Evaluation for the European Commission
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EVALUATION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION’S SUPPORT TO THE ACP SADC REGION Synthesis report Volume 2 Annexes October 2007 Evaluation for the European Commission DRN Italie Aide à la Décision Économique This evaluation was commissioned by: Belgique the Evaluation Unit common to: ECO-Consulting Group EuropeAid Co-operation Office, Allemagne Directorate General for Development and Nordic Consulting Group Danemark Directorate-General for External Relations ECORYS-NEI Pays-Bas Un consortium constitué de DRN, ADE, ECO, NCG et ECORYS-NEI c/o DRN, société leader: Siège Via Ippolito Nievo 62 00153 Rome, Italie Tel: +39-06-581-6074 Fax: +39-06-581-6390 [email protected] Bureau en Belgique Square Eugène Plasky, 92 1030 Bruxelles, Belgique Tel: +32-2-732-4607 Tel: +32-2-736-1663 Fax: +32-2-706-5442 [email protected] This evaluation study was carried out by: Dolf Noppen (team leader); Per Kirkemann; Nicholas Charalambides, Theodor Mutter and Giulia Pietrangeli Marc Wilke the Evaluation Contract Manager The evaluation was managed by the evaluation unit who also chaired the reference group composed by members of the services (EuropeAid, Relex, DG Trade, and the EC Delegations in SADC Countries). The opinions expressed in this document represent the authors’ points of view which are not necessarily shared by the European Commission or by the authorities of the countries concerned Evaluation of the Commission’s Regional Support to SADC DRN-ADE-ECO-ECORYS-NCG Table of contents of Volume 2 Annex 1 Evaluation Questions.................................................................1 Annex 2 Terms of Reference..................................................................85 Annex 3 Intervention Logic .................................................................102 Annex 4 Methodology...........................................................................131 Annex 5 Project Analysis & List of Projects......................................165 Annex 6 Background to the Region ....................................................193 Annex 7 List of documents...................................................................213 Annex 8 Desk Analysis of CSP/NIPs for the SADC Region .............221 Annex 9 Country and Sector Reports from Field Visits ...................261 Annex 10 List of persons met...............................................................352 Final Report - Volume 2 October 2007 Annexes – page i Evaluation of the Commission’s Regional Support to SADC DRN-ADE-ECO-ECORYS-NCG Final Report - Volume 2 October 2007 Annexes – page ii Evaluation of the Commission’s Regional Support to SADC DRN-ADE-ECO-ECORYS-NCG Annex 1 Evaluation Questions Table of contents Introduction................................................................................................................3 EQ 1 ...........................................................................................................................5 EQ 2.........................................................................................................................13 EQ 3.........................................................................................................................16 EQ 4.........................................................................................................................19 EQ 5.........................................................................................................................30 EQ 6.........................................................................................................................44 EQ 7.........................................................................................................................51 EQ 8.........................................................................................................................67 EQ 9.........................................................................................................................71 EQ 10.......................................................................................................................76 List of Figures Figure 1: The main challenges for SA SMEs exporting to the EU..............................22 Figure 2: Constraints to Foreign Investment in SADC................................................24 Figure 3: Investments in Sub-Saharan Africa..............................................................25 Figure 4: Export of goods 2000 and 2005 ...................................................................41 Figure 5: Import of goods 2000 and 2005 ...................................................................41 Figure 6: Corruption Perception Index ........................................................................55 Figure 7: Corruption Perception Index for EC Member States ...................................55 Figure 8: Life expectancy trends..................................................................................59 Figure 9: GDP annual percent change .........................................................................77 Figure 10: GDP based on purchasing-power-parity ....................................................79 Figure 11: Human Poverty Index.................................................................................81 Final Report - Volume 2 October 2007 Annex 1 - page 1 Evaluation of the Commission’s Regional Support to SADC DRN-ADE-ECO-ECORYS-NCG List of Tables Table 1: Index of Economic Freedoms: Trade ...........................................................21 Table 2: Macroeconomic Convergence .......................................................................26 Table 3: Economic freedoms: Investments..................................................................27 Table 4: Status of road sector institutional reforms primo 2006 .................................32 Table 5: EC Support to Development of Corridors .....................................................37 Table 6: Adult (15 - 49 years) Prevalence Rate in SADC Region, 2003 and 2005.....58 Table 7: Summary Table of the AIDS Epidemic in the SADC Region.......................60 Table 8:Percentage of HIV-infected adults receiving ARV’s in selected SADC member states, end 2005......................................................................................60 Table 9: SADC Trade Flows 1998 and 2002...............................................................71 List of Text Boxes Box 1: The Ten Evaluation Questions...........................................................................4 Box 2: Relation between RISDP and 9th EDF RSP/RIP................................................6 Box 3: EPRD Contributions to RIP .............................................................................10 Box 4: From Gaborone to Paris and Back. ..................................................................18 Box 5: EDF contributions to Transport Corridors.......................................................36 Box 6:Using regional integration to improve financial services for the poor..............84 List of Diagrams Diagram 1: Objective hierarchy of the logframe objective to the evaluation criteria .20 Diagram 2: Tools of evaluation during the field phase................................................21 Final Report - Volume 2 October 2007 Annex 1 - page 2 Evaluation of the Commission’s Regional Support to SADC DRN-ADE-ECO-ECORYS-NCG INTRODUCTION This annex contains the data supporting the responses to the ten evaluation questions, which guided the Evaluation of the Commission’s support to the Southern African Development Community (SADC). The text of the ten evaluation questions, as approved during the Desk Phase, and around which the Evaluation was structured, is shown in the table on the next page. Accordingly, this Annex is divided into ten main sub-sections, each of which covers one Evaluation Question. The responses to the evaluation questions are based on a set of judgement criteria elaborated during the Evaluation’s Desk Phase. Each of these Judgement Criteria contains a number of Indicators, which contribute to addressing each judgement criterion. The indicators have been used to structure the data made available to the Evaluation Team during the Desk and Field Phases. Based on these data, responses have been formulated for each of the Evaluation Questions. These responses are contained in Chapter 6 of the Main Report. Supporting data on which this annex draws are to be found in: Annex 3: Intervention Logic Annex 5: List of Projects Annex 6: Background to the Region Annex 8: Desk Analysis of CSP/NIPs for the SADC Region Annex 9: Country and Sector Reports from the Field Visits In addition, Annex 7 contains a list of reference documents and documents which were consulted during the evaluation. It may be noted in particular that the information contained in Annex 9 is a result of those interviews carried out with the persons and institutions detailed in Annex 10 (List of persons met). Team members asked respondents for their views and, in order to allow for an as free and frank a discussion as possible, it was agreed that the remarks would be non-attributable. In addition, many of the points included in Annex 9 were made by several commentators – and hence, direct citing of individuals has mostly been avoided. Final Report - Volume 2 October 2007 Annex 1 - page 3 Evaluation of the Commission’s Regional Support to SADC DRN-ADE-ECO-ECORYS-NCG Box 1: The Ten Evaluation Questions To what extent are the conceived interventions of the Commission’s