Note to Users Um I

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Note to Users Um I NOTE TO USERS This reproduction is the best copy available. UMI Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. "THE NEGRO IN AMERICAN FICTION" A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL of the UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI in candidacy for THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHT by THOMAS WARRINGTON GOSLING ?0. |CM April, 1911 Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. UMI Number: DP16691 INFORMATION TO USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and photographs, print bleed-through, substandard margins, and improper alignment can adversely affect reproduction. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. UMI Microform DP16691 Copyright 2009 by ProQuest LLC All rights reserved. This microform edition is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. PREFACE The purpose of. this study is to explain the use which American writers of fiction have madd of the negro. Whether their portrayal of him is true or false, it is not the province of a purely literary study to determine. Nor is it necessary to consider the so-called race problem except as that problem is discussed in these -works of fiction. Consequently the aim has been to arrange and classify the material which many writers have presented, rather than to establish with regard to it any theory or thesis. To be sure, in the process of classification some sequence has been discovered out of which a theory natural­ ly grows. Hypothesis, however, has been the result of the work and not its aim. Since free quotation appeared to be the most, effective means of accomplishing the purpose of exposition, wherever it was possible;authors have been permitted to speak for themselves. Finally, this study, it should be understood, is concerned primarily with the negro himself a3 represented in American fic­ tion and not with the literary value of individual works that exhibit him. No attempt, therefore, has here been made to write a history or a criticism of the fiction devoted to this character, Thomas Warrington Gosling, April 13, 1911. „ f ? n 1 7 Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Chapter I. The Negro in America. "L .2 In 1619 a Dutch man-of-war that was out of provisions sailed into the James River, Virginia, to replenish its Btores. As the captain had no other way of paying for the supplies which he secured from the settlers, he offered twenty negro slaves, who were unwillingly accepted. The captain of that vessel did not regard himself as a maker of history. He was merely engaged in a plain business transaction, and doubtless like many others befors and since hs thought that the demands of trade were of more importance than the claims of humanity. Slavery itself'is of great antiquity. Every age and almost every nation have known its curse; and even in America, negro slaves had been found before 1619. The records of the early Spanish explorers show that some of the great Spanish commanders had carried such slaves on their voyages of dis­ covery. As an institution, however, slavery in America dates from the year 1619. The landing.of that band of twenty in 1. George Bancroft: Hist of U.S. 1874, Vol. 1, pp. 176-7. Bancroft gives the date as August, 1620. Some other authorities give the date as 1618, 2. Some authorities think the slaves were brought by a trading vessel, "The Treasurer." Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Virginia occurred but twelve years after the settlement of Jamestown and but one year before the coming of the Pilgrims to Plymouth. The growth of slavery wa3 not rapid at first. The earliest American 3lave-ship, The Desire, was fitted out at Salem, Massachusetts, in 16136. Thus, by the irony of fate this town, the home of freedom, became a sharer in the in- quity of human bondage. By the year 1649 there were only three hundred slaves in Virginia; in 1714 these had increased to but twenty-three thousand. In 1756, however, there were one hundredi and twenty-thousand in Virginia and fifty-two thousand 1 • more in the other colonies including Hew England. At the open­ ing of the Revolutionary Nar it was estimated that there 'were approximately five hundred thousand negroes in the colonies. Some of them were free. From the first, the laws governing the conduct of slaves were severe. No slave could bear arms without a special license. No slave' could leave hi3 master’s plantation without a permit, and then only -for a short time. A slave wtio resisted hi3 master might be hilled with impunity. The laws against intermarriage of the races were of the most rigorous nature. It is said in defense of the early colonists that their practise was not so harsh as their laws might imply. The indentured white ser­ vants — many of them debtors or criminals from England — were subjected to severe treatment, also, and in many respite* TT Thomas Nelson ?agT: The Old South, pp. 103-1. Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. slaves. The negroes and the white indentured servants were distinguished in the conventional description as "slaves for life, and servants for a time." The lot of both classes was undoubtedly a hard one. Beverley^'however, in his History of Virginia say3:- "I can assure you with great Truth, that gen­ erally their Slaves are not worked near so hard, nor so many Hours in a Day, a3 the Husbandmen, and Day-labourers in England." After Virginia the various colonies in turn recognised the ownership of slaves. The first to follow the example of Vir­ ginia was the Hew Netherlands (Hew York), where "as early a3 1628 the irascible 3lavs3 from Angola, Africa, were the fruitful 3. source of widespread public alarm." 1 Under the Dutch rule the slaves of New Netherlands were treated quite mildly and many were set free. ’ When the English assumed the government in 1664, the law3 against slaves began to take on greater severity. The i records 3how various enactments which indicate a growing fear of the negro and a strengthening resolve to protect white society from the dangers of an uprising of the slaves. In 1741 by an unhappy coincidence of circumstances and by the criminal purposes of conniving whites, the people of New York were led to believe that the negroes had formed a plot to destroy the city. In the course of the excitement several lT" Robert Beverley: The History of Virginia; 2nd edition,- 1722, p. 236. j ^ 2. G. W. Williams: History of the Negro Race in America; 1883, Vol. 1, p. 134. Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. innocent negroes were condemned to death and were burned at 1 .. the stake, Thu3 the "Negro Plot of 1741" has gone down 'into history a3 another example of a nervous public imagination which creates- conditions that do not exist and which vents, itself upon innocent victims. A3 early as 1G33- there were negroes in Massachusetts, and presumably they were slaves. In 1637, the first 3rear of the Pequod War, the colonists began to import slaves from Barbadoes in exchange for Indian captives* because it was found the Indians would not endure servitude. From this time forward the number of slaves began to increase, tho there were never so many in Massa­ chusetts as in the Southern colonies. The 3oil and climate j' of Massachusetts were not of a nature to make slavery as an ■ institution very profitable. As in New York, so in Massachusetts the laws governing slaves were numerous and severe. The fight against slavery in the colony was long continued and bitter. In fact, in the middle of the eighteenth century there wa3 a well- defined abolition movement which doubtless- would have succeeded but for the opposition of Governor Gage and Governor Hutchinson. ’ The movement wa3 just about to accomplish its purpose when the Revolutionary War broke out and diverted the energies of all to other channels. It seems likely that negroes were held as slaves in 1. G. W. Williams: op cit. Vol. 1, p. 144. Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. 7 l. Maryland from the founding of the colony in 1630. In no otha: Southern colony except South Carolina were the laws governing 2. the slaves bo severe as in Maryland. The fact that many con­ victs, - perhaps as many as six hundred a year, - were imported into the colony, tended to break down conventional standards of conduct. Consequently there was a rather free mingling of the i negroes and the white indentured servants, or convicts, on terms * of social equality. Maryland, a3 a consequence, had a consider­ able population of raulattoes. / New Jersey stands conspicuous as the only colony which allowed negroes a trial by jury. An act of the legislature of East Jersey, passed in 1694, provided for the trial of "negroes and other slaves, for felonies punishable-with death, by a jury of twelve persons before three justices of the peace; for theft, 3.
Recommended publications
  • On Sunday 18 August 1940 the Luftwaffe Launched
    On Sunday 18th August 1940 the Luftwaffe launched three major air assaults against targets in Southern England. Kenley was one of those targets and the recollections of those on duty on the airfield, the pilots, and those living in the surrounding area are still vivid. 905328 AC2 Charles Gale was on ambulance duty and was sitting in the ambulance with the driver when they heard aircraft approaching. “Getting down from the vehicle we saw eight aircraft flying low in line abreast coming towards us. We saw the bombs begin to drop and ran quickly away from the ambulance and flung ourselves to the ground, as we did so the ambulance received a direct hit and was blown to pieces.” “As we got up it seemed as though the whole of the station was on fire. Hangars and buildings were burning and the noise of the barrage that the Kenley defences were putting up was terrific. We did notice that some of the raiding planes had been hit.” There was a three-ton lorry parked nearby so they got its started and drove round the airfield to seek out casualties. They picked up two wounded and some others who were in a state of shock from the blast and set off to find medical attention. “We drove them to Sick Quarters but when we got there we found that the building had been bombed and was on fire. The Duty Medical Officer, Flt Lt Cromie of 615 Sqn. had been killed by a bomb whilst standing in the doorway of the Sick Quarters shelter.
    [Show full text]
  • Shelf List 05/31/2011 Matches 4631
    Shelf List 05/31/2011 Matches 4631 Call# Title Author Subject 000.1 WARBIRD MUSEUMS OF THE WORLD EDITORS OF AIR COMBAT MAG WAR MUSEUMS OF THE WORLD IN MAGAZINE FORM 000.10 FLEET AIR ARM MUSEUM, THE THE FLEET AIR ARM MUSEUM YEOVIL, ENGLAND 000.11 GUIDE TO OVER 900 AIRCRAFT MUSEUMS USA & BLAUGHER, MICHAEL A. EDITOR GUIDE TO AIRCRAFT MUSEUMS CANADA 24TH EDITION 000.2 Museum and Display Aircraft of the World Muth, Stephen Museums 000.3 AIRCRAFT ENGINES IN MUSEUMS AROUND THE US SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION LIST OF MUSEUMS THROUGH OUT THE WORLD WORLD AND PLANES IN THEIR COLLECTION OUT OF DATE 000.4 GREAT AIRCRAFT COLLECTIONS OF THE WORLD OGDEN, BOB MUSEUMS 000.5 VETERAN AND VINTAGE AIRCRAFT HUNT, LESLIE LIST OF COLLECTIONS LOCATION AND AIRPLANES IN THE COLLECTIONS SOMEWHAT DATED 000.6 VETERAN AND VINTAGE AIRCRAFT HUNT, LESLIE AVIATION MUSEUMS WORLD WIDE 000.7 NORTH AMERICAN AIRCRAFT MUSEUM GUIDE STONE, RONALD B. LIST AND INFORMATION FOR AVIATION MUSEUMS 000.8 AVIATION AND SPACE MUSEUMS OF AMERICA ALLEN, JON L. LISTS AVATION MUSEUMS IN THE US OUT OF DATE 000.9 MUSEUM AND DISPLAY AIRCRAFT OF THE UNITED ORRISS, BRUCE WM. GUIDE TO US AVIATION MUSEUM SOME STATES GOOD PHOTOS MUSEUMS 001.1L MILESTONES OF AVIATION GREENWOOD, JOHN T. EDITOR SMITHSONIAN AIRCRAFT 001.2.1 NATIONAL AIR AND SPACE MUSEUM, THE BRYAN, C.D.B. NATIONAL AIR AND SPACE MUSEUM COLLECTION 001.2.2 NATIONAL AIR AND SPACE MUSEUM, THE, SECOND BRYAN,C.D.B. MUSEUM AVIATION HISTORY REFERENCE EDITION Page 1 Call# Title Author Subject 001.3 ON MINIATURE WINGS MODEL AIRCRAFT OF THE DIETZ, THOMAS J.
    [Show full text]
  • Cat No Ref Title Author 3170 H3 an Airman's
    Cat Ref Title Author OS Sqdn and other info No 3170 H3 An Airman's Outing "Contact" 1842 B2 History of 607 Sqn R Aux AF, County of 607 Sqn Association 607 RAAF 2898 B4 AAF (Army Air Forces) The Official Guide AAF 1465 G2 British Airship at War 1914-1918 (The) Abbott, P 2504 G2 British Airship at War 1914-1918 (The) Abbott, P 790 B3 Post War Yorkshire Airfields Abraham, Barry 2654 C3 On the Edge of Flight - Development and Absolon, E W Engineering of Aircraft 3307 H1 Looking Up At The Sky. 50 years flying with Adcock, Sid the RAF 1592 F1 Burning Blue: A New History of the Battle of Addison, P/Craig JA Britain (The) 942 F5 History of the German Night Fighter Force Aders, Gerbhard 1917-1945 2392 B1 From the Ground Up Adkin, F 462 A3 Republic P-47 Thunderbolt Aero Publishers' Staff 961 A1 Pictorial Review Aeroplane 1190 J5 Aeroplane 1993 Aeroplane 1191 J5 Aeroplane 1998 Aeroplane 1192 J5 Aeroplane 1992 Aeroplane 1193 J5 Aeroplane 1997 Aeroplane 1194 J5 Aeroplane 1994 Aeroplane 1195 J5 Aeroplane 1990 Aeroplane Cat Ref Title Author OS Sqdn and other info No 1196 J5 Aeroplane 1994 Aeroplane 1197 J5 Aeroplane 1989 Aeroplane 1198 J5 Aeroplane 1991 Aeroplane 1200 J5 Aeroplane 1995 Aeroplane 1201 J5 Aeroplane 1996 Aeroplane 1525 J5 Aeroplane 1974 Aeroplane (Pub.) 1526 J5 Aeroplane 1975 Aeroplane (Pub.) 1527 J5 Aeroplane 1976 Aeroplane (Pub.) 1528 J5 Aeroplane 1977 Aeroplane (Pub.) 1529 J5 Aeroplane 1978 Aeroplane (Pub.) 1530 J5 Aeroplane 1979 Aeroplane (Pub.) 1531 J5 Aeroplane 1980 Aeroplane (Pub.) 1532 J5 Aeroplane 1981 Aeroplane (Pub.) 1533 J5
    [Show full text]
  • Comox Valley Ribfest
    TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 12, 2017 Volume 59, #15 The Battle of Britain con- The Battle of Britain is radar stations on the south flict took place between often described as having coast. By sinking merchant July and October of 1940. four phases, the dates of ships, Germany would pre- It was the first major mili- which seem to vary. vent the British people from Battle of Britain tary campaign in history to receiving the commodities be fought entirely in the air. Phase One - required for their existence. Commemorating 77 years On July 10, 120 German July 10 to At the same time, it was bombers and fighters struck August 12, 1940 hoped that it would draw Comox Air Force Museum a British shipping convoy out the British fighters from Attacks on Channel Ship- in the English Channel, their bases so as to analyze ping: On July 16, Hitler while 70 more bombers at- the strength of the Royal Air issued Directive No. 16, tacked dockyards in South Force, determine the speed which called for prepara- Wales. and efficiency that it could tions to be made for Opera- Although Britain had deploy its squadrons. tion Sealion - the invasion of fewer fighters than the Ger- Intermittent bombing Britain. He demanded that mans, it did have an effec- raids took place on Ports- “the British Air Force… be tive radar system, which mouth, Falmouth, Swansea, eliminated to such an extent made the prospects of a Newcastle and Merseyside, that it will be incapable of sneak attack unlikely. but these weren’t consistent putting up any sustained But in the opening days like the Channel convoy opposition to the invad- of the Battle, Britain need- raids.
    [Show full text]
  • All Nations Together a Battle of Britain Resource
    All Nations Together A Battle of Britain resource This resource provides biographical content to supplement a Key Stage 3 student study into the Battle of Britain. It highlights the international profile of the Royal Air Force in 1940. As well as investigation into the political, strategic, tactical and technical aspects of the battle, no study is complete without reference to the human experience of the event. This was an early phase of the Second World War when the outcome hung upon the skills and courage of a small number of combatants and support staff. It may surprise students to learn that numbered among Churchill’s ‘Few’ were participants from many Allied nations. A study of the Battle fits into Key Stage 3 History in the following ways: • In the broad purpose of the study of history, as outlined in the National Curriculum: ‘History helps pupils to understand the complexity of people’s lives, the process of change, the diversity of societies and relationships between different groups, as well as their own identity and the challenges of their time.’ • One of the key aims for the teaching of KS3 history is to: ‘know and understand the history of these islands as a coherent, chronological narrative, from the earliest times to the present day: how people’s lives have shaped this nation and how Britain has influenced and been influenced by the wider world.’ • Amongst options for subject content is the unit: ‘challenges for Britain, Europe and the wider world 1901 to the present day … this could include: … the Second World War and the wartime leadership of Winston Churchill.’ The Battle of Britain, 10 July to 31 October 1940, was a large air battle fought between the German air force - the Luftwaffe - and the Royal Air Force of Great Britain.
    [Show full text]
  • WWII D-Day: a Soldier's Journal May 30, 1944 Today We Finally Moved
    Fiction: WWII – D-Day WWII D-Day: A Soldier’s Journal May 30, 1944 Today we finally moved. The action has begun. For the past few months I have been in England. We have trained and studied. Now it is time to go. The code name for our movement is Operation Overlord. I do not know when we will strike the Germans. I do know that our ultimate hope, months from now, is to liberate1 Paris. But first, we need to get our foot in the door of Europe. I am afraid that Germany will slam the door in our face. Germany now controls most of the continent. But we will win. June 5, 1944 We have left Britain now. We are heading towards the coast of France. The English Channel is rough and choppy. Our ships rock back and forth. The air is foggy outside, but very few men go up on the deck of the ship anyway. We are all kept below to prepare for the fight. Most of the men are quiet and keep to themselves. We know that our job is necessary, but we also know that many of us will die. It is clear now that we will invade2 France on the beaches of Normandy. By morning, we will have landed. Who knows how long the fight will take, or who will survive…anything is possible for us, except defeat. We will win. June 6, 1944 Today was the hardest day of my life. But we are succeeding. Over 160,000 Allied troops and 3,000 ships landed together along the coast of Normandy.
    [Show full text]
  • The Civil War Diary of Hoosier Samuel P
    1 “LIKE CROSSING HELL ON A ROTTEN RAIL—DANGEROUS”: THE CIVIL WAR DIARY OF HOOSIER SAMUEL P. HERRINGTON Edited by Ralph D. Gray Bloomington 2014 2 Sergeant Samuel P. Herrington Indianapolis Star, April 7, 1912 3 CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION 5 CHAPTERS 1. Off to Missouri (August-December 1861) 17 "There was no one rejected." 2. The Pea Ridge Campaign (January-March 15, 1862) 61 "Lord but how we made things hum." 3. Missouri Interlude (March 16-June 1862) 87 "There is a great many sick [and] wounded." 4. Moving Along the Mississippi (July-December 1862) 111 "We will never have so much fun if we stay ten years in the service." 5. The Approach to Vicksburg (January-May 18, 1863) 149 "We have quite an army here." 6. Vicksburg and Jackson (May 19-July 26, 1863) 177 ". they are almost Starved and cant hold out much longer." 7. To Texas, via Indiana and Louisiana (July 27-December 1863) 201 "The sand blows very badly & everything we eat is full of sand." 8. Guard Duty along the Gulf (January-May 28, 1864 241 "A poor soldier obeys orders that is all." 9. To the Shenandoah and Home (May 29-September 1864) 277 "I was at the old John Brown Fortress where he made his stand for Liberty and Justice." 4 The picture can't be displayed. 5 INTRODUCTION Indiana played a significant role in the Civil War. Its contributions of men and material, surpassed by no other northern state on a percentage basis, were of enormous importance in the total war effort.
    [Show full text]
  • Hangar 4 the Battle of Britain Was One of the Major Turning Points of the Second World War
    Large print guide BATTLE OF BRITAIN Hangar 4 The Battle of Britain was one of the major turning points of the Second World War. From the airfield of Duxford to the skies over southern England, follow the course of the battle and discover the stories of the people who were there. Scramble Paul Day 2005 Scramble is a bronze maquette model for part of the Battle of Britain Monument in central London. The monument features many scenes relating to military and civilian life during the Battle of Britain. The centre piece, Scramble, shows pilots running toward their aircraft after receiving orders to intercept an incoming air attack. ZONE 1 Defeat in France May – June 1940 Britain and France declared war on Germany on 3 September 1939, two days after the country invaded Poland. Several months later, on 10 May 1940, Germany attacked Luxembourg, Belgium, the Netherlands and France in a rapid ‘Blitzkrieg’ offensive. During a brief, but costly campaign, Britain deployed multiple Royal Air Force (RAF) squadrons to France. The aircraft were sent to support the British Expeditionary Force fighting on the ground and to counter Germany’s powerful air force, the Luftwaffe. Within 6 weeks, France had fallen. The remaining British, French and other Allied troops retreated to the coast, where over half a million were evacuated. The majority departed from the port of Dunkirk. On 22 June, France surrendered to Germany. Britain had lost its main ally and now found itself open to invasion. · 3 September 1939: Britain and France declare war on Germany · 10 May
    [Show full text]
  • Overview and Map Important Events and Information Key
    Overview and Map Important Events and Information Key Vocabulary On several occasions before the battle, the Germans What was the Battle of Britain? Rejection of tried to negotiate peace with Britain. However, Winston Negotiated Churchill (with popular support) refused. He made Nazi Germany The Battle of Britain was an important aerial battle in Peace several speeches rousing the British public to defend Dictatorship World War II, which started on July 10th 1940. with all their might against the attacking Germans. Europe ‘Eagle Attack’ was the name given to the first attacks After Hitler’s Nazi Germany had conquered most of on the RAF. They attempted to destroy Britain’s Radio Military Europe, including France, the only major country left for ‘Eagle Attack’ Detection and Ranging (Radar) capacity. Radar meant Aeroplane them to fight was Great Britain. that the RAF knew that German bombers were Fighter coming. The Luftwaffe failed to wipe them out. Bomber In order to attack Britain, the Germans knew that they This day took place on the 18th August 1940, on which both sides suffered huge losses. The Germans had Aerial would need to defeat Britain’s airforce. The Hardest attempted to launch a huge attack. Whilst twice as Day Blockade many Luftwaffe were shot down as RAF, many RAF The Battle of Britain pitted Germany’s Luftwaffe against Luftwaffe Britain’s Royal Airforce. bases were badly attacked. Battle of Britain Day is the name given to the large Royal Air Force Although the Luftwaffe had more planes and pilots, the aerial battle that took place on the 15th September The Blitz RAF was a formidable opponent.
    [Show full text]
  • Readers' Guide
    Breaking Point — Readers’ Guide Readers’ Guide Breaking Point — Readers’ Guide ABOUT THE NOVEL Hitler knows that he will have to break us in this Island or lose the war (Winston Churchill) The hour will come when one of us will break—and it will not be National Socialist Germany (Adolf Hitler) And now the hour has come … It is August, 1940. Hitler’s triumphant Third Reich has crushed all Europe—except Britain. As Hitler launch- es a massive aerial assault, only the heavily outnumbered Fighter Command and the iron will of Winston Churchill can stop him. Johnnie Shaux, a Spitfire fighter pilot, must summon up the fortitude to fly into conditions in which death is all but inevitable, and continue to do so until the inevitable occurs... Eleanor Rand, a brilliant Fighter Command mathematician, must find her role in a man’s world. She studies the control room map tracking the ebbs and flows of the conflict, and sees the glimmerings of a radical break- through… Breaking Point is based on actual events in the Battle of Britain. The story alternates between Johnnie, face to face with the enemy, and Eleanor, using ‘zero-sum’ mathematical theory to evolve a strategic model of the battle. Their parallel stories merge as the battle reaches its climax and they confront danger together. Breaking Point — Readers’ Guide ABOUT THE AUTHOR John Rhodes was born in World War II while his father was serving at an RAF Fighter Command airfield in southern England. After the war he grew up in London, where, he says, the shells of bombed-out buildings ‘served as our adventure playgrounds.’ Rhodes graduated from Cambridge University where he studied history.
    [Show full text]
  • 研究会記録 Why the Allies Won the Air War, 1939-1945
    Sabin Why the Allies Won the Air War, 1939-1945 研究会記録 Why the Allies Won the Air War, 1939-1945 Philip Sabin For nearly three decades, first in Queens’ College Cambridge and then in King’s College London, I shared a college with Richard Overy, one of the most eminent historians of World War Two. The title of this paper melds the titles of two of Overy’s most well-known books – The Air War, 1939-1945 from 1980, and Why the Allies Won from 1995.1 My aim is to review his arguments after a generation of further scholarship, and to see whether his insights retain their validity today.2 Two fundamental and inter-related scholarly debates may be identified with regard to the overall issue of Allied victory in World War Two. One concerns whether (as Paul Kennedy and John Ellis have suggested) Axis defeat was all but inevitable because of the overwhelming economic and industrial advantages of the Allies, or whether, as Overy himself argued strongly in Why the Allies Won, ‘There was nothing preordained about Allied success’ and ‘Materially rich, but divided, demoralised, and poorly led, the Allied coalition would have lost the war’.3 The second, related, debate concerns which aspect of this massive struggle was the most decisive. Norman Davies argued in 2006 that the devastating and bloody land war between the Axis powers and their totalitarian rivals in the USSR was the key to Axis defeat, and that the efforts of the Western democracies (especially in Europe) were little more than a sideshow in comparison.4 Phillips O’Brien, by contrast, argued in 2015 that the war was decided primarily by production, technology and economics rather than by blood-letting among massed armies, and that this made the air and sea contest in which the Western powers achieved growing dominance the most decisive aspect of the struggle, to the point that 1 R J Overy, The Air War, 1939-1945, (paperback edition, London: 1987), and Why the Allies Won, (London: 1995).
    [Show full text]
  • Supreme Air Command: the Development of Royal Air Force Practice in the Second World
    SUPREME AIR COMMAND THE DEVELOPMENT OF ROYAL AIR FORCE COMMAND PRACTICE IN THE SECOND WORLD WAR By DAVID WALKER A Thesis submitted to The University of Birmingham For the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY School of History and Cultures College of Arts and Law The University of Birmingham January 2017 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. ABSTRACT This thesis examines the development of RAF high command of the Metropolitan Air Force (MAF) during the Second World War. It sheds new light on the re-organisations of the Air Ministry in 1934, the RAF Command structure in 1936, and the tri-service debate in 1937 concerning the RAF proposal to establish a Supreme Air Commander (SAC). It reveals that while frontline expansion created an impetus for re-organisation, it was operational readiness that was the dominant factor in the re-structuring of the RAF. It examines the transition in RAF frontline organization from the mono-functional command system of 1936 to the multi- functional organisation that emerged after 1943 by looking at command structure and practice, personalities, and operational thinking.
    [Show full text]