THE CLASSICAL REVIEW

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919 THE CLASSICAL REVIEW.

VOLUME XIV.

DAVID NUTT, 57-59 LONG ACRE. 1900.

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919 RICHAKD CLAY AND SONS, LIMITED, LONDON AND BUNGAY.

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919 TABLE OF CONTENTS.

No. 1.

PAGE PAGE Editorial and General: Notes— continued. Comments and Communiques.... 1 On Plutarch, Cicero 5. A. GUDEMAN 62 The Rylands Library, Manchester. On Manilius V. 555 sq. & 133. J. P. A. S. WILKINS 2 POSTGATE . . 63 Original Contributions and Comptes The Etymology of evxofmi. F. W. Rendus: THOMAS 63 Homerica (VI). T. L. AGAR. ... 2 Reviews: < On the Meaning of crcvS6vr] in Aesch. Scott's [Adams'] Hesiod and Pindar. Ag. 997. "W. WYSE 5 W. T. LENDRUM 63 Notes on the Greek Lyric Poets. Fennell's Nemeans and Isthmians. G. W, HEADLAM 5 DAVIES 64 New Homeric Papyri. T. W. ALLEN 14 Forman's Index to Andocides, Ly- The New Scholia to Iliad XXI. curgus and Dinarchus. J. E. Oxyrhynchus Papyri,Vo\. II. p. 63. SANDYS 65 W. G. RUTHERFORD 18 Two Recent Texts of 's Res- On the Oxyrhynchus Papyri. ARTHUR publica. J. A. NAIRN 66 PLATT N . 18 John's Dicdogus de Oratoribus. W. Miscellanea. MORTIMER LAMSON PETERSON 68 EARLE 20 Gudeman's Dialogus. W. PETERSON. 72 Clement of Alexandria and Plutarch. Botsford's History of . M. M. R. JAMES 23 ALFORD 73 Plautus, Persa, 376-377 and 610. P; Ribbeck's Senatores Romani. J. S. J. H. GRAY 24 REID 75 Folklore in Virgil. F. GRANGER . . 24 The New Edition of Pauly's Encyclo- The Aratea of Germanicus.. A. E. paedia. J. E. SANDYS 76 HOUSMAN 26 Blaydes' Adversaria on Aristophanes. The Textual Criticism of Cicero's F.W. HALL 77 Philippics. ALBERT C. CLARK . . 39 Cappelli's Dictionary of Latin Abbrevi- Notes on Silius Italicus, V.-VIII. ations. Sir E. MAUNDE THOMPSON 77 WALTER C. SUMMERS 48 Cronin's Codex Purpureus. J. H. Agricola's Invasion of Ireland once BERNARD . 78 more. ALFRED GUDEMAN and F. Archaeology : HAVERFIELD 51 Antiquities of Hierapolis (Humann, On Juvenal, I. 132-146. REYNOLD Cichorius, Judeich, Winter). W. A. NICHOLSON 53 M. RAMSAY . . . . 79 On Apollinaris Sidonius. A. E. Taylor's Hist, of the Alphabet. E. S. HOUSMAN 54 ROBERTS 85 On Antigonus' Letter to Scepsis. J. The ' Bridge' at Aricia. F. HAVER- P. MAHAFFY 54 FIELD and S. G. OWEN 86 Notes on the Latin Prohibitive. Warde Fowler's Roman Festivals. WILLARD K. CLEMENT 55 JESSE BENEDICT CARTER 88 Recent Works on the Rigveda. E. Monthly Record. H. B. WALTERS V. ARNOLD 55 and WARWICK WROTH 91 Notes: Summaries of Periodicals 93 Bacchylides X. (XI.), 118. J. B. List of New Books 94 BURY 62 Addendum. ALFRED GUDEMAN . . 96

ft

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919 IV THE CLASSICAL EEVIEW.

No. 2.

PAGE PAG* Editorial and General: Notes—continued. Comments and Communiques.... 97 A New MS. of Catullus. GEOBGE Original Contributions: DWIGHT KELLOGG ...... 127 The Platonic Letters. HEEBEBT Catullus LXIV. 15. E. HABBISON 128" EICHABDS 98 Note on the above. J. P. P.. . . .128 Callinus. and Tyrtaeus. J. M. Eeviews : SCHULHOF 103 Kaibel's Greek Comic Fragments. H. Upon Aeschylus—I. W. HEADLAM 106 EICHABDS 128 On Sophocles, Ajax, 839-842. JOHN Qroiset's Greek Literature. J. A. MASSON 120 NAIRN 129 A Suggestion on the Development of The Oxyrhynchus Papyri, Part II. the Greek Optative. MORTIMER F. G. KENYON 132 LAHSON EABLE 122 Pohlenz's Posidonius. K. D. HICKS . 134 On the MS. Tradition of Aetna. Norden's Kunstprosa. J. E. SANDYS. 135 ROBINSON ELLIS 123 Conway's Not in Cicero's Letters. L. Two Corrections of Latin Poets. J. C. PURSER 138 P. POSTDATE 125 Archaeology: On Horace, Sertn. 1, 4, 26 and 2, Trojan ' Brushes.' CECIL SMITH . . 140 3, 4,—Sanus ab again. JOHN C. Eeinach's Painted Vases. W. M. EOLFE 126 EAMSAY 141 Notes: Hill's Lyciam. Coins. GEOBGE MAC- Sophocles, Oed. Col. 1054-5. J. B. DONALD 142 BUBT 127 Geyer's Itinera Hierosolymitana. W. Antigonus' Letter to Scepsis. J. M. EAMSAY 143 ABTHUB E. MUNBO 127 Monthly Eecord. WABWIOK WROTH 144

No. 3. Editorial and General: Queries: Comments and Communique's . . .145 Ap. Ehod. III. 161-163. E. C. S. . 164 Original Contributions: Confusion of solus and totus in Latin The Origin of the Egyptian Year. MSS. J. P. P . . .164 T. NICKLIN 146 Eeviews: Notes on the Seventh Book of the Dimitrijevid's Studio, Hesiodea. T. L. Greek Anthology (Ed. Stadtmiiller) AGAB 165 J. B. BURY 148 Patrick's Sextus Empiricus. E. D. On Two Epigrams of the Greek An- HICKS 166 thology. J. P. POSTGATE .... 153 Wilcken's Griechische Ostraka. F. G. Upon Virgil, Aeneid VI., 893-898. KENYON 168 WILLIAM EVERETT 153 Tyrrell and Purser's Correspondence of On Virgil, Aeneid, XII., 813-818. Cicero. ALBERT C. CLARK . . .174 A. SOUTER 154 Taylor's History of Rome. M. ALFOBD 180 On some Passages of Valerius Flaccus. Eouse's Demonstrations in Greek EOBINSON ELLIS 155 Iambic Verse. J. Gow 181 Notes on Juvenal I. 62 and VII. 114. Brief Notices (Marchant's Translation ALFRED GUDEMAN 158 of Thuc. VI. ; Miles' How to learn Ne Prohibitive in Cicero, from the Philology). W. H. D. E 183 Manuscript of Sir W. D. GEDDES . 160 Archaeology : An Inscription of Dyme in Achaia. Sauer on the Theseion. A. H. SMITH 184 T. W. BEASLEY 162 Schmidt's Villas of Cicero. L. C. Note: PURSER 185 Reminiscences of Lucan in St. Augus- Monthly Eecord. H. B. WALTERS . 187 tine. A. SOUTEB 164 Summaries of Periodicals 188 List of New Books 191

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919 TABLE OF CONTENTS.

No. 4.

PAGE PAGE Editorial and General: Notes—continued. Comments and Communiques . . . .193 Emendation of Hor. Sat. II. ii. 123, Original Contributions: - 124. J. R. COATES 224 Upon Aeschylus—II. W. HEADLAM 194 An Unnoticed Latinism in Longinus. On the Use of the Words rpaymSSs H. J. EDMISTON 224 and Kw/twSos. HERBERT RICHARDS 201 Reviews: On Cicero, "Cato Maior, §§ 28, 34, 15, Tucker's Poetics of Aristotle. H. 38. CHARLES KNAPP 214 RICHARDS 224 On Cicero, Cato Maior, § 28. JOSEPH Jan's Musici Scriptores. D. B. MONRO 226 F. PAXTON 216 Peterson's Cluentius of Cicero. W. On Juvenal, Sat. I. 102 ff. N. P. YOEKE FAUSSET 226 VLACHOS 217 Shorey's Odes and Epodes of Horace. OnJuvenal,5a«.III.,203.'W.O.SpRouLL218 J. P. POSTGATE 229 Should the May-Potential Use of the Tremenheere's Cynthia of Propertius. Subjunctive be Recognized in A. E. HOUSMAN 232 Latin? H. C. ELMER 219 The New Anthologia Oxoniensis. R. Two Notes on the Latin Subjunctive. Y. TYRRELL 233 WILLAKD K. CLEMENT 222 Correspondence : Dies Communes = Dies Atri. NOWELL Rouse's Demonstrations in Greek SMITH 223 Iambic Verse. W. H. D. ROUSE Notes : and J. Gow 236 Two Emendations of Sappho. W. R. Archaeology : PATON 223 Recent Excavations in Rome. THOMAS On Thucydides IV. 18, 4. R. C. ASHBY, Junior . . . • 236 SEATON 223 List of New Books 240

No. 5.

Editorial and General: Original Contributions—continued. Comments and Communiques .... 241 The Comparative Frequency of Ante- Original Contributions: quam and Priusquam. N. WILBUR Zenodotus, Aristophanes, and the HELM .262 Modern Homeric Text. T. W. Notes : ALLEN 242 On Tyrtaeus, 'E^Scmfcui, 2, 2. G. F. Dionysius of Halicarnassus as an ABBOTT • . 263 Authority for the Text of Thucy- Emendation of Plato, Philebus, 17 E. dides. W. RHYS ROBERTS . . . 244 J. ADAM 264 On a Saying of Gorgias. T. G. Augustinian Readings in Cicero and TUCKER 247 Pliny. A. SOUTEB 264 On the Optative and the Graphic Reports: Construction in Greek Subordinate Oxford Philological Society .... 264 Clauses. H. DARNLEY NAYLOR . . 247 Reviews : The Textual Criticism of Cicero's Dill's Roman Society. P. V. M. Philippics, and of the Orations BENECKE ...... •....• 265 before Caesar. ALBERT C. CLARK . 249 Rothert's Karten und Skizzen. W. E. Elucidations of Latin Poets. II. A. HEITLAND .267 E. HOUSMAN 257 Gudeman's Latin Literature of the A Conjecture on Stat. Silv. V. 3. Empire. Vol. II. WALTER C. 94. ROBINSON ELLIS 259 SUMMERS 268 A Bodleian MS. of Macrobius. W. Briefer Notices: M. LINDSAY 260 Brieger's Revised Text of Lucretius. A or AJB in Horace, Epod. 17. 24. J. P. P.; Sargeaunt's Oeorgics IV JOHN C. ROLFE 261

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919

J VI THE CLASSICAL REVIEW.

PAOK FAOI Briefer Notices—continued. Archaeology—continued. E. H. BLAKENEY ; Furneaux's Taciti and Olynthos in 384-3 B.C. Opera Minora. GILBERT DAVIES; G. F. HILL 279 Hense's Seneeae Epistulae. J. D. FitzSimon and FitzSimon's Gods of DUFF ; FAIRLEY'S Monumenturn Old. J. H. VINCE 281 Ancyranum. J. P. P 270 Huish's Greek Terracotta Statuettes. Versions: PERCY GARDNER 282 A Great Eastern Railway Notice. G. Monthly Record. H. B. "WALTERS PBESTOK 273 and WARWICK WROTH 283 Archaeology: Summaries of Periodicals 285 The Site of Primitive Athens. Thucy- List of New Books 287 dides II. 15 and Recent Explora- Corrigenda 288 tions. A. W. VERRALL 274

No. 6.

Editorial and General: Reviews—continued. Comments and Communique's. . . .289 Greek and Latin Syntax. E. A. Original Contributions: SONNENSCHEIN 313 The Text of the Iliad—II. T. W. Lane's Latin Grammar. EDWIN W. ALLEN / 290 FAY 316 A New System of Analysing Greek Correspondence : Lyric Stanzas. C. A. M. FENNELL . 292 The New Edition of Pauly's Encyclo- Tibulliana. J. P. POSTDATE .... 295 paedia. Dr. L. BUECHNER .... 322 Prolegomena in M. Manilii Astrono- Versions: mica. MALWIN BECHERT .... 296 An Idyll in English and Greek. W. Notes on Silius Italicus, IX.-XVII. H. D. ROUSE 322 WALTER C. SUMMERS 305 Archaeology : The Census of Sulpicius Quirinius. Hutton's Greek Terracotta Statuettes. F. HAVERFIELD 309 CLEMENT GUTCH 324 Notes and Reports: The Four Great Aqueducts of Ancient On Juvenal, Sat. I. 106. JOSEPH F. Rome. THOMAS ASHBY, Jun. . . . 325 PAXTON and SAMUEL ALLEN . . .310 Herschel's Frontinus. F. HAVER- Cambridge Philological Society . . .310 FIELD 327 Oxford Philological Society .... 310 D'Arbois de Jubainville's Celtic and Reviews: Homeric Civilisations. T. HUDSON Curtze's Anaritius on Euclid. T. L. WILLIAMS 328 HEATH 311 Monthly Record. H. B. WALTERS Patin's Polemic of Parmenides against and WARWICK WROTH 331 Heraclitus. JOHN BURNET . . . .312 Summaries of Periodicals 334 Riemann and Goelzer's Comparison of

No. 7.

Original Contributions : Original Contributions—continued. The Platonic Letters (continued). H. A Supplement to the Apparatus RICHARDS 335 Criticus of Martial. W. M. LINDSAY 353 BY0OS *AYAPIAS. J. BURNET . . 344 Roman Indifference to Provincial On the Optative and the Graphic Affairs. F. F. ABBOTT 355 Construction in Greek Subordi- On Cicero Cato Maior 28. P. 0. nate Clauses {continued). H. D. BARENDT 356 NAYLOR 345 On a ponte (Juv. 4, 117). J. C. Lucretiana. J. P. POSTGATE . . . . 352 ROLFE 357

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919 TABLE OF CONTENTS.

PAGB PAGE Original Contributions—continued. Reviews—continued. On the Interweaving of Words with Bauer's Forschungen zur griechis- Pairs of Parallel Phrases. R. S. chen Geschichte, 1888-1898. L. CONWAY 357 WHIBLEY 368 Reviews: Archaeology: Leaf's Iliad, ed. 2. T. W. ALLEN. . 360 Questions concerning Attic Topo- Sidgwick's Text of Aeschylus. R. Y. graphy and Religion (Thuc. 2, 15). TYRRELL 362 L. R. FARNELL 369 Blaydes' Eumenides of Aeschylus. Michel's Greek Inscriptions. E. S. R. Y. TYRRELL 364 ROBERTS 377 Gradenwitz's Einfuhrung in die Papy- Reinach's Painted Vases. W. M. ruskunde. F. G. KENYON .... 365 RAMSAY 378 Bailey's Text of Lucretius. A. E. Monthly Record 378 HOUSMAN 367 Summaries of Periodicals 379 Briefer Notices: Reiter's Iphigenia List of New Books 380 auf Tauris. E. B. ;

No. 8.

Original Contributions: Notes—continued. Syntax and Style. WM. C. LAWTON . 383 On the Metaphor in Horace, Od. i. 5. The Text of the Iliad—III. T. W. ERNEST J. ROBSON 414 ALLEN 384 Notes on JuvenaL A. SOUTER . . .414 On the Word Apa/xd. HERBERT Reports : RICHARDS 388 Oxford Philological Society . . . .414 TENOYSTHS. JOHN BURNET ... 393 Reviews: O2—OS in Theocritus and Homer. Wecklein's Cyclops of Euripides. H. H. R. FAIRCLOUGH 394 DEF. SMITH 414 Note on the Command held by Marchant's and Underbill's Hellenics Seleukos, 323-321 B.C. EDWYN R. of Xenophon. H. RICHARDS . . . 415 BEVAN 396 Benn's Philosophy of Greece. J. A. On Lucretius III., 196,197. ERNEST STEWART 417 J. ROBSON 398 Damste1 on Virgil and Hildebrandt on The Textual Criticism of the Pro ' Aetna.' J. P. POSTGATE .... 419 Milone, the Orations before Caesar Shuckburgh's Translation of Cicero's and the Philippics, (continued). Letters. W. WARDE FOWLER . . . 421 ALBERT C. CLARK . . . . • ... 399 Detlef sen on Pliny's Natural History. Remarks on Juvenal. HARRY LANG- K. JEX-BLAKE 423 FORD WILSON 412 Archaeology: Corrections. A. E. HOUSMAN . . .413 On the Festival Epidauria at Athens. Notes: ARTHUR FAIRBANKS 424 Aristotle, 'A0. HoX. xiii. 2. F. G. On Horace's Villa. J. SARGEAUNT . 427 KENYON 413 Lermann's Athena-Types on Greek Two Oxford MSS. of Dionysius Hali- Coins. PERCY GARDNER 428 , carnaseus. A. B. POYNTON . . .413 Numismatic Summaries. WARWICK On Lucretius, III., - 993. SAMUEL WROTH 429 ALLEN 414 List of New Books 429

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919 THE CLASSICAL REVIEW.

No. 9.

PAGE PAGE Editorial and General: Reviews—continued. Comments and Communiques . . . .431 Halica/rnasei Opuscula. W. RHYS Original Contributions: ROBERTS 452 Homerica (VTL). T. L. AGAE . . .432 Two Books on Lucian. FRANKLIN T. Aeschylus Agamemnon 489-502 (Din- RICHARDS 455 dorf). A. O. PRICKARD 434 The Amherst Papyri. F. C. BURKITT 457 Upon Aeschylus. A. O. PRICKARD . 437 Bury's History of Greece. RONALD The Chronology of the Dramas of M. BURROWS 459 Euripides. ALFRED CHURCH . . .438 Holmes' Caesar's Conquest of Gaul. The Literary Circle of Dionysius A. G. PESKBTT 463 of Halicarnassus. W. RHYS Corpus Poetarum Latinorum, Fasc. ROBERTS 439 III. A. E. HOUSMAN 465 On Strabo XII. 3, 38 : P. 560. J. Van der VLiet's Apologia and Florida ARTHUR R. MUNRO 442 of Apuhius. ROBINSON ELLIS . . 469 Notes on the Text of Plutarch's Correspondence : Quaestiones Gonvivates. W. R. French for Greek in Cicero's Letters. PATON 443 R. Y. TYRRELL 471 Critical Notes on Pausanias. HER- The English Prospectus of the Thes- BERT RICHARDS 445 aurus Linguae Latinos. RONALD On Propertius II. 28, 11. J. P. M. BURROWS 472 POSTGATE . 449 Archaeology: Note: The Argive Heraeum and Bacchylides Some Modern Illustrations of Classi^ XL 43-84. CHARLES WALDSTEIN . 473 cal Authors. EDWARD BENSLY . .450 Fragment of a dated Panathenaic Reports: Amphora. F. B. TARBELL .... 474 Oxford Philological Society . . . .451 Numismatic Summaries. WARWICK Cambridge Philological Society . . .451 WROTH 475 Reviews : Summaries of Periodicals ...... 476 Sandys' Demosthenes. EVELYN ABBOTT 451 List of New Books 478 Usener and Radermacher's Dionysii

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 170.106.202.126, on 27 Sep 2021 at 22:12:01, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0009840X00081919