Did they work for us? Assessing two years of Bunge data 2010-2012

1. Introduction The ninth session of the Bunge (Parliament) was adjourned on 9 November 2012, two years since the commencement of the first session on 9 November 2010 following the general election. These Bunge sessions have been broadcast through private and public TV stations allowing citizens to follow their representatives’ actions. Another source of information regarding MP performance is provided by the Parliamentary On-line Information System (POLIS) posted on the Parliament website (www.bunge.go.tz)

An important question for any citizen is: how did my MP represent my interests in Parliament? One way to assess performance of MPs is to look at the number of interventions they make in Bunge. MPs can make three types of interventions: they can ask basic questions submitted in advance; they can add supplementary questions after basic questions have been answered by the government; or they can makecontributions during the budget sessions, law amendments or discussions on new laws.

This brief presents six facts on the performance of MPs, from November 2010 to November 2012, updating similar analyses conducted by Twaweza in previous years. It includes an assessment of who were the least and most active MPs. It also raises questions on the significance of education level when it comes to effectiveness of participation by MPs in parliament. The dataset can be downloaded from www.twaweza.org/go/bunge2010-2012

The Bunge dataset includes observations on 351 members: MPs who were elected and served (233), MPs in Special Seats (102), Presidential Appointees (10) and those from the House of Representatives (5) and the Attorney General. For this brief, we exclude seven members from the analysis: the parliamentary officials (Speaker, Deputy

This brief was produced by Twaweza housed at Hivos Tanzania

P.O.Box 38342, , Tanzania. T: +255 22 266 4301 | F: +255 22 266 4308 E: [email protected] | W: www.twaweza.org Published February 2013

Table1: Average number of interventions per MP, by party

Number Interventions per MP Basic Questions Supplementary Contributions of MPs (total) (per MP) Questions (per (per MP) MP) Large PartiesTable1: Average number of intervention per MP, by Party Chadema 48 57 6 11 40 Party Nunber of Total Interventions Basic Questions Supplementary Contributions CUF MPs 35 (per MP)41 (per MP) Questions 5 (per MP) (per MP)8 28 Large PartiesCCM 254 39 3 6 30 Chadema 48 57 6 11 40 CUF Small 35 41 5 8 28 CCM Parties 254 39 3 6 30 Small PartiesTLP 1 87 1 14 60 TLP NCCR-­‐ 5 1 74 87 13 7 14 17 60 50 MAGEUZI NCCR-MAGEUZI 5 74 7 17 50 UDP 1 37 0 9 28 UDP 1 37 0 9 28

Source of Data:Source Parliament of of Data: Parliament Tanzania Website of Tanzania (www.bunge.go.tz) Website www.bunge.go.tz ( )

Fact 3: Fact Elected 3: MPs Elected areMPs more are active more than nominated active MPs than nominated MPs As shownAs in Figure shown 2 below, in elected Figure 2 below ,members elected were members the most were active in the terms most active of in t erms contributions, of contribution s, with 33 with 33 contributionscontributions per per MP, MP, while while Special ats Special Se Seats MPs MPs were were slightly slightly more active more active in terms in terms of basic questions of basic questionsand s upplementary and supplementary questions with ( questionsfive and seven (with question five ands per seven MP in questions the two per MP categories, in the tworespectively) categories,. respectively). MPs from the Zanzibar MPs from House the Zanzibar of House Representatives of Representatives and those and nominated by the those nominatedPresident by the were President the least wereduring active the least parliamentary active duringsessions parliamentary. sessions.

Figure 2 : Average number of intervention per MP, by member type Figure 2: Average number of intervention per MP, by member type Consktuency Special Seats

Nominated by President Zanzibar House of Representakves

35 33 29 30 25 25 20 15 10 7 8 5 5 5 5 2 1 1

Number of interventions 0 0 Basic queskon Supplementary queskon Contribukon

Source of Data: Parliament of Tanzania Website (www.bunge.go.tz) Source of Data: Parliament of Tanzania Website www.bunge.go.tz ( ) Fact 4: MPs with higher education levels are more active Information on education levels for 311 MPs (89 percent of the total) was made available in the Parliamentary On-line Information System (POLIS). Among these MPs, those with primary education were less active on average than those with post-secondary and higher levels of education (Figure 3). However, MPs with postgraduate degrees and doctorates made fewer interventions than their counterparts with single degrees. 3 Fact 4 : MPs with higher education are levels more active Information on education or levels f 311 MPs (89 percent of the total) was made available in the Parliamentary On-­‐line Information System (POLIS). Among these MPs, those with primary education were less active on than average those with post -­‐secondary and higher levels of education (Figure 3). However, MPs with postgraduate degrees and doctorates fewer made interventions than their counterparts with single degrees.

Figure Figure 3: Average3 : Average number of number intervention of intervention per MP, by per education MP, by education level level 50 47 44 45 42 39 40 35 32 30 30

25

20

15 Number of IntervenJons 10

5

0 Primary Secondary Post Secondary Degree Post degree PhD/Professor Source of Data: Parliament of Tanzania Website www.bunge.go.tz ( ) Source of Data: Parliament of Tanzania Website (www.bunge.go.tz) FactFact 5:5 Hon.: Hon. GeorgeGeorge Boniface Boniface Simbachawene Simbachawene was was the the most most active MP activeTo identify MP the overall performance of MPs, the three types of interventions were aggregated to To create identify total a theperformance overall score. performance Aggregation of MPs, was the done by adding upthree the number types of of interventions times an MP were aggregatedasked a to basic create or a total supplementary performance question score. Aggregation or made a contribution. Using this was done approach Hon. by addingGeorge up the Simbachawene of CCM is ranked as the most active iod MP in the per studied, with a total of 273 numberinterventions: of times 7 an basic MP asked questions, a 16 supplbasicementary or supplementary questions question and 250 contributions. or made a contribution. Using this approach Hon. of CCM is ranked as the most active MP in

the period studied, with a total of 273 interventions: 7 basic questions, 16 supplementary

questions and 250 contributions.

Table 2: Top five most active MPs

Hon. George Hon. John Hon. Tundu Hon. Diana Hon. Kabwe

Boniface Mnyika Antiphas Mkumbo Zuberi

Simbachawene Mughwai Chilolo Zitto Lissu Party CCM Chadema Chadema CCM Chadema Rank 1 2 3 4 5 Total 273 269 146 131 126 Interventions Source of Data: Parliament of Tanzania Website (www.bunge.go.tz)

4 Hon. , Hon. Tundu Lissu and Hon. , also of Chadema, made the list of the top five most active MPs. Hon. Diana Chilolo of CCM was also among the top five most active MPs.

Fact 6: Hon. Mohammed Said Mohammed was the least active MP Using the same approach, Hon. Mohamed Said Mohamed of CCM was found to be the least active MP out of all ‘ordinary’ MPs. He is the only MP in Parliament who reportedly did not make a single intervention in the two years covered by this brief, according to the POLIS records. The other members who were least active were also from CCM, as shown in Table 3 below.

Table 3: Least active MPs in the Parliament

Hon. Hon. Edward Hon. Mahadhi Hon. Hon. Muhammed Ngoyai Juma Maalim Mwanakhamis Mohammed Seif Khatib Lowassa Kassim Said Said Mohammed Party CCM CCM CCM CCM CCM Rank 340 341 342 343 345 Total 3 2 2 2 0 Interventions Source of Data: Parliament of Tanzania Website (www.bunge.go.tz)

3. Conclusion The information in this brief was retrieved from the publicly accessible Parliamentary On- line Information System (POLIS) and has been used to assess the level of participation by Members of Parliament in the first nine sessions (two years) of the Eighth Parliament of the United Republic of Tanzania.

The most active MPs tended to come from the opposition, and the least active were from the ruling CCM party. Perhaps this is no surprise, since one of the roles of Parliament is to hold the executive in check. Another factor at play here is that, for any given national level agenda item to be discussed in Bunge, large parties have more candidates to take the word and so the average number of interventions per large party MP will be lower. However, for policy questions at the constituency level this is not the case. This raises questions about the effectiveness of representation of constituency interests in Parliament.

5 The method used in this assessment, number of interventions in Bunge, is only one indicator of MP performance. Follow-up to questions or issues is not considered, nor roles that MPs can play serving in parliamentary committees. Perhaps a more valued role may be how MPs engage with citizens in their constituencies, influencing ‘projects’ and funds to be channeled in their areas and taking actions to solve problems. As of yet we do not know of an effective way to measure such performance, but we welcome your ideas.

This brief also assesses active participation by education levels. It may be useful to study other relationships, such as wealth levels. If the Ethics Secretariat were to release the wealth declarations of MPs, consistent with the principles of the Open Government Partnership, such analyses would be possible.

6 Annex | Ranking of Members of Parliament

Rank Name Gender Membership Party Constituent Basic Supplementary Contributions Total type Questions Questions Interventions

Hon. George Boniface Taguluvala 1 M Constituency** CCM Kibakwe 7 16 250 273 Simbachawene

2 Hon. John John Mnyika M Constituency Chadema Ubungo 8 32 229 269

3 Hon. Tundu Antiphas Mughwai Lissu M Constituency Chadema Singida Mashariki 8 20 118 146

4 Hon. Diana Mkumbo Chilolo F No constituency CCM Special seat 10 48 73 131

5 Hon. Kabwe Zuberi Zitto M Constituency Chadema Kigoma Kaskazini 8 30 88 126

NCCR- 6 Hon. Moses Joseph Machali M Constituency Kasulu Mjini 9 34 79 122 MAGEUZI

7 Hon. Godfrey Weston Zambi M Constituency CCM Mbozi Mashariki 10 26 84 120

8 Hon. Leticia Mageni Nyerere F No constituency Chadema Special seat 10 27 72 109

9 Hon. William Vangimembe Lukuvi M Constituency* CCM Ismani 0 0 104 104

10 Hon. Murtaza Ally Mangungu M Constituency CCM Kilwa Kaskazini 8 27 61 96

11 Hon. Halima James Mdee F Constituency Chadema Kawe 7 17 71 95

NCCR- 12 Hon. Felix Francis Mkosamali M Constituency Muhambwe 9 18 66 93 MAGEUZI

13 Hon. Ester Amos Bulaya F No constituency CCM Special seat 4 23 64 91

14 Hon. Nyambari Chacha Mariba Nyangwine M Constituency CCM Tarime 14 22 55 91

15 Hon. David Ernest Silinde M Constituency Chadema Mbozi Magharibi 11 22 55 88

16 Hon. Augustino Lyatonga Mrema M Constituency TLP Vunjo 13 14 60 87

17 Hon. Selemani Saidi Jafo M Constituency CCM Kisarawe 7 13 67

18 Hon. Christowaja Gerson Mtinda F No constituency Chadema Special seat 12 18 53 83

NCCR- 19 Hon. David Zacharia Kafulila M Constituency Kigoma Kusini 9 17 56 82 MAGEUZI

20 Hon. Eng. Mohamed Habib Juma Mnyaa M Constituency CUF Mkanyageni 5 25 52 82

21 Hon. Martha Mosses Mlata F No constituency CCM Special seat 6 15 61 82

22 Hon. Esther Nicholas Matiko F No constituency Chadema Special seat 7 11 63 81

23 Hon. Magdalena Hamis Sakaya F No constituency CUF Special seat 4 18 59 81

24 Hon. William Augustao Mgimwa M Constituency* CCM Kalenga 3 8 70 81

25 Hon. Alphaxard Kangi Ndege Lugola M Constituency CCM Mwibara 8 15 57 80

26 Hon. Desderius John Mipata M Constituency CCM Nkasi Kusini 6 20 53 79

27 Hon. Ignas Aloyce Malocha M Constituency CCM Kwela 8 15 55 78

28 Hon. Dr. John Pombe Joseph Magufuli M Constituency* CCM Chato 0 0 77 77

29 Hon. Celina Ompeshi Kombani F Constituency* CCM Ulanga Mashariki 0 0 76 76

30 Hon. Gosbert Begumisa Blandes M Constituency CCM Karagwe 9 11 54 74

31 Hon. Rajab Mbarouk Mohammed M Constituency CUF Ole 7 13 54 74

32 Hon. Sabreena Hamza Sungura F No constituency Chadema Special seat 7 11 56 74

33 Hon. Pauline Philipo Gekul F No constituency Chadema Special seat 7 26 40 73

34 Hon. Ritta Enesper Kabati F No constituency CCM Special seat 10 19 44 73

35 Hon. Cynthia Hilda Ngoye F No constituency CCM Special seat 6 15 51 72

36 Hon. Assumpter Nshunju Mshama F Constituency CCM Nkenge 8 18 44 70

Hon. Susan Aloyce Hashim 37 F No constituency Chadema Special seat 4 19 47 70 Limbweni Kiwanga

7 Rank Name Gender Membership Party Constituent Basic Supplementary Contributions Total type Questions Questions Interventions

38 Hon. Augustino Manyanda Masele M Constituency CCM Mbogwe 10 9 50 69

39 Hon. Maryam Salum Msabaha F No constituency Chadema Special seat 9 21 38 68

40 Hon. Modestus Dickson Kilufi M Constituency CCM Mbarali 7 15 46 68

41 Hon. Susan Anselm Jerome Lyimo F No constituency Chadema Special seat 6 14 48 68

42 Hon. Dr. Hamisi Andrea Kigwangalla M Constituency CCM Nzega 4 8 55 67

43 Hon. Joseph Roman Selasini Shao M Constituency Chadema Rombo 10 28 28 66

44 Hon. Prof. Anna Kajumulo Tibaijuka F Constituency* CCM Muleba Kusini 0 0 66 66

45 Hon. Said Amour Arfi M Constituency Chadema Mpanda Mjini 11 23 32 66

46 Hon. Stephen Hilary Ngonyani M Constituency CCM Korogwe Vijijini 6 12 48 66

47 Hon. Dr. Shukuru Jumanne Kawambwa M Constituency* CCM Bagamoyo 0 0 65 65

48 Hon. Luhaga Joelson Mpina M Constituency CCM Kisesa 5 20 40 65

49 Hon. Prof. Jumanne Abdallah Maghembe M Constituency* CCM Mwanga 0 0 65 65

50 Hon. M Constituency CUF Mkoani 8 8 48 64

51 Hon. Amina Amour Abdulla F No constituency CUF Special seat 5 15 44 64

52 Hon. Mendrad Lutengano Kigola M Constituency CCM Mufindi Kusini 7 9 48 64

53 Hon. Faida Mohamed Bakar F No constituency CCM Special seat 11 22 30 63

54 Hon. Kombo Khamis Kombo M Constituency CUF Mgogoni 6 11 46 63

55 Hon. Moshi Selemani Kakoso M Constituency CCM Mpanda Vijijini 6 13 44 63

56 Hon. Betty Eliezer Machangu F No constituency CCM Special seat 7 9 46 62

Hon. Eng. Gerson Hosea Malangalila Njombe 57 M Constituency** CCM 0 0 62 62 Lwenge Magharibi

58 Hon. Ezekiel Magolyo Maige M Constituency CCM Msalala 2 4 56 62

59 Hon. Fatuma Abdallah Mikidadi F No constituency CCM Special seat 4 10 48 62

60 Hon. Juma Abdallah Njwayo M Constituency CCM Tandahimba 8 16 38 62

61 Hon. Rukia Kassim Ahmed F No constituency CUF Special seat 8 11 43 62

62 Hon. Albert Obama Ntabaliba M Constituency CCM Manyovu 9 9 43 61

63 Hon. Dr. Cyril August Chami M Constituency CCM Moshi Vijijini 0 0 61 61

Manyoni 64 Hon. John Paul Lwanji M Constituency CCM 6 7 48 61 Magharibi

65 Hon. Suleiman Nassib Omar M Constituency CCM Mfenesini 5 5 51 61

66 Hon. Peter Joseph Serukamba M Constituency CCM Kigoma Mjini 0 11 49 60

67 Hon. Prof. Kulikoyela Kanalwanda Kahigi M Constituency Chadema Bukombe 7 8 45 60

Nominated by Nominated by 68 Hon. M CCM 0 0 60 60 President* President

69 Hon. Vincent Josephat Kiboko Nyerere M Constituency Chadema Musoma Mjini 11 12 37 60

70 Hon. Amos Gabriel Makalla M Constituency** CCM Mvomero 8 11 40 59

71 Hon. Felister Aloyce Bura F No constituency CCM Special seat 6 15 37 58

72 Hon. Michael Lekule Laizer M Constituency CCM Longido 9 26 23 58

73 Hon. Omari Rashid Nundu M Constituency CCM Tanga Mjini 1 2 55 58

74 Hon. Saidi Mohamed Mtanda M Constituency CCM Mchinga 8 18 32 58

75 Hon. Lucy Philemon Owenya F No constituency Chadema Special seat 9 10 38 57

76 Hon. Masoud Abdallah Salim M Constituency CUF Mtambile 6 11 40 57

77 Hon. Sinkamba Josephat Kandege M Constituency CCM Kalambo 7 11 39 57

78 Hon. Victor Kilasile Mwambalaswa M Constituency CCM Lupa 9 13 35 57

79 Hon. Dr. Hadji Hussein Mponda M Constituency CCM Ulanga Magharibi 0 0 56 56

80 Hon. Dr. Mary Machuche Mwanjelwa F No constituency CCM Special seat 7 14 35 56

81 Hon. Dr. Kebwe M Constituency CCM Serengeti 7 14 35 56

8 Rank Name Gender Membership Party Constituent Basic Supplementary Contributions Total type Questions Questions Interventions

82 Hon. Haroub Mohamed Shamis M Constituency CUF Chonga 7 8 41 56

83 Hon. Mhonga Said Ruhwanya F No constituency Chadema Special seat 8 13 35 56

84 Hon. Mkiwa Adam Kimwanga F No constituency CUF Special seat 9 12 35 56

85 Hon. Rebecca Michael Mngodo F No constituency Chadema Special seat 5 6 45 56

86 Hon. Richard Mganga Ndassa M Constituency CCM Sumve 5 18 33 56

87 Hon. Anne Kilango Malecela F Constituency CCM Same Mashariki 8 13 34 55

88 Hon. Athuman Rashid Mfutakamba M Constituency CCM Igalula 0 0 55 55

89 Hon. Dr. M Constituency* CCM Same Magharibi 0 0 55 55

90 Hon. Dr. Faustine Engelbert Ndugulile M Constituency CCM Kigamboni 4 4 47 55

91 Hon. M Constituency CUF Magogoni 5 9 41 55

92 Hon. Stephen Julius Masele M Constituency** CCM Shinyanga Mjini 5 10 40 55

93 Hon. Deo Haule Filikunjombe M Constituency CCM Ludewa 7 12 35 54

94 Hon. Freeman Aikaeli Mbowe M Constituency Chadema Hai 3 21 30 54

95 Hon. Hawa Abdulrahman Ghasia F Constituency* CCM Mtwara Vijijini 0 0 54 54

96 Hon. Jitu Vrajlal Soni M Constituency CCM Babati Vijijini 1 13 40 54

97 Hon. Muhammad Ibrahim Sanya M Constituency CUF Mji Mkongwe 9 15 30 54

98 Hon. Mwigulu Lameck Nchemba M Constituency CCM Iramba Magharibi 2 13 39 54

99 Hon. Salum Khalfan Barwany M Constituency CUF Lindi Mjini 10 12 32 54

100 Hon. F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 3 51 54

101 Hon. Eugen Elishiringa Mwaiposa F Constituency CCM Ukonga 6 17 30 53

102 Hon. Ezekia Dibogo Wenje M Constituency Chadema Nyamagana 5 11 37 53

103 Hon. AnnaMaryStella John Robert Mallac F No constituency Chadema Special seat 6 6 40 52

104 Hon. Deogratias Aloyce Ntukamazina M Constituency CCM Ngara 5 10 37 52

105 Hon. Dr. Pudenciana Wilfred Kikwembe F No constituency CCM Special seat 7 6 39 52

106 Hon. Herbert James Mntangi M Constituency CCM Muheza 7 9 36 52

107 Hon. Mariam Nassor Kisangi F No constituency CCM Special seat 2 6 44 52

108 Hon. Vita Rashid Mfaume Kawawa M Constituency CCM Namtumbo 9 18 25 52

109 Hon. Zarina Shamte Madabida F No constituency CCM Special seat 6 5 41 52

110 Hon. Ally Mohamed Keissy M Constituency CCM Nkasi Kaskazini 6 8 37 51

111 Hon. Charles John Poul Mwijage M Constituency CCM Muleba Kaskazini 1 5 45 51

112 Hon. Christina Lissu Mughwai F No constituency Chadema Special seat 6 11 34 51

113 Hon. Christopher Olonyokie Ole-Sendeka M Constituency CCM Simanjiro 0 10 41 51

114 Hon. Moza Abedi Saidy F No constituency CUF Special seat 10 11 30 51

115 Hon. Mustapha Boay Akunaay M Constituency Chadema Mbulu 6 10 35 51

116 Hon. Rosweeter Faustin Kasikila F No constituency CCM Special seat 5 5 41 51

117 Hon. Fakharia Shomar Khamis F No constituency CCM Special seat 5 6 39 50

118 Hon. Mustafa Haidi Makunganya Mkulo M Constituency CCM Kilosa 0 0 50 50

119 Hon. William Mganga Ngeleja M Constituency CCM Sengerema 0 0 50 50

120 Hon. Zaynab Mattitu Vullu F No constituency CCM Special seat 4 15 31 50

121 Hon. Amina Mohamed Mwidau F No constituency CUF Special seat 6 6 37 49

122 Hon. Dr. Titus Mlengeya Dismas Kamani M Constituency CCM Busega 6 6 37 49

123 Hon. Gaudence Cassian Kayombo M Constituency CCM Mbinga Mashariki 7 10 32 49

124 Hon. Pindi Hazara Chana F No constituency CCM Special seat 8 9 32 49

125 Hon. Jasson Samson Rweikiza M Constituency CCM Bukoba Vijijini 9 7 32 48

126 Hon. Mahmoud Hassan Mgimwa M Constituency CCM Mufindi Kaskazini 6 7 35 48

127 Hon. Meshack Jeremiah Opulukwa M Constituency Chadema Meatu 6 7 35 48

9 Rank Name Gender Membership Party Constituent Basic Supplementary Contributions Total type Questions Questions Interventions

128 Hon. Rev. Luckson Ndaga Mwanjale M Constituency CCM Mbeya Vijijini 8 16 24 48

129 Hon. Riziki Omar Juma F No constituency CUF Special seat 8 11 29 48

Hon. Ambassador Khamis Juma Suedi 130 M Constituency* CCM Bukoba Mjini 0 0 47 47 Kagasheki

Biharamulo 131 Hon. Antony Gervase Mbassa M Constituency Chadema 8 11 28 47 Magharibi

132 Hon. Dr. Emmanuel John Nchimbi M Constituency* CCM Songea Mjini 0 0 47 47

133 Hon. Hamoud Abuu Jumaa M Constituency CCM Kibaha Vijijini 7 4 36 47

Arumeru 134 Hon. Goodluck Joseph Ole-Medeye M Constituency** CCM 0 0 46 46 Magharibi

135 Hon. Henry Daffa Shekifu M Constituency CCM Lushoto 7 10 29 46

136 Hon. Josephine Johnson Genzabuke F No constituency CCM Special seat 6 12 28 46

137 Hon. M Constituency CCM Bububu 8 9 29 46

138 Hon. Osmund Joseph Mbilinyi M Constituency Chadema Mbeya Mjini 4 6 36 46

139 Hon. Dr. Abdallah Omar Kigoda M Constituency* CCM Handeni 4 2 39 45

140 Hon. Mohamed Hamisi Missanga M Constituency CCM Singida Kusini 6 6 33 45

141 Hon. Aggrey Deaisile Joshua Mwanri M Constituency** CCM Siha 0 0 44 44

NCCR- 142 Hon. Agripina Zaituni Buyogera F Constituency Kasulu Vijijini 8 4 32 44 MAGEUZI

143 Hon. Angellah Jasmine Mbelwa Kairuki F No Constituency** CCM Special seat 2 3 39 44

144 Hon. Dr. Charles John Tizeba M Constituency** CCM Buchosa 3 9 32 44

145 Hon. Kaika Saning’o Telele M Constituency CCM Ngorongoro 5 9 30 44

146 Hon. Prof. Peter Mahamudu Msolla M Constituency CCM Kilolo 4 5 35 44

147 Hon. F No Constituency CCM Special seat 1 3 40 44

148 Hon. Yussuf Haji Khamis M Constituency CCM Nungwi 5 5 34 44

149 Hon. Amina Andrew Clement F Constituency CCM Koani 4 6 33 43

150 Hon. Ismail Aden Rage M Constituency CCM Tabora Mjini 5 7 31 43

151 Hon. Jerome Dismas Bwanausi M Constituency CCM Lulindi 9 11 23 43

152 Hon. Martha Jachi Sulle Umbulla F No Constituency CCM Special seat 6 12 25 43

153 Hon. Naomi . Kaihula F No Constituency Chadema Special seat 3 3 37 43

154 Hon. Philipa Geofrey Mturano F No Constituency Chadema Special seat 7 7 29 43

Urambo 155 Hon. Samuel John Sitta M Constituency* CCM 0 0 43 43 Mashariki

156 Hon. Dr. Binilith Satano Mahenge M Constituency** CCM Makete 5 9 28 42

157 Hon. Dunstan Luka Kitandula M Constituency CCM Mkinga 5 8 29 42

158 Hon. Mariam Reuben Kasembe F No Constituency CCM Special seat 10 10 22 42

Nominated by Nominated by 159 Hon. Prof. Makame Mnyaa Mbarawa M CCM 0 0 42 42 President* President

160 Hon. Rashid Ali Abdallah M Constituency CUF Tumbe 4 4 34 42

161 Hon. Rev. Israel Yohana Natse M Constituency Chadema Karatu 5 6 31 42

162 Hon. Anastazia James Wambura F No Constituency CCM Special seat 6 5 30 41

Mbinga 163 Hon. Capt. John Damiano Komba M Constituency CCM 5 11 25 41 Magharibi

164 Hon. James Daudi Lembeli M Constituency CCM Kahama 7 12 22 41

165 Hon. Juma Selemani Nkamia M Constituency CCM Kondoa Kusini 4 9 28 41

166 Hon. Rev. Peter Simon Msigwa M Constituency Chadema Iringa Mjini 2 5 34 41

167 Hon. Rose Kamili Sukum F No constituency Chadema Special seat 5 5 31 41

168 Hon. Salome Daudi Mwambu F Constituency CCM Iramba Mashariki 5 3 33 41

169 Hon. Silvestry Francis Koka M Constituency CCM Kibaha Mjini 8 9 24 41

10

Rank Name Gender Membership Party Constituent Basic Supplementary Contributions Total type Questions Questions Interventions

214 Hon. Grace Sindato Kiwelu F No constituency Chadema Special seat 2 5 23 30

215 Hon. Majaliwa M Constituency** CCM Ruangwa 0 0 30 30

216 Hon. Salim Hemed Khamis M Constituency CUF Chambani 5 7 18 30

217 Hon. David Mciwa Mallole M Constituency CCM Dodoma Mjini 8 6 15 29

218 Hon. Gregory George Teu M Constituency** CCM Mpwapwa 0 0 29 29

Hon. Mwanamrisho Taratibu Maalim 219 F No constituency Chadema Special seat 5 4 20 29 Abama

220 Hon. Ummy Ally Mwalimu F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 0 29 29

221 Hon. Dr. Festus Bulugu Limbu M Constituency CCM Magu 6 6 16 28

222 Hon. Khatib Said Haji M Constituency CUF Konde 5 4 19 28

223 Hon. Mary Pius Chatanda F No constituency CCM Special seat 6 5 17 28

224 Hon. Mathias Meinrad Chikawe M Constituency* CCM Nachingwea 0 0 28 28

225 Hon. Omary Ahmad Badwel M Constituency CCM Bahi 8 10 10 28

226 Hon. Rashid Ali Omar M Constituency CUF Kojani 3 3 22 28

227 Hon. Raya Ibrahim Khamis M No constituency Chadema Special seat 3 4 21 28

228 Hon. Sara Msafiri Ally F No constituency CCM Special seat 3 0 25 28

229 Hon. Catherine V. Magige F No constituency CCM Special seat 8 8 11 27

Hon. Charles Muhangwa “Mawematatu” 230 M Constituency** CCM Misungwi 0 0 27 27 Kitwanga

231 Hon. Eustace Osler Katagira M Constituency CCM Kyerwa 1 1 25 27

232 Hon. Josephine Tabitha Changulla F No constituency CCM Special seat 3 3 21 27

233 Hon. Khalifa Suleiman Khalifa M Constituency CUF Gando 8 13 6 27

234 Hon. Lazaro Samuel Nyalandu M Constituency** CCM Singida Kaskazini 0 0 27 27

235 Hon. Nimrod Elireheema Mkono M Constituency CCM Musoma Vijijini 0 4 23 27

236 Hon. Ramadhan Haji Saleh M Constituency CCM Bumbwini 2 2 23 27

237 Hon. Stephen Masatu Wasira M Constituency CCM Bunda 0 0 27 27

238 Hon. Zabein Muhaji Mhita F Constituency CCM Kondoa Kaskazini 6 6 15 27

239 Hon. Abdul Rajab Mteketa M Constituency CCM Kilombero 6 5 15 26

240 Hon. Al-Shaymaa John Kwegyir F No constituency CCM Special seat 5 4 17 26

241 Hon. Cecilia Daniel Paresso F No constituency Chadema Special seat 2 7 17 26

242 Hon. Haji Kombo Mussa M Constituency CUF ChakeChake 0 10 16 26

243 Hon. Joyce John Mukya F No constituency Chadema Special seat 3 3 20 26

244 Hon. Mtutura Abdallah Mtutura M Constituency CCM Tunduru Kusini 1 9 16 26

245 Hon. Salvatory Naluyaga Machemli M Constituency Chadema Ukerewe 3 3 20 26

246 Hon. Hussein Mussa Mzee M Constituency CCM Jangombe 4 3 18 25

Rungwe 247 Hon. Prof. David Homeli Mwakyusa M Constituency CCM 7 6 12 25 Magharibi

248 Hon. Selemani Jumanne Zedi M Constituency CCM Bukene 2 3 20 25

249 Hon. Beatrice Matumbo Shellukindo F Constituency CCM Kilindi 2 2 20 24

250 Hon. Rita Louise Mlaki F No constituency CCM Special seat 5 9 10 24

251 Hon. Samia Hassan Suluhu F Constituency* CCM Makunduchi 0 0 24 24

252 Hon. Abas Zuberi M Mtemvu M Constituency CCM Temeke 4 4 15 23

253 Hon. Dr. Milton Makongoro Mahanga M Constituency** CCM Segerea 0 0 23 23

254 Hon. Shaffin Ahmedali Sumar M Constituency CCM Tabora Kaskazini 6 5 12 23

255 Hon. Vick Paschal Kamata F No constituency CCM Special seat 6 3 14 23

256 Hon. Abdulsalaam Selemani Amer M Constituency CCM Mikumi 4 3 15 22

257 Hon. Dr. Harrison George Mwakyembe M Constituency* CCM Kyela 0 0 22 22

12 Rank Name Gender Membership Party Constituent Basic Supplementary Contributions Total type Questions Questions Interventions

258 Hon. Dr. Maua Abeid Daftari F No constituency CCM Special seat 2 4 16 22

259 Hon. Haji Khatib Kai M Constituency CUF Micheweni 6 5 11 22

260 Hon. Lolesia Jeremiah Maselle Bukwimba F Constituency CCM Busanda 2 5 15 22

261 Hon. Mbarouk Salim Ali M Constituency CUF Wete 2 2 18 22

262 Hon. Saidi Ramadhani Bwanamdogo M Constituency CCM Chalinze 2 2 18 22

263 Hon. Sophia Mattayo Simba F No constituency* CCM Special seat 0 0 22 22

Hon. Suleiman Masoud Nchambi’s 264 M Constituency CCM Kishapu 6 7 9 22 Suleiman

265 Hon. Zainab F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 1 21 22

266 Hon. Abdalla Haji Ali M Constituency CUF Kiwani 4 7 10 21

267 Hon. Abdallah Sharia Ameir M Constituency CCM Dimani 4 7 10 21

268 Hon. Adam Kighoma Ali Malima M Constituency** CCM Mkuranga 0 0 21 21

269 Hon. Ahmed Juma Ngwali M Constituency CUF Ziwani 3 3 15 21

270 Hon. Benardetha Kasabago Mushashu F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 1 20 21

271 Hon. Hezekiah Ndahani Chibulunje M Constituency CCM Chilonwa 4 6 11 21

272 Hon. Highness Samson Kiwia M Constituency Chadema Ilemela 6 3 12 21

273 Hon. M Constituency CCM Chwaka 5 7 9 21

274 Hon. Abdulkarim Esmail Hassan Shah M Constituency CCM Mafia 0 2 18 20

275 Hon. Ahmed Ally Salum M Constituency CCM Solwa 6 2 12 20

276 Hon. Jaddy Simai Jaddy M Constituency CCM Mkwajuni 3 2 15 20

Nominated by Nominated by 277 Hon. Janet Zebedayo Mbene F CCM 0 0 20 20 President** President

Arumeru 278 Hon. Joshua Samwel Nassari M Constituency Chadema 2 2 16 20 Mashariki

279 Hon. Kheri Khatib Ameir M Constituency CCM Matemwe 4 3 13 20

280 Hon. Lediana Mafuru Mng’ong’o F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 0 20 20

281 Hon. Sylvester Mhoja Kasulumbayi M Constituency Chadema Maswa Mashariki 3 2 15 20

282 Hon. Elizabeth Nkunda Batenga F No constituency CCM Special seat 3 2 14 19

283 Hon. Kidawa Hamid Saleh F No constituency CCM Special seat 6 5 8 19

284 Hon. Eng. Ramo Matala Makani M Constituency CCM Tunduru Kaskazini 1 0 17 18

285 Hon. Esther Lukago Midimu Minza F No constituency CCM Special seat 2 2 14 18

286 Hon. Haji Juma Sereweji M Constituency CCM Mwanakwerekwe 0 2 16 18

287 Hon. John Magale Shibuda M Constituency Chadema Maswa Magharibi 0 0 18 18

288 Hon. Maida Hamad Abdallah F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 4 14 18

289 Hon. Philipo Augustino Mulugo M Constituency** CCM Songwe 0 0 18 18

290 Hon. Selemani Saidi Ally Bungara M Constituency CUF Kilwa Kusini 5 4 9 18

291 Hon. Bahati Ali Abeid F No constituency CCM Special seat 3 1 13 17

292 Hon. Brg. Gen. Hassan Athumani Ngwilizi M Constituency CCM Mlalo 3 4 10 17

293 Hon. Dr. Christine Gabriel Ishengoma M No constituency CCM Special seat 0 0 17 17

294 Hon. Dr. Fenella Ephraim Mukangara F No constituency* CCM Special seat 0 0 17 17

295 Hon. Mariam Salum Mfaki F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 0 17 17

296 Hon. Mizengo Kayanza Peter Pinda M Constituency CCM Katavi 0 0 17 17

Nominated by Nominated by 297 Hon. Prof. Sospeter M. Muhongo M CCM 0 0 17 17 President* President

298 Hon. Donald Kevin Max M Constituency CCM Geita 4 3 9 16

299 Hon. Neema Mgaya Hamid F No constituency CCM Special seat 1 1 14 16

300 Hon. Riziki Said Lulida F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 1 15 16

13 Rank Name Gender Membership Party Constituent Basic Supplementary Contributions Total type Questions Questions Interventions

301 Hon. Shanif Hiran Mansoor M Constituency CCM Kwimba 3 3 10 16

302 Hon. Asha Mohamed Omar F No constituency CCM Special seat 2 2 11 15

303 Hon. Hamad Yussuf Masauni M Constituency CCM Kikwajuni 0 0 14 14

304 Hon. Juma Othman Ali M Constituency CCM Tumbatu 1 0 13 14

305 Hon. Rosemary Kasimbi Kirigini F No constituency CCM Special seat 1 4 9 14

306 Hon. Asha Mshimba Jecha F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 0 13 13

307 Hon. Namelok Edward Moringe Sokoine F No constituency CCM Special seat 4 3 6 13

308 Hon. Tauhida Cassian Galos Nyimbo F No constituency CCM Special seat 2 2 9 13

Zanzibar 309 Hon. Assa Othman Hamad M House of CUF B.L.W 0 0 12 12 Representatives

310 Hon. Deo Kasenyenda Sanga M Constituency CCM Njombe Kaskazini 3 0 9 12

311 Hon. Hasnain Mohamed Murji M Constituency CCM Mtwara Mjini 0 1 11 12

312 Hon. Innocent Edward Kalogeris M Constituency CCM Morogoro Kusini 0 1 11 12

313 Hon. Lucy Thomas Mayenga F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 1 11 12

314 Hon. Muhammad Amour Chomboh M Constituency CCM Magomeni 1 1 10 12

315 Hon. Devota Mkuwa Likokola F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 2 9 11

316 Hon. Dr. Abdulla Juma Abdulla Saadalla M Constituency** CCM RahaLeo 0 0 11 11

Urambo 317 Hon. Prof. Juma Athumani Kapuya M Constituency CCM 0 1 10 11 Magharibi

318 Hon. Haji Makame Faki M Constituency CUF Mtoni 1 1 8 10

319 Hon. Mussa Hassan Mussa M Constituency CCM Amani 0 0 10 10

Zanzibar 320 Hon. Zahra Ali Hamad F House of CUF B.L.W 2 2 6 10 Representatives

321 Hon. Anna Margareth Abdallah F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 0 9 9

322 Hon. Philemon Kiwelu Ndesamburo M Constituency Chadema Moshi Mjini 4 2 3 9

323 Hon. Sadifa Juma Khamis M Constituency CCM Donge 2 1 6 9

Nominated by Nominated by 324 Hon. Zakia Hamdani Meghji F CCM 0 0 9 9 President President

325 Hon. Abdul-Aziz Mohamed Abood M Constituency CCM Morogoro Mjini 2 2 4 8

326 Hon. Mohammed Gulam Dewji M Constituency CCM Singida Mjini 6 1 1 8

327 Hon. M Constituency CUF Mtambwe 0 1 7 8

328 Hon. Salim Hassan Abdullah Turky M Constituency CCM Mpendae 0 1 7 8

329 Hon. Ahmed Mabkhut Shabiby M Constituency CCM Gairo 1 1 5 7

330 Hon. Kiumbwa Makame Mbaraka F No constituency CCM Special seat 4 0 3 7

331 Hon. Juma Haji Ali M Constituency CCM Chaani 1 1 4 6

332 Hon. Kheir Ali Khamis M Constituency CCM Kwamtipura 0 0 6 6

333 Hon. Lameck Airo Okambo M Constituency CCM Rorya 3 0 3 6

Nominated by Nominated by 334 Hon. Saada Mkuya Salum F CCM 0 0 6 6 President** President

335 Hon. Maulidah Anna Valerian Komu F No constituency Chadema Special seat 0 0 5 5

Zanzibar 336 Hon. Shawana Bukheti Hassan F House of CCM B.L.W 0 0 5 5 Representatives

337 Hon. Kisyeri Werema Chambiri M Constituency CCM Babati Mjini 0 0 4 4

Rungwe 338 Hon. Prof. Mark James Mwandosya M Constituency* CCM 0 0 4 4 Mashariki

Zanzibar 339 Hon. Jaku Hashim Ayoub M House of CCM B.L.W 2 1 0 3 Representatives

14 Rank Name Gender Membership Party Constituent Basic Supplementary Contributions Total type Questions Questions Interventions

340 Hon. M Constituency CCM Uzini 0 0 3 3

341 Hon. Edward Ngoyai Lowassa M Constituency CCM Monduli 0 0 2 2

342 Hon. Mahadhi Juma Maalim M Constituency** CCM Muyuni 0 0 2 2

343 Hon. Mwanakhamis Kassim Said F No constituency CCM Special seat 0 0 2 2

Zanzibar 344 Hon. Mohammed Said Mohammed M House of CCM B.L.W 0 0 0 0 Representatives

* Minister ** Deputy Minister

15 16