DOCSLIB.ORG

Download (815Kb)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Download (815Kb) Harada, Koji (2010) A study of the origin of Scottish Presbyterianism (1560-1638). MTh(R) thesis. http://theses.gla.ac.uk/1655/ Copyright and moral rights for this thesis are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the Author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the Author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Glasgow Theses Service http://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] A STUDY OF THE ORIGIN OF SCOTTISH PRESBYTERIANISM (1560-1638) BY KOJI HARADA FREE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND COLLEGE A thesis submitted to the Senate of Free Church College, And to University of Glasgow for the degree of Master of Theology September 2009 © Koji Harada 2009 i Declaration I declare that I have composed this thesis, A Study of the Origin of Scottish Presbyterianism (1560-1638), and that it is my own work, that it has not been submitted in whole or in part for any other degree or professional qualification, and that all sources used or quoted have been indicated and specifically acknowledged. KOJI HARADA ii Acknowledgements I owe a debt of gratitude to a host of people without whom the completion of this thesis would not be possible. On completion of this study I would like to express my appreciation, first of all, to Prof. John R. McIntosh for his patience and guidance, as my supervisor. His pastoral kindness enabled me to accomplish my study. Any shortcomings are, of course, entirely mine. Furthermore, acknowledgement is due to the professors and my colleagues of Free Church College for their warm fellowship and kind friendship. Research work is generally a lonely experience. However, fellowship with them encouraged me and sustained my study. I especially thank my friend from Singapore, Winston Tay, for his friendship to me as both a colleague and a roommate at Montpelier. And I thank the principal Donald MacLeod for granting me entrance to study at Free Church College, so that I could have such an enriching experience in Edinburgh. Furthermore, there are people in Japan who played an important part in making the completion of this dissertation possible. I thank Rev. Professor Yasuhiro Sekikawa, who instructed and baptized me into the Christian faith. He was also my supervisor when I was a candidate for the ministry at Tokyo Union Theological Seminary. I am grateful for his guidance and for his constant support. He has also been instrumental in my attraction to Scottish church history and theology. Thanks is also due to all members of Tondabayashi Church in the United Church of Christ in Japan, where I served as a minister for more than six years from 2001 to 2007, and to my mother Mitsuno Harada, and elder brother Masanobu Harada. I owe much gratitude for their support to my study in Edinburgh. Finally, I give thanks to God, who lead me to Scotland and gave me wonderful fellowship with good international friends, and sustained me even in the times of depression, encouraging me to continue studying. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................... iv CHAPTER ONE: The Eve of Scottish Presbyterianism I: Religious Situations of the pre-1560 period in Scotland................................................ 1 II: The ‘Superintendent’ ....................................................................................................... 6 1. The Purpose of the Office of Superintendent...........................................................................................7 2. Functions of Superintendent .............................................................................................................................9 1. Preacher of the Gospel ..................................................................................................................................10 2. Admission..............................................................................................................................................................11 3. Oversight ...............................................................................................................................................................13 3. Abolition of the Superintendent .....................................................................................................................15 III: The ‘Exercise’ ................................................................................................................. 19 1. Biblical foundation ..................................................................................................................................................20 2. Roots in the Reformed tradition .......................................................................................................................21 3. Purpose of its institution........................................................................................................................................23 4. Transformation of the exercise .........................................................................................................................26 1. Obligation of Attendance..............................................................................................................................26 2. An Administrative Body ..............................................................................................................................27 CHAPTER TWO: Reconstruction of the System of the Church -Forming process of the ‘Second Book of Discipline’ and its contents I: Reasons for Revision: A Post-Reformation Standstill ......................................... 31 II: The Making of the ‘Second Book of Discipline’ by the General Assembly ................ 34 1. 1575 - Precursors to the Reconstruction Begun at the General Assembly of 1576 ...................34 2. 1576 - Organization of the Special Committee to draft the New Church Government............37 3. 1577 - Discussions in the General Assemblies concerning the Draft................................................40 4. 1578 - Approval for the revised Draft which was to be the ‘Second Book of Discipline’........43 III: A survey of the Contents of the Second Book of Discipline........................................... 46 1. The composition .......................................................................................................................................................47 2. Chapter I: Church and State................................................................................................................................49 3. Chapter II, III, VI and VIII: The Offices in the Church ....................................................................50 4. Chapter VII: Ecclesiastical Courts .................................................................................................................54 5. Chapter XII: Plea for Further Reformation ...............................................................................................55 iv CHAPTER THREE: the Eldership in the Scottish Reformation and the Formation of the Presbytery I: Examination of the ‘Eldership’ in the Scottish Reformation .................................... 59 1. The ‘Eldership’ in the Second Book of Discipline ...........................................................................59 2. The ‘Eldership’ in Other Reformed Traditions during the Sixteenth Century................. 62 3. Comparison to ‘Eldership’ in the First Book of Discipline..........................................................69 II: The Idea of ‘Ane Common Eldership’ in the Second Book of Discipline ..................74 1. James Kirk’s Analysis of the Emergence of the Idea of ‘Ane Common Eldership’.....74 2. The Exercise and Synods in Relation to the Common Eldership.............................................78 1 The Exercise during the 1570s .................................................................................................................78 2 The Synod in Sixteenth Century...............................................................................................................80 III: Process for Inauguration of ‘Presbytery’ by the General Assemblies (1579-1581)...84 1. 1579 .............................................................................................................................................................................84 2. 1580 .............................................................................................................................................................................86 3. 1581 .............................................................................................................................................................................89 IV: Inauguration of Stirling Presbytery in August 1581 ..................................................93 CHAPTER FOUR: The Development of Presbyteries (1581 - 1638) -The Growth of the Presbyterian Powerbase in the Age of Conflict I: Historical Survey of the Period between 1581 and 1638 ............................................99 II: Presbyterian Polity during 1581 and 1638 ...............................................................105
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Memorial Volume of St. Andrews University In
    DUPLICATE FROM THE UNIVERSITY LIBRARY, ST. ANDREWS, SCOTLAND. GIFT OF VOTIVA TABELLA H H H The Coats of Arms belong respectively to Alexander Stewart, natural son James Kennedy, Bishop of St of James IV, Archbishop of St Andrews 1440-1465, founder Andrews 1509-1513, and John Hepburn, Prior of St Andrews of St Salvator's College 1482-1522, cofounders of 1450 St Leonard's College 1512 The University- James Beaton, Archbishop of St Sir George Washington Andrews 1 522-1 539, who com- Baxter, menced the foundation of St grand-nephew and representative Mary's College 1537; Cardinal of Miss Mary Ann Baxter of David Beaton, Archbishop 1539- Balgavies, who founded 1546, who continued his brother's work, and John Hamilton, Arch- University College bishop 1 546-1 57 1, who com- Dundee in pleted the foundation 1880 1553 VOTIVA TABELLA A MEMORIAL VOLUME OF ST ANDREWS UNIVERSITY IN CONNECTION WITH ITS QUINCENTENARY FESTIVAL MDCCCCXI MCCCCXI iLVal Quo fit ut omnis Votiva pateat veluti descripta tabella Vita senis Horace PRINTED FOR THE UNIVERSITY BY ROBERT MACLEHOSE AND COMPANY LIMITED MCMXI GIF [ Presented by the University PREFACE This volume is intended primarily as a book of information about St Andrews University, to be placed in the hands of the distinguished guests who are coming from many lands to take part in our Quincentenary festival. It is accordingly in the main historical. In Part I the story is told of the beginning of the University and of its Colleges. Here it will be seen that the University was the work in the first instance of Churchmen unselfishly devoted to the improvement of their country, and manifesting by their acts that deep interest in education which long, before John Knox was born, lay in the heart of Scotland.
    [Show full text]
  • Aberdeen's 'Toun College': Marischal College, 1593- 1623
    Reid, S.J. (2007) Aberdeen's 'Toun College': Marischal College, 1593- 1623. Innes Review, 58 (2). pp. 173-195. ISSN 0020-157X http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/8119/ Deposited on: 06 November 2009 Enlighten – Research publications by members of the University of Glasgow http://eprints.gla.ac.uk The Innes Review vol. 58 no. 2 (Autumn 2007) 173–195 DOI: 10.3366/E0020157X07000054 Steven John Reid Aberdeen’s ‘Toun College’: Marischal College, 1593–1623 Introduction While debate has arisen in the past two decades regarding the foundation of Edinburgh University, by contrast the foundation and early development of Marischal College, Aberdeen, has received little attention. This is particularly surprising when one considers it is perhaps the closest Scottish parallel to the Edinburgh foundation. Founded in April 1593 by George Keith, fifth Earl Marischal in the burgh of New Aberdeen ‘to do the utmost good to the Church, the Country and the Commonwealth’,1 like Edinburgh Marischal was a new type of institution that had more in common with the Protestant ‘arts colleges’ springing up across the continent than with the papally sanctioned Scottish universities of St Andrews, Glasgow and King’s College in Old Aberdeen.2 James Kirk is the most recent in a long line of historians to argue that the impetus for founding ‘ane college of theologe’ in Edinburgh in 1579 was carried forward by the radical presbyterian James Lawson, which led to the eventual opening on 14 October 1583 of a liberal arts college in the burgh, as part of an educational reform programme devised and rolled out across the Scottish universities by the divine and educational reformer, Andrew Melville.3 However, in a self-professedly revisionist article Michael Lynch has argued that the college settlement was far more protracted and contingent on burgh politics than the simple insertion of a one-size 1 Fasti Academiae Mariscallanae Aberdonensis: Selections from the Records of the Marischal College and University, MDXCIII–MDCCCLX, ed.
    [Show full text]
  • 107394589.23.Pdf
    Scs s-r<?s/ &.c £be Scottish tlert Society SATIRICAL POEMS OF THE TIME OF THE REFORMATION SATIRICAL POEMS OF THE TIME OF THE REFORMATION EDITED BY JAMES CRANSTOUN, LL.D. VOL. II. ('library''. ) Printcti fat tljt Sacietg Iig WILLIAM BLACKWOOD AND SONS EDINBURGH AND LONDON MDCCCXCIII V PREFATORY NOTE TO VOL. II. The present volume is for the most part occupied with Notes and Glossary. Two poems by Thomas Churchyard — “ The Siege of Edenbrough Castell ” and “ Mvrtons Tragedie ”—have been included, as possessing considerable interest of themselves, and as illustrating two important poems in the collection. A complete Index of Proper Names has also been given. By some people, I am aware, the Satirical Poems of the Time of the Reformation that have come down to us through black- letter broadsheets are considered as of little consequence, and at best only “sorry satire.” But researches in the collections of historical manuscripts preserved in the State-Paper Office and the British Museum have shown that, however deficient these ballads may be in the element of poetry, they are eminently trustworthy, and thus have an unmistakable value, as contemporary records. A good deal of pains has accordingly been taken, by reference to accredited authorities, to explain unfamiliar allusions and clear up obscure points in the poems. It is therefore hoped that not many difficulties remain to perplex the reader. A few, however, have defied solution. To these, as they occurred, I have called attention in the notes, with a view to their being taken up by others who, with greater knowledge of the subject or ampler facilities for research than I possess, may be able to elucidate them.
    [Show full text]
  • JD Article for New College Anniversary Bulletin April 2006
    Article for New College Anniversary Bulletin April 2006 Teaching theology in Edinburgh: beginnings The teaching of theology and divinity has a very long history in Edinburgh, of which the New College phase only forms the latest chapter. In the sense of formal theological instruction, it was the Dominicans who began the tradition when their Edinburgh friary was founded in 1230, the first to be opened in Scotland. The Blackfriars buildings were in the Cowgate and by the sixteenth century they included a particularly fine hall, spacious enough to be the meeting place for the Councils of the Scottish Church called in 1549, 1552 and 1559 that produced reforming statutes and Archbishop Hamilton's Catechism. The hall was probably used on a daily basis to accommodate part of the comprehensive educational training undertaken by the friars, but they generously made way each year for the Scottish Exchequer and its accounting sessions. As the most commodious roofed space in Edinburgh, apart from the Castle and Holyrood, the Blackfriars hall was in considerable demand and it was at the heart of the famous 'Cleanse the Causeway' fight in 1520. During the 1550s there were attempts to make more provision for higher education in the capital. One initiative came from the Queen Regent, Mary of Guise, mother of Mary, Queen of Scots, who founded two public lectureships, one in Greek and another in civil and canon law, both regarded at the time as ecclesiastical subjects. The second initiative flowed from the noted humanist Robert Reid, bishop of Orkney, who left provision in his will in 1558 for a college with a distinctly non-clerical emphasis to be erected in Edinburgh to teach the 'new learning'.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Download
    Arthur Williamson IRSS 36 (2011) 7 THE RISE AND DECLINE OF THE BRITISH “PATRIOT”: CIVIC BRITAIN, C.1545-1605 Arthur Williamson* In 1586 David Hume of Godscroft recorded (and no doubt embellished) a dialogue that he had with his patron Archibald Douglas, the 8th earl of Angus. Both men were about thirty, Hume the rising intellectual star of the Presbyterian movement, Angus its political powerhouse, by far the mightiest and the most committed of the radical lords. For several years Hume had served as Angus’ amanuensis, preceptor, companion. Together they had returned from exile in England shortly before, as part of a coup d’etat that overthrew the conservative regime of James Stewart, earl of Arran, and Patrick Adamson, archbishop of St. Andrews. The dialogue argued that it would not do simply to be restored to one’s estates and earlier status. For the “good patriot” bore a far greater responsibility: participating actively in political decisions, protecting liberty, promoting the “publick cause.” “Activenesse” was required. One needed to restrain particular interests, personal preoccupations, and private passions, and direct oneself to common purposes and society as a whole. That responsibility, the dialogue further insisted, could extend to revolution – as in fact had just happened. “Tyrants will call a good patriot, a seditious fellow.”1 Hume’s dialogue provides one of the earliest instances of the Anglophone neologism “patriot” used to describe a * Arthur Williamson is Professor of History at California State University, Sacramento. His most recent book is Apocalypse Then: Prophecy and the Making of the Modern World (Greenwood-Praeger, 2008).
    [Show full text]
  • The Medical History of John Knox
    Proc. R. Coll. Physicians Edinb. 1998; 28: 81-101 THE MEDICAL HISTORY OF JOHN KNOX J. Wilkinson,* 70 Craigleith Hill Gardens, Edinburgh EH4 2DH One of the most striking monuments in the city of Geneva is the large and extensive memorial to the leaders of the Reformation in Europe. This monument took eight years to complete and was finally unveiled and dedicated in the year 1917 in the midst of the First World War. The central group of statues of this monument commemorates the Swiss Reformers and includes a statue of John Knox, which is a reminder of the significant part that Knox played in the Swiss Reformation in addition to his vital role in the Reformation in Scotland. John Knox was the last of the three great leaders of the European Protestant Reformation to die. On 18 February 1546, Martin Luther died at the age of 63 in Eisleben in Eastern Germany of myocardial infarction, secondary to systemic hypertension. John Calvin died at the age of 54 in Geneva on 27 May 1564 of pulmonary tuberculosis.2 Knox was 57 years old when he died in Edinburgh on 24 November 1572. Although some specific clinical details of the cause of his death have come down to us, very few details are available of his medical history during the course of his life. THE SOURCES The main primary source of our information about the life and activities of John Knox is in his own writings. These were collected and edited by David Laing in six volumes under the title The Works of John Knox, and published in Edinburgh over the years 1846 to 1864.
    [Show full text]
  • UC.-MASOM John Knox
    UC.-MASOM John Knox By J. D. Mackie Price One Shilling and Sixpence G 20 Historical Association 1951 \L SERIES : G.20 John Knox By J. D. Mackie, C.B.E., M.A., LL.D. Professor of Scottish History, University of Glasgow. Non-members may obtain copies at Is. 8d. each (post free), and members may obtain extra copies at lid. each (post free) from the Hon. Secretary of the Historical Association, 21, Bedford Square, London, W.C.I. Published for The Historical Association by George Philip & Son, Ltd. 32, Fleet Street, London, E.C.4 1951 i COPYRIGHT By the Historical Association 1951 John Knox DURING his own lifetime John Knox was engaged in violent dis- putes, and throughout the succeeding ages his character has been the subject of acrimonious controversy. To some of his con- temporaries he appeared as the apostle of eternal truth divinely inspired, to others as an architect of evil. Later ages saw him variously as a stirrer-up of strife, the founder of the protestant kirk, the perverter of reform into devious ways, the father of intolerance, the hero of the everlasting verity, the destroyer of the old and the beautiful. For centuries he was, despite all criticism, one of the heroes of Scotland. Latterly there has been an attempt to show him as the man who robbed Scotland of her heritage of art and enjoyment and plunged her into the ugly gloom of a perpetual Sabbath wherein the Calvinistic elect found their main pleasure in denouncing the shortcomings of blinded ritualists. And now the wheel comes round full circle.
    [Show full text]
  • 108111345.23.Pdf
    Given by Mrs R Killick. v- '<V; ED. TUB UR G-BL From "fhe C aXtccn "Ell. TRADITIONS 0 ©jjronologtcallji glrrangrtf, FROM TITE FOUNDATION OF THE CITY IN THE YEAR 626 THE UNION OF SCOTLAND & ENGLAND IN 1707. 5«on6 Ebttion, rtbiaeS anij grcatlg entargra. WITH AN APPENDIX, CONTAINING CURIOUS AND INTERESTING INFORMATION. EDINBURGH: WILLIAM RUTHERFORD, 45 PRINCES STREET. MDCCCXLVIir. '■/ D ^ ■'oo20 Mr ^n O, -o3 75 'N il^ PREFACE. The Annals of the city of Edinburgh, previous to the union of Scotland and England, are so closely inter- woven with national events, that it requires nice discern- ment to separate them. In detailing national occurrences in this work, the author has been influenced by a con- sideration, either of their intrinsic importance or their connection with the capital. To the original and authentic sources of information, the author has, in every possible instance resorted; but every history must of necessity be drawn chiefly from documents already in possession of the public. For the accuracy of the facts related, authors have been quoted who either lived at or near the time the events hap- pened. In this work is given, an account of the origin of the city and castle of Edinburgh, the time when and by whom the city was founded, with an historical account of the public and memorable events connected with the capital,from its foundation to the year 1846, among which, IV PREFACE. the transactions of the citizens with the kings of Scotland, bear a prominent part. There is also given a minute and comprehensive development of its ancient and present ecclesiastical, municipal, church, and military govern- ment; public amusements, charitable institutions, semi- naries of learning, societies, clubs, and public establish- ments; the constitution of the supreme courts of justice, improvements on the city, &c.
    [Show full text]
  • Owners of Guild's Books
    FORMER OWNERS OF GUILD’S BOOKS Positive identification of former owners of books is a hazardous affair, with the attractive option not always being the correct one. This list of former owners of William Guild‟s books should be treated with some caution, therefore, since while some owners can be positively identified, there are others about which it is impossible to be certain. Standard sources have been used and acknowledged; full details can be found in the bibliography, also to be found on this website [insert web address here]. The numbers following the references relate to the catalogue of Guild‟s books [insert web address here]. Aberdeen, King‟s College. The core of the first library of King‟s College, Aberdeen, was a gift from the personal library of the college‟s founder, Bishop William Elphinstone; it was managed by Hector Boece (c.1465-1536), the first principal and de facto librarian. The foundation charter for the college was granted in 1505. Boece‟s position as librarian is evident from his signatures and comments on many of its early volumes. Unsurprisingly, books found their way into the personal collections of masters of the University such as Guild, who did not scruple to pass them elsewhere. (Kennedy, II, pp. 366-68) (64) Aberdeen, Dominicans. Said to have been founded c. 1230-50 by Alexander II. A prior and thirteen friars were in residence in 1503, but the house was destroyed by the Reformers in 1560. Its possessions were granted to George Earl of Marischal in 1587, who bestowed them on Marischal College as part of its endowment.
    [Show full text]
  • Receiving Christ Better: the Eucharistic Theology of Robert Bruce
    REFORMED THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY RECEIVING CHRIST BETTER: THE EUCHARISTIC THEOLOGY OF ROBERT BRUCE Thesis Paper Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Course 0CE751 Integrative Thesis by Jeffrey T. Hamling March 2006 To my wife Annmaire, who daily helps me to receive Christ better. 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ………………………………………………………………. 2 CHAPTERS 1. Four Views of the Lord’s Supper ……………………………………...… 11 2. The Modern Reformed Church and The Mystery of the Lord’s Supper …. 14 3. The Calvinistic Historical Context of Robert Bruce …………………….. 25 4. Definition of a Sacrament ……………………………………………….. 34 5. The Sacramental Union and Presence of Christ ……………………….... 44 6. The Relationship between the Word and the Sacrament ……………...… 70 CONCLUSION ………………………………………………………………….. 85 APPENDIX: Pastoral Considerations …………………….……………………... 87 BIBLIOGRAPHY ……………………………………………………………….. 108 2 INTRODUCTION The Reverend Robert Bruce, at the age of seventy-seven, had just completed his normal helping of breakfast at his home in Edinburgh, Scotland, when he called to his youngest daughter Martha to bring him another egg. 1 After musing in silence for a minute or two, he suddenly called out, “Hold, daughter, hold; my Master calleth me.” 2 Next, according to historian D. C. MacNicol, He asked that the Bible should be brought, the large house Bible, but his sight failed him, and he could not read. “Cast me up the 8 th of Romans,” cried he, and he repeated much of the latter portion of this scripture, till he came to the last two verses, “I am persuaded that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor powers, nor things present, not things to come, nor height, nor depth, nor any other creature, shall be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.” “Set my finger on these words,” said the blind dying man: “God be with you my children.
    [Show full text]
  • 314 Proceedings of the Society, May 10, 1926. Scotland's Supplication And
    314 PROCEEDINGS OF THE SOCIETY, MAY 10, 1926. II. SCOTLAND'S SUPPLICATIO COMPLAIND NAN T AGAINST THE BOOK OP COMMON PRAYER (OTHERWISE LAUD'S LITURGY), THE BOO E PRELATESP CANONSO KTH D AN , , 18TH OCTOBER 1637. BY D. HAY FLEMING, LL.D., F.S.A.ScoT. This remarkabl importand an e t document would l probabilityal n i , , have crosse e Atlanticdth found an , a permanend t homet i there d ha , not been for the foresight of Mr George P. Johnston and the open-handed patriotism of Dr W. B. Blaikie. Thanks to the Secretary for Scotland, deposites wa Registee t f Decembei th o n di h 7t r e Housrth 1925n o ed ,an there it is safe for all time coming.; Historical students will find the beautiful full-sized facsimile, which Dr Blaikie has generously had made, quite sufficien r workinfo t g purposes e originath t bu ;l itsel s opei f o nt all reasonable inspection in the Register House. The three grievances petitioned against were (1) The Book of Common Prayer, better s Laud'knowa w sno n Liturgye Book f Th Canons,o ) (2 , and (3) the Archbishops and Bishops. To understand how in these the shoe pinched s necessari t i , looo t y ke earl bacth yo kt histor cond yan - stitution of the Reformed Church of Scotland. A Confession Johns—Knoxx f si Faitho e th drawy b p u n, Wynram, Spottiswoode, Willock, Douglas Row—wad an , s approve ratified an d y db Parliament on the 17th of August 1560—that is, four months before the meeting of the First General Assembly.
    [Show full text]
  • Steven J. Reid Phd Thesis
    EDUCATION IN POST-REFORMATION SCOTLAND: ANDREW MELVILLE AND THE UNIVERSITY OF ST ANDREWS, 1560-1606 Steven J. Reid A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of St. Andrews 2008 Full metadata for this item is available in Research@StAndrews:FullText at: http://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/ Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/10023/849 This item is protected by original copyright Steven John Reid Education in Post-Reformation Scotland: Andrew Melville and the University of St Andrews, 1560-1606 A thesis submitted for the degree of PhD in History at the University of St Andrews August 2008 i Abstract Andrew Melville (1545-1622) was the leader of the Presbyterian wing of the Scottish Kirk between 1574 and 1607, and he and his colleagues were a perpetual irritant to James VI and I in his attempts to establish a royal and Episcopal dominance over the Kirk. Yet much of Melville’s reputation has been based on the seventeenth-century Presbyterian historical narratives written by the likes of James Melville (Andrew’s nephew) and David Calderwood. These partisan accounts formed the basis of modern historiography in Thomas M’Crie’s monumentally influential Life of Andrew Melville . Modern historians broadly agree that Melville’s portrayal as a powerful and decisive church leader in these narratives is greatly exaggerated, and that he was at best an influential voice in the Kirk who was quickly marginalised by the adult James VI. However, only James Kirk has commented at any length on Melville’s other role in Jacobean Scotland—that of developing and reforming the Scottish universities.
    [Show full text]