldwork. ix Acknowledgements I have enjoyed people’s hospitality during my stay in Cameroon.