European Neighbourhood Policy: Political, Economic and Social Issues New Insiders and Outsiders (Haukkala, 2003:5)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
EUROPEAN NEIGHBOURHOOD POLICY: POLITICAL, ECONOMIC A ND SOCIAL ISSUES Edited by Fulvio Attinà and Rosa Rossi The Jean Monnet Centre “Euro-Med” Department of Political Studies A publication of the Project The European Union Neighbourhood Policy of the Faculty of Political Sciences of the University of Catania, cofinanced by the European Commission Jean Monnet Project – Heading A-3022 Catania, 2004 October 2004 The Jean Monnet Centre “Euro med” Dipartimento Studi Politici Via Vittorio Emanuele, 49 95131 Catania (Italy) PREFACE This book gives to the reader the opportunity of examining some important issues and problems of the new political initiative of the European Union known as the European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP). The publication of the book is the result of an important project of the Faculty of Political Sciences of the University of Catania. A grant of the European Commission Jean Monnet Project – Heading A-3022 (Support for European integration activities organised by the academic world, 2003) covered the fifty per cent of the costs of the Project but this Project belongs to a long tradition of studies in the Faculty. The University of Catania is innately concerned with the development of the relations between European Union and Mediterranean countries. The Faculty of Political Sciences has been constantly supporting research on Mediterranean politics, history and economy. However, this book and the Project that shaped this book are a step forward to renovate this practice and bring it up to the present challenges. Over the last ten years, the change of Europe and the surrounding areas has been creating new conditions, problems and responsibilities. The new European Neighbourhood Policy is the outco- me of this change in terms of policy action of the European Union. To match with the change, the Faculty of Political Sciences decided to create this research project. The main aim of the Project was to create a group of researchers concerned with the broad area of the analysis of the problems of the relations between European Union and neighbouring countries. The true challenge of the Project, however, has been networking young researchers of the EU and non-EU countries in order to make a screening of the problems they recognize as crucial in the European Neighbourhood Policy. Indeed, the Project was not invented to diffuse ideas and strategies cooked-in- Brussels but create a community of scientists engaged in the study of neighbourhood building. The young researchers got knowledge and experience from the analyses provided by senior scientists that represented various disciplines as well as different EU and non-EU countries. Some of them have contributed to this book. The Faculty of Political Sciences believes that the Project has been an effort to give impetus to the study of ENP. Her aspiration is also to contribute to the venture of making friendship and cooperation between the peoples of Europe and nearby countries a real fact. Giuseppe Vecchio The Dean of the Faculty of Political Sciences 3 Table of contents Preface, Giuseppe VECCHIO 3 List of contributors 6 INTRODUCTION The European Neighbourhood Policy in Perspective Rosa ROSSI 8 POLITICAL AND INSTITUTIONAL ISSUES European Neighbourhood Policy and the Building of Security around Europe Fulvio ATTINÀ 16 The European Security Strategy and the Neighbourhood Policy: A New Starting Point for a Euro-Mediterranean Security Partnership? Sven BISCOP 25 The EU and Democracy Promotion: A Strategy of Democratization in the framework of Neighbourhood Policy? Elena BARACANI 37 European Union’s Regional Approach towards its Neighbours: The European Neighbourhood Policy vis-à-vis Euro- Mediterranean Partnership Manuela MOSCHELLA 58 ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ISSUES Enhancing Neighbourhood Policy through FDI Ali HEMAL 68 Foreign Direct Investment in the European Union’s Mediterranean Neighbours. Past Trends and Future Potential in the MEDA Region Brian PORTELLI 72 EU-Russian Economic Cooperation: the Prospect of Development Oleg AKATOV 85 Regional Cooperation under the EU Neighbourhood Policy Ekaterina DOMORENOK 89 SOCIAL AND CULTURAL ISSUES The Integration of the Republic of Moldova in the European Union: Problems and Solutions Diana BENCHECI 102 Vers une Nouvelle Europe des Migrations et du Bon Voisinage Tahar HAFFAD 111 Muslim Migration to the European Union Liudmila KUDRINA 117 Interaction of the Educational Policy of Ukraine with the EU Neighbourhood Policy in the Context of the Bologna Process Olena SHESTAVINA 131 Towards a European Perspective for the Common Mediterranean House and the Positive Social Development Capability of Islamic Countries Arno TAUSCH 145 5 List of contributors Oleg AKATOV, MGIMO, Moscow Fulvio ATTINÀ, University of Catania Elena BARACANI, University of Firenze Diana BENCHECI, Academy of Sciences of Moldova Sven BISCOP, Royal Institute for International Relations, Brussels Ekaterina DOMORENOK, University of Siena Tahar HAFFAD, University of Batna Ali HEMAL, University of Batna Liudmila KUDRINA, MGIMO, Moscow Manuela MOSCHELLA, University of Catania Brian PORTELLI, University of Oslo Rosa ROSSI, University of Catania Olena SHESTAVINA, Donetsk National University Arno TAUSCH, Ministry of Social Security and Generations in Vienna, Austria, and Innsbruck University 6 INTRODUCTION THE EUROPEAN NEIGHBOURHOOD POLICY IN PERSPECTIVE Rosa ROSSI This book focuses thematically on issues relating to the European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP). The ENP is conside- red a response to the new challenges and opportunities that the European Union (EU) has to address after the historic enlargement on May 1st 2004. The new EU with 25 member states and with its extended borders is facing both internal and external relevant developments and needs accordingly to reframe its external relations. The new geopolitical environment increases the importance for the EU to establish innovative forms of cooperation within its new geographic proximities, considering the fact that EU’s most successful instrument to build cooperation - the prospect of membership – is not anymore sustainable. Quoting Chris Patten: “Over the past decade, the Union’s most successful foreign policy instrument has undeniably been the promise of EU membership. This is not sustainable. For the coming decade, we need to find new ways to export the stability, security and prosperity we have created within the enlarged EU. We should begin by agreeing on a clearer vision for relations with our neighbours”1 . Or again referring to the Commission’s Communication on Wider Europe where it is stated that: “the incentive for reform created by the prospect of membership has proved to be strong – enlargement has unarguably been the Union’s most successful foreign policy instrument” (European Commission, 2003a). Political conditionality seems to work when the “carrot is enticing enough” (Haukkala, 2003: 12). Candidate governments overcame domestic resistance against political and economic reforms and accepted the Acquis Communautaire for the incentives of full membership (Wallace, 2003: 3). However, the Commission realised that the enlargement cannot be extended to the infinite. The integration process will loose of the selectiveness and meaning that are drawn from creating distinctions in terms not only of territorial boundaries, but also of normative ones. Not to consider the institutional overstretch and the EU structures viability in facing an everlasting enlargement. As pointed out by Romano Prodi, “we cannot go on enlarging forever. We cannot water down the European political project and turn the European Union into just a free trade area on a continental scale” (Prodi, 2002). What is needed, then, is to draw on successful experiences with new Member States, and exporting these experiences to other countries, however, without prospecting the membership. Neighbourhood Cooperation Background EU’s interest in developing close cooperative relationships with near countries is not obviously a novelty within EU’s external actions and has been a top priority also in the past. Expressly, after the end of the Cold War the EU has fostered regional cooperation, in a context that was facing what has been considered a new wave of regionalism2 (Mansfield and Milner, 1999). New regionalism becomes an attempt to “regain some measures of political control over processes of economic globalization that have curtailed national policy instruments” (Katzenstein, 1996:127). In order to face problems derived from the new global trends governments promote cooperation with neighbourhood countries, as they find that “a neighbour’s action or inaction on a cross-border problem directly affect their own policies” (Attinà, 2003:183), and therefore “to provide states with political stability, people with personal security, societies with economic growth, and groups with social and cultural protection, cooperation with neighbouring countries is of the greatest importance to national policy makers” (Attinà, 2003:183). Regional approach has undeniably become a key factor of EU’s own identity. Regional cooperation is defined by the Commission as a “general concept that refers to all efforts on the part of (usually) neighbouring countries to address issues of common interest” (European Commission, 1995). This definition implies that the EU should clarify the classification of neighbouring countries and the meaning of common interests. These notions are not fixed forever and came across a continuing redefinition over the time. For instance, recently there