Faith, Race, and Identity As Reflected in Spanish Diplomacy During the Reign of Charles V

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Faith, Race, and Identity As Reflected in Spanish Diplomacy During the Reign of Charles V A Distorted Mirror: Faith, Race, and Identity as Reflected in Spanish Diplomacy during the Reign of Charles V by Alex Wall A Thesis presented to The University of Guelph In partial fulfilment of requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History Guelph, Ontario, Canada © Alex Wall, May, 2021 ABSTRACT A DISTORTED MIRROR: FAITH, RACE, AND IDENTITY AS REFLECTED IN SPANISH DIPLOMACY DURING THE REIGN OF CHARLES V Alex Wall Advisors: University of Guelph, 2021 Professor Susannah Ferreira Professor Karen Racine This thesis examines how the ministers and officials of Charles V sought to cultivate a specific state identity that defined Spain and its people against non-Christian ‘Others’—namely the Jews, conversos, and Moriscos of Iberia, as well as the Lutheran heretics of Europe. These officials utilised various narratives and policies that emphasised the ideas of Christian purity and crusade, thus building off of the work done by the Catholic Monarchs. Charles V and his ambassadors expressed these narratives on the stage of European diplomacy and projected Spain’s state identity abroad. More importantly, this thesis explores how these ambassadors were often challenged in their attempts to define Spain on the world stage, as the foreigners they encountered presented them with counter-narratives that destabilised their image. Such counter- narratives often played upon the contradictions and complexities that were inherent in Spanish society regarding its constructions of religious and ‘racial’ barriers. The clashes between the Spaniards who sought to defend Spain and its reputation and those who disparaged it demonstrate the weakness of Spanish state-identity during the reign of Charles, as well as the anxieties that Spain’s ambassadors often felt when projecting Spain’s image abroad. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank my supervisor Dr. Susannah Ferreira for her invaluable help and advice during the course of my Master’s Degree. I would also like to thank my co-advisor Dr. Karen Racine for her help and support. I extend my gratitude to the Department of History at the University of Guelph for their funding that allowed me to complete this thesis. Finally, I would like to thank my family, who continually supported and encouraged me. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract ..................................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................... iii Table of Contents ...................................................................................................................... iv Introduction ................................................................................................................................1 Historical Context ....................................................................................................................5 Historiography ....................................................................................................................... 11 Sources: The Spanish State Papers ......................................................................................... 21 Chapter I: Jews and Conversos during the Reign of Charles V .................................................. 25 The Projection of the Narrative of Spain’s Crusade against Judaism Abroad .......................... 26 Spanish Critiques of Other States’ Policies towards Jews and Conversos ............................... 29 Blood Purity and the Question of Jewish ‘Race’ .................................................................... 40 The Jewish ‘Taint’ in Spanish Society: Complexities and Anxieties....................................... 43 European Anti-Narratives: Spain as a Land of Jews ............................................................... 47 Spanish Responses: Denial and Embarrassment ..................................................................... 51 Chapter II: The Moriscos and Moors during the Reign of Charles V.......................................... 54 Moriscos as a Fifth Column ................................................................................................... 54 Morisco Discrimination and the Question of Race ................................................................. 58 Spanish Anxieties regarding Spain’s Moorish Heritage .......................................................... 60 European Anti-Narratives: Spain as ‘Moorish’ ....................................................................... 64 Spanish Responses to Foreign Criticisms ............................................................................... 68 Chapter III: The Figure of the Luterano and the Symbol of the Spanish Inquisition ................... 72 The Black Legend Emerges: An Anti-Narrative of Spanish Cruelty and Tyranny .................. 77 Spanish Responses: Embarrassment, Denial, and Reaffirmation ............................................ 84 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 90 Bibliography ............................................................................................................................. 96 Introduction On March 11, 1521, the College of Cardinals wrote to Charles V (1519-1556)—King of Spain and Holy Roman Emperor—on the election of Pope Clement VII. The cardinals told him that his predecessors had earned their “great reputations” by “making war upon the Jews, putting heretics to death, and reducing almost the whole of Africa to the obedience of the Christian religion.”1 This image was exactly how Charles V wanted the world to see his Spanish kingdom. For indeed, Convivencia—the idea that Spain was a multicultural society in which the three Abrahamic faiths coexisted in harmony—perished in Spain with the ascension of Charles V’s grandparents, Isabella I of Castile (1474-1504) and Ferdinand II of Aragon (1479-1516). The Catholic Monarchs had implemented a policy that marked a crucial break from the past: the rejection of Spain’s medieval identity as a multicultural realm.2 This policy entailed the propagation of rhetoric that defined Spain’s subjects against a group of people who had once been seen as cohabitants of the Iberian Peninsula: the Jews and Moors. In the new construction of Spain that the Catholic Monarchs and their successors propagated via their policies, edicts, and propaganda, to have membership in the state—to be Spanish—meant to be Catholic. This new identity was thus grounded in the idea of extreme Christian purity and defined in opposition to non-Christians.3 Indeed, Spaniards came to 1 “Spain: March 1524,” in Calendar of State Papers, Spain, Volume 2, 1509-1525, ed. G. A. Bergenroth (London: His Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1866), British History Online, http://www.british-history.ac.uk/cal-state- papers/spain/vol2/pp606-613, accessed 14 April, 2021. 2 Maria José Rodríguez-Salgado, “Christians, Civilised and Spanish: Multiple Identities in Sixteenth-Century Spain,” Transactions of the Royal Historical Society 8 (1998): 241. 3 Rodríguez-Salgado, “Christians, Civilised and Spanish,” 241, 238; Mercedes Garcia-Arenal, “Creating Conversos: Genealogy and Identity as Historiographical Problems (after a recent book by Ángel Alcalá),” Journal of the Association for Spanish and Portuguese Historical Studies 38, no. 1 (2013): 3; Francisco Bethencourt, Racisms from the Crusades to the Twentieth Century (Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2013), 143-144; Anthony W. Marx, Faith in Nation: Exclusionary Origins of Nationalism (New York: Oxford University Press, 2003), 85. 1 understand the world and their place therein through a fundamentally religious lens during this period, a sense of providentialism having become rampant in their society.4 A zealous crusading mentality had developed that was founded on a sense that Spain was unique among the nations and that Spaniards were divinely tasked with defending the Catholic faith against any threat.5 The Spanish monarchs and elites of this era drew upon and propagated this sort of religious rhetoric in order to support a newly-unified state.6 Whereas before Spain was divided into many kingdoms, the coming together of Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile united Spain not only politically but also ideologically through the monarchs’ propagation of this new state identity, which enabled Aragonese, Castilians, and any other ‘Spaniard’ under their domain to feel a part of this community so long as he was Catholic.7 Such rhetoric imposed unity that transcended administrative and linguistic boundaries.8 Indeed, the Catholic Monarch’s Kingdom of Spain was the first largescale “proto-nation state” (as historian Anthony Marx terms it) to emerge in early modern Europe in which political centralisation was married with state policies and rhetoric that were aimed at creating cohesion—namely, unification through the elimination of religious difference.9 This was not a seamless process—indeed, the kingdoms that made up 4 Rodríguez-Salgado, “Christians, Civilised and Spanish,” 244, 239; Michael J. Levine, Agents of Empire: Spanish Ambassadors in Sixteenth-Century Italy (Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 2005), 207. 5 John H. Elliott. “Spain and its Empire in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries,” in Spain and Its World, 1500- 1700: Selected Essays (New Haven and London: Yale University
Recommended publications
  • Calvin, the Church, and Displaced Persons
    TTJ 13.2 (2010): 137-151 ISSN 1598-7140 Calvin, the Church, and Displaced Persons Elsie Ann McKee Princeton Theological Seminary, USA The name John Calvin is so closely associated with the Swiss city, Geneva, and its international connections that it is often forgotten that he was, in fact, a resident alien in a small political entity without pre- tentions to university culture, precariously balanced between hungry larger states. Calvin came from France, an exile for his faith. He had not intended to settle in Geneva but was compelled by the conviction that God and the church were calling him through the mouth of William Farel. Geneva itself did not much want Calvin, this foreigner whom they accepted, exiled, and called back because they decided they needed him, this foreigner with whom they struggled as both pastor and city learned to live together for the sake of the faith they shared. Calvin had only to speak and it was obvious to any Genevan citizen that he was not one of them. Furthermore, he attracted ever increasing numbers of other religious refugees from his native France and also sig- nificant numbers of exiles speaking Italian, English, and Spanish. The composition of their city was changing and their traditions were chal- lenged. Calvin for his part tried to minister as faithfully as possible in Geneva – faithfulness including kinds of Christian formation (education and discipline) which Genevans did not necessarily appreciate – but his eyes and heart were always at least partly focused on France and the scattered worshiping congregations there and in exile.
    [Show full text]
  • Andrés Laguna: Translation and the Early Modern Idea of Europe1
    ANDRÉS LAGUNA: TRANSLATION AND THE EARLY MODERN IDEA OF EUROPE1 JOSÉ MARÍA PÉREZ FERNÁNDEZ ENGLISH DEPARTMENT UNIVERSITY OF GRANADA I In 1539 a Spanish visitor witnessed a cockfight in London. He was surprised at the enthusiastic response of the spectators—even more so when among the audience of what he described as a childish and vile form of entertainment there were some very distinguished gentlemen. One of them, a man of raro ingenio (rare wit) in the description of the Spaniard, must have been piqued by the explicit distaste of a stranger and came forward in defence of the show. In addition to the pastime it provided, he claimed, the disinterested courage displayed by these creatures in a mortal engagement could not fail to inspire any captain, or prince, to fight with at least equal valour for their offspring, their religion, or the honour and well-being of their homeland. The visitor was immediately persuaded by the lively eloquence of the Englishman: “Las quales razones tan viuas, adornadas de palabras muy elegantes, luego me conuencieron”. The Spaniard in question was the Hellenist and physician Andrés Laguna, and the story appears embedded in one of the commentaries to his Spanish translation of the Dioscorides. His English interlocutor was “Thomas Huuyat, hombre de raro ingenio, el qual hauia sido Embaxador ciertos años en la corte de la Cesarea”, i.e. the diplomat and poet Sir Thomas Wyatt.2 Laguna had already given an account of the public spectacles he witnessed in England a few years before: in a commentary to the entry on Liberalitas to his 1543 translation of the pseudo- Aristotelian De virtutibus (Cologne, 1543, p.
    [Show full text]
  • Dreams of Al-Andalus; a Survey of the Illusive Pursuit of Religious Freedom in Spain
    Dreams of al-Andalus; A Survey of the Illusive Pursuit of Religious Freedom in Spain By Robert Edward Johnson Baptist World Alliance Seville, Spain July 10, 2002 © 2002 by the American Baptist Quarterly a publication of the American Baptist Historical Society, P.O. Box 851, Valley forge, PA 19482-0851. Around 1481, a local chronicler from Seville narrated a most incredible story centering around one of the city’s most prominent citizens, Diego de Susán. He was among Seville’s wealthiest and most influential citizens, a councilor in city government, and, perhaps most important, he was father to Susanna—the fermosa fembra (“beautiful maiden”). He was also a converso, and was connected with a group of city merchants and leaders, most of whom were conversos as well. All were opponents to Isabella’s government. According to this narration, Susán was at the heart of a plot to overthrow the work of the newly created Inquisition. He summoned a meeting of Seville’s power brokers and other rich and powerful men from the towns of Utrera and Carmona. These said to one another, ‘What do you think of them acting thus against us? Are we not the most propertied members of this city, and well loved by the people? Let us collect men together…’ And thus between them they allotted the raising of arms, men, money and other necessities. ‘And if they come to take us, we, together with armed men and the people will rise up and slay them and so be revenged on our enemies.’[1] The fly in the ointment of their plans was the fermosa fembra herself.
    [Show full text]
  • Columbus. Sometime Before 1485, by Isabella and Ferdinand in April 1492
    MOMENTOUS DECISIONS Columbus and the colonisation of the New World Decisions that eventually led to the colonisation of The New World • Who? Christopher Columbus, Queen Isabella I of Castile and King Ferdinand II of Aragon. • When? By Columbus. sometime before 1485, by Isabella and Ferdinand in April 1492. • Where? In the Alcázar castle, Córdoba. Seeking a sea-road to Asia • Why? • To find a new Route to China and Japan. • The Silk Road had become too dangerous so a new sea route, was needed. Silk Road closed • With the fall of Constantinople to the Ottoman Turks in 1453, the land route to Asia became much more difficult and dangerous. • Portuguese navigators tried to find a sea-way to Asia. Columbus was not the first to suggest sailing westward • In 1470, the Florentine astronomer Paolo dal Pozzo Toscanelli suggested to King Alfonso V of Portugal that sailing west would be a quicker way to reach the Spice Islands (East Indies), Cathay (China) and Cipangu (Japan) than finding a way around Africa. • Alfonso rejected his proposal. Inspired by a legend? • As a young seaman, Columbus travelled extensively on the maritime trade routes in the Mediterranean Sea and possibly to Iceland. • Some historians suggest that while there he heard about Leif Erikson. • There are myths that the Viking established a colony, called Vinland, on the coast of Newfoundland, Canada, 500years earlier. • Statue of Leif near the Minnesota State Capitol in St. Paul. Approach to King João of Portugal • In 1485, Columbus presented his plans to João(John) II, King of Portugal. • He proposed that the king equip three sturdy ships and grant Columbus one year's time to sail out into the Atlantic, search for a western route to the Orient, and return.
    [Show full text]
  • Spanish Persecution of the 15Th-17Th Centuries: a Study of Discrimination Against Witches at the Local and State Levels Laura Ledray Hamline University
    Hamline University DigitalCommons@Hamline Departmental Honors Projects College of Liberal Arts Spring 2016 Spanish Persecution of the 15th-17th Centuries: A Study of Discrimination Against Witches at the Local and State Levels Laura Ledray Hamline University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.hamline.edu/dhp Part of the European History Commons Recommended Citation Ledray, Laura, "Spanish Persecution of the 15th-17th Centuries: A Study of Discrimination Against Witches at the Local and State Levels" (2016). Departmental Honors Projects. 51. https://digitalcommons.hamline.edu/dhp/51 This Honors Project is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Liberal Arts at DigitalCommons@Hamline. It has been accepted for inclusion in Departmental Honors Projects by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Hamline. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. 1 Spanish Persecution of the 15th-17th Centuries: A Study of Discrimination Against Witches at the Local and State Levels Laura Ledray An Honors Thesis Submitted for partial fulfillment of the requirements for graduation with honors in History from Hamline University 4/24/2016 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction_________________________________________________________________________________________3 Historiography______________________________________________________________________________________8 Origins of the Spanish Inquisition_______________________________________________________________15 Identifying
    [Show full text]
  • The Portuguese Inquisition, a Inquisição Portuguesa, The
    THE PORTUGUESE INQUISITION, The Portuguese Inquisition remains THE PORTUGUESE INQUISITION The case of Maria Lopes, burned at the stake in 1576 largely obscure. This book provides A INQUISIÇÃO PORTUGUESA, context and presents the tragic case of O caso de Maria Lopes, queimada na fogueira em 1576 !"#$"%&'()*+%,-)%.#*,%/'0"1%2#'0% the Azores burned at the stake. Ladinabooks NON­FICTION Cover image by Kriszta Hernadi Porto, Portugal ISBN 978-0-9919946-0-1 Ladinabooks 90000 > Porto, Portugal www.ladinabooks.com www.ladinabooks.blogspot.ca [email protected] 9 780991 994601 Manuel Azevedo Fernanda Guimarães IV THE PORTUGUESE INQUISITION A INQUISIÇÃO PORTUGUESA Ladinabooks I 3$#*,%(456$*-)7%$1%89:;+%.#*,%(#$1,$1< =66%#$<-,*%#)*)#>)7%)?@)(,%2'#%,-)%A4',",$'1%'2%*-'#,%("**"<)*%2'#%,-)% (4#('*)*%'2%*,47B+%@#$,$@$*0%'#%#)>$)/C D'(B#$<-,%E%89:;%!"14)6%=F)>)7'%"17%3)#1"17"%G4$0"#H)* Ladinabooks I'#,'+%I'#,4<"6 ///C6"7$1"5''J*C@'0%% ///C6"7$1"5''J*C56'<*(',C@" 6"7$1"5''J*K<0"$6C@'0 3#'1,%@'>)#%"#,$*,L%M#$*F,"%N)#1"7$ D'>)#%7)*$<1%"17%,)?,%6"B'4,L%O"1B"%P"1,-'4#1'4, O#"1*6",'#*L%!"14)6%=F)>)7'+%=7)6$1"%I)#)$#"+%Q'H'%R)6<"7' I'#,4<4)*)%,#"1*@#$5)#L%3)#1"17"%G4$0"#H)* S7$,'#L%!"14)6%=F)>)7' Printed and bound in Canada ISBN 978­0­9919946­0­1 (pbk) 978­0­9919946­1­8 (ebook) 3'#,-@'0$1<%2#'0%&"7$1"5''J*L% The Portuguese Inquisition, the case of 12 year­old Violante Francesa, 1606.
    [Show full text]
  • The Massacre of the New Christians of Lisbon in 1506: a New Eyewitness Account
    Pag 221-244:Layout 1 16-06-2008 19:46 Página 221 The Massacre of the New Christians of Lisbon in 1506: A New Eyewitness Account François Soyer University of Southampton On Sunday 19 April 1506, the city of Lisbon was convulsed by an explosion of bloodshed that lasted four days and is estimated to have resulted in the violent deaths of anywhere between 1,000 to 4,000 men, women and children. The victims were the so-called “New Christians”, the Portuguese Jews forced to convert to Chris- tianity by King Manuel I in 1497. 1 The massacre of 1506 sent shockwaves throughout Europe and accounts of it exist in Por- tuguese, Jewish, Spanish and German sources. An anonymous German, who was present in Lisbon at the time of the massacre and personally witnessed the tragedy, wrote a vivid account that was printed in at least three different German editions.2 Likewise, the Spanish chroniclers Andrés Bernáldez and Alonso de Santa Cruz – who did not bother to mention the forced conversion of the Por- tuguese Jews in 1497 at all – both devoted an entire chapter in their works to the tragedy of 1506. 3 Some of these sources offer us stir- ring eyewitness accounts. The New Christian Isaac Ibn Faradj, for instance, was present in Lisbon during the massacre. He was fortu- nate enough to survive and later escaped from Portugal for Salonica 1 On the events of 1497 see F. SOYER, The Persecution of the Jews and Muslims of Portugal. King Manuel I and the End of Religious Tolerance (Leiden, 2007).
    [Show full text]
  • Cuadernos De Reflexión Teológica
    CUADERNOS DE REFLEXIÓN TEOLÓGICA AÑO II, Vol. 5 Verano de 20 20 ORGANO OFICIAL DE LA FACULTAD TEOLÓGICA CRISTIANA REFORMADA 1 2 Publicación trimestral del claustro de profesores de la Facultad Teológica Cristiana Reformada. Director: Manuel Díaz Pineda Consejo de Redacción: José Uwe Hutter José Luis Fortes Gutiérrez Alfonso Ropero Berzosa Juan Manuel Quero Francisco González de Posada Título CUADERNOS DE REFLEXIÓN TEOLÓGICA FACULTAD TEOLÓGICA CRISTIANA REFORMADA, MADRID Email: ftcr_es @yahoo.es Impreso en España ISSN 2659-9945 3 4 INDICE EDITORIAL ......................................................................... 7 LA NOVEDAD RADICAL DEL CRISTIANISMO Alfonso Ropero...................................................................... 9 LOS PRIMEROS EDUCADORES EVANGÉLICOS EN ESPAÑA (II) Juan Manuel Quero Moreno .............................................. 27 UNA DEFENSA DE LA AUTORÍA DAVÍDICA DE LOS SALMOS QUE SE LE ATRIBUYEN José Hutter.......................................................................... 43 EL HUMANISTA FRANCISCO DE ENZINAS: PASIÓN POR LA PALABRA Manuel Díaz......................................................................... 59 HIPATIA, UNA REFLEXIÓN SOBRE SU PERSONA Y MUERTE José Luis Fortes Gutiérrez.................................................. 81 NOTICIAS DE LA FACULTAD .....................................105 RESEÑA DE LIBROS ................................................... 109 INFORMACIÓN DE NUESTROS PROGRAMAS DE ESTUDIO ........................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Rescatando Un Tesoro Protestante
    FLIEDNER F. EDICIONES FUNDACIÓNFLIEDNER COLECCIÓN V CENTENARIO1517 - 2017 Fliedner Ediciones - Evangelische Kirche in Deutschland Universidad Complutense de Madrid Fundación Federico Fliedner FLIEDNER F. EDICIONES FUNDACIÓNFLIEDNER FLIEDNER F. EDICIONES FUNDACIÓNFLIEDNER FLIEDNER F. EDICIONES EXPOSICIÓN CONMEMORATIVA DEL V CENTENARIO DE LA REFORMA FUNDACIÓNFLIEDNER EXPOSICIÓN CATÁLOGO 1517-2017, rescatando un tesoro PROTESTANTE Edita 19 octubre 2017 – 6 abril 2018 Fliedner Ediciones Biblioteca Histórica de la UCM Evangelische Kirche in Deutschland Comisarios Coordinación de textos e imágenes Bernardo J. García García (UCM) Marta Torres Santo Domingo (UCM) María Antonia Manzaneque Olmedo (FFF) Bernardo J. García García (UCM) Comité Científico María Antonia Manzaneque Olmedo (FFF) Marta Torres Santo Domingo (UCM) Aurora Díez Baños (UCM) Pedro Zamora García (FFF) Mercedes Cabello Martín (UCM) Daniel Casado Cámara (FFF) Pedro Zamora García (FFF) Coordinación Técnica DanielFLIEDNER Casado Cámara (FFF) Aurora Díez Baños (UCM) Fotografías Mercedes Cabello Martín (UCM) Biblioteca Histórica UCM Colaboración especial F. Archivo Fliedner FFF Mireia Vidal Quintero (FFF) Estudios Organizan Mireia Vidal Quintero Universidad Complutense de Madrid. Biblioteca Histórica Mar- WernerEDICIONES Thomas qués de Valdecilla Pedro Zamora García Fundación Federico Fliedner. Archivo Fliedner Elena Hernández Sandoica Diseño gráfico y montaje Daniel Casado Cámara solucionAr-te María Antonia Manzaneque Olmedo EXPOSICIÓN VIRTUAL Bernardo J. García García María Antonia
    [Show full text]
  • Incident in Messina: Letters of Ferdinand the Catholic Concerning Portuguese Conversos Caught on Their Way to Constantinople * Nadia ZELDES University of Tel Aviv
    Incident in Messina: Letters of Ferdinand the Catholic concerning Portuguese conversos caught on their way to Constantinople * Nadia ZELDES University of Tel Aviv On the 5th of December 1506 Ferdinand the Catholic received a letter written by Pedro Belforado, archbishop of Messina and Inqui­ sitor General of Sicily, informing him of the capture of a ship carrying a large number of Portuguese conversos who were on their way to Constantinople. The archbishop complained that the jurats of the city of Messina had forbidden the unloading of the ship, thus preventing him from exercising his duties as inquisitor. Ferdinand was in the kingdom of Naples at the time and therefore able to personally intervene in the affair. His presence in the Itahan South was due to the complex political situation that followed Queen Isabella's death (1504), when excluded from the government of Castile by his son in law Philip I, husband of Joanna the Mad, Ferdinand The present article originated in a paper presented at a conference held at Bar Ilan University in June 2001: «The Jews of the Ottoman Empire: Culture and Society», organized by the Dahan Center for Society, Culture and Education in the Spanish Jewry Heritage and the Institute for Research into Oriental Jewry. The subject of my paper was the passage of conversos from the Iberian peninsula to the Ottoman Empire by way of Sicily. A few months later, while working on inquisitorial material in Madrid, I came upon the correspondence of Ferdinand the Catholic concerning the Spanish Inquisition in Sicily. A surprising number of letters dealt with a single subject: the arrival in Messina of a group of fugitive Portuguese conversos caught on their way to the Ottoman Empire.
    [Show full text]
  • 164 Angela Barreto Xavier, Inez G. Zupanov Though Published in 2015
    164 book reviews Angela Barreto Xavier, Inez G. Zupanov Catholic Orientalism: Portuguese Empire, Indian Knowledge, 16th–18th Centuries (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2015). xxxvi+ 386 pp. Price: inr 1095; isbn 978-0-19-945267-5. Though published in 2015, Catholic Orientalism remains salient today, in light of a deepening religious discourse that is rapidly reorganizing social life the world over. The central argument of this book is laid out in an extensive prologue: the authors assert that Catholic Orientalism was an invisible and fragmented body of knowledge. This theme permeates throughout, so that one could read this book as an attempt to recover what might be referred to as a “vanished discourse.” The setting is India in the 15th century. The authors begin with an elaborate reckoning of a heterogeneous group of Portuguese Orientalists, Joao de Barros and Joao de Castro, being the most notable of the earliest Orientalists who went about the task of locating those “archival rarities” that include, for ex- ample, a “big book written on palm leaves … in what appears to be the Malabar script.” (p. 19). In Part ii, The Catholic Meridian, two chapters are devoted entirely to the handmaiden roles of the Jesuits and the Franciscans—two missionary orders within the fold of the Catholic Church. As active knowledge brokers and en- trepreneurs, these missionaries oversaw the large-scale conversion of Indians into the Catholic faith through systematic education. A new creolized elite, well-versed in Portuguese and Catholic theology, emerged. Resurfacing the discourse in fragments, the authors cite archives in remote convents and cloisters in Lisbon (pp.
    [Show full text]
  • The Portuguese Inquisition: a History of Religious Persecution
    The Portuguese Inquisition: A History of Religious Persecution Bianca Ferreira Department of History Thesis Advisor: Dr. Nina Caputo University of Florida April 10, 2019 1 Table of contents Chapter 1: Introduction 5 Chapter 2: The History 11 Chapter 3: Why was the Portuguese Inquisition Established? 25 Conclusion 49 Bibliography 50 2 Acknowledgements I would first like to thank my mentor, Dr. Nina Caputo, for her continuous help, encouragement, and guidance throughout this project and my undergraduate years at UF. I would also like to thank my parents and Ryan for all of their love and support for which I am immensely grateful. Finally, thank you to Dr. Jessica Harland-Jacobs, Luc, and the faculty of the History Department all of whom have educated and prepared me for my future. 3 Chapter 1: Introduction Thesis Intent/Abstract Portugal underwent many changes of its policy regarding the Jewish population, and their status, during the 15th and 16th centuries. For Portuguese Jews, their society went from acceptance to outright persecution. This thesis analyzed the history of the establishment of the Portuguese Inquisition. Through this analysis, I identified the specific causes that drove the creation of the Inquisition. In the first and second chapters, the history is presented to establish a basis of understanding upon which my analysis and conclusions in chapter three depend on. By the end, three major factors are presented that answer the question: What led Portugal to establish the Holy Inquisition? A look at the lack of Historiography The Portuguese Inquisition spanned over three centuries from 1536-1821and is to this day one of the pinnacle examples of religious persecution.
    [Show full text]